%PDF-1.6
%
1 0 obj
<>
endobj
2 0 obj
<>stream
2021-06-11T15:38:20-04:00
2021-06-11T15:38:20-04:00
2021-06-11T15:38:20-04:00
Adobe Acrobat 17.0
application/pdf
99081805
uuid:cfb5fdd1-e87f-41e0-8ea8-471d291626e5
uuid:0ca42a25-2ac9-46db-a680-e6789582dd2a
Acrobat Web Capture 15.0
endstream
endobj
5 0 obj
<>
endobj
6 0 obj
<>
endobj
3 0 obj
<>
endobj
7 0 obj
<>
endobj
8 0 obj
<>
endobj
15 0 obj
<>>>
endobj
16 0 obj
<>
endobj
17 0 obj
<>
endobj
19 0 obj
[18 0 R 18 0 R]
endobj
20 0 obj
[18 0 R 18 0 R]
endobj
18 0 obj
<><>]/P 16 0 R/Pg 13 0 R/S/Article>>
endobj
13 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 0/Type/Page>>
endobj
21 0 obj
[28 0 R]
endobj
22 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(99081805)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\
chived%20-%20HTML/99081805.html)Tj
49.712 0 Td
([6/11/2021 3:38:20 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
0.604 g
q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 734.2497 cm
0 0 m
0.75 -0.75 l
579 -0.75 l
579.749 0 l
h
f
Q
0.933 g
q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 733.5 cm
0 0 m
-0.75 -0.75 l
579 -0.75 l
578.25 0 l
h
f
Q
0.604 g
q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 732.7503 cm
0 0 m
0.75 0.75 l
0 1.499 l
h
f
Q
0.933 g
q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 733.5 cm
0 0 m
0.75 -0.75 l
0.75 0.75 l
h
f
Q
0.604 g
q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 599.2497 cm
0 0 m
0.75 -0.75 l
579 -0.75 l
579.749 0 l
h
f
Q
0.933 g
q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 598.5 cm
0 0 m
-0.75 -0.75 l
579 -0.75 l
578.25 0 l
h
f
Q
0.604 g
q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 597.7503 cm
0 0 m
0.75 0.75 l
0 1.499 l
h
f
Q
0.933 g
q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 598.5 cm
0 0 m
0.75 -0.75 l
0.75 0.75 l
h
f
Q
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 749.25 Tm
(DATE: October 5, 1999)Tj
0 -2.75 TD
(In Re:)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Resource Protection)Tj
T*
(on behalf of)Tj
T*
(Carlyle Brothers Forwarding, Inc.)Tj
T*
(Claimant)Tj
0 -2.75 TD
(\))Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Claims Case No. 99081805)Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
15.224 -2.125 Td
(CLAIMS APPEALS BOARD DECISION)Tj
-15.224 -2.125 Td
(DIGEST)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
T*
(When the Service obtains a repair estimate on a damaged item, it is not \
required to also document the depreciated)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(replacement cost. )Tj
7.247 0 Td
(The depreciated cost used in determining carrier liability in household \
goods cases is the replacement)Tj
-7.247 -1.125 Td
(cost of the lost or damaged item)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
13.08 0 Td
(at destination, not the purchase price.)Tj
14.912 0 Td
( The carrier cannot overcome a repair estimate for)Tj
-27.992 -1.125 Td
(purposes of a )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
(prima)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
( )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
(facie)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
10.165 0 Td
( case of liability)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
6.665 0 Td
(against it merely by arguing the depreciated purchase price is less than\
the)Tj
-16.829 -1.125 Td
(repair cost.)Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
0 -2.125 TD
(DECISION)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
T*
(Resource Protection, on behalf of Carlyle Brothers Forwarding, Inc. \(Ca\
rlyle\), appeals the July 19, 1999, Settlement of)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(the Defense)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Office of Hearings and Appeals \(DOHA\), under DOHA Claim No. 99060712, \
which denied, in part,)Tj
0 -1.375 TD
(Carlyle's request for a refund of)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
12.953 0 Td
(monies offset for damage to the household goods shipment of a service me\
mber.)Tj
0 0 0.933 rg
9.75 0 0 9.75 558.3379 348.75 Tm
(\(1\))Tj
ET
0 0 0.933 RG
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 558.3379 348 cm
0 0 m
11.369 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 569.7065 344.25 Tm
( The)Tj
-46.142 -1.125 Td
(only item of concern in this appeal is inventory)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
19.134 0 Td
(item number 197, a guitar.)Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
2.382 -2.125 Td
(Background)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
-21.517 -2.125 Td
(The record shows that the shipment was picked up on May 28, 1996, at Tam\
pa, Florida, and was delivered on July 5,)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(1996, to San)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Antonio, Texas. The List of Property and Claims Analysis Chart \(DD Form\
1844\) used by the claims)Tj
T*
(office listed the guitar as worth)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
12.718 0 Td
($450 when it was acquired as a gift in 1967, and the repair cost as $210\
. The service)Tj
-12.718 -1.125 Td
(obtained a repair estimate from a music studio)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
18.772 0 Td
(which estimated a cost of $210 for repairing the cracks in the guitar an\
d)Tj
-18.772 -1.125 Td
(for revarnishing it. The carrier's estimate from a furniture repair)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
25.752 0 Td
(firm merely acknowledges that the guitar was damaged.)Tj
-25.752 -1.125 Td
(The carrier originally denied liability for the guitar stating that the \
service had)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
31.461 0 Td
(not provided evidence to show that the)Tj
-31.461 -1.125 Td
(crack was caused by anything except atmospheric condition. The $210 repa\
ir cost was offset)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
37.293 0 Td
(against the carrier. Carlyle)Tj
-37.293 -1.125 Td
(argued that it was due a refund because the $450 purchase price less a m\
aximum deduction of 75 percent for)Tj
T*
(depreciation is less than the $210 repair cost. The Settlement Certifica\
te upheld the Army's offset of $210, stating that)Tj
T*
(the carrier had)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
6.024 0 Td
(not submitted evidence that the offset of the repair cost was unreasonab\
le.)Tj
-6.024 -2.125 Td
(On appeal, Resource Protection contends that the purchase price less 75 \
percent depreciation \(a total of $112.50\) is less)Tj
T*
(than the repair)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
6.025 0 Td
(cost \($210\) and therefore the Army should not have held Carlyle liable\
for the repair cost. Resource)Tj
-6.025 -1.125 Td
(Protection argues that a carrier's)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
13.091 0 Td
(liability never exceeds the depreciated value of an item under any circu\
mstances,)Tj
-13.091 -1.125 Td
(whether the item is repaired or not. Additionally,)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
19.828 0 Td
(Resource Protection contends that Carlyle is entitled to a further)Tj
-19.828 -1.125 Td
(reduction in liability by 25 percent of the depreciated value of the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
26.49 0 Td
(guitar because salvage was denied.)Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
-4.585 -2.125 Td
(Discussion)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
23 0 obj
<>
endobj
24 0 obj
(b>QHR)
endobj
25 0 obj
<>
endobj
26 0 obj
<>
endobj
27 0 obj
<>
endobj
33 0 obj
<>
endobj
34 0 obj
<>stream
H\j0~
CI5v!0r t1NzOJ3$#!;cY&a4
̲
0`@^;ͤ|ſZ/Lniv(B&9ag;^`-`!*W_UIspLeYJzik;LbڦsN|.d[1ɷB G)3R3i|ANSȊYOȻs|DιNNu9#ܜr62d^Wq}Ǽ#+Q{bGbĚ
)4{jS&>|4hGjn|q^c|:zG/1>+ Őv
endstream
endobj
35 0 obj
<>stream
H|XUsfTT,pp-.{LTc" [bDAP^b+
{Wzcj}do~ E,!_֨RzK H} UW%nBv=4ʳm}+P#{dx;ç|ˉbJIG2sas8zWfrCbJM@bo26K?І0UjA`1++nӥxV sJ
MA52
u{NERTEQYUs5ǐN2K|աYZfk59-q栬+/ /8
*o-IKq{ ,T7wYh^%J.]O*f?R*U}XFZԭWAF5mQ-[nv|Y|/o}~.]#uѳW>}c0A/G1c%&<1e)SM1sl̙;o~ꂅ/Yljoظi2ؙk8xǎSϜ=w/s@\@B;0\Y騬f<y\j
5TWՉ̷o/߽}]~#=KzQ7iݦ?ԟ~dse%2Ͳ̪Xݬŭ%孺5{[Q2
`T3AFo#ֈ3c`d;lq¸h
l20,0"0*W`j#2͒&-=͵2)9ݜeAf|kΤ*P,qC2/~!Q
WǩIjCol|?=}tNy!Tշsesy9Ŝ*9jPBr(g{!ڵo8b+q8,9\Sr>ieӬi i^)9Yl(94wr7ppݐO/x${>Ҫ"+I0Pn? s^ɓ:oj
p,n&HQQQQQQ#ajrggʲ+s.Mr\)/7Tz5s
k+ۭ
vo;l-],[-]ZlKlkmml-m-l6bU+ό2I=]&6"IX/$JH10 #C
<HE_Cc ~@`800?c8~A:`$Fn9
ph: p5ͤY4~ßȗϝ4hͥy4Riȃ<-ExRJeVJZEi
u6FYJ$DiV*JhePqTWqJ7mTxIEh7䃵XG