%PDF-1.6 % 1 0 obj <> endobj 2 0 obj <>stream 2021-06-11T15:38-04:00 2021-06-11T15:37:59-04:00 2021-06-11T15:38-04:00 Adobe Acrobat 17.0 application/pdf 98051109 uuid:7ca6b55b-e9c9-491f-8b7d-1d4e71b68804 uuid:7af972a7-16d3-4bc9-9f67-9a4416625eb9 Acrobat Web Capture 15.0 endstream endobj 5 0 obj <> endobj 6 0 obj <> endobj 3 0 obj <> endobj 7 0 obj <> endobj 8 0 obj <> endobj 16 0 obj <>>> endobj 17 0 obj <> endobj 18 0 obj <> endobj 20 0 obj [19 0 R 19 0 R] endobj 21 0 obj [19 0 R 19 0 R] endobj 22 0 obj [19 0 R 19 0 R] endobj 19 0 obj <><><><>]/P 17 0 R/Pg 13 0 R/S/Article>> endobj 13 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 0/Type/Page>> endobj 23 0 obj [29 0 R] endobj 24 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (98051109)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/98051109.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:38:00 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 759.7503 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.751 l 579 -0.751 l 579.749 0 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 758.9997 cm 0 0 m -0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 578.25 0 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 758.25 cm 0 0 m 0.75 0.75 l 0 1.5 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 758.9997 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 0.75 0.751 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 675.7497 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 579.749 0 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 675 cm 0 0 m -0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 578.25 0 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 674.2503 cm 0 0 m 0.75 0.75 l 0 1.499 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 675 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 0.75 0.75 l h f Q /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm (In Re:)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (American International Moving, Corp.)Tj T* (Claimant)Tj 0 -2.75 TD (DATE: May 29, 1998)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Claims Case No. 98051109)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 15.224 -2.125 Td (CLAIMS APPEALS BOARD DECISION)Tj -15.224 -2.125 Td (DIGEST)Tj /TT0 1 Tf T* (Where the record shows the existence of pre-existing damage, and lacks e\ vidence of greater or)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 38.094 0 Td (different damage, the)Tj -38.094 -1.125 Td (common carrier is not liable for damage in transit.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf T* (DECISION)Tj /TT0 1 Tf T* (American International Moving, Corp. \(American\), appeals the May 1, 19\ 98, Settlement Certificate)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 40.126 0 Td (of the Defense)Tj -40.126 -1.125 Td (Office of Hearings and Appeals \(DOHA\) in DOHA Claim No. 98031210, whic\ h)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (disallowed American's claim for a)Tj 0 -1.375 TD (refund of the $190 offset by the Air Force for transit loss and)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 24.688 0 Td (damage to the household goods of a service member.)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 567.1855 465.75 Tm (\(1\))Tj ET 0 0 0.933 RG 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 567.1855 465 cm 0 0 m 11.369 0 l h S Q BT 0 g /TT1 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 274.1992 435.75 Tm (Background)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -21.517 -2.125 Td (American picked up the shipment from a nontemporary storage \(NTS\) faci\ lity in California in April)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 40.239 0 Td (1994, and delivered)Tj -40.239 -1.125 Td (it to the service member in Alabama on August 29, 1994. )Tj 23.189 0 Td (On appeal, American)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 8.774 0 Td (continues to deny liability \($65\) for the)Tj -31.963 -1.125 Td (repair of a coffee table, Descriptive Inventory Item 10, and)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 23.823 0 Td (for 50 percent \($50 of the $100 total repair cost\) of the repair)Tj -23.823 -1.125 Td (of four doors of a wall unit, Items 44)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 14.997 0 Td (through 47.)Tj -14.997 -2.125 Td (At delivery, the service member and the carrier's representative noted o\ n the Joint Statement of)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 38.277 0 Td (Loss or Damage at)Tj -38.277 -1.125 Td (Delivery \(DD Form 1840\) that Descriptive Inventory Item 10, a coffee t\ able,)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 30.99 0 Td (was scratched. )Tj (The NTS contractor had)Tj -30.99 -1.125 Td (previously noted that the top, side and edges of the table)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 22.772 0 Td (were gouged and the top and legs were scratched. )Tj 20.103 0 Td (In the Notice)Tj -42.875 -1.125 Td (of Loss or Damage \(DD Form)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (1840R\), dispatched on October 26, 1994, the shipper noted scratches on \ the surface.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (The shipper and the carrier's representative also noted at delivery that\ there were deep scratches)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 38.523 0 Td (on the wall unit doors.)Tj -38.523 -1.125 Td (The Descriptive Inventory for Items 44 through 47, the doors involved, d\ id)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 30.271 0 Td (not note any pre-existing damage to the wall)Tj -30.271 -1.125 Td (unit doors.)Tj T* (On July 13, 1995, the repairer described the four wall unit doors as den\ ted and marred, and he)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 37.85 0 Td (described the coffee table)Tj -37.85 -1.125 Td (as "top surface badly scratched and dented.")Tj T* (On August 31, 1995, Air Force inspectors looked at the damaged items. )Tj 28.967 0 Td (They found a deep scratch)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 10.801 0 Td (on the edge of the)Tj -39.768 -1.125 Td (coffee table, but they found that the mark was new damage even though th\ e)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 30.517 0 Td (mark appeared to be pre-existing because)Tj -30.517 -1.125 Td (the member's spouse had attempted to color it to hide it. )Tj 22.62 0 Td (While the inventory had listed scratches and gouges on top, the)Tj -22.62 -1.125 Td (inspectors stated that they were)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 12.801 0 Td (unable to find such damage when they inspected it. )Tj 20.716 0 Td (The inspectors also noted that four)Tj -33.518 -1.125 Td (doors of the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (solid oak wall unit were scratched and marred.)Tj T* (American denies liability for the coffee table because the damage was pr\ e-existing damage \(PED\). )Tj 39.678 0 Td (American points to)Tj -39.678 -1.125 Td (the discrepancies in the damage descriptions between the Air Force inspe\ ctors)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 31.517 0 Td (and the repairer. )Tj 6.774 0 Td (American argues that)Tj -38.291 -1.125 Td (the repairer referred to dents while the inspectors found)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 22.463 0 Td (scratches. )Tj (American contends that the deep scratch the)Tj -22.463 -1.125 Td (inspectors found on the edge was the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 15.024 0 Td (gouged edge that existed when the member tendered the table to the NTS f\ acility.)Tj -15.024 -1.125 Td (With respect to)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 6.359 0 Td (the wall unit doors, American notes that only scratches were noted at de\ livery in 1994, but the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 37.906 0 Td (repairer)Tj ET q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 12 0 0 12 16 39.75 Tm (described the damage in 1995 as dented and marred. )Tj 21.214 0 Td (American did not conduct its own)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 13.831 0 Td (inspection of the damage.)Tj ET EMC Q endstream endobj 25 0 obj <> endobj 26 0 obj (WA'e1&!) endobj 27 0 obj <> endobj 28 0 obj <> endobj 32 0 obj <> endobj 33 0 obj <>stream H\j0 ~ COkgXrt1NzϊJ3$%CrTVvD~5NvxvV$)NO}Dyl;<#lal E ^aUks?أ m8qM-iʄn7!/svNXFGh􍽢0 a>qڥߍyJq&8eN[X2K9#3K|$>1A8#G$$;HrPYq1ja7En=y*vSM[>d|WFwe\0Q҇3ZzI],>^,įW. endstream endobj 34 0 obj <>stream H|y\TG5o^p fQѬ,d57FADTE#7x!(xⅨx1#!~4?~~ ^ >k*p\\a MIm;)"z# i7]Կ ǧJn;P}IvZ& |XO&Ab}BMHNc>n#M ل.9ftjl0 IK2kлJM a:5:<.UD_$)QS zyZDlE~倨|;0.~P!ICSR Qnj '};9L6}Y̝7AœEtY+W^ּn}icA[n۾cgѮ{+ );zxNWTs/\+W-kUסPurj )D%ҥLiT!=zi{-(y<]-O1;u}zgPbАAA?) SU+_*JrN(00̐iXjoxb`la\`\gҘm53SSۦS\&'ĨBը6Pjs]5BMR'Tu:O]nT{bT=VWԻaa:EņŇ Kil4O1 q?6{{{'vgMlյOkk!4GYYbOi1ji P)R+eN*Rzߑ14yҼO+_ JX |' @6{dba=Vɘ' SĽϨSFC b(G8NN~D<Π( <YCÆiH` A20yH0b8Fka$FFc,`a1A֓i!iH"-ɰrh-%t2ʥG+ȍɃR>e|q.|OiJmV:eGCd,,d&|9_+|-lk\7;|{|]KtUx|tuu:?4W=ss.}mA)ҤH`OLb! Ҥ $N1$t ,Җe:A'$StN:Cg,nȍ8-_Rȗ2?5Ы**ګjG^ث#usu.9 m=UOwt=CԳl~_s<=_/ "X/K#'#zY{\+c F5z^Qo\כުvC?;.[Y{gIܘ9S9939 p.q~tQt1vNX={Eb?|YCp(>p811 )r7܂[_|[qknsqb\Kq.Wڔ撹kp)3Wp𣑴 )w8ws=p**کq ZS@!4rC;-!R  =f_sb^rZC@BC4Bsr;>g\w(fZ@Kh v~ ?a ކ0 ށwa:~ 3`&A<cxxOxY<E UxoM]wbVbVc ̂2 P6:|,8/"DD$I&$"14xlAh"e$LS(h*M4fR6};;;;+Y9ͦ9ͥy4?:OW-xDgv8X_w6N]lwբbZi)-崂V*ZMkh-6D|B[i}I+wN{Eh7xrhtQ.#t(q*B*b*tNi*2:Ct*蜮kyH?y{fH?%LW.@ױJzmMW `1D\p9fr꺺:XPH:\GFQ:UN:RGhxMb@6VUmZmdf [ִlm[ֵ|:F7ձ:N{x{κvks>!k#ͳ=n l-ŶĞ'){ږ2{Ɩ۳Zm= _OԘ½9rr稓;D8!NS(e(gE8'΋⚸.nQ)nWDBOK dC,CP&F73/!=fH'Yu_T1ORU0EƩj#eQ̕L2S2Y0Y3ihلTȦ2Vx ̋'@=T11QřLLQ"D(kUiLiM3̤ꆺɜdڄ3mU{o7a޴m"UYjfYiVfYk֙fh6fjDB[>dG*d'05et$() 7Mj0؄E@u~PLP^??a0 X]0N )Z$:!A v uHcEY=l31 R؂ܻ0pɻw`2Cg^3ZjXAЀ P*{s+)CPq[Ra4L5o%~DxbVVb= Ŀ^hO{7H;tЌm4lc\(B4AcG˹L%MKu"X]T)PkΑ΃̐c/? U I`6|ϕ;V1=c~ސm Ϡ?qH*L7s#(c2D e"+#[^f÷8jG5xcag1A _Æ [rf7XQ~}K-p' !{e #3C9܄kXޙLX(ʙ[*Ogg癲긿Ota`}`p /k܇%xg#/E/搬';r,{.yxy=n3w>|y u㓠-wH/kGk/^ZQb8$01c1w*+WabŘ&>|*S$ZLV l;Uz Rl~wy?K[ư5 vC.R}9\+/}aw&sTXUq|3m[PW8װM[<~"x6qݝq}NG$bMB!_  $Np lH@٨V-ctT+V`]3I F56u ]7 mJ9 f[Ͽ>{OBBt?=+:VX01>FaT îb/طMji?^~]n '#-|g >gxZσGC $9s;i)AlY,2lTg*v ބK5}h L=/:'c{KXuv/cgk(qI)DSЦqgr~#]8F;Q%P_>#1WcH[v,L N:`h@ :/w/d\g`o"H-%d;κm|px{j̠0,&vQn',Bw:ʽ^X_ZQ3UD;pTރ9flfA| {pY>ϯv؊sA=ԓnQ4Aen;j~kQ(9}.y YClK^Na`|%`^&N'qMvWuxlX_ì=^k$;|aB-}&!eЏ5p.0ڠ=W 0cw@69x3ǁyN3w ϒHJvz@̤:{t>ʑ$KçZ.uB2ؓ_v(s >jac8/a p uz9K UmWP c ld=,W;;׋Fmv=dW+y2bp{[q@K[ha;Z9宲Rn]Rl,Y#oXxJT=)MM~ 5RE$gʨbJgJP %CSDĘ,% :ku!,I8A9JRbL)T"rAT`!BCJkP0RjrT@eܱ5$)$Uêū@DF5DT^Fܪ߈r +@w;GڜPՋFUӷP\8;bsWT&s%mL&q Kǭ7ݓLdn)j'N?_(mZ >e[ ]Sat,4 e1QiKȒ蒓]lP6:]Kgr`6cLS<5yÔeB"jL[J$8KAlU ")Eh|s y㙔 - d*Ԑ? ^:"|}:~@HDCA ڶ+P$!FDlMq] TM4qF&9v38ə1=S?`/5?ؽy~F#!ƔԄmf`y~oRK" E' bt.)a IRY7 zPdy#FN!b\RM1isR6wW=6/Po ¬6u(i/HQWRJW67- ᝦF鏥&= wI6NID &-[/;{yl񲺥Kj<55 ôKm+V!F>(!V֋v-v*7nwa+?7sBeqIAڸ2skR H{5@y7\9u{w?w}s|?C.)dt*aqu+4-iBՆR`R!V֩nlCu 6-Xgig{'[=`|E+~Й߲fͷ;J!Ug R#gi-0U{ >p`B{c?ƿv,ܠsvN=W1 0¿FMo51 } j*5Au9*bkp)aUi7?)'4Opt;@ :O7۵:O; 3o }6*v§X+C> Uo,P^6+BS4N g4 k7k&fI CXq-L"H7I*gڜj:. [s}|u'~_9s*4~'%(`%:uy։ *,ζK5F^)@!WP`Q0PX8]L5qd;o$i$e$e%wq9# 8Ġ ,I ݖoNBT\Y u%]^H@uV#U6ZaE]5ds8 'yu&R V@C1 -kEW&4MgP Z<G ts,C]9h+ͷ{kF!}jS_}`MmamaOeߏ;<3͇_>[h2oѸNK=IǮ=7=_xaf{{|e 0ܓ$CJE|zez03˚o:L7Ftz֫$+FOk {jɐ$Fdan' '325'Q Wjݛ\ >}gjbWvx葕}(ckMAmW6g –ic9[}ʶe;O*xc:8]t,۝[B!;,7M1o(|<%EIGTB pJ*CB ,3&l0d[Y"U/(QQ,UaF+ w M#MTϰB/h]~p/_n]/jU}sL;^b􉞖+@Vӕ_v]2k96.ܜ;oݧA d-"Y:9d=B@D\eAaoDNV!\X u$$5RdZ% ̼UǻƎOWVnysGf.cjxq <¦=JKz\K*Eaf֦<+qX `-گ#` ?ŧ'0kźLO@ds Vxjp+wߗoU*dž6Y#cY;@;Uy7wΝw>络;!k@=c@$ZIGNJ@h;i`UPNMhB+@&4uEb?#q{mӁ4[y}Ȋ<40q싿'm }?CT x )C^4cQ;IBH!7]XfWp?4.5O1ѥԼϞTE֬BCBj^ϒ+;xRQ65h)U:e ~Zwޑ0T-,f{OKAjЀ @cB^ ʎ+x;innrLdAeVOݕn+K/63Z$:!옸g9/M. 1M1k77*Q<N in[U]vQIэFI^1Ϫ1U1z</4Z?3}1b=vUJ%tV+ Gw-VRaXhqTKG]F 08B'm+GFnmw'Ϡ3ISs&3&Ffd7_^s:NIEtjC9{Cxm7߆w`ecL@Π >+F>bNRܺuVIl_Zs-|,iuF{g&<$Yǯ :19 QnoqU&_S7GE",*M|S),ψSK-%\^J tӷ0]Q|ǼQ1r}wU|'NsHDVGTF#CIԫ[^fECC9"yO`mێ-v`z4qBB p,^LQϗݍ㼩B)JEeI&n/pN1Pnl gDL$;an,y-b`9Mgn*O߶H$)Otf韰蕿胫S"~|e<$5ӝ0unS)7bYe tx$N~.;#ϯ 8˳]vzcsǪ/^`@Өd,0B$FE6BNȰxjH#zQUZӬB]QI-;<;@c XlAO XٷѹͱVW~Oȡspj/=AP5$ yH_|Eȅܼw;rbC!}q){J;t/zOvlL=f("=jUz0W bouWtbFэǶh nl$dRNzaXd3$Xv;60꘱lqx %*ҥRu*ZSKHTp iᴔ!9ye8jdآe 5-Y&.$AU s z;7?1;.TW/J-_΋# I_ztnLq]Vwq&qY|:5)X/_(g?O7_h5WHHLp=55%p X|5yi8F;Q,ss[iqLzZ~ JS$UƼ sl1&­3hWO5D" Z,KZVcQDju<&󗭲5NY[g7=[̯8?* Sk;6IBO,PќDoz@{NTS; LZdxPXs'>ғ_W%.4[ؾ}}t^n$&~O\ڢV#M.{~'%7]dҶKY͵Gn#\nحƑ>}mIЩ n]mM\gxϮݕuY]weZɲJ._1I\.mJ`[-6\HR1M')Pfi=Cdh4 a ڋ|7H!!lg::`<ǂ8cQ:U} \{# CXwoHb}( &Ax#~e211Ld Yܧ!kKsSy2u|!Qz/O%Uz(v,SE&.g ZU]7=g;+jU;%b=N^BOf K +S4E b\#(˧2aC{rCn\6N QS[)Nej?5A@[6j"NQ^NJxvIi As<&;l]M,˧;fV᾿~t)-C) ]gV<5C @^C e=eh58y 0S4Ž$l3r|>xW/P+ ZnE$Q vWzm0Bv 4Ju~iBY Uf$|T:!yƠ^,9ST .7Ra :wcw{[Ξ51Q$;j*YTćpVTYPhLQڀS*@?O:9E& \ݞX%ФBL~0!3.vYAV3\q^6"(f::O u&abԍ+R=x@ANFw2 LFUV  "zO("vqD|]$⌈qyu66t Pp<' Z/5Șn)i/b*|*v^Efȼ((b`y: @ϲMQU\DuG6A0%x3-&3.nʠZWd؆ݧ^Y잍jj*u}'m[2P(gMa79fMV n學5ɱ=b\!3 +uդTZ9ǂY!Zcܙ\g;33a,a5rTR@KHB[ jS@-5 RDjÏGa 5#IJڼT+%UQ+Bæ16uνg}I6yӷ묡Og@Sꓰo62%(- !$XCif61iQA+ ^ ڔYry;w1ƗZ\mLeMXag3o\b_>f?cpF,LӴr;bOǞꙈ"\|9;/oa9d/IkUj"]Ph0b j,vŽpU60h6:Y0c3 lFekZN%XFDH"4U۰-3B8VaelaY& xNm%bY~\˩KZB-i0 ~NۥOm+|{oV2@ NU#(2ΜHbd{vY34V{J 1H5jURX+Luz_#)0#hI9t#-Ϗ.|G6[) ) ϧH!P:p)gF 0>ơNsZD#A=0ɞUDՕۅ DA)Q sׇ֛ ɲ,A9 9#FlN ycl`ې,+giʶXV!e)~,гY]w/x!bQ^a]WֶeTV6 7VհhZƩ)W6ݪ{\")٨:[SzB=ġ~YzE C[W\P4S-qTjz f:$KK!q*Ha%aE򄗈KhG콕Hcjֳo?"\y9Ûݨ'd p߃ VQnI(?(_@:sFn5,c꽲pN'VL@j ۪u\Pڐ 6d6!kVd\_Wi1LUе $7~QΦ9D.sVw8VUV jBVVU\U+Kִx( UaqKTD/*+ k D"94ISY#!WNdPf—Q񇨧]K)L߽y> ;‹UvS@!LWz IEMn{\%'Aew!#Ć@ET+䟂rUhW+ ǜms}!om/DC$ yj-0"lnK}4;3?ZW Cpd BPQ@ğyl^y|\_֫ {뽗Q/=]@PHPEJik5N-Lc+[uj\cvŭ]Z54-ӥt*F[Śe9V쒇|~y4LC7 Bq1_͐`> q)(N Y=A=)= ^_ ޸}@itDRmi4Yl)9G?f3ē[< +n|1k}ٵKKhAk99x%oD69BI f©㕼卻Zg%fesJ~VWV3m;/u͛6F;=xzך 3#{D') :;#eusV6@ 1ֺ"&joP0Q#M5}J曙3MπW͉&,&SPK~by.#မ̬pXG dBDIMM1Ȉ8%e@ d11111119g(Co3T2jp3JDc:TBn>-7d%?ge|1Z$ ece˳kl9N6? nEM)渂JVmyATڹ,̪MmY(D!}M^R|'q y7B6'{p6=/vI ʞ_3xx^ds^EZ5M蟁haNDyy/N@# |HȎba_`{dbq[!ߓygiAylgZE$Gώc{sY}< c0"e_e[1u(hqg="Akb)kGy?裷QG H0罞>eCoCâO}-6x cfď !ZO>NL)ƻV -Rz۔㞇OH.S" _RALEQ)/(kUtg*4b/Wln[0\ؒdgĵ)¹3ܘvO\j}6:y]a'pNf?^gq|18W~(w˸2bY@P9qqpSgm%&n|^c=vXb9UD'eTSQڝy\Fn̟F αF7Oc?><%k>Z{4y16 P؁Xu]{jdޜKOj+jG)?C:z7Vt:{:߽ WPEldAH=gx-5URr?`}EvnnkxkcS+ȢG:ZR~ֺzz ^i\Y` CvSW0#|?XwP'xl4!4j7Q1:jy诗 )_jg|<^P6:; }_۬ ZTp5lva<|_Aگo"ƿ{Hu%U?JlOڛngs>-vЉ!<L3R\p?OK[x?>Jz껴.c}돇:'QC-N2?@⻈eI4`^Koż!m^OQHk&_Ysh_/.TU m*:GZwd06<'oCl~w;}>nǿ}/p/xg6u.&v6 ov|ϋ ]hkЪ8;<㷈&rYa]OUԭŽǞ=-Z]:ڭ_Fd{<_]z[7{NaoFff9?<}AU4Q}BH+O3!N^Ӿ5oϺD+֬7wi,'ZM9@ujYϪ56t{UWd:|v/GbkL zZ{26/{:m-V4jBsgbg؝."ƶiidsȩuE1\K*%Orrt~esec[Ҹhܞ=r\w7+moq]qZrEz7;w' tm۝WCΛ-'o 0٢ 9= 1K> S|L*~DS&υz՘8GfvʠSbme˜s|ߪ>753ͷThaI[sdgD3BZw(wܙ\, j^Z[B_ a˓w6?]f7d/l <_7H vZ! |`ꄺ}zAhrj8_<$Jm0=:М7m}dLf]K) 2BjY#=ԡgI)wlVCeA_'}R}Z˫&'g/\jTqM[ibcؐ?.`r%s\ٺӬU&r6׿~6j^kjYȚr59;Xķv:Şl*6˚h(\`<,|C-\/4눾BV?_oș2d7>~Qn_Lf~yFGH?|z%wO?k+ d)c3c| ,~r)c4V3aL6beɼ4'uHRwr.d#*=2&X Eׇ{i2xQz˰WX}(;xy4<}VJbcQ=gF7FY& I\%%Em+sx]dU\nht1>}Vš^8wՎCV(Ԯ+P_)Qh8ԗ_mkOB<0cZ >m繣.^݆<_· ӆ`BD۶:SٿFyTc`L4>m}< n{?HDŽ+lv'#CWF{Ћ>w)&jXg=S=mKGmglnXz785NG9M}}vgOK2rimtG+6Uyճ]2.9{,f)$SR7^c3LSӿd#P (ְ zN|m{3,k\;=wٹL\~e:uU=W6R}v>X=Üqyz6ձ{'XPmMk߰IjխB59˝f]ݪu=; ژnolqA: ʳOqktF}~˺䢶=DXl-HÕ'? 5vP K% .J|VHI/g.HNj仴$G? Ջqxgݭ[툾wg;~O]>n|˯ջD5ɍ|x&V,w;6A[koUM"nb~ĀG˭G&B ]q/E*4hR|_,zj'8T/6xWG] Kf`oZvYnگ#x 6CxCg zܖ!XT_01B`=z95}FUɩ[YZߝ2՟~DF1Ɩ8U"[st %0.n^%,~' :뱒]0 x@m2-w}oY8aրLx 3Öa=(+ &a(-YK! $ "% !%Q0"PHAs~RfʪL7}O&t2sZ=`5P? Q/c 4q@hĸ=гMtJXZH>}莕zYr6={&vq6i'*mM,Ҹ-]eeF[iHٜA20TPw>-1>^.y^q u=_* A'6fu^+v7 =J:g;Ҏr;e5V$]4 i9W}ݯ%m{"RAG[j9i8XAwygwWS ()wHMbx.N;N"e_iJ%}߳$>yĮ) +#ZZu5nUM:1w%_5~5&.B_lC5GXdʷ%l˒q:L$alF'c?-Ϸ'Ci;1Ucg°:P=#U!&/:00e[" Ү:>C)V >)%wci/!TܭW2n\"z_+M~/%1_Gs=O;qzNK/lXRO9޹(P6PEy39Vi~@ V86(g~siZF-Tc ÕK7V]Moar8%ʅ m矐+FF*J%0|B%t-1U)9sP*/좔:."]XQ""g~>=Lml5pK=8|:>:CJ/9nwnRA{Qr sB%Gf^Cܠ}ߖR?&/NIB|zS6mZ]+ s2I9i4;yH6t.a"\ 7sܾ^s]ka26;/D=-Xtߝ ~~sYoFzS]Uikk|tߗ&߫z]$r3qG399XD܊S;N_Y?h}:wƌ~YALy/P.1;e"t%,,7IzAאPݴ>-m-^$]*j 띗v ˡ4QPh*b.Iʠ46Y54{j3Q@o4Xֈ4Hz;koZe4vBVWwT;lu&lF3:/zsp])EU)`$5?  X6}io #%Hܐ"#;qx]%J}?M6leɎE0whK13;U5uI~2|hÒǝ}n rqsFM^{&ӑ YwE2"o8+YoRm<-C=ou!q,ZwwiV0x^<2[ %G< s ޕ9~ ?Bߗd_G|<?:L29yh}ۃ~S}4V* gU%+8޿b Ӥ= ?_- jrKx}nOe_|sac;K7^ROÃu!ba}n ml%'gN#c/2O{;.b3JfF$_iId_GfqRI)W' S9tg4(>i> ʓ"R;aJ+[1ih,I>HS~ݾwI'.4\F*{lVn'9Li84?ߓ6/蛾V5QUQ;5VwgͿc~--м7{X]4H=.}bYϜ`{Ԏ]$$stp'&Gb+s䂚#&/m[)EЄmnhdg7ZIC"S E ~Ƕuq{m&}>[_γݑA4mNj9Mcv2V!DUIDM0ĠL!FP66=@1suSB css~q׾kPr~zlAXQ`?UK it7oG3'^lؠ}~8YE~;ݹC7%ط=>jv,Yw必{WY>#C`xO$w*x7cծ$U{Aoyk1:`XgoDe45d1t=k.I6exD"z ̡lƙj (*:=3[87]=B`ݩY=h3 h{+DEGu{]T|C)p/P6CLK[I13+Ikw9A?qz.`Z·{mڋw,yk?cIu\F{4_Ulg cqwۓ|'Z6(l>^8swnGDe PؗboΪ^A~d-Y{rԈu@?="x@F&Cy'p/` cY nW{!š_c55O̲AH407)b=pV*| /ψ8ر~{u%d3q O{Rʬs-B6k/#؉ퟗiY@9 zwZŚoؿD{Q쟇§$cvAn}()~V#:^ƵZ;wZG/;'34u~om#Tɕ;p_A/M4c~d^{b_Q]u<6f7^%.冐ݽJM9& @NmɈc$3-4qt| q(6tԙo2s;{%s |ȿ@5\eD{Ep"HYu4M4[{lcWe֓^B~` 6tP Nd_>;!8O4e[HxpANTIqUa}Qiy[9XJi^l\{ga9;n؁uhO6v}< jZnFÝW[rO؛2e$%JtR7~V[ ? D! zZ?i* ? S!c 4,t80M㑀 QM\YCE|/;K3hu~mS ]m_ж*C2Wo1 &=5F ^(͘q&D&dT&A e PL A\X+NEIbt)%n~JCi"94#W}?OHS^2u= :!#U>q^$aOd(*BLVdO.Mu84EL2ecv"#ݼɤZ*H f'HԽAŒf5d1iAW2UZ##XcZ+#'rgX ! ((3 ZZ,S@e'*Gb:i*W~qIJG,$azqߏgkT"s/ɝn38cp-yS\K/L(2ssqEE6X "Lj8Er@Y!^T߂55#8 _J~CY,r:NdN$lNnfª c*۔i˔QF [RĚgj+r͙5Mg˶AJoMϓ̝--ܴ5S_ij_q}=GIk[ΨG2!Bϕ)^v2+q_dƏ1v]cŽS*|iK[ty{&̲-mCl?ۻqS6Dw6z>HRdl;)DFQ8EtP4kּ",mТh" h)`?1f~-[d0"J2 C0M#ͯkl#$G4ǿi4 #"ֿK %rdrPRژL ␀CUv)Q(~:#dq-Y޽W-b'/9r~<$i3{< =5hL@3OwtCmY]y؋7g{͂I;՞)6bm 5pBp@\ q%uqha͜F}g-F+rꇏ]yu:-1dڔ vM'C%[}J%d2& oQHQpƜY IZB FMʥw @2a1th3EO-\k[wBn%j%7-X/e_.E *K?[v@TxJni幩l : TB++0)W0T^WK endstream endobj 30 0 obj <> endobj 31 0 obj <>stream H\͊@}݋&jݺ`k7ƙI$qO&9!)ǑJ}7{Cܩ-5ʵ]3}\ͥ2/>ܯSPT+)æ(6?_ã+q/­׮C_k}=|OyͿ'~Vfhuj.bw<O: /y,̂2+133 yc!1!3gp%6Npz:=N7WלAhAhAhAhAh PСCA ;ta@s9h0́s9  ~(g)f)g)f)g)f)g)f)g)f)g)f)QGяҠ0(;Qta'N(:1vbh6fh6fh6fh6fh6i>a3~:lp{9vxϷ8.§+Ej endstream endobj 35 0 obj <>stream H|y\TG5o^p "f# 1YbPkv5ՍQpJE#V<[BTD[Wq?LzI>U`<$Du޼UP#&LRt{ P,fD.S$%h5 qt|EC{KGNKq^@aյ^,pmLJeeDŽIhI DIR7P 4Xo7y=[}ᩮPĂRaq);Z͞%&HһzyZDkIhXFD3#N]; BDu&: r\b\in~@'fTO(FƽpJZuzO/o~5kS^`h2a jԸIӷ5oѲUw -öEk㎝KOE}=y/zW}1qJ4$9eߌ9jo;.m'0iӦϘ5k/XK.[bkZ֭߰Qڴ9wmwܵ{}nrss55M4e֙5f6́zfm фT[S:j5TmFx5]NS+MvuzPWz/,",2}XaMӚ5ko1Y&[r-{,qApGcQ"yG*WV:C4geo*GI[+JQ)]p!J(KYr(}~S! FgJŨtV8S+r]y0oL5fs'MY՜j NuUc_q2 jNYjStUpS\XԿձY̖)[NprmHGG'Dž*#^qit8G8ǻ9n'B򇯯sזYc4py8=*Ҋ3|Á'qi=kk}>voa.%Ǝ7;;7.._Y u{n-'CmlmmֶF6-FV{zؚgzºƺj5[M; kn\ "J0hF+DXH{E/;x?[/@yBE)|*lryTeZ=;׻@w>|X'd,5߿:l5 RMȭKV!?H}{Rj!C@9x11H'X + P1q8(,~B<Ρ<,\y\@<SA$$brH0 7H}Ʒ+qZOC<>ʦ!$Á Z@ i-F%Ĥ#=\2ZN9<ȓțV*KZMkh-Yh 6fʥ-vځ_q2(v.M{h/P Gɗ&&~Z@ RmF(:J(` R]G)S2P0nBF2N):Mt,S*jH 9:O"SCzQc]x:ųx6/Cy!/Z^Kx)/+x%ռײEx=o7s.o᭼ީM&.{x/|!|1>| $\gr1pB[uj]2d!3de=dOًy2_|6|o|o'!eBW_秫Nsy?yUq{=}=r]KY , AMLb!ҤwP@@ `8Dz,ԭ,L&| `!,ŰRXaUZ?Jy=oZ f`^4noͼ?᭼M1_kDnA"bxWBX,c"b%>_>0G sn8%qE(n q]TBT')Ο:~9ZPAD#@BY,˧e)/]ewSX<'2(_"_NoɷԘ͐b3[ΕH. J5r(7mr#"&_ʽ6/â<*O3\^%.+=Y%dJ+VV5RUUP*Ke*OfXPD;ZUOTIU7]P=U/[Q}U?_ P 5X QC05\P#ճQx?,FqjzYM=Ǔyȋ4/Bk{.^7FycK$Ujfl3,02ʬ3Flfhn;n~io>? L AR06aNÒ]tL!v ;ak-{K;{a{q{žS=c2{Ζh/jMO2Sw.8NKu\K빾k\n#7tqCs9ZVGk:So7Mp$7m⦸nfnM\7w B|>Y.訊, [^ԭ MBȾ/)2"da !l:"#$@!egX$HH d!APq9Bx<>߫յ%Qq)*}P(˰"8a?3V9,RXBEP@1Kqr,rf]2:K H/P'8'3v7 un"Ǩ;L=Oԓ^^ԛP_zQJdJT@i !FC)sQ 4Fhz^? 9\#eF=@iOdBSiM؅2i&͢lPͥyMi-<<JO-1- -ͼ ޴ՒKqnET{j<:[71:)ך>rhjʥ5Gki}F)>/hmU6崅6NvnT@{+L_G-:HEt:J8TL%TJ42*t* (Q.}G$X[y5I ;F,`/{KL^8•G%Z_BL(,RC{{:9-0nf\j. e^G?d]}V8#uh 3al]=g?WSDߞ_\^PrޥB8jY膃p(9c#6r](;Y)puQy{j y yj|wCT` Q?Xt}Y9w\3n{{ |8:d^cKp:WW w&Gɥ2O5i*HXz'Ykf_a +_8&)i `xɅ-P. {=}Ÿ{˰O9ItdsSĻb1+b%ɷd$d \.YIv+}}|5zriQO/{w{f!t ÑXP*Vͻc2k 2X#p4k,l #\'k=m~ECxuOs7~Fq\7wƘp/=3w)gbN>a0] Ȟ TCI{*"Fk'jQDTi3-E %iTIV%j"J7{aWj+yng̼y{Jhs/5|v6ފG󃸡S4Q*axryke*Wj^ݮV著k ֏ 5_ys>7O/ݢ0+4ah5E2 +{gZ*sAy%?SglrG#䲗n}v'T1߯$O.]RKCGD S!'Nk .u>1 za2U4sλa˕ P1Mv^۬.:KGQG=zFf1)r{y4@G,KzE*wt ugy}}p@ޮ۶7ݷ6n{WgW],_tIUx(/\+ͽsN`Jf(4UጢI#ejX-a# Dz:P5c wظJGP{*n!!hX醻i}>*: k㝒Y;epLJdl:[$=޵t0J>Čbx|J_b_8)ɮԒ>X\*?u:z0Dž1gb58PH^p.N]D:uG)^%CR2pۀQ(*f&crof4tzұ϶} -{,O 5d@Z;MO SbnTxP(,DΥ}EP`؍U rM9knߓEµS)8 VxS{O'e)v97eSLt3A~8=YRI [b[2DWf/ƨ$n'T5ؑli4Dvs3b1(aJt P-"?8'xTCxpw+1<._[(N5OOpqFZHs~?UhN. ?_Hο.(;|O|{}[`^ SMB(HJ0䏊4II XD ETPTEHVSrZGiofgV3<͹$!DP]KX8 G1C!-JʆC@vzV Nh"+.x@mP"lG z/. .Qy#ѨqgXuVJ@S!V~ ە·[=jj)hO)vĒ_}',l-d !E#D" *%U:b1hJ&OHQ% }H:T.ӍةƎF:G%k8^DXh:Nƺ|f9(4%oH4y  }1_][W {<Lum4/é$oInpr0, XciSڈdr\C:LPYI$ QG8nm޷oEfl>tܷew(Nf'eu fsʋx ἈLYK8n0Rt"٬G~AHiFzK\OcG#Mp bzvH bYLq~#}&?Seٜ92/_;35]Κ]sNszćR@S/U˗S^R))ll冐>lJ F!;QZj5|Qk~Ljca`V]@H̝ 1ye2$i#}2Q6}"/|mç'10"KɩUa`I"~>9 vZCTvbaWW?帶,)aB2C`RAJbGp$VU飱D*=JA1wmDju! mdE`Q  pAtJfOєf3 1` eKEXZ?%E1+bNb lKfA%(J8;42s@RfY9K:o?!Tџ:y7"~3dΕshZ~.5CM ('Oy̘N39| wW'v2TV.R,Y-%B#M;tsM F4[]#f?&]fIDjupҢ^EīL>>m Z'ٶ9`qt-_fQ5eWΓFX S8uuhgȸVr>ڸ/ c3翗y>fqԂA.[`&2 [tnrJA0T>UUq1JE9VjK\EdEH&.YNʚɱb@D'P&1.tUgcB;錝Q VQ+Nh8V( TʕfS6'FuԶ uƽ _N Tps?ڻk.4=?83z|Ol[5{_=56my}kT:iSkl g,98auԫԙWlJ#A9B[?Sp!M%jc:{ko:ر8q N]rÀAR4!} THFd0A&`CGNhK':j MPhν mEW7}y Тn4$[y 逑?.$v(xƐz]׿nDe/Y>9O{ ktw8IӌeI|Lcu,m-ZZBKn:mGuܐQpQ.t8Qh,C)u~΁UaS /,ڟgzT1jUUI[nZ1rь!8I=gNXzPErmDM&-ǞO92667m~#ö?iĴ- l5b^0M2"ewhS܅7Bf)TZncHnʡoJ2Ԓ![Se1N]2:3-## %pU5%wO+]EXWS֎a=5C^TF!6%9J2 6X mCpxau@%hY`9zl&k#}v5~HG= 'oMia4QV3",y[WFH54\1XgH'jgztQ޽ns{+sBl|0?qn,hOZjѶPt2FcAI/BF!tenC<%%E%Ȝ@AQ%bTJ0ko'\Vy$@ Lx8lv=\p'§#l(p¡cwQdntkqҮ їwɟگzui*KReuKj'-hV[Ç7vԭ/OacM=3{|m!ߤ%>GO^#!q7??DfE"N4I!p߾BsXf+J2%05[JOuȽpPLK9ьlSB7%RcwvkZ8zm@cؙv-?/Z TBfy(XOaA8ld#gIy}sL4XO/p='::~9V]i4:D>t_$G#RJԍgZJ5K,MEee ˴D[b"1oHWb\,],8ϢO# SY^--,xI1, D e` q]Fh>zV) }UUJ|>*tcͬ%`(M.9/;Sѥ֗pXZ2wcvW\K7@*(&ZL4?li}ʆ鮴=e77VήvmtI|?=$|2eɄ@(!`b0cEqLyb7mhZT4PLm2dǴ@g1ԝ:ӖƦߝDz=fsh$kJ?xfdmAq0ȹznO1]%Evv83IGS3C ^i7  :r]^i;ccwwtp,( %].,rp(H=V (nd  yXI#b\Q4eSlZG '$`S3"i+h|@!JF[x҈D#ԨG]&se4r htn; nG76Mΐ,\N"85TGг*,cayX*˜\5$ HH֖%qČcQg$mf%H͂(Ҩ5T_%'0fZ eTY**C0T! Qa\` nH?t9(`u/۳Oox!BQ7\/TrSCr C'Y-Ax>*`-fH(%-єH'T"x^( TşIMoq Bu9:|cʲVDqBa}xnAAK(ҔkF1ۼpѕ_':o\q[P_ -˲C8 a Y H-r:ϰVACHf)/[~4;ڞ-[Rkלx%ZF\I`tۑU[vs/e~s 5(1=ڲ7t5"n\%ʿUݸG/`c;>Z+~Oc=lx0AzQZte~WE0b- Ul2rcܶ۟vۃƤ}[ ?PTZ_4Һ VdW l%;>w;wΉM.&yt4JaM[*CcSG **Ge,u XZUӠR'T(F #Ж;~_>?2Gc]Tvp?P w&|Noru/x'|GI"E+z$Vy߬p0YS&yR񑤢Dda Y}۝'uuukXpve͞K]N Jl4UIjNP$1U[X"ay@@ [xv)m)n:c,{އοVuJZ&.J.fy+Iʁ|@a|HɞdvC< E%whq<%փ RxY̭+ GP^^@5ߐVYm\OPΡ7 ,:|m0MNڴDP($jґ[M`R hJEY l#X(/Üma CU ")3X2}{(̳W#/ $,sELD s5L!t$SY.-Zfx,Z&vZ mxc+F#?{skɏN=׽qpLGHqe=?c,ԆI#»Mwp妣½I7wD͊oRVIR^nr;=3 Kx+@yd1j5L1%8'I SDzD3!SL^͟CԒqݤL)K@+,I^̣fs j |x_0C(Vb-NwVff}_r5ІT$.m&0!g3 q_O\ChD!I'D/ʔύ҉ŮΚ0Q">/Ʈ=rh:bvyU~w֑ʾmQ_:]}j ^';_Z=zJ݃G}G'`DŽF)^CN2R}x;| :Go k?+ _L EC!K֩;!5PBFuyA-y['>aM5vUhV 4 >tu(>vX2y!?,*&{G%̫@j >  w̐EZZMO7Ilz!DcԀMOkDYKȈ뇴+GH5Wd̼Ho~Xz꧷0UIg>^;sY,ˆcGY`Wg>A$L,OfЀklcG]83β*1C̨eJ :JKe(@C,lG6e3dyI䑰t] [bWF .Bwi)%M9ZKHtwfT6FPØPnCj:숏aF\-Tf Cp*9h>R jU; 6r8H iQ\Kr,kb/E&>M6&a;\Y{|Sⵦ8bp!FgTMN&9J`x0<{ab%LH@W~.Z;ɹZj_%}@$ձZ20O mw>;N|%>9Kr1K4^*hcVMAF"Ni@'6-VmďIU*V& 5 Q:X}_;۴w>Gy+r>92wW8Qd]Ⱦ}] wEx{GV]Ug5~ =w~ %W= 7B^ɸTDELSz"K sa3$8M2S$nl8AL8j̺ݚms!ŷH QF$#I/vRF: ﳃeSpmrQ_S@v3˕HY_'pD 8&pz2bX (D"@pk4RM7E! xR e)&+|yJ{͕?GCivc'WwlOiCHcN1.pwp4՞Ʋ"GqvUݷnVPND}^A cjT}%e )HwsE1+ /j1?c,&#Xh6!L2@h5ą82y5cIHjI #?~9y0~b2_Z&3גvdZς{TuGƷd!3fmߧ\Mz M678-dP 6jsؠ72E8 ^8(A0 fE04C7lM-FES7TAOh' &zOSR7 |.*j1cKQ5%mpiGw.Q4Z11{wd?"ߘ*SԠe\87im/m,خZ PYzN"GN؀U V6~d(I{]H`_j~=!e- oKǓO^ E5*"u]gW>sy=|m^/}z§;龨+k* ESCT' D1.΢hV~gWydcN/xm ]>/鬥;uvQc2-0K>`>SӘ#9'AFkkAd~k#/Oe7ed}i&]qlTLUqB;ZvH55+ tL72)r[#l0 pNGӢ_ ,nщnk=Ǽ_eqSʿ;a*eոݼ;.OKW-'hћFqyybjvU;OP}L=yzZ:#jӓC !j-o5^B+#}ӓQ=ME"ݕb:r[ܚA&վtV°k8<Z+DJp.x?#)q^Z]xG +a7v|93GG>2׼1qcwȻ{y~nB}U~3pbyu=~\Eпkf==0O/;z1`ʱʦV’Ű)-*n$@ 3HX^V~Qݤ9FQSӺQT.S]$4MM{:Ɛ0l$[vزlb16^DTIXJz8-z\) өO)Ja_6'YVq j.c" :+h d м P`C!6*Cޅ  sO ɍe,m<&<B/ᢐ[u˻lx*35={ōnbDvSCB[<)g/¥:pC:%1#c8l;'ݱYF m!KKZ  @6Qi&ƪ@+$ 6* USGQt C 8{ׄB,y~vGeLPS!m6NIb]hө@ 6#SԘHoL4]scUp&[jl̉=_2sٷsL>/~40?.{;IJr\nrEbJ+j{@x"5](&3&yY fVҠd,›vX;U1 {J U_ONDu8Ts WDѐJCWVs\@b8$3PŮ\] '޺E#(%RK2B,(xXt0z87]{#{怅fO6,dG^ݳL;Vݰ/5I3-GD>spSRG X{dp#֤Fh/3 ݧCE7D se{dRBYWE)A(n$q' ctQPrE(Ȳ b94:yaD*H@U@U)UFZ9Al9 fS3xhxw`[nY,&Zˢ6oN$7jp2~޿1x&MިAe0T K^ 1$qvV$k Ch20t ""꣈H ( ^)yGtVBɱNVK^M xOxI[)D7' ӄKB- W8]룏eY(F'?.X V2D)b%cc ^=B]THRN1( "Uh=-n g ~N0Fxt&#9IXR t;t`8sX1 '`DƋC 1* R'*OCX'¢3Yt0wIJ2SOvjc"&uE^كIL% B5e˓O%יio!i]kRu(]..%/nj)N9ܔ (%ף(g©btQG? ;DBVZ EsMȄy?7ϚLά&ăqvnYs6 +V~Gޛ⮎y'?vdR#ud@Ғ*ShJd0q%ڀ5wvP E[mtt1B/:x8: (PFOLcjhb_3'Ѩ HTU58q>8 ;{aF#M_ w[Ÿa[8Y>ڇ^rbk(I\3)Ԉ;ؼ dZ8+ssY-,#:9Oa-^~\9m9>ڋ#p$~*fv2k;ᇱɗc`EdFDa1Ep1lVǞʹ2(@ŭGEգ%\ >!vkϤ_)$/s{OSXbV:Ƶl amFLLF\kg=݈i@JQr?h*`p~M]eͮq߸+;W[N:a%l{B;)z)"SR[݂ tI6P#L [m*@^[^:58yA;Dvmٺun=pPm6=vl*`Z5P//!_G"2l0Sgh8QgU sfgRgʊaCH-FZB. \҇,ϳxz bPs4Gh{\{=J{ :P(_14+,VhSM׀b- ,j9 ,#Gݙ*{~I$` ?&Kx*I:՜JYrCfW=3F滗+iE#1.9t+nˑހp˜K^FYO%08=ӯ)_{ ;_Δ6q)ٲnsWǽ5*݂dtpf3u3QmK&frc)v[؃"L$\6]I>s8G]'hz)))@O5%'"0Wx9Աzatr0rv7-mwp&yTlo 3'ߌΑ oK2y#mRs$}C(t26:ߡdj_>ib&L&Y؁sAd58 ;@<_4(sB|#-ݸq &j>I2煮0᥷V-yOi RbWs?9tL23^7e'QoJ>3 M̠#ԧ}cv A~,Ktgp$,3 M}~CgYOٍ䨜2" xMxҵkאVPbPRDG/BV&m̱q0,n!($)ȱ{!)QyAO̠ .xpwp4x$Hk/sqe}salIb*Ⱥ*'z5LN n8haq9¾h*tm9 sJCƏޜ+kMurA$80I.d9t[ZI@=Ƥ]N'yvu`Ew6s>q{؎ql3N2g7&@%lv hiXeY*-J[(}X6 [UTUX۴< ?Cm7X2-G'[Y;|:\sI},W> KE&L*D4]:T;eH*% (q*^>I&y^mЂ NU$ݻKQfD(r).+tHi9LG3t9ѢMvnF}#Htn½OHW GQt\>=OoO11οm˿'ދP7%xYҸ|1? j9CaCs^~p@š`w`["Z#yGWьԾ^ F ߬ %iW 5e" CE1d FCz0iURzcNmerV|!7d |BaD0Q7`7 Bʇ,+osY C _sXofR꾝ٖ@K#&\[yW(C򾇤/Ը ǧ0RX&EjJ%1ucpHpcMle4K]`1{L!@[l#R}B=007A` Hn~{6,g:>TD%F֨ Iӳn& {ԎBL[,H\[px/N=!%c2VQvE676?ɵnLeM kި3Ɨ;x9lv %7 8'8?3rcʹ$ԅDܩV.|UT4:'+qjWT+h C܆ĆP[9,Jnƃ`w)老f{0PB˝\:Hk#%G&أ%t"b5. /f$gG;yMNL[eL\5GJj#upnD, p; ~ԆLqjNk3ML2Sq1=ؼ$a xU_8Y$)ZR8KwƔÕ#K |}eFag@q-DJ@栁>1PPLRQR IhzH!gWڵ`濎`AP TTX>"DAN11X^e+@on3SsĔk83HuV$䁳&;bwWW7WMDBºH8"&gwW{y6~kRLQӯn3T_d"7'ٽv |-mg%늹әS|/=8MΦ=+Vпf¨ ?xX Q6$#Gɤ$R!D%C^(L|Y" +´P#MQj2jb<+ڃK\uC) 5˦Lq;4?;͑s#2$)3I H<->o<Я()sw{~XW"}9Ma~AJ7W BZDFFPj='v(8h,~*AdY'~ &;ޝ>Ŏa8CI KJX66R7vdjl*Vbt#봪@GJ# IqMsW~).ECdVTS%{:~>#*I5P=K2> +I"P:e^/E5}o~g[=f0Ҩbzŷ;V{?jB_Yq7coz,n Eٸ$.Պ.Eq$2G&ykh ;I1gEW&:Wޥ]΃Ir+ L)| *{ӭ(Ap o6Cl og{ChȚ_0g9C^`_?#{˾G#SܙY>D.>nFnwpPz|OCW Gd EN8diimF֘Uf9kr[Dox璑 lov<&j܅{]G\+d<D#h  S{TGkqm l߼"ڢC\91 +baY`K:*3E:7GwEDFA ہ? *D< 桌uhZӘQ-R*l!|-51 >Z""^&X,rmg*|Orx/7yDݏ~ίjOM~X=.Szv!aGq*ggOgPoe776Ő_dpG-,Yr9/+!菹w?syiw~_Aݰ>'])DSJy=-Ʒp[\Oɧ%iRs^͹8 @[zF঍|GCK~}>]Ig7?􉐫Qz 8bƝ@`H-҈ĵHGI;Ƥ9IN)&ע&G*?bD{v:3/ 40rTFѨ})RE0Z'qY@>X֐ְl.8ӝJ#zyء-V# ^ 瞇?ssdZ 0W @v&Aͧ$ҚP)Jdm2 Hk!ab:OG"\hRgbL,_gn+bK/{ߞ@4 "o xyA"A - }D[J4hQ;tbaU=عHz.%!n`8wW7VsPmE1hʹ*TmSR[Wrx< VߕJ UQ*b Ra &gʆ- }43N(]ʌ]4b(*ĨݶH):и0!#Yj},Y2cсރ"u8}0F a,nX?oD>]P0U0.*5r|Hk>B9q S9 {ҁ@u hcfT{xaxt8\dv{ 4<6n䉹= ո-rco !GСYv5d1/^1s|?^;_;*eʧ^ްxB p D5`ACp[> ~Љf0'4ȁJf̭=f?KG3}[[Cmk g= [ ,'4^}zK<e?;J~g_PЖ j:- ׇ ԁ&pK{I8V##p <vX׷hlyiiA:ҠsP? rܕ 0} 9\SXk3긺3r7ADx32t sd\f,K)*&ux{g:rM` zΚp h& !k9ғm'\Ѽ\kel%bⓌI_'67ԴZi fOM8t JGbivk!30Q p< @^Y]TM2?I34hA-ddLd`̝YUCrA-Щo~ 1dsgw·3q5Bxd&#تiowlς [N؛?6cWזK5ԵD.񕰫\ +QK{=}mCv;LnocǒԀﳶ,,PVU7&:9>Ψ7E"я.] Z wL5])n\Cݕk)D b2.p*z%)@f /C1Z[K0|[6M_ni%lך`_1#}S=~z`T4Mў]9d}cѼӘdR^:ׯ "FFe_ȇ7ȽLb6І0 Ira0>p/V|pJB>?$l cE)O z{MCAl0M$F4(ѼP-J-#E " bƶpmI:3Ԃc8k{0Pttc`0] Ă$,d7o/É3-pv =}`Ơcb#Ea]ubxrY.ۑx(21s?(Q˹2Gɛu\8a&A5M]44t^v8$[GZ4f;f;$pleB*B J5V̫v8Y/0ʸLբM *phA~(hFkh&*af|jap{ǏCM1pfsnL_Uw՗sИ_*y }ym<:$f; Lzԥ%XVKi$rsf,*,Y UR4OXEwU7-NWQ7-0Ejt;V'^Aw\F_A[:34eu{\6d ÈZ25يi;J!m[l6 b}zT%Yk 5qQZkӍ-5B[ -,j*sR:vBQ_Hd|\a.TIt 'ybQzVPZlupÑ㙰(q><%(CP"U'Q~>?UbRT&JsuK{[8׻K޸@b`4E|">=vAWgB&Gi(-Mp4ItG[b4e,Ӆ;+ X8'$ǥȘH>|TzQAaĚ]y=csdZ+IGXEt}QrD3J/tdA8"O>-}x-bwѼ//Wy~7s^ͼw3d}l>ξ܋%#1 I IT %e඼ `D]a֩h'n%аnnmVm)l&Lp4c\({u ]h&]LLqiloiSM13X[FnS{cK#II]PЂ$aR8'\Xa~ˎX*9i朹`2) 1awB@ld[{1bq5HñnDNqoj S@_Vx*7 L* ,$W D/ZWdjx}(`Dwj.M;=q쐴zV|dZ122:X( ʅ*L6L-kjD8en8,6|l?del8-4Uہ u0:N|_G1* <2qH$K|Y6hq"0_7fg_~w>vέys҇Q^]*mk_bL,]^]avdco{l8i{A{T֎\/jlEy)^ڽ2jF~CLb)ߌvѕQ̗3t1JsЩRurHaouetu*CyZ aNQ߈=JNN'| U6 cAf;eo1 /NEJ^?Y,Q^o]* nĽ88.dd:M 0S6sOiW~׶1g3g/|Swm={)ޝ&hPEztޕo.RJgL?Iu"qXF:&|ȩoBZqSԚG9 N\ Y!NԠ|]+T1yfVCgp'k /;JQhP("bx5x^kqlaOz0E_+?e4ޞ͇ǽǛ.7;Άhg{PdM.rg$)#1dĩ-2l܍Jh)5]y㺥%dM *!'#1vkLrv[ <ִ7\W2eaxoҝO=u[GVVц蝚p쾎x{I/8^l]?\JXkXLĶ F] u;G-AúVdFjf C7|8X# PNƕ4t_u#m)8㏕kG3AzBHĽkHLH$&$ ^% :0.1Ni3G}n^qAPYeLAVp$Gsh3JjA-Uc[f[~=¶zkHU;1nHh|8'ߚ:JX[/K//_L0wyYWBo >n[Y9HHK~5 &d9#U$UJc sb4Ji1m44q4VCd2 5͐dwTZcXpa~7Vzb~};PRY8Tt(##`5Vq{ it^TKŒ%!t[VL,U6M15V!qnRce3m<#=7Ӳ^o7_1+zh@b}ld0iCѐ%?{X{kupy1ZӪY'ɅHfPBeSqȘ0f 򊇁0\v"-ݹI| |v9㤝p ?0dos3/ܟj]^[ި=mM,op6yxL0Mrsހ.#Vu"gQ (Pϣ?@( 4mUyZV ^0mںҒt>Fz %ite}f[Ko&DF#J#"VpHW:qt^R-K+ `S^;+dW O_NřbMdU|1x1^9u5zzqt>"5fbdž"ica%3 ։ԉYg8U|ziKX`NPKtQR<%%3aH2,xr% &@akMfk%-K \JWI6pEѴ8#ΉD+m^NF]`ȢFhw{|kOoK[۸ }^@ Jه;PDg1NQZm|'NY >g8Q3u\dΘ3b}?IՇ s0&RNba/g-岺*KC34xnG" ]F :A<%a 4M&?x6U47h~دަC~%CYDB.ED{z:Ŏȹ\]x, xK?z~|qJFzdO{_ٸ(KJy['scف'xm{v'87;1A 7eه*_&^Q+  b "JRP P9U`14٠8rr^5)V5' .JC9g[Ot,8 (r0vYy@_xY!ybx.]\.K-i Ev`0_w Mt9>/"M1 NѼ>-h ܅-/P›^GamJhZgtB{UTSJuYMӱ_[75kFl@lk6\ZE@щ2ʢ!}'Mku]Cj#)躱"Q}%9Uk0 Cf'y?)iϹ0f2. ^O߶?Q?19`9/u*m>+r)_vӊZ]s)xA1Qu6DGC㈹HyGꢱh?ǯU|]n־0W7n%*#Ȫ+>&OǤ%(WEmؗ-gAg!)UUѠ, .W+J2 s /ɊR0Jj KL#m|>ʰiaə9Nj$Ԫ$rTa)J a*UKr ADE~ V3 d.Q/kq3n9)7dOך2" NDuU) b.|VC640gYʔ捻F nN5ޠ B&7eblEsͼi9{pZmnm@6C6r`H!X P/7{M?3NH/]p0{Gii4̐ghh8Tjb{Bˢz2>d34 Ax*dom |PI37I|?>(J_-DPU"3[)%8u58Ԏ")* xZc'uP5A.7R80+TC|05Jk^E&ʃ"K%aA[܊o,okfяZtaB <a\NgtP(>*PiO;1:9q9a.;'J_.Hz RL9)xor"Ajύq mu$.DXtl{`I-!_gZYrX Ɔejr)cgI)M\5P]ڶn|jz{luaZiUݮh;nc0ۺ*GǛc[ P*`N60 @V~Q&{C h(J},5X)H&+_,ߕCdjG)}skګw(Y Ҷ9ܼ5 ݡ*ZĴyio¶TIIIg)C7Wt!`wZ4BgIXgi >-Aש(s.]e$xbADFCh iM4xrWxG-\qwhiAqo哎V&E13$I?= /@"Ic݌C,'=7qzL1Fӎ E`],똮%H;P闄э>zdYN`}]vTڄ+#H#y)+ccNebmQ]'YyYF?|pDCSOt'r}'7_˟DGNx.)䤑 j(׿&HzV g>85mεS{8.H/Bf)0&@ ͖l]MzMwZT1-^jN*R}܃Oif>C둆G/Om*>%?K`8l0-d1| U3{?0`pks[Kr5zn wRFYwN>Nl%f-̷{93БYQLA`  Rt)LМ d9SM-*e d=T.8?wΫNV43A$ls Rg\Us *̨C-xQ,Yyd|t(xK}Rݒ@4A㈻7@rXkWe3qv֋8^ Eܣ ~:W>f+USUMB]J CS쎼R/NOȈU9Ì';tWu& h^nuϬiUFkҼISa1X4aIYWՕV}.[JP Iu3@2C(NJP •~ܙ%FRD+YV]+.P Eu(4u^8(^,խTnpg{K*K&UQ3Ҽ/GV%#-57@5##s?8GX6ޥ;.]| *Ly:"*1P0V)!;Hi马~|"!#iDY']K_>eSG7(碡SZ1gR_%GTёx.νsfi6A{D%#Q(ȯlo6Ne;9H\ 3=V2  X </.갯{S)h]Rm 77T =u%l=e~h'۵z$wQLEy&96C67xU߂\[!|)}!Ч@4Mnظ)V-uCfq[Y"*Y^zY#rJ>EIn^&m ,dOmUKP'>Q%Z_R[7AϷP~r@H[Olcx~%x̗h04OjsL}m~Zbf hL_O9 =?{E#ξr0{19GOP0Nrg>=H=B|,$Z'x:ds9q sܐ$g`ocQz?=AюJV #̾c33D}ay̩8[qRJA˜% a>)h*%ɏHI+śV؟}j?u;A ,w_$0ʷ1 PVaEO~(,=^N2cɈ_g~ijC)@%Q~x(u=.e<(I 0NK~G ]uᬇI(XAl4K 1zf<̹/sIJwnKJ ~2/H 98>@26O:SI}Ab`^r<v!Tcd 1TrFuPo7{E2ST!i:LQ%ȗȏDMO[j)͛2?!K/>u6ʱPCG:!bMWMSFSxn/OJ3f 2߰={?tΉC'3 R.C֪pл(ޣNa{DnEo^Umy(<_AED]7 ag@\Gz@ ~pӶBi3RoR966>\-qbo V w`5NI;06F*eaZvjǂjEG)RA-*X봖ݎ/j`_P oInB;=ggw;7kCII71l2mrDdP ~PFۛO=1o7,zv5?,Uf+k`}+B?g+z}9(\ӯWDGw-Geڇ3v*h[ۿ?* b=@̇y\;6&'bGagg6u>t&q6 Ο)z"auL&9 9/"mN^yY_u5XBM[zC ww;};9kq6=p?ǿfʗa|r6a۶A0GR[q3r苝|P]ïo%vQ?=qe䃖VM:Zl1g6 o4vVfyuy>o֢C]L}u{ʈ}?Q(Wh^ê2rcr#|lc{i1r8=sT?v./'-<)iqJf٤$uiK7rRw%zR*s$]_ѻEC{8w\9qrV-> fTA9|MqW|L^5z vb*N:­9U}n!sfiPVzdS=7<|nN>e@DHm qyM Z'9oHC¥Uc:G?1Ys5i;\46xMVhEy`</\ʸKeIPE~GJ=.!}18ۜ~â)֏~U_m8G` sxEk(+f)>̕*iADf=_7.ٮhsU͉r89 ?HM2e~@.Zf~vB&]wǹdhy\oyP2+6k֜q?{rwZjڇak`SҨkMŚ.KضbiNz2(} Nr*Etj_~' ΕaA+gkE ݰ^~ aثobTRF|7\W$Z;`]3ba칼| /B!o³QjP&LBړPR7~jWȏBP?QIYI? $ԏӓPz?1ƾJ53z%dwYʯv+:П"\3iÝ"Ƹ|¶oxlnNx<; [ k]ܸ[bkߌҁ <y΄ Wnlؿó0x^/+qA^ `͍ 'ژ+Ҽ\_EN"C~D\{IJ%"P!_b*ϣ u_[y>LԼklqIFTmɗ/'_92,{^,ci#"^rR h7%)9St>(-~C*e qzz;sNkaԯGݾ:М[F .UaS?\O|woh&6m`M8XZut'8VYkv-W_{McEvB~5;g ]w'˝Ε[ZCUz elESL2&cK38ʹ&ERk,ng+5.GHq^W|+ށ^c[Şp,rzi✏U8Iā (ÝmeN8~<}VoxW]NoW2d|{_Ft 26G.{^`R 7bQoNڞE,)k:vNSi_l–򁭪9=B[) ,* l-AOA'cbF` 00@`:Ƣl *̸'T$}~Wl^9s?lO,ޥo\o Kc9kiCyq_s/ yoe)iI QMgL{A@'6vGSWZh]ga{7˳0rb;=< ĸ롆 'Fo3>URZns/{R7Iδg?t#5Pm ~bkﯓ~!W$L M-2T2~ܟ3^$]%`_rJYNcfd[ͩYZ Ơ#GY[cO&Z+S5-}I1>~yzbK]*snp{ v-QN~/oé'*F%_A媮uβ"s dO҄ܬcs4H/:vNJ{wWYBu~wZM~wx@k*w#!W~|;hx}ԧg}Nu ֏Cm?iY֐r%5GWijWn1mmu3,54>jl [!Q/: b_5TnYUp~#"l^vƥѱyg2}n5 'J&Hs4 v 3}tY1(tj~sT.K\f5;sX!Sk61>%;']i$՘oJ-0)ΏPD/d2Tsؔ]G7y3Rme 0p"ر]y\Q녛cs'5~P?)&wBf~\ |;O|[f(٤d@V"u:e ́ɱ-Ը%{@*RP\]Cy)gc/g3vVj?5<ɐ`vг<{;Scn_/I̹RmLcMI$̒wg7֗1[tnڟ. k'"pgk邮#s_~b"%ڛEx NE]k̑^0e6tyL{:aL;|G߳*~/=\>C`Gc 9guǥgλwm4/Qv.rLsjg)yYo>cAi|u܃> HicSqד _",!ut:d3;|_Ά'xWR\ o$n+Y|"\/TR#uZ`\?ĸJi^8n\r6 S(Eh|O9X+LZÞ'VH{'uV̿K◆g |lo'mB7'|*;?7=Si1xDpJd;6D:43>Ȇʰniˢ'caLZ׋uOIׄ&:ӲÙ'=2_IJps85 צ6\.Q.`TTq>aT ?tܩ,Ş4+ҪTRy(sܔz}L$"<,[{d)LcZX-]ɂ~klzii5 D/%!ȓo8Ve.lHF) 0<}h~ LCPe_rlRwYOy.>'s8o َ.y\fGل7ZmXC{wsoIhqqtJby5)d2zrOy.qLC5IMr_~<(b%)hzWԠCjX##fgAﷹbC%Dp6?\(c㛂 f$::ow_$oH '˼/cc'+;X.ϐU\^g!m7s^ LWk[ɳ g5y~抑u W\wZΉs3CeO*/Jx9ozd>c.嵛<|2ϨL)x^ -֙l\wm84&?fto=/]n%8m.op@#"z6m'o0Bzz,q0Pb;8+sky0> >K3%eeY9C6-W~n3F}4}?Az}lNg2 ؖ||v0o;JS}xr'CslRFh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4(nwb 8QK?`KWlaΡp9eib-(e77mكEjnʧlx&0LPX@ɏ^XLG Y\ PV5jX҈MtRHb- yoaZ [Yh?miǤ8m`YrsZQ-@!@ 5oHAu[Vؘ<8"Gͅ&Y"571k'nT4+s=mJZ!5s&뱒> v15T{KհerC״=k*}9,OӋ0[8 ~JQ*{,U39:RAOOM_2xz{2œx2c5fc$bv7Sf[Pbu'6mo `<=)ۘ|mY!fg 5[`^ڎI ؾ1$g,|kdž%H  !v9.iLCShnkWKTPn)2Q~ ~U7cğIs{ι\_9k6 Z(ҝ;L""lDb-&xuY,8~+7'6V4c%M<4cЌE9|9. >@ƺo[]40k򷰎i%a+l3"kQ,!-L=*F,[P{ ԕ,T߈Uʃ;D`fvUCN8Q& y6a$h 9Bz[Jn"\fYM&MFifYKz~&y[(/Q@^#=@?0R*#+m.\%555[zY?J+4+1>7›Hgt#5h,b@UUUS] ]7nvٲ]]]r[R D ZL!-`dY g@& Da&-n@-.3 fψ/X\.X[c_s, HO38 pu &xYYg6hß}ef@#ܔ{f>|\.aCݼkhZƼ*T''O 7*;:uPNҳ;^11 g7{j_W?Փ~+~n=*U vso p3L=6Tz"; 3'!k@OYQ"ϰS*~-}6^Wr.1y /-5B$nv;v?‡m+md}E[;§a~dLYA>,Y[MzkIP#*g*z>8iyOP햶fuYdD&]KVRJ:-5\ aүRu}t;_hu _. i2vHXl)\t"p#\llB+l!|]DtNCzFobok}A-Z:9@8ɺlWH6t$3*vlm/򡴠ٳȸQP.-=vUB4oÎVGswT;^gst*NSrgu"8Պ&^3?%pz̧䔔S*ERf[(UtӮkڗ5ѪJ<ztՄx7Sik3fD<@9eJ_NJiL }E:D桌Ȉ HHKȰ_b P}H;C!:V)W7IH^e<_lљg`pKۂ,D, 'C"OfDJiJlFrB^CAL  &dByϷx6Lyc2okC - >!<Zb &5` $D0?ўz,釹'יִO=!y+sxyc^JTOzIC%[8L|wd8#;5^~Cs7UbM1!J=Pͫ;W{Zj/&~shS>ksߛ2wK'M?~@6ղlCv6 lZw{բhCt֬5lLcAlyqeӆ~S }Jt{]u#p3 eÁT`&PxP؉tW2!ŗWG|"95:咽.ez\ayBe&7Q[vFY0.e{{mܷvSYRn)]SZCQ2*ie!Gܧܲs w`n9Q>_kxJ+LL0|P>Ԟ ޏ)SG#`#d͋ ȑB˖"ђ+䞒cX+ZU |Kg0#Ŵ*rQB3 ?O㧘\r "fynW.x/ 0b endstream endobj 29 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[567.0 463.0 578.0 474.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 15 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 2/Type/Page>> endobj 36 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (98051109)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/98051109.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:38:00 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 672.75 591.75 93 re f /Article <>BDC EMC BT /Article <>BDC 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 752.25 Tm (Jean E. Smallin)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Member, Claims Appeals Board)Tj T* (1. )Tj (This matter involves Personal Property Government Bill of Lading \(PPGBL\ \) SP-110,895; and Air Force Claim)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (Maxwell AFB 95-1340.)Tj EMC ET endstream endobj 14 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 1/Type/Page>> endobj 37 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (98051109)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/98051109.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:38:00 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC BT 0 g /TT1 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 278.8662 744 Tm (Discussion)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -21.906 -2.125 Td (To hold a common carrier liable for transit damage, the shipper has the \ initial burden of establishing)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 40.377 0 Td (a )Tj (prima)Tj ET 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 508.8496 717.75 cm 0 0 m 27.99 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 536.8398 718.5 Tm ( )Tj (facie)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 539.8398 717.75 cm 0 0 m 23.309 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 563.1484 718.5 Tm ( case)Tj -45.596 -1.125 Td (of liability against the carrier. )Tj 12.106 0 Td (Such a case is established by showing that the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 18.635 0 Td (shipper delivered the goods in a certain)Tj -30.742 -1.125 Td (condition, that they were delivered by the carrier in a more)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 23.768 0 Td (damaged condition, and the amount of the damages. )Tj 21.105 0 Td (See)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 554.4766 690.75 cm 0 0 m 17.326 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 678 Tm (Missouri Pacific R. Co. v. Elmore &)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC ET q 1 0 0 1 16 677.25 cm 0 0 m 178.652 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 194.6523 678 Tm (Stahl)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 194.6523 677.25 cm 0 0 m 24.668 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 219.3203 678 Tm (, 377 U.S. 134, 138 \(1964\).)Tj -16.943 -2.125 Td (American does not deny liability for the doors. )Tj 18.968 0 Td (But, in effect, it suggests that some of the damage)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 20.217 0 Td (was caused after)Tj -39.185 -1.125 Td (delivery. )Tj 3.776 0 Td (However, it appears to us that the shipper, inspectors and repairer used\ )Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 28.546 0 Td (different terms to describe the same)Tj -32.323 -1.125 Td (damage. )Tj 3.609 0 Td (The Comptroller General noted how different people)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 21.409 0 Td (variously described the same damage as a "scratch,")Tj -25.019 -1.125 Td ("mar," or "gouge." )Tj (SeeAmerican Van Services,)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC ET q 1 0 0 1 108.5723 611.25 cm 0 0 m 137.279 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 245.8516 612 Tm (Inc.)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 245.8516 611.25 cm 0 0 m 18.322 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 264.1738 612 Tm (, B-252975, Sept. 8, 1993; and )Tj 12.5 0 Td (Continental Van Lines, Inc.)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 414.168 611.25 cm 0 0 m 132.967 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 547.1348 612 Tm (, 63)Tj -44.261 -1.125 Td (Comp. Gen. 479 \(1984\). )Tj (Clearly,)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 13.47 0 Td (there was no PED on any of the doors when they were tendered to the NTS \ facility,)Tj -13.47 -1.125 Td (but they)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 3.5 0 Td (arrived damaged. )Tj 7.191 0 Td (There is no evidence that the service member caused additional damage af\ ter)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 31.041 0 Td (delivery and)Tj -41.732 -1.125 Td (how such damage may have affected the cost of repairs. )Tj 22.629 0 Td (American remains liable for)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 11.495 0 Td (this damage.)Tj -34.125 -2.125 Td (The coffee table is a more difficult issue. )Tj 16.632 0 Td (As explained above, generally we give minor weight to)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 22.382 0 Td (the terminology used)Tj -39.015 -1.125 Td (to describe the damage, and give substantial weight to a military Servic\ e)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 29.241 0 Td (inspector's statement especially when the)Tj -29.241 -1.125 Td (carrier fails to inspect. )Tj 9.19 0 Td (However, in view of the specific)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 13.301 0 Td (facts in this claim, we are not convinced that there is a)Tj -22.491 -1.125 Td (difference between the gouged edges noted)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 17.548 0 Td (by the NTS contractor and the deep scratch on the edge of the coffee tab\ le)Tj -17.548 -1.125 Td (that the member's)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 7.317 0 Td (spouse attempted to repair. )Tj 11.024 0 Td (The inspectors found no scratches or gouges on the top of the table)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 27.021 0 Td (even)Tj -45.362 -1.125 Td (though a few weeks earlier the repairer had noted that "top surface [was\ ] badly scratched &)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 36.837 0 Td (dented." )Tj (Even if we)Tj -36.837 -1.125 Td (interpret the word "edge" as used by the inspectors to mean top edge, th\ e)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 29.391 0 Td (repairer states that the damage he observed)Tj -29.391 -1.125 Td (was to the "top surface," and the inspectors themselves)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 22.199 0 Td (had clearly distinguished between the top and the edge. )Tj 22.382 0 Td (The)Tj -44.581 -1.125 Td (inspectors' observations vary with both)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 15.872 0 Td (the PED noted on the NTS inventory and with the repairer's statement.)Tj -15.872 -2.125 Td (A military service's inspector's timely observations may be necessary to\ effectively impeach a)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 37.82 0 Td (carrier's over-broad)Tj -37.82 -1.125 Td (characterization of PED, or explain how the transit damage added to PED \ of)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 30.823 0 Td (the same type. )Tj 5.998 0 Td (But it is difficult to accept)Tj -36.821 -1.125 Td (the inspectors' statement here because it is so)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 18.286 0 Td (inconsistent with other documentation in the record. )Tj 21.106 0 Td (Acceptance of the)Tj -39.392 -1.125 Td (inspectors' statement would)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 11.317 0 Td (require us to find that the NTS facility exaggerated the PED and that th\ e observations of the)Tj -11.317 -1.125 Td (repairer were incorrect. )Tj 9.604 0 Td (A possible explanation is that the inspectors may have been observing an\ )Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 29.493 0 Td (item that the shipper)Tj -39.097 -1.125 Td (had attempted to self-repair before the inspectors arrived. )Tj 23.185 0 Td (Thus, the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (inspectors' observations may not reflect the)Tj -23.185 -1.125 Td (condition of the coffee table when delivered. )Tj 18.159 0 Td (Where)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (the record shows the existence of pre-existing damage, and lacks)Tj -18.159 -1.125 Td (evidence of greater or different)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 12.687 0 Td (damage, the common carrier is not liable for damage in transit. )Tj 25.408 0 Td (See)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 473.1367 317.25 cm 0 0 m 17.326 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 490.4629 318 Tm ( )Tj (Continental Van)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 493.4629 317.25 cm 0 0 m 78.984 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 304.5 Tm (Lines, Inc.)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 16 303.75 cm 0 0 m 50.982 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 66.9824 304.5 Tm (, 63)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Comp. Gen. 479 )Tj (supra)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 170.3125 303.75 cm 0 0 m 25.992 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 196.3047 304.5 Tm (. )Tj (Accordingly, for all of these reasons, we find that the evidence is)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 26.769 0 Td (insufficient to)Tj -41.794 -1.125 Td (conclude that American caused additional, transit-type damage, and that \ American)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 33.32 0 Td (should be refunded the $65 cost of)Tj -33.32 -1.125 Td (repair of the coffee table.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 21.767 -2.125 Td (Conclusion)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -21.767 -2.125 Td (We modify the Settlement Certificate to allow American an additional $65\ ; otherwise we affirm.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Signed: Michael D. Hipple)Tj T* (Michael D. Hipple)Tj T* (Chairman, Claims Appeals Board)Tj T* (Signed: Christine M. Kopocis)Tj T* (Christine M. Kopocis)Tj T* (Member, Claims Appeals Board)Tj T* (Signed: Jean E. Smallin)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 12 0 obj <> endobj 38 0 obj <> endobj 9 0 obj <> endobj 10 0 obj <> endobj 11 0 obj <> endobj 41 0 obj (file:///usr.osd.mil/Home/OSD/OGC/JosephLM/_MyComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Archived%20-%20HTML/98051109.html) endobj 40 0 obj <> endobj 42 0 obj <> endobj 39 0 obj [15 0 R/XYZ 0 711.0 null] endobj 4 0 obj <> endobj xref 0 43 0000000000 65535 f 0000000016 00000 n 0000000141 00000 n 0000003649 00000 n 0000107385 00000 n 0000003527 00000 n 0000003582 00000 n 0000003715 00000 n 0000003742 00000 n 0000106847 00000 n 0000106903 00000 n 0000106945 00000 n 0000106663 00000 n 0000004277 00000 n 0000097866 00000 n 0000096833 00000 n 0000003845 00000 n 0000003891 00000 n 0000003940 00000 n 0000004090 00000 n 0000003994 00000 n 0000004026 00000 n 0000004058 00000 n 0000004491 00000 n 0000004516 00000 n 0000011592 00000 n 0000011641 00000 n 0000011676 00000 n 0000012184 00000 n 0000096501 00000 n 0000043273 00000 n 0000043540 00000 n 0000012597 00000 n 0000012870 00000 n 0000013297 00000 n 0000044152 00000 n 0000097022 00000 n 0000098066 00000 n 0000106748 00000 n 0000107343 00000 n 0000107161 00000 n 0000106987 00000 n 0000107290 00000 n trailer <<50F2E7C9E5110C4A93C104F87133DEC1>]>> startxref 107555 %%EOF