%PDF-1.6 % 1 0 obj <> endobj 2 0 obj <>stream 2021-06-11T15:38:01-04:00 2021-06-11T15:38-04:00 2021-06-11T15:38:01-04:00 Adobe Acrobat 17.0 application/pdf 98052614 uuid:ea0c67a8-9c2d-4da4-9f49-7c34665dc6ba uuid:65fd1cbc-a1a1-418f-b508-c2ee79344cdc Acrobat Web Capture 15.0 endstream endobj 5 0 obj <> endobj 6 0 obj <> endobj 3 0 obj <> endobj 7 0 obj <> endobj 8 0 obj <> endobj 16 0 obj <>>> endobj 17 0 obj <> endobj 18 0 obj <> endobj 20 0 obj [19 0 R 19 0 R] endobj 21 0 obj [19 0 R 19 0 R] endobj 22 0 obj [19 0 R 19 0 R] endobj 19 0 obj <><><><>]/P 17 0 R/Pg 13 0 R/S/Article>> endobj 13 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 0/Type/Page>> endobj 23 0 obj [29 0 R] endobj 24 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (98052614)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/98052614.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:38:00 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 734.2497 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 579.749 0 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 733.5 cm 0 0 m -0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 578.25 0 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 732.7503 cm 0 0 m 0.75 0.75 l 0 1.499 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 733.5 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 0.75 0.75 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 599.2497 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 579.749 0 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 598.5 cm 0 0 m -0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 578.25 0 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 597.7503 cm 0 0 m 0.75 0.75 l 0 1.499 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 598.5 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 0.75 0.75 l h f Q /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 749.25 Tm (DATE: August 10, 1998)Tj 0 -2.75 TD (In Re:)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Resource Protection)Tj T* (on behalf of)Tj T* (Allied Alliance Forwarding, Inc.)Tj T* (Claimant)Tj 0 -2.75 TD (\))Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Claims Case No. 98052614)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 15.224 -2.125 Td (CLAIMS APPEALS BOARD DECISION)Tj -15.224 -2.125 Td (DIGEST)Tj /TT0 1 Tf T* (The Army offset the amount it had reimbursed the service member for a ha\ nd-made crystal chandelier that was missing)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (from his household goods shipment. On appeal the carrier)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 23.439 0 Td (must show that the Army's valuation of the chandelier was)Tj -23.439 -1.125 Td (unreasonable.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 0 -2.125 TD (DECISION)Tj /TT0 1 Tf T* (Resource Protection, on behalf of Allied Alliance Forwarding, Inc. \(All\ ied\), appeals the May 11, 1998, Defense Office)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (of Hearings and Appeals \(DOHA\) Settlement Certificate,)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 23.215 0 Td (DOHA Claim No. 98021004, which upheld the Army's set off)Tj -23.215 -1.375 Td (of $750.00 against Allied to recover the value of a lost chandelier.)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 333.5605 375.75 Tm (\(1\))Tj ET 0 0 0.933 RG 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 333.5605 375 cm 0 0 m 11.369 0 l h S Q BT 0 g /TT1 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 274.1992 345.75 Tm (Background)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -21.517 -2.125 Td (The record indicates that the member's household goods \(HHG\) were pick\ ed up in Georgia and placed in nontemporary)Tj T* (storage \(NTS\))Tj ( in October 1986 by Trading Post)Tj 19.08 0 Td (. In October)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (1992, Allied's agent picked up the HHG from NTS and)Tj -19.08 -1.125 Td (delivered them to Pennsylvania. A rider was completed at NTS. Allied's a\ gent unpacked the HHG at the time of)Tj T* (delivery. A)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 4.749 0 Td (Joint Statement of Loss or Damage at Delivery \(DD Form 1840\) was execu\ ted and in early November a)Tj -4.749 -1.125 Td (Notice of Loss or Damage \(DD Form 1840R\) was dispatched. The DD Form)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 30.994 0 Td (1840R reported that Item #14, a crystal)Tj -30.994 -1.125 Td (chandelier, was missing. The List of Property and Claims Analysis Chart \ \(DD Form 1844\) stated that the hand-made)Tj T* (crystal chandelier was)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 9.135 0 Td (purchased for $500.00 in November 1984. The shipper provided a catalog d\ escription of a)Tj -9.135 -1.125 Td (replacement chandelier at a cost of $3,026.25. The member was reimbursed\ $750.00, the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 35.766 0 Td (maximum allowance specified)Tj -35.766 -1.125 Td (for this type of property in the Allowance List-Depreciation Guide appli\ cable at the time. The Army originally offset)Tj T* ($1,258.00 against Allied, then)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 12.304 0 Td (subsequently determined that because there was nothing to establish the \ original value of)Tj -12.304 -1.125 Td (the chandelier, Allied's liability should be reduced to $750.00. Our Set\ tlement Certificate)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 35.92 0 Td (upheld the Army's offset)Tj -35.92 -1.125 Td (stating that the carrier had not shown that $750.00 was unreasonable.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (On appeal, Resource Protection argues that the record does not establish\ tender of a crystal chandelier nor does it)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (support the assessed carrier liability of $750.00.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 21.906 -2.125 Td (Discussion)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -21.906 -2.125 Td (Generally, under federal law, in an action to recover from a carrier for\ damage or loss to a HHG shipment, the shipper)Tj T* (establishes a )Tj 5.276 0 Td (prima)Tj ET 0 G q 1 0 0 1 79.3164 67.5 cm 0 0 m 27.99 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 107.3066 68.25 Tm ( )Tj (facie)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 110.3066 67.5 cm 0 0 m 23.309 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 133.6152 68.25 Tm ( case by showing that he tendered)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 13.746 0 Td (property to the carrier, that the property was not delivered or)Tj -23.547 -1.125 Td (was delivered in a more damaged condition, and the amount of damages. Th\ e burden of proof then shifts to the carrier)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 47.512 0 Td (to)Tj -47.512 -1.125 Td (show both that it was free from negligence and that the damage to the ca\ rgo was due to one of the excepted causes)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 25 0 obj <> endobj 26 0 obj (;=S9oRU) endobj 27 0 obj <> endobj 28 0 obj <> endobj 32 0 obj <> endobj 33 0 obj <>stream H\j0 ~ COkgXrt1NzϊJ3$%CrTVvD~5NvxvV$)NO}Dyl;<#lal E ^aUks?أ m8qM-iʄn7!/svNXFGh􍽢0 a>qڥߍyJq&8eN[X2K9#3K|$>1A8#G$$;HrPYq1ja7En=y*vSM[>d|WFwe\0Q҇3ZzI],>^,įW. endstream endobj 34 0 obj <>stream H|y\TG5o^p fQ,+nuCQg$ވ^(Ɍh$3QW$>U]]@ Q=>k*p\a MIi3q/ErbGRo _ ǧ Ln3Pv}IvZ @_ a =tPrn Uiʭh &1Ses.p_aHLr\x{I`P])R4 IJ Xn-P_R.5$k4zI'I{Wxq; gBuFt:j6.~'z(DxaFE JZuz7wO:>u}h0Q``4ao4i oV{D^kߡc;wǟ[O{D_罾ݧ?:_8hpBbR)ÆHzcƎfNSN>cf欬sΛ`X,gynފV1]^PPh-[m߱s={?pK=vSϔ칊.^•Jj5h3Da"T0@ zH4i4CʓHO^r s3(!(1pPY38-xyOJ=%HtWz)ʗxeRT(Dq2 K ӍkMMz@bjjzc фUSQjc5TmFIjNQgsB)TJSR*ihr& N\~F5`6JQ, @pq'p#qgPB CyCl F"!P C cF*Fbb4b a<! m=($Ғ ;jh!-ŴppRZF9r)ȝ<ȓVJ<3ZEi i-|ZO i#&L[ .4N[imM>T|q?K>͠}TLC@ EԐ0P#jLALG7MR@F2Q:FǩNI:E)BIw*t*g^("^52yW*^kجM&Z^7pF.MVm6v;y=q1|a.#\G2>'3\jZ YhȒeedwك9 |/e•la+_*7;#{|m"]t*ti.'3{\.lc.إ RI.3C"(MIIc1HRX-u+;3uNI:YTuYܐq[|/e.+|kWUzU^Wz:WG|Gg&:G< tS](s8zzg=yz^Ez^FNFJz^WƨA^kZN z999997-#UozDw]zޣ81's rsgrgs\b={b ~ 88P|p#ccyp|t)pS."n͹'7&< p!.Ÿ2\+p%p)5%sZSf:|G#iASq:{}ST:UNS:#yŬ)1Q@4|0`!BCh48wZ8-!! C2@*Az̾ļ"i崆l 4ȅ<ȇh *v|9ŷ7P͠9 ZCh h0~? SatfL *e `->luX6q2^&`=E!2EI"MHD.1yL)2Utɐ@fL%ԐQS%R5dJTJtʠLʢl_RRS5B*Md5ԂZR+jMm-'=u'̕yԉ:SԅԍS*Tw޾>ԇR?zHYLCh(=Gh8=ous4mSw{~Os5}<4T %H ҂ # lIh4i,3@i@/K2Uz~N+5A7̅y0BXa ,e X X k`-CJ7FdL0$y&oom1o34_í p T.fb/bX+b.>;nJ|-[s3'#8/.'qKp}x*JvOʎ ;kc7jAox >H 0=‚Y*lv O]naGX K^aO7xa{q=aOS{{ڞg9{^d/2{^?kAc>'yS\t.9ލNKu\K빾k\n7tLK#̹VFњh3MXǂƻ n6v7Ms 7r&nn۔a>G/]u{}͝ *$!R lBg)M EwDeŕ-@iXC3 U8g9ܙs#{>EPS?n1[!Aނ= bȆc0(N+n+(8\jFDL V&r5Em诔DɔBoS[zQ{@)Ҩu.ԕQ:uWB7ԏFi A#~Eh84> }Jch,؂&DʠI4P&eTFiͤlwwwwWJsMs Kh~?u:[:|48 pȱ2_lН]=$P# #AVE h!-ŴRZFiUZZGim%66W5}C;-,6I?nC{>O \:LG(Q>T@TDTB'$TJet,U9]Kצ/~L̠ t~Kt]ccTk!`&bLr̀Tuu=]_7 uѡӍu4tNӝtѺST51>mb@EYcZ[Vikڶk*tncuNuS:A֝uUwD}v=`C6GQg1{B[dm=aOS-e-gmEzA31{{'x3Ds9:#Q'wqBiQ*Q.Ί qNW5q]7/Rů̉6̅-Ȇ2X0>PLn*]ug^ VC{̐NSPbLaS'S5F)+*KMeeagLѲ eMe2A6͙OS;z~cb3ڋ3##}y&D 3P1&R55Q*D8D%TśXgI u9ɴ gD8o<'üi}FEH,3 Ҭ2֬3l2l|";Ȏ2UNaj,95HPSo 6!&42a WrՕ+{W%;4 uYZ~`4;`aSVI&tB,!BƊTڍ{fbt ] H;wa&ᰓwdѽ!gհU0!VR.5j {I0.hk`+OJ=>2Ū9n{>ўo w< աh51Q hg ,%#8Ǝ0s;K9L8 ESל#ۙ!p^c@4fl+w c*{>!GA04$Un4 G*Q6d{7DW<Gn+˿͆o93p- $=j0bO<VE 21o rZNvB0 ;Gg9r !東3 әP3Ud*Nq3eq:W86>)\lp % f\_׸K,G_V} 5+^!YOFwfY \z<#qfw{}r'A[0_+a#|/w^Z%<;M8 pVIac&lb~T3V>Ŋ1M d}1TIr<'癬v[VW__&r/z9=Ʒ!a !k4+;g\8\r W^MHIؐҁQZF`SPW2g@jl V41Jn4ڠ(s1Ͷ_}8>A;񻅦7~zWubab}¨;]6_b/oɛXX̽!O YG[6;7|X>l-=Hr4>Gw2/$SPBYdn1?ب^U k.2.z_tNR,gB=_Pzc R =M$5FpwKv=x|ϓ!F$c}plX6tЀ" t^f_?+lz'ݤiv֢Pns\Xh\(J<Md?+N&1FwٰY{x aImwc=YZ4a2M2g!Bʠk\aAzr`>rls.f<qfhGX%0I=݉iu0|##IO\ꠅd'Q|]Øp^ c '|rt+sر1ڰ O<zX:8vkY w;s{ɮWr eeCP eKeB 5SM=h /%A UQP3Gf,lΧbb$roXo)ꅁGg2 2 צJ&"iF+p8ŧ3b33+[Jxe璇F;>_֔9Ƭ:Q|3e͚owÕB㡝':! X #AȥxgGL[`$O|{꧅Ƃ?. XA07ŝ"'m'<{ cz@`3&Λjb@pնUksNU"SЫn~R$OiП/@wj/tnkuv0Ag >4lmTfO\9Wp}6 A*O1geHY* mV(hthk0o@M(PU[)P#D(:*nTdϴ9tS]2?nہ.h/NrU{ihOJPJtޭU>:XmS@j"R U3@C? `qN;j6w?H~NI"&IJ rF03pAXXI-D%.!: ,:0JW;,),9t[Gl> T1Xkp$ NnM( pc[)MhΠaAxxe)R!8hXhs|W6co}gװBꧾ%&žԵ[Mw>yXg|O!! 3 eq)L{ғ]{nz.b˼9@`'I\0afy5t>nz>2[FXW-"%IW-Ap,!I 1+e,O.7Ox(6G@jFp 0NQH©T'76;qa1g'x> Ҙ!ɗoUYڜ? rge\X g;SܝҌ"!!AӜ( NZ_ DR# nauZXƶ=o9Ϳ!6Ǒ/62Uf~ݲ?]y^qGseZb{[iHj:7`i!3Y%4{QuT{9bQ>h/_"_삃ja[6iODO?&hW#R7/4} zdż #+Q$_5 <^l-#r843m8}mU\ǪuFqY; =BBv:YobP0"yJV!fUh ؅@ :X2 gLئaɶD^ QFǣVYŒWt*~Or },Ga1z__к*G_ܺ_Ԫc*xw=-W |+{?veB4sPm\Z9wӃO8ZEXusz۝#,%)˂$® 89C Ax+ H2y\dL0O ]RbOHu8!oA ś*pdsf}HkTJy5w j1T]3հ|`xF)M{=Ir.T4V+i#1ͬM yV 5[_cG~&+OOca׺u?Lt=Γ&[=/]O&V,/̫fU| mس>XQGvzc5Xv>o;?|w9'%v C Eka _z@ǀBGImv`] ]&@ЄVԡMiP4-0FGڦiy~ki"a1N::."RԽhDQԟP;w&B|#o8 r!̦~i]jJbK5u#y4e=Y% ZxHUTő2*!LU^fwxf\fFr_wTNHp3he}%WGgw2;2nCTm:ykкSTut!е#YavZXRBJ. (HAWvȂbTw+MrW*m _lfuBؾJZ<Y"]uFLyIx_7tbstoA8ݾ<4p5zM\Uo >䉋DbEYT`SYZK>عݽVoa syc}ԫO!b菨э !vGt:ʝΩWc̊ӕʒLܜ_0b&{P+ΈHvbYYZrpxBUm3BHB?R@?as+WEd?~xHRkJx5;/yr_Xyoø;mZ ]kʶʇʅ ؏ſyc_epFU8~d8ҀlQ)tG};3^aVXSݺRnIJ*;(@Ih]dwG`_ARq8 n#gI%.3&bO͏U)^53 QwY5؂ō_39<o[Q7Msc;1.CSȁCߥ'H]ß Ԋ_{˃kH"e^ yv6ņbC>Rƕw,G3^y2әW zPEz0 h5a/@%ۭo^ӯ+:Ō)3+m@ؚ Hڇɤ.(gH# vm4a(1c>ٹ8 80y@j0?5Q(׮&)>U},TKTK 0T 6f%&+Қi)Cr[3%ʬq mɰE)k"Z7Գ"5L\ I 'f`=xwnv7cv,],<_|?![*>=/QGl!cSl߳2}ݙ-V(L%fkGǁ,[Co#}ےܡS9:4ʝם%ڂ]I+벺ʖe]w啴+d]X-c0(\&@Zh!m$- icNSH81&C;2 z҇2OhxCYC5?K nCC.ttv;d7Z[y5qNa%9uPM*GpA %8ד!4P x 0/0aN&D IhatE>SsŦ>~u%5.{txH([|M0&F`ecb!ZO9;B* ז %dLB_RsL9t KrQX0(L]O ?K0~ûNoz΂wWMLywJ{n@Vhĸ F1QO˗e /?'?72*5ma7R*Q˨~j:I+EPm(EYX/8V$bxn-7Mpg+w3!%yo( %z>Gna͡KtI_ Ahpf`MLT\Sשz1~k;m(Ь`~w0&@$DlBB@Pw6Ϛ;05ϒӯU7N%[%pږXmmm d7Uטb!_*{`Nzvc></^^<֓tT 1nwQPxp†gm=jd*~5|I3D<^ɯoq4~=Sā #l&p8p> pC T6Z*jmCpW܆e~ܟ%Cv*.(3$@[8m >bShX l]SP@:@\qyfVb:f xQ su/^?|4DXOw(O//ͬ};h?^S[\瓇&^Sάx1QG[Y< lP-W7EemvO"кO;7`6h1)4[0-y~-u$"}>1E>Ys\ntR{wSh=!kc0HvՄUӉ5ନjјBU~tr:M4ۭ<=?nK8I&`Bf\"tIf98lEPruuL¤%+pW`{d&;p^-D<zE-PD4 HT;bg 45\mamnAСnyN@^j1?R t_T?TF͐yQP? Uuҧ^9e: |sl8a,J4f[9(Mf\ȕAS=0Ɋ ûO4={7 TpPa/N6Ƿd JyXJtv]სLfekOIgNcuё-8`BJB `~S`+vq2~;DuX;yڄN| &͡,PΚIÀor:4Jz@#[qkc5x{ŸCf2VtbuIrcCvFq]3;ٝϾwfvgf>YljR ԁԦZ[jAɏ4@ jRGTbyA+VJVԇMϽcm${Gs99߇loYCߣꁦ'a1mdJ&QZCH&QmcҢV<½0~AZ)tK6*۹v]ch18/۵f!/`۬˚,]0g7߼!6ľ.}~+kXʙivĞ=3EI$~%s.v^*+s8(_ תjD&`ĐԤY4!uի݅ m`m.tafƍ2ִK`$D.i$a[fqq6,˪Fò8M ڨK*IJS!ӵ%Z`"aA:$O#KF/eV";Bd2_A7FPd9'—Hfh2cjժ Vpՙlf5PM7[FS`FrQ 0@G[]ϏlطSgSzO-̑B4 tH?o7R(Y2=)Aa}xCP8Fz`=}+ qA{R@/7yΟ>MwQkKࢶ&S֭fPȭxbR&T[JJ"yͯ-qCE BGAg$`Ǡn6[dI0 ٵHP)$n:,YMȊ rVJWTf . qF@ 8[&~# f.AuA NeՖ:y^( uC F}eY*r sFBٜj4G,F2#!YV6 /nmñB>/R$$YgS^M 6Bp-Wºm*ʫ𤋮mvUoza^SS1m00UXE*QSQ?[gu  zC!~~=rD#(fi4[ȣ.@ +avKe#>/tH"0ďC<9TÁ1`;Kj /yCj+Ww &2)̂ڽCE a$?$*%P\WyzS;c&bLlڈϢ &xKP N;ң.uo =LLEx[44 wGh]=ĴL5Gh1 EJ-۽;y}@HoMse\'<+w!G+W8pbԄzxtXǫjWėi%Q>ƣ▨^UV)@tD4 ^/sJi2ҧF&C`Ƞ4S/9AE/)QOhR{|Xv  ldCeߙٯ2q+J(OCF rV?  W9Bޠ^塉kI8B7ԉ[`Eݖ*iwAg/D<P?w?؜34*)ȹ08 濬W l3fvYc`  Q\rALH)P4  EV UdO+$`JO}3U:>޻w?قB@mu/fH0ro Y=A=)= ^_ ޸}@itXRmi4Yl)9G?n3ē[{< +垰n|Qck}ٵKi=Ak9x%oD61#BI fɩce[ %fesJ~VWV3ei/tΙ6J;=pz 3#-{G'(;:#euT6@ 1ֺ"kQm2aF2ϛj/D3Od~M^PML}(\F3+%Y9ᰎ2abqJʐ%@cpcpcpcpcpcpcpsP28gd gɕt*өxLa>>t>ݦe5RsQFD|DZߩ{NsRkS\.|ʿ[ZoJ2*hzcHʆXg(slj(> GT6fc *Zk=uHiC))ehh`߽^ߡ˓/t;>$&<d̤G;AKcT)#b=D<&v] TihO/` Lfs >QH&YOK[sL*Zicla,I|ȕ3'h \k`?l .^Y7𜇵bnIyy蟆haNDy9/F@#|pȎ`a_`{dbq[aߓygi!AylgZ7E$Gώa{sY}< c0"e_e[1u(hqg.="Akb kGx?7Q[ H1}^eMoBâW-6x cfď aZO^N/L)ƺcV -Ry[OD'E э0S.6^͵R>־F Uh^ ύ$ٵ!ȱ%lψk:6Ssg1{u29Nlt^Nn؝~<.1c$9q`qe\ۯ"w!Jk(JF ڤ[kc9Ux'eTSQڜy\Fn̟F αZ7Oc?>,%k> J{4y1֓S؉Xu]{jdޜMOh˩j(olvs+0U4cV5N<.w5/ez("u@9Rr>{jaY1ZKT*ZW]|ZB#C>2+6p f}`#NjmGsf1DF-c5bF4@Gv=>_:07i&UO [=yK{vAz3ڭt`gu1_C|3nSC1 [;gxOm}U1b$T.[fdh"_B jxBZi_w;/FZ~vZ=xǥR/8iCWP=9}SuG;@nhσK{B?V`^u\x&P!.Bn(`+ߡʡ:ь\RPס㟠Fbff>m]d= hMk2u򏲪w}oe00$ $$P @HOY*: \͌de*1D2"TdTZ}yܙ7g{;?=G}>g w׹XZQh'8;>/*tQE\sD,rtȱx>#v 97vTQ ;{ #HBku%ehw2'ۓaw ?h ov9aoFff?y<}BU4Q}JH+O3!N^۾5oϺD+֬7wi,'ZM9@ujYϪ56t{UWe:|f/Gbkb\ =-=Hk=օЖw+b5a!l31wkv'>䲴i.-sgZ>1rjeQ W2@ⓥsy?iyGl4+sOyJr\r{ys9_Ϋ!vKr͖7$l:qtQ%_)>&g?&#)BjLa3EOr@ePv)beN{9oU}Ț[G`,tpM[sd7E 1֡BZw(wܙ\, j^8.$fOÖ'0m&_?Xf7c<O@L'yT'J vZ) ꄺH̠`,C`gkWIm0=:М7m}d=ʺR=d-Eljղ&1NzPC)MϒRjuRt)^H+WMNh<\j@÷!^/]*!J6um3YM;l'>*hWmmmo>&>yLmIq5yw *,u2:0FEړ7R~t,yMv0Fh.gI)忕2E:+SW R+S7?vZ+Ʋ?vp=V Sgh=oS#rh)rMN S 糥 ,gɹNߡhy2ѿUHu[* V9/8Lh367ƝeL\n>>jI;'kRrimtG+659ճ]2!9{,f6YmxqQYro_2 cP (ְ zN|m{,kl;=wٹL\~e:uU=W6R}v>X=Ü yz6ձo8OS.[־im5zq[kNs;oͺUu{f\1ކHvu:Q_gߟSZ>uO墶=DXl-HÕ;'? 5vP K% n.J|VHI`.H&gA=_#cmŸP3GFqѭ vD;糝ߍI'.{{>W]"ӚFIky5KMp@⣲ڛ>-r}sF aA hm}B{mJjz=8}C|W\Ko G5W!vpEcE{.e>|kėM XDo ?zxUr6ysF`Ʃ=wge\B?j"IcSdmq wM+|ofQ|E何%44w [] /zoaMEmVwVo}k,?Z^u Ӯyc/ƾҶsmjۤVzYU\aYd1 mXLx 3Öa=(+ &a(-ؗRD@) HHIBHI h%`+|߽す*S龯oӧٌ k]aR=C^QG@zd<%Z7w;z98u%uK3Iç1R:\;COZe<˾.n& ֠3S^Ϳm1E׷ h+=33W`4v>Z*c Jg$>;#W|]K^ta_mC><_/]Jb ~PPޫs۹ӈ+m(^ c_cEqN)vy[NUZ'P_yz58RVT]K;):g@|?O.Us)xvYte(}Hc.MC)y#v%LE8^)]Ҫ~иqUujR`8ՉC7qv"g9"WEx$`]Ď5ɘdʧ8 c5*LYl}<⏵_۱Q:ml-{z8  1y>᠉Wq(kbdgvUi%!NF*MQN+;KC|Ag/1nm}q;_e)?})_ sHzrwGd:b$ȉ؏]dtEjT7<ꠔ|/Lw|R۠YQQ?JK2jy O\Z| ñ.Q.D\ho<\ih4Z%0߰PaMV)ۥ-T@s^2~휿J3Jzc8$ߩd_: .Is"ҙui .Q.tHwݴ#Ɩi;]w˧ӥ[vF-Xj$.<-Ir7o:}ЮuMam)ȚPn/XF1}/sI=3{|R`>fNvy1|.t<ƾKiHu_%w\#kFLM uO|wp@ļ;wg1Cm.%ߥc\ѽm{2>EWcdsښ=6=ﺞ~gɄwsQdrNnģ?ѱ8}+yΝ1|fPc?Szf3~>IY5{%N{ wݠt)"( `"t%CW-u0ŋĻ:_=)s 2.a90ڪ KRA}åGBAC}P* 5" V5xi*?#[ռ +ьN^~%xt7boJwM cK({G5)HQto0;7E8Kg'1K7)[qηvo>)2Xdn" Kw<`?#b=,9 $6G&㜂),djlw`p\@mWh_-PwsPTLJlI^ y3XUiwkC{[64:ԇAi >տQQ;5FweͿc~-uм7{Xm4=)c'XϜ`GԌ]"$sڊ7;\o+w{_1U9rAbO$16Œh#6 I=mv3 ܁}x-!]Ylbt/U~Gl}9ϦvGmҴ;Y)sı4d{ DUIDM0ĠL!FP66=@1suSB css~q{jYQvm4~k;F^]5T/ޝHwV}8g?]|{f܍ƹ'G{Cܝ:SZ൤H8Ses#߂+-˼r f{Z~%{TBǻr%sz[h@w$:c=8{#-K1A}<밟\EWIiѫ;q pJ"zC7؊3U/A{PVY+tuVKg$qn:zfvў/vpQv'd +ᣓ~gy_.l-Lbg(Vt܍8~!⦍S~G!޵ͅow74w,54Gĺx.s#=S6W;ŻA|C}I}~}|_t 6(Z99w"j>2A]KpgUBoK`9jٺIkM}֢~?n!/0a0~|_.J3 *@? /a}vȯ/¿ZB׫ :??/,,,  J:4 L>mԮW?j?1E5p0PiPS!]nj DM®2?Ž ,-|hYjo ë p80 Z"eJ>煭l>};hOW\ѝ<%OV!G -RAY_<δ/Z#Ö_LPR>ptm0k-?Dk\vFor[l_hht}t`~"߼^tN99y|s |QrTj&ˈƋxaYr_[R">!6+FZvGExpbeHOoco x z 'Mb&5ؚId1CK;hyj~tkoC+8`82Ŀa%8:@ ЃNjEH'0d 5%|5{L#1C`(еC} F"V쁵NFiAFyƩ {y,GNBI>IYm邴']j.X{YLqjqqb_ o'o%&`"ZJƁ)QAɃzFǣSQ>ON%ShxTE ZMc:xOc&x5,:7q[7}npg#+}~>a;{}njGamFv :՞G^^]e E{z^@T9[@o`-k&h' 2Az%8dH٘r Y,sL=uWuWSGuvkςm^Fy ԕ8]$kN~#A<-"MF:%'$*͌>٤}<կ[TG4k6ZSA9;n؁uhO6v}JA܌̛;ͱ7ȱ7dI*17褶kۯ%;`#`8`0$im^8h!h$h4NazѰZ7~7~7~76G*TX}7 emY}?}o}/|O}K>g N5w}^ ʨXeɰ6t,!a6bBiFE4%2H&r Z(Od򸈻X ąEb:T\$hv)i9/i@TL-ݑU+@JR a_d$[$ߓ;d $JZd?&J3 zEA4%Z:)SAߕ2_#aL2"td5K&kAd2hT]wAMSԙ>*S&;f'IL%Y nv"MQhQ,i@f`~>.S525u2|+zvej. P<e2Tz"Q$*RytB'Ήh~JVIx7 :')+n1>sNCz= r_7ŵ_܄*?3W\xXd ˤv)Ij8(z/PNMVc Q8:,œf{jbYDv]Q0/-zQݰ!YGhde]W5m1{Y|ÛOX+O9v:Z xXXX:=bgtڝ6's'asr3V%/GݦM,0dʔKliU&r͙5e[ ϵDf$ӗ%f  4MDk3k9JZrtF8Z6 J}\϶y_-yk7}霵*-REۉ-m홈rf*e[|ۆ~w]ۧmfmVtwS;dh}"vU2oi0͋i֢yQEڨE-:DRY~b͂Z@C!DJd0`0͛5ͯ_S9J׆نIHbah*7f4 #"?u)\LJJTDph+]t;_1S>Bגŏ{E%Gݻݑ$b^:^F> endobj 31 0 obj <>stream H\͊@}݋&jݟnnp1?3I$ĸNNМTǁTmwm3U4SCvJM[nj.(:ˮ=urua]wX߆: M{6Po}']R;YXBNE_%rZf?5ySXLsbNPОScXeS0)YYِّ__7- 9O3ϑ d:#g3pF:#g3kWלAhAhAhAhAh PСCA ;tPѡү+ ү+ ү+ ү+m ң( qaqaqaqaqaqaqa7Co {3fl 7CoFћ;;;;;ħw/Ta[´ M{vM;U!¯+ endstream endobj 35 0 obj <>stream H|{|LkΜ5D$593(u=[7ՠ\ʽ*Zy  RPixśD07 *ESz;LY{$H٫E려F MȠĨ&/p pe!Fs[%NL۰xwp¸KoZryʓDCN1B_+!)c?oONHnխ!vQcwFãc.(tL}Q)PĀMqG&h=osw)2RYD (e!NOFÒ5`lCzlDJy+љ@r !PQ!j5o)ie=<}jX7^ 5~IӷyZyݶk_?aDN?o>?g?ի?Y~?bAQ2:&6n'%9*cƎ7&N픴゚:mzfɘ;o/Y+V^f: 7Ilݶ}]ݷC'O.:S|\Xz򕫸^f( m@8h8aH.QWY zJcT)])eKZmOʤE!$ÁJZLKh)-CĤ#=\VJZEYMI^M)/ZZGZOh#m\Ly6N; .S:͠vK>T~%?M:HTf!ʧt1 z؂Tq*Ԉ L'ů;LdtNSb:K(BI5<Ht 1EM)]t3y9sy3y/Cy /:^yUټsx ulkzyf-v; DŻy}A>|Q>ǹOp!S| Y>D[:.ѐ̲N"eW_2op9[;|}C~v~'t5Nedjuut@]]o4W=ss^}m,X{"I13$! ҔtIc1h.-u+;3tN:E43t&\-_bė _k|oM+ʼr«^̫#t}st.\C=YOzgcg9z"@/ԋ"'#zq^e1jk^SN"g"g#"#"FIo[VަsSһW 89S9939s6p.E 0:;b']k=ݱ^`_qA8Pck8G"\ 7&ܔ;܌s sp.X p!.Ÿ2\+p)6esWjs\5>FR$ĹdCBC(0׹%|]%|Ch ͠9 ߸&GC S#4?CxQ<SxY<^b ^kxoMomw}|,2, 0S2 e-g#x92A&(IR %&O֓I2YTF>t!3eQH6աO H()R))2)˗M9KyO 2QcjBM5ԒZs<@/Rk#s LRGD ?ԕ>>SwA=>ԗQ@i !4Ʒ方m) ~'oylRSfMEAZdA WhJHEg:&MGM?_;Kޥ{[zf `>X`1?%rX+a5;~¥\Ɵ:^@3ּaq9M7ʟ6.[o?>O- \̿D|(b)fbX$U(mb)v/_7[_0ߛ9i}qDgqY\?D<cxPl;sɕ\OqP UԈp!ZH'6l'"kWD)_[|_ʉr@N49#V<9OɅrqΖ˕@kEn^7Z<"c<'ULޔe|$dQBiʪ8UKŋ*Q42TrTjƪhZSU$PuV]TWMuW=TOKV}T_OW@5H VCP5L Wy`ƪ7s<{q^/K2l/ &^ yzo7M6d3|lfy,4KJ֬3&l7^>vfw=K/0A Q0)L 0?l6 [m×vaCXv ;.aװ[=A{GQ{'I{ʞgY{ΞE[l/j ~\p.:%sj܈ĺDQW..Ƶnƹ[˭m*M'/e]U/M6 !d_H"",BBCtDPG50HXA! QvE;IBv8/gޝOs{v].Nq"))/zK8aN),bXLCGqOme9@ usJ( %R@8>ޠԑ:ы2u?QWzQwA=UE)RR_Gi A4J4Ig.arLCh,GhxPCtQ:FRI:EJ 2:GTATETCnw:O퐍]! t\ٸg!tyRV:D֡:BGd#(Tu5^gqֳmˋj ƒ66F MlS6-:N:Aԃ`Du_Ol݇ha{q{"[lOS-=k9[n+lն6PEzAas9wN8NS,ΈLBT*Q-jDV|'.qU$~uqCdNta.!*]V2Df:V01jbzSfgӪDrP)2UMS̓j,#d̕Y*Sf|dYdYƤ+cd,eL2I 1/G1㞺~ab3#٘LqL 3Tq&JśhĨLWI0̤+9Ŵ`Ĩ^o"'Ǽ}EE(d&Ǭ1kgf5/zl4fle_P2Ez 2Mdp<Щ (2-MieBLkjژ0n" 9[>5B}+!|G Q_}`tkP A@/BIS:\HH 1TX@k m:Yb AD%+6^H`!*qp}N؉xBMXiYꎇΜc*_R0چAXބwC=fhhwaCLnw7 D(~#R`,-Ic/{K 8̕G"%AZA_|L ,b]%Ϲܛ 0nb\i陦 je^G?f]}V]uR 0 ʻzN7jO =ټНӸeKpugiϢ.fZպB^ /Xh9~4MbMLKaK6lUi򖗕הUFu]ݭRQUS?jIk |?}ow_Eax7Whr橏k ePb81oW**>vSU(ʃJg"*1Fe/Q-eOl c_Ip\D9:CO(`״]|.]Uc6di}1w?–+b𿱛(Y]wu%xtAmWU爱Sl /m >aD%edU5C91xS DE`KӒ&Jc:+=6 =;DVN~bQMzVZ' ߿#2C5l&e9d*ދ2[Mcz鰬sT5 dN@雾WK.9uI5 uxqV#QSvެ6u`xM|cݵaz={{iHv-}l~Ye_Jzs;JqpB]xE?c[rgݔ2܅ݽgߓ a˨CrE:HeL2]t+e刷*.Cık۬B:/sCS'hb mmȱ,ځub4b^D1CwE<Dd:_C4 }C={< 9"GcSB?בi-:X6ϋt Uz/?}];;ڷmoo}ml5^u/:Yl钪bcQH_ w+W͛{;f,QiEFE-*ZF$-tRSyn{lT8838Y@_O뫣zŅCϱg K7^^Ɋ]0[O~'i7`ℑ-Rx&3`1˓,YJT I1h%L3 `nKQ/fG<Jx_BeֳsH.@]vI0s"XA?Amߙ0&S%8Cn9_S#8¦6kÖ)a,}=wk$%ޣFq1C1:U&u4BbCа weq}TJu4?;%&wz 4^Sk\uzIL{Z+?k^ 6a}  ĀB  pƍLŤ1pS]%E}/"|T7 k#-8;i#(g9n? Ȯ@PRG |;l,pBi ‹BoUu)mƿꈶz/a ʘ6EHm0iyl:;Σ^PS#_2^srַV: 89"S/h |/"2k$r #J.Qr suO;F(ҋlvE1ȄnC6/KL 9(r]Ƅ9(^A"n>iƜkfZᨁ۵v~EAvz}%׸4ɍG 8]+qeaZ»e:si5oJYZ]tJ1xovS2i\Qf:0] bj%_ʕrw.eRbGi/-BƄ)Dw+^ݲw^V?l߻:is|s5om`ubǺFx8} .?(>(*$Z/J?m97[~tD^ӑ $3^^6Q`^Pie?}x3We‚;#dT\,Jp4G>"h4yaçg.x/b/8P8\ԋC[E [8Pd(2!#Ṙc3]ɣ0|q@ 3Dx-.,Vت-UXL /,\kiCqKĦ!4cf9$}>cp9PhDH2I?xTO2 z#iL>;a 6PўÉLHi<UpESt*i9 qNp޽\5GV\(bVz<}l `ioqCPBN%Pb>%0cp˰X fW B!ߪ&M.篜wJpN-co,7uo;zO]l̵JM{5uSz-cc#UJuA`&QeP~⧘4`vN&se?4vZCxt1!t=v^H ecuInZ$v$:RO)"e׹l[螯%o~d~2*_h,@LLmL'>JwjLFCDͺP~yD>&$/OvYVDL0kY3ʶ-O<>Ȅf]Z2 K V\,hHvff4SZ ]mFM`JA޹{*/bmp33̤e5:``EN(1&4DWȊ&+[V%$KVeK6)çBM80&r j9l2nJHX2@33m)vΌS)@)%6d=YJs*5ST*+S|7li Xz3ꬢxbs68_-a׎Ju{97vV/X[77{}gǎ&-O_h\U}`oƷ^@/~PMsŝ;'s'[\RY9E/)ކ̍FŰ$ ^EIz!8HjTBZ1-rL*_&?BC)R/:%H K@n͓JC[2J>,jJ]>0}&9ƙ1lP}\`&a] &5YGaX!lA.dlQHԈA{ }n<߭==mOq ?n]uȵ?'2ZTPrT%4pL˂04DŽ84Mٹ%, (K4l3"6![@叽ٝ}ڻ/T7Vm|'gߥqr i| ]GU4T;)Q'(#V2YR-ÖQ$Ε Cgi1Y $5n}DƊalʪ[֯HSR; dt*R!α,/U ӳ2;WZt+-*\jmÀ{Nj φX CP?E!b+q}&f@x"QB%(AςJÜA%ծc2]X6*BO>"om \f@RIQN*r;-]ԕ# bÏO "I>ẋ C' 1H e%:C5eHVW>jbKUoT=0 Dxx~:iJ|>5G0݈(>1 Wiӹ 9 JA"}*h/eچ:QXAohJRi Y dC0 Ê3M1AN!Ư2գ Uzٵ `_=va1mH*vS\#MlI&NQdYVYd%@CI\%/Iw믴o$ %9 K"gxZ ̓-gpWy2wY3S;TXJ:gs̩BNI~"Mq|!հς2MW9Ph?ۗJf aCgP -2\%~|?/OQxYNlʁXdITo){!MVt T-^"S\7N? NNŇӿ:sƼSEnaإ)|ϫ֩wsnQo7m7w?t?Ap\wrr:l6Q &r{"3>Gu 8\V`t@hE6Q8ɪ-OpKRE0@ѮNƂ#T&ZotbֲfQY,̅|/|}>.P:,IZNrDM|Z/KMOdOdM|2>5v wr27TW"%%8u˹=֗m\CyxK p :%Qqk2D`NԸ$"4e/جtweXgbsӵߌӼ7( kibӏD;~rGo?jhx|n0_iГ5l&i jK8xiK*E|Uj999R.2<а(+]#YCJ.U$l#JaNRmc{HyOgȨɾqo#] cPk 'IW~_>ɇk6@|)i:B"%e EMil_ű/v P9Ү>*V>VRB&hnEmP * :mh6mMe2kž;|>zV4u}5`SJ $,oKLtDρ`"0,EhQYQu'qcEIXXdt,ТH_KH`"/3k ;6. }KP 9\ptRth,$_ Q Q^pndžAUUsE;y).m Xz>D~SiƟBPS<fuuF%M3to2o/_^@i%+zԆۨ`7,!zyO_[[-2[ uH0ë瓄;ãa** 7X8BäcuX8gMϳttn)y˶ }23#}6wU̮y39J_ @߻Q).3m[m­De M:΂=.z_2$)$KflAQA[YK- BO !P+6ؕX" 6bNA23,5$nn'݌ aIYz|xs%Uq}9s^ouw㕷OǗٿowd ),/8v3p~fzS{W߮8{AcIe?6`22xx̐Pt^JK¿nԘ`+F.!H*&/N0w0 {2ݑ[="3JK]DtfHd̀LY~,v**tڠѐa2|`eiZ?L90u97ԍ[ӽ/dj#W}VP]н{=(ٿ0?xL,NYSbʛuSS!q{!rIjj!pȂY Z򆥰m)>_N#|4/EK ym}5TSY߉wig}LKݎng_^_;aǎ#D>>g~q6MTF9IjJ)^6Ov9ϰLcQE<2YgQBOPz>N%D2 02˥]35cę4dv1]&e**ŎLFȋ5r'x}1 0F 13Ks 7>m ^ia6def=T0eK$b j\+;yjƵpU4Xr~ɳk4iruCؘJ̮ZblOzu'mG[-oluW;۷b˧Oֿvs3͠}>q! 7{'S(ћf7);=˿X/Jͭjn4Q"rc}X[ ^ -a7Pƀ6v6ϋ iwę/ Fh*Jh}4Qlh ?-X(Lw7ꦲ޴0'It'3|%CH(R$ P6TvAk&URh@j:o g'9ΆZ$[yL ]*ܬ?ͅ9 Txf5%1=O7v\;~;k:{cݢ ?m|a3Z3u{;G߾F6 ?9Az@mx28JMUbuĉ`RTF188R?fiWr0[yMNarr-s>A*׺tOHŒ_e%dHi-kqYrRJ9'BNk[B5yXXz.S+QkԷ]ţmVmS 1 mp_N쎚d% TU}U2/*aY+s!PmPǪ$8C?|:mDHb<k8,0!Q8SJ 7PnSj ݰ}qc|0"*ΊHh!oo3<>8>_cuo:eF.Cxөv| lb_|Tb1^<)5F 6d*.Ng ?~ɳEޢY#3 ]# ɢ 2 oj5'c1t>ϋᰈӴvO)S;i>M#Z lI[+XtLmN~l+ ᒋqb\0ĬSOm-^/ n!N/m_@aLx[پLno|&riwNs+bJ28t+i:r:/ےLGTJrTFOADުKG,e,T,6YL<˂9wRf&oDlaX*@w$%T"f=/rW )|cNIB&P9,OR[ͭ~:y(5D-/TYf八G.^SX -]8Bje+;3] Nyl2Vɷuf'LL*b]vxCWߗl|eM6_-0Ye.az@88" Ts*d }!A|.ƙ _\((˸2Y^SH8(1u)6̛̋%&kg<f<j?K6ih=BDnEg8k^z8Hl [}to":NCMIuub# &Du7z.* 渂PP1M=ܯ0A/J'|vuT#PpkX( PZW2Nu^":is1zapyKg6j<1ֱG`ǻ; Aڽnݑm3.fcPp.=X+'o$SR$tYo\ۂ_a<ŻkN˧c01aCpTڪ4d@:Mɰ>EӢ83+8@?>(Ig܎$Hdzؙ ag*`2&1IOW%`7dr+vs5dO8queF~+?@\&5vP82 h8Pc8g_s9%qK,cm` Vm2nB P6?։"-TtDibIU*Z& 5jZi3JщC˦%7w(z<;c-LY-/,_奒H .uZo`J)5F|@+SF0-r(~-j`%16<݌? '1! 0|Ս4E׈xx "UO===9\{8 pXYla1;c5v=7zZi>h!A6F֯AfPh3)++ }gS/720GBO/>WGy?o}2 }`w{퟿/N[ ?U2ίnz7O|Vʶ%@? 1{`fs? ^]Uw YZt-J /حv+Ҩ4:ZuF_Ԣ#"w&Gyga8Jw|3ÅM]'T p ׿ =<e1GL]%zUMSU9j iKN*kf]Pϫк3@4v<|2ijY ^I “1د~^®t忱@1Ł Ժ)+o~ܲ;2u[Qf.uCxy- ?b/nSS$XL^y }ǥp)@{ϋQ:#{# $xz2xy6B~W&1oxEUֺb+,Aּ닓5K;ݙ`מ8r;RODBq;~ ~b_}V8#`5gvg=gg=~)yso4~>ا|?/^ ؅f0Qv v>btT AuM{#^>{=>Ct jƧ='VcbΣ? U*\K}kZS}[-hR|tmfbdش%eSrz ~KO`)JXV]~"A QȠ\r:6 EjrZ% 6# Sſ'L+dֈsdF,*?>wpVBp#ǥ@&\  ئ3~s&ol\_+N|/ JFht@(ф@[VG%ZX)cT6[GWmP5u<*Jchm`-Kr9:} SUÞvWK6iA;l}εjtNԢǣYMOxNP&+_ G]#ac ߀4 L8p0h;'et!eVXk>o!.[uC7FUs6Z6wz{kW[6-{@8:u\do Py%OilX槱TEN7t5Dbq|)Ӈm:m bbxӹ@("NgjmWjY F2K[VrMq|v8+/[֛`T)Ѥ6Qk>^Rڬ/kNe>7&e08.kp2s)6q& KMU$v2O-pY..+]d;o5{yj)(W/q:RE>WoХ.2@xZ~|g^eWM/2;cZ}ujD fn Itɔ,.uE9*˭zԊҨCvnsٰ^RyKߠ]. \͗Oץ5fkw!;dOm3)W6=X$ $ŔyH >WL>MjeIqpʮʍʵ߼}9golr :9ٵhS_ڡ"5I^xi^Qƶj[#n.|?`5&{YgB6]J2Y&`a#Ȓ_×5,zbBF#b%YS{b3DƓ$75F$M&l(.K!rYoowx)XX|A*4xbB!^ޡ(8_ >,oe[dKyAm#Grj霚n2Hir{'1BDRK3vb=C?v2u^F]Q'} j5d%|g 5U ᄟGKgON#ӀOμ?_h}e9]6C17U%û^=}K&[I[n.&;.qg>#G4h)Q⅊5e"]B`hPk JaLd\ҪRSSMVi4Ź;ٖ}<ײAGCp׹<#Xжe趕ZҢ (G(-sیx*%$QJdIviYzAi+ҡnu#{Yi3|wkXݽ̜J->IɅ=r,!,Ko^4W.㹠% 5>Mtmo~~X0RgN s[a+d"A9*i#IwVc M=C};s| k|ǥ?-OvJp?γկ=ЄG7>ge//j\h\ܿM3{i7bA }Nm2 ЩHRv3k[yPC^Oꏃp$vh%-˞ɫD#LMOo3kO٬Z`Xͅjj%ojP8 UYŁʞ֢fv=#G&&Pm,Y "]'Yy"\ÖБDHx /F2YKVA| aŦ *[Qp>p \liiwi ] bml0=sc>4NOAh0$N/4O 櫦1.w}P0/قzVaA\(B_x58F@}EIWQ?{|`J2Euj߻y h?';uWwp+3GƎAyZ;6 0i+J{uԺ]YT df00 m׫VVV6aTUG~ns=+gE.Kr)Eʸ,Uj&-˘AS1U3>#BE,W}к@i[;f?*Y# FЀDuKVOOs8V)syW2BX! *'FҠe IBY܂?wjCkF`;&B L즈.ݣa7k-Vċ&_B"rjL -z)G-H(iI20GLH:%k `$+%Y2# <]x981M\%hp):V8 #D[:b3Zenutt{X\U`,ަ0Ii@+n-SErd.LݲD,Wg(ƙ3'IAL^FeфIydL5JG>n HP+y5I!פ`~ípV} GvD5IBjWoàHMxL!'7d)&Yvꤕ!V>L!O12Zivᮕ |TuINSQxh^=?3jc8ޮ=|}]V%&66&F Kŀ[ *5DۤUC?D+EU8&E RPhEϝ٣vޝ}f}ٜC- ?8f\ٴin\Gw'#_AeziZ-oЦ݆D;Ѭr}h%p C×5k_ ơ*YE-7o^cI{Q_}+n{%ќRy_JׯF.%"b#csќz^cfkglݫf~(%`rۋ؝hx)8^r/rl"g:ՍT_5V3jFcMNɱ$;P^ &-h F[ ǃzT^~:ιS,0ZU6j<njxyeƫ~ ZZl$)8Q?5OՖ4Fo:^RT6SjIe2l1eriцF1Ga5 GݿiՍmGp2:8{6p"!+nLy|b dBd|[l8ag\ѐtƧ0^$DSWq yUk$1e9R֠t},VfI }߂^#zX0kcvǛY:ZV{p YjEӘ.ailMՓ*.Lè`@,Lհ[ ]I|@@͹H !W—A yK$Fq5B$0yKqm|2LXI;k87Cb1 a~$0, G!g/M cs;/K/GѣZ'׬S[7"2zӾ s\q1:xZ@ @9r(>n|4a)4&c?2h~a ޛ鷘cDf1YqD˰(#UWPx$w F/"ly (/(OqX,HXFFc)#:[^Z0@ryDH4 Ո⁨MUoۖ!D>:!%ɸBA1y$]4/Srfzsߝ%w /{"ߞIMw+} U1~=./?jmt懪:gUu>᧟-<~#W83#MM\WĢ?Ͱ\ȋªT'`dalk+MDOD\;Ct~f hX}[L寕-gukĻ 54ZҙF->o>*ǿew,2Mnj>̡SPkr~c;&W*>!=PH6ECq) (B8 ]eMܼ z.L93,w A8!lYH~o7;ye'dۿ< ȖһPvɺ/8VTهև!H+{!#yG 8&C)@,RG% xcpHb`˔Yc;cc )CPIjPfts~-22 * ` 'iB>)RW?Fҋaۍ|Q(Mi5,{{[~@|їҭBq?)Ojj=}iEGljEIIʒ'* ܖܿ*9nE~D #GŘv;/yQkl$mH*bd$1u?Cng( CG'LHrp/׮}g ; FO$nxAX J2MM^Έg \uRדi@%> k7t.O ''! ƋpQl*N%\[\)#*8A$:##u xUߥiK?CX\uC {*[l[1bǵ,ȎTFyprW2?]ʌ%sdmE虷g3<i'mH:{+cuՊzj́C7v>OpD<5}G wߩݭ]ɭ|iWwuw&קFZ?y@Wvt zj]qwW HGx="RhWE***bJ ^׫jV2vjr \VI{ž<̣s܈(&( F?]ΝYz_CR%[X>-Qȃ}\;I|+|?$ʟ2y<o"!#(>]Ikf<䒳"/~6֩rL8$.̂ |`U@5E5lpLkR *_:4r!d Jr86:C9oώC53{z5\_:AuZrQawz虡:Ihƞ Ogv?d[[=wxG]]˛Zlb~7߄ B2Ze).(T7Ju$L#q]Λ&|4G5g!zty+C"$az/.Qc{(F߰߱] 6aX;B; )q8&er,7 )TU|;;W+5ږHܠ{h(-d^]DQ #Nޜ49dj&1L)9mk梹l:yEeo6Nw6xʩ) ,ʣ 4Q -";k{P~ݾ}<Կ$(j⊟KTA 0 *rdD$3 sQʒaN  bypMayjnEqx$\ea xSbRs_v,DS0Άa.UoQQ(a^#G!$aF$)8`Upi,F.[V2!.j@:EA9O=+<+&SgSMM8}ֈ8bf2&Ѫh/lAmXTܕcwڷ4PrDjC;w>ƻ/-<{Ʃ+Od~흫({P"0x|>a öl׾j{U*l_aoUߗ@aU`ƽM ·,&rjYmyҹ8[|U% Z>2,W}vptͺ8}cZ$ qNdxSM -ߐfk2lC2Ȋ{2Ilrw{3|XB45 h᫈.e@P'L8A'<@"L&L:@ TM\a[Ֆl@bYRa.YUzʵTILٖu*ެ7fkД ARLYqJnv4 U\.>IY{!5DH= i=zx_箯!?*#}m<ܑ3;D#la3󱬠)M gE(7DoWS52(<Ÿ 0O#z0{5^dZrkKRneMY e:e#\atSͺ>+ 01r U1>2hS;?@M ++ȴ1wwG{;]m=g!-9~NXlꅸM!5_KfR eN4[ k6Ft71$4I(oI>X$F(fMhvU9k:[%iQsJis2'%yUeo; >7Zq5pyP}6z([/v(l7Mw3b~ TC(c^tG]6 Ux[EqQBݚkMu9)ptJݒjK.r*"$o4ĺ#Hm`0lr_z:g=Roֶ~]} ۿbk~[s (:昸R`72|3%>Xh?,Zf/zfSqjlw_v,[XK{K­½oS٦`S1}[S\S]%l8M/?9**_9L_1AVPj 7\xcaJƚ<ɛ`͛`7aQ&Y;!"4TXFLݤ̵޼%Ci/!(N$wdxKeTd"1XHp yC)6sd߭m|R!иgJ5z0Fbwݛ12-Vc# h0Ď YxZdAa/UpRokEIׇ.凟*sU#qgt٫f|Zqp+uIZê;6w=Xx<τtqc0;֊봱fo+16Ɣr8h2S֊Uj J7,RE-M,E XH7d*,kH=ѿcW$s{5ommkMr`Yo>[BLɅ֜pxz~ mcvC?Jlw0`Olg5 1~"i=:,ߣ8:EԔєe!.jTB:eၩÎdP$9$(H4NtyK^o-^ddVC=gF7{1,b&lHH T$ht;E6d}>ʩC4drv㛙zh nOUjJKYI>$:^--ySd|wٴ6&MN_vD5$X8frԑ=v$ {'v}Bۈ8ٗt,@c@MWCAT´`߳ ;4qˤ#c(xA4DT}-SaF85*Jx!(q״S@׋Р;% J J=Z`O6J3j]Eii0ܽ ߖBŕ[ebY1$ 4HRO3ܱ> jDɁD DI&5yɴ059Lax{4A^ox<Ӿ)(h XXQiB̖٘2@ u{t:3\,eV3̡$CvǶqܯ؉&46vNjt]kvqnwVn'?$$Wg-H7P+!N?v]oHiCB$M]E&} T>yc'~y>?̨V!ї{+=+TPo[p6L{eI5+%‚"F $U\e^4+ X٬ܬ+so9CɄ3P;.{ރG4!ݑ(ח݈f(>,.1RCو a^+%:۠@Cmy9tyх3]2&|q;ڷD#UMT㗿~g~qԺ-X>~5,KNT\`-L/;_ S*A͑(hDhT5Z_ Mm-j޻B%N9owyM+^4qTN ^NfkVz6kg+@ǝD$L?|;_f|1*ǒe+d{nrf,f= $ACvG#i VC-['kGoZhZ֪cELkb}2X yl_0WGgճ`'e7QΧD>a XJ1L/敔ЌG``LبqBOXxYˎnjhZCsڂV-~BC.{8p`;@nؚԶ1f8E\"xYISK(mnd#ڼ IHTvG=\gKI'[I䞭Ϡ^>l0.]#^Rhۧ)_'Im8p@Ɠ=)bSb6Q5._9{Ob[URnm8:7[,t%5H34o: o+7P6Z ;_ɖ%sf `~Y\Q^gk!Q, vj;JmFDUs &9xO̵ }ʐ#Q'Lhnm֩*NKt=B` x|RnONZz&#+>ʼwJ",W;"=ZfhHiWԞB6'TS]8 zXJN}Ubd cȤҚD.2a%CF`S=wH]$LS/GťfNqIn&_A˗蒄d#/پ!ҘhNS#VFF~K +1V}t6o|kύLW9uAmp y~]Lۉ %K9AVS71h/&^;82*h<4ɓֻ-6 mgƳًg/,ދ=^l/ mTCBTiK*biL֢-j"З!ON*RC Y1jG;g9HG=мtJ#hgwb͟W'ϱ7c2&_"ըz5$?,zL'~NFtotoz.Wd\@L Tyjy^ͪo3ckdNEEL++00?08Ȑ~c]$pXWI 5Go{v7:1Vc@/Q@ҀZ90qLAn|q6fJޟXE@ͳ*9?"1Z\S[p1+ʑҤ:2+r I U5Ib(0IzŹtzפVkmkaG3--{ϩpfm~~+h64&7ˀ]N4iUT<^H iʡKڬc5k\&Zd F^>ibݜІDJHUfIelU9P> Wv%c9^R[*it=;W"SDR?VNjLY.י:d{^e0l3ǡ^铯IaƓOQCQ":)DF˥XA';Dx洧I[,D;qG*d!O]QL4hbxҬ ( yEJYڢ@P% am~ץ^iJ@=m 6JϜtSoW)vi)d'qYtaLw %9(V&:]x9zn[Vsm&tk=[_*#̷ߴEތr_8>!e\88kXj l|`-T;dRA)^ AV `yJ[}*@*Ĥ,ݐX S怪Ėbrbr[,=[ۭ) rmcu&-e20x5kv156h̥ Y;4}* m3g3H?}i Ztﲏm=w>|wgKwmFv]: ͨ&奠%W^Q.dZ*@4h JxZ٘ʄV%Y޴E;(foӾ#֛b܈< ,"$"$GJ: ~B,V.pn^Y]\3$fPEElɉ"m52 l*NyKJ[}:=~گJ=Tp¨:ƭԯY///i/^,l{E^밂wuhg'##ǣe gv6 t&YlqP"Az˴Jh уhD _]}Vz[zOb$66gFv6:a]6ș|$ *]66--x b]oQcQ= ^ɜXXĶbbM` 똖VqAkCrmJOd}GTԳ۞-mKޑ9If\5df~kASs73p Rm),/G _*_p9w;0솕#1bmwNs^,_.-oRo=C;]SDEc i4i&/\ym! Cq|q#wE/"n cʠ)C0~h, ,,;vqt(Qh5VfUC*"[ <b 0BMd:Wg;ѽgM&[rW$V- U!9[K¾mɉN|<1Qo\v=zTI#kXO3)~x\{y|%Z,:¢!*B)k耆AuDUxz:pZZhP{M., ZzRqcXab7Fw$K"ICjGŊZ lf1ZOj7Zm8^Ǜh{h XW[RJ(V]m9x(7#|38_W&jn ssFCK\җ2WJ~T/=V>ZD$3!MsJG7ۛWllĜ9ⴣ *kM x;In5h~Kr5a !{wx.mFl9Aj)"]*rjgo;%nx,ot.!#!|_GOr|ܙ}r(%ŃTw?ryɵ;kaA 0'W<|Nk>m7`}1·dpwޠt6v8"8_mq] HFH7BJd$'DPbBn痪F: rJ]Mpt[V; &(O Q-t'Kb % WJ*+t>:EBP#yZp]>_/ KBĐ8Maw4@ӽit6\V}@_2%ٔ$+*.8Zخض2|?Ͻ7{u~anhvY?ұhւJ% K* 6@&Am.MVBcOc*Ӥ)=9} C܌cך% e\Iϥ}iq ,&R0RDeNi+?)!Hg7LMqĘ8yTIe 5(80#W'n6u+̬,$1pdp'=뺸v$\]7:>&k۠.'sIV|?P =_ẕttQWrc?U7`5HJfCH jSapPSlLRn5P.0`*N5Bt)"}ؾ£ʽ g;<ĮоWܬ7r /PA\ջkadGYww*FC>U|))?z듇NbĶ'}O Xcy.b$8(>/# NgmQTajsIq9`8)!3Pv+V{sg4?BmU/k1-A>'QR;:C5mw}qcOk.j/m#}] ՋNj{zѲ{Qljjt4ӾHWzwvM=<˟Ug4<5QPfKȖg%Nרi[8>q|R  i PHu C;c/|?%fr\'o@S2N"8xި\ski7XX! n ֠k*J5ǨZũWW rCwXV;rs'feAuB0L)iYx:"DL %BWꄂ\{5Wp:C@!O îRrqO(  M-cyliI)ˉ߾ `|j}Y>`gayä-!_t 2{nAWWW!J2s)+-1.GmdCKFRI-7eudBŘTM&mA*UM.l,:e`C8ec[^* r塞cjL6&{$'\fpN5jdX||;Y~xc 敚F2[͕Η5-̋o͒Y7?^2`FI?-pKlI3fYU~^<ujq~x˾U΢` 8;KŸSr Yv6?k̚rb{61cC)[j<C )#|.CSʠ(DZ&Bl fS5 .8vqlam!\/F|Eb9f^S6Q @:@𰅂-c@V`jT (:ʪcԮ*eJ+2IlbRM*Em! 脭=y{ȶ*c5&k]f0ƽQ(I.[[ 4!O(k4)xi` :2, IH?' y&Fd5DH4sy m ~z5*J\nA(A`òZ\)*) %/c"DƵ(S *q"Z0Rl4_|+X6YI+d2/ 'LJsAlj㾻El'yl L<#LF#A+X1R3;ӰFRAvb+Fd p2~*~~~cn]_riNqx}x>x]>gzYסFAc]ҠwW%b5˂pAvu1Bnt,g).fx­^ݙdͫHfߓv2v5X: D䂝i饓IWU볳?*t#6y"(Z D '4'۪LTV)m87/ԗpw"~zw"g9/!T./g}\iH[8) ogn~M7KmyhzײT[PV_tsR4W4%CiW}C}> G=}î#С סsbSg""]uw(4䊋iHBB79]t8w@jHЍfD,jH#J7yj7ܸ ʊc1*vbWsJw㿛|}† }juOÄ#Һ:+.e g cdf\ӣv@Ƀ=8t\-UT3Ӷ 2qw+iU?u}GJh㚤g""&H/qoΓ~:.)T$x,xQ8|x+s1AfLzefvRiOoumGtQmN{U..L -R^0GxıA9 sHćDK/RbQmH~#`aC$iE 38i3|xE1I3~fh7ňXfāvX,`Qˑ1r+GccfxpcyxhO(ԍ* (Livim[??A߂C3_kX lK7 0rQخ!yx0{@-RJ*8Ǵb2]~^Q93`צzJϺB @ QI3NR|̵$g,x0*jwGLF o O k'n-Q\H8=!_u8% "~ ~reC ?v6Ad7VK&k9MN4j 9zcJFN mԿʼRI(? UD4ԯbl' s,~=D:#ɱuւ`>AS(jRڲlo~Jڡ_o+{ ڗC 𱯠0H!fGdAXm!~#3H=ˠ/o#.V¸B 0gM6}b6#KMּ&b?XE-l[o1d k}пi~zG+ ( 0Hc#k`T A| D# tpnT/4TPG/.+{w$$4($0!4aI f Ѷ ufҪ!3MI C,jji)"~ݽ?M 7w=inޔ 21n_K⹂Uȣg?r2~6?d?mntbi[p?}n;J>@?Mm00Lup?H1XwƧCU3Oga1^LA =3c}sd.[3F?3?٧2w}+ sY r6*elm֡# #>|?u̶s7"&7S}:GiOx 9 iw_9:i%;Fcq|w7d#鰾`,NGqZi^a2d}}=GVZ;J9"+n$޿crƸ:kod%o΃Gd}ѩIE~֞ p$6 V&#Г 4GaKZE7Rߩb'}՟,Vݞ87p|tlj5?,q!!? g %2,o) \_}tC+f|X^E}p;3Qa75]ij>u.;[˩Q*cYɥl'Fhf,TnChΟ-9 |!e#_TWd=,6ŽOb4Z&aAU\a̅nqlTt!w+ Yg^x휥"ӢkTFd;ˑWV$Mb`~n.5/kMs&+qIT8/Q꽪$uVIt8@nsuQ9ȗȏ@Dsu>у>[DKXKgHk]}g`Wx_,Uq9)%RD6ާc^@CԥtXџ_r~QA(!G5別qh'{s<>k_m{- b qo϶IC:{ؙ5΁X*z~<%ػA1ZvM^9s.~A2 2r2xg>~gbIocBw#jk?8~"*HF-*5g !v32y7y=<Uk\Pٍ yD@6TD^VzktN|y;8.Tf6TbYY| Zx:ցOv~p >#|PyJadoȒ~}kKo^8FA-5%\:~In2_΁\;sL@}LV<5D0—us:{S/Ƞy CxN@lG; i&}hZ0s}ݹ*9:۶AeTD*>&\hU;%GL=J1BnYot}۰QUā;rV bFH^ISȫcA-AY nUA;Qa\ׇc)$2XbΚ=qD+ Հ}BzlG;mj /)qy_41{ zwSJIzc:Hrs(ގn GcPqwq?WUGc.˲" anC,s|[w/GΤ\Pκ ƈghXXj-v9mi0;9:MDuAq')fb+W9'Hlsȗ?kF}ͼ&ohT0_[aG RjA52a'`Z.rh霫9g8 >yM0^d>+%O ȑi*B_QSLWCb)g=֭JMp6YRG3:AEAU~oҁs)],ZDj B7^p:1' 3`߻KR 0! 2,ֺ$D[Cmh uVMip"jV:P[[Va»}瞛ܼ$țwygɛ(lВr!뵘6|7}YPAosQ uՎΆ|lW[ 9\W~t?<?j"+l?<ˆaѐ ~ކ'yľN= m'߼/6-za3exHNf'Չ …V+f~m};a{ԟ[߁cߧ"3wao+T; niߦQ#'c/A5Ѽd y+&"}\+HU+p' 'į{kHB$j{#(/" 4bf "HL&nklqNN;tS_F>9z4;/QqpJ"&j4#ܛC#C17$Qۼ;7ATg?"s|g&msO}F޹j4i7£~oˤ FO1mUoJY;W|Lj2'5{lU[FqG^Rw(ו8彀^b[ĜZo,zo~qG^(LsQ!ox>˝V5XPa/5S] ޮi*om7 31? 2]@Sf9k"msSv!uΆFSLuk?nԸME`68[XfyREE?چ7#ӃrOJ]_%m{.OҘhV?/ kMC'n4$VkLo<-o4borA[)'oERWb %smf,?p/u+e_l*N*u6|`0N3-¼˞0R9[[)z=i%=V:؞4a\t7Xj{M߬o=>&d v*X03ҽB#MFY=euzJ)exm[>߷毱)WF3j"4#nL5!ruNj9OEn'J+qA{E7ܤ[m\q&mILN K< I1r}8U7G Y,ѠF}]dj#OvPiM0R߫aT+6CЬTX3oj >ɼ-3潠ηдr^gyhyʹ SƼ+ݛZ/9FH"?z_سYE!_Bf(Ag A/7sSh?\*ӫ]v0oϪW^n㯖8K2Z#)ٮz_;9ÔϵoT:yiGc3 6ݨk2wOl+?ػY|;g~v|w~֯oz gO_JDke1ʹI0W=_$K])('Ay~g @cmz+i}gԭ}rȍ:ͬ7[uϯ}e'[/9F1]7XUgU2}+j*Oty?tln|ݨniIZN{W^XS< ׵Ԭ+N_:{t-avvUT{%{l:npÆbY둎evTقDr\)F! 8΁m pnsmb5#/{D͚Dܹ,^Nѩ!_j}Sbs_U,vLˈ'[MY4~L!O;f][vo)Nڴ{#A ̇z;49::6ne1)'W՜.W˺.`.sfxSG>tG^O mPsD;NJc [G:}1wdqtr3XWEHd P R)ÉTcq_ޡ e'2+Ow=\J_AW.Sՠx%Ҩ}yܳx:z{AiVP.LsS}3'iĞgpi|GV{zզ`B\juKϷڻ4& x|.=.|_@#6wvْ,u_\ xǙ[;w!~~BM4ȳ*2Р(cIZ_A@6[YYioOb |-^;nϸOs㿡'ʹ4#Zttt?aBڥqN(|1q=0'MҾ'֦<84z=2W< *7@b^ӝMZmưYv/|qnz~rcnj>k=!e Lh7Xlyfe+<[_e<`'iO/ p*A+ךć ?>0jMf.Ҫ|@{Y=ޞ rissl$G{W̵6vs'v>{*,̫ĞŞ3.y29:]||~F-=mv4Pfg#~rʏ/2dlwsu)55B>1Ұ7Hjw6χoY`ȇNb~i qzi"I.h&?*UNy6w_gYlr:[,կ* KS|dQm%Xoi߶wנK=(mE7-݌@+w{!6MߏxOۮ?J[ݍeޣOr޳Ɇ͆ Py6Kkڲ6<,I7$4ѰٽIlL t` $ -(G:*_G*ѩiuT{ބv38sw7'7wFTެ_FnҩQ7>Q)җKl7)4C?jی>Nٶ .KvVTjysKضFuڶNm3] 7ҋ$OuaS/͔aJvxiRFdBGPb=Lh!cg.DMBE>ug ca=yMb8EaGaKϭ#v_G[`ɧ ) :r(ٵMzA13w&ه:Gӭz!h.dd4:3I'jAdCVATTϣ{݉q[xSUԏ5ecJ {GB3s|cd]hկm 犨]DLAO>(uE{)pۓT2Ɠ5"HxOo6#̌>hja2hIrL82̊D'dj8-9}Vzh$RbWd !ڔcR{o<#;]x4IbQI&Twv(6@LqՂ:AFIKpz`KKX'> @V)?yS[ 琳c#}t(l/ݽr~HR` >|Y|g/hl^iR\JBeB' A[T^bu#/IذZ`o5575.hRtcD)ؕj} l;64Da]f0ff(~ tw+jEd*HSmjLYPB7WZ>FjVfHJMiL ]3xapMcl#:X}PT:ʦpyy6r2n~fhn<oQ>=:"pFmÄb}]'lW'.&. >~,@w0Vtr endstream endobj 29 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[333.0 373.0 344.0 384.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 15 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 2/Type/Page>> endobj 36 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (98052614)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/98052614.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:38:00 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 504 591.75 261.75 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 754.5 Tm (Christine M. Kopocis)Tj ET Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 729 Tm (Member, Claims Appeals Board)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (1. )Tj (This claim involves Personal Property Government Bill of Lading \(PPGBL\)\ RP-925,802; Army Claim No. 93-352-)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (0070; and AAFQ Claim No. 943866.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (2. )Tj (The carrier is liable for the contents of a sealed carton unless it has \ excepted to delivery. If a chandelier were missing)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (from the carton, the light weight of the carton should have)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 23.549 0 Td (been noticed at the NTS facility by the carrier's agent and)Tj -23.549 -1.125 Td (annotated on the rider.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (3. )Tj (Despite numerous attempts by the Army to obtain documentation from the s\ hipper as to the value, no such)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (documentation was provided. The shipper's failure to adequately)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 26.089 0 Td (respond to the Army's request for specific information)Tj -26.089 -1.125 Td (was harmful to his claim, but was harmless as to its effect on the carri\ er's liability.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (4. )Tj (Although the adjusted dollar value method of ascertaining damages is not\ favored by our Office as a method for)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (determining damages in carrier recoveries, we have recognized)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 25.515 0 Td (the reasonableness of this method for determining)Tj -25.515 -1.125 Td (depreciated replacement costs in certain circumstances. )Tj 22.406 0 Td (See)Tj ET 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 284.8691 531.75 cm 0 0 m 17.326 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 302.1953 532.5 Tm ( DOHA Claims Case No. 97122315 \(January 12, 1998\). We)Tj -23.85 -1.125 Td (calculated)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 4.303 0 Td (the adjusted value in this case in determining the reasonableness of the\ Army's $750 value of the chandelier.)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 14 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 1/Type/Page>> endobj 37 0 obj [39 0 R 40 0 R 41 0 R] endobj 38 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (98052614)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/98052614.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:38:00 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm (relieving the carrier of liability. )Tj 12.828 0 Td (See)Tj ET Q 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 169.9375 754.5 cm 0 0 m 17.326 0 l h S Q q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 187.2637 755.25 Tm ( )Tj (Missouri Pacific Railroad)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC ET Q q 1 0 0 1 190.2637 754.5 cm 0 0 m 126.311 0 l h S Q q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 316.5742 755.25 Tm (Co. v. Elmore & Stahl)Tj ET Q q 1 0 0 1 316.5742 754.5 cm 0 0 m 107.326 0 l h S Q q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 423.9004 755.25 Tm (, 377 U.S. 134, 138 \(1964\); )Tj (see)Tj ET Q q 1 0 0 1 558.5664 754.5 cm 0 0 m 15.322 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm (also)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 16 741 cm 0 0 m 19.33 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 35.3301 741.75 Tm ( DOHA Claims Case 96070203 \(September 5, 1996\). )Tj 21.608 0 Td (Additionally, when goods pass through the custody of several)Tj -23.219 -1.125 Td (bailees, it is a presumption of the common law that the damage occurred \ in the hands of the last one. )Tj 40.488 0 Td (See)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 501.8594 727.5 cm 0 0 m 17.326 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 519.1855 728.25 Tm ( )Tj (McNamara-)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 522.1855 727.5 cm 0 0 m 57.967 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 714.75 Tm (Lunz Vans and Warehouses, Inc.)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 16 714 cm 0 0 m 158.607 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 174.6074 714.75 Tm (, 57 Comp. Gen. 415, 418)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (\(1978\). )Tj (The last custodian can avoid liability by showing)Tj -13.217 -1.125 Td (that the damage or loss did not occur while the item was in its custody.\ For a carrier removing goods from a storage)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (facility)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 3.082 0 Td (for delivery, that showing is made by preparing an exception sheet--a ri\ der--to the inventory; the rider then can)Tj -3.082 -1.125 Td (serve to rebut the general common law presumption of the last)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 25.243 0 Td (carrier's liability. )Tj 7.039 0 Td (See)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 403.375 673.5 cm 0 0 m 17.326 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 420.7012 674.25 Tm ( )Tj (Able Forwarders, Inc.)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 423.7012 673.5 cm 0 0 m 105.299 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 529 674.25 Tm (, B-252817,)Tj -42.75 -1.125 Td (Apr. 19, 1993.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (In the present case, the inventory identifies Item #14 as a 4.5 carton c\ ontaining a crystal chandelier that was carrier)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (packed. Allied's agent created a rider which identified missing)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 25.171 0 Td (and damaged items when the HHG's were picked up)Tj -25.171 -1.375 Td (from NTS. Item #14 did not appear on the rider as a missing item.)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 332.9336 609.75 Tm (\(2\))Tj ET 0 0 0.933 RG q 1 0 0 1 332.9336 609 cm 0 0 m 11.369 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 344.3022 605.25 Tm ( The record indicates that the carton for Item #14)Tj -27.359 -1.125 Td (was)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (delivered, but the crystal chandelier was missing. As the last bailee, A\ llied is responsible for the loss and damage to)Tj T* (items listed on the inventory that were not identified on the rider.)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 26.299 0 Td (The fact that the inventory written by the carrier)Tj -26.299 -1.125 Td (specifically identifies the crystal chandelier is evidence that it was t\ endered. Additionally, the record contains a)Tj T* (statement by the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 6.804 0 Td (shipper that he witnessed the crystal chandelier being packed. The shipp\ er's notice of the chandelier)Tj -6.804 -1.125 Td (being missing was timely provided on the DD Form 1840R.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (We find that, )Tj 5.498 0 Td (in this case,)Tj 4.693 0 Td ( both the Army and the carrier erred in the handling of the claim. The A\ rmy did not provide)Tj -10.191 -1.375 Td (documentation as to the value of the chandelier.)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 245.916 500.25 Tm (\(3\))Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 245.916 499.5 cm 0 0 m 11.369 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 257.2847 495.75 Tm ( On the other)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 5.499 0 Td (hand, )Tj (during the period it had to investigate this claim,)Tj -25.606 -1.125 Td (the carrier did not ask for evidence that the member paid $500 when he p\ urchased the hand-made crystal chandelier in)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (1984.)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (The question for this Board to decide is whether there is any reasonable\ basis on which the Army could find the)Tj T* (replacement value to be $750 based on a record which includes a)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 26.268 0 Td (purchase price of $500.)Tj -26.268 -2.125 Td (There is well established legal precedent that the carrier, not this Boa\ rd nor the Services, has the burden of proving by)Tj T* (clear and convincing evidence that the calculation of damages)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 25.072 0 Td (was incorrect. )Tj 5.858 0 Td (See)Tj ET 0 G q 1 0 0 1 387.168 415.5 cm 0 0 m 17.326 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 404.4941 416.25 Tm ( Title 4 Code of Federal Regulations,)Tj -32.375 -1.125 Td (Subsection 31.7. )Tj (See also)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 98.6641 402 cm 0 0 m 39.656 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 138.3203 402.75 Tm ( DOHA 97012102 \(January 29, 1997\) and cases cited therein. Appeals bas\ ed on mere)Tj -10.193 -1.125 Td (questioning)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 4.916 0 Td (of the Army's valuation are insufficient to overcome its liability. )Tj 25.979 0 Td (Compare)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 386.7461 388.5 cm 0 0 m 43.986 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 430.7324 389.25 Tm ( DOHA 98021008 \(February 27,)Tj -34.561 -1.125 Td (1998\) in which we modified the amount of the carrier's liability after)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 27.727 0 Td (finding that the service did not respond when the)Tj -27.727 -1.125 Td (carrier had requested \(during its investigation period\) information co\ ncerning the value of a lost carpet.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Resource Protection provides no evidence on appeal to indicate that $750\ .00 was an unreasonable amount for the)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (replacement of an eight year old hand-made crystal chandelier. As)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 26.794 0 Td (our Settlement Certificate states, this amount is)Tj -26.794 -1.125 Td (relatively close to the reported purchase price and is about one-quarter\ of the claimed replacement cost. We note also)Tj 0 -1.375 TD (that it is within)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 6.278 0 Td ($80 of the adjusted dollar value)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 242.957 297.75 Tm (\(4\))Tj ET 0 0 0.933 RG q 1 0 0 1 242.957 297 cm 0 0 m 11.369 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 254.3257 293.25 Tm ( of $670 \($500 x 1.34\). We do not see that an $80 difference between)Tj -19.86 -1.125 Td (the adjusted value and the Army's adjudication is sufficient to disturb \ the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 29.451 0 Td (Army's finding.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf -7.685 -2.125 Td (Conclusion)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -21.767 -2.125 Td (We affirm the Settlement.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (_/s/_________________________)Tj T* (Michael D. Hipple)Tj T* (Chairman, Claims Appeals Board)Tj T* (_/s/_________________________)Tj T* (Michael H. Leonard)Tj T* (Member, Claims Appeals Board)Tj T* (_/s/_________________________)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 39 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[333.0 607.0 344.0 618.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 40 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[246.0 498.0 257.0 509.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 41 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[243.0 295.0 254.0 306.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 12 0 obj <> endobj 42 0 obj <> endobj 9 0 obj <> endobj 10 0 obj <> endobj 11 0 obj <> endobj 48 0 obj (file:///usr.osd.mil/Home/OSD/OGC/JosephLM/_MyComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Archived%20-%20HTML/98052614.html) endobj 47 0 obj <> endobj 49 0 obj <> endobj 43 0 obj [15 0 R/XYZ 0 713.0 null] endobj 44 0 obj [15 0 R/XYZ 0 674.0 null] endobj 45 0 obj [15 0 R/XYZ 0 622.0 null] endobj 46 0 obj [15 0 R/XYZ 0 569.0 null] endobj 4 0 obj <> endobj xref 0 50 0000000000 65535 f 0000000016 00000 n 0000000141 00000 n 0000003652 00000 n 0000109454 00000 n 0000003530 00000 n 0000003585 00000 n 0000003718 00000 n 0000003745 00000 n 0000108706 00000 n 0000108846 00000 n 0000108888 00000 n 0000108522 00000 n 0000004280 00000 n 0000099280 00000 n 0000096554 00000 n 0000003848 00000 n 0000003894 00000 n 0000003943 00000 n 0000004093 00000 n 0000003997 00000 n 0000004029 00000 n 0000004061 00000 n 0000004494 00000 n 0000004519 00000 n 0000010228 00000 n 0000010277 00000 n 0000010312 00000 n 0000010826 00000 n 0000096222 00000 n 0000041915 00000 n 0000042182 00000 n 0000011239 00000 n 0000011512 00000 n 0000011939 00000 n 0000042803 00000 n 0000096743 00000 n 0000099494 00000 n 0000099533 00000 n 0000107526 00000 n 0000107858 00000 n 0000108190 00000 n 0000108607 00000 n 0000109286 00000 n 0000109328 00000 n 0000109370 00000 n 0000109412 00000 n 0000109104 00000 n 0000108930 00000 n 0000109233 00000 n trailer <<689523DE842B4346A3C5CFBE46FA7D5C>]>> startxref 109624 %%EOF