%PDF-1.6 % 1 0 obj <> endobj 2 0 obj <>stream 2021-06-11T15:37:22-04:00 2021-06-11T15:37:21-04:00 2021-06-11T15:37:22-04:00 Adobe Acrobat 17.0 application/pdf 96070233 uuid:c31d861b-447e-43a0-884b-5a7fec304e0e uuid:71fdc0de-9ee0-4f3a-9b4c-09d3d1628265 Acrobat Web Capture 15.0 endstream endobj 5 0 obj <> endobj 6 0 obj <> endobj 3 0 obj <> endobj 7 0 obj <> endobj 8 0 obj <> endobj 17 0 obj <>>> endobj 18 0 obj <> endobj 19 0 obj <> endobj 21 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 22 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 23 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 24 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 20 0 obj <><><><><><>]/P 18 0 R/Pg 13 0 R/S/Article>> endobj 13 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 0/Type/Page>> endobj 25 0 obj [31 0 R] endobj 26 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (96070233)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/96070233.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:37:22 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 734.2497 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 579.749 0 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 733.5 cm 0 0 m -0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 578.25 0 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 732.7503 cm 0 0 m 0.75 0.75 l 0 1.499 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 733.5 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 0.75 0.75 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 650.25 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 579.749 0 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 649.5003 cm 0 0 m -0.75 -0.751 l 579 -0.751 l 578.25 0 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 648.7497 cm 0 0 m 0.75 0.751 l 0 1.5 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 649.5003 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.751 l 0.75 0.75 l h f Q /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 749.25 Tm (DATE: February 18, 1997)Tj 0 -2.75 TD (In Re:)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Stevens Worldwide Van Lines, Inc.)Tj T* (Claimant)Tj 0 -2.75 TD (Claims Case No. 96070233)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 15.224 -2.125 Td (CLAIMS APPEALS BOARD DECISION)Tj -15.224 -2.125 Td (DIGEST)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 0 -2.125 TD (1. )Tj (When a carrier aggressively protects its rights to inspection and the me\ mber discards broken )Tj 38.21 0 Td (articles before the carrier)Tj -38.21 -1.125 Td (has the opportunity to inspect, the carrier must have a substantial defe\ nse )Tj 29.519 0 Td (involving facts discoverable by inspection to)Tj -29.519 -1.125 Td (overcome a )Tj 4.886 0 Td (prima)Tj ET 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 74.6348 528 cm 0 0 m 27.99 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 102.625 528.75 Tm ( )Tj (facie)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 105.625 528 cm 0 0 m 23.309 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 128.9336 528.75 Tm ( case of liability. )Tj 6.915 0 Td (Where the )Tj 4.386 0 Td (government inspected the shipment twice before items were)Tj -20.712 -1.125 Td (discarded or repaired and the carrier )Tj 14.714 0 Td (does not provide evidence of a substantial defense, the carrier remains \ liable for the)Tj -14.714 -1.125 Td (damage.)Tj T* (2. )Tj (A carrier's lower repair estimate does not prove that the shipper's esti\ mates or the agency's )Tj 37.389 0 Td (calculation of the carrier's)Tj -37.389 -1.125 Td (liability was unreasonable.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf T* (DECISION)Tj /TT0 1 Tf T* (Stevens Worldwide Van Lines, Inc. \(Stevens\) appeals the U.S. General A\ ccounting Office's \(GAO\) )Tj 40.085 0 Td (Claims Settlement)Tj -40.085 -1.125 Td (Certificate Z-1348910\(78\), dated December 13, 1994, denying it a refun\ d of )Tj 30.768 0 Td ($2,471.90, except for $290 allowed by the)Tj -30.768 -1.375 Td (Army, set off by the Army for loss and damage to the )Tj 21.689 0 Td (household goods of a service member.)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 460.8906 386.25 Tm (\(1\))Tj ET 0 0 0.933 RG q 1 0 0 1 460.8906 385.5 cm 0 0 m 11.369 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 472.2593 381.75 Tm ( Pursuant to Public Law)Tj -38.022 -1.125 Td (No.104-316, October 19, 1996, )Tj (title 31 of the United States Code, Section 3702 was amended to provide \ that the)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (Secretary of )Tj 5.108 0 Td (Defense shall settle claims by transportation carriers involving amounts\ collected from them for loss )Tj 40.434 0 Td (or)Tj -45.542 -1.125 Td (damage incurred to property incident to shipment at government expense. \ )Tj 29.741 0 Td (The Secretary of )Tj 6.913 0 Td (Defense has delegated this)Tj -36.654 -1.125 Td (authority to this Office.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 21.517 -2.125 Td (Background)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -21.517 -2.125 Td (The record shows that the carrier picked up the household goods shipment\ in Richmond, Virginia, in )Tj 40.547 0 Td (ay 1990 and)Tj -40.547 -1.125 Td (delivered it to San Francisco, California, on July 9, 1990. )Tj 23.163 0 Td (The Notice of Loss or )Tj 9.025 0 Td (Damage, DD Form 1840R, was)Tj -32.188 -1.125 Td (dispatched on August 20, 1990. )Tj 12.916 0 Td (The shipment was inspected twice )Tj 13.968 0 Td (by Army inspectors and the member was paid)Tj -26.884 -1.125 Td (August 29, 1990. )Tj (The carrier inspected the shipment )Tj 21.217 0 Td (on September 11, 1990. )Tj 9.776 0 Td (The member destroyed the broken articles)Tj -30.993 -1.125 Td (and repaired the damaged items )Tj 12.967 0 Td (prior to the carrier's inspection.)Tj -12.967 -2.125 Td (The Comptroller General denied Steven's appeal of the Army's set off. )Tj 28.407 0 Td (On appeal of the settlement, )Tj 11.496 0 Td (Steven's argues that)Tj -39.903 -1.125 Td (it was not provided an opportunity to inspect and that the Army failed t\ o use the )Tj 32.271 0 Td (carrier's lower estimate.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf -10.365 -2.125 Td (Discussion)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -21.906 -2.125 Td (Generally, under federal law, in an action to recover from a carrier for\ damage to a shipment, the )Tj 39.01 0 Td (shipper establishes his)Tj -39.01 -1.125 Td (prima)Tj ET 0 G q 1 0 0 1 16 118.5 cm 0 0 m 27.99 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 43.9902 119.25 Tm ( )Tj (facie)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 46.9902 118.5 cm 0 0 m 23.309 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 70.2988 119.25 Tm ( case when he shows delivery in good condition, failure to deliver )Tj 26.576 0 Td (or arrival in damaged condition, and the)Tj -31.101 -1.125 Td (amount of damages. )Tj 8.331 0 Td (Thereupon, the burden of proof is )Tj 13.746 0 Td (upon the carrier to show both that it was free from negligence)Tj -22.077 -1.125 Td (and that the damage to the cargo was )Tj 15.05 0 Td (due to one of the excepted causes relieving the carrier of liability. )Tj 26.461 0 Td (SeeMissouri)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 514.1348 91.5 cm 0 0 m 60 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 78.75 Tm (Pacific Railroad )Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 16 78 cm 0 0 m 80.637 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 96.6367 78.75 Tm (Company v. Elmore & Stahl)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 96.6367 78 cm 0 0 m 136.986 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 233.623 78.75 Tm (, 377 U.S. 134, 138 \(1964\). )Tj (Once the shipper has established a )Tj 25.19 0 Td (prima)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 535.9023 78 cm 0 0 m 27.99 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 563.8926 78.75 Tm ( )Tj (facie)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 566.8926 78 cm 0 0 m 23.309 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 65.25 Tm (case of liability, the burden is on the carrier to show either that the \ damage did not occur while )Tj 38.154 0 Td (in its custody, or that the)Tj -38.154 -1.125 Td (damage occurred as a result of one of a number of causes for which the )Tj 28.738 0 Td (carrier is not liable.)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 27 0 obj <> endobj 28 0 obj (*RAVK) endobj 29 0 obj <> endobj 30 0 obj <> endobj 34 0 obj <> endobj 35 0 obj <>stream H\j@E^& #[VW /AY*;%?uuC"Υ+؍.栣;uMzoQwsEڮ?ߦgs,:eO}VU.G1VSm>qts^VO𫾨˧پnϬ}PWL 4}סn4Y5k֙2xjUs[7 xGm1.xI^Kr d~"?W-rKނPN/d Uy:{8{xxxxxAF: E_/ fAaAaAaA,Yd y8fF5C-%idtQzg] ! endstream endobj 36 0 obj <>stream H|y\TG5o^p rxÛxkѨ&5fW#qcԍJ8DA%Q4"9}#ނ=#1~d`f{Iϧu?I/,V!RM}P8=*Րz%@ky\vc|88ql܊fm+(q@m1_xa6q:B|*19:JP,IQcRp,E%Ŗ,<2# sSFĦhj,OxHRf/dErk M+ NKFt7<1,nBлgY%ut:#9Nm{Qk ~Gb$X1Vq"VfӫOm_?:uoаQ`b0C7iڬZ|U6nۮ%G#:uqnޣ秽"z>__8( _E 041iXr#S5zq㿙01moi32g̚={ys.\%K -_rjK6oڼe;vڽg‘ǎ8ye8wKqzbb:b"95M_F)X%Ҥ iL*^h@y!ϒ܈4V>30!phΠA?)JUQ*/ VDP,0 y)L|&o)L`` Uz>ZOm6jNRi uLݠnVw{Z^UFv:44yZXݰfyм\3^nY]cՎ`G#Qr,q 454R),iT.F}(yr;R!Z[.zMw;ܜn*o/鉸4V~6oast66ɦ]>"r"pc͍ʜ啙@jFֲ2ue5dmhfok劲ZX[vQ*K%b-Aw$A(4vܖFD+TnnnuDs|V0:A>g`b<&2ax'!aҐDZaGBZDQ 1H'ʧT@ȍɃS|Y.rmZ:e⏆,ZYYzMv= ȗ2_|-l\7&6|1]t5x|tu:?.@_ɫ9}{9 la.XzD޻@A411f$D@{8c{]:J[Vw&?g'NtNѩ:M չd˗U[|{=+ʽ W,][gt d6q@OS4gz?9zz^%zitP/ 2F1zzA7Mzs\|BrLޢmzޡ?;.[zޯ9'q2p*q:gp&gqmbl};`G석K]ݰ; {c?8b#5qLt)s.\sn?O|=nč y8B\q .eWJ\q)4WUs :s>FR$yt!3eUS IqO H()R))2)˗M9KyOu2Q}j@ 5&ԔKԜZR\zZѫԚP[jGuNԙcB]}k}]uԓzQoC}4`BC}}[s5}~GyhyjbSbJMYAZdA 4Fk4Fq4^ 4ޠIޤ z~I_;z~K\a,ERXOa9 VX `=q1'7fs;fgƛ.{6;Sɻd9hiA)b.fb/bX+-b)v=b\U]|-߉C{s7yx(S✸$'q_Gx ϠJT/˖?=\+WPPϡ^@G"j+y|Eeؾ(;ˮ-ǚfHX9A)ߖD|_Nȩ1!gŊg'Er\Ur(Yn^y@EM~)cm<"z<#/By]4]Y$Y!PZ]RTJW*SV9*OQuU}P4SUSBTU[^u:ΪꪺzުjjၣF>+XxGTcx_x'=|WKR /k:x]^o7yI[fjf,2K l0fl7^sn fw=v~i;C ₄`t0.L ¬07녍faհu&l ۇŽas%v !{G1{ܞ'){ڞg9{^%{+feo'8NsŹ\*7:.nԕr.ˮqЭ0l;םhI4Z-VJTوu,587MpZn즸nfn[vs\7wa>G|Oi>_;*3(wsJ/Ii.!"% %t"XDD{hʊ++$FI!*fЄs<+szΝ;o>\t~U⎸+Q;= - )9pSER EQM1!{BKpSLqO-)qJĀxZQkjC_ ԎJIԞM@oQGD P*QWFݩSOE}ԇR?Oo4`"~ {>4F(McCK4hM BSiMLfLEi};;;;+ͣ9-<_tvypᇛS!J}er߹;m=S3 !AoתGi -e ZIh5,ZKh=mMp9m-bmm%}E_N;}i}K->t!:LG(1:NG'$SR):Mg,P)Q9 :tE?ЏY]]+x=XaXe6Ŧzx'KXI q2 3f:5tCH7MtStnCtst#(Su:R0^ST75LMѶnkؚj ƒm_l[ֳm6U(ctN=u/[q:^]u7]{^DA{Gl=j6ͷb{ʞgY[bKm-lEzB39z'z'y3Ds98Gcq'sNbqJgYQ"JE(D8/.⚸.nQ)nWD;BoGMdS(p&Fz2/afHꪺ/P'*UeL j!L(M[v*\fYeV5&ˬ5zl4flf.e+oXv]dLicLI\4 46MLShLifBLsBj(WCJ^UT QuY\~B`.4*.g j?_4$Ү&A0A: H58`6@Ȇ A2ٽ]{'P]k݃|@[X 0751ؽ&|8JʅNme/ ƺa0T@6 3`l[cG ޅX kc6bn{No< %Xu1QvHೆ@&acX[;8̄8DӠ.̐|:a?!:Isa|Ǖ;V1=`~ސcm5Ϡ?#qHsT~hg) ޛ-2+y@^ym|B v|yV8n!yt7Fpsyl-5g6+`1@+wTw r s| A(p`};0 D9skdyvyNz*N+׹B7!LZbˇK(6fO0= 0Xxv?[̯Q|F2B%Oj :pwYrX~ྻ*na0JM83p!3a{r Vb0/ވ2YNky?T϶KWB<#Yn";6MTax \i\lݰrp2\ys7ߧl/c2 ݾ8:q}+<^w/s%EgmlS~N|snb>I@jX M P;%Kҁ6-lTV`[Yg:ilV]TF)#{NB={=i'>[i7!=HFDcſI+B.}; sw,jߍ'[-<5Ԕ2}.ZZUl!!~$ 1֡(yGHp.Yrf*j[i@_&KUXŮpEx>˴Y.A/Mj> VݨDrFolMo h_HN7 qzC]/'1~pぶ|D6tԀ!mtq6f_>L֓J8 'd?X &͗a݅:ʉM]ܓK2*z5*5"FF߆Cxy.ʹStoe1AT}O'O ۡHRa~zj~kޒ>.\#|5V/7Z`CaL¹ž&d9FӘ0]^w1k_@/ބq2F[ X`1֠þIcBvmЁ܉CO\;D"["| ;5v:JCܟ;Ԯ4^ո˗UU.,^[^J=%En3^^CrhxY$.k޸{Yss>f D$f!⚌\Ml\N9Tf8$7Bc_3YbrtE~&b6f  9 a-2ا!\.e `IkYi.6$+ܐ`AB k,kqD <6;^9g DRVn6iP/=^$9CIPʘj*<WXt8IJ;]x$0pHQ桋ly6ڈͺA=^&K ~%[ۡٶ6  a ~ CX[[Uqrٖ*(A++|0%o̻XOTƒ?=;nen5z{X4 L$M~]fݪV6-F0U41R3 q̨@f1B0eI|OSYW?}rO4ţI63y$ZUb){Ա,bSxt,*Mv݄@p&Q|zYyB(1Ь Eca]Hohߠ̄jhXt* RI20m,`Ͷ`CA/dn$q3aeZWb(GB?uA#*,d*hzS8+""h.G bn#Yӑթek:d2~ާ=o}AK}Vů${ȏ }Vwk^3V(_ܱzԱJ)r߾kG;=9Lsq4'fFjvt'#7{K!gay;IN_==!y08n{Α67vR~y{C9>`q 4*ǻ c4@ Lzd1$9rRmMdR|\ Ra+,DMCfɊ׳voD R.' NɦKtFr 0fA }X-tF!*5/75\_]"&1Bc{>͉*/ǻk4MT;[Hy ,/̏sH+eȿ*,PS쁁בa(m0& &p^!7*UŭǍkMdУ\o`9 G@!YCj+ಘɚYV C |,eP&f)5iY3]X8UEQS|>1,4@=MDƂkӌGmM5ϒ/> GphiX([0bG>ov|W^9wr߽g"P}]F{ge?[pڦotxX#dH lx4IVj.=*| 8vvrcucJt+ a1ek+t^+*Y EupT4Pva>rEKgP)Sᒝ=2/@3L)lZkmv[qn=Ί3"!9Xqx\!Vkףz9fUY۞L * ?m._jA}S`ٔfaqz !b3y 4AgxJ~lkx̻%97pאlOڶʦ9jLZwUf_iܚᥫl;JE-Xl);p`dx*dܡt1tN6kv쌜#޲MPqs@`y4 2.\oTρS ^aKby aC P;4Xc*DkTk %X$VzA"c'Ƶ5Zp5zhWVF@ 4TF'蜊`9!V=!:TFϩJ^ӵp}BX=Fⱘ$|n:ζjcۺ9ߟ}?|4N쨍ݸ͒^%-ѭjAi*Ih HM"e4u J)*12дEӤ"Dv :{<<ܻY{'`z wY,ϔ/eILpoY̎m~hs4Aexay.]cF -縁UhnzZ`oN(pOcƇߍn.v44bB}eeq<[<}2;TZ"M4QA9\1)U={qyy;a!޸҇(wͫxHNTwE8CVxa@.i3p4(@1{(>edBʶr~q\@MS1d3è&rmD/*]IK<ݙ133WLZJN/Y̎F@`UF1=k3yv=(=gv 9nԗ.#!(Fo iB*S&I.NFk8 3K\4 rZkf1A64= Is%#*IQPr,ْX@$mr#[d,z#>})eCtyZ]݉dk>G|\g_]şt4VP|v$P dt!е,\cV5,i2B2bx:rz/Z\]e 3P~*j4ս>6gY7KxKoqW̕I a3LU&u*Kn Tѷ0])|L;gS u?sx. vqzyg_|c4~TbĮs`lт#۬vfƑBW২7ԲxL$Gl%+tc1-imɨUDm!* ]`ֈm2Soc'N|쫟bэNr 4T5 2ٷUζzLT"mvK\r '`~qTNooѿ _%l h!0K40 -tZD׵DGm*kkw5 j74 k|i#'V{&|OuP$妪jX 7H0{6_3O05)OP'! UnWڲfo[:5?TJ!Jҕ LƘ5J="tiK6ڑkb<DphT"*jKY$-Ax^Z BT%Y5WֵO5k~tGLqMNx7z̞d= |s}уKv;R55Νc&=c'qⱓ86~B3nlQa6P.ml˪P$h ZABl4AQUQEh%vh̽ۚ||稦F V"XZtotoDz$v%̾L ubfD.N%$@w#}'!²Zְ=\5Qb3MT 3P7CȈV!.DFns,-QRSmeMk9^,'Xb cDq}y{D^F) ŒhHhnlcDwӖ,VXZm 3p)&,PwƇ]sOS5n 3fKtW|<_xFOzw]>Y[5> 7dŖ='](I}}ycYqz<] 얉ӗ aVq@늡6$c6? SFcu!dciacnHbH$ %ȜdSޖ #W~<'@8,LǡM[*0%lNPT`fلzyPzT[%}eoa'd\`,ݶԇQ~K4yU7q\ sٔ^GC řYmĘOL<׼ȹȳ0C$e"]юO ?Md &4KؗÐ+]^Oo $a8{4ck~r9hJ$>;ړ- SCD1$=YA>pF&*n)I x{ G>ɴ35 B =1^Q ºYxG| ~HgE QlI@0l4N:ѺrLnbI(M_u&8׀?nwd$= *Pj,w|\/0|P'DqmYSm*2`AK(v)6E$Zr" XU~N4P*J*&U @A}ܶX!`zWNAT;1TKK O}sx̘60׾rwت\V_4j[.&R6,tj6D/Ko+͊ =?h(;ysKCkT70!@<7?6ze71t4W(N\5i+j@rvvW\+A;x'AjGQt wW),f"ME )o;^ƞf:;|gZMň5#oK:^tL-4t1>PC'd{p H=n@TP 5#4S4Fջ=o855<QIXزi#ېg~ؕk^qxףڀufًq\P^|v=}e%h I`h$fy=8$ؼrVwUWݺ׳r`ځr)AX gA}I8`q/ùi.Wgr4I'$ɤV <~+9F9mh)$tՆ1 vi{< =.*QbVg}0$MP$ &[PqD FaV O]Hw!%~?v6y=i :z7{<Z܇ݧW^;Q,-$<^~bA.xrJ][vV0o=1ಜe?N>2op {sLu㬷m d:ቬYj\f_6;~p;=ܞ|u=]{??w2W e5&bW \`/ț-''ԘujGӫOyTޤY31 6i.e7GP|Mi6 q¸1@׭{{:Yli=CJҭlu'w}~495$]_[26~?| #;7ǯ=K]ӐaAQ>FM$"$"vB{%IἾ<%8FDlj1̉*/#nF|5$-S0#vei+Ŭ(Yݼq9N_KzNZ|}׫9l<5CZxhJRI:&f$ {tWrJmf whl8= )4D ^:tW>ɱ LeF&egÌ ~dUX>%QƨeH7n;m|P+OFutzzk"H"[mLv b-Fͳ +%]qr˥}pLMM@R[mAѝ# \\r]6jot{]eq@h.#c;'s]o1m8գZ{Mj) ~PU Ti&kUJVؿ用UZh(d@ &_ 춄y!N%WLh&!ـSjS7|146hw D<"Nd'T/ Sx \3rK;ʼn='<³g髌;y"9_zU}ES]}C;t zrK%mtjD{/=܆ҿ'G*1ZA/[8݋ʖcϏt8İ[`Lq)\ +>>F|MOe5J\q$tK#tUg*VB\0@j:+@חtA)uv40Pֻ$PG(D` bi<Q-2[v=lh{0ue|YdfY-vl_~ԕHZٶⶦ a U5 #c zY @;,0Cu[/$=A}Լ pm2X&b$SPyX-&lB'T[NFŲeF޵~5Ӧ(XזZ Uǖ_>?2yjf܁SӜk_Jz&R&vo?ivȁL;r.ݤa?Rʼn+8.F40IjF@>낈D!).*~ G]d/\4BaK`e@,:A\GQN@F@ NK|:vO&JI{__?i}K~yYvKq4َ&ӃzDjBnl-`$IfeٸvZqF%Fpg` Cq"WUBZfUUlP$-nɆU+,* ;(8ܑ#wz[u{\h<4k^zdpIbu( yb|Yy0Yza!k}9\uaT?'6f'ⵏ{Pn{r,y_Z팽iMV:,G\ T/޶qێG&&{b~<:d_۔\M ʧ񆗏k#+"i >/.l:yW9zG +[oS8S @LӒjk11'+B;&h/zXcc # B, lzM/!HVAx\8)C 2eZh)V+e@2ֆSl)c1[21P s hi$ӤJIN.&]w"U:M۱,Vl.KflbJɼk*k$I>Z~)>SfWRL]eJ3RL)|)azF JڬQ٫[w}E$jBԎ-Vuj#}gV~ eAy ~j wx\/2e(Cۼk)dHL8fF&L%e yFiBSB#U0H|G/iƒASg6i3N!HDKq$8^c.E{wN?ySc*] ,v ]ԬJ3r[f3ݑP:,H*d3jcR1E*JXTv.cB3t>m7eYui3cg\2?L ܝdZy0,dL~ٴì&*̘VaMh!SC)X`QT3oryop5l &Pf2_5fqBqdY\)(7Y{P8[HeZ$X|kw5Tmٝ~э=;]o}6bM t.;<gsXOxo13EPDLyї4dOkd>/kUrQeA$ѳvW MsJ2JE J?U״ AU#q5eH:zDZPEFD)**h1v_8($4KכNuILgId]ь(]i|VbyYO lKe&b٫֟1- x]4q~xZ֨q)la:)a-k'5dZKpcGPj=w%)dڬԱ']K-ܽuEf/"۩s8'ןP,%쎻܆{e\)ś#]ka:3=U|Z/uƿۉ$qIlB«NHW )m0"c#DlbU):V*])&]Vl4- iLUPDTVE˪UrKǶD;s E+9sq\ibbO5BxYS'SJqC(QU瓜`,|6Vs,+3qExx p1#?)IMQ 4̿s&g!.[ʁޚw|b Ou"+: %xpT_=dG EM8W. w!H\X{^x 664g,5-!e>0D4xOydxSwxW.-"]m; 8˼646l;QCVfT.L]8-n+/=vlm9OZ;0Pi^v]N=Ǹ:I~:pqqtH:*yeI/u8NŹ˱픕!ɝ(֜] %U%VZԗ'7חؤV])>,.0@/ Ql"&Ǻ‰{ynKR0;X_Dwgg}_,Q''^]ܝ?<&;=|&sLFA[d@WjW+jqu^/*Rn`9cA?<J4OIMBB!Q FI0t-˿rR0 IZ.'m^Z#MX ]x4{v`1/wA V6g>uzEO_*N*▜ V{JT>AZ'Ayߥ /<oe|`9@`^ڨ]"A1p;Pvzu)B69Q%r Qh;[Ѯ5qA:*hGF̍) Kп͘Kh/C;Y}Ta΃г]GMalp5<~"M?E$87dĹ; B4 XG/\g>nX|W&T~yI_}J ;8n&oBv헴lI}:MPb1\V#j09p ] c[L{h oxں'/ |q 2z-a_ɋgKSM&ƺGqz6)`>֭2^*X;r-osN,ug;d`ZZ-Ɇ}W KKV`&v 汿 /=mͤ[)yji= 2LQQlo)>?>>Of5FaU4O.\ uZ? ݿEԪbu(gx?s\7S6,lg1i6Lqa 9HvʼH"! 'ǘckvwm3BG9G>j,$Ǥi0h'(#&QF *ړr.}/{/^:Î>gsؒN1˖=#-drnc42m),SyZf>r Se|v#Gq#9qK"W07%@ =VA6D+q]#7%ȟz#& |r~k9eqڪ yjb2ܦ"b-9jys%mQ6QU΢Geڟ͏z[i1mȽۭx<]']r!sir,Z)(#l7DPs>!"[Ś"ڣ2u0j{M*KVnA>mQNr B.%NȕV{q}}Ū+EX:QO~=hC$CoB|GMEz1! ^->= 07T9OSxV/Ga*oAKO~b}Ffz;hSd Ze31vdТ$o$>@6KAʩ>Zldg>uu=9+4?+`߸Ƭaл2 2?Vir,}z&/D2S~3urvV潋}ȌZ/g-JZذraR4h֩o—ebH-P(7? kݢx;BgD%&7k_|߇'s%'ng6u.&v6Fz?B+lBa' 'ѨנUs.9"Gn9Ifnv2K>& >rՕ<7m|o{A04<#웿 a+uy'VCMC;v'֖u gwtnw ;.ю5`MF>qe䢠+єTGUYsoCG{Fl7կUb.Gfgry$[ar%d2m^f'tO -U4jB݉mr.ZcsZ>rjeQ W^csY̹D[vyޑ(L-~Ҹܙ=r\wDr\r{/3}8oع;^8kWyu>qYrv9X+G΀XYMa}TFQ&z՘8WaOpXePNb2߷ύ>d͌-+50zz{2os@)-Xrϻ^{SNlNY8fg`+LIhWgm}<7;KԬ5˛yZķM-u=r_Gf/G|b9j|Pr\/4눾CW?_޷dw e-ބx}NXH^ET0}y/x̚%{;ˍSٟR. me\;m0?j3;Z̍#h X7mcۘG)V oi3VKclvܧB#Wlh=F >w)lrN0x=aU?)r9.菕+rhyIAKw;#~="~9{Lbaϔ֓n F{ܟOgh)79McoĕSdHjօw/О#kh#qK"ztI}G]2E;'33O.Qnl'59lj>F'DR[? |y韲^]dpf|e24hr9;tmHz?.];dt gUo5HfGUh;c XZ6Tq:iˍc#F c8{޸Z.%FwcC^GϞüM$ҵKd1?+-ktU}kƛ9::[1jx4^t\V/3; 'ڶ> nm+170SYWsEMW;tb s'EpZcw8GYƩRmkw[Ojvm)Z[n:}]ž%mLw`{t6jГnDl)n^'X\:~[o}ivyhgdۊ(W̽]lW뢤Qo쭌wBY_+Pn9Bvwrŭ[G.λ߽~]NԼ;= {mxZK7Qew'V,v{5n)>*)ȕMZ!dnb?~wCzWUq97,1<H-I0-V-h h#A0ZR0PZ ZZAQ T[ ۻ/Lg_ݽ:N>/7RuYr^7w%}[>f!:~%D97'|&6cig@Xn\?͔ۋ̥$tZo$4t1ϣ?T/ػ0ۈu{|W4@5դcS:?QMbM*5R GxQ"2ʞw+s)x #;?uv1mbpu~)(]y'GN_4:*U_ounدcc$Z/sguףWpnc籆_Z{Ξ)Z!^σjf{dOY~`:>=bmѾ`$m &JCHg07\.]0wζJy;l݌lbr̦#>7dx j+=i;Wf5v)Z#_jΛUJ m$(p|LH` Y!npWGAT*޹)[/y`32x K=A)6·śC~)-yhKm;_+$xy62%>kK|x1$e{訟r?gI'- 㿯ڔRc!W-:ZWU&SY Wﴆ6&4:Tc4E֯|qA$Tu^M_;:%Ve|M6\|Ԭaz3$zcXٛwr; zGme[:ڑָF9[ *JO[l0miBF٣/p[1Sl60*c.b}Õ6X'J8kܘTCnNY[N~wM&+T;h,A灿Te{qg xX_{9ioj43VssU˨L5A)/Wq8Ù'm Ǻı~5)Xi htZ%pšTe eLQs^Sd2J?KbG;O/`V]D3Q+ t~6m-yl50OHp:|gtTwb+9'Q2ά.3RgZk-N`>mЮQaͭN)5? eMH, "SJV҇w-{é`Nv>Y0;'!z>r:lt9}%ZdúaG8~t1[Ű1v-sam9aر}3tZ53G.HlRG|S> ]Utɶr=ڳmztߗfu=賔[df1]9"ɋo.Ѿ70.Ηmnӹgryگy^Jxz[f":o^\ﲾ3|]h}WD)Q|[;%6H r7Q}jl\~Gd;:&DyDzdb%ߵ]ApR=^$Rl'IIS\oeZpTqoS~@&=="7}؏r}myag JS2od]3d^}VOh͉d< iK4D;ok=kZށ9_%tUj>tKJ-a_S>C0dmw\C>M_/vwtM\cnw+ene9 T΄Ǐ{G.@Ry^Iwte̿`X.~DdیsȍTn|fd3.fJt'g_1BmƦ[3:4telT=B]9M`zҏyfj@O)Qꦽ&y&>{9@)J,rVU)G>w?SoV%Tx =*CReY)eܥ}s\<4$NV_U^u< X閶m@(㥯t{KoケNlctY4(.f`+3ɦnMcc/qEqn˄^<D2\\LNs;4q= >ˍw1}?j=$~Β 4, c=ApVÌw \ }x&m[~83p.l{eQJ9,i"^~f)p[6AQGk|wCLL{~w[}EYsno|oRgo9[ү u~A&xo]yXijoKYc~o3t2i0ŗCܗrogS/2AiYBXiQͳ\bTkN}n`9M)<8Pϱ,dVsګmf7̯ĻXa~T1^Sz>evk"2b\4yuʼCB\v亏`{Bm;ߎ^r''mv5W9߮͞FqsLJwP|~UGcL*2_~%>b#\|tzeK{GčF)cҫox6I#26z2WnfRD|6j$װy2.͜_MWӇ[n;1;Y_J?~w lJzntXx \6u1n&ڠa<8ڬJk4q\G4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4F|XX^$1Rif;2㰣^9Xersn{&8|96(PeXA-!X#FҘ@Bl`*I]Q5X҂(zHEiêloajƙӥzﴳ =~BC,K^2z4R[t%j A`]GNV+KG9ԕ9I;D<7ϠzX"s:G3S2ҐL qMQ + gc+$QbʶU{Kհ0oJKկpF+T~9~++xum۾d}<|*_N!(` &E|\v/.c#ӂ>\@lqylv,lf݀Z]GT(Z~$/%s Pa\sC sΔB6Spڜ5U)* Z b!nwI BY<I[l柰b+3g⩒ 2{*7a.kln15zE4Uqܩw٭MNU-w2-H3I/a)O2T)Y~0yuUoƂ]QWx}x}6g]rbq]^!M ڤARRvIUE*;`ύ`1T5MZ!&,-Ti(]$ ̺UY9s̙laa{P)<NCk@s*30*$) VLIL,t=68% @3+VLK ntJ Ġ$Q%Ц3TO=k:Vwp-1d`@rIxZ* $NT]@Ox3UweZ+dK{tyEbDAWy-'(MbW|>}?:vIV׹$^?IZ;QG~ T~75d:kf@MElHIf%Ld%!FGCQUH:ȏoj;$BCQ~/qX8q8fY>FއO3BzeR`[gO8g^TB(zy*^YSaX0$?#OV =ujŸe~,0q:aOJ8&?|׫vr8Mhv &a8;ГUK0_Z+gDuNFX;A1 lø?:@$⪉mNrӵX'E-k,߫^Edv\$U{Կ${ڦwDxI ug?#t`:'̗bK]lI5>^toП ]m ]@FIOFy#iw`#r'@ 9񜑛rubݮIQ+y2; FxwDۖ@_ے3723fYWt%&%`dZhYhY3|4UJMh++Whcq6gY'9z6vnqPO(ɐq+ B?4 ]M.&}:|]_W|o>c2]FQ#ypA[_nw{twh+N* !˃ S8@ .]rDq7άx$HN8H,ǐr 3c !ۋ".jShwh+N*]e,<"vI3-<`,>;$ ,sxv:a>S[OoCf{л 12s&T5Ձ"{UnELX,RIqߤ_ܧ皿9b11XLW/8'5y[77_G摸9D(湳ߣ_R<5#Q*~7fsYӈ׈F|!b~=bENo;դ-h1綘2Ԇ>*$8}B)QA-l̇̑4Nf6BfSZ9(AxVEJ+á2M"L1'2;r[f!l %gI! Fxz$TX.i`'Ei-Sn6ǥv M2{K9$;U^q# ZwLGf!2 !S!d꺚Rn%q19o~ʌ*$mSYEWw]AuWIy\/"r@28-Z`:44TOIBḪԩHvjIUK[yYҎs4D:biN;IH*mR|73[?3Ez 8%Jp;uq9։7&ݢ^^ "q2#܀iRO#9{xrQk Џ{ X犞f=%ŷV}Pt7ŗ[=kdv5 {`jS됪^+++2|<oow|<z&`@  K| D;("KU%rBU f~n3PP"NFTV;JHfI'd銲OhsJ@ԥ/{}SzmF 6;6nl1K˶d 6O1ovCJ?y}b%ڤ[jP>c{P̥MJv&8ɺ-B8s#:O\7t~ol` cw~v_<ޜgDmIeCtۢebmcMh+FthA4@tApFCG " .͆ H$f)+ җHpt@E!8Z4iA7R% $|pBV@4I aJ?LtȵJUT"?~/$wKL~0]ӪqC7S23iK5F$UF+u2$ &KV:"C*jUQ+ -{۠"ߐ&'z2ǯF U?Pr-\iBQRWWMAxZ5HX&|} ~tJ8€ clX%>˺XʁB7|X$Mص(c؟=p~:r[Th]Q巡@BDnmt{ݹ^d'MGaO5 3*v+ Ew|` ?kbJa0}Pc[p`Шm endstream endobj 32 0 obj <> endobj 33 0 obj <>stream H\jP\>lJ <ƙ d$x^Y## nk1߇ڧ1ҵ U tnbuSeykO]\Gx{xX1=巡NCӞï1[IԎaVPS/B9f?{}Oa1}Suu* ,Va_"xT> r/f-wdGlEv3~AoE ^Fz">stream H|y\TG5o^p "fFz&ĸĠFjdW7MT¡"*J$ފ^x1xxψ+j l#ϧu?UգgA)1MX @@ؑiFC P::099aOq?3z`Ҙ%UP0vP|LH'PJ>Hto'B6V }q뤔f2A mrơ1iA}ԔiPātvSǧnm=g߹w) 2b8r'YaII{ ]1XCzudD$Jy љhO$rnAQ!jh5/)ie=<}jX7^ 5~IӷyZyھ0CNuoݺ#럟,OϿ@ O8hp␤)ÆHjc~͸&O:mfϙ;o~#g+VZ&ϲv]z`CMlݶ}G]ݷC8R|'O>s\)_(x\n( m@8h8aO.Q H=QR4U.I/>r Sːhb8b8ip/I T Jg[V*_(mJRXsi334&֚5f6́f9 1P5FjL}GP 5SNW+u[ݫs5~XDXdXǰaa aCR7jbLZ,?ApG#!2yՇUUϫ!4gUYNj1ih P)J+e N3URR[K%y,QpY,fd&-'88 S_eEU+N:THg}* I9km5H ӣ,<$x*=/؞׊c{=v]kxz3qo1sGr |O)>g,RmJԺdGCvg2:Y/{Ȟ \Ɨ2_|m|&6|#c?t5NV/_WG /Uu}ҋ "#hbčI4wIc1j.-u+;3ϣuNI:YTuY\ks|_+|u7+ʽ ҫz3Ə9:W|] u=]$s9z =Sҳ@|@/ԋbD/"'#zy^WU1j}ZN'z99997zުOvCԟ]zޣ}sN$ɜ©ٜù\]]`']+vݱ^>aq!8G(|G]ƅ\>7܈|pSnp>.\p9 WㇸK油kqjz|G#iASw8睇#S9NS9USyԏYSb  Ai `BqB-4:4rC$BԅdHTH}͍yEi N3ȁ\ȃ|(BE:7|yP@Ch 4fZs;{] `:3{ x<8x O<<^X2^x ?-w.c|XX0@a>L֖udLC e $E\bd],SdL!K̐2KfSTjSJ$KɔBFAEپ\ʣ|*BGET_\j@ 5&ԔQsjAQKjESk'jC/R[jGuNԙPW~u}w}ԓzKԛP_Gi A4P{ߚ[涹c{w;]}<4cĔ2Sn* 5H ҃ 3 i84^4h MI*MGN?_Kޤ[[z|X a,%r~ +`%! r̟hnҌ3p7&[yylf60?7p7r31UL3,1G LkcIlNK7;q|o9 qBeq]$Cx BVyٚwg+r5?s*)T3BDm@֗/6lweW]}Xӌr''Mȗ)]9-c3X̕BX.cvZErHn[[_ʯX #<&OsX^MMy[GLV%VSTTJW*Se T=U_5TE T5WTkVWUgꪺzToGUT5@ T`5D Up5"pH{p Qj^U Gyu$/r|+yͼ ^;zCo7ɛnify5 bԬ4kGl6[mvk_گ~p& 10; aE&|1l ۇŽas%v =ž${a{q{ži{ƞy{^lثno؛A]'S\r.;WƍNKu\K빾k\nڦT]Ss-Z-G+*Sm&n[MvST7Mw3L7vs\7w BC|Q>\&UI~t:aB$)2"$-鈠(k`% B $ΰHБa' @HB8/gޝOs{v]%Nq"))=P xKB8a/SṄXDCOqOme9@ 5͹ps)^vp S{lpoPHEz PgzП+Bݨ;*ޔL)ԇR/4R t42h a4Fk:Yf!r&`CXG}&DDi MIh:fЇ4flCY4|Y JZ@ cZDZBK###(́?_οڿ&Vmi 7ҧS6lZI9ri5h-6F6fB[oI_.i7}k;}C{>EA:DctJSTJetP9 *:GTCnw:O7_uf`6Mf"-e#SdYrv"*ش4 1MicLPT_BBs*knO8uȆ Fhb"G}1 B.je`VB'0  'u:Lp"!.c *L{?Sa{j=kec:d1|fKx~j+a{{bv\"^PCߙP 1QF6ro.D0vs b#rgJz:g6ey0uYUuwK=N#`L鰅wo\M՞R~{~usxmá;{wsKy b+E'쏃]5x밎1Iܑ RKSchP;0W;Ja8.Egѓse>f{}W|w}K7C&U76fQ8|'$P~Gr\,sy3ٓ^pW릺 x-+bt G875f4}k{ͷWqg0xv]q ncH,2{}G| h]늽1X85 GV.ߵ B<:ϧXofw1_ {,g>SĜ|`=a&ȇTDNV-DKT9ӨgB[5J- R6JDDJoîԪVμy3ޛhs/5|v6ފG󃸡S4Q*axryke*Wj^ݮV著k ֏ 5_ys>7O/ݢ0+4ah5E2 +{gZ*sAy%?SglrG#䲗n}v'T1߯$O.]RKCGD S!'Nk .u>1 za2U4sλa˕ P1Mv^۬.:KGQG=zFf1)r{y4@G,KzE*wt ugy}}p@ޮ۶7ݷ6n{WgW],_tIUx(/\+ͽsN`Jf(4UጢI#ejX-a# Dz:P5c wظJGP{*n!!hX醻i}>*: k㝒Y;epLJdl:[$=޵t0J>Čbx|J_b_8)ɮԒ>X\*?u:z0Dž1gb58PH^p.N]D:uG)^%CR2pۀQ(*f&crof4tzұ϶} -{,O 5d@Z;MO SbnTxP(,DΥ}EP`؍U rM9knߓEµS)8 VxS{O'e)v97eSLt3A~8=YRI [b[2DWf/ƨ$n'T5ؑli4Dvs3b1(aJt P-"?8'xTCxpw+1<._[(N5OOpqFZHs~?UhN. ?_H띎-u1ٝݙϮ;z]wcl `L4EDPGEh* 660)P5 (JR[5@U?zf{=>F~;wbAXB-_Qæ8xҼT4d$ AIu 5/Z_h aUթ zĪ#VΛ*(c!l:{u@bO|ɔ{ͭ[#VhZ'_f;*fBtFD,N&UbK\h ͒Κ%"q#1mbGJ*/ȤiDgOW1h-Z:3qGq8@0ycY(LV@yaЇЬOKw-˻zϸ,Bvq;X^6ĸkleO+DE>P#H/  ټp.I2-x|(uuDz! (º=PskkNn.mHy\$7>~t>ƕIT"X!k! ̱_\*+i:)gku))OɤqEH`u*HOe@kG6F")Wy[ZܹͮK8KIsB$rr""߭{uޝ{;^[}έxnՉ!]5O/by0a|^Q( |69^;srN|+:ҧ돽9?{sī.b?CCطv:3*5ΏN9*@OOn=2珍雏T*ֵ3HFQA]ybHby9OnH1s\r\j IXDȇ΂mt A]6m{6=LVtT~,11nq2i?(O񸮶M8FTIH2x0kCgk=Qq |K6K*b [ 0B a,X$Ҏ#2j,iW@\S$My1NnptJq G&6bQDMA66b.[t$T{ܟG7 [_Tw_tol&LN;l=Xs*NmH#{[wmCw}ƩboZ_n=矜Ç{4_LO{r̸ ڄz#o MqE20lݘf70= !7C|V _??)e[e71m[\g9+۶?M,rzfLk5Sk tQb5*2yvL1j엪hjx0j-c;ĘJXd+]B&+[Vj%$KVeK6)çBM80&r j9l2nJHX2@33m)vΌS)@)%6d=YJs^ɭ"PY\aOUYTg[;anAvPIz߿q;;v6lyJG㪪{77756~?tnZ; K^YZsR8wu[ޛ`@.]:n!miш Jx0CCrq QIq[~bZR%&0TL6 =$R^uJ@n͓JC[2J>jJ]?0}f9ƙ1lP}h\`&a[ &5YGaX!lA.dQHԄA{ }n<߭==mOq ?n]uȵ?'2ZTPrT%4pˊ04DŽ84Oٹ% (k4b7!6Y [@叽ٝ}ڻ/T7Vm|'gߥqr i| ]G<ڪ`YM넛aĪTF]H:hϰ'=s%mHĴۘ>/{BXt+(R`ǔons,-Ҫ؂Y+zƕ.~a@ƽ ' *Z#t³!FOQJ\pyP"JP#dz R0gPIkةLVݿГq ]AZ4WZJ('Gk9˝n.ŀCʑ f1G' NQT UT\QP$zjbKUoT=0 Dt>C#}k r'aP}.c\%13HvCw%Qp.D cAU,_6 u>:8:єA<ij8 ` g=nbA :^ _eG s`zVb1둠5U޹ڧFۓWMz l#@q, ruuݻWڷ^]Tm҅%3Wi@;ltrf+"m|#.[^Hb]?{vK""y7̀ςӟ{aoNm 1/`u8r2v){e$uu-nO ?6ў1ܠoם[1CCn@C=NN'"<#;}S w :S'/ lFqMW0`]F"!Lt$>  kuͪ&1+Y%8 $_G|'\nXldi#2%?#෵0^Ȟ dɚxYd|jen#&^7XETKJis{|_m({Dj 幇zKd:d&qIVEh^YʰώPk뱯yCoPFpɇq}.Lx>v~bSaӠ'kٸMf"<ԕp,ӕTp4UQHhd,@âڲv> \ nng?=+QTM(IƇnq8IESɁI{#D'nD6đIڕRއuX]p=?OI>\?_˶AKI#Ep_ŝ?,Y/[U(m) =y7ݓ{u^;K88g$*+E $ i!$⦡|[Q760+J>& NuM0iS`YLbeƚΦI{_Y{~OMB_,bAieMI.㘈90LŴh-J4+JZ .Cba}ar_ydY-m <%ޥ[Eh DJ 9B5`riϩ=5Sޜ1nJ/Q'7lj6u2uH=y-n.BK,jQ!FTZŪ'i;eY݉z0#{QI8_Me&] Ǘ1PZd|Ɋ.v=؃{ ghޓVz;m̶B~=A$!hJJ?br },h`ҹbfz,ݻW:e˷{ c3Օ2:o{(~ 7}F.]aIe C讂.z_2$)$KflAQCʏXYK-g?X&5!je5"KFT, =Lfe yٍ3ܭ!u()K_G&Fd4!ނZ9߅wGv{=w#GG  GI?Idd2IBdߨd2m,TX##{;x%'xN ,s\kE\yc9Q3F)SMLe>UmR"P(|MeB0pxV^;i01ҔnDYc8!ti](B+,o#IQfg;CI!s\s*gĸUHcPHa%ggN~TkG>S,0}fwEn37oGt':ĝR_W,LĭF h41"rc}$ Q*(`ic@\HrE;N@z4%z!G(6S閏,SLw/꦳޴8')t'3|%C 58.FT(C*5Nł Ņ$PV d :1_BW9?OsaUY@MIL6Mx/O\X_{~ڎK>|<߻3PzVl3}k`dxt '5Pj=#N| TjM f"qFrqQ+i55p̪5Vr ǴRs9sg p +S?Ψ u*^xLFQ@LUW%E2Uq*J?c+ӶAT-vʃ+)E9ڼ@~l &;U }]>#鬈Do&15FQSf2Ŀ87jgDZ,GU!̓]ӯidbA"dskp3E$;(٭Ђb6r5bޜNJ7Zs្|[ߓמhK O:,J N׊vo}JJEwA9|-m`#V?._VEfx~yuu^:_>]*QJfpejKL Z RۤO'ru0mL#KAU4t(),~c p0P)^जJf]Ĩaj5>x.t֠5***vUn3$ sP<[-5R8n5ɼ,I+f0Ys2ӘH8+1Ml2421^N>vԿRUjNAJd|&.-Vy-.HY;֢L <0RV< tFȄ7eKʤ;_nbN*vw4g"О+Ch#-tD$GeD䭺t΂YɂIbZ`˳,s7Z KX@mf˸l@hAĶoEPT~'@"_boL'h,G}!~;=7$QD)DnB%ß$:;?׉RzJ\1_Bue&^^z;/⟯ٵ/V?ɞ.au|XwjvHϤ"Ͼ!lǏ?$~}WdY_ ϫYEY&#@5?@Bėk.i95υb2;a!=dؑ^wZa` ]ocK̼1ϼ[bv6ȣq!lo#d(D8Yzff_qI쥷VRwJG-2>K<${jؔTW]'<2jB$pQw {:"?`++Q t?WlWGe06逅BŮ5q%Q (⭮66 wtf3o~vs졀f6sbi;=r(}(F2%EO8Vձ-UQvO|:vs S6G*JsMdd Q-yQ4-S;bs;t&IOKI&vB؁)L,M &S=-z'VÎ΄i']4o;`mH©`*(=P k=P܇enߠW/qh߫/IqE D I=$YKȸ+¬G'2 V!*yi|o|*lT>ogRgN~9B #ydV2Ib8h6܀Jc"y|UQb?qv3N!bw9nϘZC_WwQf'de;PcU@)Ápc8|/gljϾ;sKr1[$Y*0@ڎeӵ݄$lEZЉ&h#TLj@մf~kMKrwoQNZ?E{+;xF_|rҍ)TQqxƼ&G qT~Pϴss.V}*J~Nv9j. u."Ԥ " 6$SLF ѐNp{KL1Y3kg+YG˥7:FnR|@5"P9T#QHl&; nP/{yl=W=Gxխ;HGm v+݊4ΰV]~ǦCG0%@;tvqp@vĥk H/3B BR#U 0Mf8R4k4?Ԟzjhz<7*,ls][1'y 0x/hOaަ޵CESLDVAU(2RE`⇓".ESᦹE]ɍs9vXA^㨆䳰1Z$*괺:nV K>`>S; Dc#9'CF+ < [x)?YyIW\(HQ MBx[- 3(!Su`(R!;C(TeHuTCYY*CxL^s.qˀ,nB;DlGK[ԫ町0_.ӢWFqi<5\ ^bT}Q_72@',CgC!䇚~unq p 5ֻjZWu7(ҚWv}q2}p\;G|\(]_(`gV=دR g nL,?bP19FOC}?+ͯb?E]m@ sya`O] aAuMF&}j{|~>O'VcbΣ? U*nv5 tyRaS}[-hR|tmfbdش%eSrz ~KO`)JXV]~"A QȠ\r:6 EjrZ% 6# Sſ'L+dֈsdF,*?>/qpVBp#ǥ@&/uw${kk;~ʼnyR@B&ڲ{ģTmX5U £aUۨ4TMJR,Z[1X qGǒ{ι,~сXaP%4 ۰6>JX5VZ:\ kϬ&'ko!.[uC/FUipJm43io_Pm٣J+g%{K;-|2"Nc#2?*:pzנ ,%8\R&Mgt$r sŁPHE6)jMgj}6W$ބl=, 6*9>:&xK\7\|6өtC6@?{s7Xm-0R;k7gR̰)9TU)Orx$jrqI [𐹟c3_&ͣUpxlz/-zL-Ecˍm{Uv"3 =Z],n\0: t54&SM`gWa].BL3uO ǏǹwYE(oQ+t,a07}Ш ȤjB=B)ą7쾛Dw fȁ2Tor1JXI<Z-ft'իPX5!!J\H5焩#<Ⱥ9ӌ$0dyeLRKJ\ x/a'|ƊP$Ԙ3W$CmXc*ժJ[Veԝ6q ]N܅츓=xS\f`0S"9Gn^r N2v闹wVr&M+;*7**gx䛟{־ʹJ?.ΉE{Tި:a^*-/_;K X:ڌf6 EX~ĹerR# t)Utfª72 Åo"# _G𧆋ꥆ  f]^N ix?O͖K4tP.fU^[4F `O cBA9+f+z{5Fa_SS3}Zj&^-q7Viȩʦsj"x˄[ %[Tsw"5I-iK;1\Dpv 8|ډhry@4 6:?ĨTŨG'+{>sE,`GLHVT~INN#ӀOμ?h}e)Y<C1'6$ >lxu($1%G.&;;;緋srRmE@Ҹa 2C"n4Z l@J04hLTǠ҄T)LˤMm=ϓн1);,|!5'BjV[KÐ,LZGm`'Dh 8]J]/%!jPz2yM_2. ]ꅺ3ؒca4 + Jˈ+d1&lՒ>Ar !˞`2lg, d(q*Zi#&ߖŢ8TX)~[̵UJ9nPjn, KȒ-hON~2)4Qh7Fu밸WcnN@BlukaAHh}%#/Ib$)$Z˔4me@Hh!5hLi8qs?f# Ed|0=Dh[DߋCQq2,eeFQo"'kж"lkzOKU"p[3 W{g=_X2:9sy_?F$:{~ xC*Kݠ&Xgެu": FE9*wnwƹ4"G ?* WUqUcX%VE8 ָ|y XFؐ PVWVWu=ulqmd1P,U F@8YC̪xQy_Je4Ng>N^_mb;Djg'+TӲtU'KQ16,t%T“R9q֔l*X@$SNSJTS )gݷwN\$]@ހ +k{%d#U za Z Q`-N([@0Dij1 |N _̣C50גͤ2屡{ц1˖L9zZ@sٜAmxztbdh5w8vvF_|F)i5βMoZ K$W% C%½! * P PMhf$Ə?acTwYsN%SjVnPk<]?|W6ܻPE(163tH{=Ώ7о`DiA8O5 v~͓tT~dGjX.n9L@"S?/{-*]Jrx~Wd IȲ%aN2!J^7vSfVzjŒas^s`@%iP:.Y+0C0ؑċߏ?6_ ?`WV'kK*p.U(qD|Jʡ&3?3$C&'|h!xj /?rx{!8..|ILe=荋&_?b 5hKwh `j TrŊCN>N>xzxIz9|+kpq 57 EH6lwEFR2-*ki-N9yhQ-Oe{@lݜÎ&!XE !Ґ8\]փ87g#iB ]Gz%-;ݿyƟ񵏗Jo2ڮ8A:iˣ [zlҴjrl|3v0ފgփԯv -M!|wۅ8R%,ܼyKjAy://_VȾHq7W}r%x99 }:<J_]f蓶{ag2pXw [<延 >$MlmJ_G=њ-d،?~+]mGQS-H "aen sw[Q4)/<Ǣ7AIK;, !Pu>lfwz=3x̒LllM@)n0(EahV%UB<*ٔJG UH EVE;K̝{zspH$drBn8Rr4C1~{dtl,:HJ(5|Vu1xH?YJS_a5$LQWsy<#@Y&5(]~o:jiƦՖ_B5{82#a]+V}V C~˟I`üLXZ笈z:Rc&͡tTtVhYLjS-"߀A$YưQ Y 0aX07x^S|V3JƟt+3i{5DxP׷#xDFȈ~߉==!o+oGÉo 'Z={3g~lo].K K5OCabsǞ}VF+-1ʾzduM2'i68<dzJs~iQsN >TEmfi';H]5|DUGR!Фr<qL!&J` `4,In(p>XD![g/oUBE> WVj7-TTi4ՕP)o噭DYQPG.y%Q:TU^T:.A{5$tLmutget/36#LEE~|.zBm/=0+ۇ]QXdX.*SC G_(L`* [aN3Y1SazzA{&^O:(ZIĖ^!aѯ 藾64ZL&} \XUkwP[m/F[ A3sxVDXxBʱ)Jp!2.Mpp9,) $@6"7Ձo߬,Ա0 3=030~Rk;ܾ/k[eV}@1Ti&6PM n~q]T xU+ @ ^۰~3ZEeN=nC]rdfxܠ<ҕ5ޖ-0yĒ罽y{#uX&DHWVJ>xK.vcdG(쭆aՈb'Ks9ȯe`:1-%B[Ȅgdn$zm%wѓyZ{e5qR J& |j^T)bt}mCniUqj@Ҁ.20nanY;P;mUFAT\l߻;g>w1v'qӤea dŢTFWiaUfXi!SmBl4ulj4˔iBb4g(,ݽ{w_wUi({8bYrH`ՙuЮdMx bN{3 \Sn@Z wk&(.BQV,|>Jk8LMӄIUISlT8 Yv6ZZ9Oa`F5Ml,KιV-KT#ۆ; LgGG'$_Z|ձ5z@*Q׬ s ]3쪎ۿm?%L:H}4;?5<0Ok:.ݲ:<6{[z| 8[*d7lGYr=?t xFyЀ( AJJhB%; }9.Q8!+8}}%Fi_+ڛuUW[p G搹QO&P@$[s;tu j2HtTHoH9GKa^y_V_}׃Ά GYLQ٬{Y *э 4z%k҂T93$oEXH$$|%*DE8 7pnûGVC|O)k.|b.r'cQc{,%9{:2>Ư & ̐gP9_nbepK([A;kbY"Y3Vźb-Z˖yDž],_$M˓M*oc*VW5VC4 E$+/l !*c5Y04vyDW*n\ʗwE*=[Z*qs7 #G#" ~q⧫ w!B%Zـ f@3,iYLlF[yUb>rɖzY17!l,W-2D }(oUa%{]y['V<x34޹kߘL'cѡOoC+9CL~)6 A*A*G*MdFt@]1 D}JdiҫaV W!EbC͛kQ%5R,uAi8]s btLOGQf:O;hd .Z,SĐb&1=AOlLMtCKgۅoT N).|np5J\o(isR}")5 &Lħ(jq. E\*3c"'{TᩲWx_U~Uc3/zc0`7d;efLl{|.?;B{A/Lf| 3ȇ"' iUHЦbߚC0* %0n7NE$j"#l2tt.%Qõ) q4|>OF Po")t ǚylu'J!UDh3"c"'~{X(F"6IdŢO҅BxBSX^BC|>okzT9##reI<1*ņ ijɄZy}{m! ʒ?+`-<G~̜ {g&)ivw@~]Z!ΧV&$@< uAy8,`JzO'ei^q\d,7Q]M\w=}w$绋b!>I`Ci xiPA:eJbV!McNJmA?BjDɦ]F4u(Tbcu(~{}ïqqkeda.q,].JNpr-n.V _p `Ju#>6o1"܇;9x}=fYyޒ<#&o_,貢sįVSI8"2Hİ<H{)j !L3PF|K%\@pq͢q7VfXfQaC&!Vל7(_#65=/bⴸ,k}aƫ<.OEOT-6K=M97AMbNwTsE5wEbC}`76:ӲϓڬS[ *1}d% 5XeQ}K2jma cM|LL0ZIFY8S<4dX7؅>Wa:z_Ah߬n=b!(P\Xηkmu Ǥ_pΡ!&eJͥSLK_ŭqK$U@oBMx*`mE25PW.s?كHdҞ;\*0e2]O>bn6.q#Ō0#Fb, J_Sְ*CnO;iCޑyp]"RpW7H8v6ic]/ݕ Km.pdm~N )/Ք$2*?Rou :h5H@!SI 'v&ۢڶΎtG۴3hh ^|$h>=t`?sގBi S@b_E,G'DHq3JMM5$%qY* p6 ;ayHĢjAҍȇк{f!=MHi3庳=Qx@aqE"B~pn=*DySdJnRAbZ>? Rt:02^KwƏ.d79ѿ닇;={iM4j"'?iKRtM|f iۊ0z2GRq3]S]cl(N9"T#QЈ AAB1j@p[&{Kh*k-snԛncɏ2Ur{Nrd,f= $AC,pFu\ gw8pm7giO2ްќ`7{ێXdI`sξ`'pW7q+_:Vp+ta^I y VC/a;F֌= MjhN[ڊEꏩyeol 4&Co h qᢻp%L׍-∁/CmR>T?޾ط]l$JGΑ fu)kt^`'mD#A۽h{G툗)&yHҧAKķ"* 儹Iz9dQ5._o&T6lqun@vtQJ8R}gi8o&̭8_+7-R<[#֧g^gQOH ye񢂔u_  @a(նm Vm+dYdk?AvV2)C֎H"kGs>h0j^]Z z21TA4JNOf vZZ&#r]W|Rv^=-rr_\hS9 _|S FV~J;O79 XHӯSjC0a t$Zs :-L"VZ2d6; |'ki(? ).4}.IH6=jt@+=45Liex14  jo MgiAcgccq6n@-C2`d@53=6I{Mh|!yѻ,S)4/ϛؽ.Ǿ!e[?SѺ\UKWh퓬nꍢQ +\ѴxGz E>.?k{GQc̙veQI8'&w<4>N'Nsy IuXGRH( 3F H-”ߡ2@oZ\}UOmBIHRSX9(nyT*u l,/R*KSe␣lL[L`~ĦbX%V$IFF]Gq&2f1ocvo`WU4h*J%wýF&]6\֝. MKnJKIxZ1F6k:epZl՜7gVMgɶ,z,|q/N&)L %; q$Y<7, \ iDjnwu(nkh4T8Wh7F0irjx#;!8ZA{/u3=ro{,vŤetH{kY;IQF/7oΌjȶZdhCYHr^=rTNSu(1xD l0iH7mHocp䗐V\\Iܒ<H ڽCƎ~PbKiEG\T`8H{4 c5󑖥 jCPՐJH~pol OW'9uAm+#{.ԛJt)1pI<'0Ni0EF+xGjfBGf""y2Zᣔ+QY}ڢ9j뮑45,#9r?'GsBCieC?cII[TevŶm^a$%ԍ$b]eu3:fI$j;350'C&KX+6c/{k`!tjnF+ ~KЧmҸkD9,F?O;QwsH?5~X1]:ʓYYcqdeBU(*B]WZ18&Nt^Okڰ,2iu0:f Y:΢pSn*immPôT?DP6LkW\c:U6a9x,ȣT#ca0 @3Ƣl=<1wM46 iEX7hQWsESuNFhhJ2|?$%ĩdrJ~%%),^b7R$5fEmYWUq&khB[@qH;@ÿ7|:b XB_8 ?fY\jvЩ\* xY[rI)TNtbB~[B |"5J˟UTi+<%ϟ91tWłT*&_:r;D 6Nhd>ޅt1vϮ Nem6hCqJKü9Fr"7z@_Mx@eL&>2^};aS0,bҪ.J+u>SYO2Tu&gW℉f|=ުn[23XrmcqGm20x5g1=oϧ RψJ !av {szim"XGZm*8Z'760D S`vtɇj q+Pf"v 3KBS?~㛧_[ᑁV'ꏍ۪>_lߝw亶.c菭ݺtZkLb ˏjD~(Z2-iAK ꚉ!&GUcc*Z%]'{~{|ѕG>;fgC~bsjLKW\޾N%2á̆]=r#)"MK<~ivBr78!TۘqBw 7?[ b.u1S>1EZ8CClP9ELɉ"m1@DSvi<^Axөu{^ton{Cw*C^moz%aDGcS7/__(ctUk hHǤc2HAv(^+Px`2ZR y#e *e0'.A!g{2# q0=2hױAf"Ư,%ڲm&)Ϙ` f 8 ~E`]oSQ)}p%*Xh32bb~nM̴h)1-"E@]Pjۖg>{pW=ǿ7՝儠`B4*9W_;=WC^=l)< "`Q=JuXqƊ60E1$FAL7$FB UH5dYpzSX-f; =;~4E+%D?#BĨ,7.N>(>h|ڳPz|7ͻùE/Y=Z۞Xygnmb4f QwPo(Bf 0aܜ0i̓yd́ˏ0ʲFF hmeVZ!TG#E8WT3%5|0VEE0&]J\pC^E)?uǒ] fXod+Yz,f6NrLb ?"Luy])F0UsAcBW(bލ.gihpA\tsڰFkh[ȧUQ: #M..[j~ Aiyq]tk p}\ۤ~ : ~jQ<_|,7U^VV;|^a~#̋@*KjŊtJBuL ɲ.jõ񚗯5tA|.|.2)Vϥ˞˙٫S+.#f\G*ax:Cdz2$xJ-$Jy4s4p[=Qxt̉r2TuZ@CL-*z&kf7;3q.L8-Ұ:T]_eUU7K!K3s<  X몖V J XָŘVE[l$-7zSEw&%ԏKBr>`,>ؑ|B ׮7 47[5)[ #: Sz9#NKm').&aE,pDsop Fo=>vFiw6HNLC0fٯS%އ}4o?: sfӎp*R~'$bO'dcgiT'ƌdZM5"[c"BDSN3>_ܵ{'w}[;LlpvG|oF%*˥\1_Ŵ )XCDJHR k*9 3RW1O3xF.^X6/(TԶ89˫j/^%nPj8A>b5d:LKb }eA+%ʊN$+}a בt#0$NSa;CN?tOj2:Nsz֫Ȋ0qYQ5)8ܹZ /:~^~oP\sK&J5u2E(vH0.% IiN +y]m]e{nb{m^;q;M즎eHFCtPBDQ2!J PI!ieV Zm*$zS&NyϽINy9~<>lQi>6(jtVyQpjCaFN26u+ܬ̧0pdsǣحuiP"/nxU}fM׶B]Oܾ=d|kG~4xc폻:9cС#zG2|6jru+!2#M2|ƫ݅ `*r;J$WqYD ""hއX@(-{㞇ؕ7kMr ~BE&zu<(.0|2O|NW1Q(UFxEX:JeB#m9dWW &]-%+P#l,;Ƃ:]VXx{8Cv0%xg3Fa@"~%.a'y6E߫MCL~󵠹sxu<7OVR@"̆6GjJJGtTO#INIiT(T#-s5 Br8F*FzIXPp2mc[1H4ד"k{J1`'unߝSo>-6:?iMl ager| t% p'r)5*P*QڢR!E/=XHv| 0s;_gٿj鮻Ez@|gNjD-Gs2S *Ә>"RWkڈvНNm\?F~J^~:K2r5rMZ~L?V? {-ˋeٍͦFCxw"n{>aTiUZνguF+c/31bP9|$S5m@qA)]/z$ aLB& !%Z< SB]j*ud)A;/bH*U?ƹ ]5$,[įK}hTII+zG}OPmնgܜ|=ɺ`Yu;Ewm,-onF{P&n4kt7Q(njBhX0Kp`qQJAGJH#?qVrU2]\0 M-cyliiIܺ$b_|zmYcgA9d{[oD3|nHAWWW!JΦ2s9+-r.GmdCOFRI֥M,oʮȄʽ3vMۂT"^BſS%txƶ]T:߫1٘N7]J9ݨXLba1D}}/u7Rj\vWӲTP,uKɋɋEpaڇqkuf-%gVE_l,I׍ ]]f9p(H FSK>.=.O WrΈgYv&?k̚rrFx>9cYY9[j!X>a)ePF2Ѭd!ۂ|T#a" w aXD"2j)5€UUs̼&)d*}X 2ޕ,|$"2||,tV7E3j7a [dG)WQ'I3LU&4|Aïjok~qDZ`QKi+3n6Gki|?tW}l߻w>cǎc' 6k(#AR)*Fj)USuk+@XH&)!ĴMdEUB=9 [{<u~TU ME6YU9ۦmٌEefbnI/p!Oi>*Dp \8lr"~^H[tTTdžT\*J28~)<Fh$?g4's9E&.Žif:'IotwQ~@b:;SJ|I5+,68|UE˟b)E"(}~%'{,SrM?Msv_?THS\di,sd1v,vq>=3ucxbۭ _ tڬ ;gs4**41GTw}zY!G7@J[D1A8 w:dG R4.L-TA>&UW-T ]<*OtqLFet.M@6 ]PrjLE*S!9i 鞄\TTٚli)I#ݸa| %M 諄xSdvEV 녝+8jart4D|ez^7GADv><5;S;>nc)Ex8@"-=Ma+00]a!b8 C8=ሞ :X+zrR,hbW_g:<E yEt(3֖K=}n^_{\F] ըK2Hʃ>6iy*wQore5?+3n4`muK~Ny݌H@-4C5ReqND`#N- ,:N[s(ܠں]])S2|YJ܄cֲ,͍r.XW0UI9g0;Mnfx:~ .L}J?X}ga8MĥF&TyarԲ3ŚV\ToMËqq|^*[I~:tJ>#&$;#O<5Ĉ;פriX7棱2*y kGZB\%ouO hsHzz.yx68l&!ܸs|v!,`oR2ܛ=d)s$lO^ooûw!6ZwA!fQ@>/iLC!砽qr_]TW?$MH"h QĐ`B iCI V 3mm Rjf*mm`)02IQ@i#ա@[ ^ci"~ݽ?M ;sv5aY#!Np#{9PA n1h7j!`^t}c~X>þ}ql>ݙًiH.ѳ>1W>G֙;>c$3}?}* G:od6>KQCB쳞:T};aч茶#Rv|F[Vb8Mci8`}??:#-任9$H [fVڬe=BYӤ:Mjao%o`sh1)%hȿ|p< FXqցLJ\ SAd [&'kqm$(fvƋ6#egrȉ>ݗ4ڃ;`So^;Y8Wov@Vk5 ӏ#8oujJSN5% /־Lnrr?\lG;ѺzIv=u :u#%%N' lIkj'emp,Z>3$@=xnjjḠ˵TR̈!]C*Пu3qn?{zcE_c_fW:Պ3:SC kc+KcN14Wm[K ?&*cd9p;-*c܃;ؽ- sQlaY4bQ5΁X*z}%Al1Zv[qs>\t/d&d>#~[ tĒFwmp~EUtZBUn!jBNQG*d n^jx~5CnDBB 2 ;=zk;/U}ηY>Xcy' D{W;O`*';x<xCoG_07DdIU{[7 GrMu4ײgc۪L12s \:P3{y9*7պ@ e-\ƷaĞDԋ/1hp^~s [Nhrbl/9f#o ,q~×}g¹o8_#G6y_FLB53Ẵ[K:pv.10þg4Jw-kC߆ ܅ O3A2؄ F^U[dUvIu]d;gQo[u}8}֟@ H/%>is\uQWYHO]h'X>se=B\~ї8?A̞ı]TbRĽ8EyҦrZ1$ٔ`GTHG` 1n>#qؗe ]Ft䇝tBkSes^[r@Al9r@9 c,xk?FFETvd&ƝVgPqit^h#꟰~.#_ X?nkE6#~F>gZݨbm^W]jU#r\;? ;/bjۮ"fιsúw']ҵ K3SchOb_T)1& *sTK# EQ"p(eOg3>uaJ*|94mp[|^#~ym6]D'w$N?t!#j*{A,E纵T&wS3Ri\HGqԱ(dZe֯)8=2ܭ$hK;p3V |ncX?{+W5`GS/f3^8xH_G}.~#g!F]0X2/ YFia0/eU{o.W]]Y`Y b,rMe!r)2G4M*xAC%!"6 Id9h(B"heHCA~yϻ7f~|s?*זmeC~gG[͆w~6<ˆ~Q ~ӼK`$voB~Ӗ[ք‹+Q2yC[$o"Ka {F}ln뎬tgVcj[I3ߙD?~;L 3Kp̄4tRﳰWh^27 =nƮz71Ww"bI%J9)A~CM>}1+l#fnW=aMwM&V˹z.5w*63'So/e22məˠ)3s7s_w${Swww<ZF6YMS*ӓrߙ}[<,Eo쾁S@RW5,j R?𧐶JR|c{8ϧ2FJR盻:r)1,<C9lتވ@Jr)p3FUmukb.c,g΢4e4XƦnJ04 (Bg;iԾ$NS_zGя"]gֲ/ r%c?.RzN|?wzy~A:ʠ*ʭcSDhMlw򭭍꥖aU<񝻡b#P#-?/Q2drB4Ի2ƛ'gCfOnԚ{|&}V_.zo1O;ᕄmИdRm۾aT79ދqd\#hw47s"LZb=^a/ߝ_ooȬ''oS+O;,mW\WL!0&ZK[%5}Fj%2}Ywok|zo|!ŞCݯr|]tWGȹ_(} >羀B{e@ .t_#^){z觍U{Ehe> n3' LUu^bDc|/BU8#/-P?l]O1sy&/¡/Wk̵9ѹF6IYtޓqǰ0&otՌY8z0^6u):/g1eu7S)}di>e736{{Χ_1D㟶DbmO?̹Y+SgmD&}7L}6cߵ f)T(?1  ڧ3[΄C| %(䓖)9i'!%8|UnNqLP@-e6毒ɝ~WUq{9{M0! B<! 1 R(@^0hVZj(vuh:C)yhi|0jN?{ `bM38{vY`_XZז~ړ5:5Hq"EQc T~=&|y&OOꦉ$Y Bp(8? NܼrbRӸCM>/F[vgOZn7CĂĝlj4)35/*+J̼;838e6LBe?/Өp-rL3j<]cu:vrb|j3l.S_ v#m;0׽_##0&7Nmɘ2+%G{6K~E#OS}̻FW|0qjMCi4Pm xʳCO,?(ym_ko.p%ꚟ^Y:jЗTqrFJ`\ӥ/Re 4PcSu@o>pOc;z+iխ} rm:M7(6Oy_P<" `y-$9AKR`ifcK*O[uٍیB6 y]7Q3u:>-͚y?G~_c\~ oV[zaj--0jVء{k?n/am@?63@۱xιz=eDrg;bx:Vu]lvt"sTLai&.Fr΁ F|͹ HGG3۠ĝi2#7>>xJǵx2Ex($syޮiUj-`\iTw38~ƁCr5.:$6n0)Z/_UWúu*M&xWK>tfEl^C WwfOLjȼ踎3YX~Z,aN§pǘzr|GR_e'(;y?}Dõ8y>u~?Nw2{VD/bo]ms\;Cn ˹dtK/ey|]*|D?=Aj,8}غ[ZӪ}g}4~ߢŮ˸D$F/;lLz4 ϋxǙ[;w%~Bu4K.2Ѡo(c]X_!a@1U9)YʉE5%J{6>^ڽswܞq|@q?Ǟ'P2V_d@! B]8֞Ľ=]ZT ѣ-[_1;u㵈?~3M-ǹC;=Yk }˞Ş;+dds&ػV|7̍ZX7+\{"[?dmp;_ :䰛TىIN"sFűz,϶> RR}$5R 7Jj1oS0~i q$4_KWK㞕*&J;*MbrTgi*{ҬgQ>N;d]H]˧I+Gf޹jVߎ"wl{ޑhzZ1}?a_QrIl;8_={p8p8p8p8p8p8p8p8p8IDʭ/UU{&nv*ᜰ XXӖم $dGf&Yɮ23:0!im5`]mAuпBSkVԩ眽 QgqFv>==)@tP%*x&*@jJwaXI3S쬭;_B述u'`GX59kT[T\8h Q[w@?omǹ^ A~mTȄG 24BI+]rʨF$Dq|׋ eB> L5iV ]ا`!#nk(==Xjq}-maѪ#!7}s`+C1x&9:GcQv7"V$ u^i`aԦgYQ59hDOr:1U7fC՛*ä)'U,rK.> 2)t@P5Z쳴#w@Mr\aեNDU=V':L/1Ȍ$M+J&RL,1X-BheҢLfZ^;e֤9!k#'zcI$GRFk RD{8{ÃDަDߠ;M˝:bi:="ḰwDNtb(1!z2)fJd9;Ds,b"m6Q3*yH*T{DL8OW t60-p{b <оOWP.sXdR9ND?|?)_#P'5@#_ܽ-!סz/|w˿'͗c/TD-gdo⽃72cȲͼ>ݡu;mAx<$y`~ݽAnVTIk?di#q8n[+ר-kN[}y%yvݢbiS*?2ؗɭii.:ٯ{GeXr?)xW\/S(;wM``ߥq80 8 @ *=lMP 8dd<;DQ;E+ N*,jg_4l)'l O^ - 㰥mfC.cIqOhSNat7EH?@^b\cVW==F?ɍarc@ht!g4"g9,]04.3M*0)-69Vc쐵K֛?诿z0 ɮ*k-)_Db[efv25Yb/:+O E2k>:S,a[)++ eM v/#@҅܄> Yˍ<7uK`iI;ZYs2lDbr<'5 ˀe :0 Z;~(T9 ZoLvJNTi@}\*))9zyzfGWsyg֖Z+lZsv <qp P$> jz PqAf܎IIMpz`{kh.`B2;M+E 5LȻ$P@7X'N>I`ptN>4r%.Oȣ/C5?z&&GMƣMF(&]3S˃KCƥ2BVW(.E/XZn_n[n]n-7Xn|\֭K/=IRnܨFi؝v*^xdK7-?Y*I m n@ 8ɯikꯅUqVh~זok49  hZ#2ۨ? ZOS]-׍]Xz|j',xOZc߰|qVlC˵^en*uI^ܓ/mdU 6.i^jSq˫YF^ZPŚ[5oz%]V)Ty%pUswp05ZS՗,~×*_zW\\t2C\]§}WE"G=x*a[lp oLU4l,xS~i)"'[SWfV.{~e^rjCA3vw~޹ùݹ)eεRW*v-s\BåU n!K =R:$;%E*mی/JeBx)88tZQ+147AxkOvCu`6F`Hrina. v%{Oʒr>'ٿ(.TM&,lVsF5a_zpƸ(YrEѵfewPZxFdQ6eUNn-bJҽTyyS?ْtd_;UwǗMc8vػ슻ڶu%fi+b<3B ܛgi#5"XqIZ||hewN&MSETq؟ȧ`|y[c34&pjp㣈D%\37߀8_a A'FtZjp@w+H5 tBo ],? endstream endobj 31 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[461.0 384.0 472.0 395.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 16 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 3/Type/Page>> endobj 38 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (96070233)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/96070233.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:37:22 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 735 591.75 30.749 re f /Article <>BDC EMC BT /Article <>BDC 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 750 Tm (#90-64039.)Tj EMC ET endstream endobj 15 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 2/Type/Page>> endobj 39 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (96070233)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/96070233.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:37:22 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 731.25 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 579.749 0 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 730.5003 cm 0 0 m -0.75 -0.751 l 579 -0.751 l 578.25 0 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 729.7497 cm 0 0 m 0.75 0.751 l 0 1.5 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 730.5003 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.751 l 0.75 0.75 l h f Q /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 746.25 Tm (Claimant)Tj 0 -2.75 TD (DATE: February 19, 1997)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Claims Case No. 96070233)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 15.224 -2.125 Td (CLAIMS APPEALS BOARD DECISION)Tj -7.237 -2.125 Td (Dissenting Opinion of Michael D. Hipple, Chairman, Claims Appeals Board)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -7.988 -2.125 Td (I respectfully dissent with my colleagues' finding concerning the effect\ of the denial of the carrier's )Tj 39.846 0 Td (inspection right;)Tj -39.846 -1.125 Td (however, I concur with the remainder of the decision. )Tj 21.687 0 Td (The record indicates that the )Tj 11.634 0 Td (carrier had requested an inspection)Tj -33.32 -1.125 Td (within the period required by the MOU, and in fact, conducted )Tj 25.298 0 Td (the inspection within that period. )Tj 13.442 0 Td (Nevertheless, certain)Tj -38.74 -1.125 Td (items were repaired or discarded prior to the )Tj 17.993 0 Td (carrier's inspection. )Tj 8.038 0 Td (No issue exists concerning whether the carrier)Tj -26.031 -1.125 Td (aggressively pursued its right to )Tj 13.026 0 Td (inspect. )Tj 3.333 0 Td (While there are some instances in which a carrier cannot demonstrate har\ m by)Tj -16.358 -1.125 Td (the )Tj (government's failure to accord it an inspection, it is difficult to make\ such a finding here for many )Tj 40.89 0 Td (items.)Tj -40.89 -2.125 Td (In )Tj (National Forwarding)Tj ET 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 28.9961 517.5 cm 0 0 m 100.313 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 129.3086 518.25 Tm (, )Tj (supra)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 135.3086 517.5 cm 0 0 m 25.992 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 161.3008 518.25 Tm (, the decision cited by the majority, the Comptroller General )Tj 24.382 0 Td (considered a claim involving)Tj -36.49 -1.125 Td (crystal ware. )Tj 5.358 0 Td (The Comptroller General was unable to conclude that )Tj 21.715 0 Td (the carrier would not have had a valid defense with)Tj -27.073 -1.125 Td (respect to the element of the amount of damages. )Tj 19.882 0 Td (He held that it was unreasonable to discard relatively expensive)Tj -19.882 -1.125 Td (broken crystal ware items, ahead of )Tj 14.466 0 Td (the carrier's inspection, when the carrier vigorously pursued his inspec\ tion rights)Tj -14.466 -1.125 Td (within the time )Tj 6.305 0 Td (allowed by the MOU. )Tj (The value of the crystal ware, of course, affected the amount of damages\ .)Tj -6.305 -2.125 Td (In the present claim, we considered damages to items falling into 3 gene\ ral categories: relatively )Tj 38.819 0 Td (expensive glass or)Tj -38.819 -1.125 Td (ceramic ware, wood and/or antique furniture and other items. )Tj 24.741 0 Td (The Army's )Tj (administrative report is incorrect in stating)Tj -24.741 -1.125 Td (that most of the damaged items were dangerous broken )Tj 22.354 0 Td (glass. )Tj (Of the items reclaimed by Stevens due to denial of the)Tj -22.354 -1.125 Td (opportunity to inspect, only Items 7 )Tj 14.526 0 Td (\(stained glass figurine\), and 4 \(broken glass in a picture frame\) we\ re clearly glass.)Tj -14.526 -1.125 Td (The )Tj (National )Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 37.6563 384 cm 0 0 m 44.32 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 81.9766 384.75 Tm (Forwarding)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 81.9766 384 cm 0 0 m 55.992 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 137.9687 384.75 Tm ( decision would have required the retention of Item 7 for inspection due\ to its value )Tj 33.602 0 Td (\(original)Tj -43.766 -1.125 Td (cost $850\). )Tj (By logical extention, that decision also would have required retention o\ f the )Tj 35.324 0 Td ($110 Hummel figurine \(Item)Tj -35.324 -1.125 Td (179\) which had an original purchase price of $110.)Tj T* (Most of the damaged items involved wood antiques which would have been a\ vailable for inspection )Tj 40.295 0 Td (except for the fact)Tj -40.295 -1.125 Td (that they had been repaired. )Tj 11.328 0 Td (Stevens' expressed concern was that the repair denied )Tj 21.672 0 Td (it the opportunity to verify transit)Tj -33 -1.125 Td (damage, pre-existing damage and tender of the item. )Tj 21.27 0 Td (It is more )Tj 4.083 0 Td (difficult to demonstrate harmful error in such instances)Tj -25.352 -1.125 Td (because the tender of the item at origin, and )Tj 17.771 0 Td (its condition at tender, were contained in the descriptive inventory.)Tj -17.771 -1.125 Td (However, as in )Tj (National )Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 91.3105 277.5 cm 0 0 m 44.32 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 135.6309 278.25 Tm (Forwarding)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 135.6309 277.5 cm 0 0 m 55.992 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 191.623 278.25 Tm (, the amount of damages is still an issue. )Tj 16.414 0 Td (Of course, the carrier would have had a)Tj -31.049 -1.125 Td (much )Tj (heavier burden in proving harmful error by the government's disposal of \ the broken glass in the )Tj 40.864 0 Td (picture frame in)Tj -40.864 -1.125 Td (Item 4 or by the disposal of the pottery \(Item 134\).)Tj T* (The Services should be much more vigilant in protecting the carrier's ri\ ght to inspect damaged )Tj 37.975 0 Td (property. )Tj (Even when the)Tj -37.975 -1.125 Td (disposal or repair of any particular item does not constitute harmful er\ ror, )Tj 29.685 0 Td (the Services have a duty to honor their)Tj -29.685 -1.125 Td (contractual obligations.)Tj T* (Accordingly, I would grant the carrier's claim with respect to Items 239\ , 122, 123, 128, 231, 303, 7, )Tj 40.116 0 Td (11, and 179.)Tj -40.116 -2.125 Td (/s/ Michael D. Hipple)Tj T* (___________________________)Tj T* (Michael D. Hipple)Tj T* (Chairman, Claims Appeals Board)Tj T* (1. )Tj (Government Bill of Lading #RP-709,759; Army )Tj 20.582 0 Td (Claim #90-022-0150; Carrier Claim)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 14 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 1/Type/Page>> endobj 40 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (96070233)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/96070233.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:37:22 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 85.5 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 579.749 0 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 84.7503 cm 0 0 m -0.75 -0.751 l 579 -0.751 l 578.25 0 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 83.9997 cm 0 0 m 0.75 0.751 l 0 1.5 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 84.7503 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.751 l 0.75 0.75 l h f Q /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 756 Tm (The Military-Industry Memorandum of Understanding on Loss and Damage Rul\ es \(MOU\) allows )Tj 39.437 0 Td (the carrier to exercise)Tj ET Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 742.5 Tm (its inspection rights within 75 days from the date of delivery or 45 day\ s of )Tj 29.911 0 Td (dispatch of the DD Form 1840R, whichever)Tj -29.911 -1.125 Td (is later. )Tj 3.193 0 Td (The Comptroller General has held that the )Tj 17.133 0 Td (carrier cannot avoid liability solely on the basis of no opportunity to)Tj -20.327 -1.125 Td (inspect. )Tj 3.333 0 Td (The carrier will not be )Tj 9.19 0 Td (held liable when it aggressively protects its rights to inspection withi\ n the time period)Tj -12.523 -1.125 Td (stated, the )Tj 4.304 0 Td (member discards broken articles within that time period and before the c\ arrier has the opportunity to )Tj 40.431 0 Td (inspect,)Tj -44.735 -1.125 Td (and the carrier has a substantial defense involving facts discoverable b\ y inspection. )Tj 33.517 0 Td (See)Tj ET 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 418.1992 687.75 cm 0 0 m 17.326 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 435.5254 688.5 Tm ( )Tj (National Forwarding Co., Inc.)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 438.5254 687.75 cm 0 0 m 144.639 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 583.1641 688.5 Tm (,)Tj -47.264 -1.125 Td (B-260769, Nov. 1, 1995, and )Tj (Stevens Worldwide Van Lines, Inc.)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 158.9922 674.25 cm 0 0 m 171.287 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 330.2793 675 Tm (, )Tj (B-251343, Apr. 19, 1993.)Tj -26.19 -2.125 Td (In the present case, Stevens conducted the inspection within the time pe\ riod stated in the MOU. )Tj 38.49 0 Td (The )Tj (shipper had)Tj -38.49 -1.125 Td (destroyed some articles prior to that inspection. )Tj 19.217 0 Td (The Army's administrative report states )Tj 16.037 0 Td (that the shipper's actions were)Tj -35.254 -1.125 Td (more the result of his failure to understand the carrier's rights rather\ )Tj 27.282 0 Td (than any deliberate attempt to deny those inspection)Tj -27.282 -1.125 Td (rights. )Tj (The Army suggests that most of the )Tj 17.304 0 Td (damaged items were a hazard, broken glass, which was reasonable for the)Tj -17.304 -1.125 Td (shipper to discard, )Tj 7.609 0 Td (especially after he was paid for them. )Tj 15.216 0 Td (In any case, the Army determined that the carrier suffered no)Tj -22.825 -1.125 Td (harm and is not due a refund because the damage was verified by the Gove\ rnment's two inspections )Tj 40.14 0 Td (and the shipper's)Tj -40.14 -1.125 Td (repair estimates. )Tj 6.803 0 Td (Stevens merely argues that it was denied the opportunity to )Tj 23.939 0 Td (inspect and does not discuss specific items)Tj -30.742 -1.125 Td (in the shipment. )Tj 6.666 0 Td (Stevens has not demonstrated that it )Tj 14.664 0 Td (would have a substantial defense which would overcome the )Tj 24.52 0 Td (prima)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 566.207 554.25 cm 0 0 m 27.99 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 541.5 Tm (facie)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 16 540.75 cm 0 0 m 23.309 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 39.3086 541.5 Tm ( case of liability if certain )Tj 10.496 0 Td (articles had been retained for inspection.)Tj -12.438 -2.125 Td (Stevens argues that its lower estimate should have been used by the Army\ . )Tj 30.104 0 Td (The Army used the )Tj 7.942 0 Td (shipper's estimate as the)Tj -38.046 -1.125 Td (measure of damages, determining that it was reasonable in comparison wit\ h )Tj 30.602 0 Td (local market repair prices in San Francisco.)Tj -30.602 -1.125 Td (Additionally, the Army determined that the carrier's )Tj 21.007 0 Td (estimates are not responsive since they do not cover all of the)Tj -21.007 -1.125 Td (damage claimed. )Tj 7.024 0 Td (The differences in )Tj 7.524 0 Td (costs between the carrier's estimates and the shipper's support the idea\ that the)Tj -14.548 -1.125 Td (carrier's estimates do )Tj 8.649 0 Td (not address all the damage. )Tj 11.107 0 Td (Stevens argues that its estimate is more responsive in some instances)Tj -19.756 -1.125 Td (than the shipper's. )Tj 7.457 0 Td (Stevens does not present evidence that the shipper's estimate is unreaso\ nable in )Tj 31.949 0 Td (the market place. )Tj 7.107 0 Td (A)Tj -46.513 -1.125 Td (carrier's lower repair estimate does not prove that the shipper's estima\ tes or the )Tj 31.766 0 Td (agency's calculation of the carrier's)Tj -31.766 -1.125 Td (liability was unreasonable. )Tj 10.941 0 Td (See)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 147.2969 420.75 cm 0 0 m 17.326 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 164.623 421.5 Tm ( )Tj (Interstate International, Inc)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 167.623 420.75 cm 0 0 m 130.271 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 297.8945 421.5 Tm (., )Tj (B-197911.6, May 25, 1989. )Tj (Our Office has ruled that we)Tj -23.491 -1.125 Td (will not question an agency's calculation )Tj 16.454 0 Td (of the value of the damages to items in the shipment of a service member\ 's)Tj -16.454 -1.125 Td (household goods unless )Tj (the carrier presents clear and convincing evidence that the agency acted\ unreasonably. )Tj 44.483 0 Td (See)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 549.8008 393.75 cm 0 0 m 17.326 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 381 Tm (DOHA )Tj 3.139 0 Td (Claims Case No. 96070206 \(September 5, 1996\). )Tj 19.942 0 Td (Steven's has not met this burden of proof.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf -1.314 -2.125 Td (Conclusion)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -21.767 -2.125 Td (We affirm the settlement.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (See partial dissenting opinion)Tj T* (Michael D. Hipple)Tj T* (Chairman, Claims Appeals Board)Tj T* (/s/ Christine M. Kopocis)Tj T* (Christine M. Kopocis)Tj T* (Member, Claims Appeals Board)Tj T* (/s/ Joyce N. Maguire)Tj T* (Joyce N. Maguire)Tj T* (Member, Claims Appeals Board)Tj 0 -2.75 TD (In Re:)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Stevens Worldwide Van Lines, Inc.)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 12 0 obj <> endobj 41 0 obj <> endobj 9 0 obj <> endobj 10 0 obj <> endobj 11 0 obj <> endobj 44 0 obj (file:///usr.osd.mil/Home/OSD/OGC/JosephLM/_MyComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Archived%20-%20HTML/96070233.html) endobj 43 0 obj <> endobj 45 0 obj <> endobj 42 0 obj [15 0 R/XYZ 0 56.0 null] endobj 4 0 obj <> endobj xref 0 46 0000000000 65535 f 0000000016 00000 n 0000000141 00000 n 0000003655 00000 n 0000115136 00000 n 0000003533 00000 n 0000003588 00000 n 0000003728 00000 n 0000003755 00000 n 0000114592 00000 n 0000114648 00000 n 0000114690 00000 n 0000114408 00000 n 0000004391 00000 n 0000107674 00000 n 0000101063 00000 n 0000100243 00000 n 0000003858 00000 n 0000003904 00000 n 0000003953 00000 n 0000004144 00000 n 0000004016 00000 n 0000004048 00000 n 0000004080 00000 n 0000004112 00000 n 0000004605 00000 n 0000004630 00000 n 0000011293 00000 n 0000011342 00000 n 0000011377 00000 n 0000011891 00000 n 0000099911 00000 n 0000045667 00000 n 0000045934 00000 n 0000012322 00000 n 0000012595 00000 n 0000013062 00000 n 0000046550 00000 n 0000100432 00000 n 0000101263 00000 n 0000107874 00000 n 0000114493 00000 n 0000115095 00000 n 0000114906 00000 n 0000114732 00000 n 0000115042 00000 n trailer <]>> startxref 115306 %%EOF