%PDF-1.6
%
1 0 obj
<>
endobj
2 0 obj
<>stream
2021-06-11T15:13:24-04:00
2021-06-11T15:13:23-04:00
2021-06-11T15:13:24-04:00
Adobe Acrobat 17.0
application/pdf
96100201
uuid:36cf8646-8159-4aa1-8e3b-c6fca70353d0
uuid:8fc49934-4b28-44da-9e74-e14c0fa9bcc1
Acrobat Web Capture 15.0
endstream
endobj
5 0 obj
<>
endobj
6 0 obj
<>
endobj
3 0 obj
<>
endobj
7 0 obj
<>
endobj
8 0 obj
<>
endobj
17 0 obj
<>>>
endobj
18 0 obj
<>
endobj
19 0 obj
<>
endobj
21 0 obj
[20 0 R 20 0 R]
endobj
22 0 obj
[20 0 R 20 0 R]
endobj
23 0 obj
[20 0 R 20 0 R]
endobj
24 0 obj
[20 0 R 20 0 R]
endobj
20 0 obj
<><><><><><>]/P 18 0 R/Pg 13 0 R/S/Article>>
endobj
13 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 0/Type/Page>>
endobj
25 0 obj
[31 0 R 32 0 R 33 0 R]
endobj
26 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(96100201)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(sktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/military/Archived%20-\
%20HTML%20Word/96100201.html)Tj
49.657 0 Td
([6/11/2021 3:13:24 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 749.25 Tm
(In Re:)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
([Redacted])Tj
T*
(Claimant)Tj
T*
(DATE: February 20, 1997)Tj
T*
(Claims Case No. 96100201)Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
15.224 -2.125 Td
(CLAIMS APPEALS BOARD DECISION)Tj
-15.224 -2.125 Td
(DIGEST)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
T*
(Section 12738 of title 10 of the United States Code states that once a R\
eservist is granted retired )Tj
38.713 0 Td
(pay, his eligibility for)Tj
-38.713 -1.125 Td
(such pay may not be revoked "on the basis of any error, miscalculation, \
)Tj
28.872 0 Td
(misinformation, or administrative determination)Tj
-28.872 -1.125 Td
(of years of service performed as required by section )Tj
21.019 0 Td
(12731\(a\)\(2\)" \(i.e., 20 years of service\). )Tj
15.846 0 Td
(However, the administrative)Tj
-36.865 -1.125 Td
(determination concerning )Tj
10.496 0 Td
("years of service" does not include the determination concerning whether\
a service member)Tj
-10.496 -1.125 Td
(meets )Tj
2.583 0 Td
(any additional conditions precedent for retired pay, such as the require\
ments that he must have )Tj
38.099 0 Td
(served during)Tj
-40.681 -1.125 Td
(certain periods of conflict as required by 10 U.S.C. 12731\(c\).)Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
T*
(DECISION)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
T*
([Redacted], )Tj
4.886 0 Td
(who retired from the Puerto Rico National Guard in 1971, appeals the Arm\
y's )Tj
31.339 0 Td
(denial of his claim for retired)Tj
-36.226 -1.125 Td
(pay and requests reconsideration of the decision of the Comptroller )Tj
27.159 0 Td
(General to waive only part of a debt for erroneous)Tj
-27.159 -1.375 Td
(payment of the retired pay.)Tj
0 0 0.933 rg
9.75 0 0 9.75 145.6152 426.75 Tm
(\(1\))Tj
ET
0 0 0.933 RG
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 145.6152 426 cm
0 0 m
11.369 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 156.9839 422.25 Tm
( The U.S. General )Tj
(Accounting Office \(GAO\) transferred the claim for retired pay to the)Tj
-11.749 -1.125 Td
(Defense Office of Hearings )Tj
11.272 0 Td
(and Appeals on September 13, 1996, and the issues related to the waiver \
on December 19,)Tj
-11.272 -1.125 Td
(1996.)Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
21.6 -2.125 Td
(Jurisdiction)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
-21.6 -2.125 Td
(Pursuant to Public Law No. 104-53, )Tj
14.666 0 Td
(211, November 19, 1995, the GAO's authority to settle claims )Tj
25.037 0 Td
(for military pay and)Tj
-39.703 -1.125 Td
(allowances, including retired pay, was transferred to the Director of th\
e Office )Tj
31.598 0 Td
(of Management and Budget. )Tj
11.636 0 Td
(The)Tj
-43.234 -1.125 Td
(Director of OMB delegated his authority to the Secretary of )Tj
24.159 0 Td
(Defense effective June 30, 1996. )Tj
13.356 0 Td
(Under Public Law No.)Tj
-37.515 -1.125 Td
(104-316, October 19, 1996, Congress )Tj
(codified the OMB Director's delegation of claims settlement authority by\
)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(transferring it directly to )Tj
10.052 0 Td
(the Secretary of Defense. )Tj
10.356 0 Td
(Simultaneously, Public Law No. 104-316 transferred to the Director)Tj
-20.408 -1.125 Td
(of )Tj
(OMB the GAO's authority to consider applications from service members fo\
r waiver of a debt to the )Tj
41.502 0 Td
(government)Tj
-41.502 -1.125 Td
(resulting from the erroneous overpayment of pay. )Tj
20.105 0 Td
(The OMB Director delegated this )Tj
13.69 0 Td
(authority to the Secretary of)Tj
-33.795 -1.125 Td
(Defense effective December 18, 1996. )Tj
15.631 0 Td
(The Defense Office of Hearings )Tj
13.077 0 Td
(and Appeals now exercises all of the authority)Tj
-28.708 -1.125 Td
(transferred or delegated to the Secretary of Defense )Tj
20.878 0 Td
(through this Board, which is part of DOHA. )Tj
(The Board can)Tj
-20.878 -1.125 Td
(entertain both the legal claim for )Tj
13.328 0 Td
(retirement and any matter related to the waiver of the debt created by t\
he erroneous)Tj
-13.328 -1.125 Td
(payment of )Tj
4.776 0 Td
(retired pay.)Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
16.74 -2.125 Td
(Background)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
-21.517 -2.375 Td
(The factual background is set forth in the Comptroller General's decisio\
n which partially waived the )Tj
40.307 0 Td
(claimant's debt)Tj
0 0 0.933 rg
9.75 0 0 9.75 571.4863 159.75 Tm
(\(2\))Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 571.4863 159 cm
0 0 m
11.369 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 582.855 155.25 Tm
(;)Tj
-47.238 -1.125 Td
(we substantially repeat it here for the convenience of the reader.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(The claimant was a member of the Puerto Rico National Guard with over 29\
years of service when )Tj
39.765 0 Td
(he reached age 60 in)Tj
-39.765 -1.125 Td
(January 1971. )Tj
(At that time he applied for retired pay pursuant to 10 U.S.C. )Tj
30.16 0 Td
(1331-1337, which at that time included the)Tj
-30.16 -1.125 Td
(provisions authorizing non-regular retired pay for )Tj
20.105 0 Td
(qualified members of the National Guard. )Tj
16.967 0 Td
(However, in a letter dated)Tj
-37.072 -1.125 Td
(September 27, 1971, the U.S. )Tj
12.026 0 Td
(Army Reserve Personnel Center \(ARPERCEN\) notified the claimant that he\
was not)Tj
-12.026 -1.125 Td
(entitled to )Tj
4.277 0 Td
(retired pay because he had not performed active duty during any of the p\
eriods of war specified in )Tj
39.485 0 Td
(10 U.S.C.)Tj
-43.762 -1.375 Td
(1331\(c\), a requirement for members in his situation.)Tj
0 0 0.933 rg
9.75 0 0 9.75 266.2656 50.25 Tm
(\(3\))Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 266.2656 49.5 cm
0 0 m
11.369 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 277.6343 45.75 Tm
( The claimant disputed that )Tj
11.136 0 Td
(determination. )Tj
6.054 0 Td
(He indicates he made)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
27 0 obj
<>
endobj
28 0 obj
(t\\v Tp)
endobj
29 0 obj
<>
endobj
30 0 obj
<>
endobj
36 0 obj
<>
endobj
37 0 obj
<>stream
H\Qk@>u 4i!m0z
({< +|2;xv_ihw:C Zu{=1[m~fr IOxvo 8~I
\Nvk35'u vO;uTW ʴCi55Y]صt]Lc~U0? M -Ɓ ̶|OW
sG#xE^5xCހ===<=}<|<}<|<}<|< < ]]YAVdYAVEE,`)0;
: ̎ :zxzxzxzxzxX3g%%yTQ& Fg)ٗ
endstream
endobj
38 0 obj
<>stream
H|w\TWg3C <,qhMX1ٍQ7AP)JQ46@
!v̈BqW u1Gr{9~?@ 0 "{~֢Ur*$:69&%?ĎJ5%Sǧ Jn3PWf]{(q@r1^`a6 =dpr ?'Ⱥ]69fLJLQahLr9g =M?(eTgt.ʈMTt^o0$)ASzyZB}]J%,k$-9aL1 9DGWj3 )z r
\ OԨ1k(5WO)ie=lCN?no{|3?{ob@Tt ?hĤRըcƎi&3%N1csΛ`K.CVvΊܼVYk^~FiS~-[m߱s={/VrSϜ=WZ.^|*[7*nB.6*C(&ScKROi&eH3A6'G(1.|O)>g,R.ViS,~4dIʲ̲Nn_|5la+
ɷ{w.J~6~t5Ndj|u~:]4W=ss.]"Hw hbčI4'q2!ƨtԭ,L&g_ Пs'r-NdNTNtLڜ9yE>>v ;caw=>a q!88Gk8
GR:\u ܐ{܈sp>.\p9
WShu溹} INy\t ;ONS:eNST8ϝJS7fM)$\ 0x TC
>Ԅ8!$A2@*kN+2FNcr@mȆ ȅ<ȇ:P`nrSn_!~ u ԇAchM ? a2 >)00 0!gX%XeX` d52ձ_XErdL$AQHKL%dL2|2d)2Cf,F!UT((jQ%S
RSeR/)r((PՕe6գԀR#jLM)59̑
W5ԎSH3?ԅ>>S7N='ԇR?Oh
4Ʒ掹k) ~'<2<3ŦĔ 9H R =2,Fih13KhZ|#9nNP 9qI\7O(<'A1@l!_-y7{+9W 2 ʡC%* !DV
)d]l%[˶}{Qv]ew[5p&Gɱr|S-ߑ\,?Sc>6CΊ 9O.,fgQ
r.wɽR~%yD yF^h$o˻H>%BV)beU5U]ŋ*Q42TrThjZ(PuRUUuSUSRU WS 5P
R5T
SG}Wƨ
5 Oz^5x^{^{kux=> o7&zd30 9fYdf`6fnvh{~~eow/0A `\Yan VaM6l; NaK5v&C=bc=aOS=cs`/K-WU{^7M{j%?Op.9BsչFUnub]"ܨ+]j]r]]]Z7p[ݭaM'$|,wtUg}Q~^H%\dCDJJ,EࡉRC4BWV:H B`Ù ,xvWx 7ޝ;3w|, qWܣ0
w
{#z 1[ASş(bdwCb
)R(ZR 㔈6Ԇ^@7 =%ӛԁޢԉ:SJTJԍSJԋz~ԟh
4Dd9@}hQ4Ї4>i 4[$L44N ͠4f wwwwWBs3GsZ@ iQMMx:lH#<37C|sUwzfBޮUZJh9.VjZCYz@)6rL["Jh;}A;Kw.[;Mi}XE CtP ctr)NIʧ*"*StY*R*r:Gt^~ =3='H?%LW{x_7JzmM N`&d\+qf!tj膺n:P`L:T.FQ:E4 #tnanj1>m5[ְ5-j`%km-[۾b_:gmQ:ZX{^tnaؽvo=l { mͳ'Io l-=mسĖ2[nيZ$ȅ<=YgPs
NNf"sq:ǜN8-ΈD2Q.Ή
q^\W5q]7/Rů̉v̅ު+Ȧ2P1 SL *]d^ U;̐4Uu_
UOUʘ"D5yX2Lt>a,`g,b̔e2F8/[cD츯 ߘ̨L&Fc(hyOu ̌`T W&BŘHkZxeU1&t]P73LPM1}BC C$t<+w
b
{>!kA0 G $gМ3l>R?o9A7[dP7 <3w&a:rr`iĖPbl̞a*{ `&.5~~eշ_9 d|Kn%@% yȟ:n]f/n!w|t
86qA)}wU#?T#
` eq fBf,N%>eAlS`և_e"*mگ y+T/yU?GDE/w^m%s|802FӸ9a)(ڗe"vo1<?
O^ 7Ӂe}iq.ulq3nVy_ "J$Μ/ئwνq:ď 7'q '$<` @ ΫKؐҁ- S٨j[meRI9X4uuݪRMҮ͆&h%F}: ~Lu' rS.:M: &XލZLH_ >N 'V/7Z557 ^Ǿ&ed9Fӄ0]e| ^W1k_D/ނ{5d҃;|ވSh %.B EX =8t{uK$.9. ߌ4C;z} AJ/,%hJ^O'ΎNGX9҆^d5 z3=qZh!Iɯ ;e
B)vFS8/ab
SutH
UmאP c d3Lb-kNcagpPЎz:|9 #/aO]~0lX&_f˪VV,^T-+e%"Oat/ȳK6knN%,*",5oB㽬RY|MNb| J>_dpVHr rڵ0S5,.kрp.䈻?,k$!GPIqd%B}
HZFHs$q%@]$s.*pD+`a]+tj-Hأ(
zXQ h&iW$NrzYou=>7v?BqP\S#YGUl*8Ej>Fl*n`")3MZm@N\og@5o,5b0 4GFMb T}uԡ~gi-+Pzׄ2}`̧tMSLe}A=NfC
3iK!"ЧZJ AI?4 mUh~E |$nDXsUF:g|h93
L6I'ЀeՊ]@xx(sd~ o]p5#`I C.;4L{Y5afeغD o_~ 'vVnǓM ":xDkxRIϲs.'rGr))eJS,bKqH5g9b')@sI2ER¨RivQEV[jCVb)dJybExNBnKAƹN Y8ϓ -AMM/)
z[r̫yv}:nwC@oCPD ;>_|>/N&2 ,nv+B15i(LmZ@J`h[)JR
jW1itݦcCjMh7g9fE{}}ϲu}~ "u?/=be{ɫuWn}|9 =i1,ъ%f:l}4ߴ/uڧ~ H; Y?},XY>]6h (KvkOci67KT4D3 ZdCB#'iAn (TT#FRW9dL*Ѡ
`ɶ&0 8lPi cٛ)Hf+9=EPGh>ؘ CGs$ 7(|Ul#tp|mfxo B3ןݻ쾡qekWRo?{:w[>^z0_عn[r1t=-5b4'f:\ Wkaǡq_رp>9> x/pYdH3څ{Saq(|f 16Ev~q朗jp&ap @2
{G$?
z2 B0x}Y-^&Lv=1`KJO0NAr}6
45=ϮX=zՄ0vA` 4EhF04ΠG90JPJ}lBQG4IRU4m>P2>\5_X<ȯ=_뷓nȨ!hb5adLg~EN 4\+B\% bK@>N Frh^ZhoN=_ zo_:FN}[lXmY2zB.O7#*I }, czQ4.[Yz|8p#e `vw}̘m9 3[/X
>W!Q%>0(Ybv_OJ& eB"WT@b.ʍYxL_0 rxAR^j%B3BPH/©u|3f1#1a>
sM,`a^wčG\5=*Q%WjfoG6HPYjֻWV3Nw\KTKW 4B Zh%qN0\
߭iX_s[S I0іo7ߙ^^YUӛ_ES{n
` ]={Ԉ%4?y:2
ğN0jU] pܥe$hg3 ^ui N Ը~9N- "uKn%09{; PT.iTuW̺`#@0y+4Ʊ -u<=bچ/jhmװJDKGhTF"歖"*P-!-|s3Mq>0D%99Az =ASKueۀ dzḼc^݆9-TFQEQ+\T5U( iWz)<}lLFaI \6MKK|8b\d7?}~ ND n>eI/fll!-4[Y%$KS8E9 W Kk 29{Z9EZFGlF_
DZìl+?x%1R%Ds (%:ͺ~'ͭ3u4$G \t-u
/{a_2k]`B$JqP"-v%W&2΄I| uCԟX#'h S;҃Ӝ.9%@l 9t c`Żau 82+# a_3fhBCCU(;ljS/lD?ML \*`ztDg-Yg \C.P(2Gr &.7^mQ+l[iQzcWjqqE E?qX8iq` 2y$Lm,0"~bYrZJ*QQݑ0)S/ X\Lp{ 9?o^=.&1`Oc6n @<Әq Y:E[*%`Pct !;D>za+- PVd N'ZJ-~m1ڽɖƁ]Z. ]]ymj #OLO j ?c1%DŽRumF.\QښMRѮ#wwWGg3aahԨj/iDCQISoSS+㊊U ZN/j3rgۋ I(
[]`Q+§|A?CS :]\p 'mVwR5OV9*ͫI۷$0YiSiBz_XX2EpQ hijU`l
J4
ưm 4N»r M
DŽmAt{IP,42/4JX@Oz",2'vY|>ށЃ fܢ'ŁH ο-h3YE$ f܋zB>P ߢ5-^ \E%IoK2IJZ6%%q,M-KYkr m!6`Ͷw4&LHjdiN9eL0O
_䁲O*䲴wͼ*j=r`O1Bc`N[? =lVr'
$?z ý sxHL"$ԦCq mETT86K5 f\N^uukDɝy &ӿ ن
zϯEHRkjiRkv=e}cGT/a#KCc;#嗙ޕs$/TSSYhy aC$2sn ݒR2wxLoZ?lQr}Okh!|k oͿ~m,_:_yOCQ?,dtO8eP2zs\oVf-g 3֘e /5?31~g\3naY K 00g>[a}0o6dv!GC$#vIJ, NH%O'C:$iQ8jV=lD"2XM8Ht F g"! ir>|kqV)tA1avRqӉ\"3r1 n%&)
0 _RcqN 2AirKTz-$zUnզjl?M
&IrЪ9lUm}
`hHUATTGl(c1Kaa84ڴ?b=̟aoc3ʎGQuuV1}+&Z UTGi꣫\?uoF_[GlryKkok[k`]Q?\=u aN%S7-E?MlI+U| 8f
WMăqI-F||jġbCif O|5NK)o; ]T0'"hnվo7*ן%?"/{W_~cvQ{W/i r\EZG- Y79 m̐f&0p8N
{3-V֞о Z$!`אgyY}`XU@9UA+F*703\,LK}Vn U!&A)$tD/ #cE:#N4Rm4 'P9`S{-Cڥ]ذWQCEw.>npc侙}D9"o>P 5P7͘:E%Fr4ThHgR^e?sLLq~BfJ 8iK,\^7%ONQ
A9c)9JZLC*0UR 9lڌSeHL cf`xIdL(t2E!B2Focy=n4h! ?AX .[c{(ľf1P6:a,0ۋI$nS_u_dEߡC/ZojhiA1.!o ҏ-<֕PM^_vm4#+kOA|W厧s\pz?3vvw{#u.mʝRa姮'gsgʦjnE[^ؾn`++ ?_ {7m[^]4VX'uutN%4"gi璇 #B)yՒ1EjFM1E'?7 m)hV"Ta]>TWEsaC49 8)Ih10Pݢ{Eĉ("~,D< yg(V,Z v|6oyK$%xI'$:{ v,e]nVd(7j \XPP>6CK29@de, e
XzAn(}&X8!L/{p7cD PXo-a(;F;1I? TKr-$p˚,'.'zCd T߿33sO?U;4W,FG8(4hݳDD\3^T漄@4)^^h)XRjlLh04} 9&&Zֻq `pnmR)X%tP2a{ \$jX^,o깂1+FBeS IE~Rge.p !ͣ @<|k}h1 /62{ώr}b_?6iۜ*qteMѵHi;mNn1PZ5? MehlCH@:JDBqq&&PoQV1 l
&xuY@A/:66 |M{,쓻f@3级O | '?O\ _7-"C OAJ!/%؛ jATWҴ\zeڏeZK:')˚c")E ¨#MP XX5JD5ꪦi]-j. o(^$IN+re)2..r)^*@N\h?lʀ,Ay45X~-A?Mp//D\xַ%ws ?L\3߾B#-U}ܳ@: a@hU!
!pp<५[L[NW79_YFo9Z;@<ϨaVaaFXn
>>_Vi|.V]q:]aG8.=y>2 } n sQ aj̈E{C$]ُ/em]탉#fZӲXW{41QVWyۚ3tuNA۪#3~Uj *GAjC}l8C.=dLBc6 #Ņ)Q|M,]<4#LP/lcج} ;PZwQVo BSaKy sjhV]7s'km5P=dܫߺ^$e>Fʨ
2PP(\ SP2+R=ʳav;j:Е(OʘL:#pgn{5n6X.!q
uM^no3K;'ۀݍ#and ?p:D;q>~%?Ȭ= G]3 {O= yaltfOM`R-z[)b)ٗ)=ŭٷm9:{
3OWߞ n$rTZ蕦G]a- X▅6/.,Ky֛`lKv<= %-j,9!N}jXPVpyFXƷB*/eaKfroYc;pT{Ֆr eHͩJZa9'rL%RR`¯%(L/;1('S/f2cYP Ű҇
fIin&4Cߩ*<txDH{Y*IJ 4^hY@yu_;r?-ݾXom F.[}Qߕ5篿N))ES4[; 4%# ?ӭrO~
< f?B($B}4
mA
[8T[:X*xh! qW,!XFj0ObLr8 >Zi?Zs9 E{=GI|Qa9 p Ga?d{ o9l{j'0|j ƌ5%MƔ4U
L,)_hSMP `k0+m B#ZFZ.ÿK.7'h hp␅8NsXlvWCokN' ╴-R6_4 (?6/S_gWqe+^h @A3a: Sj@U<үҍ3HlM|!ILwjI/*ոerLfD$(NQ0s$
AZ0$D0p\=#>)<■ zn` +j+L%[u"MuN`58ˋbjr9G,YX_AT% #b;ݎՉH mqפW6GVbUXD3
L8;sR525,H :c{wW\ ߩE; xhW =08F C( Z)'uѥ_ \{^#Z SY\~Џ%mlTƕO > H~"=~#-ei
*#h$~"zQy;Y#H&pɩ&دAqkRU.MKF(p$ 'a EqHR
YV1oZgTѼ SwvϽDݛL*\$J%WKJқy C=ܲi ]w߬CCV ꧂ݖr r}Y@ ͦv' y5,L$D/vp7[̃8{w J { v@XaX3`[
j#`Rւ{݆:ik;a\IQKn?}>o|{{x1M pƗ DXjB{NYs7mtV]ğ{ܤC 2btN۶=
gX=yCOŻEz`7x_I4 4Vϐ3OHdNv"5e'#x.dKP~tp@Od_'}lg| Ǩ
/љRNn-Ph0m;K]NlӮkiWJ>ǩEWc h{Ȥ'?sFG; >"s[ho4t(B~ }
]~cH6|{TLbx2yo:PΕ#/˯o;|7mwfN-ssʼO]8mb3t^l_#KǷ*P?$zZʕx#ə/1gd桽[rv02BwꏍH_2͖4om@=R˜+u!N6}CLj[ƾK5!2 Q w@bóM 3noIt6" [>2{a96[@{Ō9|ڇcmol,g ` +3-hQڬ/G-@վ;hAs0ߎmhڙ]'F ̞ٓ49 UPu-&}k+$11[z'W*2ҙ#'?M>#A ^XQȢhgU>}la. t|tJ }Z%-U{Ư۾HhlPA}4LHk`RN
3l}N]ԏ-3ugT >R}Xw6
WA!Qߏ Vy>* Gz5ޒdLuzѽb}h9)GMt1&iN dZkX\i EMʝ>d[!وоW9A7J 3&lOe:FF/.1w]iw$״75J~YJ2}ѱb*̬Պ ikHJ3fg؍/2SqL}1͒~ 'O'qj'b^كrxg-k^K Bo |6(Uy졋 nOel( `5X5:WPK~b=ө6`{%we |6mV6ُ&7C5^iTt-;y&<6F Nhtk['"[=,Rκ gD @쀽pZl:.WzQfR0 u{Z*OyۓHby{fwJ}|l?ob?۞} |&BhlsɕvحBKYNJƋEh.kW?.656tT\+=Wn;mWI䥫Yϝ%?Q 2P<\Nz<ޒJ`Pp>~T(XQ|ZJYqN5s9<)VS>gtH櫉 TX^
kGq *~t]:ky7y"5{6l&7o';}v l2QrV}Q/#D&r%uϢ@ $FtEbʶ:uG878]ei4u"݇o`#A
\
ڮg%$6݊n ]
QVE g?P <_q3
!.IF[.тuMGS>Yg,=GYVz~ 8G|H?\ Y}sKgBRaryo5Ch I7?&c`lG$?U|F/x ?+Ǥ/ֶ|ffa9 ff/NJ1C&<K'>d{};Xw# %2) D`N"f_Hjï j. Q-{jMihrj8_8-/2ztМ7mV*Sa^]G) _85#)ѱ$+%ZEr` 0Y'2 ^^R*ʫ&'gYyϱvF4tM[SԥK B Ml]یi*A9I?K v+,=}kj{i4s59_·uvuV4{--i!c S^ J&<侤%S^g ^>ThS<,28(V,ӽ f(E} dIP>.><@r''/F)}6{YJ;>ٟ9 ^gJYL3sDS1rlX ׳=q8ۤ ~sy9n2HSN$12Iow9n/APB
xOsBTX.gFZِ r*|8nYmdi{twOcb:U;$ Kǖ= Cyq+~U-?*/HkG[Cy^;CyG[뜟Q~~%ca}3=3k߱& CaRH[Ls)ƏߢqTc0& K6n}<K{'kwcնB;kߍw/ hڽLe`_ջqr639S,%N7>ML {y6). o w 44Lbx/H ]Dή'w.$ ~wW: wQGp9X.r2bD
t ^yWs4'}5i#K{ߖ~ɍ~ 8D}FN N.FI Ett ܦZy&{|ʟ\o&?ie i-wk|ް0]}VFMG矓OGGH>QorWGO,$ϕs
'cHߡhq'w |E"z#Z4'S])vdM}e-eRtT)|#4W4F4 c}+r'cъ
}:y[=?"ERE ӽRG,m3 n ïPA5}@7]2KP8[X>o
[>$m/vd]nNe]Uͺ>GU}X=Ü=\h~SMWX)PmmнZ/ݦVm[Istޚuu6mؑM۱E6#Ԡ]# ) b3SOZm~Ϻ'=D/Yl-ÕgW?!1zv s/0p4(d)۷B"& q&OjԿ,shD6BFGYJ:F.鼛|G~U˵w{^> {ջDVk~%.c oLX [ 4n) *US}Ӧ>*oRghf x5U!ĀGcG7b)=D/h,8%
-V9VI`]e&&ϭf`G-G,.t -w0 xXY;4 7v_n41@| z9ft#p
ާ 'Σ?T/0[O{tVF &WBklWwByrLu?ߌ} Ou{ ew X^:4'S< Au.|~?:Ycht巔X}i- eu2UϗZZ^uJSqco MI[_Euʚ$Vk7[+X Y|.|ӯAZCCׁjͼ_p}P: vZ.b\=wٽ썭q"플gIifyU3v_N NS/
[2>E7-uuF[iE q_&zylTɦ{~ՁQ5R:5Xmj vJw?LF)
cw+)_wpoqe(C[-+,W|0xǨTp{WISWw!V;so@[j۹WwNIfg|gqJӼSִۚupZރeܵnQ)#1f/^orIi waɦM6Ȼ` mfV AUխImT'{F8;"W?ؑ{.I=NCQeƠar?=ZubG^!΄0i{>2m , zo1Zްi%N Gy WUq{{ҰQb@
eXBd K1V
"k"TeF ( Rт QtP˔ZETH:UV!{4wyݳ}@4iprLI=%׳u_厩[od\ʹDZj:%_Gs=N;9) ?5n1O;Q1w 4Sݠ~pR(ykǻQ 4
*`p68)NUZT`_¹Oy|E1/Q.ĽЅ&Wڋ.zAYoX0'PDR R500ܹhq=ݏ;Eam`]< mRGe';zʥ^i1lr J . _*DZ_r@6$09M:c$.w?cЮ aͣ!)0K7B% fip.}f>\
|?'gLp
>|##ٗDߟT0\L]}|] 5b_8watTTwG`tM=nP_O}G. ;&\lGגzxUS]U >3Ov!-oӽ&^_+3 ػf
~ Idr%o~*܊;w a):fm]};ό|7Ѿ0h_)c>y~TIUص}Cf@!Pr[`0 z -=qIdo eIYVX &CZ_A d`T ڤ "
^'`Z# b*SgK"YgfWwTd lc~]E+ѬN^~:x -W\J<)˚
ybEp{y*ԩM1-};# ' &7Q
w'R9IY:/s.Hv|N?wn&nld'6ް1XsLD2?о@Fa^`F:GkkE>zNոq&ӕY3Yd|+쳁|[ćvH)T%)mU-m>2Z4;d|2 4fݥ =kE2!
ř?Nxz1x{GE~yO|!kd6폲:mDrk، +10ggLɑYMǬ2VYzPv0[}P!#};rK-%3#[_RьӚw~ú/2gs ҋRn4OL#=3g̞h3Rw Jt?i>#T%mC=vDR{`4 N+{p :
'Demy68d'C'e7ߩyH:$$64* >( |gALv62 nGNj< ˽ךupPT'CQ9v09{F<ֵ0V.G$)&V^
r^L 4 ۇc|Q/HTiCՆ9lZr {Yn'`>?|}Y{&+ 3MZzO g#Α jWfl^1"^J36 4')m).D3?H=vNy;NJ9G_)=,=8f u6I22,k[+MXcw8Z.?g| ū Kb܍NyK&i|7Kwg(HZhMBs|V&Nٜi4P|Dmdգk\4N+3kMQ/`?/JaHdݹ!R{TD]yL&|PÙ*V}w<e%* 8+dg"5W»_Xܭ\>.̝hr=(~z=3yv!obMĻ +.} fbkMunGveGfӑ5ȯ:{ )nIfZM-"4HnJS
i2RӎZxFOHF) ~rf4`} ϸ,ǯ}4
M¸71 iLP r rmٛoe7k-J!
r8G N#cfL" GԆ>mTf?cH e1
(ffVq9؆9$dzߐ
cL|rgF7l\[q.J%92´/B 8@GQ,L#r#|=?Ҿ^_ QDqQPZ%UYEA>Ye>]fU>ͱx h4s#x0tQVi~.:"k)]DB?a'
gJv.Vi>.W{BaV[@BeidsRA[miݫVopׅ%s
2$
<}5 P Cip \[I ^)\ uJ>Z RBVLVjR2xNYΔY4V\p>1i9ps2 aZ[V6¥HsQ˪kԯu%%h[On:~Bgta~lX-b'R ` 0:K[bUl+d f}`}jGv {bgQb_qy } =@ 1A8-fM=yn .egI}CdC S؏m;Gm3PO!՛
Yd260' 袣ΙpNqWaACvĬ bK v(r~&eω Aߑk-[Sx{I^`3fL3X, f1MK2Z.æ24BrDOKaI~} D&Sȝ -OYY%|4!zx#S)ʄ5o-C>o:>&`#2eN*?\*CXi<WbУu#;o3}4@ 2[ f=r[ A /
k>c6wL?nj1 &=uz둹1jj^{_[b&aYzd+Z=}NF ` w ơ[J8eD:)aq }
amUWmL[>\
D5:H ý !f7,8T8JHB&E]A˴tK*Q6ׇ*q>Y6CB
j[6-٦vZ=瘆V˯مys{Ӥ v# U@++\@/9>O#"8 q;8ywstcvqQ;dw"GĊvEg*to;\2I*WW˷l>RKWa|bTc++aVPvy{Wv( J&H[$d[aȈ%2CBhl8\Y!KC +:?.RNN)TNIѹBA })#D#RV%d`A!6!dxR8T^.9JB!,;EtD Kc}*{ =.^[ ? x_} l[!YNdfm1hrr̓ZO<$ l}!A.j
ZvsDE:=dR-dGg ,_uUOW_+"qI{Va"T ^iZP[몯 ! d*v0 a\LUq
J2rv1>D.(hILd-+Vu0Z8{ 1BA Jyw;*7zzR?
>
endobj
35 0 obj
<>stream
H\j@ཞb"ܹ7apu 4v$o9:!
l !ǁQ}7{Cܩ-5 ʵ]3}\ͥ 2/>ܯSPT+)æ (6?_ã+q//DW˞mM?ctzIL3:MLuEUXooeSNEËE>b^! 怬̊l̆e"woo\yz<<~ɼD=Gpz:=Np
5gA`A`A`A`A`Af;t(PСCA va9 h0́ s9 h0z< E?YYYYYYYYYYYY~(QGяң(Qlc?~(1c7~7~7~7~7|آK>sK)os3y_q]^_W I
endstream
endobj
39 0 obj
<>stream
H|w\TWg3Cmx3q,]ƨJ(*,XP6D{/Xb/3E >u`&w |νs}|?@ | Q]5nRR:݀z} ϞGwJk}h XU8 .:QbƉZ .cPaRF~4ЋND{R& URZAz褸+ 7I 2<XP(?yX\f3g}>; !eC^^ 7QoF) 5d7ȵ #{S<{vFD誐:;PsvG\.=[~D (xkF^M8%:O5_A5k֪]!D1̡ajx7x_5nҴY>lѲG 5O[Gi ֱѹ]nE/{}71q L4xHaSM 1r 36-}3~0q)SeMϞ1s99s_Ey ,]|ek
oظi۶عk %G ;~gJq /]kVf@E:c,4FMO:)T*ҤLiT ^h}]r_y)Or.]~~eH0 2 2 7BB|Pi,-ך_`G GSGgWELEye啕Pg3YpY@cJaR4ZRR[M%7{dy 8kF5-ee& h8_ѧyekNFg3ՙ
h9ȟR^[*f
D&x *J+N=n<lOi`nؽ^vO]ggl; |C Xy#,lIls#lhY_5),k^f`ko}dkaknkbo3md}l[[ZowYKE}V)˭mmaVd
3߽% ">Fd:]nnn7~(o`)u.
y榠3,1Γ (w鞻{}/LG |Oi>å
m֩uɐŏϐeu^=e/><_K|UVu.|[|]?}~Ώ?.eBWYu~:].PUu}˅mletDʲ4)cfHB)4i@8q 1 ]@ ne|g2>|~xytNЉ:I'tЙ:r#c/%e||{=*JʫjZW=lD\un es~[O;]=]3,=[s\=O BH/KH^^/+>k^CAoԛ"#g"g#""fEmc]ПONK{^'r7dNTNtLln9y ]]ݣcO,^778 | 0 #pdq >cq .nʅ\9#Vܚ\q.ER\qU6梹d.\k\/h$-Hvʝ;]sϹǷ6 4ZAkhm <߸ &Ga*Lw] ?xa>XXX` dG2
F2N92Q&(IR %&O62E4N> )d65R#xJDJƔL)JiNIYKʡ\ʣ|*THE̡fԜZPKjE
v$u2:QgzԕQwAԓJ.ߣ^W'P_GP@i=Ki
h
nn方m~i枹o T*S AZ dAVM#i1J:~E77&ނ0X`1, rX+a| a
u;~\ ț̵@ fd^0/r-?⭼?C1_}kDnA*L1[bTkbYl'b->_~q|kc9wQqB%qU$nrq=!T@%TIّ?Oy'p-?:~TC
#P/" :!e,dgEvbY"{˾r kQ"]U|C%d9E-|l+9r\ %rYVբP&U^7RyX qyJL
Y.JY+PZj
RUP*K5Q*_5UEj)ک֪:.ꮊDRU WSϨjg`5D
UϩajFQFn+XxGQ$z? Oz^/KRL/
Bkuzx~@o7&z/yx)fa3s,1+jl00^1#{ g큀/0A`b a^X6 [Sak- ÞaI+ /ك=lأ=n'I{~oO3=g ^e[fث{-h?9\pJ%2ջupt]tu]v=wkmnC1~y9WhU:Z5u汩Xpx7Mtn⦺infYnqs<7-p!>G( eL*0\tu&! IdSdEH[aA P K A@Ha#N $:,q e_ Μ#;~n}]ES'n⎸K (KC!) C ,hXȧ8 q\RJe9MD/P;8ǩ=7uN"G3L]Oԕ^nԝzPOzzQoJCԗQ@)QiL40N#5z,39Tr0h,>}@h"M4bʤi4J3CIh6͡,Kh>}ƿ%-1- -
|
\tёG{QnC?__p+~C4IԆHMSZF)V`6 ZEgsz\AhXJh3m7Fi/i|J5=T@{i ޢTH t1:NETL%tN)*2:MgRURjZV7; ,\Hx][aXe6<'``Wn8
Wbpg9u nu+ [PFp #ucN}t:F3L}8hgEXcZhl#&mfyZ u[4=H:Q' W [`"}v-A{ GQ{ Eؖ=eKm=mr{VJ[ej[ckL(b=MOpNfz2s9 u9ǝ")Q.Ί
Q)9Q-jDV|'. qU$~uqCdNta.*CV2Df:V01*y1RF1CRU_Տ)U8W*u)2EMU̓ j$#d̕jLɲɲI%cd,eL2I 1/ G1㞺~ab3#٘LޱLq 3Tq&JśhĨLWI0̤+9Ŵ`Ĩ^o"'Ǽ}EE(U&6kgf3/:l0&le_P2Ez 2M,9;X@SPlZ`ʄ&Դ1a&D /sk!s9{5n|}'j ƺWdC k`#_1v!zC5ײ0+vB^ߓ:x &u
1y&Bcxѽ͟=w5 5ײ1 u 9- tKm=Wm=W7BdJp}Nh6γ 9T3ԥa5[+t3A<;].8vq$BT߽>@# r4uޘi P q + |IfZsۆ_b! f
fA>6㊿ݽ3Ƅ#|)챜sL 8s Z@M" JS1Z;Q[?-"RJL mi(J(ID*HMڴ*U)UZٳR[3w;>f{o
9̗;M|oEA)~(s0TKY;[~W'.!#"~b)vi'5t:K`C0*s_{ ]Ǐe}o&;
qmV]| { l`h}UD9bEKp[bk%.+dIY/e&P~f ^"=3Qn>X$%*'J
CN*QjlCTt:xVI7z䈌P
oYپ//| ~~ e:, -U%eDM3è=qmcD~ o~%|tRBj F Hqԧ<d7G= ި-xߤ%pw!w pO;h7/ tG^,]cd{>nGaVAF}i^R"P^!֨{nmY7 ⅺF-)w!+~w/gw_oΎm[[_[vͽWݳ+jF/[*X.]e9'0Y%3g}pFѤuQe hl"= a T >3ξ9Nꨞ4tqsD
ן~(zA֓"uI
.;8a$z-LD1eud,˩hFCR7B '=L6C!:*Xdԋ2~o}@l3 P )1z;L-ƜmO|Pqw&̡Ԡ$+t :ΐ.bNײ0MZe
v r rOIbQo;{l\L#hee|̽NIi74t]y>~z~\?R 5{NɬɝyZ8W&%26A ޭCOZrׂ
b%zp bFv1rCw>%ܿq/S1q/ dWjIA@HD,_.ğB:^] = hp|ԌM[ ~($w8. "baXےrnR!) Jam@DTU~es1 7Ooj3Z:M=g>h='Im2zDSFrnAF17a*An{O{r"(azJ*A9 5I"S)J UqRpV2c;霛2)b:I{sHXD?UG
Iq,)vSăYu$--b+b dcTjqHK6Ύuc"H9OVv1hN\b%RFy e j*YNKo!MWsv~wf|]0k D(wH9EX Pِ~.@RRBݐ^UC -XvZ
*aZhA_ZŅ%S=od!3 ,T^ +zvX^ r*#ora~20` ӠGMMu; 7X+lv!DhHAőCSJ\G 7M 4s#o}iq ^Evqq;1ۈr3`bQ(d Njk -bT^'։X3`fF_#/uT "5P?2@I&tSEmfᓿysD'gyxK x#Gڢڈ?F}t߃篯>y7g*ʒ ;֜4zu}?J?ޖȴ]'Mߥb a# 6֩r&oaDN<s%Z1%D($ԣvuWwǟn /^(ZxK`$ #$"HmN0S#6[Zثx'R+$=1DZ2%[KԌ?B<&>yv( K#`@w
.l JG>e40oܧ,.ZP9(;eK~ ԤRaKUvVMN5h aBCǢJ*N;R4[ Ǫ]-`rkHL "iYY39V ($E*l Ch8`'3
R!*jЕY
gW
U
UlʆZȶږt[_w:{^
zG{t-^}vv{C>ow IזmFv~ئ-wJ'_tju
Y~̞%g6Gq8`ЀzU:Mir0(GYK'zʠ .3 /Uy/_^_& qcp B@Х %t
PC0ueBBU>6$ 0?vRMD[:Qkh2FcvMh+-qss&1p:d߶q}N%76z:nH(8(:nn(F!:|_?|qw~{͇`Gʗ|?rg3=FΈш-7- ǎa9 hƐB|Ǥ 3'?,=( r֢F96"&Tc' \Vvqʛ6?a[dmxڇg4bږ?{K1]O{zۦPA;4)Bwqg\*
UT_Y1݂$7}7
XjtխTa'.F֑q뚒;zvʢK^rkǰ P/Z#z %gP6!<
ObHi =65>Y;M?ޣm MvrXƷ0ՊZ}m?tkch
e 8KYP4'Q-Jh[t(:evUݤ Q#ʉ 27!⒢S`BdNA XΨD}W|B.+<J &< 6w;Qx|i
ʍWya.dFYӑNY6 8U뱻(B2758iK
mOWl4I%%t4aZg?NC'uT汦=Lsi6ߐo'jmp ЀBƸ^ ăO[P'$ʐqo_9VEƕnORXE-Ez%Z}cէ:AS^ WQa(] phq6)JzMõh^ 6w1L;OzB Yv- H_y<,a0 69O&| ~(ALH +w^ =n0={ѴþoӖu{ &C^U
kY >ooHz2RydflDQsI="Y(߫n,:`IY8Ʉ[չdY4IH PK y+ZvM{e:AoQU W\Jf7 Yn%̬]zE,NdWLTfrnz@ſڸWHot H RQpAm Ս\*^F:4ÁuIW&\KȌӕL.`N~1 !4m`4N _' ,Χ?b8Ξ\} Yh4td ? u/)%3-ĥe"vBeZ-1L7 $
bw+wK.Ǯnߌ| gѧi, HNވC<$OZEU"oKHYV#b@ q =+>|^SI**i%> k Yf0m&Pq]МԩvK8
,s-1e\W}%uQd*5+,_.#a"hԌ2VVCP[2 bC u͖y.ѭȔ ij&N,A +_/IC[pxvz=ƒ3c4:n
y}ߩ
~GGVi;mw >잷
3qeia!h~8_B ЃR
Y*k
)P.[a J9KL&xD
e/A?5^4c%+&جYDQa`9P& 5 U
rRa^@P_h&m`F i>UeCǀ{tWڞ`gWEQPK6f
$De>kjڃ8ON:z:'!,cYL8 b
.i0J06Pǔ!vӆeJE%dj(.C& iK:}L t Mݩ;milI{hv=>S5 KW^H<^Vi3 MI8L|O_=7[ߘ.ޒ"?;N٤I!4bY
AqꄏM e .PyН11;|:8Q.9p V[@+AKN<
$e
1(yy)6PZ)H~G4>Ii\%->wfmAP!Q͌!{ Ʀ
![IfXaUj
5c=ЌJ,@N`9B@R ':q3t"?&EZI&>Ve/cp'{οV[-on&6s˾li|y#BVUX }ilo?7akξ}~@X݃ `̌rE==OcZ,\ (_4IH ??#;Ę )fM MM$IP@k8f`b1(36cBC$fADi*MUȒϓNR3{2i,[\C~{* wψɄ(0Yx0ro7 hl٧vf{wVuר&3~cP.Bq|֨Q xq< *IS;VSc se}%
mE& *8~]8dP
^Vs6㭨o#ZB}xx>N)m++z:}v~臡ų7ie: A *g9dq)!9~,?رЀLeY_b+BUҰf< ڌ%_oiʊ5m^8yʯ {-(L /Ie{I!r ,9rgXS!$3|L g?J^XẊx^mϖ-kN-#.|0^wȪ-;~ѹyח2O XcꪭOkzTWs [D @aȨ]v0p]|e)wzeEE v*a'MU
(~ 96 ^Z
1u
뉴LJ $8usc
Kg-Z)EֹSiL5 O73u39mZ'EijaƍF=To(*f&UN^}
ɰj$ZQ `C:Op#Q]m_ӧy3G +b= u{nmw|ǛyvlzÒM_n\xe±K |x{{{ӧ۱ Z6
< g-CX|BKu+"
Q+$50]H^*ho0ʱִ@'d7#VA-je6Ҕ [c|ɒrscKj 0>ksZ8p914~hk)^/!,G.xˈӢ KҊ f/ #ՈJRH#(3ИGg1iȷṛw*xB&
P~d)-v喝<˚U{յ-}dF]KnIY 6dB ݆xa0 #_1U.F# "- 8 9PLƏq,W45?p,' 8|c~GpVQ$/^0,mn1
4sjB*6TsY1FrہPnm;BcҾ-Uh _(~Q\*-Vzi]"쪁m<پ$}g|gb9~<<2y&ϓ$5| j &
( 0 ep'r;aO/]
PL{=7=科wڌh",-YrcZ +xZs'f u n$Gˎ 0TX-PpT'|CQUD|[ţEeԚV&;۞mSG3 <$?ľl'du?hsןZ
w;ݻ)a8ZɵMsG #4JW
al>e]a߉RWEī}agEbbΑ-_ ^\%p h$*!5%Pme pAd]5h w+.I).$Gmτ{H 0uفh,#n+P")%tY ~Z\ZGKai@٠_M&mSƭԥ
ZpFcPfHSթؼEIj%2V%l2ٌݖ6zsI7J'>:k_FˡEp8a TcK[F*{8Y}zTA燻{%X|jw
M sߟU 4rz
9fʧlVKmm; #1qt&| 2A +cvL0.U"ZJԄ&C A 9`No? 53@DڻҢ[*l(4@
.%C{aM+C-_|겨p~hN 01{ _'0s /2CNjj
6=$IQ6=iW4P##>jV.Șy Q/^n
a54vVO^z2X #_;.|Ey| ~>azCz+ u8 U2z<*+14"O(I.D
eE 6[fL6ϑ%M45Y3la\Nz+M4h
k:mk4jQ,EP,QݙRPCUhC
cnCۇ
~#>qP-e]
J5Uxؔ
+3 u<D ^r--e)ap(L4Q4ۘdg_p
Κ?`=QLMךQއtQ5~0(m.x^E/;$^{#6#Q_vjM<$i-~YKTTǖj|?5 ?wg8].9]Y42VF+mE7T'nB @QJEZ ЉMFcbIC
B.tV'|6-ݽQ|?~M[ k
1J ->].#֮ 'wW^r
xfO=O>#+Sb\+hҵ < L"ɤ4NT*b|*>d3n2^݇9 [`$ʈDq(#I/vRF:g eS pmrQ_ S@v3ǓXY_'pĒ
8pz21bX~ (D" Ap۫4R7E!{xR e)&+|ir{?oŲz⏱k۷4!Q XM*Ҏ^Tսk) 5/ J>Vr/r%.~#Pbaf0ph>NA|7SӛαR$s#uXP"["dJpds4(j 7 ǒ(ԓ5W&&) Ts`, t=*h#[2dS[FҡGir 2)&Kla G" &g? CpA ]ą3C"M|P,)c7x:zt(2:`ۀaa k
`$ZtM3y#ѯkFTHtwk5%M۬G 5k8ˣ;FF(Xf;P oLAijP2I.mDMlNA-^_Lv抬N=x+N' +ʸm2$@.d|/5?^{7LGveI}ӦW;3}}
ûn mWa^q0x/3۠Šn_5vwx]ÆZ0U]CF¯ka# C w*O8S9QW~gWxdc/xm e1c,m; v``20K>`>SӘ#9k'aF똥īAd}{'/Oecd}&]qlTLUqA[GX5B ' r-72) rnEQ
մ쨭jsD3p
[ۼ?19_W@YܔnJF5n.n۪Slv Z&7u\Z*iby]:@'OO@Q$BMzzRsz#;B
&Uc]«The/vR5rT[+R=)*v#g5QQ5.mggW7=ڏ෨ǥ]~QX0/0(U
s ߇ 3I>?{H bO7qtTm/ .=A%a,T283ם?lԏ
X~='6g`.ثUt
K.*m}mk;lakCfWid3lJiS5ūHabf_S8[;EV5wWi^ ki,jeimĀN@ cJb6 Sÿvm'jDgSa['" ~OJ$,%}֦ Wtjp:(pSJ,zR×I]f9>$bξ3;;p> `wl@FACmҒHg*Mihe0
v?FJCQiT* E$51K~;t~H 9\2AM89&Jf &
tMD،LQc" W[3L[v͍y;W_/oim*׳y3'~ }GdHU2|Z$a*)ˉFs!l)*t)Jv8wlSdf5>YE@hH oKaV
()5W5 ?9 t#0S1\EУZDC*!]
XbAߗrLb$B.4b@sWt} n*xcd>袔HB/
aU:lWTtW$'Zm?~ذ4W
xu2MXv&7>K|O'̔ ]
}OI -lcu ;X=ŋs`NS^ 3->x9w^,_rM .nͷfZ s+)',.WYա49kE-RAn
6Y|7ڊ6[} -?oYA@Xm{%B~L!^FIwBhC49|zW~&_܄EnKtQ]1:|H"2Vgɒs#.A ; ,+rXOo̙c:Wu<`y{`tv5̕ I>
f]?wĝ'E B "T ނ, Y:TvVT
rs9j%=.r6ܓrR1:+N1Ha
mOR⋭rZ K`>me_8k-&e0;L<ިr+6v:>x 6yWIP>( .-jzƐYk_Ó5 Qi208""*^ yO4|h6xI X 9D':Y-.z5J'=%mݜc.O . ŦR4 H_Mt>¯g
XjXjby*ZCT|:fC3
T 8xa uQ!I9Š"*WoZU) 7`D<{;:XOtC"&aH$cI-н'b#ĀX|/M+\ =+wJ<#Cc-VdܵˊN,Q r:n\ _I,"hknztSG_%oN_j
F
z!n>uXm- m 5)Sv<;888+qU\["Tl¥0{g N͉=Έ;U+Yۻz;:uyP{3g٪5忔ϗăyo o8T~|bxdx.R; :8idR)gn>۩uU~|*z9f&3( ֔e.O>\gn3 v+Jա)vI h8pSj7 z_V EQ L*cQHYRh]*f-6!J1~h&GQqw6qqؾ;_.%99K:JIcDGDeX@m]Bu4UZVHJahvLTǠRZ)Ih=ϓ(|~s~l=5BQP}:^=a
He`G7ʎr'Z}&9H$DZH
p!Jڨa` Wt_*~IH{M$*ͭuDëŘC)aւВ|Tthkj)Rf3^VRT57n.ӁJ7 t:?#ULIDQVa(-taJKxt/hQ~ga-JD⊔
y l9\{@}K//YŸGS[,"p{7Axs|ډ{w! K̻OP=3;%p',D3(Y:+DߏZDrP"z[
rg9PPd(:*= #6 1qMx& }(@ T[DfO]
+S(/!2l0Sg h8Pg5 sfgRgʊaCH-FZB.
\҇,ϳxz b䰒h9z tPPinWXЦX)"~[V!)@XP@sX JÁU HDD3R!1~M,U2'Ts*evǛI_]^ĸd2sfбjzg?r;CQ1qrm]͇~mL xl{[Ɵ{VDnڅ & ٩8PplnG?X9B Ȳ%ɉ<%wCBODKh3vwu{uu6dPW *CIV/ %/f#ċeo
B
ev%E:b do)ePX\_z_z w@DͳPU%^ a
z$/q>K^FYO%08=ӯ)_{
;_ʔ6q)ٲn_sn?<o3Sh3QmK&f}rc)V-AN&D{z}b}i.a9zBL_I#ŮPBIӔޔ'p+Lf< X=0:C
9w;ty5
BaI"qL{Vhp/KS%iB ]*@z5 ^#mR_s$}C(t26 :dߡdj [>i|&L &YsAd58};@<_4(sB|--q &j>I2煮0V-yOiRbWs?9tL23^7e'QoR>3 ̀#ԫ}c v A{>,Ktgp$,3 M}~CgXOٍ䨜 2" xMxkkא PbPRDG/B'ḻq0,n!($)ȱ{!)Qy^O̠
xpwp$x$H/qe}salIBȺUN0+091Pac?2W?jQl*Of
+o+
?zsJ5~DzTsxA :2 :IVA,Bh@tBK,_Gȥ!t0 kvDFn 6۹~D#k
2?! _- erGcqx>e K?|Sxx;u.t>x^{/CZerKr,?+|E?X應Z"ӣO_1{ ҃yfTߕEnfxhkL I\eF3RzuK4)P*]% n=rzxfУC4 A}xXL@ %
t>U Kݣ;Y]%j+ܐ% Y:֣}> F݀#,I+ <Űl8j{:8*$Ox'6ٌ[ zM嬢eWifI}%jT
@QoWraO2-_Qgd|0xI)KR-'ՙ<0Ugӎ0 _?amy,Wʄ0&IH JJ4 Jo)\D#C 64 yܭ*d='WJ8ޞ\vk*= eO?^^h[~-'6ZKQ)b3hS֓_zcf߉H4M+zb TЯ
e
o.ũOfEBIKqx3cj/ )Rb$I%
4skwI$]*=MShLa+SE5 Pس-
˾a
{ȺoY|d1M`bk Jvf[-pP˛pmN. ?"H_h 6W R", HaE( ! 6NU,u l2 oZvflK
2 : f " d ž6eۼH?@zSvKl[w$Q;LϺH.VR;
a2oy6@a#ron: tPtXEᦲL $Vn12I75y7CS_`P Fr-Ȣ.?|A%8SQAbX?5gR358 jF&+I NKr$ Ee3
8b{uB XLMMXS #ՙZɒ|WΚ PO]] ^5 Ǻ
"Hpԟݍ^k@a{2 cK3ESfOP}5Xg tl3t@7vݗLvv+vNggO-/|< +7u;vW;5+3rՇL^!u& 3q3AH0 CJ8bD:9{2 .n>#*I5P=K2> +I"P:%e^/UǷ 3iT?;mǎlk= xhJ~uZbp~,o۵ ([DQ6. KqFtQ iD#I8ZNRYQ woE`$`\ǹ
9"_t+J'\~EPn"[["Yn&s}Wn9O`1rw$S|;8?Ч-\ ߡ!s(1 ^,2ሃ,(2[C,2
u5kYn
\42] dicIźw^ah(Ce4dzCv6Z\[.7'b$j);uNq?D |JX/nRJ o ]QGQPVO{{;nB,O -Hk9(c 4&iT˿Ҫi1[xdeDnM Ȅ F` '\[+b>m%ߓbIč&&*v`C 9 (!$9 łjAh{ PHyc9 [rcoc߹fq̖Ƿ
l{vwϟq'#Dwj`ۗ."1@Q~!K8PE*kT&êb#lp
e
L; RI/AD# _لi6{ й|FX(LnhQr9Շq9dWQD/b/PIH Bq"Wq"5:
@ }.Aw jS}9aGq*ggOgPoe766Ő_dp[-,Yr9Am';I=״;ܿx/O nX\O>˔O"g{㛸Mv
CG'Β4)9/rf]wi`DfW-w#pƈH'Pӥ}Y_G o肮$`x3`K~\ ?+Q z 8lƝ@`H-҈ĵHI;ƤYIN)&עG*?bD{v:2/ 40rTFѨ})RE0Z'b͠( qS0p4Cznӛ *\n:\ D WZJ0)R,&a* 'L$;9HЛgRGBh46'˝= ?m9ώk!}@ {w&Bg*|,,~)KSW>wBu3icLyqlR^.+?wqbe3o.ԭjԝr{[u3hG1[htV*S1 y=nW tcYA>ӚxO1*`kZ
wZwn W]ޕ>h9X"XSX- Ѣ b\@:rE e si >.aT
/-ۖP r[,c Bzz 41\-fV23tF|qa(e|^Exon@98q|ZCyjn M$PD3JN^Қp.B<+gf
O+cʬ=2c(*ĨHi:и0)9 j{}*Y2g C"u$u(FMD07⟷{"Un(\l 58_>
qG@('@ݾe*g U!aO9Ќ ׁu `ljo 0 / m:9]K
".7vɮf `A "*
z :a aWCO\'6\\U[WzRF|w~_ߛj
)]ͣ+z鉁f^]݀u8Cm_Y|nmNwogAu vwF/}JFwa ZAPn`B/~;r&. ˳YABU%I[ 1Gq .FBC &5p"'H aAPHt^t\#K% [xbM [" ԆϭȆa# }97&tX/'X"X"X"XHHrH"a%`7OIMγ[H$b`'9`s
xo|9^*J\ 9T^RDMEbLw 1Q,.A<džٹʢk,2{*%Vf]V55
/jw{U[zAP-,^nXP
ﰗa>r?|Rm(qfJKUj AT
Z;DU4#ʁ'!@TX>aN4ݠ=GV 6ck5Y::{ؚѶ^~}ı\Le9O3;tTl۸
m0쀮Ӳ|O@N 8}n$༗/N`5/<"0> 8ģna{ G`3 H1D^dllsZh@Puqb$rԦH1ÃQAs/im"t]n MЃw@ADn5 'wnoQؘ'=Y8U-yU"?m1$[L|1V4lB 'ӝ DH,".*l%OQ.Ǯ:3uژ-7\.w- p-;
$"
WMXZٛ1 6d]lYg|홉 I<ĉ?;iĬm/mĠYXؗBHHH6<6H$muQxH+
V mhYZs6g̝{g94 ]ld <&'xFo82aEk2S3':OwRQ[F~ttz{b.AB!S , NÛ /`*? όNH3M608Ji R*\fv3okY Z;P]I:p= uBcY[.[ K;+I&R"Z ҝC
w|
QY y)[bp.Ҵ.mv06M"dżl..fccLJ ̫iw1TucBUA,P}unh0r^+-A72 S J/ F?Hb%[V(gÑ5Ľ$' j[XƒV`6~}KKHJ,l)
M ~pdhh'./STIs КaIQ.*;vTK&pL&l^ N16`4 5)D5F$-2d/VF i$ 7Sh{+$jZVbX0ށ8 Z`Fr=B7M&(^yӸ&Iy= 9RO3"0kv}yWST1eMٓӊ9ldSdJ{yY7E(U>VܟS_4nuߒ.b 1,xU997ZIw]W. D|W;d&LDqI Fߦ?=A)u(+wYfҀe0>eSϸamHi 4T}NM nD
LdJ.y!FM#h4M3 J(a)qZ|T7^$u=,yt{ܡS~nSf4R#Fx&ي}9l؛6oL[b? knO(B,kO1 _K?R(a sAp;(Dn wEg}}mm[^'[֠$)6Aʌ$ԗ8 1y^x Ji8xTW}uRO Y=bT/A u@D¢
aцhC(pxj#9ЇcV<\ >7d%
<ư"ZjG9P$A`ljAanFXjm=f R-\Rj1Mm[\Tqv gD{urN#6hڦv:4TTH R G#q mOCBMLoR2G
]2ݣnz5t ZG 8ɘis JbhfhGF8T> !s e&!99ɣ*j*[tVvrH[ W?k^hnk [-K_I$T*qNΪt& SGǾ Xlņ[9XZNj
9{qb~5dz<ΑS *C519,K[94v za 3gƎa, 쓩jgj\< > "2n2ݓm:I)=g ;Zz fnq G*b,fJĮJx-Ls 'i'-U-0>aw+RۥԧG
{"z~=HXS
lxQȵ* Z>Y'LE
`. VRA5.f.P)ya棵O*Wu 0Ç.X ͆5X$7ds)ۊOesd5w%-T],+:W7U*U
=,! nWϐMP-֩p "UYRd kGU8}C#q'~y?B)X-(-L QZe*qz4\݅Gv / y{.w9s>?DZ38fBBfMQT$(+nG
6SGeVl&TcRH:i} L[{s?<BO+L(?`e}}.b42Pس9kE48~w}SQVRmPjyAu?P?X7EJP6*=y
zyܙ̌?dd.M~)D/NvX6Q !
5R( Uv}g (_"îIIyc$ ,uL E9 |Av`:
c2|j%2U"B:zêuH&u4ꘈ6NNBZBh#ĝӄ@ e :M:H;xY;s 4<wRFi IHpH.J%w$*(
A]7?^9eqcmZS015:As̜4̦,,2y7o d2 a"\m zX쏩z8X:bTfsg8dXm~9 h^@NaR8'\Xa~
E5>>3.鴎}A3`B @
l 2ܩ71@ @D&.Ф4 rt
>(O;m(8| -D1=_5FU&}*ۏ 8u䝑F殼[ݵd#`k6bWYOU }a =帻DpD.R;KJa
KyMfh)T
JHu'$hM\j
0 0H
10~
6Po:G݀pXl OmJ7CUË
Ө]iNLQ((bx5xX =R`:Xl'^p϶J{Oھ 퇅pqk*('0i{|&/RсTB4vH%WBxMXGls6z6khcl4ڳX!MNF(Rt>mu[]m6I+ZmMei(a FLEHt% ΄4k\PޡQԚSӣ(ϕNj ''D?.(8,.(ºnS
U7kf-)ɭ/w7K邿\i
)O ,~}h;sqWBvcjz ctXVz`˫ O{qR rLC)յ+uAMcT
x1[&[_&ܫlŊ|]fh@KaS*Zbg
y XfjgW2?|КHH2&JhZkN __Y*Wo[ Pb}N a0RN"Jts1֮]mu ߝ>lvoOn}[_Hm&e4iZbZ!!!րeSCJlEQ QUyMI=yܓx RD QkB7Si[ObLAfm]$H^HY'2 285 1c\|ǝ`;YN҉D9k)y͉/bʲ3kfL d+H3HXNeyrަI.."APoT7Mv> G~ntxH oW}(ߦ{x_HX q~s_0ƃG,DtW% ̣k컨hʪRMUmB,hD#M1K[IW$bd\p t(E a>SK&qgL&i5g5Z#UŦ>Bdlz%q-
&%Kpq̳Wg]9Ói8! kr ك3>\W4FN>rNӧݎ.MoS > pdy!?xq(̂$J|3''r0sƛ, ܂Slh֘F8E/)b/8M* %>F>3;X<"s<5 S+=5 WF&9!.Ejki%4^l.vR:kI
>BG(|dKNj ي9xhz0f4Dze\7].M\J ;xH7%RMu-/)vR*;lfx=&|mW.+SP/}ǿw d]x˗L\c^rmóՎIװ7rD=/|15ѫ_TUUEHpJU47%QE$&DpG_oUګ]w9y9tO ۗ(::! M J= @ gbxkx(O
~H ;ΊOƢwxEz}Enɫu.sCw7[q BmݵzG}q4ީ4K!M78 `Bۻ嶳,8Cdk(=ňM.hJl1 OPQeuQ]QPDWg{fԈ]rRI.fd}ơ5@cf('lǘB +#
) M4%u[rJ(
W)epƍj.;`{'
? ~/x}/=;{d:>~#~`1 ƭs { -LF ̑Ks8kJftD<'LRsU2QIG(N8Eӯ9c%̻' r;>(U,we ´ 5:Ӈv !**?0
2( rP!kRNr4ۏJ¨dtJvU g<-"+Adq!H2-?c8<8h", {M1V=L&G Gb$y,H0
p
d팢iE9ΪlO*Giv̾qVBE2D# ɶηhID@T2 ȱ(Sy:RZC2#cM4(irp+ \ ]Cɮ&d8a7>w =U =c#o =]Xw@4:F0g0ƱGXח j9ZnMZv3_-4 \2g6]jwnݕ5`&6"n8RH$pCBC#Jh<ƒ-YMp_17M5Xj3#vss̜}'hP"?_@Ý ɅSI [bXv
%EB6 F@1y7
<{:,?:M[rTj;J ݼWj(Wl]dM zRW)_e'ayZ9)sѷ_oo*oc.ܺ!lG? p/y? X ѣ!fZ?zCsgW?VF :W]bzKsҒ =}R䤼JJe9A7YE$Y cr&Eh|eN+ rn u퐴[ |.1%((qUlBIjB>JEg߇'U hB26TCa~]6G7E&9ANV۲6VEZml/IOdX>1A=Y^u7~ xՌ QULyh9JOB+zxk2 r?AT*IPPCfTbZ2eDMꌎ YpfU:} G I/]:d;ݢaMM9f_t>?пR\78Zҩ:Yj؉qƈ4)=mKe|/ľ*.4 z $Ā=!EAZjT)˨|EV
oL/uV-9ưyaɅ:9Nc$6j$rTa TVA@zʀ/qiT " -=JK|xzJj9/^ڦkW;#7d A \wAJ# NHLu-)*|=e X4"K2 0`8ТuϊXM4ҌmDl~oش\?mx1]HfU ]l )D(( 03"z<HI4f@Zf 4e$=QS}J戢x*z:BлXEBEHFPq
O%tv7
&*I%ԙGʳGh(O}PL-W@Z3Q]/~rjDӧ -2LDJ+(d?ZS'uX\xK LBcjB(LKTi;B/esh%YMyzj;d. ىӏq_4M'uxZO33Br/ 'y|^ mj&c^\*ME ى^l߃_DE~"1: 329N{$KB-Q&\ErT
Ɔezv
H1.FBmPM k>m=_|84]nWOMsʷ)X}MmS!qT6Y+'2*W`M\,A iihZ-U R`z/PDEG2kd2E
w} O=9FHܗ"TwW zFQ{+Qȱuv`xwrƣ7ԠAL[fRf>*i )ͻ; _n hOe2xjUW4 b fY&Vr^ҥ
55ۇk@- _}B3Mi h[<:OŭUޣ8zzF ci`HV!=)= @"Yc4 uBӂ@ Ycyφ"0E
&+z/@)xc۬^~$خC qby8/<
I h
eM[ʈn-2PB&XH -UɄ&LFJ=\y4Jos/Mcs9}{so
*.E[U]߮6^}
\X4q4xq!/O5q}
F1d
#˥$:|c4VX>WW/u[N~ڳxqa* qk"-2۷꺻~UU}1|7*r<"͋#]:weq.+͋sES
IJ^6=C>sB`UjV ѓ } ͧ X;54E|=Y){'b F6w)sEbk ށu7)h~L!Jp,N/Y~Qjo
lܧNV:Bδ/TWC+ʎ[g8v ޓ9:4ȤNK*T] d GIr)X.F(w.cŵKqvqnv*νD|$}FZ9ӝ3碿>j(VM9=;3<<>枷{t Dq̻7@rXk¥t']z1!p t>|<׃hl,8/ՋGϝ;R*P |~U+ZW͊Kz45@d$[J*e \PQu3Z:G
c|9H7~%U&95^brE5&ݫIMZܶ ]ڥK;tYo]=,qcy'}.Pلg5턫L-EUdU冇gQ5IkmͺHKY^FEjҚ=R'QT OKB+3ky'҂*EW<'̿ gOrJV|2VY} .cAxC2/ #nO?>"+PNR R9h#YyKTBOHo 0eRN\IcBLDvl֗|@B{X-_wc->h= {K{]ɻIUEhZ*QQ-GHkQhB!u %v|_yHΑ~c \n V֢ x #Ѿn^%~1MJ;)
1_:5#hף]h v_2!u
!, 9k5?]q-/ =+QR>K䜹z؛
n>>hP÷m12m1f7蘺|bݯR9lgװ}QOm/% p&ZO)1z7;mGwa 1 Q o2 ^~So` qNF5[go=*g? y5C `7+o`f>wi}a mCn`'8 ?,8, @` 3MsC |s܉a}-26%V #̾c33D}}y̩y2e[d#skh'i)sז6?OXҲSrU[ڋ9%PR P[zF胐]؟?R iy?I,w _ 0Sҷ1$^=M 9%שSi}EX|d%c~Z@>-צLSpKjj-@ʑ8n&Cof;<}MS:Iݪ_]CM
g=E4I!z6Nsgh LJ1ǣ2_$ǒ§r?_s'sf(i "?_xsW><ϫϻ e)x,?E ^?8VrMc_E >M7Z~
Gqޜ; 17v~s#y 'r<6S-ŲKyӴh.&hM)%8"hȟPmYa/!`3^y3ZI+q_r98T".g合AJ6(i0bϪ5i=4>$6\TcA qVV\泷] >N9&D \Euݻ7ICTj0I1 bH6MFRRfLh)8
2S iAe,uPp:Z8QKJi9RI
.VF[OL^#W;n"_FM# FN_f<3^)י|B߹R8)\1έ~Kn AF9KQĞV넴5hr]0ػްx?`|
;؏5h8:R&V3W -,RNunTˋ s~Y:p/co>rUPɜg,uk ߥWJ|fbG-J\jƩ(pI^bc/_ I,%xtJYIg vUxg W KȍöEKrp=}aS ?ΊGV9<<$
3-)
w_
( gpL߲{Q|>|sSE\mkC/A]ڄCjb>k'ܗEN\ ^Mfg:ZƒDo-_*dQd[M"hjE_^ڽ盠kǮj{舍]䓿H.v 1_O] Mfֵ Hp)߆}eX]`NC0MjPL?ѩ:ߖCIoJbE}AʃC-G!#yIX}L-ͽC;ނ2k45hVOQaZ\ASFW=Ny[[Mp;uS^A9i
7y[M~Ț8S_*r={sN'DrAm(gQ&V{(.%G+
1RM#|ұ"Mc:e2JxIs1i; -?sUZhUSb>B&0x'E̻Hk8c lCFN4~dRe )+݅0~@.җc 5Q%%fcL)NFy=O; "7;JfWFWUD7fZe?Gs~Zy~wϡT- ({I_d s
mDY tM.fLfMWV qԗp.B&7Tgq=c^Y2i5rLr6$'2Y |ami+/kbkWǥ=L2ܨo(N^$S Fh^b{{@ά*6͚K(y$ϽBrV'}H
atcRqź^
6Ķʏð^~Kp\u{8 >*( sL]`ƀu)Eksdqcgs." Gq#Fʔ(U[zQ(ԫ 1P~tG?8
ŧ9
Ccu.B}i2
WF >^^ C#~w[%yganU/~ pw^~p >n+t}/s9M#s`?[߂-͋|~4p
ކk!_iwv|./R%> ɑcFsEujL.#E ФQ29ĵ,qӉiBⓈhx9? LT5q[/Q.5JMpoo&^1V8/Mg"Q.92".rzKML%]!_w^ЦA28=5}4Κ}g ײB+rP-U5G.|; F}O9|JRNC? LKƥMRw}ў`NeK :$X9Z759s\MrYշ Q@^M/ׄyTJNy 1 =5h:V_O<<*jܓR B̏Rf:%䴎dj~ƚT#
9WmS|7ˌ[rCnw`[6ڷsrͲ:ն@jJ)cLhA n^6Щ%!Y 6-DdjNG\ (FED9y _/? Nem||:lwyB 4&p'ADž DzXGwSn>k߳zWtu k=ou7۩{ z.Φ>l]'c--VN.Sw{rvvX썓Bϝo=C!]bx13zQKh٣CE1{ |G-}a:8Ep3@3˵]=^x]yy勚w_cO|j`q -8b42`ǰ >bP9suz wh$0'`%6
;Ƕ }JƸ{8U v)lw"Qa 6Qg&4M1Žv
04Q>-X ~Rb.u^3_FяM"].\2o:~8] (n#({[V@:C|7`n ة$$tX#R#oaNYm^6p-,sLtY_t^[9Qeˤ>*4JXpkjT{r2{:0 :^▎Ikh=-2_a,օ[2dZ>&6H?w#9 -J! v$&ƒ 'ŇR.Ô(|mMg
CGVtGO7kGh*<5~ԻI{=WV>8<nuXԽ$IÛ6Y
ҋ+nQiq>V3͜y ^B|:/&wۤ@}jm
{j5geZP,ۏTu~ok_~D[24~ h| ڏI8GϚt !GRc4|o2JSL^ER-ن s\~fF_>nS [:7Ys Upޑ{"L\y*v/ ߪT dMxwZMcӄz V>{sRN ~SS㘋=ﵿXj|?zj;sO x4M#ynN/ ;?B}vFsɼڶ`3U78lܐ8v RGa6z;#رQϙT-ꅋ bsj܋}EvBO:JdXp;Odd2[Z|'Qqp!Z宼-wLwސE eBRHؓg{g69Y3
S)^K&UR< . Ⱥ+t3?xF)swI?67r66W5RmL4ֻE2 P;3e&ד7:-ZGM
u xDΠ@< 8l ]ӽ?ŬE%Zp "z%1cYB1ѵMc~]$f1C'۞ww9kgA ɦ.e PЌKYLY_p(ܚX~wiZ# ˡSîI{WکI-h$&z:5ozkwӗJT&Urv?{ ??59_^7>;oSF-E Yʻ3»HF3d8ޥDʘ"y yK؞^ C}5~MR"N _)-bLj<ޭ6iP]^#?WfROR#<'CxZmmau1)n& ]wfY!_.-*omY~ 6Y9$o?G< iXL,.7/J3DeՌsLCnH
?#k?Y)
k^
g[ĩ?MrSܠ8״w&TUJ^bEک?+nU{)"4}OQM$],g=VLJraKN5L
2R>?|+ (z [e\c:8߽{wx{ p T0&6j̣)w摠D[rS64 EGդV$VĊThJ۸j^`7B9:3sf3W!xn&oz>OO]/卐n̤טnġ!J6N]I&M3L/$; Ob9۾t !ﺟx1U uerwb
ﴚ)wb 7>m\zz>.2v-õϺ^ jÅ]~bؽA}
bz:i1OL]|S9 ̷ z!y[)."#
<\ߎmp?j?\;}g9 ~bs< v6bOӈaWd~ɷs
}yk8c==vqRθsWMhmc!|@
r/c(ViW16;XַeE鋾uX=On
)yG;ZӮWy`$ۏnY'xF#ͻԼŷsX^M}s"x3͞_:/"QwwhƷ {9q p 8_:8C<#ܫFO31v5_>??"RF>j վWy^ÔQ C)GT ;fdOΡe V*e'ElET1^9
|͢K;ѼBO?;egLҞ;xb ]Bs:^~,@}b$,}S xf>rǾEAܗA_)Di8LHX@wsK}n;9%lprM]N*ʼm8,B zy'6e &? ۸55Ⱦ= | { ~ Jx8G'}_
H ca3Wyw`Ns)QL9׳$yotWcH|EAq> 罟.2KCXB_;\@kc|}s}6 'J 9Fss۬[o"8gVȾEYg_]1]?toJoi`#%̥tٕGO*_V~ x /!Zbk@-J24Bw'?swӚȰnv>|sr>A:jt? pI ;
s8~i4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fj{F B `~+L`Kd 2Ryrsds Cyȑ/:kldQgrd*toԑ
udW K#s> B*P i b J3,Ur! ,)$UfjAT\72RXEirܱquPE1 #H9H9κ8+PMixn% g[8i\'KsLIV||:-,3)
(KܽƌRKڠZ:&TI[,&IVʶkT[1!k93kk$K~ Xԧ80{&i6JݪZZٶ[Yrl]5K9!5YEZosʕV[mĢԑm%D E˭Hj
L%V;i'ڡr+7nO؇-q;&}Gb=)+ZXHBXZ$25wZh0biS3j52R[g8iEKXH8XΈlV2֓L:R ꉆ섕uljA;XI۶v;CV$Sjd0!;GMej9,\vHPije%[]-,"dIT
i
RS':՚D!ipEme2vTciHI'-}#33tyy|{^͛;6v
O7=j\eH̹m[gw۞|Cψ3q}&:/
kW %WʉzO d d&r{g<`˹/&wd !bC<dMwǟ j{DXCr,# [FA4tթBbyV $
nTDـ eR(5ٯK=#Wϑ{K1\:).%(@ ;wiu`L} ID`T"&9Vp% L3N mɎЗQoAAD|
ԅ'""
i}"qԅ~']vi e}n ,A JP:;&0e_eHqڝRlנ5L<3- bsĄ]@Sg 0^x ;}wu0*jEc9fu08nwmVbyYF*2ۙ-E)kg u/
BuH-ğÇ!6d0ѼC,d ^ c^Z5<fMlz# !ng1K zq&ـ(@3PgϊQ+,2
@+Лfm#",C6 r<+J@-j*j*j*\וO0C4 Lf \?܊tȔY鹛'~rrz_>\7YwZ)VS7TǪs õ#)pXLbf1p `+ I0V z d9̂y:'#2'J"|*ϰSO9FO%w4):xFQml#Ύi@ƚq6 &ۊo3kV{V9~uN
pZlӒ_|POr?VSVz T*=& PZ PcATeL7Jv #C}ݡvsvXJqɵs'\mjW*=E1: J^"H05d%.I=Q[Γ
B o wû7{
W{_ SkAy`1Gi , :N } $%4v#F_OnǨ'
0 ▣bo#zp |p 6b; r ȥ]TTL#~ =nH5n*$HjC[ Y&fyjA
M.hD."N9*'C;^2;ox/?Sq
ַcrJlyB\[ >NZN*cuxzO9Mf4dqGDW4H7V{ N$E`,Axu$&Ҥ
1q/LjK5L<_3UUL~syyy sn.6/6[,6K%ےeX2-&b!܌E gڄdd٦\OQ"AEH)W"If}+[[QtIJZppW2E( >T$t`P4J#t;XI֦z,$|ukև Biv cՙ39#F-Sn' RzD[Kf/lD配x[) i6ܯ%P$ez+W)@_
B`SRWDpc:>Y6Vٙ5 SxJ'5gj:Q8iTC}OYʃ!Q,#iƶpn@ m7D® moh!}: 6-' ᦖx3dZ[( |jƪ zHgCj1x!H"bk?.NJlHCKBgSPgh-rDuY(_tD5ճ"U RAؚN_(DOS6s5OZaн>A{{ e 1ߴEްo
E 0i1g,6fz=e=czY_V?fi>7f*ec Z8>}q:^ &L!6R%AHB鹥/-x҂7O7/
<, ;ofͶy` zش(o^fYmͳeNr߹v`vnvmO-ǁy?-D,f'vⱻ5S EMV]J4%GKQ獝 $;>gJ䌯/N圇</xGVj&z:C8B7\UF*L noԷ5cZ#m `7Cw\Du3h- ](>N|zSJ*i zF.G+RJ7*^x'q,Nwtx1vJtE I* ;I
endstream
endobj
31 0 obj
<>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[145.0 424.0 156.0 435.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>>
endobj
32 0 obj
<>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[571.0 157.0 582.0 168.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>>
endobj
33 0 obj
<>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[266.0 48.0 277.0 59.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>>
endobj
16 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 3/Type/Page>>
endobj
40 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(96100201)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(sktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/military/Archived%20-\
%20HTML%20Word/96100201.html)Tj
49.657 0 Td
([6/11/2021 3:13:24 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 380.25 591.75 385.5 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm
(Michael D. Hipple)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 729.75 Tm
(Chairman, Claims Appeals Board)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(/s/ Jean E. Smallin)Tj
T*
(Jean E. Smallin)Tj
T*
(Member, Claims Appeals Board)Tj
T*
(/s/ Joyce N. Maguire)Tj
T*
(Joyce N. Maguire)Tj
T*
(Member, Claims Appeals Board)Tj
T*
(1. )Tj
(The claimant is represented in this matter by Juan Cruz-Cruz, Esq.)Tj
T*
(2. )Tj
(See)Tj
ET
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 28 525 cm
0 0 m
17.326 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 45.3262 525.75 Tm
( B-271426, Nov. 4, 1996.)Tj
-2.444 -2.125 Td
(3. )Tj
(Service members who entered the Reserves prior to August 16, 1945 had to\
have performed )Tj
38.045 0 Td
(active duty during World)Tj
-38.045 -1.125 Td
(War I or World War II.)Tj
T*
(4. )Tj
(See 10 U.S.C. )Tj
(12731\(c\), the content of which was contained in 10 U.S.C. 1331\(c\) wh\
en the )Tj
37.854 0 Td
(claimant initially applied)Tj
-37.854 -1.125 Td
(for retired pay.)Tj
T*
(5. )Tj
(The statute also allows credit for wartime service if such a Reservist l\
ater served on active duty \(other than for)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(training\) during the Korean conflict, the Berlin crisis or the Vietnam \
era, but counsel has not demonstrated, and the)Tj
T*
(record does not indicate, such service.)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
15 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 2/Type/Page>>
endobj
41 0 obj
[43 0 R 44 0 R]
endobj
42 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(96100201)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(sktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/military/Archived%20-\
%20HTML%20Word/96100201.html)Tj
49.657 0 Td
([6/11/2021 3:13:24 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
/TT1 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 278.8662 755.25 Tm
(Discussion)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
/TT1 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 16 729.75 Tm
(The Claim for Retired Pay)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
0 -2.125 TD
(There is no proper legal basis for payment of the claimant's claim for r\
etired pay. )Tj
32.668 0 Td
(As the )Tj
(Comptroller General indicated,)Tj
-32.668 -1.125 Td
(while the claimant met the general requirements for age and length )Tj
27.017 0 Td
(of service, he did not meet an additional statutory)Tj
-27.017 -1.375 Td
(requirement that he perform active duty during )Tj
19.021 0 Td
(World War II.)Tj
0 0 0.933 rg
9.75 0 0 9.75 312.5488 678.75 Tm
(\(4\))Tj
ET
0 0 0.933 RG
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 312.5488 678 cm
0 0 m
11.369 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 323.9175 674.25 Tm
( This requirement was imposed on service members)Tj
-25.66 -1.125 Td
(who participated in the )Tj
9.441 0 Td
(Reserves before August 16, 1945. )Tj
(The record here indicates that the claimant served in the)Tj
-9.441 -1.375 Td
(National )Tj
3.693 0 Td
(Guard from February 23, 1930 to January 21, 1935,)Tj
0 0 0.933 rg
9.75 0 0 9.75 308.6055 648.75 Tm
(\(5\))Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 308.6055 648 cm
0 0 m
11.369 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 319.9741 644.25 Tm
( and therefore would have to meet this )Tj
15.606 0 Td
(additional)Tj
-40.937 -1.125 Td
(requirement.)Tj
T*
(The claimant's legal counsel now contends that, right or wrong, ARPERCEN\
did grant his claim for )Tj
40.228 0 Td
(retired pay in 1989,)Tj
-40.228 -1.125 Td
(and because there was no fraud or misrepresentation involved, the govern\
ment )Tj
31.711 0 Td
(must pay him under 10 U.S.C. 12738.)Tj
-31.711 -1.125 Td
(Section 12738 states that once a person is granted retired )Tj
22.993 0 Td
(pay, his eligibility for such pay may not be revoked "on the)Tj
-22.993 -1.125 Td
(basis of any error, miscalculation, )Tj
13.801 0 Td
(misinformation, or administrative determination of years of service perf\
ormed as)Tj
-13.801 -1.125 Td
(required by section )Tj
7.914 0 Td
(12731\(a\)\(2\)" \(i.e., 20 years of service\). )Tj
15.846 0 Td
(Counsel's argument is misplaced. )Tj
13.595 0 Td
(Section 12738 involves )Tj
9.638 0 Td
(the)Tj
-46.993 -1.125 Td
(determination concerning "years of service performed," but, as the Compt\
roller General noted, )Tj
38.108 0 Td
(the claimant's retired pay)Tj
-38.108 -1.125 Td
(was revoked because he did not serve during a certain specified period, \
not )Tj
30.267 0 Td
(because the government erred in)Tj
-30.267 -1.125 Td
(determining the number of years of service under 12731 \(a\)\(2\). )Tj
25.519 0 Td
(See)Tj
ET
0 G
q 1 0 0 1 322.2227 510 cm
0 0 m
17.326 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 339.5488 510.75 Tm
( )Tj
(Master Sergeant Henry W. Schuchardt, USAR)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 342.5488 510 cm
0 0 m
223.611 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 497.25 Tm
(\(Retired\))Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 16 496.5 cm
0 0 m
43.313 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 59.3125 497.25 Tm
(, B-274195, Oct. 8, 1996; 51 Comp. )Tj
14.666 0 Td
(Gen. 91 \(1971\). )Tj
(In accord, )Tj
(see)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 365.2656 496.5 cm
0 0 m
15.322 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 380.5879 497.25 Tm
( )Tj
(Bock v. United States)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 383.5879 496.5 cm
0 0 m
104.654 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 488.2422 497.25 Tm
(, 650 F. 2d 287 \(Ct.)Tj
-39.354 -1.125 Td
(Cl. 1980\).)Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
T*
(Reconsideration of the Comptroller General's Partial Debt Waiver)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
T*
(To prevail on reconsideration, a claimant must demonstrate an error in f\
act or law in the prior )Tj
37.653 0 Td
(decision. )Tj
3.833 0 Td
(Neither)Tj
-41.486 -1.125 Td
(disagreement with a decision nor restatement of arguments already made )Tj
29.434 0 Td
(establishes that the decision was based on an)Tj
-29.434 -1.125 Td
(error of fact or law. )Tj
8.051 0 Td
(See)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 112.6152 405 cm
0 0 m
17.326 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 129.9414 405.75 Tm
( DOHA Claims Case No. )Tj
(96070201 \(September 5, 1996\); )Tj
23.358 0 Td
(Eck Miller Transportation)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 410.2422 405 cm
0 0 m
125.297 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 392.25 Tm
(Corporation-Reconsideration)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 16 391.5 cm
0 0 m
139.963 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 155.9629 392.25 Tm
(,)Tj
-11.664 -2.125 Td
(B-245385 & B-245385.2, May 20, 1992. )Tj
(Counsel for the claimant rebuts the Comptroller )Tj
36.023 0 Td
(General's rationale in not)Tj
-36.023 -1.125 Td
(waiving the debt created by the erroneous payment of retired pay receive\
d )Tj
29.932 0 Td
(after December 1991; otherwise he repeats)Tj
-29.932 -1.125 Td
(his prior arguments concerning the claimant's age and )Tj
21.784 0 Td
(financial resources. )Tj
8.024 0 Td
(Counsel argues that the claimant obtained a)Tj
-29.808 -1.125 Td
(favorable decision in 1989, and the )Tj
14.301 0 Td
(Comptroller General should not have relied upon the December 1991 DFAS l\
etter)Tj
-14.301 -1.125 Td
(which, he says, )Tj
(pertains only to an "alleged existing overpayment related to a previous \
period" \(through April 1991\) )Tj
46.693 0 Td
(to)Tj
-46.693 -1.125 Td
(adjudicate's right to a waiver of his debt for the period after 1991.)Tj
T*
(The Comptroller General's decision had a reasonable basis. )Tj
23.922 0 Td
(As we interpret his decision, he )Tj
12.858 0 Td
(acknowledged that the)Tj
-36.78 -1.125 Td
(claimant was justified \(for purposes of waiver\) in relying on the 1989\
)Tj
28.048 0 Td
(determination that he was entitled to retired pay.)Tj
-28.048 -1.125 Td
(But in April of 1991, ARPERCEN reversed this )Tj
19.471 0 Td
(determination. )Tj
6.054 0 Td
(Thereafter, the claimant initiated his request for waiver)Tj
-25.525 -1.125 Td
(of the erroneous payments )Tj
10.83 0 Td
(made to him through April 1991, but before his waiver request was grante\
d, the retired pay)Tj
-10.83 -1.125 Td
(was )Tj
(erroneously resumed. )Tj
10.664 0 Td
(The claimant tried to obtain a definitive determination concerning his w\
aiver )Tj
31.017 0 Td
(and entitlement)Tj
-41.681 -1.125 Td
(to retired pay, but no direct response was forthcoming. )Tj
22.133 0 Td
(Finally, in December 1991, )Tj
11.22 0 Td
(DFAS sent the claimant a letter,)Tj
-33.353 -1.125 Td
(which, among other things, stated that he was not entitled to retired )Tj
27.16 0 Td
(pay, notwithstanding the September reinstatement.)Tj
-27.16 -1.125 Td
(The comments on the entitlement to the retired )Tj
18.994 0 Td
(pay transcend any period of payments involved here. )Tj
21.41 0 Td
(It is at this point)Tj
-40.404 -1.125 Td
(that the Comptroller General )Tj
11.774 0 Td
(found that a reasonable person should have questioned whether he was ent\
itled to retired)Tj
-11.774 -1.125 Td
(pay.)Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
21.767 -2.125 Td
(Conclusion)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
-21.767 -2.125 Td
(We deny the claim for retired pay, and affirm the Comptroller General's \
decision with respect to the )Tj
40.221 0 Td
(waiver of the)Tj
-40.221 -1.125 Td
(erroneous payment of retired pay.)Tj
T*
(/s/ Michael D. Hipple)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 16 61.5 cm
0 0 m
103.98 0 l
h
S
Q
EMC
endstream
endobj
43 0 obj
<>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[312.0 676.0 323.0 687.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>>
endobj
44 0 obj
<>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[309.0 646.0 320.0 657.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>>
endobj
14 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 1/Type/Page>>
endobj
45 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(96100201)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(sktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/military/Archived%20-\
%20HTML%20Word/96100201.html)Tj
49.657 0 Td
([6/11/2021 3:13:24 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm
(several attempts to persuade the service of his entitlement to )Tj
24.381 0 Td
(retired pay at various times but without success until 1989,)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm
(when in March he again made )Tj
12.329 0 Td
(application for retired pay. )Tj
10.912 0 Td
(As a result of that application, by order dated October 4, 1989,)Tj
-23.241 -1.125 Td
(ARPERCEN notified him that he was certified for retired pay effective Ja\
nuary 29, 1971, the date )Tj
39.432 0 Td
(of his 60th birthday,)Tj
-39.432 -1.125 Td
(and monthly payments to him were begun. )Tj
17.33 0 Td
(He was also paid a lump sum for )Tj
13.386 0 Td
(retired pay retroactive 6 years, and he was)Tj
-30.716 -1.125 Td
(advised that the statute of limitations, 31 U.S.C. )Tj
19.442 0 Td
(3702 )Tj
(\(b\), prohibited further retroactive payment beyond that 6 years \(to)Tj
-19.442 -1.125 Td
(January 1971\).)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(The claimant disputed the application of the 6-year limitations period t\
o his claim because he had )Tj
39.21 0 Td
(first applied for retired)Tj
-39.21 -1.125 Td
(pay in January 1971. )Tj
8.582 0 Td
(Although he was unsuccessful in convincing the )Tj
19.58 0 Td
(service that his claim was not subject to the)Tj
-28.161 -1.125 Td
(statute of limitations, his current retired pay continued to )Tj
22.994 0 Td
(be paid monthly through March 1991. )Tj
15.47 0 Td
(As a result of the)Tj
-38.464 -1.125 Td
(claimant's continuing efforts to recover )Tj
15.925 0 Td
(retired pay for the additional retroactive period, ARPERCEN advised him \
in)Tj
-15.925 -1.125 Td
(April 1991 that their )Tj
8.443 0 Td
(review of his entitlement indicated that he had been erroneously certifi\
ed to receive retired pay.)Tj
-8.443 -1.125 Td
(Accordingly, ARPERCEN advised him that he owed the government $37,167.65\
for the retired pay )Tj
40.13 0 Td
(he had been paid.)Tj
-40.13 -1.125 Td
(He also was advised that he could request waiver of the debt.)Tj
T*
(The claimant filed a waiver request dated May 16, 1991, with the Defense\
Finance and Accounting )Tj
39.931 0 Td
(Service \(DFAS\))Tj
-39.931 -1.125 Td
(which was responsible for collecting the debt. )Tj
18.606 0 Td
(He also followed up with a letter )Tj
13.357 0 Td
(dated June 27, 1991, pointing out that in)Tj
-31.963 -1.125 Td
(view of his age \(at that time he was 80 years old\), DFAS )Tj
22.939 0 Td
(should expedite a "positive solution" to the matter. )Tj
20.507 0 Td
(Apparently)Tj
-43.447 -1.125 Td
(the next communication the claimant )Tj
15.079 0 Td
(received from DFAS was notice in September 1991 that his retired pay had\
been)Tj
-15.079 -1.125 Td
(reestablished )Tj
5.47 0 Td
(retroactive to April 1991, when it had been revoked. )Tj
21.187 0 Td
(He received a lump sum payment for the )Tj
16.55 0 Td
(retroactive)Tj
-43.208 -1.125 Td
(period, and his current monthly retired pay was paid but with a monthly \
deduction of )Tj
34.27 0 Td
($71 to collect the previous debt.)Tj
-34.27 -1.125 Td
(Apparently no further explanation was provided to him at that )Tj
25.049 0 Td
(time. )Tj
2.277 0 Td
(By letter dated November 11, 1991, to DFAS, the)Tj
-27.326 -1.125 Td
(claimant referred to both the retroactive )Tj
16.159 0 Td
(payment and the current payments he had received and stated that based o\
n the)Tj
-16.159 -1.125 Td
(resumption of his )Tj
7.25 0 Td
(retired pay, he assumed that the response to his prior request had been \
positive and that he would)Tj
-7.25 -1.125 Td
(continue to receive his monthly retired pay. )Tj
17.661 0 Td
(He requested confirmation of this and indicated that he )Tj
22.243 0 Td
(would assume that)Tj
-39.904 -1.125 Td
(his position was correct unless he received information to the contrary.\
)Tj
T*
(The record does not show that the claimant received a direct response to\
his November 11 letter. )Tj
38.82 0 Td
(However, on)Tj
-38.82 -1.125 Td
(December 10, 1991, DFAS responded to his waiver request, stating that he\
should )Tj
33.105 0 Td
(have questioned his entitlement to)Tj
-33.105 -1.125 Td
(retired pay when it was established for him in 1989 since his )Tj
24.495 0 Td
(application for it had been previously denied in 1971.)Tj
-24.495 -1.125 Td
(Therefore, DFAS stated, waiver of his debt )Tj
17.523 0 Td
(would not be appropriate since he was not without fault in the matter.)Tj
-17.523 -1.125 Td
(However, his retired pay )Tj
10.135 0 Td
(payments continued, as reestablished in September 1991 with the deductio\
ns for collection of)Tj
-10.135 -1.125 Td
(the )Tj
(prior debt, until February 1994, when DFAS again discovered that he was \
receiving retired pay )Tj
39.822 0 Td
(erroneously and)Tj
-39.822 -1.125 Td
(stopped the payments. )Tj
9.165 0 Td
(DFAS then calculated the claimant's total debt for such )Tj
22.313 0 Td
(payments to be $53,836.81, consisting of)Tj
-31.478 -1.125 Td
(the $37,167.65 he had been paid for the period prior to )Tj
22.133 0 Td
(April 1991, and $16,669.16 for the period from April 1991 to)Tj
-22.133 -1.125 Td
(February 1994.)Tj
T*
(DFAS submitted the matter to GAO for waiver consideration. )Tj
24.995 0 Td
(In doing so, DFAS indicated that it )Tj
14.277 0 Td
(had changed its)Tj
-39.272 -1.125 Td
(previous position on waiver of the portion of the debt related to the fi\
rst period of )Tj
32.825 0 Td
(erroneous payments, $37,167.65, and)Tj
-32.825 -1.125 Td
(recommended waiver of that amount. )Tj
15.217 0 Td
(The reason given for )Tj
8.552 0 Td
(this recommendation was that although the claimant initially)Tj
-23.769 -1.125 Td
(had been advised in 1971 that he was )Tj
15.163 0 Td
(not entitled to retired pay, it appeared that he was convinced at all ti\
mes he was)Tj
-15.163 -1.125 Td
(entitled to it, and )Tj
7.026 0 Td
(when it was established for him in 1989, he had no reason to question th\
e payments he then began to)Tj
-7.026 -1.125 Td
(receive. )Tj
3.386 0 Td
(DFAS, however, recommended against waiver of the $16,669.16 the claimant\
received )Tj
35.072 0 Td
(during the second)Tj
-38.459 -1.125 Td
(period of overpayments on the grounds that after being notified in April\
1991 that )Tj
32.992 0 Td
(he was not entitled to retired pay, he)Tj
-32.992 -1.125 Td
(should have questioned the reestablishment of the payments in )Tj
25.3 0 Td
(September 1991.)Tj
-25.3 -2.125 Td
(Adjudicators at GAO accepted the DFAS recommendations, waived the $37,16\
7.65, and denied )Tj
38.657 0 Td
(waiver of the)Tj
-38.657 -1.125 Td
($16,669.16. )Tj
(The claimant appealed the partial denial of waiver, arguing that it is )Tj
32.351 0 Td
(against equity and good conscience to)Tj
-32.351 -1.125 Td
(revoke his retired pay at his advanced age, and indicating that )Tj
24.935 0 Td
(he continues to believe that he is entitled to such pay. )Tj
21.605 0 Td
(On)Tj
-46.541 -1.125 Td
(appeal, the Comptroller General modified )Tj
16.994 0 Td
(GAO's prior settlement and waived collection of an additional $4,138.41 \
of)Tj
-16.994 -1.125 Td
(the claimant's debt paid )Tj
9.677 0 Td
(for the period from April 1991 through December 1991, leaving the balanc\
e of the debt at)Tj
-9.677 -1.125 Td
($12,530.75. )Tj
(The Comptroller General did not address the legal basis of the claimant'\
s claim )Tj
36.865 0 Td
(because jurisdiction had)Tj
-36.865 -1.125 Td
(passed to the Executive Branch at the time of the decision.)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
12 0 obj
<>
endobj
46 0 obj
<>
endobj
9 0 obj
<>
endobj
10 0 obj
<>
endobj
11 0 obj
<>
endobj
53 0 obj
(file:///usr.osd.mil/Home/OSD/OGC/JosephLM/_MyComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/military/Archived%20-%20HTML%20Word/96100201.html)
endobj
52 0 obj
<>
endobj
54 0 obj
<>
endobj
47 0 obj
[16 0 R/XYZ 0 561.0 null]
endobj
48 0 obj
[16 0 R/XYZ 0 536.0 null]
endobj
49 0 obj
[16 0 R/XYZ 0 510.0 null]
endobj
50 0 obj
[16 0 R/XYZ 0 471.0 null]
endobj
51 0 obj
[16 0 R/XYZ 0 432.0 null]
endobj
4 0 obj
<>
endobj
xref
0 55
0000000000 65535 f
0000000016 00000 n
0000000141 00000 n
0000003655 00000 n
0000120649 00000 n
0000003533 00000 n
0000003588 00000 n
0000003728 00000 n
0000003755 00000 n
0000119798 00000 n
0000119991 00000 n
0000120033 00000 n
0000119614 00000 n
0000004391 00000 n
0000111525 00000 n
0000103164 00000 n
0000101122 00000 n
0000003858 00000 n
0000003904 00000 n
0000003953 00000 n
0000004144 00000 n
0000004016 00000 n
0000004048 00000 n
0000004080 00000 n
0000004112 00000 n
0000004605 00000 n
0000004644 00000 n
0000010570 00000 n
0000010619 00000 n
0000010655 00000 n
0000011165 00000 n
0000100110 00000 n
0000100448 00000 n
0000100786 00000 n
0000046396 00000 n
0000046663 00000 n
0000011611 00000 n
0000011884 00000 n
0000012362 00000 n
0000047279 00000 n
0000101311 00000 n
0000103378 00000 n
0000103410 00000 n
0000110849 00000 n
0000111187 00000 n
0000111714 00000 n
0000119699 00000 n
0000120439 00000 n
0000120481 00000 n
0000120523 00000 n
0000120565 00000 n
0000120607 00000 n
0000120250 00000 n
0000120075 00000 n
0000120386 00000 n
trailer
<<3FF30878CE87F2438CDF9024CF215508>]>>
startxref
120819
%%EOF