%PDF-1.6 % 1 0 obj <> endobj 2 0 obj <>stream 2021-06-11T15:38:13-04:00 2021-06-11T15:38:12-04:00 2021-06-11T15:38:13-04:00 Adobe Acrobat 17.0 application/pdf 98121413 uuid:ab1679c8-b51c-494f-9171-612ce0ee0c2d uuid:9f9bb57f-bf83-4b79-9098-d57940b9b3f6 Acrobat Web Capture 15.0 endstream endobj 5 0 obj <> endobj 6 0 obj <> endobj 3 0 obj <> endobj 7 0 obj <> endobj 8 0 obj <> endobj 16 0 obj <>>> endobj 17 0 obj <> endobj 18 0 obj <> endobj 20 0 obj [19 0 R 19 0 R] endobj 21 0 obj [19 0 R 19 0 R] endobj 22 0 obj [19 0 R 19 0 R] endobj 19 0 obj <><><><>]/P 17 0 R/Pg 13 0 R/S/Article>> endobj 13 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 0/Type/Page>> endobj 23 0 obj [29 0 R] endobj 24 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (98121413)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/98121413.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:38:12 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 759.7503 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.751 l 579 -0.751 l 579.749 0 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 758.9997 cm 0 0 m -0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 578.25 0 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 758.25 cm 0 0 m 0.75 0.75 l 0 1.5 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 758.9997 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 0.75 0.751 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 624.7503 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.751 l 579 -0.751 l 579.749 0 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 623.9997 cm 0 0 m -0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 578.25 0 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 623.25 cm 0 0 m 0.75 0.75 l 0 1.5 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 623.9997 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 0.75 0.751 l h f Q /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm (In Re:)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Resource Protection)Tj T* (on behalf of)Tj T* (Cartwright International Van Lines, Inc.)Tj T* (Claimant)Tj 0 -2.75 TD (\))Tj 0 -2.125 TD (DATE: January 6, 1999)Tj T* (Claims Case No. 98121413)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 15.224 -2.125 Td (CLAIMS APPEALS BOARD DECISION)Tj -15.224 -2.125 Td (DIGEST)Tj /TT0 1 Tf T* (1. The Military-Industry Memorandum of Understanding on Loss and Damage \ Rules \(MOU\) provides that the claims)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (office will use a carrier's itemized estimate received more than)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 25.279 0 Td (45 days after delivery but prior to dispatch of the)Tj -25.279 -1.125 Td (Demand on Carrier if the claim has not already been adjudicated; the est\ imate is the lowest overall; and the repair firm)Tj T* (selected by)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 4.72 0 Td (the carrier can and will perform adequately, based on the firm's reputat\ ion for timely and satisfactory)Tj -4.72 -1.125 Td (performance. A repair estimate offered on behalf of the carrier is not u\ ntimely)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 31.486 0 Td (merely because approximately two years)Tj -31.486 -1.125 Td (had elapsed between delivery and the time that the carrier's repairer pr\ epared the estimate when it is offered by the)Tj T* (carrier prior to the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 7.552 0 Td (Demand on Carrier.)Tj -7.552 -2.125 Td (2. The MOU also states that when the carrier's estimate is timely, if th\ e carrier's estimate is the lowest overall and is not)Tj T* (used, the claims office will advise the carrier in writing of)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 23.437 0 Td (the reason. In other words, the claims office is not required to)Tj -23.437 -1.125 Td (use the estimate if it articulates in writing a reasonable basis for not\ doing so. For example, if the claims office)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 44.459 0 Td (contends)Tj -44.459 -1.125 Td (that an item is not repairable as proposed by the carrier, it must at le\ ast offer a reasonably focused estimate finding that)Tj T* (the specific item furniture could not have been so)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 20.021 0 Td (repaired or material from the manufacturer to the same effect.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf -20.021 -2.125 Td (DECISION)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 0 -2.125 TD (Resource Protection, on behalf of Cartwright International Van Lines, In\ c. \(Cartwright\), appeals the November 19,)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (1998, Settlement Certificate of the Defense Office of Hearings)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 25.324 0 Td (and Appeals \(DOHA\), which affirmed, with)Tj -25.324 -1.125 Td (modifications suggested by the Army allowing a refund of $423, the Army'\ s set off of $4,237 for transit loss and)Tj 0 -1.375 TD (damage to the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 5.859 0 Td (household shipment of a service member.)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 286.252 228.75 Tm (\(1\))Tj ET 0 0 0.933 RG 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 286.252 228 cm 0 0 m 11.369 0 l h S Q BT 0 g /TT1 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 274.1992 198.75 Tm (Background)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -21.517 -2.125 Td (The record indicates that the shipment was picked up in Virginia on Augu\ st 14, 1992, and delivered to the service)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (member in Arizona on August 21, 1992. In this appeal, Resource)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 26.272 0 Td (Protection contests the appropriate amount of damages)Tj -26.272 -1.125 Td (to four Descriptive Inventory Items: Item 70, a sleep sofa purchased in \ October 1980, with a front right leg and)Tj T* (surrounding)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (wooden frame broken; Items 181 and 184 \(a twin headboard and footboard \ respectively also purchased in)Tj T* (October 1980, with a gouge in the headboard and a broken piece and)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 27.768 0 Td (gouge on the footboard\); and Item 234, four patio)Tj -27.768 -1.125 Td (chairs with bent legs, purchased in June 1990. On October 30, 1992, the \ Army and member dispatched a Notice of Loss)Tj T* (or)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Damage \(DD Form 1840R\) noting these additional damages. The member fil\ ed his claim in August 1994, and the)Tj T* (Demand on Carrier was dispatched in January 1995. On behalf of)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 26.492 0 Td (Cartwright, in July 1994 a repairer prepared an)Tj -26.492 -1.125 Td (estimate for repairing these items, and the member obtained repair estim\ ates for Items 70 and 181 and 184 in August)Tj T* (1994. The)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (record contains no member/government estimate for repairing Item 234 or \ a replacement estimate which)Tj ET q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 12 0 0 12 16 38.25 Tm (indicates that the four chairs cannot be repaired.)Tj ET EMC Q endstream endobj 25 0 obj <> endobj 26 0 obj (ҕàJK~m) endobj 27 0 obj <> endobj 28 0 obj <> endobj 32 0 obj <> endobj 33 0 obj <>stream H\j0 ~ COkgXrt1NzϊJ3$%CrTVvD~5NvxvV$)NO}Dyl;<#lal E ^aUks?أ m8qM-iʄn7!/svNXFGh􍽢0 a>qڥߍyJq&8eN[X2K9#3K|$>1A8#G$$;HrPYq1ja7En=y*vSM[>d|WFwe\0Q҇3ZzI],>^,įW. endstream endobj 34 0 obj <>stream H|y\TG5o^p fQѬ,d57FCEPTE#7Ⅰ5xnjh$3ۣ.fH}ޫ炙xa$DE*$:69&_ŎJ5u)Po20m@a; L'!h8(>&Q>Q_A ,z1=o,NVIbciw|%njIiC1񦜾E`ʰP ])#S4QM^ $%j@^^,QZ) _5ep/ A] ZFuFt:j6.~'z(DxeFE JZuz7wO:>u}h0Q``4ao5i oVk{oбS.vQ?{??|ѷ_9 *:_' 48qHRa)GLz1cǍfĴISM1s9s_0kQvb.[_|Ukoظi۶عk8åGʎ;^~g*p /]k@D:a"95M_M"FKi iT krbDƚYY+g]#7*W WٲcePk7kWk=kkkkKkSo%crrr˵Rfog)#U ΖNPbq͹-rI(4v–D+Tnn.wDs |V028 >ɧ4 mF:eGCd,,d&|yȗ2_|-l\7&6|1]t5x|tuu:?4W=ss.}mA)ҤH`OLb! Ҥ $N1$t ,Җe:A'$StN:Cg,nȍ8-_Rȗ2?5Ы**ګjG^ث#usu.9 m=UOwt=CԳl~_s<=_/ "X/K#'#zY{\+c F5z^Qo\כުvC?;.[Y{gIܘ9S9939 p.q~tQt1vNX={Eb?|YCp(>p811 )r7܂[_|[qknsqb\Kq.Wڔ撹kp)3Wp𣑴 )w8ws=p**کq ZS@!4rC;-!R  =f_sb^rZC@BC4Bsr;>g\w(fZ@Kh v~ ?a ކ0 ށwa:~ 3`&A<cxxOxY<E UxoM]wbVbVc ̂2 P6:|,8/"DD$I&$"14xlAh"e$LS(h*M4fR6};;;;+Y9ͦ9ͥy4?:OW-xDgv8X_w6N]lwբbZi)-崂V*ZMkh-6D|B[i}I+wN{Eh7xrhtQ.#t(q*B*b*tNi*2:Ct*蜮kyH?y{fH?%LW.@ױJzmMW `1D\p9fr꺺:XPH:\GFQ:UN:RGhxMb@6VUmZmdf [ִlm[ֵ|:F7ձ:N{x{κvks>!k#ͳ=n l-ŶĞ'){ږ2{Ɩ۳Zm= _OԘ½9rr稓;D8!NS(e(gE8'΋⚸.nQ)nWDBOK dC,CP&F73/!=fH'Yu_T1ORU0EƩj#eQ̕L2S2Y0Y3ihلTȦ2Vx ̋'@=T11QřLLQ"D(kUiLiM3̤ꆺɜdڄ3mU{o7a޴m"UYjfYiVfYk֙fh6fjDB[>dG*d'05et$() 7Mj0؄E@u~PLP^??a0 X]0N )Z$:!A v uHcEY=l31 R؂ܻ0pɻw`2Cg^3ZjXAЀ P*{s+)CPq[Ra4L5o%~DxbVVb= Ŀ^hO{7H;tЌm4lc\(B4AcG˹L%MKu"X]T)PkΑ΃̐c/? U I`6|ϕ;V1=c~ސm Ϡ?qH*L7s#(c2D e"+#[^f÷8jG5xcag1A _Æ [rf7XQ~}K-p' !{e #3C9܄kXޙLX(ʙ[*Ogg癲긿Ota`}`p /k܇%xg#/E/搬';r,{.yxy=n3w>|y u㓠-wH/kGk/^ZQb8$01c1w*+WabŘ&>|*S$ZLV l;Uz Rl~wy?K[ư5 vC.R}9\+/}aw&sTXUq|3m[PW8װM[<~"x6qݝq}NG$bMB!_  $Np lH@٨V-ctT+V`]3I F56u ]7 mJ9 f[Ͽ>{OBBt?=+:VX01>FaT îb/طMji?^~]n '#-|g >gxZσGC $9s;i)AlY,2lTg*v ބK5}h L=/:'c{KXuv/cgk(qI)DSЦqgr~#]8F;Q%P_>#1WcH[v,L N:`h@ :/w/d\g`o"H-%d;κm|px{j̠0,&vQn',Bw:ʽ^X_ZQ3UD;pTރ9flfA| {pY>ϯv؊sA=ԓnQ4Aen;j~kQ(9}.y YClK^Na`|%`^&N'qMvWuxlX_ì=^k$;|aB-}&!eЏ5p.0ڠ=W 0cw@69x3ǁyN3w ϒHJvz@̤:{t>ʑ$KçZ.uB2ؓ_v(s >jac8/a p uz9K UmWP c ld=,W;;׋Fmv=dW+y2bp{[q@K[ha;Z9宲Rn]Rl,Y#oXxJT=)MM~ 5RE$gʨbJgJP %CSDĘ,% :ku!,I8A9JRbL)T"rAT`!BCJkP0RjrT@eܱ5$)$Uêū@DF5DT^Fܪ߈r +@w;GڜPՋFUӷP\8;bsWT&s%mL&q Kǭ7ݓLdn)j'N?_(mZ >e[ ]Sat,4 e1QiKȒ蒓]lP6:]Kgr`6cLS<5yÔeB"jL[J$8KAlU ")Eh|s y㙔 - d*Ԑ? ^:"|}:~@HDCA ڶ+P$!FDlMq] TM4qF&9v38ə1=S?`/5?ؽy~F#!ƔԄmf`y~oRK" E' bt.)a IRY7 zPdy#FN!b\RM1isR6wW=6/Po ¬6u(i/HQWRJW67- ᝦF鏥&= wI6NID &-[/;{yl񲺥Kj<55 ôKm+V!F>(!V֋v-v*7nwa+?7sBeqIAڸ2skR H{5@y7\9u{w?w}s|?C.)dt*aqu+4-iBՆR`R!V֩nlCu 6-Xgig{'[=`|E+~Й߲fͷ;J!Ug R#gi-0U{ >p`B{c?ƿv,ܠsvN=W1 0¿FMo51 } j*5Au9*bkp)aUi7?)'4Opt;@ :O7۵:O; 3o }6*v§X+C> Uo,P^6+BS4N g4 k7k&fI CXq-L"H7I*gڜj:. [s}|u'~_9s*4~'%(`%:uy։ *,ζK5F^)@!WP`Q0PX8]L5qd;o$i$e$e%wq9# 8Ġ ,I ݖoNBT\Y u%]^H@uV#U6ZaE]5ds8 'yu&R V@C1 -kEW&4MgP Z<G ts,C]9h+ͷ{kF!}jS_}`MmamaOeߏ;<3͇_>[h2oѸNK=IǮ=7=_xaf{{|e 0ܓ$CJE|zez03˚o:L7Ftz֫$+FOk {jɐ$Fdan' '325'Q Wjݛ\ >}gjbWvx葕}(ckMAmW6g –ic9[}ʶe;O*xc:8]t,۝[B!;,7M1o(|<%EIGTB pJ*CB ,3&l0d[Y"U/(QQ,UaF+ w M#MTϰB/h]~p/_n]/jU}sL;^b􉞖+@Vӕ_v]2k96.ܜ;oݧA d-"Y:9d=B@D\eAaoDNV!\X u$$5RdZ% ̼UǻƎOWVnysGf.cjxq <¦=JKz\K*Eaf֦<+qX `-گ#` ?ŧ'0kźLO@ds Vxjp+wߗoU*dž6Y#cY;@;Uy7wΝw>络;!k@=c@$ZIGNJ@h;i`UPNMhB+@&4uEb?#q{mӁ4[y}Ȋ<40q싿'm }?CT x )C^4cQ;IBH!7]XfWp?4.5O1ѥԼϞTE֬BCBj^ϒ+;xRQ65h)U:e ~Zwޑ0T-,f{OKAjЀ @cB^ ʎ+x;innrLdAeVOݕn+K/63Z$:!옸g9/M. 1M1k77*Q<N in[U]vQIэFI^1Ϫ1U1z</4Z?3}1b=vUJ%tV+ Gw-VRaXhqTKG]F 08B'm+GFnmw'Ϡ3ISs&3&Ffd7_^s:NIEtjC9{Cxm7߆w`ecL@Π >+F>bNRܺuVIl_Zs-|,iuF{g&<$Yǯ :19 QnoqU&_S7GE",*M|S),ψSK-%\^J tӷ0]Q|ǼQ1r}wU|'NsHDVGTF#CIԫ[^fECC9"yO`mێ-v`z4qBB p,^LQϗݍ㼩B)JEeI&n/pN1Pnl gDL$;an,y-b`9Mgn*O߶H$)Otf韰蕿胫S"~|e<$5ӝ0unS)7bYe tx$N~.;#ϯ 8˳]vzcsǪ/^`@Өd,0B$FE6BNȰxjH#zQUZӬB]QI-;<;@c XlAO XٷѹͱVW~Oȡspj/=AP5$ yH_|Eȅܼw;rbC!}q){J;t/zOvlL=f("=jUz0W bouWtbFэǶh nl$dRNzaXd3$Xv;60꘱lqx %*ҥRu*ZSKHTp iᴔ!9ye8jdآe 5-Y&.$AU s z;7?1;.TW/J-_΋# I_ztnLq]Vwq&qY|:5)X/_(g?O7_h5WHHLp=55%p X|5yi8F;Q,ss[iqLzZ~ JS$UƼ sl1&­3hWO5D" Z,KZVcQDju<&󗭲5NY[g7=[̯8?* Sk;6IBO,PќDoz@{NTS; LZdxPXs'>ғ_W%.4[ؾ}}t^n$&~O\ڢV#M.{~'%7]dҶKY͵Gn#\nحƑ>}mIЩ n]mM\gxϮݕuY]weZɲJ._1I\.mJ`[-6\HR1M')Pfi=Cdh4 a ڋ|7H!!lg::`<ǂ8cQ:U} \{# CXwoHb}( &Ax#~e211Ld Yܧ!kKsSy2u|!Qz/O%Uz(v,SE&.g ZU]7=g;+jU;%b=N^BOf K +S4E b\#(˧2aC{rCn\6N QS[)Nej?5A@[6j"NQ^NJxvIi As<&;l]M,˧;fV᾿~t)-C) ]gV<5C @^C e=eh58y 0S4Ž$l3r|>xW/P+ ZnE$Q vWzm0Bv 4Ju~iBY Uf$|T:!yƠ^,9ST .7Ra :wcw{[Ξ51Q$;j*YTćpVTYPhLQڀS*@?O:9E& \ݞX%ФBL~0!3.vYAV3\q^6"(f::O u&abԍ+R=x@ANFw2 LFUV  "zO("vqD|]$⌈qyu66t Pp<' Z/5Șn)i/b*|*v^Efȼ((b`y: @ϲMQU\DuG6A0%x3-&3.nʠZWd؆ݧ^Y잍jj*u}'m[2P(gMa79fMV n學5ɱ=b\!3 +uդTZ9ǂY!Zcܙ\g;33a,a5rTR@KHB[ jS@-5 RDjÏGa 5#IJڼT+%UQ+Bæ16uνg}I6yӷ묡Og@Sꓰo62%(- !$XCif61iQA+ ^ ڔYry;w1ƗZ\mLeMXag3o\b_>f?cpF,LӴr;bOǞꙈ"\|9;/oa9d/IkUj"]Ph0b j,vŽpU60h6:Y0c3 lFekZN%XFDH"4U۰-3B8VaelaY& xNm%bY~\˩KZB-i0 ~NۥOm+|{oV2@ NU#(2ΜHbd{vY34V{J 1H5jURX+Luz_#)0#hI9t#-Ϗ.|G6[) ) ϧH!P:p)gF 0>ơNsZD#A=0ɞUDՕۅ DA)Q sׇ֛ ɲ,A9 9#FlN ycl`ې,+giʶXV!e)~,гY]w/x!bQ^a]WֶeTV6 7VհhZƩ)W6ݪ{\")٨:[SzB=ġ~YzE C[W\P4S-qTjz f:$KK!q*Ha%aE򄗈KhG콕Hcjֳo?"\y9Ûݨ'd p߃ VQnI(?(_@:sFn5,c꽲pN'VL@j ۪u\Pڐ 6d6!kVd\_Wi1LUе $7~QΦ9D.sVw8VUV jBVVU\U+Kִx( UaqKTD/*+ k D"94ISY#!WNdPf—Q񇨧]K)L߽y> ;‹UvS@!LWz IEMn{\%'Aew!#Ć@ET+䟂rUhW+ ǜms}!om/DC$ yj-0"lnK}4;3?ZW Cpd BPQ@ğyl^y|\_֫ {뽗Q/=]@PHPEEJj5N-TKj1kV.`薌`vE]bMܲ~[d[vs{?قB@mu/fH0r Y=A=)= ^_ ޸}@itXRmi4Yl)9G?f3ē[< +垰n|ZŴނ?Sœd7"{KXf{ÑQ,SmjԱJ޲]-ׅӲ9%ԕLYdڋsfe$%N޵H/<\K HYݬ5M+{87sڛ~LE|>Q{9⦧߫Dg?T)%SDG< pJ CfVN8L"!qX"䤦dD2dpc2P\\\\\\\35*AC5fr%e1t*өxFal:s4OdGL\g&>v;1,wSŤo¯?=Bn); !7Ÿ̳ Z-!V}5J6' jMyM)昂JVmi~cTڸ,uPymY(D!uӏݛ%.jRhE ~Jo&D`&0@-dMT?KA <4Ψ@6Fʦyyo{|u',y!gŃϤVYO+D+T y}wn";Tu@ι@ M6-8mjXơ\_PK ڤ-f <\Fc;z nY7qY,dے؟u>IimZ0 x`ËǺՎ`ۋC' A>>< ֍@kD;mk{hpl' ](m`0[Cv ۬#یlџ8CH 8c;cֺ)"9"}v ۛ'O;}YQ.*b᧬D)]Es8O Z+MK^;3Y7D/`(3#~_^*<wzi7J0eo۪< " <)(UnĄr"l]5Jg|B#'R/ ^>xn}憰%ɮE-If{F\"8>s~ ̎٫kT ~ȵvgc vr dSq|v)Gq#9qssl~;|(p~GWZ=uFQbm4Sj6SwbYKe=E n[͉iwj&;ie~c4CQ0QAH7/Jyl=Z?eu/X׵F􄶜xvV\n}!|>>r,ܻƉLbS%](Gn%<(KTI=e9 u5]عA'_݇=O- #<#f^kiyJY몓O뵃|D{ȧUPreYbtN]/}?blDAMm{N,"ӨE|FH訙Ү{^'N`! oxBzT0)@~mjQJհ~T*}kB~N5 TB"JFz{.c}ꏇ:'PC-N2?@eI`^KoAm^ORHk"_Ysh_/NT5'm*:o+h`m-yyyO.?xpۃ7wځ 2E-elcc;4S9T'qKCJ:bS@݌l' 3 G cMRAF^^q_QVUUX~d!*cd I"KEUTU1bLP0&pYfVJ@x>7;f}yǾ瞳h_|߇]<3:KZk;# g;>yE^.`4hrEn9ǰĮ!Gn*Va'bO]yɞ]{l_Fd{<Z`!mWc.A#H ڬ0gA;JOiպ{;Ik۷YwhŚu>mqeAK)V-YކwϳTvV5`LgH^lM +'i{ sѺnES1,qIrf-Z'#߃3ʱ9d$e\Xs?lIn N9E,ֶ_io?sY3|Hn}kFbs!:TH nΔ;+%"A ֖Ǘi,< 35$ϕRDpN"ޓR+Ҡ!\@s@q\B@P7%wvlM* FGgf0}GY5R#4yҾh8Z$I6t#YR].=[*Pn>KT|ɉޔKs\VX6Ke0\&Wm5k_zꚚV$=\Mm=]rs' i!M`h8o<"\C:-_D?Y}z~*ߐ dk&=^c_Q~}x3>vǿW 2Qk>%yXޮ>%ޟK^0kzP0PƘ$ngd%kL{TdyG4s,wN>=GRsT$9GxT*+D41 ^20^vxauM>qX_T{s虺1^˃vaI%9jy.*}.d?k:ӿHVŘjPvP[;j'ġ~B+~jWȏBq(4ny6'Gum1-~6cKab?}.?=,lsabB3vn,ͥ}Z߶4y[ch>oz&1JfpQ㻣w4n&O] f&fs6qF9($ѳ)}r9⏖+F9Ks@r悬L'抿Ve%=ĻįߓHhi@@,{n#m)1/~G3 t>Mͧ<4'5i-)"[&O#AŝN[HH{FjÏ%ɎHE,"eRXg}ezjJA{eJFgNk%Xg*a6Xv vD>Cn-XNɟ^d`j|T=Р,29;tmP [;|[EU x*iB:vƸ)|#q]t~G>opDq\Jn;hF>=z6K&$c/Ō1& 25u5N:>K1<:K1x ^t\\/ө;u϶moEѳ~֟m_Ѿ2;W:Bc گ,_*[f]_߮uߧg?!OWZߦ: gt y*TE6|7mҽZ/ntu~w{rYWj.`ό6۰;[iЮB'lS]^zj_)\:~IvzDgw {!|)!ܭE 6 o " "6HGsd RW[z(n:uݎ{|q?wz|χ:ZKdZ(ɗ{-<3bؽs޵ hR|T\{ӧ>8_4o`h$5>"~[hM>WI^o}MR@Ɩ*Ďe{V=9zɗƻ:LL؃?_"7s}Ӳr~N>|hx 'ork֛݀D7'@/JNߦ8P`l=8վ Y'PMd4icl]5Nz_.>ṣc4ȻxY4>.w0t+e@o{-hMѕ_P7n2V/^|V˫_a3;xנZ3^ڶvMms Y/ + 7,fð k@ /af2l#geeDv0,"RQ %))I) D bz<0SVe9u}V7X{+̽\jA|߫yĮ)+%ZZu5nUM:11w_5~5&.B_lC5GXdʷ$lKq&LaLF%c?Ϸ'Ck;1UeOg°:=#!&/:40e[, Ү*>)V >i%wci/=%TܭO2n\"z_L~7%1_Gs=O;azNIOlXRO9޹(P6PEy3NC9Vj~ V8+7*g~SiZF-Tc Րˀ7V^Koar8%ʅ -m矐+A픚F**%0|ⷴ Zb.ګBѯW)uFIol;_Xg%)qn]D:#C%ʅ.}v{2mk:0t4|t/`_rn(k[r_產6IMս^I?<-~\_7YmKh2ưo}:gp/O .>O܅#Gws? .7ckľp"X鰶}!`n螘w>l"f\ͥ{Lp+}ӗ6ԳͼxW誢pПL?}N[X[>ߦ4^],Øn;yL͑x4":VrqRpwEs7ӹ3f4w *}gXlχ2)fDio"!%PaLtbew&xxwYk8'ewAڅ2,PFB[[T!sIR u1<ȺoV1([}4xVҵFAYw*sfϼ"WE?#ݠ{d=4asE5i}˯︝XM)Ia'Y@ndJ ~ﶶ_q-!7|H ĝ)!܉܏ŋݔHiTo5d/Kv|zCkMީ錮CNhϐοFnC<&sFs$7zo<3 6g+gݬ|[9-R=L}EVQ$Zcyǩ/E1?&WyfiϩC[gY  + pD(h.g+BO=-?sHoS ?(|B !?W23%H"&}w875OGbNJ<1ͽ=Q==J̙\K=)uDI VhP:4gZMI@#x4dI_t=k}ttkCck6xvi* 6c͐V3U=i >aUsgIxh&E) yGQp]%c}־Jڬ\>|;v`%'=#*k.=9}᳟S/pL~c&B[] *cy܇g=eo `\kx'ܠU{#y~=3mЇcG?zO\/#Z<޸_}xn# eOۉ`榠oUirWA}3l0+q~v,7-zGlrr12YPk17OTE=C'&0j+}4gLZV 14AzCh{pBqBBO,s~ujZ"h! [~#GI˶ i1{uNq9u3.} 1܈l'e͔^Qq=3 G~i=vcL;qY/)}I7ASSx:&Qɖ,rWWp~bd#+*vccdX̦s<h*=uh=W G"IFSI&|t,+z Oijhzy2 d.pZ_Ps'ի ȃV0Q^X4DIS|`aCzu> A!]e"]=*ӫ5 *8TPPVh[ؾìefo7}Hs $}@2% V zBKu/Jr^x `t NɧGw+.Nuw'+#e6)ƀ,/YxJgڗi a/Z*K(e)T M!Nth:6 "mcsD.\֢7v t/44:žCORmh0?o]':b' ʀѣxdEW*Y|}P-{yc/B.<~~+\x D`~R#cw{h4;497Bn5v4ɲz|{؏B1ޅثljF|Gys%/p+!ew._ !o@Q@b\VpԖ8JR:c+ز9ہMG0agH8hJGj9K/>99y|P݄j\#UI.2"4sX)⿔{[{lcWe֓^D~` 6tP "Nd_>;!8O4e[HxpANTIqUa}Qiy[9XJi^l\{gA9;n؁uhO6v}< jZnFÝW؛rO2e$%JtR׵[~Z[?D! zZ?j*? /S!c 4,t80M㑀 QM\YCE|O[ Shu~mS m׶*C2Wo2 &=5F ^(͘q&D&dT&A e PL A\X+NEAbt)%n~Ji"94#W}/O/KS^2u] :!#U>q^ aOd?/*BLVdO.Mu84EL2ecv"!ݼɤZ*H f'HԽAŒf5d1iAW2UZ##XcZ+#'rgX ! ((3 ZZ,S@e'*Gb:i*W~qIJG,$azxqߋ觤kTw#sɝOn38cp-yS\KM(23sQEE6X "Lj8^Fr@Y!T߄i55#8 _H~]Y,r:NdN$lNnfª c*۔i˔QF [RĚgj+r͙5Mg˶AJkMϒ̝--ܴ5S_ij_q}-GIk[ΨG2!Bϖ)^v2Kq_dƏ0v]cŽU*|iK[ty{&̲-mCl?ۻqS6Dw6z>HRdl;)HFQ8EtP4kּ" mТh" h)`?1f~-[d0"J2 C0M#ͯkl#$G4ǿNlV?KP1"bS(HK`ԘL%A!ХKGE9#dq-Y޽W[^r߽yps{: 齑=[|2%=}Gq65c7n+ pHm9 0nmZBSޖPǦÄ=r!R1jֆxhr]₥kPeg> endobj 31 0 obj <>stream H\j@ཞb"ܹ7apu4v$o9:! l!ǁQ}7{Cܩ-5ʵ]3}\ͥ2/>ܯSPT+)æ(6?_ã+q/­׮/DW˞mM?ctzIL3:MLuEUXooˎwj|yżBfA٘ y˼E1ߘߐߙ34xyL{fLaʬtz8=NOo7ȯ̯9  0  0  0  0  0 2ءCa :v(0À@s9`4@s9 4(QRRRRRRRRRRRRGُe?~GُMgQGяC?FoFoFoFoFo6Ǯö_[Jyϟycw} * Ȉ endstream endobj 35 0 obj <>stream H|y\TG5o^p "fLIAȮn CEPTGT0ފx}+^(x3mqWIa5GҟOuwUu{z ~Ȁݚy؅MIywܟǦ qK@ͫ@@fBJ݀~I#I =JtoZ]WB?9u'-4N:9fDJ`vbqPLr|;)~7K<,8аx)CS1 τ$C9-EoM  KVHh>)^BнK{#"atWȓ]D{#An[%w< ČaTŨxNI+NW?z`!jש[MpR 5K͚h;mD|ȶܡ_;}wiר[}螽w1*6.>_ N2tXiG1c3};>'L=yi9g̜5;wyp%yK-_ru7nڼe;vڽg‘£Eǎ(>YrtiΜ=wKrfV~ڠLEcɭ1j504\JRTzvʟ} r&?s=vnCaሡM]JRT(۔BbS(188ոx4ޔmmZm֘o4ss#s's9>LfRjT_5@ Rkp&j:QT-uZ%iigk$XZ7NoҤd`ͷDNv8[9#mm;9+?|VJu*/K|SyhL|)\FITiT&VFh9F$OeSyNIB+yϔZQDUqd(;"rMy0˜`L5'2M99UjC85ǽdNQ9yל˂9[MФ5jNn\Lpl-8E:;;:UxV/.+ŕprOR^[&f E&x**N=n<HiXQs:|/!94TiY;7߷Hw~zpV'}=k}u#!٪_(AG?/rJXL|'F.{LE6a V YxS)D.>bOxX8"lWEDň1iD N$ JQ|cLy980 HF!1)aHpH|1XtzvS.! I%NT\Gi*"&ᦅʣEC^ ZIJi u6P>mMV EٴIȏnC@)7pjP}L5i2:@DBK@t_[M Df:FI*St(TQCJY:G籇[ԀlSx*O3x&ٜsxx>V^ȋx1/<^x9D@^kx-y#oͼ6m6ɻx7ὼs|.\8b>%|Os)i+Z-C??CYzK} s|/%W*׸ ɷ6|1]KtUtu_i.箪3{\nFl ;(ֶZ}A6Q@`8ZTPvB@T$w?g'N:A'$StN:Cg,qܚr\ɗ2W;]ƫzkyM^G|G:W|] u;]$s9zg7l=Gowzz^%z^9)# RQkM^zAoMz999)[6ޮ?zޥ?һWYǜ܆S88388s-rsAtqt F_^`_}q|p88 GbIqJtr;.\#wG5]|\ q.%r\+q5֔ \uTK_HzT97[9SqjZΩw"ѹ49N5E h@ pb`h!AkCR  2b57Ng 8%r! ܕ>:*_B{(:Ag%}p?«{^?0f,xfW0C1L%e5S%R%SJTJtʠLʢl%RSR;*̥b@u.TB]G =$d>=LУԝzPOzJ>ԗomG}k}]i A8=Ai a4FHEi =oO檹f/{>榹enjs55ԙ 5H ҃ 3 GiM'iM)3J)z,=<@?_ЋK^[z|X a,%r+`%հ:Xw|kM+4S4y .ws7=nfn1eP  ED#@MB^>,eؾT}e9PcM3^dIr|F>/_/WD|U&_3c>6G+r\(˥ryV˵H]{~7L!yD<)rY):+򪬒ղV6%VjTUP*Ke*Ov:nP*U>jWOjjFjƩ&^+XxGMTSSY9V^yY^zE^GĻ{y!o7M{y/L3Ǽc暅fYjVfdmfivsvmO3{~iC^`0H0%s0,;GGagXX {}¾a8 L_qΞ'){ڞg9{ޖr{V؋^JІ~s)sʝ NsZ܈ĺDQW..ƵnrC7mmLs*Kњhm.Zm6&lZl:x7Mtd⦺infYnus<7-p v|7|q,tEy|̝ &!"ME:+""&Et"AWN K .p}{xg{7\S\t.9▸-EN |[ iqJabX<J9+AE($\+L)pcx:PGD p:ӋԅD]%FݩTJ>N}4`R 4F(z^? 9L#9;4&DzޣI4TFӱe IY>ͦ,\Gi}ο-E-%1-e|\!tёGyqnC p[G pZ`s ʦM(VZKSZO}Nh#MY,-vv>ʧtoA*CtQ:FB*b:E P)sTF穜*ju A33.%=;xVXi=VYM} )9Uq&,nխunCt[tБ:Ji5M|n6flfl/;LiLLi&' ʀ"6&Ĵ5&̄V̭\-ܫܮq>V 7޽"4pX! ~d"; 5 YX1 Të0t0mL%􀯸C SEnA[^o sA*_ 0VA cvcafmag;:s|fK D~j;a{NzvE"AP[ D@cP1YF\u*bEca9lըk'l1U?K-2}w{W\jA4dٜS25#>6qo.vs `#ȶrgJy2g&ley0uiUwwKN0F$3a)8߸#=%F@w>}/]ʇì:6f{|W|w}K7C&U76e8O|8 $P~Gɡr\"s3ՓNq{W릻 y-+t G75`>,/9xޅP_pw0=ãQWrq/c )S(x[,bX'nV 9WcmU)TV~Q~~cT<$'}k{ŷWsgpv]r `H,R{*fǻ{cbe(Xsq.q!d<Q>?UqcX|99|Iw- {&LR%ݨZFRsQτ4j%Z"R&mZ*-ه]U䙻y3f7+sKx _&FQ n?J8@rYըZWC;gB-#xDt?}.~( o:2M.5#<1~ vQ jC'^n*:e@y}NIOl;)[\%E[?-U~+ hR!B1;_Cvv1ŴvCzϥk!~ |Lu ܿ=Grz>P 7v׸6.On4ȾEq 1rm%-g5bbf~w(g}TV3/q` [ݙ(h,| |Z[It [gՆg'( S IOJ:U?^}D2u2&la 8}vr"UuZڅ7wXCN:F!|#j8tqz 2ΛFxޣpooЀ{V;L't/ i߮EUo=z o7U0?WQwnpG_Q)cN }skT=RB]S,={2@{;w`whV(QiL2]t. V re8#3} bU= s[q}bMlA 9E;PwBFԋ(q} ߣ,\+PdQcǑ|C}D9Yh~\g^2IBy.!J!6-]Ctu_8G>0C{3пkgG u[իY5wWG#˗-]R^l, |`ys}Ǭ3>MU8hHٺZe46VKHTj*mMg߿q' i}uTO`9b ן~(zA֓"uI .;8a$z-LD1eud,˩hFCR7B '=L6C!:*Xdԋ2—~o}@l3 P)1z;L-ƜmO_qw&̡Ԡ$+t :ΐ.bNײ0MZe v rrOIbQo;{l\L#hee|̽NIi74t]y>~z~\?R5{NɬɝyZ8W&%26AޭCOZrׂ b%zpbFv1rCw>!ܿqS1q/dWjIA@HD,_.ğB:^]= hp|ԌM[~($w8."baXےrnR!) Jam@HTU~es1 7Ooj3Z:M=g>h='Im2zD৅SFrnAF17a*An{O{r"(azJ*A95I"S)JUqRpV2c;霛2)b:I{sHXD?UG Iq,)vSăYu$--b+b dcTjqHK6Ύuc"H9OVv1hN\b%RFye>f^{e 1v`ʂc 8mi DqĦG! Q $llІTjR>ԪM"TE+2-=w )UGw=w7|w4Ҁ PA58`T1dS Qq]dB٫7 -d pBcxAm'OU׼S4jgH p<&z<$xl+n@)o!&l68+1KvC`렚+b+XhAcD]APW!Q+4is#g^xrHtlJnSlʃ/̀Q4@XFz^Ż|&)W0hK_Y2@n:@]f6 Oܿ&RXr"N!ejsSƾ)sBCПHӓ1#\.I7|dD&lx4].̍g$']7nҩL2aG?2䌍jJROێ+Cp3ş- l rrdPN,O#"~c2Kx/٬gت-…؛ϲLU谬5 _o)\ ȼgC|G$RnnAUahhn`gatbnl4ىd`'qE֜ fB6 ` x;H4^SqV&zp>҃➺TY[ éGB$KRE8P$l 9,Ë"P*;S:?ʧOx*puSK|RJ7[&hF %iM!AtRa&0ӈ4 D͒f/>yk{ w†={f}g=g3ϴ4,n)^9rH-NŲv-k,*:c;k70]Soe 3 dZ>w녪 Q-/. I4u;NOԞ]T(~+FV.DD/ʸufA+Pˠ>ܰ~# ٰDPu_l0:tQi*LC<ɍPj4A!h$x.Nc`P5jMA! mFs|L3z7J-\$z` -xC`u9F kكAe`GkErɁ@Dgj@,cV1l$:=9y `Q.d~ƖLdNF2mS/zw{K{6SX'^Բm}e}dY,PǢձ_`W>y ?%[iNM^iKnYsoҚ?X44,m9w5`c-<pG*:pe_FO'oRD/pnwil:Æd).n|o(F? AuO 2#5[SŨž,uهM'Mԏ;5#[Q]ܰsP(`+ l* J (+r]o'wZ|ikMoqm<wvUPRQPQU/`"eYa$/ॹaqE@i-!(KaIg2f`Tؑ~}o6u!Һ`J*-=bRzA7 ]Tڻ8i-F)/3)\X%*__N;G?Poh`C jl d}RQ) f7hA5k,WzֿbZd '0u;ِyaM#JoO0:6lij`C+eqGDߓ;emB*zZʹVΧk3~ssw޻\ݻ˽,ʂhL+f iF(Dm5u@FkL}M'MS11u҇?L?#cIG2u:Zk\PǞ=]~ *񱴡0'LJ&o \\Y|]+v+`4bY6)i:l *0yMNEi;L3t<|gaUQ M {YD:/l?鼕p/ 'rK\gNN犹o^+[Y!j$ D$N=IN$dr ڌ06F^b"@D)Q͏SHj o2lL"|+#]Їb: _%GL.d9R]C: yYp5Ι- r BR3E`W%Y˚c=;.zu[be }6MCכ3}cG>CGGߨ|~C&?kNnga ;aGlfLde4;~4G(7wK_sZvXhfI1LΖa,&"Fz=]^*]wk$œ׆+\W_5\L2yvm#ea Kmi>?Bw~g~$$:g;)+Vo!>GKao}(\d:bEeRD@e~rhMx%%gNyO/ B_ ] OXw<򦐟gP4,)!oMϘB,)l>STI1baj:Eqr}M} (YZU2a&bs!8Mp6Ƴq Yä#8],ZoeRż|iuUVŒ]l'l^d҃2VWt@LÝţTPFL)E#!_G:+gѬt{KW/F:W۠ =뺡0]7f3n: ~o}0žoVf$P"GHaZ~_ȷZּ30g͏vTI Yh]-GKconY{B58APWJ*hbѨAyPEyUSN$J,S^}2NhcyaQYe|yX|aU =M ' M.}5hGШ&:H+np1m@}jf.4.!q [V4=>^&CK*~s^Dŀ ] 5׏Oí?u}~6Ʀdva9g v~C؆X+FR-_/Xۄ{ۑ ޣ+D\Q9ee X6F ޲#T Xm`G6ǣ4rha,Ȓ888#$c(gtEpn՝lE3[Y%]LsK&x{rK˱?fDQ{XO-ՏjޢW^rM96 Bj6Q++ۣ]j8+sg0l1; -8:K dE MwU*㑒e+ |_/,?9V2VvX_ɼvz?/}"7}J.U_E ;~GpOoKERSV 2ؘdR{`$ ,h* CF"N=IM9~aՆc62de= 퓳̕-",Jɮ&;}پߏϱ8!P{D J$,!U ds)[VFƀV 0U RZ!A)P #դEZJwwa-s}5:mт4$3pH a&d 6(vqkE fGxt3F@$u"GӼY7dzVCM}Ϫ _M/Y}Unslu]Zڟ>>> _66mQ&ޅ0fCb\cdB I|S4d/A8 8Fȇq̍6'CހXn@TA3|kJ4+kmptAty*Oppv;OJ307 W$)QAVA΢=$ͷχgGQFn)GUHK9JHCa{R#(s"H%=ҤA1rt׉7v. ̧9 \\3%1b(L~MNFˢ/߬|[l6YL.r;s;;|w7ZfC-_\s%ZMkgw5|h'-D5Ptwm5jB%ZVz+پmqm.C2tGN?I\ @g~i5bDI/(nI/$G"n֯3_Sp9qg>X0%I\K6$;CI" u_ӬX1kO7b1S EaP'Ì$i=!ȡDq"FAC*vE6 %Ubu*Kj(C'r I(8.eYTSN9 "iԠ܎?%_^5./yS5-O-ʾoTycfo|/Ȇ7>ȡ:TQ+[=͜YFizfG4\5ƏރC򻎦~ YI]_w_E$oCf0j>x7o51̐O 7z%RưvYGQW> BF+Kfl=z^/uԹXTSf=M!6* 1G Re9Aaoh> I8OaY1u)zW ##߅i% hL)5xZ7XQ\yZڔB~ uvahF2DdfBzz#0ؿVƦ7/^PEc J}.pV)Y+Kn^W2[!tK޸S^VK]Mg;ٱ}Ͼ}>sl'2b~6 @;j'4v]AV%j5DZJlT5L6!Xv`E HźNe1{ϡ0U=yya#PB ڞLÇ pRCy K3(/'&?4XOggeF#7R`REޓO?T򷓟'Cx" AqLR%K %$2˳&KŢ-E1@t̲X2=ERV2uoU=f=%#r!BG-<ہJ㚅,(fAV/,Jfn7>N8@c}lEo%*NDA ѻex8\5k /w0$RBo/f-3XV;Ըp+ߊHD!6 k_; hW*>IZ|Z U 7Oڦ)nْ'4E2*_?(ws8pqVXT`QzQB;^/e [Qf$m5gk}$GSs Fik"WJ{ ] LAU P -INf@` Z_p ;j4H5. -ߡhb:Pt 5l6# ePԠjl :#QmלďT$\OK4(8ӜԏEWXMs_l| orۅɭߝn+xSiUoڞc/6j(F~Y}z呂+q\iGHu$imd9b3`|\6nYn[mkLYi`mm4w8(UrU$1`.J YRqva@"Vl :cit|kTQBd,U8ϡq7GG\.WBDI3J8=8Xi xd Zj0x9v92՚y1`X!Hi@rAB ТK JhUD0n?f~DzsӮq: LؿIk =y{)7ئc7ܸ 'bݲ>GaBuG`%m&8:<jiOlaݹ@wG_Yu[́w3x@9s@"|3:{siMѬ &X=˸ 82Ő g;~/=bkZ0^0막QZ)N))ݒ_CKm󟳝;w9Iqĉ/M ƺfhtZ&UH0X;P6i@WF@֊ cFiJ` 餉ݻ;)~z3@ҚA&K|!kq ~nӉ!c;I 5cWTlF(G(ZiSMgkk=ᗫcTDK,N&8]dYO_o*WV]Q=4iU*=@Ll 38y~NTOsDl}i='nT9?ҏ幣Q]y>ݳP:~j-lU5BRȭ ?:zd6^!(p/cڵWcEc̆6!hRX8BGx=`? w,`t?/ ~s;9~x 3ŕb٬ai8+r3Q,|İi]-;o^+,YcP+-E%n8$U 9ZUgEuE+ЉsL' > _?3*8,11Y6 :5a]EϏD8$c`>B5jz iY^#`Kΰ/ϋ~rH<`L=<'{ZZYr"ͧɴyJ8-KVJ0'L͠nkEQ+4(N:{O_gF73n+2pÍ Yryr%tߑ?pu|y⦠L&ed4zF8:qlojI^\ ")^uү`RN5m]ɐڠ鹞.5gXT%PHiLډEdBE9hd|AXX ԓtT]/D[v?pBuv64ĺ:: )lYcc #i1+F2%d<3tff~!P֮3^98(qׅO%`0t RH^*/K9||1'ŖЫ$-s:厛!hUDvӑL7$75Z CxMgV ygמ*,MIl༳b;'nnVws/ål:p @ VMl|SG9 e[8%NLNtE~ NQ>x=f'#xOu+ۖ켵ίӿM-DHǍjS*o&>33Ʋ4S1E,uG>֕Ř#ÕXzV@^3+pfvfU I8Է/Hx:Rp֋[fZG%:7.R%-Lġ= Fá%Eˌg2x&t:ќ쩓9 n77eM\Z-"w TiVܬu,ڗfG9 ֺen]E5Y1mK N]RE}+Aэ}#`9yĽ*_~T>M UEb@hp7,ۅC^[ٓTMI+`l3\V 7bJ!\5]'ە@OݓڍC>:;αql_8 `WFAkĿQT6+(`Sutk0( I 4jZ7).-JcZۥRn#8{9aI{?{}k۷:6\1R2)L;Q&QCj@dj(Q]):H#+ fm*>3 G}XL3iW粑pX?S^(A`z ;D{N2Av~ZiŤf8B6m" _7IQ~*jNr7v,*\DRM/L>]$rF& U-7D#rSXO>M "ŌA:;%&Fpm IQ 1\- 1$qƵ̵3^+% ":MuS"[#D /;g^A9NgX2IDx/8ɶJKƉSK'RDRPNA8Rp妷XjXj^^gyol{~I!j2TI3#EҜQQ277ZE(28xiy 1D/r/mw4 o?@s&4!E&&a )cY+r|qQ2/gNٲC.^%y$2Ύ7mfj?'E\v.M':؋htaUDXܵUczrm,Q9Bb:E4t80ȭ,06%4RVt}G,_-"O,gc}5"Ɉk=.OK ~U@Ǩ!.aI\32g広@8\.a;ĐnkٶWzzg v4,rxC"p% RAɀ'J*ޖ?&YdB.8}zHʼ0:qu"j)MH9%]>MD씒 <~X[.}>葧>q_G>RYCxêߝV0qnr0 4-p"ʒV|Ra`YBy% zU{'VOJY#Q]ݜ|(96 WU{'vr0VACSi@H(~EpKs(E{8=͆/( @90tV ( Y|2{9;-F)u@cchX"^cþ0=' .@d8Rtrq[p~IJ.Ms? -ee1G%_ %5 3\Z%iɣh  X LE'ɥ&A R^ jtZXMiiqh &Z4YTԀFPvP,ȥۨсai쁶E T IJG?3> APAS}Mm[[ڷtl54\ j*J?;Oc|qwې B)Ii"5E*аd @U@WiQmB\]ŦJH?h *uiE0-h{:mQ|ݻ+k9q'ߕv=芭:Ub#\"6^Ψٍih!ZCX(.aɃؑ@ގ)kU(4@(y+ r[@AJ"tp~,u1< =q,%<$SƠo7|f3ќ/cF1 ?Ja iH{C:WtXCB,{$Z4%( ÜCAa_7!^u#pGr#^ō5rVN$YִX3 @ 'yG,'{@73qșFbGaъF* </Ҕ^[Z|Ut*˚fz ??{W;i#DiϱջV.\+otOXݡy۴t1LgPN"C!G#G *K%[4yy6'tRpF<(~"-E`X#N m?Xsy,<\9% iu=AhvLKM(Rdk~.,0OבjPzY!R%*}&.=kKB ~^"hGGy4ӓ v¨N6Q|⳼ YAT ΰ2N W`8vf>@IglA{k駩 WbXa6= +N%; E!ׂG_TmeG(3oZ%%ֻjynvDƭ+ֿ ̢0Vhu5e4uyYWF>LB%M/܀ ViH[>6럾3Yk<3˷\IrmC% ĜF$+@I ètK^8sU]%JNN*$K**<_YdT2=żq$;??fGK~_Bm6!eUXl`WA`>?*C*_JM9;n+4߆k1n$~!F.P&0,I8s5uz[Տ4PH\T#aެ'4Uo 8y/ 05%zIdQ$*_yP]7gt.&);NߧrHguEsCyxRտÙ^E|ɣwDdSezs2=TaS/*@ Cn+yqH,Ysdǖԋ0|k {&ѷC1=O&2k_%Ҟ P_ JOٝ^+sAgk!4֏HiU)A"p T^73x qA ]cpRB"r|јN5g9?H y6ٲnUUx<#,Sv nyHe+n nvv;3rtޤu٣!Phzs=MDz23=cqyCEan.NuTۨZǮ@߫/{jP]t}l7$(ˆQbU/?aFv.Ϊ @M+4;=.ǜbڕ~WRp6 (cK<$ߐUrr]wK;-]]^rJ_>Μs|0pH_XpOP T5 2 uTvR HA5,Kr'.I\aNk\;-ftG&zqTY.^=4&XN8{4M<۾|ʑ<깾N,h(OQIbodz3\e>{?nYV*;,sOn{TGr|͔h|aRL@/;SEa8CT#~4sL s723TL2"s?)BZ\P/}}Q _D} sfk ӣDveM )lՕ8rX"E}勄q iŋ")B#cъP* Ƹ VI\0w.6 @N#9`J;@wK!0u,G QFC= 986WvO!x޶s6ămEMm[sP\D-ǺYHTWmIpGmFf?lV.]!%]f;:SYᦲJ[7K޴t,'u;BWPdQ7ԍr滗Ln8qܭDzs>+g?-mO֌HR|]h 8:yMH9UJC;fcstG]' ni(! pse JZH (4|!h!'ּ`Oq|qtQK DL#UҘ5;iv $uCQ$pZR 7@/B/Qମa9[ޟTX(gGե̌$PuӣTWj1A 4kA`z"酠T~o}'hnHyr.QDy. tP-WeB&͢ٮL$ԆDcf "(7>.;=fPl0;;ajgk7Nrz1X"!7dPVu5&¬pAziW`g\ҠNd2a$G\1=1`gL6ly;o̐xh8Xa\p>KCpvJwE,+11n?B $Z\!BȆ"*3c,EK¿(“%hy@Pmcc8{hwE k)w/=ލ}}lz- e߻Ov%|s]#A=$ ;E"Ұb4[@8 bAɉi!$#d@9ҽ+t\>G[%˔n  04 9֢V&QyHb%L ,8SncɣX:)҃b.E ls?/ҹLIZ>@+gbȆɬ&PƌI]5}+J .8?¼qUf5֣~X݈[#)Tİ')*mbvfbF<#q)锳$H07]w^q^H"d`&^.EMAѳzqИ0naax Kڛ,cѬg&g4GMּI&qT!hqR)i&V*,RTRE+d&XLPlY*T,@XE%5D !u>(mA@@pbwN3Lq'-lȇVHɵYV! @d_i+ז[JYiIe+RP}Yeࠔ c' A5 7== 2WS]_RxjbVW/+N2u{: ť#շg_06~wzMo]=!+())Z&O`UᱨıHXwVtJTȟ뢡jqw t^DBY-ԅIz|A2"7`uOb<\L+:LC%/q<~n8m^ƍv6]79Nc„8!Wk)IL@TCGtH( M.VƉ*VƋS(mgGS8Ub;%Uq5ۍ dh\sJ[Em"1W+ee^_<˳B*`޲'E{;n @얆sKZAM[˪F }$|fKPS5!J`hE'裹f8&yFڢն4CK]*V\oz7zg] U7X}rGuu]G~\g-dz+6$<&OPYE}x+Rjs@F~[ݷos}ܨPK5-G8_~f:k.e.=Qٷ_aj5x[̷d[#y?uV\S<$G-%ʑh˺^>>ӛnȽDLB,D^f,6m'IzE۳OE8o~jm#s==clΌ39c'vb'n=illtInCvTk$ɂXZh$ZnmBr[Q҂ 6ѦsmVwΜ;;}xvyJɜ*k3r)!cX_kl5caFX̒ZRJY;R)[(ey2ks!m]x ;G h0'x&zXR g좱ܲSEdRI9G\&KhD|} 5 kc ÊG)ϣ}*ş/0*H'Ўl~~5Tx i2HBHN22=U2L hAs9Hf%) CK,x{V?)(!%TJ !#F @] kW53VrJ*Vo%a+qYrTwWsAl!}<~yRCkO |5E,73_ctq)hMʝ0F pE]z|xx+.2DJɐ wo:O ɐ8QXuH!ˇ D1tnQ%Ͷ.q UpS0 X iF2\z9]MWi4]L_OJ?(.dOZ[p wXK]*=~LçXh A[|( >1KJޯ`iX0fMnunVk@EkۇayjmywW+;0׻ԃ8(9W%XQ@pWlCyCPn*zA ~#uؕ\ pmxgefkA׷8xt;k<<78p av δٴaB8({pe-HX&( sE8- ch؄{Ӭ4hO&ekڎfQ9dࠡ 8ڦm$JFFNީ^G21%NewRb^;6b+//pU gv$C/I%2'e*KҎd6#?FƀnYnp4M$1H .YsW tſhe&wПLR/ʹLƇtY^TjtO}()K2g&ɚe $;hǾ}0u,4h^0- `n<ݣS x@@G:%Sl8%p8ڞ/pCdmz{Э]yO8>* %u-[=:ΪΊ~k"C m)9$ACd;%QN`<#,ϊ?1CDмJ\3Pܮ(B- %"^1rzAW8HB3@ze }>15+Ch;DtN: jGأc \JX Cox&LLK/G K.ض+R)Z$-dK-2-GiY[Q]bxCX6HzC=a@>i&mU ݌ӊ=6t (D9GD#swEmF`\T%W@+q7C2SF25H~XLbd`Lf602TRUߟLj5MZߛTbsڹv1y﹟xwz~*/IJVflKW?#h4fU_Mis_eXV-/d<<ʿq%LOyS5uE[ JѴ,OwJ&I22C6[}UUS@J#2ܺ0^ h2fߓҩt$fp9.eɰx3 lg|1 1oW$UHE3[ȿ $?D4yyG'ߔd^Ē%V\˪^Nַe;Fn̖Cod`k{DuhJ}̚G(2~8`6 P18!S+cAXZַY,ⶸ-(>T6aʒcP_w!Ɣ/P E+)KO"P" nȮ17Tӓy%;?=1q!\6E|7Yƕ#j˙M;C~ ü6e,gxN=.CVpފXol]Hטx#}g\P,2k;kfYZZ 5=4 :zaFjHm @@Frd>0>{Ⱦ@VD8.I[Ѐ1%:vt-8N`]T `r[h,s%KvW>h{#c I.M33sec4[Qp| :NVBK_+wȄPtCf2ې7H]xA:bL79 + VzAs):*`2Әl@^[$ȧ{~ɝ2bXsq ]WǥƅWgWP\Zw{-T+ԯB!TTkj7gUڍbߪn",S7㊃IZ9>ȇfb^%fo魶s}v5ԣɣPŕ}ruv~FS_/"#a~' %j-;c#;hcKg&4MPmVHeҰ0`.CeTݶ6ADSzPVQねj',NdPDPu p SAh+@7eUWS1d8šG #zߵF];B'Ћcfg{X@=+Ѐ>?1wxYt o1{=rm 'mhA&}6em-UOm__ǎ}3{O1sosx]?Uy^{w*[EWqNgss5R:Ta"suo$Ic`2) 6u7EA;&u:^l02p^X@Twa}5xv$uzuUmLj4pUL EOPY q|KӜ] >d+k- jzyw99󎫡o$7]f>dRi.z9g&(3>do]Ex&4l>3Y7㾥Ӂy8=GT\/į5ڭ٩2nXSH^e,#HzG4dguWG]vц蝜*REo"wFJ/_* HT! \T6p,]ȅmany­Y\xQ`аlHInzi{'?T6Uf $%T@.xx=qs?mT@aO8wS+O$֌l{&~ -,7QX$ћ .!^Ey$^ʇ5F &$" ^% 80N \8Q' K=P \%k^l!`nc̬"*#Hpmʹ,uT:jkH;>lʨ:ߙcMH{1iRV' ֫ʫeN[ rGms+4^ x%ofVyULdQ՘FFQ&`L;( BAANVK ߇bB>o&nMNm-ߵXpa~ז w1|T IT*#БLUVq{ )& xANJ2O;KZbbq.%l⤅Hϰ 2ܖJ6)(z~_QXrMw?=طlaHBiua$ U# G$"2L!sœ63^p bY%ݹ |$|v5]p ?0dosI_?QXZ*.[o̞6UYѦmY3hOi8E}i5r2ajnܞ/Kg\ȕ;0ڵ PMt4iJ~Mwc׾I`\enLNTy`S`r`&SygLڂ]VPXZ7YzYN#6w$v@*փQ!h>o5{7ӏV2A1[¤O|Wf"j ToSf0AHƌ 3Ę4&<ϋ]r#Tr с*z\E+hL9 UaXO=슰0FKח|l\4l&t&tT4~KUAx &JsY)i沵U{_+KZ\,EN0^iWk?UFc;}cw=+'IJHąnJd*򃆈$D%qܸUEI$h(?B DN;q̜sv Zx,Dt6|NUUXm#9 %ZZjjO?V=K2\{tO3Hh堈Dg/ΗN.ƙhXGzYyLLVPBi`ulϳB3/Wo3@ۗ$BD6*rMKf2dXC}1% 1O7~K+( T[=N8Z/~GAHz?j3aGф8%ΊF;=o.fMsClW$W33p2T.NHW4J֩ qs XU#</tYwɩ8q88/xh,{]^SC3g7Qn2Mld֘5gseE4 L%|v䭏aa/, ަ`sZm`vnH쀔TC@ƶL΂hv  ]Tw.ŝKT` P쒥|" mF :A<u0&F?x7c9A.Fm޶6d woDB Ec19Xށ%!\ҳo|a笮^[|泓H,J'w;TeI 0/̗~S=z\7?=!cbH~/zMʤ [*_.(P.kB@üȫT%#TbN%6*%1٢8rrsuoO|&(#[r/aXYq6% A4QX #y@_xY!ebDo,c~^_u.s* hs~%r%of2x`<"Z^cM7b"7vli #t|S˕ąx!5TDzA]RoU}D6M:;T &eV3Etbv)ĭ``"mCtlZvmې nLt`^DoެRLcwȶy{5XOᩣRc{Vu,l_4`VB zɬ$+fd8e+Hv Tlİr> iD)$}t,OUnۻ㎋" K[aNS,%hl.S :(C~2< 2=Can` 7A5*~REwoT=t2\n CvJ he5Nc ]Cޮ`Ճ 3\>.m F#SPxJP]GԦYE9Ϊt *imַ?S #s؅lZj̸(E#NI)%TI;1d[Y-B$F^%l5r jQy3M|R |9*]z~|t)>.~q Ѹ~hnWrC;>I?5H2`X<Q YhoPP;;w+LPxd9. (AXʊ&wbX$~@R񧴓:3hU 'UʴI8-9%-M׷s|x0 y=||.hm7#M~#Op&*/S~ӟ1^G&eQWT8o=Ab@ڵѕ)im(Du K.3ku\WumUgkș+NzI:HZG{T& K C}"U@.AC.aQC$ gP,9P $ V(8]j*jUESKE|.82ϙ\v3ݙlv晝qfeS SՁR $(R눐²v%h%}j4C.Xd҈Fʃ[TE"vά]`F|眙9s9WAn膀.V"Dv3])l.Y7fIG^t2G ״}H M_?\]r";J/+Btc.QS+q}!:}~l;CރI*$(!W{3Q '? 8!-~Df7e:NL/\;:{=μ~}j |Vx|Yv]vQK FY;O ka OV5OysޚuʿO֖ 7My-(՗FgDž3!\|*ڼ>s̫gCBTXDj(&$+J o6 A iUhZfڲL%4cf4̀23UVKVV$9-IWdIdSYX%tMAwKp' |)&4z+Z5( Y+QrA&{2zSFȿ?>TNC<,:vx-!Љ N ή0ӆG@cUDIXMFH~B",Rh-[,zb[gw*iS[ ai52 r1,ƶ^{'zH/mp;G)BL.0$Nz6ΧJ-D)fkdޥL2x1<.bIA)'%LF`oCM_4K3J~4 ~MȎ+4}ݴWYoCۼSEB;ܘhZD+g_mu@!57E~LMf30_ Ғ$c SKBɱXKFY~t9ܞni*<4_\)QŢﺣ6=-&r]|Yfffhi' 8(N R,1_|ZUmiVKKd cH7 X}I C#.Dj0T$W@ 85P(E6W/eQծ*#O[|Q.G&qEK仄OvvמZ\]{; +~kcey=*n )O{]~jS~v܅Ecɱ$?6 Ba9.S "^qH1*66` B? B`@LvbA*ޡ$ڸ5eXlW9_S9,.p)ίÑKci(H.zFɓ|Ay8Aq%3)L3~z@oJL8YַJƯwݡ/ ӣ_} +ͨK`ȅR!b,P\# Gʧ(cm'j 3V]oʣr%}]:j^}v9QWV|/K_` Ju~ױc/2EgwGtR++_$VcN %6F΁#El@=i9!l IM7a~};컰wD1-Qt'Wy߃Kl|.>@狻.;D}B~N ̰l,?gx59t/~0-9Ntt{Sc1 c,{V>Vs='A$c{ȶA*rClNpl;L@Ad0DY+Ρ+[q5_䚢V/#v%g_fFs9DiHۜ8J G9tFgfCOCF1ڝZݸ׽q|'{MoBBbla) ![jB!8ZSdZKVʏL'eTZZ*@79羛Jñ/BwԻ = G84. wW|1CVa{Y:;~<-ҟVU k*{ԱcsNpsK@Qz\5{[kgL gOϟ2t@¬†JZqQR\9ol}YIUUS?0%hC䋒ʦ|I"ZmbkeYe9ݓKwo8+gz?ڨ_ 3bMwED=mD`Ef[6(G ʳ!Ao 1׀ }|p 6Sk=h#F@kG*'|R,d>;wG:g1,wQm3whOQz N僟9}^*]n[~[gY hz >otO2Zo%#~ۖ׿ `#Qx(qj[˴\7J! {iLU~@\]%IhKnG>@0x~U<ܭ\Rm$בʧߔ_'PXD U~ G8|叩@\g OYqX^Hn:~1ikx*>)Rqmrx|]{*_#øovQ]4!s%^hΩIJN.s2hp ЬH< p>{y4Y(ݸb[}p^!L9k\rtSbnu_-ař:2cH} 7%ɱeܕk T=.׀[)A]\$u* 1{Ab`YDrsiޯ8k1U5wTjFuh/wEǨB4h#7!G#_6"?,0ne|cS n3),rC+^<+k_m>+Q?->wOecTa{oќ]q䥻ٿ K ~K k9w^(ޥ'#@>Xބ:N[sQX_YҢ UmahglĘS$zX}p#B.i Z_ef rrmd~F@a7ݙngcx^eklmSv`^5}$ t P]{=Š1,'rYM  i;sB0п >Cn'xishϕ_EA#\O5XFN0y|R\(E>bF&ܫ/lo"Cwǻ./kS6|Jam<`l"(E99OPCUs ǖcZ |xr2eT0ep_UUW^sMbh0 H4DBJ <3(C"B2u;PQBQT*֙R@ SmGv oInbfgkv;ClP؃ZiO"Ùty7q߉| zvr1J̇yl'\߅.틭δec3ltOGXZ٨'8;/X1aBg0uL99o" ]] j^ n=v5PӐ'8"j낾ωz`}Qf [Q 5 s)O s~X6.cz{ֆжCtĎT]#\lxhŚy{y -'7tjJѪegՏiZc@sjgկ!hWqHpKhs.bO1c .װ?w\@{A`wR.~03]h 9ueAl!_\DsqGi/w\%Gg-y>$w Vcg.m)s;Z#$,GitzHD]Gѻd}yehb&ār%fC!|sN\IS&z?Z1;;M۹EU}n!sf#~ uZݓߎ?/\w "];TM (S]/}Y+KbW4{65Wsq@q.4CW.I?E|.ܛg:Z6W&!W2]&KbãrAEqەqщM^>cȧRcW_YH_ #<|̝%ɵR*O{n꜃!!o|e9Y2:&P+>ܿ:sܰ_rJٴMû rjA氯ɹz{"S3ߗN29]sw;Q_±ؓBFuf(OеҽdZr+S+euX2Jy_[ڊC'ea!f s-g/'7[dΌs 9Zv%)̗87bܙ9]$m`;>W9?vηgyI{7X[#:E0?Djm9Y&.ޥ2]7b_GǮ76{J q{Qz=lgkf*X/? sqLpy`35g'q:όtf_DUu߸3! }Bڲ(( jG~|+~dk͏l}P Q/mÿQ?s(iÏQطum.C<&RX%sM^K.ySRonS2<9;H'nZߙ/ǶZ+~#We-wǾb C&E!Fk,4pyLH +ayĂ[rĜ*w,zo~Os^ Iā(;eVMCDZĩDU#o%x[hx/=Dsn>˾h F\\30.4=Oߺӹ87݂~ۛl,K|qN & 24O9';'0s?p`=uJ71*=ϒ޵nλmK\Mξ=!=b~jn~Pd#W~J]Kf٧u.'9=f[[\y{2 .# ѾOJ{Et/GlxO^5ܴ-t-,OS+ );p[-=r JPIOsier nL150ڌ F~ٟyǼ/ zy*{Dʳ*EEn{5ފSL7Ns&os?׼"k8,ۏ#C|L'O ?{=K/H໋?XĂqbBJtE5 #_0 e<$~>$ϡ~ܭNw9{}ȇ3o ZΑ{5/yzΕol'N9Wa;M^{yoSSq>!%Ol{sR/rP\^s?ψ]3].sMp~ Y/|Ai@D1H&&٦So,gW7yO>>ijmÙW "cA~)ɒ܎ kqx S~o6ҾGM B .%[My1 ǪE"zqX[v}G}^/ QB kRJĤ|!cryyNl}o#{%k,$̤aɵ!WUc(Bj"SRC5s{+ɽzѯ#BrceTcnJx_shk|[Pc/u>9y#6[k'1ʘ5y6I]:g>*uO5޳iw7a(!*1M3V|Fh{ ϒW{PiH@з/9! S-<@R>T 36QF9Dy3A𢡊$|';/u71X pYs'%jf'e̓a>63Zva ~6x &gx^~]YF=rh|'0y,klj0Q9k o[ܽmǒvs6bΌ`1%+ X (pXO7 }lmXSJvU5D#P>xG .a kcnL4tݔ՗k/XmQUsߺ``f/|̪s}(ro.d 7Wj:?{TW33ewK Z@*V4M0sYffYHٴUBSiEVJ ILJ0?M4EBw %5&g&}}ww~y b?`ٗ{zs#~KSKpgȌ8q20"C+CK WZFJOOD气q;myad6)/,"&sVY8x{3|ˋDV꾌W>|smg/hKgaKX/u򤶗'sSԃh~N2)#XR4XB~YR^YRݸxsϸxOq>t&YTzmR^XEQۺy?+5Ҥ!nFw Y6#0u&a2"8?  8_wnW7B6֫,>iip18xo -wK(;ɵ88A) 9 &eR~Ȑr/;je2rCp+z?NC.1qPI̦sإG{8F rXF<=w>)"s?nރFmw8CUݞ9ika z,xT=רSv۱(eOV`R{SŚji`w=d= ʀ\>ܭgq}R|}}IwX|T2~$iÍm'nV|*9owO R> (GW=ݥtZu\Nfe6ڔ{pޥp5\) ~!D2xmH lT5HGIݏvwqGE>"XN#=}ǏM9 ̙$resw E"F4yizô\s<|G@&|Y7T" _&J8b~QɴSNl s~yvOX,bX,bX,bX,bX,bX,bX,bX,bX,rD{R ~)#<I T iHg+?JFg<=~CozzQ gUtԆz_~OtS0X#a2EE$!+, FqS:IwJƤ\Kiisd*ut$O%kDimff77]v7٢,lNufDjmI*Ի:+N@@)C9DN1otA?V'.&D߈JSrSW'M +VLȷPPWBO=$>TK ~~S3u%fGJtxX*CY %. )|  GR !e^? jAۯR{ϒ_.i-w{o!u./G wzW"&S^z4U겺*mۡO OڪfWad{^b-}cǙ=ۨp/&݂`-Xn(ӝ3UuS:0^FDz<3]eŽcj]߄j^Wzj5&jXDO꺮)uz6usؤy pl\HjG X(kdž%H  Z%quS2Mј] [j@|hD1oBZk1Z6Vݲ(&ysϹr*o$1m@" & @ pcNS"#/ĪcҴdG?KZ9πL KZ3<ڀ87F\g̪11q鑸5wvv'X/6pJkImW焟2@|,]ymٰuj jj?|Jp\pU׫~ի}WۊԌw*Hp% ?$4d MZ/XL&x>kwڇav<})mıФ>uX>iŴFRT'I7r]{~DRD%" ]ss/̿,'y]S߂snzU!!w`.t̓\6ƿ/HD1n[q?sbAbꏝmx8S0?tb/v >;S,#M׎C3V2228/Pݎ f+5Q9X&.&H a_L^#aUG?,E6y/kX!tB{Ev9FLKU2=䰕XYEz,X 7نVR輎(9;dy+>p.lQ[&Y5lM4;ʴgymk*#%*n1l3t]-Z1ϔgsȳ߳i<<= jPZFUUEuJԆڪ%8 J%3?%J8=rF &]7I+){;[jDrҫeJfEkѮ^&ͼwf^h^#ѐ}o+?ddlx)^chчW0+)i:}wS2gw{`Ht\H.K䲗/rd$"MBFLnlDD貐 k$*E"c\M(\@&m&M"W˰1*MVK_$l# %.%‹úQNAs5 6CU#Dx[GzzXO_z.h JGo@Ȗ =ȸ}KOGT42K̖Ƭ3bTnya;HSjuO?&4Ok-d2ւ je$if [RI2}b%_ pc8-Ȯp+._hήՓPk5C8S( (x)`޳(kT¬ż7yׄ>aL4O̻~F9>jیyәټ(\w \7o҄9m6%]q_܈HDd:r:2Y(7P~F+QRWbb^5El"B~L.Jt?w. 6=rܚ> OҠܱܾcGvk;8T}k&:N&ǫ:%WprH^\"Lq*Dh T!%b?AbB ER(.!D+ѧf endstream endobj 29 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[286.0 226.0 297.0 237.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 15 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 2/Type/Page>> endobj 36 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (98121413)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/98121413.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:38:12 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 47.25 591.75 718.5 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g /TT1 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm (Compare)Tj /TT0 1 Tf ( )Tj /TT1 1 Tf (Continental Van Lines, Inc.)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 14.999 0 Td (, 63 Comp. Gen. 479 \(1984\). Perhaps there were other reasons for rejec\ ting)Tj ET Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm (Cartwright's estimate for these)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 12.455 0 Td (two items, but the Army relied on the above reason. We cannot see any re\ asonable basis)Tj -12.455 -1.125 Td (for the Army's conclusion that Cartwright's estimator did not consider a\ ll of the damage)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 35.352 0 Td (claimed and cannot affirm the)Tj -35.352 -1.125 Td (application of the Army's repair estimate for this item.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Finally, we consider the patio furniture. The record indicates that Reso\ urce Protection disagreed with the valuation of)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (the furniture. Cartwright's inspector inspected the furniture, but)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 25.562 0 Td (it failed to offer different evidence of replacement)Tj -25.562 -1.125 Td (valuation. Therefore, we will presume that the claimed replacement costs\ are proper. The only issue is whether)Tj T* (Cartwright's)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (estimate, which indicated that all four chairs could have been repaired \ for a total of $30, should apply. The)Tj T* (Army had every right to question whether this furniture was repairable,)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 28.769 0 Td (but in the absence of some empirical data to)Tj -28.769 -1.125 Td (support its position, we agree with Resource Protection that the Army's \ rejection was arbitrary. The Army could have)Tj T* (maintained its)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 5.888 0 Td (burden with a reasonably focused estimate finding that the specific furn\ iture could not have been repaired)Tj -5.888 -1.125 Td (by bending, or material from the manufacturer to the same effect. In thi\ s)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 29.184 0 Td (case, the record does not contain a repair)Tj -29.184 -1.125 Td (estimate or any other material indicating that the patio furniture could\ not be repaired and had to be replaced.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (The Army believes that its TADV estimate sufficiently overcomes Cartwrig\ ht's estimate with respect to Items 181, 184)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (and 234. In this case, we do not agree. The Army cited two)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 23.882 0 Td (decisions of this Board to support its position: DOHA Clams)Tj -23.882 -1.125 Td (Case Nos. 98021009 \(March 5, 1998\) and 97122315 \(January 12, 1998\). \ However, neither involved an issue of whether)Tj T* (it was appropriate to apply TADV to the exclusion of a carrier's timely \ estimate. In both of these claims, the carriers)Tj T* (made no efforts to obtain appropriate damage estimates but)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 23.964 0 Td (simply attempted to avoid liability by arguing that the)Tj -23.964 -1.125 Td (government's own estimates were defective. Unlike these two decisions, h\ ere there was better evidence, especially for)Tj T* (Item)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 2.083 0 Td (234 where there was a timely and un-rebutted carrier's estimate, for eva\ luating the damages, and the claims office)Tj -2.083 -1.125 Td (was required to use it unless there was a reasonable basis for not)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 26.02 0 Td (doing so.)Tj /TT2 1 Tf -26.02 -2.125 Td (Conclusion)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 0 -2.125 TD (We modify the Settlement, finding for Cartwright on the amount of damage\ s for Items 181, 184 and 234. Cartwright's)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (estimate for repairing Item 181 was $20; Item 184 was $30;)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 24.188 0 Td (and Item 234 was $30. The Army's modified repair estimate)Tj -24.188 -1.125 Td (for both Items 181 and 184 was $85 each, and $256 for Item 234. Cartwrig\ ht should be refunded the difference \($346\))Tj T* (plus the amount previously allowed \($423\).)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Signed: Michael D. Hipple)Tj T* (Michael D. Hipple)Tj T* (Chairman, Claims Appeals Board)Tj T* (Signed: Christine M. Kopocis)Tj T* (Christine M. Kopocis)Tj T* (Member, Claims Appeals Board)Tj T* (Signed: Jean E. Smallin)Tj T* (Jean E. Smallin)Tj T* (Member, Claims Appeals Board)Tj T* (1. )Tj (This matter involves Personal Property Government Bill of Lading \(PPGBL\ \) UP-221,152; Army Claim No. 94-051-)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (1211; and carrier file 348147.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (2. )Tj (The estimate prepared for the service member provided a $450 repair cost\ for Item 184 and $300 repair cost for Item)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (181.)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 37 0 obj <> endobj 38 0 obj <> endobj 39 0 obj <>stream H\j0\/֚ma&NQwNN` /IRՇwL`0˶.4܂yk&oF`L3oQ2i|zvV"y B:drgʲZ\_dcx7/k\FYoXQ8S 6إMEFdͬ+|DηAV̊xϼ'lN|@VTƜTAo"cs49sN4guwM&7n4Q`aِagCΆ} 1cǐal?N%#zSu;8WJ endstream endobj 40 0 obj <>stream H| TnC")@ 4ō\cfLdMTquETg(.O!L.;=n[]};u!nW,3FĤ@?bی&1â 0Io ASF<>cظuWx|)jth ǏCb3gGD7}^kҔb-NGO}[368s~|Y/RSLjrwMbc[׮s. 5n.5ZOūi-ZĻu|wةs~v̿{z?ી5oA?!A!044,~"dg Ξ;_ J.^|*^nˀ[XC5XTja<(&4J+V q$GKn#NYܧq&ח{yݕ^{1^Y $CXPU\UX}r=i#D;::|LLmMmLMZZLǫfPlqq1f8ģ6Fgl5g&=횷yl1}&ow{zVvM3B s.tYZֿ[^nfc/< u a(DK_XRg84Ujj*@U `s͑9>J=l,0Oyy:ݸT3ǰ,HdX[`C4AsPEp@\P ;a<p J"DC(90H(0@ q0baLd2a-L[NGR\2 UqB5W?k+q5kQ6XmqWPp#nBn-v܁;qfn܃{5\$L}`&ĺh0 =:#܄[x`}ls(l<'0]vA6Fxs16A7tSo-܆;(5|eg;z^7>g}RA/=LCT.=HOU3T Y٪DU*Y5W5OJe_~K֟ `_Ⱦ-)t/B1# ݙ3̿-!@N)5wH )!HB|zAnfEnvCnG~y@t.87!<,ȣ<.Oȓ<-g'sٹ\un8M.ʿ<' $/+򪮮k蚺躺膺n覺nfu~jSajFQjƦnBT Sj&5EMUt7n[Vnv~_~;莺کvjګ::i{޶:Nپ:mH3\KJo;,ދ"P|DHP%I}A_Rz@)e%) eAe씃rR.My(/KܴE* RA*D*F;NVO8D4TS Vg4B((&$L44 BTkFUTz>JQ3;,eɊ=l8[ 3qfY9g7rɹ87Ἔ4].9p.ƺqn0n\8ĥ4qi[\sw]`ȕ2W\s ɵ6\snȍbnM7ܒ[qҬ6ܖq{w.ܕ);np7r4W^ܛp_yAyYbM5q&0#x$<88C9MI4IflءvnG9gGQvcqv`Cl`?O6Ŧp x"OSx*O|PPEP(@G DJ4ʠ,ʡ<*FETBeTAUTCu@MBmA]C}4D#4F4E34G D+F ] ߠ;E|lz7/?`. .`1C:P%tl1Ӽ}Fd411C1L,pHhXxL@B&"i&a2"0S1 131 ,|,B,B$X<D#C<$,2,XXXX؀؄؂؆a֙؉]؍=J>!H<OĿf.>~1'y&N,HD(1'Buh6fjfivfk.vi.g栝eg9vgv!C@lv ")UFO Fy%P&XsE,8K+f\fÓeE//@ɜɋ) :,D7N @{ƚ*P +yGp4hDi?+Rԗi8qKzޤsYq0z{Q~ 9k,O7!oF^C4kx]OA{y:p/m`7=rtZS W>wzXfnROےێ] v N"Gk.0_5fTP dN=Oӡ0u:6!t"N@_\۽N7B{.+8p%q)*^*Br*5KY``r؎ۮm@5L'Dv(^?{qs ->^$I)|Yr!!_B†VS,8,VO+=yW9ØtfNsh;Q&B qrh++e$"<miHAw)FŸ51&vR/JV^Vq=@;FJ5 8*78-V>[[!>Sx|V%U)T mFxxN5e!.<\M|sHr0%.6 t[up@WW9iIpx(5|iޢD5xt[z%Xg.34DԺpzk .Q,^j qwQ%7"vG(XʡkmG";bu4cinNr>Ι}1(Q{@6#*j?6 `6}s/Y+F*^tg]*{qYcnj523caC N2c$GjchLZ5[yjknݧBr~H^Bv:1AT5YP\}xg*J!C2zU=;8$gTPʈ40ddQPN_Z2 }-%4\e ˰f[Z>)1J)]f3Jy Y螂u݆c?c[ǟqyW<'ٚU Vho O:_\`ՖcҡM_zE *v6f7[(֣Jܽ{PzOl=iۭYХByG_H s>Q`he4HSIL c2f N. rn7H] ']u閒G-dVptFJlŅGBǬP}DZFq[/FNl*EŨ)5*k!VO㞞S=:w/ QO#,[dtb?oW8իyG+~ޟH2\0^M\w;glvl'}\bĉ11AH ~lƈ`b5D2?S 68Tjj6JӒx;'3{~;M-(7z;)(k u* PQ`_5ngg90 J-U<4k뤕z }L9 Q{rvr#3P@n.rw.#Z(u_81.^lXH16 Tƕ; p4e\Z6l˖KKp&(pPG*z_dP'G(=Ag:}'[VFF.F}Fܝ'S➦R[TB !C&Vc! 3> pEK5]¸?Zj=F7Q̳^԰Z}c6m?ߢ!;2aYvVngIwe}-1X1_mM[cXG'oq7Q |^_ju3Q┡4nBN f#s OܓqO\O+ni} Yn6]HZ5]\cXؐhPXM`Dsc:=hn"~V)icCs"Di7קw<ûoL~rvǴ;{{?XBhX۹p+mP:nݮW6n}6?ҿ?ãt.~~A㆖Wvow[=x#\pJK۽ EeپNQ36[nCHCMNV'<-hf]ӫS BktoWO?.yKԺaFB{K3}US:#$q;*šXBmT]+RK%ߢQvF'eAڌm~!a㑪a=\<ȄN3am/P)'Avl/UpuxxJ3$327m{d[{{T/$`l;Nqkb(3Gni~ դWhm᫻^_[&z`qX e'NP}m@7goß{Q- 8~j<&&\;3.g8l%[I~3Uo9F].Qv'5~{[+ݘef90^Wz#D⣨7뤨]Z3q׭uA[8J!Q3(GkŠ.s-;q7wS}:rrE'~z2I]Q2:ݤ1 <+`A)g9lIf~c-ZM:^!.q)i !8P{,i͇e):Uytٙg.ݟ{z%i6f. #MSf2#=+)gZ.:7d2(QiA!EXhVVu$jbau#oGE>~.K?L0Ec7џ _k.Z뤸k1_i3.R&޳ma0ӑ&!䕝aBU>lP'ˬU>qΚwYycbZ.W11  sަ(lYRM(9I$Lw\jRTcCḒbS̐?P'2ki% Մ8HaUP v"4m&H*VA0Ֆ U}VE,!K,Ql*r%{ M4˲UUEdѦz[LT:X/P̐$+CpUT>35GUM=&d>W"-U ╂5ĬCծ!M1)R|_hxTMn}X -n!Kx30$ X'"nj M-Z$ .#}"-ީux@v#\M^G52& L2!fzÁW,ZcMp@Z]҃qKD,wY0_|B|W l;}g|svmI0p6|.t٢U BRH)*ֱ1JTBB`P֪T넴bЦ Nj5J-j'w6Y}{]W~nili{0U/=(]ސ%7_ӷ>ޕ!]xs'D (0*0Q-Mh~pZZ6 kdGt #:`FeVC3mb0 gRDސh*hvYg;%vvC2((E[!";fO Y1 k[,#<݋LoHWw,WMq푊@LБv'A4b~ pQ gki.zWZ"`l:vlKȅ=_͛uHƕb[]+\lv>5zjQ*E&~B{c͚VR5O&!&%=`jrHv{ab3`ߠPխH~NZv^Vʖ9Ͷ͆ GOn ">fAr, ,Yl(*4$D^{d⦝ /xz($Bb#  $Ͻ1 ;!OY꘏ B{+{0SG #H8k6d5GV uJ}?^clcoY(}߻oںݭKF&M{4ͼfB/]#UWgj1Pn`W @[raj5]̏L3J^%e3 fB w"! )j(V`0WQ0^ܛ le,@b, /ϦIgJaRP:~8ۗSzqwݑ4*d7$vэK2YjoƟJFzHN `;rf^H?8׸ָ8\].qa{3]'l$̲F3ײǵ#o9CrƺPiEytCPlʼq`0rݕM; E_?8yv:{I):\oh}^Ol|grcw>LN]V`q%hRL>Ng)4noF)+ 6^=s;# ,wD |5K)h,ӍY/&m*EH@38? j ȱlTx%22S@Hj`qg)V5: RD2:B/>A'52\Viձ澬<ǀUO% c؈1'*Bu={9( [lYPoDټNqwvP֝cl^TWS=`4-m9y  ?)ݏ5 ֈEi}/y <hN$S©՜\jR%9W'Ezf:tt聦K­ا1R 0gibL/݈b#QzU`|_qfˍY)IלXaU80 |/jms|vםs~|u*im XM2hi"eXK(acM]2?* iЦD7)ʐ?Hӈ)ۤ%ޝ}y}xǴ]%ZM"JO9 Z]hܝ'F>[PTaܝي2 "r@187f&Hg-4Cdž.wl]BMsZHzdУiKڑ3b0m$5F溛bLV/!?qhtxp߻G?Pv%X^j3Vz.7oHCxu~oG0v.lPT{Q»4xYLK=D{4=-^$}+t%ʆ C :Oi&]yVʜDJ!|22\ D:@-Bb"e!nD"c+Fmmz[F24WEq~ee{댾Y3g*"QrRf)ƔӸkMе4tW ½+j rF۱ךCboqT<%3sQ3D}}m|`<ZI טrYxc~hd`bTwȀ^-@^62xgfEmk6%+0~^f&XGxٜ2O(ϣ]׈k̼7( z vSSHDqK//ԸnɌD\텖Б(:KPD qqHh#](x>X(`xv %9(Sԕ#:.d-9Xy,$^3r$K`.XYMRpQ,$ @v1m?եD ^\ O2_P` 0AʼnseE} Й3 DHESX#ȊȀw cf&ZvP()° Sɠ6 O҉zɣk Vo{gsGqڼ;'['sYqxm%?owбwFwT4pOĈg-1/k"c fR27V;i{QVrO?}.mNPZw okxsWhե͝cN ?V_>o,g2U;Q ٯJ =}Hnؼl?v7R:&ETxNl4Jg)z?]܅_^CA¢ޒ!5^]mT~*~ZOCl"l&[duj+ʶp*R_c>pij,W/.0– }YX/Ա t6XCpWH]b8,6]ʭYP$ꆜƻH^?_@Xa)vCk߶9b%D}@ofA} F3םZAΫ|԰%qcXzvHvyGBp_2R"{"unB$PT=:SV"I7MJRKbJ6TD}( r n:9V򮤕Vɶd[Ƭ-eKSB\4ڒd`Ciʘ L[Cf%/e3}t/n&tByaѳ1V9+> 9s؍l7"> rjsI\Y0ׇOjE;9~퇝 @5 X_ l -6AW b)$rSA'(v.g:;eY2(宂#pدz̪ (]Y,{ug$(%%+e( x7Os]}7 ykC0 6\BiS>'¤텻)0bC?_ё߻3@=6֗"tE@O>jG%2R{^zUڐ75hW{ޮ=o/)@^*Ł :Ѱu(ʺsR*kԶh6{~H0-n/m\7&]k"d>YZ1FAY[5{VZJ{k`ge$ƾP?mrjFS2UʯʥrY |/m%L}\MMrg氹e>i40Xb#(oŒF%)J\&!HM!B I'dʙL4I%&Ď_L]!p<_I,JRgi&aRD{y w',f?Ȣv#A tX53t0Eq遏0ZR0Y+s+< U5'|W k"FNyzU黥mA@>dv׻N'w6vN0nBl҄bieff="u[q3=@9N𜦈zZveT?Mʐ+*T@x%^j#𲤺j @=Pw>OZW.Vm`t@[ ;B2L[ 4U?89Hl,y3GހV=]x #څ EkN[*.\7صek,$ـph Ԓ$pL"W7 WX !@KG1@ ɳ>'"!=eg![2 P@/j\%ϭ%B; eD$˾`pE}TcZj^&]u,֙gqņN=_zҎ;M ahV&B6G;J:ǟ.jE1j9#={r4&F熆~Rj376DXK> mfǟk)Ԍ[)*b|e8lh܇>ާH;tϨG-o yp_oZog=Y8 O6`CgL̀n9Ǡ?mY8a1nyc~1)n*E񦠪 JvEVP9A #RU”pK+<]ILF$5{hY:hY+KU$dTOBRa|6DvH .-=~:s xR߀,v6WFkw5jm:܇'cu71~A8N`ȅ $RB(E tB叴XN )]*ZM"UP mwisw;lZ. FY]qh KJih_K+hIuOԙMBlgŐɗq)Ӓ9=}fs) jj)IVd)wR$TjPJϛk.*U*e4ٯJ&/5 ""e@^~E/sOO:EX"{e14 To)҉]#,tē]i>[ tX! Oqr4fW>{Yu?o,9']l̢\x ;b;wkO+u77OǮC䃥M6⡆`߆_wo|<Prn Hy9 $fzd%P#%^Q̈́0u`.7rX sOu i>M)PM:hE㢃sY7zNr2.C 2!aG_h}De1-br>lkaԦ|X8c˚8U /[LuZ[?سD6zvxkN՗ڵ*PUTNгi/5g}KnqpHw˛bkG撦kS{Yb+I \o jC}55S c@=$N1bY6[L6ܶix9lΔ".aVe g)+}\Ή/df:%aCvu7jCvP:@m߀Ti&a7sL~@ZJ^njK")j2gqDwiEyaG;AߧlK,l$P.ܤ7$|旓jhwʀJՑ EG<ngX? >ɘգo1þ֖m..LZh"YsafgNI|OO1s gy] DŽRN Yu/zHV{-DPfX,oCeQVdxAl܏ɐOy'c=zۭsa7#|7+\!LJ51,l~~)t~.<@ vmmIsy̸7Iz{(0<^Yz>.6ȸ_D}ۻ~q,n7[E ,gba-ƙLpc~*!u=[cvǸ[i&zY6A#1O3E%Kʤ.dvm'9,>@8o>_"s k$KMJqr?t|p/\T{[0{i$}d?உd.^4*btJR8(4>X{zA%5 #uG}4GFOf0u|3lkqO?Qk5I2'9MJWrIJ6b,>0+Đ9qՐ'ydw[2ߴW p>[:H-ڌ3 -`O rPۇPxjϤJk3>^u ʸRAs"|oTϟ4dLx FйY4f>glZj_:X@. + 5qb]ZQfՅk<*(I-]V v}$7DCX{%ss:- ` aY3Dq:0Cz 6Z?Bsch :PͧJ>*j2V5|2t Ek|MMSϨR=NGMJg1 ԒF6SZ-j.H|Qmg2'Atl>JT7c1jGcgPj؄̫ǡ9F#fIu&k`މ" ѷ8G_yݜg,=<6~`\7>] ,~,k>Cb=<mۏ֞# X5K|Um  支eG|%0xf-10"­o«m§'Q Nռ&DZPTLTZpzJz pgHf4x-93%뚮"XUKw;պ܉yѫFKβG+۩|k0f60Jݧ9u(93 4W"/jǐ3|OS3 Esڇ\ў@|;Gh0onKc|,H) y0-O*\Uv]oIDc=\ޞ"H]ބoU|}u;杵M&FuADW;GfHd -xOK4Ϧ4!9LNS Zt"b2篸-藡\iˋb8RW*͏\۷3; В}zzRɝڞBs\ ŷI:֡+>&3|:Ϧ X+]@(9ҟאv>Х<.WyKe_F(V꠮uTTSxZ_OȟQ6;2ZCmFmWFY S @`fO D8˭d%ڈ=ARu8 ?(]{߯ @ wm.[͙։P>ꎗ9_]T;]L`.-&'ohzgMxLMkByܵd\ZճXh ޡuX5uuC_z9O\QmZn7kw?t'36== B|_]J؛ߵ~m.jvxNԷi6?ֺVx?KXh}h=>M+rJx#ec[]ZHkoh%PcpFoeܣ{8=_Rv1!FƫAMtz1H=*ijԣfX#HR %SRX55 Jow{/u=s眽f0{^Gn!{p30Nb\s4!]_~ {w|yowQl/w~6`CS[P$ {XN+]P*(Bۧ}b'x(Ү˜Ym떖Dyj ,W_ ~E$J _wӠ{󩈳 zV݉ ?A C{{$ꮩgyXl<ܶɢE‘AUy9T;h?`ͫp Q&|JF~Yڝ4\)JEUJL퇪/jE|Z5;TClS(oiZ9+7P㠭a64s. {;ebJQM?S*Lu!DEdWbZYVz&4NF_O40պ@v5:m; c@%Q2cSVOZhD?(q1͎IznO&qh;&|EZݓ9Ϣ<`hk)K; ,}/Bѷ8 p{Q mk=Aigyՙg>(S]%cFv"\"ORr/V_R?{PX_3ӡkːhN=?l2g螊xҸa T¹9l+So=:y y3*q?;=݃Yzii- /|/9#Z yhjy^sy&AMjdJɲW>==)<:zc7 ю~W#@,Sa2<Z}e!vZ5źFA\pWeIvIĜ\Fcz:?GG@-D¶A.wHLu֊.6{R[Q*%}9oeubJƨܹ<=1bj8WGCQ3ҷs c/]?gr<u,%vu$➛I#Cc4K;.#B]%/C66d)-;J#v>2={ʎ`P࿯{ƦM4ހ{6ÏƟeɤc&_vҘZd]z@u'x Quwc=G6g*_@M}S?G[y7Rؠc1绾??zg?tSs:Ʒ_.җ|ه/|C/mm7{M9շ4cgZ!w4وqW%v NA`^aj w3_UJB aRzh4䑲}E|Ip9j̵Ր h{Y1*'UDoÎoP/[zn5?[idw|Yq1AYr7<0o;M*Cz %8.%÷uv$7Ns+C3Nwj]ʈ39rRL4ZO@nhN]rPJR0D 1Z\D>yWZ/gab>:A?J{L^vȫB?L:us^lgF p! nj1dv3:{T讠6B93Si[4As&Mk [NhIsS4PN3:Va.S[]UKJsۋA:&QuPO ;J-u%> •U Շo~ {[&\uq6;gQW=wq:ctej㌁7R[$}J%).t"* RJ$H 6fС$*Sek-:C0*J+-$bR+8["S S6Zc;d~{}:93qƛF-7ҧG%Cͺ5c.6c85dOW2(? جZ-зn&xڕ_HF^6`VC h`8`p޾[ɻ=%|S~)xg7ߏ8P|B3k_S |`M!]h5eYÚߵޡaCq:zi7g36agT5Jg.CkUNUiG^Hܧ5ZolڽT&쎈ewoxLbxéˈUg O?W stmM{fb(CoqchNЫQ]>}bd ډvQLH2lph;CF?d^Po=y:jmejMI"N:(}ZR㰈M)x-Ĕ jq[GyЦLC]L%*ʠd|4ye|W~2_WOD,#H yO(^G=v~_z<3))ͥ構n\LKf1MKwM*J+sf7nd>tKi{j!w^ Sq4כ>gauYqצ,|:x7 %ħc bm/KM) 6vc4A gp4%|gџY ߒ.OxgC~Q?r)w_>Jg7/b\ĉrxA{ se9 0_&渉3M􀱃`Ƴ4LT ^gb~̘{aCOG:h%tX/R.F`7LqqM+/EbMj>^R7c=gJo¾q.Am<}RX}p~ܸ@e9faoJ~ _ ta瓘%$vVѯ(ɀ/ >v'y菉D#UD#/H4mWQޯ *HThBP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP(>Q F)2I4j+Rґ'G/҆_)[ԈGɓ=ʌrسC~ŕMȿqeh1}+{hĕ5gnqe\Y+4vec}vM%TDT Ku ]@ 5STB.YP- QSN!T蟠9Hno@rQPJØ75|ތ0q#3H~~Qz{/FJ)_Q11m;:]؇\Gʽ>\crR[ҀZ\b&ɒ ȝQ:9INP ˽*;CSt@ڮF,D_!"qRcBw-h[/w2.R܉Ab\orv%EťαD‘DsԱgEbH̗F…vy(dWW%vwbN̬rǜ&{Q {EHCEV?m>h=Z$v/|aĿ s#ua!3yq;t8]\ }!۝m"ԎGb~Imsp 9^{~T;8S J'brCB<ʊ\բF-kB|v" 8*;R{C 2?cMXamf$iDLbZB/!W/\ZBr]oO'`>C"/;p.N5vL;fA5"0Xg[eevy2ms_I:ONzNnM'$uj/ѽe֊ WT+`thuИd1%=QgL`q2QcK:Oٺ)96ZA&ks*@Goo;Fqgf}޽?9w/ޅ&xpӋ5\.T6 #RCE$8Dj#Q>PJ*8p$lkR~TUU?yoD(/{/J^2D}PC6Vgu^#˴cˋ>Dk,./c;>E8'N=`x-ix $bΘgBpGi}Ѣ>joE0Q!W.mE6BgJ"nZ!lEMA,};Ա +zNOc;nd>bwA~/'ri~R?R鷁rkr9)CӷzhI: q"8m՟! 2 /YO!񯝎Soa6Ҽv0h]A5{ `-x%ߜ2|S ߨ9|C*DQMas5Zߜi{ǖ/L0Q.SeّurR{QV(]J(a%0(~=$] G!!qa(AۆQ=wTfIw,rk;n;*MJWeIk 3O;s۴IFˤ}2d}ǧd{ŧ-82F7UuF# "V 7v`>O?'473I[+MLV7 ȾzL IN,"$Pǣ3P{KnX%\>P6??_Lٝ4;X5Kr쎀Sd:T4 _lbF1)b|x1aZKQUZ?D bDTc endstream endobj 14 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 1/Type/Page>> endobj 41 0 obj [43 0 R] endobj 42 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (98121413)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/98121413.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:38:12 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 742.5 Tm (Based on the member's August 1994 repair estimate, the Army set off $250\ for repairing the sofa; Resource Protection's)Tj 0 -1.375 TD (July 1994 repair estimate was for $100. The Army originally)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 24.578 0 Td (set off $255)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 368.2539 730.5 Tm (\(2\))Tj ET 0 0 0.933 RG 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 368.2539 729.75 cm 0 0 m 11.369 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 379.6226 726 Tm ( and $338 for the headboard and footboard)Tj -30.302 -1.125 Td (respectively; Resource Protection's 1994 repair estimate was $20 to repa\ ir the headboard and $30 to repair the)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (footboard.)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Both items cost $200 each at the time of purchase in October 1980. Using\ the Table of Adjusted Dollar)Tj T* (Value \(TADV\) as a check on its depreciated replacement value, the Army\ )Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 29.848 0 Td (revised its assessment of damages to $85 for)Tj -29.848 -1.125 Td (each item.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Resource Protection's repairer stated in its estimate that it would bend\ all four patio chairs back into proper shape for)Tj 0 -1.125 TD ($30. The Army found that the four cushioned patio chairs,)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 23.55 0 Td (which cost $480 in 1990, could have been replaced for $640)Tj -23.55 -1.125 Td (in 1992. It appears that the depreciated replacement price was $512, but\ it concluded that an equitable assessment of)Tj T* (damages was 50 percent of the depreciated replacement cost, or $256. The\ Army contends that the chairs were not)Tj T* (repairable by bending.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Resource Protection argues that the Military-Industry Memorandum of Unde\ rstanding for Loss and Damage Rules)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (\(MOU\), effective January 1, 1992, requires the application of the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 26.296 0 Td (repair estimate it provided. The Army notes that)Tj -26.296 -1.125 Td (Resource Protection offered its estimate about two years after delivery;\ therefore, it was not timely.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 21.906 -2.125 Td (Discussion)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -21.906 -2.125 Td (To establish a )Tj /TT2 1 Tf 5.804 0 Td (prima)Tj /TT0 1 Tf ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf (facie)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 4.583 0 Td ( case of liability for transit loss or damage, the service member, or th\ e military service that)Tj -10.387 -1.125 Td (succeeded to the member's claim through subrogation, must)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 24.202 0 Td (establish that he delivered the item to the carrier in good)Tj -24.202 -1.125 Td (condition, that it as not delivered or it was delivered in a damaged con\ dition, and the amount of damages. )Tj /TT2 1 Tf 42.433 0 Td (See)Tj /TT0 1 Tf ( )Tj /TT2 1 Tf (Missouri)Tj -42.433 -1.125 Td (Pacific Railroad Co. v. Elmore & Stahl)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 15.776 0 Td (, 377 U.S. 134, 138 \(1964\). The issue on all of the items is the prope\ r amount of)Tj -15.776 -1.125 Td (the damages.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (The MOU provides that the claims office will use a carrier's itemized es\ timate received more than 45 days after delivery)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (but prior to dispatch of the Demand on Carrier if the claim)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 23.66 0 Td (has not already been adjudicated; the estimate is the lowest)Tj -23.66 -1.125 Td (overall; and the repair firm selected by the carrier can and will perfor\ m adequately, based on the firm's reputation for)Tj T* (timely and satisfactory performance. The MOU also states that if the car\ rier's estimate is the lowest overall and is not)Tj T* (used, the claims office will advise the carrier in writing of the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 24.908 0 Td (reason. In other words, the claims office is not required to)Tj -24.908 -1.125 Td (use the estimate if it articulates in writing a reasonable basis for not\ doing so. Cartwright's July 1994 repair estimate was)Tj T* (presented more than 45 days after delivery but before the Demand on Carr\ ier; it is within the scope of the MOU. The)Tj T* (argument that Cartwright's estimate was untimely is frivolous.)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 25.148 0 Td (We note that the Army and the member failed to obtain)Tj -25.148 -1.125 Td (relevant estimates until August 1994 even though the goods were delivere\ d in 1992.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Cartwright's repair estimate indicates that the front frame board of the\ sofa was broken, but the estimate does not)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (mention the broken leg reported in the DD Form 1840R. Resource)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 26.828 0 Td (Protection contends that the member was confused)Tj -26.828 -1.125 Td (concerning whether the damage involved damage to the leg or damage to th\ e frame, but the member's claim \(see the List)Tj T* (of)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Property and Claims Analysis Chart, DD Form 1844\) and the DD Form 1840R\ clearly distinguished between damage)Tj T* (to a leg and damage to the frame. In its May 9, 1996, and)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 23.132 0 Td (arch 20, 1995, letters to Cartwright, the claims examiner for)Tj -23.132 -1.125 Td (the Army Claims Service noted that she did not accept Cartwright's estim\ ate for the sofa because there was damage to)Tj T* (the leg and damage to the frame and the estimator did not reflect the da\ mage to the leg in its estimate. In our view, the)Tj T* (examiner's statements met the MOU requirement that the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 23.118 0 Td (claims office must advise the carrier in writing of the reason)Tj -23.118 -1.125 Td (for not using the carrier's estimate. We affirm the application of the A\ rmy's repair estimate for this item.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (In its December 22, 1995, correspondence with Cartwright, the Army Claim\ s Service rejected use of the Cartwright)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (estimate of damages for the headboard and footboard because)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 24.962 0 Td (the estimate did not consider all of the damage claimed.)Tj -24.962 -1.125 Td (The damage claimed for Item 181 involved a "gouged left side of leg" des\ cribed as 7 inches long, and the damage to)Tj T* (Item)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 2.083 0 Td (184 involved a piece broken out of the left leg top decoration and a gou\ ge on the right side of the leg. Cartwright's)Tj -2.083 -1.125 Td (repairer noted scratches at the top left edge of Item 181 and a)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 24.739 0 Td (chipped post and gouge on right leg of Item 184. If)Tj -24.739 -1.125 Td ("scratch" is substituted for "gouge" on Item 181, and "chipped" for "bro\ ken" on Item 184, it is difficult for us to see)Tj T* (what damage)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 5.553 0 Td (Cartwright's repairer missed. Semantical difficulties are often experien\ ced in attempting to describe)Tj -5.553 -1.125 Td (damage, and it may be difficult to conclude that there is any realistic \ difference)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 31.959 0 Td (between a "gouge" and a "scratch.")Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 43 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[368.0 728.0 379.0 739.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 12 0 obj <> endobj 44 0 obj <> endobj 9 0 obj <> endobj 10 0 obj <> endobj 11 0 obj <> endobj 48 0 obj (file:///usr.osd.mil/Home/OSD/OGC/JosephLM/_MyComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Archived%20-%20HTML/98121413.html) endobj 47 0 obj <> endobj 49 0 obj <> endobj 45 0 obj [15 0 R/XYZ 0 125.0 null] endobj 46 0 obj [15 0 R/XYZ 0 86.0 null] endobj 4 0 obj <> endobj xref 0 50 0000000000 65535 f 0000000016 00000 n 0000000141 00000 n 0000003655 00000 n 0000138435 00000 n 0000003533 00000 n 0000003588 00000 n 0000003721 00000 n 0000003748 00000 n 0000137828 00000 n 0000137912 00000 n 0000137954 00000 n 0000137644 00000 n 0000004283 00000 n 0000129254 00000 n 0000095822 00000 n 0000003851 00000 n 0000003897 00000 n 0000003946 00000 n 0000004096 00000 n 0000004000 00000 n 0000004032 00000 n 0000004064 00000 n 0000004497 00000 n 0000004522 00000 n 0000010679 00000 n 0000010728 00000 n 0000010763 00000 n 0000011271 00000 n 0000095490 00000 n 0000042358 00000 n 0000042625 00000 n 0000011684 00000 n 0000011957 00000 n 0000012384 00000 n 0000043237 00000 n 0000096033 00000 n 0000101375 00000 n 0000101796 00000 n 0000102072 00000 n 0000102510 00000 n 0000129479 00000 n 0000129504 00000 n 0000137312 00000 n 0000137729 00000 n 0000138352 00000 n 0000138394 00000 n 0000138170 00000 n 0000137996 00000 n 0000138299 00000 n trailer <<1A937347FD675043B0E025C01B94D704>]>> startxref 138605 %%EOF