%PDF-1.6 % 1 0 obj <> endobj 2 0 obj <>stream 2021-06-11T15:37:34-04:00 2021-06-11T15:37:34-04:00 2021-06-11T15:37:34-04:00 Adobe Acrobat 17.0 application/pdf 97021808 uuid:3eee3054-7dfa-40a1-8de8-0a1d67a9abb7 uuid:6ad6b919-1542-4e9c-b18d-57ef6778efe2 Acrobat Web Capture 15.0 endstream endobj 5 0 obj <> endobj 6 0 obj <> endobj 3 0 obj <> endobj 7 0 obj <> endobj 8 0 obj <> endobj 17 0 obj <>>> endobj 18 0 obj <> endobj 19 0 obj <> endobj 21 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 22 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 23 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 24 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 20 0 obj <><><><><><>]/P 18 0 R/Pg 13 0 R/S/Article>> endobj 13 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 0/Type/Page>> endobj 25 0 obj [31 0 R 32 0 R] endobj 26 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (97021808)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/97021808.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:37:34 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 759.7503 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.751 l 579 -0.751 l 579.749 0 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 758.9997 cm 0 0 m -0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 578.25 0 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 758.25 cm 0 0 m 0.75 0.75 l 0 1.5 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 758.9997 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 0.75 0.751 l h f Q /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm (In Re:)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (American International Moving, Corp.)Tj T* (Claimant)Tj T* (DATE: June 25, 1997)Tj T* (Claims Case No. 97021808)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 15.224 -2.125 Td (CLAIMS APPEALS BOARD DECISION)Tj -15.224 -2.125 Td (DIGEST)Tj /TT0 1 Tf T* (1. Consistent with the policy established by the Comptroller General, ou\ r Office will not question an )Tj 40.492 0 Td (agency's)Tj -40.492 -1.125 Td (calculation of the value of damages to items in a shipment of household \ goods unless the )Tj 35.826 0 Td (carrier demonstrates by clear)Tj -35.826 -1.125 Td (and convincing evidence that the agency's determination was )Tj 24.671 0 Td (unreasonable.)Tj -24.671 -2.125 Td (2. The fact that some pre-existing damage may be repaired incidental to \ the repair of transit damage )Tj 40.206 0 Td (does not diminish a)Tj -40.206 -1.125 Td (carrier's liability where the carrier has not demonstrated that the addi\ tional cost )Tj 31.891 0 Td (for doing so is ascertainable.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf -31.891 -2.125 Td (DECISION)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 0 -2.375 TD (American International Moving Corporation \(American\), appeals the Sett\ lement)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 401.875 447.75 Tm (\(1\))Tj ET 0 0 0.933 RG 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 401.875 447 cm 0 0 m 11.369 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 413.2437 443.25 Tm ( of the Defense )Tj (Office of Hearings)Tj -33.104 -1.125 Td (and Appeals with respect to the firm's claim to recover $676.08 of the $\ 1,779.21 )Tj 32.422 0 Td (initially offset by the Air Force for)Tj -32.422 -1.125 Td (transit loss or damage that American caused to the household )Tj 24.771 0 Td (goods of a service member. )Tj 11.274 0 Td (The Settlement allowed $295)Tj -36.045 -1.125 Td (which the Air Force reconsidered in its )Tj 15.856 0 Td (administrative report.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 5.66 -2.125 Td (Background)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -21.517 -2.125 Td (The record shows that the shipment was picked up in Pratville, Alabama o\ n June 3, 1992, and it was )Tj 40.38 0 Td (delivered at)Tj -40.38 -1.375 Td (Mountain Home, Idaho, on August 10, 1992.)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 231.9824 339.75 Tm (\(2\))Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 231.9824 339 cm 0 0 m 11.369 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 243.3511 335.25 Tm ( American still disputes its liability or )Tj 15.359 0 Td (the amount of liability for each of)Tj -34.305 -1.125 Td (several items. )Tj 5.748 0 Td (By Descriptive Inventory number, the following )Tj 19.579 0 Td (items are still disputed for the reasons indicated:)Tj -25.327 -2.125 Td (American disputes the amount of its liability due to the damage it cause\ d to the eagle on top of a flag )Tj 40.627 0 Td (pole \(Item 242\).)Tj -40.627 -1.125 Td (American contends that it was improper to charge it replacement cost \($\ 14.10\) for )Tj 33.1 0 Td (the flag pole because the pole itself)Tj -33.1 -1.125 Td (still functions without the smashed eagle. )Tj 16.803 0 Td (It offered $5.)Tj -16.803 -2.125 Td (The firm disputes the application of depreciated replacement cost for a \ silk dress that was damaged )Tj 39.93 0 Td (in transit \(Item 168\).)Tj -39.93 -1.125 Td (The owner purchased the dress in 1979, and claims an )Tj 21.91 0 Td (undepreciated )Tj 5.858 0 Td (replacement cost was $128 based on the cost of a)Tj -27.768 -1.125 Td (similar new dress in a catalog. )Tj 12.357 0 Td (After depreciating )Tj 7.552 0 Td (this amount by 75 percent, $32 was offset. )Tj 17.219 0 Td (American complains that)Tj -37.128 -1.125 Td (the Air Force did not provide )Tj 11.942 0 Td (the brand name and model of the dress on the List of Property and Claims\ Analysis Chart)Tj -11.942 -1.125 Td (\(Air Force )Tj (Form 180\); therefore, damages should be limited to 25 percent \($25\) o\ f the original purchase price )Tj 44.125 0 Td (\($100\).)Tj -44.125 -2.125 Td (With regard to the five piece set of china, American delivered the large\ platter in a broken condition. )Tj 40.539 0 Td (The service)Tj -40.539 -1.125 Td (member claims depreciated replacement cost of $65. )Tj 21.324 0 Td (American contends that the )Tj 11.218 0 Td (depreciated replacement cost should be)Tj -32.542 -1.125 Td ($50 because neither the Air Force nor the service member )Tj 23.435 0 Td (provided the manufacturer and model number of the china.)Tj -23.435 -2.125 Td (The carrier delivered a lamp with a broken shade \(Item 131\). )Tj 24.601 0 Td (Because it was less than six months )Tj 14.526 0 Td (old, the Air Force did)Tj -39.126 -1.125 Td (not adjudicate depreciation. )Tj 11.329 0 Td (The Air Force found that due to the design of the )Tj 19.856 0 Td (lamp, the shade was not replaceable;)Tj -31.185 -1.125 Td (therefore, American was charged with the replacement cost of )Tj 25.1 0 Td (the lamp \($39.99\). )Tj 7.637 0 Td (American contends that neither the)Tj -32.737 -1.125 Td (Air Force nor the owner demonstrated that )Tj 17.3 0 Td (the shade was unreplaceable.)Tj -17.3 -2.125 Td (American argues that it was not liable for any of the damage on the rema\ ining items in dispute. )Tj 38.294 0 Td (It )Tj (contends that the)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 27 0 obj <> endobj 28 0 obj (H]ipazDg9!) endobj 29 0 obj <> endobj 30 0 obj <> endobj 35 0 obj <> endobj 36 0 obj <>stream H\j0 ~ COkgXrt1NzϊJ3$%CrTVvD~5NvxvV$)NO}Dyl;<#lal E ^aUks?أ m8qM-iʄn7!/svNXFGh􍽢0 a>qڥߍyJq&8eN[X2K9#3K|$>1A8#G$$;HrPYq1ja7En=y*vSM[>d|WFwe\0Q҇3ZzI],>^,įW. endstream endobj 37 0 obj <>stream H|y\TG5o^p fQѬ,d57F(CEPT#^(xⅨx}̈+ʸjM20=bߧ~ !g-ZN-,V!Q1Im'gPP/;ft!+}AIm aP> Ԯ@qѱB(, ~@bNJc–|>n8<&Zv7 ȱ ]RFT 0 N;s_x\nި 4LC&ScK!R/i*͐fIYKKn!.31R~ƍ٩K; * r I)]J_RPJ Ey@mw5QMSi,unR{"D=U":u 6yjx@xg<\`.4;7Lv#ٝ1j:T.=(a5413>! NBf[yoDm]\Ȼy}\A>ćQ.c|OpS|Y.VkkS,~4dIʲ̲Nn<_K|UV|o|]G~mÏ2]tW磫u8sslcHY&E@@{bc I4w&M'q2! H]`Aԭ,L&3@`C9qp4q,ѥ\M7ܒ:܊[sp>.\p9 ?զ\4e\kM|Nsǹs9NST9NS::SDA  <@  iᴄH$h ɐ1,6r   )ܖ>r@4ZB+h m-'=d=SO6Li [3!>SKOh gi0  4|75 s2M=s3TJSe 5H ҃ 3 i$44hMIH/ ߧW59^_үޤ[0|X a,%X+`%`5~+CyH3L4 E7GǼw6+| (Wm/(S;b)fbX,bM 6mbDg+/o!s̜4g8*N⼸$-Q.]< *A>);')G\Ǐ\jZxuED8Q['̗E,Ȯ}wY,KdoWcM3J˱r|Q*_oȷD,ȷ崘͐b3GΓ "D.*Zʵr$r+"&_}6: ˣ<.OɳTV!}Y)keJ+VV5P UTJW*Se&*W嫦H5W-E;ZUTGEuUU@S^~_ P 95L W#H5*ph{p 1j^VIv aq3, {>a%{{w=iOi{ƞy{ڋl{`': Nsѹ\z7:.nԕr.ˮq m625/12J"ZVGk<66b n&nMvST7Mw3L7v9nnS>ćc||,wtUg}{7w.FH.IDJB <4QjWV QB`̀T ܿ޻sgΛ:⎸+AN)Ԡ#AyNYPo&؄PȄ&\-UW: ^gj$Geulj Y*ApZHhMxX' j NC+Rj7a{a 6@t7 ޅpN޽!:cGttw?V: M W8XI֨-%zhw? ܺ a<}+ (w$0:FlwR清Y V@D{ڻA2; $Tflas D95`;\f.nlZ0$zNj_stlg}{ɏInW@ЎO{qB4-ooxDV g9И3LfFwq 2^(O^DxB,6yV8.&n& 8Y<WX}6fؒ3|*T]j;]+`(&܇Xw$LgB.BQ(Wy=<;==ϔU\~ p%X볧6ƞGKp%~_>,<Y-x(z1d=%ߑe'sG{\ǍvK e[mF ~ \P?r]{ir7B0Y&a_8SXD[+41თoP"'gJ`۩rcoe@Xg_ȽΫ6\0m,L ]rr2\y 7ߧ*lbi2ݾLƹm=n­\ < >@ĈƋ>{|Cs?'.;mB 1jXH avJ']`CJFjLB]6ʤuNZX41`T[U(lhV$IH4z}~xߤ^ױ?`Ɗ1_d1 2g?0v~'oVcOc12+"wo ?1d &o?o9c Z~<"O ,@NNNA z` 2g~`:{VK&\⮱6#@X_`9|9I^ª |;O_C;-NJ_&'6?s1!B/Yrw:SFKTcw cy) 3T@{PӭYbnhƨjξSFS8S2Od(/$'dQ,hM ݨQ^uaI bUcj|O\#&2B Rr8VXCRhL-*u-X%IIO%ܭV-^]"6!6V4_FYSY=rOt%=^7:|ő\Ĝ[E Uz51+ic2k\ꎧ8n}ؼQdB%{pKQ;vzFIm9,)R2E SeeM(J[BF슖gfaҐX:ekްeU4.A,K4Qg׆zP($YjzdZI)BF櫜[E>`ȣϤtMP n>h'SIXz#Sq/Gr Zж]ɆZ4$iޟ A7"`k":ZoR)32ɱkI|06Y{IA%7ͭ 1&l6xZI0.:Qs1(7O kHbʺgЃ'1*u 㪐jʏI$,Ѵ 5L| |zf=CQL3xq@ŸRnYde45J,5lnxKH!HF+pF&Z3!ocGbH%NQB#p2SĐҩTjD 5W觨Qw u.t<%ӌ4,ӄF}vtsB,Ҍy`^z9ƇiKL=ɒ~, B9xe!|>C%0yFw2oUP}|8':^pXhdnH9 Efa@dGP#|r}ڃ,  {o˯B.ZP%˒\XarH Ga)ƊVa'&-($HT VAD-f 0i+vY)Kz. - M-vb&A& Bh*] zzznzxDOӂ?]ylh'8~eX'Z;D:^3[Ԁη@NF0;# A)tN%ov6ii]2|c-]R㩩am\ /pm_ 1A [_rߵ^hWo`t G؆^9m*K & ^[jXDCϿ Ž:Γa%.&;߻|s'vI p S [!4ƠiH46  bN-vc֮4u ulHui=4M;~;}9 %+^ | MN[>lWvӗInEK"-ItJRk"T,.%[֤}HqM]jvѸB[0pɟV[`v_*=LgCW{ mBsX­FP@qDه"P"Pjb흨] )Ly4Yhޢ)2 OWEAkJM`v0׳BAG;Nފzʽ-c-H(2ʤ3\+P(ψwKLTϬxK,o]*2s㕝K :W\~-~kXSl$JD5k fW v$`=7̏!9K3mړ?m 1%+`ܰsw*0$]Ϙ08ozImVVa'9U[LWCrNI?AݩmRyٮy)|H賵Q-.>r\4<]؟&~#e|YqRm)A+ѩ{N\8W`iw O]}4J7T >,º:Pdټ['x#M;%,[$.+ÎA,X!E\\`IR`%t8,Ⲙ^\+"\Broa (*R`F'Ñp4Lf8ɻ=n6f((~ fhnY(j4i:J\nH\?D0/G+Ηyƥt2]JIOz>v}C3[㻈..q$&Rr-r+Ä!O]~a5lc^$^Y6zZ[oUH$1"+Ĭ s?!o<=El]PK޼J^=S.DF[|h 6hx9cLcϠV-le~ VFpvHtjgfi, f1o9xC))J:ZXSU5b)`(1a9$Bz)DZey 3R_Uh]?5UhiRdz5}AL=~rv~Q[6e:hO\q.h_U ]AqiyO> R$kYb5!Alw>wr$D, ~$rpX!(‚I]3 s1À3>)^ v=J!<ʇC#ᄜ2o6A͡h!Q"S*!lg:4v4xvw#= 0SvT폃m6Q'U^ZP)BPT Xh46.Y)ԌZ n~S<,>=· t\.dzz:l$3N8OlKt=U[3W=6acEǏմ`خ&;s|>ؗ؁&\ %t| %J::VBIu%Dt݆unBZQ6C-ӴTkCV>=O=c_8i\X\RChHReDSCnIB".ȅ2v)~.ԍuД}|*Df%R*jU!U#\PG˨2UExe,ϛqC}%Q:"‘x9Yz^wY>ʸeR@AN P)KЅC׺[d-إjaI5 }Z* R,n8t"Qv\IsKwcc" -Sݵz4u_Y5~!"Ƿդoa=yirqViDGYXɤVIЬa{KR=P,SZ9k Bs7ZjG?w0_>i[3y':~XЉ ιнYƏvf~sЌ5rU)<'.eQi⛂MfyFZj.`>tRZm"d==Ȏc}S~?qzn{E"?6F7*/(wN:^2+{|Ml[Umvxh%;֣`S76@g=dt5nM5JLW**K2qs~s8JtC`LW88#b" eu÷fki=u EWyE" EHyE0KEE\Un/!I) #켐I!}b/w\>iᪧ7ve+*V**w/`?_+G}}=fMVeHE)؛£xY cMu놟J (('quݑ}~%I5&ՏX%}:{=5?Vx4F%d%1*JpBE7&sUCR=ыfꊚOjpD):[Tb J7V~d`wʾmE4m{DM#~ u 4P+~Y.ʇ!OȋEz+G@.]ٖ KWrޱϤ{{+eOgg\-1CaQ0Cdjedl~C;xO;X3nl?E!wck6 i&v  " !IJфPnjeNg( %D\' Ty`T P.Q.5dSԚZBr،͖P&dXHkTɱo (Q3%-/[T`xh ?Pϊ0q1$1jkuwܹمďٱtDWzl ?w^N[710 H2g Jspg:|׋K{؅W"2Ac397FnIFʸx7&J4!obXŶJ'J`T)7l9Gt`y,G(@_[*ȓ3 RCI]3E~r5.ɭbSGcw,2 v?5,u-_ P Hߓ?(ߐr˨ /״qƇTzJpD-vP $BQvRgwbTXMpNK㹵7p߹ϸ0fcI.$VDؗGa4/z'}6151 .kRqM])𴡷WmMLgZ8@j\g4} E=\cwDŽ`ܭ!]1>j芳 Hwe2 N:D|L1e[ Y/7;} Xm?lfP%Zf .`K@ IZHsa"z!Q"Y阍2E)X@h|Ց7׿xmbY>ݡ<$4+xMosOxNIB8"oZ-)ESX ,)m>p5l'a&nz^X86j>v{(&0bഃp8h?UKsL*jn4# xk5A2 hLa {7e㡘a%o~k4QIH̽Cp&6 ?R#iuuFcnE:\%@..TBq$ZG]so%Өms3Oրj΂Ec \̚gl޿'9խGGLL.J?sS>G * A+lւO5o`Ml'Dah:ye9 &4@9k& 0(~mHX,v+oŭIYb`Xѭխ&9u>fwz<ޙٝ}f wK*PZBbPjmiV&R~%?1IHRUZ)Z)R6=ys=;||Nc]g }~Z?zWŌ~S( wFiY8! FJ3iIBZ`iզ-ۨn.۹w࠮6@||13b)g՗{"v8TDb'̹yc| p&T~I^V(FCFXPfѰvׅWvF zi`7Z/Xr.!Ă5"hDچmaƱj ۰,f 7Y3pj.pZNXrLrXXjL0G Ҁ#8H9d5 HAx5uB"B I".!%J ޼>TX桗:;~6E-.u*ښtOy?X:C"r7JPm))95ڶO.~  s6fh AU3 D(nmQ$dע"A裒K$޳gE4)"F"+3Yk*]eRQn*B__7 NtR`%q ,:U[y(p2\\hYCIUd 1$\7resmdˌ؆dY9O7U Dz ,K<fM{{4FG#µx\ 뺪-(aU E{r0NLƴV=bDMFlmٺ7&wC!hC,Mdl#V)5-!\^?Qf`PFR ƀ-vc,%K.R'DѮ \&bKJ`2,ʤ0 jC0TP\(zBq]y魻~bĊytsXP^>22o<@@,Ӈ;c}`B :5S@_RogP9R 1d)^q d,S7.uSk]=Tό5kY{,=dPXś_/M1q#O/xیm#l:+^VJ\&qSpKMG3VF=QtNQo$39>Yfu|~_sWڄ6#Q0dtOa hy<5MȓhѱǠȆ4 _R|JYBG}G?gܔGuSK w'}Qʻޜ6FWǵ8$[duK
FA2*O3tcSՄtR;24do9/A-89A*HԽT;32Q@dI_lЀuH02xZ')n!avp66?p'rܝc߇`_.j@PuWOb__GX['zQVYa0X!u(/V6x) NH r"2hO%>W?D=%]JaaUA^$;. Q]gJdkHH.j_vww3*< B,C!6*WfZ!+B{(ྒ^IO>l yn{!&"%HS P'nIa w[ꫤA9BJb&SzB="XcsDȫ#z,^-Q\Wwx]05ޝgLlc/?8PhH i+mT! 5Icڀ JQ$hPEFi h Ѫ"sl6Ъkys#,%P.p¼tܓi1$A\ wHCMs/oܾA|,6",OP~,B.["Kz?p)Ry<+o_ίx[B-Z0#G+Fdo )>xOa8;*ۧO/,o6s} 5?+,y}y5Kg=oNNZzk*϶5]I$-ꪉY[ղG>_c\yEFAi;d^Ed7O'i՞r_=t `,udE>C5Z2CpIK22yP Bj'RRGR0Kʀ%HG٣s٣sţssssţssN|4^?ˤuYgǰ+îx a>a>̱l>g52c!ؑFE||DZ׮{vsT*]9|.|ʿ[ZoJ"ϊ*hc4* ece((j|Y9N4?mE͝9Ƹ*VmyAcO:,m@f(R$"r5o>wwwz ]<λɽ)\C?}N_$R.?z舺DE@3٭P\MdFF'ThO/ŸF`Lfl >Q&@˴( ^XLjZDqB6 0VbȍC{*.P;h-\k`/| Jϫds^Qf@|1'"g< QfwP!Є9 zT .0>J)Wowۗwg|F>_"Lry lARL5@חp0>UC5 7wq+@|h_9jon^ؒzgMM{i+䉰4A%UaJBv!lma}h, '?m~y"-a_ȏYӤ!ئy cˁGq6D|[caq{r`2m]sz`1`NڱlllXCm;ibacϼ=6c߲1_fٶffvw9EZgwm%pK>i}y#jlq.<t5ߥGBjTi?CyC7Q+lwIy_Z[eX/~I״ s"'CƘcmvVSO{8G>ʁ>wt06ǨRELE1)`sT1:3} ?|+67- vuڶ$qC?ybpnc407n]R !>Զ&>$s tS}vGq#9qs9>^>qs-@ ƿoaKU&WI-573)\ϩ*McYKE=E)NکÎiw+&+kD~c,CR V+4!o_-EL d(D{޼XG_хŚ"yb&﵎VT59A9:C$쿏:jyo )_jɣ|8^X6:=q}X,!p lv<|_I%ʯo"ƿ {ȦZy%U?*54<ׁ=A9F `Чc +A1Tޢ*ið3J7h~b}F x^"=k/Ýw֗猟qs`]1e*/@⡅r7^?^"5OBIVH;nR@?p8 Snߥ-pK3\"O̓mmU3$T~1"/ ;D<:O4N~_ƺJc\(P/BHnRێJSڊ\RƐף㟠FVV>m]dȗ= (-k2򏲪w}oe00$ $$P @HOY*: \͌de*1D2"TdTZ}yܙ7g{;?=G}>g w׹XZQh'8;>/*tQE\sD,rtȱx>#v 97vTQ ;{ #HBku%ehw2'ۓaw ?h ov9aoFff?y<}BU4Q}JH+O3!N^۾5oϺD+֬7wi,'ZM9@ujYϪ56t{UWe:|f/Gbkb\ =-=Hk=օЖw+b5a!l31wkv'>䲴i.-sgZ>1rjeQ W2@ⓥsy?iyGl4+sOyJr\r{ys9_Ϋ!vKr͖7$l:qtQ%_)>&g?&#)BjLa3EOr@ePv)beN{9oU}Ț[G`,tpM[sd7E 1֡BZw(wܙ\, j^8.$fOÖ'0m&_?Xf7c<O@L'yT'J vZ) ꄺH̠`,C`gkWIm0=:М7m}d=ʺR=d-Eljղ&1NzPC)MϒRjuRt)^H+WMNh<\j@÷!^/]*!J6um3YM;l'>*hWmmmo>&>yLmIq5yw *,u2:0FEړ7R~t,yMv0Fh.gI)忕2E:+SW R+S7?vZ+Ʋ?vp=V Sgh=oS#rh)rMN S 糥 ,gɹNߡhy2ѿUHu[* V9/8Lh367ƝeL\n>>jI;'kRrimtG+659ճ]2!9{,f6YmxqQYro_2 cP (ְ zN|m{,kl;=wٹL\~e:uU=W6R}v>X=Ü yz6ձo8OS.[־im5zq[kNs;oͺUu{f\1ކHvu:Q_gߟSZ>uO墶=DXl-HÕ;'? 5vP K% n.J|VHI`.H&gA=_#cmŸP3GFqѭ vD;糝ߍI'.{{>W]"ӚFIky5KMp@⣲ڛ>-r}sF aA hm}B{mJjz=8}C|W\Ko G5W!vpEcE{.e>|kėM XDo ?zxUr6ysF`Ʃ=wge\B?j"IcSdmq wM+|ofQ|E何%44w [] /zoaMEmVwVo}k,?Z^u Ӯyc/ƾҶsmjۤVzYU\aYd1 mXLx 3Öa=(+ &a(-ؗRD@) HHIBHI h%`+|߽す*S龯oӧٌ k]aR=C^QG@zd<%Z7w;z98u%uK3Iç1R:\;COZe<˾.n& ֠3S^Ϳm1E׷ h+=33W`4v>Z*c Jg$>;#W|]K^ta_mC><_/]Jb ~PPޫs۹ӈ+m(^ c_cEqN)vy[NUZ'P_yz58RVT]K;):g@|?O.Us)xvYte(}Hc.MC)y#v%LE8^)]Ҫ~иqUujR`8ՉC7qv"g9"WEx$`]Ď5ɘdʧ8 c5*LYl}<⏵_۱Q:ml-{z8  1y>᠉Wq(kbdgvUi%!NF*MQN+;KC|Ag/1nm}q;_e)?})_ sHzrwGd:b$ȉ؏]dtEjT7<ꠔ|/Lw|R۠YQQ?JK2jy O\Z| ñ.Q.D\ho<\ih4Z%0߰PaMV)ۥ-T@s^2~휿J3Jzc8$ߩd_: .Is"ҙui .Q.tHwݴ#Ɩi;]w˧ӥ[vF-Xj$.<-Ir7o:}ЮuMam)ȚPn/XF1}/sI=3{|R`>fNvy1|.t<ƾKiHu_%w\#kFLM uO|wp@ļ;wg1Cm.%ߥc\ѽm{2>EWcdsښ=6=ﺞ~gɄwsQdrNnģ?ѱ8}+yΝ1|fPc?Szf3~>IY5{%N{ wݠt)"( `"t%CW-u0ŋĻ:_=)s 2.a90ڪ KRA}åGBAC}P* 5" V5xi*?#[ռ +ьN^~%xt7boJwM cK({G5)HQto0;7E8Kg'1K7)[qηvo>)2Xdn" Kw<`?#b=,9 $6G&㜂),djlw`p\@mWh_-PwsPTLJlI^ y3XUiwkC{[64:ԇAi >տQQ;5FweͿc~-uм7{Xm4=)c'XϜ`GԌ]"$sڊ7;\o+w{_1U9rAbO$16Œh#6 I=mv3 ܁}x-!]Ylbt/U~Gl}9ϦNGmi~J9Mcv2VBlIDM0ĠL!FP66=@1suSB cssߥu^ZqCԫg; _ڎwW ՋwyG7]U`-O{wcqI☏8+)y;w \ukI} q~+&+:GW[迗y ^E<*b,iQP fʕ*Q2o1^ܑX{0 _L_{YyHa?d{b<'(H$)_8w1b `+To@TWlIt %8w'Kggvў/vpQv'd qQMWbN<ua3l`=Kwn 7m;j]+\qbC{ҕ%`Q/)n2܈xϔf+ ,aՎ.}Puxxwc^q`_cFŗ'gΝiLP0A-~R-Y+)3l%kp/Xpn臱oh?b9OS{8y,/aۣ$j>YXq&)Y6f9?u wX՟=߅|E ^] y eR➯2+:KrZ,|p kjF6;ьaƝA{ߠq>'>[Xq=hKyd̎a7G*irmإUg hWXs!h;99 G?NmoqrghcJ%s?.Wqޡ[%{HB{VX)Ap\U胾6G̸nnDoN_ | LT[S*oPzbhɪ-&us9ּeRy^$j]n\P( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( ?_;C[rF>ZGDGgɎ4Q9}OH[*Rw~M?[vձ#C;`NކMw }h5*w|`:_X69ݖ8qVZO4Ad?( r4Ki t ?.-ZPFs)Ҁ~QL_~:΃yxd*76T&DrT >7#kd^V3|0m$âN_d65ԾxGSٌÅ6F&>I'H2N"'5仦cYRx"剫23>G# nt&j@f"O'cF8ü/5Yc37ƌẌcF6e1#'-]wwv7SFvIMEC6w\l."<ČHfƯ=#QW˕En@c[V)ԋa0 j~ ^o?RX_:֫O ˃Bj{C>xn{OuOuȘ"i"}P[PS!]nr]&TP,^*h[eYjojV!AH"pE˔|< [ -}(ɱ0S;duR> A$]) NXa)+4HeA~:ӾLkɏ [~2YBNKͦRhh yt @IQU/i#&r٥oU#c!Izhb=@|z;Q}@&@_(T-_{+ds RBE9vV4$6 )pc/xQ6K(~݉Ͼelll> y]$>N l2cb?7 o}O߈ਮ:|}ds YvrCH\MKDMI[unTdı U[l8:> 8CZGEDT:RkXL79yܽ9P݄j\_ UI.2"4sX)⿒~{xT(J: ذǸT-՘j2pj2 ৆āc @v `X:`j 6rm>'8 $:&ifi tӪYMhr<9ǯO]磕SJEk;hMc&hfj]<͏qU<`tw{ܼm[Y{q 2}^bw{]8qeM'5,l`W{^2{E{u[-az`{S l*An^Ebސ?HNDeB#!6cc:1d9C1=]]NyW ۭ= E{Aj屫2XIg/!bl?0pRtI({ b'/ aFyZE-v$<'$*͌>٨}<խO[TG4k 6Z^7:to;>xv-7#N+qr-'rMyc :kmm?rWF}P=ퟴk?WBƩ1LoX oq:`ƦH@&V,ݡ"kxo:?6ީ/h[s~!V嫌ֆnfn#/fLK["KAd2*͠2T&y .,A"iF;ONiHsK3z_Awej1LC7bC*S'"pN&PϏN$17?%4}MЫ W)@/ I:L*^8/'e _I[&@]2Y'cA{d꺋Rn"Q21;ϑnNjtdR-z$aui G頎bI4à+I1Xճ,Ss L--u2IΎ#1T4+MD$#0=qN|r3RܵrN*{9Nd^q sb1[Ƽ)&VB8|@""\,X&SMoM"9F{ xѬ/s*oAđae/%!4EwdQ{b7& }OEgxyYlshJ= Rzdj@\FuEͰZ#Vŧk/0iqcQw%Ŏ9N,v9 Nis2'q6'73aUͱ{mڴe¨{ NL)obM[3M9̚e[ ϷӦINΖ`nښ)ӌ4/8þ-GgTe_Ct?\{;/Vv}ǘY߂)gӴ-s=ULy{Sf!]8)jouU=ZFbld$2Ĕ ?"nf:Dxhhk^Q6hQVN4AVz@`-PpRa%! Gu{͑|Us{5|#YYߥ p929X()mL&IqH*{(vHn,~wޫ9ww{G?=^lzӋQȞ|4&'،ld!,<ݳ=֍fzjOP6q8!8  z亸r0fNt~ޖA9Ǯ:Ԙo2mjed>Ax G2:\.Ct7t(B(8cլ $-!#&һKWb0} \g{C"`ȉ~].z![~~Zݲ[u/ cZUZ-; HWO <%7h6{ \BEe*`!I*/R+ʋq_ endstream endobj 33 0 obj <> endobj 34 0 obj <>stream H\͊@}݋&jݟnnp1?3I$ĸNN#hNHq춻C}}éi!]PpL-P7q7VC_y~eמb :𰮻cz,oC=_c(.,VNG_%rZf?5ySXLsbNPОS*,gU+OP,xy6˗ dadeVdc6dgvgg y˼E~c~C~ge'sd"l12Gd:#g3pF:#g\3__sA`A`A`A`A`d2CA ;t(PСCEJ¬4+J¬4+J¬4+J£4( ʹƮ ]2teЕ+CWFfЕip2te4ή]9;;;;ӟ/ؤ5*,nÐ?v~ӦөW[`5gL endstream endobj 38 0 obj <>stream H|y\TG5o^p "fF%5fW#1jAQ DFOo BAdF4^QUCh631.fH~U!!Gϖm&,6!ccRޙg"شT!Ns_e$ JNӸ'д?gP؄ gw뜃c%E9Nq^`a׽QB:ֹG|$ r}R;]r̘acz㰘n/6зJ>*8P)?ed|6sf ;6eC^^,QR4$k4,ZY#io"ucSrKy57M6e֚5f6́Ff9 1P5 &jB}KTԉj:UUՍ6uz@-RKRz/,2,*cذa[w,S,׆ G#U[惚g55g3YvY@cHR4NfJ+2酶6Zn-ci y\&?ep.Zߥhd(28<18/JiJ+N.X\WFlcS)S]9渗)StZp*8W)>,Qp 2ղbC+ z(_]U/N3ř hvCܽL̚LQ TU{<lOiX^k{۽vv.5vڭwܻCBȔ֎PjY^s[DQyMDV PTDX7^w~N02y{%;{wwx|vWZ៟㳰v>|GB([[$A[=/{唰Vw,,:2ɘ3SD]|\O3FD16 "[Tӈ 9A $^("^52W*^kآM嵼ț7x;&iy'ݼ> !>G(">|O)>g9.2mFԺdGCvg2:Y/{Ȟ \Η2_|+6Ε|o|o!eBWU_秫~8sslcHY&E@@{bc I4w&M'q2! H]`Aԭ,L&3@`C9qp4q,ѥ\M7ܒ:܊[sp>.\p9 ?զ\4e\kM|Nsǹs9NST9NS::SDA  <@  iᴄH$h ɐ1,6r   )ܖ>r@4ZB+h m-'=d=SO6Li [3!>SKOh gi0  4|75 s2M=s3TJSe 5H ҃ 3 i$44hMIH/ ߧW59^_үޤ[0|X a,%X+`%`5~+CyH3L4 E7GǼw6+| (Wm/(S;b)fbX,bM 6mbDg+/o!s̜4g8*N⼸$-Q.]< *A>);')G\Ǐ\jZxuED8Q['̗E,Ȯ}wY,KdoWcM3J˱r|Q*_oȷD,ȷ崘͐b3GΓ "D.*Zʵr$r+"&_}6: ˣ<.OɳTV!}Y)keJ+VV5P UTJW*Se&*W嫦H5W-E;ZUTGEuUU@S^~_ P 95L W#H5*ph{p 1j^VIv aq3, {>a%{{w=iOi{ƞy{ڋl{`': Nsѹ\z7:.nԕr.ˮq m625/12J"ZVGk<66b n&nMvST7Mw3L7v9nnS>ćc||, tUE_7B$}!l  a !l:"#d 3,t$@I$D%0swx޽w׭˹\r-q[w)Rb~(x>8|(EM1 GV PӜPJ ;)j87uԉ^u +ԍSIR/MɔB}(R?Oh J?M)PFiFӟe"a2]1q4ާhMI4T@4_i}H3iͦ9Esiͧ>E>%<›:;:b8sȱUkno&P z#)}Jh9e ̦C(VR}N_:Z+hmKim-Fh;%O)vW7 h/[ CtQ:FǩNI:ETF YJsTM5TKꦺ}GtKOots+צ>l JU8,n-unCtk0#tN6x)NQ:ZX5~oml=[6Vk,YkmCmd 6ls>_tn@t=X'$~` ^D=h=j{žl-[n [i9[mklm`3 EPNީLtQr;G1S;%8#YQ!*E8'Eߊe"⚸.n̉.̅t5Xe`JL&5P1/F7(fHq?JUgJU1E*y2AMTdQ22SR)0Y1Y2ideq2^ 2Q&d;CH=fvS/L bf>;1;^ޕwcBtcF0*Dxښ`bU3*Ѵ5 &tE]U?1g6L˛Md1y7/{(eVf̬5ysYg֛ fd6- +2Y>2U1A%g (rMKlZڄ6&̄@`n-d.4pr햯DPXl_` l6+&rC` BoZ6f`x zN` P{RdW R2r?Dh /3Zv,fP,e ZA8t0 u+n_w#ʤ `3yYR!>|;?quIVDA9)S8DnS sn#B4 c>!&=ϻ< x9rV,r><~&њUbWC\Ί-B%\Y(ɬ]kynK,dì|| 8~Fq\7wƘp/=3w)gbN>a0] Ȟ TCI{*"Fk'jQDTi3-E %iTIV%j"J7{aWj+yng̼y{\6^a o㭨~A0?:O1eN+\Vr5֨nPKj^w?#?>- [}BK6O}_]T(xWyVή2GPtWR3e?!W)}4B.{ 'j)kbKoJ"%T=}DįP?בrB1^szà&S]}N8k\dG5.bc/- oS:Gb[x nKYl #e,)#⥬Y߯ՌK\'V@w&- _7VRY鱵aI%Jvm|jӴ@ =fXa3-!W^E`߂obӣLeIx&wv:N]mHov=֯NQH3)4guf;o4=Iw6E߃(KCŷku|xgۍt(*Ϩ/C:Ur+TX+=Dstϭ<릔APר=.d=K/5 -^}|]Few+_A.eL2]_)C-GU(&v"Ld|_fb5!~Esz=)D[gmCmC@eԝc;"G0f2d(⡯ " "!Ttq>ߣQid9"7L Dpoyb^K=~G]]G|  Ѿmk|C}kc֮w{V~qEeKTB_+X9l;f1df"OS(4R.lV6@'!l#tcӧroש2;n+;OϏRf=)5[y=]Z ʤD&лuHbZ]KNZX Dc@HN |@Z8`Χ7ne*&=J-)(}˥QXs\ qi+V@dZ҄mVmle^l6=!UH$!Cdb&wS<}t3$^+R`IL@cRcoð7LwZ8b3 YP+|VV"Sv,r;"ӬۖnXX CՅV[o4 _&a,"c{ iB^li6SPq G0NW _&71ҽ2 QHoقc88>=ٷw6oM{1&BL906 @c Z(҂?*$%u/` h%%Rէ@Q!YM%i:j7Y쒀 Au-aဨ)B+a*HJJ}z[j78ЮA Ae W0U-hQK0D},8DpžcEYY<:+UNewXR.oW:lan=AK~.h48rH|jWA)>A"Fq.bė0 O W#-PN76.c;fQ|vL,Exa ԣE:1} Ќ9#kn*CdF!#ǔuYo_H<@0ֵ$H%8`2`n tCMi#q 0A=f%L&FeGYz߾sߖ8]4-m)/&⁂^x"2Ixdy.wdHH%Ӊ8gjH!9"-s= 4ES̀h%5/aj'~'N8n91Kq6ebx, L*a BAHAf,LPF|;Ҋ͐љ?yWZFٸslK/#GۺG]K4s835ޡO@6-k7sX*L^JP >(D$0s0 G0 W+K5WWJHPo ńdž洳UW֪q%P5hh 8eX6?HgG0"DD&.k_rI$(;] rJlI@*Da^/ĢtK2AI 5 +;W`"vf7[T ls#?qc<T]܍sLm5UnTQ\X @s45w' Υ"iLp9968}0P K3@GHqkog*ȿͬ:|׻:v.?ښ̕6Oyc<~H[4PG#Ѩ{P߼sg7o]}LEYczGbvۚFyo'SkiR 5v8VRqD`~GGć]9Onwec{,NE#Zhzǿ̟/7:^eS *e;lӏT4lӹ);lRVH;XTITiǀS*f XV.q {!\\Xd9m +k&NJe7A@ĸh^U6a 3vFA*ZE2 ;*[*P*W2M[Rےnk0~4Ya ?8uB74RUhū>NrsP{o'c?ڲmxPoִ۴}z} PʟSg_)W!oBOe4A%jc:{ko:ر8q N]rÀAR4!} THFd0A&`CGNhK':j MPhν mEW7}yA3KמO*_Bbg u6` MTV>aҝ8C6Hwq4ͨ[vND;9N\֢<=!F`T I'B͍?$]GX7o<h[G~GèQ5Q1,'R4~%:qPZ(Fdҁ݂*+j.nSy7?0K ~S >R_T^fT>>7,ڌ-(j.G1{UЍUǙ,QR0 4kv:;3 01? i ѐz  oe4W+Ni/L'M/jj8 SFx!MdәB ):JQ[V^  @* .Ȳ-QqTH'f80.*k Bqrv̩/&a#mFԉkE2?pX s{c; mՕNCCEb~49"DxTԼTNPVLK%&f$A.~%nŒ⛑c,4"0eRҩqg}|Oǂ" bQ"Wj (`%xIIѰ@@G՜A8"Q9O#^v9ŦuJX 6 ?#V4)-d'N4Iz$ L|ޕpm0W^FCh!GzЎۉ@7& Nzylܠۨw;|tc r$I*3ˡa0 [Iz= R:61;"U[0P}:؊3{_)HlH*`mLR2fKP s{'ˌEw{Ln:2 ]TW!7ɠk!8B8ƞr"ZdC!Qnv%hS4RQW.K ɒ+dM2+"g`'̠-"JT;?0pಹ^~/T!A`+ӌ+JMfQ3 ,g52\HrD'βwNZ($ݧ٪q|.dwJ{efnٗ-/?z@ު ӣ/ \<~qf7<{xmӽٷ/{0AXNcCi:`L+4k&4 ig| ، $ASÿI$ hmY L8ewFflvYQo$>,(ZC)JYy{ CjuP&M\ayhү2=tCa^1&&QC-V =lΊ>.tuSd{ ׅB(; /G]%)sʒrnW@~=VÁ|n,^Av,~X0ERR4Eґ:w*50Bզ^ck/YRcnlI>G3rmnU |cΒ8g=Qm-7%EȅoqZdUZ_sl&M6Rwy4^XN3c\%8]D*0ҏ,ܲgYj/_hki-[# |_tצ TBې/! b?!c+Ơq0㚃#~RE>T01'R>>_`̯h*dkP%x>FfnPMPņ*c.+7Hn;mm=XhLڷ%J /KJX/+o[]5Mg;wľlߝl]l8'6%RѤ+J4jm1ҩ#TV NhiP*Cni#OhЀa0-E>)2GcPp@)w&|Vop56/x;|[I"E+z$Vyߤp0YS&yR񑤢Dda Y}D%*Rm!~.藬Ёn%>EЅ?;P_|Cf{@.;;eĴMPu%J9\$.k_¢#|;OS\uװ8, (7\ۤmʸ5=CNh ,I"c:(iQ-D& @$BS&RFv.i×GYnk ꔴL=S]\x(W*Wֹ6"깼t56=F5xAK/9"JA擳[YAs7W4 j.٭ڄ=C53Eo׽aptH1e=?c,ԆI#{Mwp#I6uD͊oRVIRnr;=Ν3 &Sx#S@yd1j5L1%8'I Dzxd3!SL^͟CԒqݤL)K@+,}I^̣fs j |x_0[C(Vb-NwVff}_r5ІT$.m&0!g3 q'!"a$uJv"`eF[DbWgM ۨ`~cp9N^g1x㜪vL7viHeg7/To~08p|/WQ=\##wNScBFN!ߌTR@tz> #p76΄C&{}a`Lܮ ƥJZTѐxd(!#纼޼-{װ&ttfh`@{WQZ4`BV SETeD|:[; svEzȼeS] _ɽ@^ 5zfnaP;Zfȉ[-C$6=1j'=x2!j|G3/>k;a=:LFϫWOVA0|kbeՙϼ(oҧW2Loh5@oeQzgY]јJfTc2QGe%PD %I%2H f 29fpX&a-1IoItM{M{ڜB_-Ju%Jz;3\*C@jh mamuP]cv0X#*! Aors9ae4ǁ(KtL5E1l"a@&|s bYSG\>iZS18c3&}%0Ce= 0hztǒ+wof$ ?[5eC5/k꒾x R-_WCwǶqa;'%99Kr1k4^*hcVM6VuH :ѵih#~LBR2iUeڡݦ%9ikc!X1Xɣŧ5~Us~DNv>Juw+]]_Tόi 5g5tE^uZ0 y%Ѽm]4\ZD0XI$iJ%q[OeǙ b2vT3\׫:C>R| D(eD2:)#NHlvpܠ x~.ޚ?05x8M.Wc ۮ`&x<K"0XGNO&q4P,b`A H1;b{xyѲP(svO}O*?D{/W7^r| 5XVO1v^~m4=?4v1ww4Y[QWw!zB9=V)JAEnoJ=,a:Qc2d !`fX$қo*_8%?ezlOUG^]ZFg;,1p0LS: ѵaVtmab]DiFb2o$umH nm` B>ѡ&diUy\4f vyt(Esv8ؙ{Jci0<5M ^&sÞV=6Ȣm!ՙ\کt/rIXy^!`ec XM(߅G xRֶFIH9ۮl2֟o*xW`ж/}P1yx׭÷ =;;ntԻv>Mk0]kHu-l$"a^Q1N g*G>*?/ l~ wgav´3^5fE1c. LƺfIgj@4vs$gd4,ctx55Ȝ~uZx{̟o=Cפ+ *T"h{(ƾQhDd[T6CnS1vԍ(XᴚRm`qchFAt0~w?=K (RݍR)ۨ%-v[5sXn/kB=1PH2 h\4DWOO~1TozGVդֺjSx R)L̬+z Gbk>Kau-mA8MB׵piaLIFrajDma {*63pDIU霄Jy` N [xJż^O {9ɶ܌U=SwAWN\1D;g&SUȄCm]+/2HewOu x -dHn,eo (4Q8 _ \F޲\dlU鑭ؗ.nȏp&# %Mѵ3ZW"HޓZ^9I-ɳh8۠@ \ɖVUy=g>_lwwo'>8 4:hh XZi>`P"Mm71V Z!!nǨQi:>*Jcb&?fwg{~I#2K&q6y'DɌ|.Tq )jL$jy&Iˮ1o*e- Mz6o/J&Ov?=$L%e9.? "1U= <.ENMt̬g3H iP2oMxP{I;֪='c:nf*9+zThB%ġ^Q9QR. 1I RÙDŀbW] hMoݢwL]W%^A!\<, SG[C= =V=sBk'zjY +nėgi}ܚiҖK"~U)m=2CrkR'cxquk[~&E/˗pS%٭,7[ d.`%*K:&gE*M&_F[FyKD筗>0:h˿-Q>O$_ȏI73_mr蔖枖6ߒYZk0S7 q=*3ƢQAAYt5,YrrrݥP0(aÁe%S m94~L>nLQ#x4p`S!t2=2GB!€ì B7n1(A(9W]"d[rA0"$W tP*N ªAq`#GP ӜEΆ{RN 3Fu)F -J&,R@΂'@ ,1YD?$Y,qvBqTCRM؝:*  HfT+P,zdvowwgwyfv?[r70moO <OEjGV_=;LR4 rҧ~;oO~\Q/`x!ٚɧm洷Դڮ5xE:?.IcS7cv nJD^Q3T1(QޟI~" !+T ULڢ&dB>'virR@I" iL(H횵T躎fҠB II0 ڎIJTX5%2iMy{%/r-gbF( *~O‹Ǣ:AX HFQ.D<<"$bh1SIYN"D6P5 :\ŏ9 67pD|hxs73ZPZ5/mM-E*lۋ2*Cj#rJe~:Pf Ng)(*JB `1 es"Liin"pc{- p#̸EHY\2ֲS#oc5kh_65o%RcjENP|~w/&~^;Tu.`yxfN=yh%K'|#!!_aUٻ,.XZG,z-e, PKKyk:03A%'}h#xްg~U1k]Ap_|kC&.%1[kv[Xb-Amf @8Bv& |!LVOn,e*=(D2ݞhOOOԤ3 ;b7 |oy} eN@U7|D-'@]2 &v*%OVx7=m^w\ ] *zN'ǜ^ffً:{{#;*MGu#q`wzoq\?p.?z/|ez n$2|&ߺo)xsC<_T OuMZvVJ J(ZHU96se-94$9y/B6e[>*˴s `e6.-Y}\CY f%&'J7 ~{Gf4Z0[c8 a_E}ɬTyY!WoNڏHO s H$kHW  --$``%Ƥ]J'y vu~`EwFq]{wf<^wƻgfvKw07aSYXjx8Ƣ!!%}U)؆lKGժ,UAD-j=w Gw5ss{s)ܐU{|֞P,uݡ'b꾔i*_KiRyzi?K=1[mFdeUܒײַk@]AՃAU`g5z%KtQ|ZSJ*kSmNFf~0(;aD (#{20!4^MS08&WG7ww̷ogo #7K}'}I,]/G.?7/7] s⇁rdH|$?iz`v}9#=Dp O'Ai(6̲mfX +HD3]kUf4!װ%+kh cYt4J F'/(=:$%)`fFEYLeۍSڢIuz 29gȁxyE!r€F4R @To0`fD1agCuxAWLہR)Q8g^a7^2cmg90۝θ3w8ѹ'EzA6E_8{ +Pbo_F.?K?|Se*;6g YPk"Hy_C6 C'%q( ה5OːdDp(Kk=&st#u\nO*WI\;>mmUjsPVQejF mBO?N#5`;Q[{bN'-`G I˲Dˉe>u`&0Ԟ;#ݐk-.UqS_cꞄ 1,d*I5!P7 LęIfags `4_xBEI?m @Cw t߷.}AU ,ܟ jUӕmkWpr'*)˄|#i 0`$F*& T@+U Te0U,G  FC= 8 ͽie;`Y*?@ *Tu'aڼA]UTP*&eW'0ҳՅ*4[lKe-+KhZϜ}xɣ®QXo(dKA )}O43Sۗ974ss[!I2.-9e;IPkj:WnzQ:IQؓ:QݟVT(v( u(| D>Me$7Ӌ8 ?.,J\tla|'G3Ki4{ &-ܫfJdqCPW:$j8Jl-`wҩ)y͎a+-q1Lf)+ %WIɮBGz *=B߸}3JQ5v}~XgI'b*W${23![ձrBg-Q| 3w@ȢoufsY-2caKQ^s5#xn\fF}^\k>޺`) R:9mY}8`tttx[etf%ث*Ao.-\ ߜ'_8k H ՘8ǹ&q\˚6^h"ZX@MӫڵP| G88rAe9[ d4lwfU\uڬBO]=. p#2(7NQ+\(4:Ue޵ E*'`?b-Ų(Nr4gX,ԂDI! INBձܺpCpֳ~-S@ڀ!]/$&앟|e[֨J}qrӋױ}îS5~Pخ3u̮soV~F_H)|wyoi$ xLr[1E᭮M R]Vj0QRS=IĤWD6Al|.C9Q$37%wvXPI>H䶒vo 9ֹK]W?{^{=nV"ݑ||g7&Uڟ 甖%j4x8<%,RLY+WLD E , 49q'3c2J-cVu_c67ݷILW]L?30 ÀcO(5!l\ʮT*R*/vڭX!/ڇMN]5ByIhBmwQsa=sk;;w0ߎԮ$az=@_p;޷v,;WU%pUw ٖY&r؈QgfXSt5z'j F$tK_`X'0*K:+E 򤚑'}> xn }oo媽Az+$Ʋahz޻^ifhgUTy|B}}}5,*嶄8o~5 %ڄJIT2Hh0QpA^ +Su* <S`] hb9.!c&!Fje5c MfT%Z*ȭEW$`c7^?kD]X,fIO[W[%5|v|N٨) Q#_C}zkM*)/δ9lZ6q{{0}:Q,,ٗ?_߷4Ӊw+'r,~n|>vpP_`&Vp|3z*Dg|= qp.W t*_{*~AwV&~Qi.8-BY C-_?ȴ30EGy y \V d+,:ǂ!2ɬ a#y=&#[/8#Vgt5 m5NFjNn F/N)7? 1,!`<8pJPnXJT1u7u?eOyHxM 0aqIpQSQ.7FxNkLNK/̿X`:g _6&׵tk˿2:W~f9Ws0śDOP;)ZxtgFA׫X Μ4=X:z|iܨ AP`B-~N<'p9QbT%E[ы &0ǰ#!fRG.5ʋ2~"H@RJ >r\3C%Vޞ{aM)[" ɯiUϺc[#3&i, H\"q%n$L2q˰g$u?-L׳;H{KIF@ PڳVebv9k5MfE첲(ΊQB,Qo&\s7DZmMfm(Pd"ZU"NNJ[Ln_ԗuU/w]rNM,^ު0a/}BOϷѷIB IQ#"!'[lR %jA԰…*,")Z #K Z,B;ASVݙ]37^.mmZNw}v/;:yvYt\%N҉QzoF"eI4N@W h?> ~Gq"Ɓi0/n.B`ǻ|p`3e'yHy@qUr /42Phg3UaW[qm G.ni2݅5nbP BHHH@uFh"5HtiֹB"HSEPhݦ`{}~<:J^#lǃ#]_'txf9,+z]t9<ػ1-WSڮ^ ~Kd <:'xFq!D5b.lt1qːğ?=2552Rnd "NJޭpXI 5#iQm{g$' j[XRV`xW}1'J{] MWptp_\Z!׭8STIsКea{\T'l-0M0=X-HHiI F!N;bcl h: kRjt KZt(n/Vqi7(+$jZVbY0ށ8 Z`Fr݂B#kRW7KoW%)G(g3Yzθ{v ~kGߕwՏ=EIפoʞ ?Cp&?I&GykPY mcY9wɭyÊoS?JXN]5e^ ?fډ$33%%}zH"IJmfKeO>*US7!1R:UE& *#؀J$$D2SMLs1*a!l%|iIW%Eѥi So|>IG"uQrOMyѴ:ѣFD&ي}޶o9u' ~յ%@'JǘUKB_K?R(\غOࠃ).Q[ x]QY[[]]H,VU(ɮs M2#%l/%y|j^n[PGӕF%?Н$ Eîd ή$1a|w+xGD1Ȫ1kXfrZr!''>L._&"6 ؕ=3fgD%) Sj|< Ԏj:I$T^ucgdQ=gYOa 6E¢ X `h(B06_BX&rAp`ŖP4`8%:V;΁z'd 8N$ s3R>T h+1`jJ"xWީkڞҐ3cxtOmĜFmN[VE'H:&$CI) M#đ ƧQLWhn=ꦛ*<'дDV IL[=[0V۬duDs>26,hУ))g r.2gIȺ~-tyd&`9]ťƅGZ5'fJ%֯$Tb*Cxrg\ʝ ԉ`߲Ӕ-6bí,Æ=LJr}81s uȩl͡Wf%v|za3>sv`L<_=W}ꪞfGC>p-"f0K.-=_'I>&̶-WO|A5XjtY;+Rs \ sf`/0ɮrel,w| Orv)^'gft}_q3we`y;Gt]l j]2'1=f:7[tl 7PNfO pt,pK γd4N{ҹO<84{zf|ggF&Հ~5Ϛdżbf;r.m[l+ DlT*z^ṊR+Bb+z}m"j G]m[W%idփ(S)Z%Jd{3S'Ml5[/ԩx iQ4}[}hH:`نEٜbv+V`Aa}(a@؂5ν!^]>|/??7}䳗EbRTHvךpMx*Ꮅ In- תbjB5B.6*t>[L6;.%.U"W(P~ ڨ}bҔ@ gf߮'UfcjXJ l8=j}V] = +՞F wZF>^SǟTw5h"P㲪C"޾?P '1)'Ȱ[gug'$j S EBAMT Pݘjj0 &;)|Jf['Trsڥ=L ߘk2-FxJ71~Tq`Xm$8^del )$UD׉Օ݈4|sPc}D>BnI#LD{wϡW_? Q`~(F;Q4 WaL,]@,ava%ct=W>9kv#W#ޣV)U\j~EiLb)S o Uh|cC =I)E'[RbK5>ґf fAf&@a+`Pj'/9'itz"xE&7Ei.K*'P i+}qxk:ewJV2iߵ^_^A3'[޲ bY2Fxx۫,?EdFt+2#\:ʑ(LOApF%,ED 2bwnO?Wp?On]kM`w.֯6o HT7Pg5 bnQseG^ W 1Wi[b1_7Y ĤRgԴ `ݮ_8}o~;k;M4xڮ6eH6h^!Eki*@Th T"H i [=PX"VbTQաFUǪ4v Hws<~}ddO1/rXG\}}YV<^W~s鍕z"*1ݢ|`w*m= UB JGCHS$S!nyN#ƯQ:Ӈ2 G6g=bTh+z Y?{{zqݍ;Xq/#Z DߤsR3ՑVI1(Ti֑8E/BTmJ!})c֞E%dg~q; JEFɦR) f9e,ZVoM~,fY;6C(g YL" bY\g|'AѾQS4٥^r'<|;Ca5ܿ] |vmd̔0ww/; {a39qg39 55zzT!ɂN4:H1S依z%M"f>Hƥ`KiZxsU(z0d2aœ6YV#rZ[lh#DFȦw[7T`ZW1T+<[t1ԇxxg\ѳ7 G_Mɜ*m$ڠ)i6Uvmګv9 W:ঈ ޲QfUr^1ʯdyǗ&jӵٚ[5r^|9p9]9s- ׍̍eQ)7(in6rBraP '1oi7f@niwх `Jc'Bʒ'.q''ǡg$Q⳼w=*w0sƛ, ܂\xΜ}?G/1b/8Mfofϖ{%ouoި㫳x0,&I;^[ezx~9-rB]icԳKZ=iؼ˺YK%˖J>#I8Msr ||N+`J-iNe+ x _ozn\*z$vxH7%Rt-2F;Ŏ\FCBٹts}~*wKŝYsu*L|g~RP7u-/pT| 5ѯ_55ըEjHpJ547'D,EB&ĖpG_mU۫]w9ɪfD"o vA2Dz"R O9(`|^ SqKRgGi񏝵tEFcEnɫ .sC &㯏8ˎ$y𛑦q,$ <waֹHX7L);\x{wvl:r%'C \&lplQ f5`4Y[V56^Y'5bܸT겋Y_#,qh Иʉ1д2C1.}]ڭMEu[ gu5J}}CJfh'0vOVwG Kձ݅I+SDk: co_v΄n<6JxhDnI'jS{T; E;w^#, QBqz-ZAݝ(Edލ׼8A1~qV6+K[Y&i|%l.v#**?L2)>rTϢenoSQPUBx[xAO+D#(W Ȥ-C`$dmq8uu uMAE.̤G9;#ذǓZb.!4a\-?AŴEJY` .;906xZ8"O+PgoO~PS(s#6&-5ɱ%3JLNęȻЍ04dzAFL4TX͠283C=">z]=MJHl[lytEHJJ2EY:@Zc ^r,FdK!bȰ(j``mpPK0;!/i`ÐufY{6Ϙ؟^/zy}C~#V]­H; @"W_dg^>G~u?~E/\hCi4x!|Z}%qam3M)9G6JrǬ1gXTn)b~D%-zqiEjEP]FC7 8>,TB:5}Kے>A\iQ&|[7$SGrTS'*uS3ǫ v(Z-q\.0*%ؐ㈩, \TSA*:[7Vvs2d){d UJGbCeiL߸eCMTmʅus{-cőYH``l0QC- EU-KWZIer$&dbAt:uإ5J!T !.r ըS)QZT;>V wޏ^Es誠XWI9܈-KbdYGe/ VhG{*{At`W里C<z1oׅd.5=*j|?4[E*#PŴ}RxR ?C1Dy|<絞c_izIxI z`J1 "咢RfMx.EYQ e!=ϸ+*C3,]1i$>̰)a S˕ʰ$$I6,e9P*6An \."^${_yUEUdQ58,Rb/\pf+#> pqz,_Fv7?\UHI'ƚx F1OhzZ@svmVS){F nj B&Ꙉ2S5]msün:jwJB6CƑ`@!G\gػ?+Cϋ8yfH![Z`ƙq-S L&EOJ XR(NvWHpo)`ޅ TE`$F X|<">*} $+kJzf]:Ǵ4aq24nQ<>EFgYq63 (,uMyZQ(ŚəY #vhǃT_CcA^miM Qyt,<mT%[Lhl&7-.5д5[F '2LlpFTb˳@y2,Q4$j4i©V 2>܈̾Ʋ 1[`I 5}_@"̉m  $[u Q(\ L3(c(H& -W~[|O(ՠhOjާ8\Ү>j:ՇZn(a[%+ˈxVu.>KtpfliS%oNˆ 7G3x||..\B cn؂)j FEAriu@ei.[;n^HdvHtx'&Zf@4 \ `'3ae x#.pyƶU|c;Ol!8\g+ZZҦ녖5mAeeu&XAlmH^T2USj"m]p]Y h@0~l|MHH"PNO>ӏF1hŰYS+r0 1|kf+l6 n1Xl)Y``fg`G6uog(t9J+{Cuvi<]D1^vcv䬉Dp ;:iV\z%,_$t;X, ̍lܹt馱.[5nnQ[7lvK,m7:t:Tm'O~+Pi-e]yK)sy ?,:UތIeI^b7jUY2FGOE`Թs Ry'9Rz(I9r}$޹{UoZQ a?\ˈjVjkZ#[{h{ۭ]QW̝ Ś`:֔Z vǗyn%->}]{=籧s'Lێ2\.z$3$_\]1q!s\S$ʹ̄e(*=GygGstov+.xb"wVzy-ߗή! (n{bjrpq|j[C}7LMʾ/B׌צ _VVs'pwp /DfUd(A<ھ ^G`D: $W ϝp:t5lcs;ZzU,mO͞%酥dotDfq }tWMV]sΈ`ð|֔ނ>Ƈb[Х֪oeuTuga%5&0YR՚_Фm&k^"]کKtYo=7,q5fO:łUպVԐJ꒷,&i>ÿYvI'TMWalu'>k3bx[IhxVL} \S52K}V*LuFTQOeEJGL}6X=qCyi=}>& ,Fϸƭ[涘E9'ťgVPHUyxu(O*@[NqWW|+[CO9Bwi]imG.`8 ?&8|1B|{@F~lTH @/> V nq#h_u<Ȝan2?, sl3oGw ^yl <6s9cK7Uxɜ!SZ^-l5C0Y*Ey3ggmKll)lRjmiŴ|Q\ -Q;FF8_ >E^c]>3Kd8ǥb1ezr\nP%MF˰r6rK̺|V۠[:N?G+'t!:גR Haaw(_;;pHc_YK/:FK=b.,aۧy4s_咐6_dRؔiCؕi]6iZy?@7lNԤ|2x:נ6/gJlv>5 {~uGtC4**iɶkhD*~~ͱ〵ѱڨ,6b@~l3H/ٱI;Msh#FK8Z#T},|[Am ~/8;kac:~{{߶J)QPX P'c٦"Α8LD,H:>b1mRT&O bt|־y嶥t?/>=s9sF&;'MOsB{w~ĠvR٥|Ìgw-:ƈO MwΧƂZt*˺5 R.7Zd~0cW+Q*Y%A"3f.10Ans3i eI(_d֪J]0uEJ]+t׵i'Z'X{=ޑ &ߨ=k9o@sbb>̐rK?o/cV:&SUd9'z2~&*r8|;j7܇uod:2>MϸC̱39*M{i9jdTl[Wޭ 'W+ i ĻckH[6?Im׆T;63v0GǑLt|hWe8}'c8yLT6 r.X=ȷ`Z,g=.WyFҶ{TtSvߠ$@좷[wJU8n;9%X,9v1ĹJG6 ~)~q+VoWVVy2c)ۋ>=;gO`#Yy=G#.3S AyX-g8!#֝_ttjjg>$Ŋ[su 臉}KoWvPb>Bj߇Kt^Q,GN t#S虎>o9yokń ԨU2J9EȩͿiAfȫGy~JyEJ$)IG\w?G"1`?9`̚v& 5 yq~xn>+~˦gAߧZqǭVwȪ[75Hw6C`bM8B-]5ZƩ~lzo52;'v5>ٿ畦Gy#5.:=YOu=KWlkH?I{[ !/9-bl9v͑ Ut?q.o'GV|H0$Fxh]ڪ@;:GP}L:-kІw:> q?96GČ<ȂMkҶ`t0[!+bnfeݜCԀԇRU^ݓO[o=י]r!Rv(=X}5җR 8?N!fX.7}jxWc8#e%_rxs5C["]$>owr@6 W&0J荒u<;I>c9#˟r;Ж}%)j+L=0~Ng1cke5\ǒ}g31}&VI ETI|Kzι%W&jN y I  >*K\?Rsy{a~j)rn(#??V.:D&ZsQ[µ8oR ڄSƞyW􌡏ҽҳd*r#_aCF?>/c Zc(zb)BV@VK5{Н3PnlƹQ2Fꜹf#]gCuCb"O}:[w5kK}۪J_%{ўOcR#d9AyY~ h?FZ_lد%5M|[ĉXA~{uĚ9 >!֛aq?V)9`c iړ;6Nuny4@znGQ72* cUE]eQ=7 *GF}dvׯ=;k~-B{M쫋B{]'h}&vBħK/ O_<ے]x~ Aџef҇;wx cugAMm 4cC[F;aY[ߍ,A]|kghgü/@2{&A'w|7/p<'9dDɍى_:& .#%W#瑓z/Hį׎K3Oj?GXE)AH5̗8;ɬat]g_szɩQt>*J~-)@H(l,_!=_%?MMoI:ySnI?kRʴ;7WGZg[j-kӾ 4"Wk4{?rxW {J.*H;tqdPH)r' יu~cwqCΔPj@`Ae'MRpwk+L Vɴl56!gz"""ӯcl^`19c%;}$q;!DDwd?wؚdݓuL%w2ޤ_u|]>p'_9[hz&|f5RGo! ;vYoTvY.${] O=>Z8.Ϳm~8+م^}A-9bxyMf9iT/~d^|!'I;v;V97ыvcN㗡ls Ϳ߷mc)>80 iW [͔S)bQf^f[M1ƿ2Qc,hE Va@gԾN/Qȿ:sQȼ1\X,Ep&a}/y3 Qqx w멃6)+ xw6d>񾇭җ[ !q=up jx>{PyoHα:ۥ6w{v8lʠANfOCKqfw eqNj[sedJE]#ej_2F ΣҀ\m}IGwJ\Jm[y{/3J˼;+wc/!9k-x&>j5&UZTG74J]W{uvOVQխ|^mʭC'Z#6}1r,A.SP FC4~W֣ 9Yg%^E[_$P(+Ag歔y̖{UoLi[+f&vQW*ػIo@cOٸi-Т0obV{R*Ĥʚ|_m;δ;o:b_t%L&,! .DOܛANzJuל1R>%ybBs4; 6Fc_IAT$y#~3<[5qI&CFɁFDGJIp')ļ&lsdXfccqYLrmnyDr˥s6UxR;M! .Mtvp-L|}fzϐ'c;5ʕ28*" !Yʀ`jDu3 Xm/ˏ#& b6»Wȭp37Rke_"{29,,s2ϼvez6JIMΐA=q{^nDo O-|#qtϼ.Q%RLhW) {==\jeJVh/ਯ*&$/!4Є$<nȒnnxi#ڱfdЇckN[gf8TmJhf$XM׹{瞋,3g& ~7JG.=CU,X-M}k'_&_@ay y{~}\oӷ3>M}ӫy¨jg|ܮ|)od}*tS*MFvbRiqer.plKKIh\yEƄTWIJv$*iUշb7nm]QB=wg;P;Ɇڅ'W[jspn?4jI7zoPyX'd`#.Ay[)ΣV3>0~4j\?߂&b6i·;zΐ-F]<_AR|EA;VuAS^n1*bFp{nM<>uXYO6>o2udX[o}ɋΙϴ>b<~d>ouikb5C;Sxɏi96rzُaɛ<Q2㹽N|K^GȞ[._v.Kް|n lǞ*?@V.PZJS=a=,I݀B~7\S)f(ݵLEGA %9b&=71^f 2ߤ'Y,s R^Õm&76Syw2ڞ1ҏxMVSEN>*YAS|U^C96eL_Mu#{wG_yO=5שn&=y1K_@gJcTk2b$Ùo^`:#lWYm"{Ljs7sQ)/Fv%QP| @W{%VT0E- =s;])OWZtπ?oi(}_ :s~CDzc; |v8Az8~#Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh>%. D~ / d~և?bkwɯϜK4&f:#{(wd/NB.zTOԑMqd7C#s> F9JQJJhCibSbYV-JXSm4l'W[oP=s-, K6)Q;:j?DcSo:PPd]8KQAiXj~jd[9i6Jm7[!*[بe5RW})=1g^ɵRR%lTY>8'NX*.WCES,T3Ѷ*D9gf8LCYK#v(K˯f)g" hWmӀ]^ZVi7X48Wź:c]D8-k"1-CPP̬t؛:Cf(֝#=u>/IRYl7#mv?Y>뻃q-#iuٵH8aj9KEE ! &fk5]h!JBWVA:݂iZj] ݥps6δt۱ʶew[;ٖ>$~L?3Mx}s'tE5;U!;GUN:QlmU֘Z՞SvN5(jtݱB|=jlkoOdOcӦǵ 09GN'ҿڻ|rFԣj ·Nyh$MlW +yʉzO dކ|H3{_:O{3$CPj|~Gp0 ,j>灌n"t{PJzy{;%K?dJrp[/([ߟn|nmXQbnۤ<5*Q=a1SJ2~M4@"^D25swt9׍?e? yX%<9n⋱xיf9@zp V*` I6yfp  ٳΰ]cɎEЗ1oB@߀:\SP?~ {\cb@ZYL/Q,*uغNSU-*šnhOJ]ú.pql0~;7& b*b3!b` `=}v <c+0Cl^&Jkj/ۑX\> ߈Мy*jbA6%)En_/E*2LzLěH#l0aXyט4n -`+0ap|v SD=>TPWУ񹽥# S 7zFXur~&;W:^/qW})̬ <QU@ )ӭ m@F,XI}LxOpN-M8ڀ1Sxt5%xVطDž]~vYj6 vy~S⻝m{N:\^y"h5Y|)Ug"eޜznzr4r`wO lOE39 ,ͷl65&-c!Kr' ^]?Q\>NKq^0d! =JR"BA{6B{NC{)WTZлzŷx~@$t ꀾ{aI &:ih]ՁtחP$q/;] ]ݐ#OpYri)xl8$>t/ s7tcjpPwQ^ Ikujr>˫NE9EEHŤCh5ˤTID ;_*YQ/Gzff^g9vfF^Gai:9SjGu)e#+;y&}R\F*2g܉*DQr~,H=XK{mӖݱ{vlOl++ԡ!蘦Bu<@cv8S^+~í]bVX&llͶ[m6|לxx'rrH{q$m$}+q͆D}l0|I.گ}@I۴{UӓZGOk~z Q#gE\98ICMFCNtE>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[402.0 445.0 413.0 456.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 32 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[231.0 337.0 242.0 348.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 16 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 3/Type/Page>> endobj 39 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (97021808)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/97021808.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:37:34 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 624.75 591.75 140.999 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm (__________________________)Tj ET Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 729.75 Tm (Christine M. Kopocis)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Member, Claims Appeals Board)Tj T* (1. )Tj (Settlement Certificate on DOHA Claim No. 96100204, February 3, 1997.)Tj T* (2. )Tj (The shipment moved under Personal Property Government Bill of Lading RP-\ 874,934. It pertains to AF Claim No.)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (Mountain Home 94-542.)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 15 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 2/Type/Page>> endobj 40 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (97021808)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/97021808.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:37:34 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm (investigation of this damage. )Tj 11.803 0 Td (Of the $75 claimed by the service )Tj 13.745 0 Td (member for repair, the Air Force allowed only $25,)Tj ET Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm (which was offset against the carrier. )Tj 14.688 0 Td (Clearly, )Tj 3.443 0 Td (the Air Force recognized the existence of PED and supported its position\ )Tj -18.132 -1.125 Td (with an investigation. )Tj 8.888 0 Td (American did not investigate the damages nor offer a specific repair est\ imate for the transit)Tj -8.888 -1.125 Td (damage. )Tj 3.609 0 Td (American has not met the burden of proof described above.)Tj -3.609 -2.125 Td (At origin, a wall unit, Item 250, was scratched, rubbed and marred, and \ the back was off. )Tj 35.85 0 Td (While the )Tj 4.165 0 Td (carrier's PED)Tj -40.015 -1.125 Td (notation is partially illegible, this condition involved the side, front\ , and doors of the )Tj 34.022 0 Td (item. )Tj 2.277 0 Td (The damage noted in the)Tj -36.299 -1.125 Td (repair estimate was a chip in the bottom left corner and a rubbed, )Tj 26.268 0 Td (scratched front. )Tj 6.469 0 Td (The AF Form 180 claimed a scratched)Tj -32.737 -1.125 Td (top, a chipped left edge and a rubbed right )Tj 17.161 0 Td (door. )Tj (It appears that the repairs partially repaired PED \(the doors\) and)Tj -17.161 -1.125 Td (partially repaired transit )Tj 9.857 0 Td (damages \(bottom left corner\). )Tj 12.134 0 Td (Thus, in part, different and additional damages resulted from)Tj -21.991 -1.125 Td (transit. )Tj 3 0 Td (In the absence of clear and convincing evidence from American that the b\ ottom left corner could )Tj 38.984 0 Td (have been)Tj -41.983 -1.125 Td (repaired for less than the $65 offset, the offset is proper.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (With respect to another wall unit, Item 219, American contends that the \ damages noted on the )Tj 37.877 0 Td (estimate are inconsistent)Tj -37.877 -1.125 Td (with the damage noted on the DD Form 1840R. )Tj 19.331 0 Td (The damage reported by )Tj 9.996 0 Td (the service member in the DD Form 1840R is)Tj -29.326 -1.125 Td (that the top was crushed and rubbed and the door was )Tj 21.688 0 Td (chipped. )Tj 3.666 0 Td (The damage in the claim was the same. )Tj 15.966 0 Td (The repair)Tj -41.32 -1.125 Td (estimate involved a scratched, rubbed )Tj 15.328 0 Td (and gouged top, and a dented and rubbed front. )Tj 19.133 0 Td (Prior decisions recognized that)Tj -34.461 -1.125 Td (terms like "rub" and )Tj 8.314 0 Td ("scratch" may mean the same in a particular context to many individuals.\ )Tj 29.501 0 Td (See)Tj ET 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 469.791 528 cm 0 0 m 17.326 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 487.1172 528.75 Tm ( )Tj (Continental Van)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 490.1172 528 cm 0 0 m 78.984 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 515.25 Tm (Lines, Inc.)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 16 514.5 cm 0 0 m 50.982 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 66.9824 515.25 Tm (, 63 Comp. Gen. 479, 480 \(1984\). )Tj (While most people would not describe something as )Tj 34.939 0 Td ("crushed" unless the)Tj -39.188 -1.125 Td (surface was obliterated in some way, it is clear that the service member\ here )Tj 30.737 0 Td (was trying to describe the result of)Tj -30.737 -1.125 Td (something being dropped on or pushed against the wall unit. )Tj 24.413 0 Td (Similarly, the damage to the front of the unit describes)Tj -24.413 -1.125 Td (damage to the door. )Tj 8.192 0 Td (We do not view the )Tj 8.081 0 Td (damage descriptions as inconsistent with each other.)Tj -16.273 -2.125 Td (Finally, American contends that the repair estimate on Item 247, another\ wall unit, )Tj 33.324 0 Td (involved fixing )Tj 6.388 0 Td (PED on the front)Tj -39.712 -1.125 Td (which was rubbed and scratched and the top which was scratched and gouge\ d. )Tj 31.601 0 Td (The Descriptive Inventory noted)Tj -31.601 -1.125 Td (scratches, rubs and chips almost everywhere on the unit: edges, top, )Tj 27.381 0 Td (sides, front, rear and bottom. )Tj 11.775 0 Td (The DD Form 1840,)Tj -39.156 -1.125 Td (completed by the carrier's representative, was )Tj 18.478 0 Td (more specific: top, left, middle gouged; bottom, left, edge rubbed; and \ a)Tj -18.478 -1.125 Td (small dent in the top middle. )Tj 11.693 0 Td (The DD Form 1840R also noted specific damage: a "T" was deeply cut into \ top, and that)Tj -11.693 -1.125 Td (the unit )Tj 3.277 0 Td (was rubbed. )Tj (The claim was for the "T" deeply cut into the top. )Tj 25.17 0 Td (On balance, we believe that the )Tj 12.8 0 Td (repair estimate)Tj -41.248 -1.125 Td (may have included some PED, but it is also clear that some specific addi\ tional )Tj 31.575 0 Td (damage resulted from transit. )Tj 11.968 0 Td (As in other)Tj -43.543 -1.125 Td (items noted above, in the absence of clear and convincing )Tj 23.353 0 Td (evidence from American that the new damage could have)Tj -23.353 -1.125 Td (been repaired for less than the $75 offset, )Tj 16.799 0 Td (the offset is proper.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 4.967 -2.125 Td (Conclusion)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -21.767 -2.125 Td (Accordingly, we affirm the Settlement.)Tj T* (Signed: Michael D. Hipple)Tj T* (__________________________)Tj T* (Michael D. Hipple)Tj T* (Chairman, Claims Appeals Board)Tj T* (Signed: Joyce N. Maguire)Tj T* (__________________________)Tj T* (Joyce N. Maguire)Tj T* (Member, Claims Appeals Board)Tj T* (Signed: Christine M. Kopocis)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 14 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 1/Type/Page>> endobj 41 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (97021808)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/97021808.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:37:34 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm (damages claimed for Items 156, 333, and 250 \(an oak butler stand )Tj 26.659 0 Td (\(valet\) for )Tj 4.275 0 Td ($69.99, a desk chair for $25, and wall unit)Tj ET Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm (for $65 respectively\) were preexisting damages \(PED\), )Tj 22.27 0 Td (for which it is not responsible. )Tj 12.415 0 Td (For the remaining two items,)Tj -34.685 -1.125 Td (American contends that the damage )Tj 14.578 0 Td (estimate for a wall unit, Item 219 \($95\), was inconsistent with the No\ tice of Loss or)Tj -14.578 -1.125 Td (Damage, DD )Tj (Form 1840R, and that the estimate for a wall unit, Item 247 \($75\), inv\ olved repairs of PED for )Tj 43.601 0 Td (which it)Tj -43.601 -1.125 Td (was not liable.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 21.906 -2.125 Td (Discussion)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -21.906 -2.125 Td (The shipper establishes a )Tj 10.275 0 Td (prima)Tj ET 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 139.2988 649.5 cm 0 0 m 27.99 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 167.2891 650.25 Tm ( )Tj (facie)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 170.2891 649.5 cm 0 0 m 23.309 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 193.5977 650.25 Tm ( case against a carrier for transit loss or damage by showing )Tj 24.159 0 Td (that he tendered)Tj -38.958 -1.125 Td (property to the carrier, that the property was not delivered or was deli\ vered in a )Tj 31.988 0 Td (more damaged condition, and the)Tj -31.988 -1.125 Td (amount of damages. )Tj 8.331 0 Td (See)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 115.9727 622.5 cm 0 0 m 17.326 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 133.2988 623.25 Tm ( )Tj (Missouri Pacific Railroad Co. v. Elmore )Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 136.2988 622.5 cm 0 0 m 196.635 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 332.9336 623.25 Tm (& Stahl)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 332.9336 622.5 cm 0 0 m 37.002 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 369.9355 623.25 Tm (, 377 U.S. 134, 138 \(1964\); see also DOHA)Tj -29.495 -1.125 Td (Claims Case 96070203 \(September 5, 1996\). )Tj 18.22 0 Td (The burden of proof then shifts to the carrier to rebut the )Tj 22.881 0 Td (primafacie)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 509.2129 609 cm 0 0 m 51.299 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 596.25 Tm (liability. )Tj 3.611 0 Td (American denies any )Tj 8.691 0 Td (liability because certain items were delivered with PED, or it challenge\ s the amount of its)Tj -12.302 -1.125 Td (liability.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Preliminarily, while many of the carrier's inventory exceptions at origi\ n are illegible, we also note )Tj 39.418 0 Td (that those which are)Tj -39.418 -1.125 Td (legible and involve furniture tend to have a similar theme; namely, that\ the )Tj 30.157 0 Td (furniture was scratched, rubbed and marred)Tj -30.157 -1.125 Td (at the top, sides, front, rear, bottom and edges. )Tj 18.773 0 Td (In other )Tj (words, PED existed over the whole unit. )Tj 19.802 0 Td (In contrast, the Air)Tj -38.575 -1.125 Td (Force inspector noted in his report two )Tj 15.747 0 Td (years after delivery that the claimant's furniture generally was well-ma\ intained)Tj -15.747 -1.125 Td (and that with regard )Tj 8.275 0 Td (to some items on which the carrier had reported PED, which were not part\ of the claim, the)Tj -8.275 -1.125 Td (inspector )Tj 3.916 0 Td (noted no damage in the areas indicated by the carrier. )Tj 21.629 0 Td (While such evidence, by itself, is not )Tj 15.024 0 Td (dispositive of the)Tj -40.569 -1.125 Td (carrier's claim and may be only moderately probative, it does invite clo\ se scrutiny )Tj 33.003 0 Td (of American's PED notations.)Tj -33.003 -2.125 Td (With regard to Items 242, 168, 138, and 131, the service member notified\ the carrier of )Tj 35.1 0 Td (damage to )Tj 4.387 0 Td (each item to allow)Tj -39.487 -1.125 Td (American an opportunity to inspect the damage. )Tj 19.494 0 Td (See)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 249.9297 436.5 cm 0 0 m 17.326 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 267.2559 437.25 Tm ( DOHA Claims Case No. )Tj (96070212 \(November 27, 1996\). )Tj (There is)Tj -20.938 -1.125 Td (no indication that American did avail itself of the )Tj 19.966 0 Td (opportunity to inspect the damage. )Tj 14.108 0 Td (American could have determined)Tj -34.074 -1.125 Td (relevant facts concerning )Tj 10.3 0 Td (valuation of these damaged items through inspection by a qualified repre\ sentative. )Tj 33.212 0 Td (See)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 538.1465 409.5 cm 0 0 m 17.326 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 555.4727 410.25 Tm ( DOHA)Tj -44.956 -1.125 Td (Claims Case No. 97012102 \(January 29, 1997\). )Tj 19.275 0 Td (On the other hand, ownership of property qualifies )Tj 20.522 0 Td (the owner to give his)Tj -39.798 -1.125 Td (estimate of the loss for purposes of measuring transit damages. )Tj 25.411 0 Td (See)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 320.9277 382.5 cm 0 0 m 17.326 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 338.2539 383.25 Tm ( DOHA )Tj 3.389 0 Td (Claims Case No. 97032111 \(June 6, 1997\);)Tj -30.243 -1.125 Td (DOHA Claims Case No. 96081208 \(December 20, )Tj (1996\); and )Tj (DeSpirito v. Bristol County Water Co.)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 317.6113 369 cm 0 0 m 184.986 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 502.5977 369.75 Tm (, 102 R.I. 50, 227)Tj -40.55 -1.125 Td (A. 2d 782, 34 A.L.R. 3d 809 )Tj (\(1967\). )Tj (The Air Force inspector also confirmed the valuation. )Tj 36.631 0 Td (Thus, a )Tj (prima)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 493.9023 355.5 cm 0 0 m 27.99 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 521.8926 356.25 Tm ( )Tj (facie)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 524.8926 355.5 cm 0 0 m 23.309 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 548.2012 356.25 Tm ( case)Tj -44.35 -1.125 Td (against the )Tj 4.554 0 Td (carrier has been established. )Tj 11.522 0 Td (American should have provided clear and convincing evidence, )Tj 25.685 0 Td (e.g.)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 517.1348 342 cm 0 0 m 17.326 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 534.4609 342.75 Tm (, )Tj (the)Tj -43.205 -1.125 Td (observations of an expert evaluator supported with well-recognized docum\ entary evidence on )Tj 37.736 0 Td (value, that: the damage to)Tj -37.736 -1.125 Td (the flag set was only $5; that the replacement cost of the dress was $10\ 0, )Tj 29.381 0 Td (not $128; that a lamp shade \(specifying an)Tj -29.381 -1.125 Td (equivalent model and price\) could have been purchased )Tj 22.491 0 Td (and fitted on the lamp at a cost less than replacement value; etc.)Tj -22.491 -1.125 Td (American fails to recognize the )Tj 12.8 0 Td (well-established legal precedent that it, not this Board nor the Air For\ ce, has the burden)Tj -12.8 -1.125 Td (of proving )Tj (by clear and convincing evidence that the calculation of damages was inc\ orrect. )Tj 36.625 0 Td (See)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 455.4941 274.5 cm 0 0 m 17.326 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 472.8203 275.25 Tm ( title 4, Code of )Tj 6.499 0 Td (Federal)Tj -44.567 -1.125 Td (Regulations, Subsection 31.7. )Tj 12.166 0 Td (See)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 161.9922 261 cm 0 0 m 17.326 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 179.3184 261.75 Tm ( )Tj (also)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 182.3184 261 cm 0 0 m 19.33 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 201.6484 261.75 Tm (DOHA Claims Case No. 97012102, )Tj (supra)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 377.3066 261 cm 0 0 m 25.992 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 403.2988 261.75 Tm (; and )Tj (McNamara-Lunz Vans and)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 429.959 261 cm 0 0 m 130.611 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 248.25 Tm (Warehouses)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 16 247.5 cm 0 0 m 58.641 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 74.6406 248.25 Tm (, 57 Comp. Gen. 415, 419 \(1978\). )Tj (American's appeal )Tj 21.398 0 Td (based on mere questioning of the Air Force's valuation)Tj -26.285 -1.125 Td (is insufficient to overcome its liability.)Tj T* (American also failed to meet its burden of proof on the items for which \ it has denied any liability. )Tj 39.378 0 Td (On the Joint)Tj -39.378 -1.125 Td (Statement of Loss or Damage at Delivery, DD Form 1840, the carrier's rep\ resentative )Tj 34.475 0 Td (and the member reported transit)Tj -34.475 -1.125 Td (damage to Item 186, an oak butler stand \(valet\). )Tj 19.41 0 Td (While the item )Tj 6.192 0 Td (had PED prior to shipment, the carrier's representative)Tj -25.603 -1.125 Td (admitted that it broke once in shipment and )Tj 17.607 0 Td (broke in another place when it was delivered. )Tj 18.41 0 Td (The service member's spouse)Tj -36.017 -1.125 Td (stated to the Air Force )Tj 9.192 0 Td (investigator that the carrier's representative had apologized to her at \ delivery for someone's)Tj -9.192 -1.125 Td (obvious )Tj (attempt to hide the transit damage by attempting to glue the item's part\ s back together. )Tj 38.199 0 Td (The )Tj (additional damage)Tj -38.199 -1.125 Td (supports carrier liability in absence of clear and convincing evidence f\ rom )Tj 29.96 0 Td (American demonstrating that the transit)Tj -29.96 -1.125 Td (related damage could have been repaired for an )Tj 19.212 0 Td (ascertainable amount less than $69.99. )Tj 15.69 0 Td (Otherwise it is irrelevant that)Tj -34.902 -1.125 Td (some PED may be repaired )Tj 11.191 0 Td (incidental to the repair of the transit damage. )Tj 18.187 0 Td (See)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 368.541 100.5 cm 0 0 m 17.326 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 385.8672 101.25 Tm ( DOHA Claims Case No. 96070212, )Tj (supra)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 564.5254 100.5 cm 0 0 m 25.992 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 87.75 Tm (and )Tj (decisions cited therein.)Tj T* (The inventory noted that the desk chair, Item 333, was loose all over, b\ ut it was delivered with the )Tj 39.545 0 Td (arms pulled loose.)Tj -39.545 -1.125 Td (This language indicates additional damage in transit which is confirmed \ by the )Tj 31.769 0 Td (Air Force inspector's specific)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 12 0 obj <> endobj 42 0 obj <> endobj 9 0 obj <> endobj 10 0 obj <> endobj 11 0 obj <> endobj 46 0 obj (file:///usr.osd.mil/Home/OSD/OGC/JosephLM/_MyComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Archived%20-%20HTML/97021808.html) endobj 45 0 obj <> endobj 47 0 obj <> endobj 43 0 obj [16 0 R/XYZ 0 689.0 null] endobj 44 0 obj [16 0 R/XYZ 0 663.0 null] endobj 4 0 obj <> endobj xref 0 48 0000000000 65535 f 0000000016 00000 n 0000000141 00000 n 0000003655 00000 n 0000114861 00000 n 0000003533 00000 n 0000003588 00000 n 0000003728 00000 n 0000003755 00000 n 0000114246 00000 n 0000114330 00000 n 0000114372 00000 n 0000114062 00000 n 0000004391 00000 n 0000104036 00000 n 0000097918 00000 n 0000096699 00000 n 0000003858 00000 n 0000003904 00000 n 0000003953 00000 n 0000004144 00000 n 0000004016 00000 n 0000004048 00000 n 0000004080 00000 n 0000004112 00000 n 0000004605 00000 n 0000004637 00000 n 0000010555 00000 n 0000010604 00000 n 0000010639 00000 n 0000011151 00000 n 0000096035 00000 n 0000096367 00000 n 0000042236 00000 n 0000042503 00000 n 0000011564 00000 n 0000011837 00000 n 0000012264 00000 n 0000043121 00000 n 0000096888 00000 n 0000098118 00000 n 0000104236 00000 n 0000114147 00000 n 0000114777 00000 n 0000114819 00000 n 0000114588 00000 n 0000114414 00000 n 0000114724 00000 n trailer <<9838EF62FC481D44B79D44217879C979>]>> startxref 115031 %%EOF