^Vcsuf3grLSm=MԷy
3s̛܋S/c5~;w|'(o OxOM|7F' ʗFHզӑL i$O]n:M1L- 8<=l.l4뾏"scK*+bl;bErwb%I馻dۛq?6(.߳y Tp3ƫxT*spi?4j 7A7Rw[*0e9f%o*=auz>92bL߷<i x&}E&'| G hgC?m]i'/po;wՄ6k2ZډL5j0H3~̕>'g_ 7kz,X{g!4{-W bZ6.{a:>YL)ǐdv-?kNn]3> b <{ojf|gd{0|=UbuoʽþZic 4ǫf0:lu]י
|݇F z;;4*+ ߽ ~eI(p S8ߟ:8zƪVٮw #SOt'>*FevʃGf(U4_ eOΡeVreMʢ&r0=3r*s67"yo7.;=&T [WSy9$)콋/@9 r\oп`zg,S* " +6 g(p[D/xGa6$B<1CnNS-F}<_AR |YA;V8|-vcU ̅|?Q7icM}!`C>kԑeJMlH:%b};L^f] :OK_{l2ʵI~ чKݦNF3FR^*sR$'͇_ClSt\7|%߳qL< D ~)t,Sb7=<ry
.3n6yY8}y91"]6_@/g~a!tW%L(u7l5PKK1
3^8M@<4{{Ncyr W 3Iwl 2{A܉7X
뛴]K|gk4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fc %0<0$0f˯6ToseO9YGvS pdˎ[Y مRO#8#{(_udǛ~(G)ʰR3bڀ("$#
)˯E k濍Fg$*bbnUl2d ḣl#E=6F 1Ʊf_
Jr+Q qDG NzX*]cblMbvΧUF
-RGטuVjQXP\+u b߸*b:_Dv R-BbUy%bCꓜE;{&hfJmZٶSYrt]~5K9A5YEZo'9OvyiJ-d7D#XǢq=)a}[2a7xw(Xbgg׆ZCX(,}Dv8=`#qc
{$+F8f#hѶ]LHm ;|hܮio am ND!vib&1vkXO]|Cψ3"Lno&Nyqh _|]}ɣwWN=9{ǗE9RL8#{ 3y!vߑnbłR
Ї 17Kno\.U/pO h=,YJ8 "鹩SIJJ-_I> v"VY
eR(5 xٯeK#W{S\7:).\H争/3
!00́*`q6qfp X3NmɎЗQoAA߄BGP?zմ{8Bc{e^-
t cXcb){uLP7'XAfh0B(tK?
\wcR1l 1@̀/8]l úDZ®5`T X
۩sl2ێ퉅kF,bcKXbQqJ˗â+Be ``Q_bIxs2Ć CwI`KJ1CG}ìCܴ80VحYҊA= ;,uggFV3fX Xx6/ͼF
Xs0(|ZV`6Vm@ʘ>h|u-Z G*Ss{KAyyyÇkaCk7<fɹ\ZzA_]mU&0Vp `0(`ӭ
6@Z,}>"}$g s8?&S8ZESDt4!xF7Ga8;5@+dkn ́>`0m6f gUW.ठ G{^(x*=-U%H.ԫw ի_WNcm>OS+|*z{؈,)^F.oMĦ~lS?6 6n1^ Uɗ<_0=.^|\O(EG3w~^U'" go䯺(B?ׂns'Zg!#Yhtx9 ⿇'PDAuzwuW]_F%nzTw |[wuC1g.R(q(b$t/nT"AbW4t\Ib1A jWITn?^2;nx.?S~
:}rJ,ίq~,I|ڕ4qՕT>EЋ|٥m;x#J~Ҿ@]\W0Hfk {zG 7?i:I|eYR eȗ!;rzK*b{.cøոٸh5My&)ǔm2L&I1S~rn$x3-B2
lQAPG )F?B$תqnL
_j[4IJZEiH˫m"V
*:0|(!m:JB VN#fya}55yr<)t>),kC-3g-ss(
gZJo00 L-N_ DRa#D%H#4!2 4,-MCD;2+WR!SJHL)avMYvf&"h@!B& tTK}ݑN8d <ޏ)O`3cbO4~3كm` h^\upX5#v hu=wTI
6LFmPm3U;ΆDg"X!p\!+$ryd?
5L?RLJ,mEҷN#km.~;#ZݯpU*}
Tr`6]ڊ.i\ w{؏o֢y4OP"T<xe6 q944K rpN:pKR
N):9 kN ~ wQA.wЭS[u_1 *{Ixϼ/",jˠ <ü? 0ȏ(j 6?6n*Ļ,vkq+Z(JlN f^̮x'~
V6P<[is=ZKwҎsnN]+ԣMhN ꠌh Sv4S~o w
c/lllNevk|i| mMsGZ 6<~yy37Z ƂB}l#p ~}ރK}ڟtdItx9x<|u'>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 2/Type/Page>>
endobj
38 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(04050401)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\
chived%20-%20HTML/04050401.html)Tj
49.712 0 Td
([6/11/2021 3:36:53 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 490.5 591.75 275.25 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 754.5 Tm
(ember, Claims Appeals Board)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 690 Tm
(_____/s/____________________)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(Jean E. Smallin)Tj
T*
(ember, Claims Appeals Board)Tj
0 -5.375 TD
(1. )Tj
(This matter involves Personal Property Government Bill of Lading ZP-718,\
206; )Tj
33.301 0 Td
(Navy Claim No. 0202270.)Tj
-33.301 -2.125 Td
(2. )Tj
(As noted above, the copy of the inventory included in the administrative\
)Tj
30.187 0 Td
(record contained the following description)Tj
-30.187 -1.125 Td
(with respect to items 203 and 204:)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
14.025 0 Td
("3/3 CTN. cp"; "mattress > plywood included." )Tj
19.222 0 Td
(A copy of the same inventory)Tj
-33.248 -1.125 Td
(submitted by the carrier for the first time on appeal contained )Tj
24.797 0 Td
(only the description: )Tj
8.471 0 Td
("3/3 CTN. cp"; "mattress." )Tj
(With)Tj
-33.268 -1.125 Td
(respect to)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
4.109 0 Td
(disputed questions of fact, we accept the statement of facts furnished b\
y)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
29.019 0 Td
(the administrative office, in the)Tj
-33.128 -1.125 Td
(absence of clear and convincing contrary)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
16.659 0 Td
(evidence offered by the claimant. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
13.604 0 Td
(See)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
( DOHA Claims Case No. 01060501)Tj
-30.263 -1.125 Td
(\(June 20, 2001\), )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
(aff'd )Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
8.769 0 Td
(Deputy General Counsel \(Fiscal\) \(March 8,)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
17.634 0 Td
(2002\) citing 57 Comp. Gen. 415, 419 \(1978\).)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
14 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 1/Type/Page>>
endobj
39 0 obj
[41 0 R]
endobj
40 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(04050401)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\
chived%20-%20HTML/04050401.html)Tj
49.712 0 Td
([6/11/2021 3:36:53 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm
(record to establish the shipper's )Tj
12.816 0 Td
(tender of the two bunk bed plywood frames and that the PED to the oak co\
mputer )Tj
32.992 0 Td
(table)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm
(was so extensive that a 50% deduction should have been taken. )Tj
25.548 0 Td
(In the )Tj
(Settlement Certificate, our office denied the)Tj
-25.548 -1.125 Td
(carrier's appeal of the Navy's )Tj
11.827 0 Td
(offset. )Tj
(On appeal to this Board, the carrier seeks reversal of that decision. )Tj
29.601 0 Td
(With respect to)Tj
-41.428 -1.125 Td
(items 203 and 204, it is the American's contention that the )Tj
23.509 0 Td
(carrier's copy of the inventory only describes those items as)Tj
-23.509 -1.125 Td
(cartons containing )Tj
7.609 0 Td
("mattresses," with no references to a plywood bed frame. )Tj
23.114 0 Td
(With respect to )Tj
6.359 0 Td
(item 275, it is American's)Tj
-37.082 -1.125 Td
(contention that the PED to the oak computer table )Tj
20.245 0 Td
(was so extensive as to warrant a 50% deduction. )Tj
19.605 0 Td
(However, American)Tj
-39.85 -1.125 Td
(offers )Tj
(no additional evidence of the PED in support of this latter contention.)Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
21.906 -3.25 Td
(Discussion)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
-21.906 -2.125 Td
(A )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
(prima facie)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
5.555 0 Td
( case of carrier liability is established by showing )Tj
20.022 0 Td
(that the shipper tendered property to the carrier, that the)Tj
-25.577 -1.125 Td
(property was not)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(delivered or was delivered in a more damaged condition, and the amount o\
f)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
37.46 0 Td
(damages. )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
3.999 0 Td
(See Missouri)Tj
-41.459 -1.125 Td
(Pacific Railroad Co. v. Elmore & Stahl)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
/Span<>> BDC
15.776 0 Td
( )Tj
EMC
(, 377 U.S. 134, 138 \(1964\). )Tj
(The burden then shifts to the carrier to rebut )Tj
29.355 0 Td
(the)Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
-45.131 -1.125 Td
(prima facie)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
4.583 0 Td
( liability. )Tj
3.861 0 Td
(Normally, if household goods are not )Tj
15.192 0 Td
(listed on the descriptive inventory, the carrier will not be)Tj
-23.635 -1.125 Td
(charged with )Tj
5.442 0 Td
(tender. )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
2.999 0 Td
(See )Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
(DOHA Claims Case No. 96070203 \(September 5, 1996\). )Tj
(However, a carrier can be charged)Tj
-8.441 -1.125 Td
(with loss even if items are not listed on)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
15.914 0 Td
(the inventory, where other circumstances are sufficient to establish tha\
t )Tj
28.74 0 Td
(the)Tj
-44.654 -1.125 Td
(goods were tendered and lost. )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
12.163 0 Td
(See)Tj
(Id.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
(; and )Tj
(B-235558.4, )Tj
(ar. 19, 1991.)Tj
-12.163 -2.125 Td
(On the facts before us, we think the adjudicator's conclusion that the )Tj
27.589 0 Td
(bunk bed plywood frames were tendered to the)Tj
-27.589 -1.125 Td
(carrier was a reasonable one. )Tj
11.827 0 Td
(The bunk bed plywood frames were the type of items that would normally b\
e )Tj
31.159 0 Td
(shipped in)Tj
-42.985 -1.125 Td
(such circumstances and are reasonably related to the other obviously )Tj
27.712 0 Td
(tendered items \(the mattresses\). )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
12.912 0 Td
(See )Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
(DOHA Claims)Tj
-40.625 -1.125 Td
(Case No. 03041004 )Tj
(\(April 17, 2003\) citing DOHA Claims Case No. 96070203 \(September 5, 1\
996\); )Tj
40.579 0 Td
(and B-235558.4,)Tj
-40.579 -1.125 Td
(Mar. 19, 1991)Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
(.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
( )Tj
(Moreover, the loss was consistently )Tj
20.719 0 Td
(noted by the shipper on the DD Form 1840R, the DD Form 1844,)Tj
-20.719 -1.375 Td
(and on a Transportation )Tj
9.775 0 Td
(Loss Report, dated March 12, 2000.)Tj
0 0 0.933 rg
9.75 0 0 9.75 305.9336 437.25 Tm
( \(2\))Tj
ET
0 0 0.933 RG
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 305.9336 436.5 cm
0 0 m
13.806 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 407.25 Tm
(The PED for item 275 did)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
10.665 0 Td
(not necessarily suggest a condition that exceeded average care and/or us\
e,)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
29.821 0 Td
(but in the exercise)Tj
-40.486 -1.125 Td
(of its judgement, the Navy concluded )Tj
15.246 0 Td
(that an additional)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
7.192 0 Td
(25% depreciation was appropriate. )Tj
14.133 0 Td
(As a general rule, a carrier)Tj
-36.572 -1.125 Td
(accepts a shipment only in apparent good order. )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
19.411 0 Td
(See )Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
(DOHA Claims Case No. 04042702 \(April 29, 2004\) citing B-)Tj
-19.411 -1.125 Td
(257515, )Tj
(Dec. 1, 1994 and B-193182, June 16, 1981. )Tj
(The carrier may seek additional )Tj
34.047 0 Td
(depreciation where an item's PED)Tj
-34.047 -1.125 Td
(exceeds that which would normally be expected )Tj
19.465 0 Td
(in average care and/or use. )Tj
10.938 0 Td
(The Navy gave American an additional 25%)Tj
-30.404 -1.125 Td
(here )Tj
(over the average care and/or use, but American argues the Navy's action \
was )Tj
32.916 0 Td
(unreasonable because it should have)Tj
-32.916 -1.125 Td
(been 50%. )Tj
(American did not demonstrate )Tj
16.856 0 Td
(by clear and convincing evidence that the Navy's 25% additional deprecia\
tion,)Tj
-16.856 -1.125 Td
(instead of 50%, was unreasonable. )Tj
14.079 0 Td
(Generally, we accept the Service's calculation )Tj
18.588 0 Td
(of damages in the absence of clear and)Tj
-32.667 -1.125 Td
(convincing contrary evidence. )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
12.328 0 Td
(See)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
( DOHA Claims Case No. 96070221 \(October 7, 1996\), )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
(aff'd)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
/Span<>> BDC
25.432 0 Td
( )Tj
EMC
(Deputy General Counsel)Tj
-37.76 -1.125 Td
(\(Fiscal\)\(December 21. 2001\).)Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
21.767 -3.25 Td
(Conclusion)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
-21.767 -3.25 Td
(We affirm the Settlement Certificate.)Tj
0 -5.375 TD
(_____/s/____________________)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(ichael D. Hipple)Tj
T*
(Chairman, Claims Appeals Board)Tj
0 -5.375 TD
(_____/s/____________________)Tj
ET
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
12 0 0 12 16 38.25 Tm
(William S. Fields)Tj
ET
EMC
Q
endstream
endobj
41 0 obj
<>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[306.0 435.0 320.0 446.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>>
endobj
12 0 obj
<>
endobj
42 0 obj
<>
endobj
9 0 obj
<>
endobj
10 0 obj
<>
endobj
11 0 obj
<>
endobj
46 0 obj
(file:///usr.osd.mil/Home/OSD/OGC/JosephLM/_MyComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Archived%20-%20HTML/04050401.html)
endobj
45 0 obj
<>
endobj
47 0 obj
<>
endobj
43 0 obj
[15 0 R/XYZ 0 608.0 null]
endobj
44 0 obj
[15 0 R/XYZ 0 583.0 null]
endobj
4 0 obj
<>
endobj
xref
0 48
0000000000 65535 f
0000000016 00000 n
0000000141 00000 n
0000003655 00000 n
0000140364 00000 n
0000003533 00000 n
0000003588 00000 n
0000003721 00000 n
0000003748 00000 n
0000139754 00000 n
0000139840 00000 n
0000139882 00000 n
0000139570 00000 n
0000004283 00000 n
0000132349 00000 n
0000129895 00000 n
0000003851 00000 n
0000003897 00000 n
0000003946 00000 n
0000004096 00000 n
0000004000 00000 n
0000004032 00000 n
0000004064 00000 n
0000004494 00000 n
0000009500 00000 n
0000009549 00000 n
0000009585 00000 n
0000010097 00000 n
0000010556 00000 n
0000076128 00000 n
0000076395 00000 n
0000039909 00000 n
0000040182 00000 n
0000010991 00000 n
0000011267 00000 n
0000011720 00000 n
0000040690 00000 n
0000077011 00000 n
0000130095 00000 n
0000132574 00000 n
0000132599 00000 n
0000139237 00000 n
0000139655 00000 n
0000140280 00000 n
0000140322 00000 n
0000140098 00000 n
0000139924 00000 n
0000140227 00000 n
trailer
<<9F7669374BBF7143A59A2CAB5266D18D>]>>
startxref
140534
%%EOF