%PDF-1.6 % 1 0 obj <> endobj 2 0 obj <>stream 2021-06-11T15:35:49-04:00 2021-06-11T15:35:45-04:00 2021-06-11T15:35:49-04:00 Adobe Acrobat 17.0 application/pdf 00022210 uuid:4a594b94-4fc3-4dc3-8bee-d12136927f8b uuid:c7ffae2b-781f-4904-8944-51b2958dd800 Acrobat Web Capture 15.0 endstream endobj 5 0 obj <> endobj 6 0 obj <> endobj 3 0 obj <> endobj 7 0 obj <> endobj 8 0 obj <> endobj 17 0 obj <>>> endobj 18 0 obj <> endobj 19 0 obj <> endobj 21 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 22 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 23 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 24 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 20 0 obj <><><><><><>]/P 18 0 R/Pg 13 0 R/S/Article>> endobj 13 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 0/Type/Page>> endobj 25 0 obj [32 0 R] endobj 26 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (00022210)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/00022210.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:35:49 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 734.2497 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 579.749 0 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 733.5 cm 0 0 m -0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 578.25 0 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 732.7503 cm 0 0 m 0.75 0.75 l 0 1.499 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 733.5 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 0.75 0.75 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 593.2503 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.751 l 579 -0.751 l 579.749 0 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 592.4997 cm 0 0 m -0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 578.25 0 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 591.75 cm 0 0 m 0.75 0.75 l 0 1.5 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 592.4997 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 0.75 0.751 l h f Q /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 749.25 Tm (March 27, 2000)Tj 0 -3.25 TD (In Re:)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (National Claims Service, Inc.)Tj T* (on behalf of)Tj T* (Eagle Van Lines, Inc.)Tj T* (Claimant)Tj 0 -3.25 TD (Claims Case No. 00022210)Tj /Span<>> BDC 0 -2.125 TD ( )Tj EMC /TT1 1 Tf 15.224 -2.125 Td (CLAIMS APPEALS BOARD DECISION)Tj -15.224 -2.125 Td (DIGEST)Tj /TT0 1 Tf T* (Generally, an agency's determination concerning the amount of damages is\ a factual matter, and we will not disturb an)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (agency's findings in the absence of clear and convincing evidence that t\ he agency acted unreasonably. However, it was)Tj T* (erroneous for the agency to use a replacement estimate for a VCR with mo\ re features than the missing VCR without)Tj T* (explanation.)Tj /Span<>> BDC 0 -2.125 TD ( )Tj EMC /TT1 1 Tf T* (DECISION)Tj /TT0 1 Tf T* (The National Claims Service, Inc. \(NCS\), on behalf of Eagle Van Lines,\ Inc. \(Eagle\), requests a refund of $503.50 of)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (the $1,155 set off by the Army for transit loss and damage of a service \ member's household goods during a permanent)Tj 0 -1.375 TD (change of station transfer in 1995.)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 179.9512 324.75 Tm (\(1\))Tj ET 0 0 0.933 RG 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 179.9512 324 cm 0 0 m 11.369 0 l h S Q BT 0 g /Span<>> BDC 12 0 0 12 16 294.75 Tm ( )Tj EMC /TT1 1 Tf 21.517 -2.125 Td (Background)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -21.517 -2.125 Td (The record shows that Eagle's agent obtained the shipment at Fort Bennin\ g, Georgia, on July 27, 1995, and delivered it)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (to the member in Anchorage, Alaska, on October 24, 1995. One of the item\ s in the shipment was Descriptive Inventory)Tj T* (Items 111/112, which was described as a 3.1 cubic foot carton containing\ a "RCA VCR S/N303481174 M/N VR526 +)Tj T* (misc., carrier-packed." At delivery, the shipper and Eagle's agent noted\ that the VCR was missing. In the )Tj /TT2 1 Tf 42.188 0 Td (Notice of Loss)Tj -42.188 -1.125 Td (or Damage)Tj /TT0 1 Tf ( \(DD Form 1840R\) dispatched to Eagle on November 2, 1995, the member n\ oted that, among other things,)Tj T* (25 CDs and cassettes were also missing from Items 111/112. On the )Tj /TT2 1 Tf 27.523 0 Td (List of Property and Claims Analysis Chart)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 17.39 0 Td ( \(DD)Tj -44.914 -1.125 Td (Form 1844\), the member stated that he paid $450 for his RCA VR526 VCR w\ hen he purchased it in January 1995. He)Tj T* (also claimed that the replacement cost in November 1995 in Anchorage was\ $349.95. The replacement cost was based)Tj T* (on the cost of a new Toshiba M650 stereo High Fidelity VCR. In subrogati\ on to the member's claim, the Army also)Tj T* (claimed $269 for the depreciated replacement cost of the CDs, but this m\ atter is no longer in issue because, in its)Tj T* (administrative report, the Army allowed Eagle the entire $269. The only \ issue in this appeal is the amount of Eagle's)Tj T* (liability for the VCR.)Tj /Span<>> BDC 0 -2.125 TD ( )Tj EMC T* (NCS contends that there is no basis for a carrier liability of $350 on t\ he VCR and that the proper amount of Eagle's)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 27 0 obj <> endobj 28 0 obj (uf}8곔~ȱ) endobj 29 0 obj <> endobj 30 0 obj <> endobj 31 0 obj <> endobj 37 0 obj <> endobj 38 0 obj <>stream H\j0E -EqbK3-@E48("_]B ь8׌f h7[?}O96 ټ0m׌?os,OiMYU-mx1W˶,]80|´~zM>lڴߍW~)9en|g,= S=g۷ʶݾcV(ҒX^WiI|GKlYoQo r.%ؒ-ؑgZioɷ%y ]`[[[;fw!0 ^P/ ^zEEEEJ`RRRRRz*< OSTz*>stream H|TT}pv \bXK^c" EŚ(K,{W{A8v؟;O[o%g}: FhoTU.=^8GDZ\6@!qfͺ %M]R G.=G7:зmu|o@2_rp5p_~PטA@Wޑ"H D &%o:w7*vemʀ@QkskNERTEQYumAd<M3\sߪ9-v4e\{puנɧ.~\Qii%Sᩙ ,TOQ_bK,ULYl+_bO+WZzjש[~>kܤi-Z~/jݦmЯͷ᧟;GSd.]u3W>}0p!:t#G%36q 'L2u3g͞/H]hieWU׬]~Moݶ}]3ݷC=vS3q&.D)y$z(W1+x <i~) vj;5LW' =  ^L[mzg}I?cclcN65gX:ZFY,-ˬZZZZڪ[[+Z[Y#QJwŀ o(i5JFM#i F1j,4VNq8m\67n#wKTnjm+]]nnnn677Τ*P,ʏP C2/L~% P^PǩjCO9H xz+==0=^ߢ/WgK38s9Ur%̒`IGr(e x!9/8~b+>p8&9\]r%m%lV[mʪܾnw]ɡe9C-Y5D+nR*H%'mrΞm\KۉrUUUU2>|#pmٵE$iy'J88äWYhhqsvpTuwXe~?g];yo3ruоԾd-y1Nh4iJ'R9/穥os1 =TFĢ/?0 `X&#|q>'Gc>%@&,><_|/k|oMŷ{!Ώ1? x#yT48F8rI"&4J'ȧe2SQR6"JRvA9)/otCzO;ۜ4}$: qtN3Ns̙ tX> d@FdםS,戹, +!s9/!'r!7 s_+@ABaAQC#AF $J4ʠ,!t@yT@ETBeTAUTCu@MBmA]C4D#4F4E34G D+Fh耎肮 [0M't1]}t!]Xq^tQ]L8u9u֡tK^w;4w=kSQO@ ` PaQ1q0#BC$h&`"1 1S1 13٘٘,\`bx$HD1)XXXX+k[۰ݬ5; ]ו؃؇8x(zm]N8M8Q݉5h+D:l0&l1[60;.1T;N7Es5~sΰ3,;αsmp/?oAs6Gus4ms3wes\5X?9 ~'_/Kewr_kuzo[s9j>OPFw?OgUwGEqwfE<YPy Dv%4kELS1bx x7R,}qTŧLⴺyOΣ("ޫl>T4.iãf" ˱tDR0UB@\J4%B[ ܾFyQ8s6,8K+#Vs!8me:c͌0R/:U;Ȁ<#!;jI xM4z֪`N+i?f|?G|"]^z)n7(_9vcIGIbxu  3i3Nڪ16R0O4e,8&AWh3 u}pYQ/ge ̓?3`Z`l{(CѕxrM ;x kvvnɳ߷7MdJG> ؋hRn"I"EIF`xΒ5<~& Dt[O1xD=6"+ys1+śԛ^7>DFU u-ȡb#$-J^pW&1] ]@v)7b lb%;h&PܳH1?+H.RI ke'7ɉ!V+Sz]@@FPBK6j8`]%Pud/27-ym0kZ72MkOy+e rZd6vbІXG2#eIFiM"/ٗ A56Lf&;acudm^%lN WIpֺr F-G!>^!cYՂ*FjY IUS-g+5J- R(eՂ ծ,]kċOh~(\?iיOZ:ʣT/kYغ껧O]+M[_lͲk['wm6>߹JkՉ6/ R۞BHwie#4'\X[PD2!v+q؉hڭuN-4UScy8T@y sxd6:%L0\b4ֈ $Qh8T}aQar$?5v=8G 2)AZMlG*i5P @EM|}u4,FdQ_7Na{?`3}A!j4qEtdXi@,~Q$/x mp|2vJmvAֻx%,> r"y NR(e '%X@i.W6xj$$3&j n{w$KZV[v-ɫJe9$P0tJi:j $<:2JhR 3M;t0%SO垻){=]|w<,SKhvY'J9Bejvi[(HB]Gʈ|(#K"# Bv&5f}&{57l;:{,+魫ˀ k6v]S[se5Nwgms3*6+]Y5v*پr|1,IP$i(*{j'6Nu%Cﴺ\XT;.gtg:|fݪg|>[|6\;ŋY'U~I?b@gZA<{awiK&.jyYVF?!K}zjo/t޿n+{VAY$SmS'Llklow҇x +49YF]F^ (Otp-Yb;X8'FGffPU\\Q:Pst1|RSDq%d 5n3&C((+e^=d-S7Ym.&WFN#6Dd]'5X Cy;ou+ɲI+:|8񏓄0vU˸9kmR:D;SD Գe==@MD<,z SA%Ч-$J)Dxi'X~y aǡGXg5_}EkUCdOj߃OD uhZAȭk2E#7daG(PWFõEn*_yy2Y{\{<]otjEƮu'd=k5q?m?E)OJLI8. d3TF;x3I 'MTh%hPl.aRL"h_zoq"o1IIKȄHoB"DSHY8k^_d؅qBv_?q2w8?qeu6֛jZ<+U>S՗'(QG,x\5rGQEeh X: bb }Muw-w͞2:FLS(Tmj~8rea]{zm&4i~7zQx}6ax婥>yT6sԻFjvrL+ :l`1Bt^mRDC1X^d-(Z+q^ɑy6P0O7мFyvgQ z>~qs_Riɸ\F6ryKN$2EjLf{kr,-iıs9_~ۉ'$wܱΈJKa-p|n+C ucZQډю=Xm*_ڮӴN@Ҫ nҶ:QII|>[<ӑ*9) Z;PGmw\g wݏ>RMTx 0cySF> O:b1' p#oZt Nt 1aަhY&Z;i[-ÿ]]sˣ^ '΁Jv(_)ҍEzsCʒ-D{|/g#++#qq_>fHCEfS>_MKE)2SBPwSv!4Fчʇ⯆jYRYFᄣtg4aF@n\Lxm@g$ C00znÕГshEXrǴcs+jҰ֕> ȉ㋷XW;kv,.ٵ5ޤ~%H6mgΠwh~堽?9FNKr⠅b\b4x"qAB~[2[NP)'YH\zρ\{-@W Nܞzʻi^&0h;Dd _OG- TA߸+1`3ۋo=wv2'𽩂&E'Rhm=uVP.uS]neeg4WnmkE $ʴz&A#DVC%-\T5ԠGoԷ0?aƨdNPph)?=mn/vvp9T/Xv9l,ac4pXo?WDD5=LKp'd1eX,Q,Z,(4X |#?QSJb&&Jj[*Wh"&Nv@@űA/9g/qM񾟖 G+zrwET'qUn$ZIJtつQxRzWG2%|m\F"#V;,l>2Y`yD|&smcX~FNu4D\Qvȶs}3dLo))k>ū;^+NR+zWy_߭7V 4Nز)vE#Xo]yb#wS qVZz;},.,^1/6-0<ļJD!I%DIf %/3'BwOΖѵGgs:m=zȷ~G;?5__ }볧ܕ]}l؇=.E?*(lMies>3s|v|ى'RlB lmG ڌP$tN $ (&? m#uQH=ű{^ιy .]S.}vh Ehmv0*a9fwlvIPp‹=Ĭ(le|8ش[i'L%v*8dg66C$B92ZQa䃁3/58ڽۀSV#C' kmv>>l_uryr@IW,tVfxң ވQy2ȞH}>4XF쯕$ߚ?`ǔK)%TZM-6f}E9\ŖAV3NȀJ:ׂ5 O6z8L&$Z:C(, B(vD\<4OB^H(T%cK_8NV^F ʀ`^7ȶS20yY-#6v.{ștT/-!.bL|Q?` ʽsj+( 珗K[D[^owD ג u?(E\dޖEf<~.lmA)e5L gfm&~"/, F l^$؁iPYK#/Zgc9+SuSic>MsJJ+5Jۛ k\ EsqU.B!8yU15kM^ٛ)}R.&ڜ=Aa!=Usy/Nx ɷ!t:cNj030pVn^-TJmUӣ&sq"=)-9ܴ$Rd݅J&pk!oz" /ҩh38 >JxNe <Ɇbv9˽f?w!7}̑ i\Gmi1Ajm<ÅEO܂.:X;ʊf4(Pz"m axvqML?|NZnӪ$]߾{Zm]!)V:7? .%t:bǙ o7g}m  <OplJb2;ggka=E-\ fF٘fM<^qޗ&$:@$"IqFRĩR~@P Z!@:]Wb혏ͣ*(iw;:t on&W+ <•?\ :}0ve*1&8opp++^DD(H +}:D5oBFoZKNg&6[MB7u,g49xSd;ifbd:͂aBPwֿ|푑z$-_yhgu|gNoKׄ#gw{{OgӅ=ߝ*->vڕEw{WwWy~'z8A&c#}vR'%q:j8>a슟M]bkqFƟ}SBGڽ[Ңn Qv ."hgmΎ/ILּ uN^qѷJ~lćk8hOԀ͕ ]sZ%‹imB2Gnaرx[Zqe tl*T<~k8 ?o`>=wֽ/h'

S]Xt''- j<(Cݡ?:^T-[Gx*qJM䤆BLiÝ3Ohu%"MRd:ݔ5vB!tf n{;VPl fӤe9 ѡ|([HFM挪 ʄ> }'L7k@-a$hW[l1z J4E*doCr/@rCrQGd#nGA ğ\0wMly&[(39]ڛsY6JݑxWD mML Wh4%i@qJocG $Koo|:yMi؃Ζ$TehQ |ROK!!7MPxu8<(Yu&XhB{h#aNÂSL*aЗQ4<^)rb<\u;)RIJ\V|J$PRŤ'>62;EԢ ,2jcޚX[_+@E4PqƬuo]|÷W=^JB~6 XoŒ}s/CCe5B$[ŤZ*bV71IV;B<hwxF’3{U=KG<9Mkh:CNq%W-O P-ciسdHȊ8 JpBd{'nU'PRYkыqAE٫.rfzj~ؒ XBm+s^dǴ`qR\t8ĥ]nM\g?gWZe+[궖dY l,\|gl#M) hh4:`C6&C @ 3Rf2Ng2&i=+_j{|Ξ>$lu+3ޒuEZ=B ΄Z2E"VT2H+S1GD6h;{HGfܜ _ g!Ҕr7!͹ܫeL۷G])zYm_݄VIt\. = %x-A zx,lmbYa :X6\UW82qïW1F5~UׁςZ3Ɲ'_,X<)ZRV=n 'A0X֐>z6#ɠN(l5zQ慍[ixJd}-.Q%H)⪊;˵Za* 6Qę6J Z]]6FQ2;5L-V4%lfg~Qo;@iQ6bPE/RAJهOHz8 ń,,ZߛMxX(jFG5Zq{%OxPmN *FK kk[bv]n˳݆=rS[R/i~e*=^ʝ8yZZ3͛;~0ߏwߘޓڕî3imҁѡUn@ `?6ۍdB +pb %pdl5m]`|wueRD5[ț=GrgXI%S)"&ĵ8mYIHf%g]b{f{IHZ' w*(TN)NT-IwEPS<=TU l.4+mBekK)CV2uk@A5h]2:ӪIUӂJ*~i~sY~#M4I J}$"˫]>?k0OܙvYf?bn쬙h!Ҝt"A%Ͷ|] H͒òF*i09Q; ױ9(B<<;yI!iS%.͉@ 'OD\z cby- ( 7&&p3 ժ DR$2(X8{شލz yh/Emk;ï\p%D"=[78RJLo&dH3(gxo|Ŕ)8/ `l%lOĞOmd+0NO}XWQu >0zƙ!B6E.z)"{2zaXK!T ߠmk΍Qh΢ ,8myae;ϳoϸfqAʑ읤xmξ8wZřfYJgy̰ xDX:Dܨ,e;Jw/²X·"m*x.h cYJew/c5aZgdyl4,BZ\ϭ-K&۝cVVRVs3>,yF/:o.|AiV|wMcϲ `P| Z2 +pF1y0<>|-͕|ɑzAw]#'87p|1 +|!_TߘiKs 柆7ax:>"q83?mF5n)=׀|{ȉ#ôS|jgq?hMP*+:BxޗMSo3zAZT:ܷJMTDjOzC(r/tncT,OiƚC?<\2\XU6rϱmi DouâbEzꥶa;x\p5:~UEE_, !K|ݪԱs؇XX2zE=࿉Tw2R-?HBuxW5gD-ZVGo;Ļ4ŸHub1Q7ͧ8N}َƘj#%^!q]Ǭ=~Ġ=5x.A+4+ | ! tBSҵsG րE`_=uA4}]CIޜrGrג7N:%t]G=yD±UmO9%bkOBR}ȱRg'D(^]8[W"E}s!7QkQSAqJ.ju}*@[̡R憨4ZEST-URT}w_爚kyYs8OD an}u37Z n?'QOܭFkő3~z8[ܹ/;:.mC w~s>8V?M/g u=JtRɖy4 v;=u:m @$1n b~H9N33Y#יػz.\d#P7]Y iAC> @b9+1!(mg1cx;DaOS(]%&ZGe.e=A4_d0惔x֌" \#up%( F&ĝ.ĂYnBu1h+|p P Q3H@eNrleQbљzA!p(e@N}Y&zeG ,{~Mh][v}/ w`G[ na8/Џځ\,G֫4 {Ϲ/(FAc2X-֥2.c ,cBLB2BE"CV+8"ۺP,Ͻ彗4h֗ιgg}6*dS @x7ƌ{h dhput 那_!Ӂtpܾ;T.5|սps@2 s |.4?߷=r;7 a5g06 8퐯7O}=0%^ m4s@ZoxMd>[LO#T-j'u*B2*թ 䥫z ƧТP{Wxv+c )ݥPЍ7 jg{W0;MNE.H" ߲OJQ?| S_zGι yO\b@JuV'M a.4|EZ eKt{\ u.2؄E&^G=qQ>p4O=@RbBaȔG"z5oY!OϓpP. YK25x~^w;Myo5 s {9j$gX=59# dS5v<췃 '~JtItk n\5Ϝy83 ? h _eJ[E g{2 an-D/kI}];b ~8(u)<`i$M)b}S0?nM"q <ʤE^Q p9/t ^ӝ B1q?CPUns.cFvҷKp@=^ׇ ޾0Zgn2Ԉ*qWJO_J>-@@%#~[ޢ ,Rسamg%KKl ]8O(1/K#\%yo.l 6Hŷ QZ}'Vfx¥7 rПLkusT{iBu'^K${u;j*&mc'Q& %l `3 g=i>W;)| %Z=a˙և|=Oaϝ@Ϡݺ":0<Pp7.F?oQq@ 0YOy}7*X{31h|.p"95{:Gñ W/|3-dnu3}cPgIOg*6 iIde/c&}[}\,v+/yjmp .`yoM̺ ӽ<39Nm]gAo#bLy@ڇ@ݖï&i9X~eaqf105ݺ@ Hyog~qe{z'b|OOY^DJ]B1Ԏ>/wJLu6 5jԩ"bybJw\O8,ƈn9qq>odށ*zv7چJ7g0WEBՔ$bw7|.3USK`P o]Lc ;㳡YRZ |9K/Ӂ@rL" !EԄScuD;YmBL1h0;뮴Hw [-VhAȕSTš|DwrBsVg\a:shg}bR#?˝Rlqu"]Gu!-T{)9EsKp"9y-:fb?F: :}"`@K-@HkGaO~=jotmH}b֩v `u4JllĞ1>>.^}~2͜Yygo΅$. |@UqxOF7g*_F}f}Y)3O1VF?'t:gtVF q=rY0x/窪+cs[EMBBoh%D;m ($< :PV@e`17B``-+M!})g>k}Zz.r\t8Vysh#6Dl59El?x{GJe6=6W{V) ;ld/"#OdCsS }6܇9;Gf J890jzf 1;y:KFr#-TDڱ+9%hg1εECk·]kz^^WGu}|%;gݴǟĚ&=jWŮUd`ʴG`!y""X+e\^W#?G .MꓱI(vje/~7bmC?1O!8˯3:x/^rɿ!u%G x񘣮2LDkG7e.eyo=V#ndwt-gfh3@JBWYf؉un.F:mȽ-X: 7uD;'h怒vMЖGhhmaXć7h5pKƑdNj=*^3g-,Ĝr}O2%6VCi-C6Es9)cv$WC/-.:+hёmEεz 80 +n(m^H7ru-}\kA?Or[5I˨2ī29PWi_Ѕ5vnO`6פ9YF:j;B0.=\0V$k>sl-9k;k"7V#]9ۘ.0_AVP_[9ӐLRdZFHw@zm\'׽[uwK; ˣ5=m"^stj\e5b#{9Uת\w^aHݘvsPls.a:,<bt"*!.c+No-ߴ2ӧx=MOm[88BiIGug%x{j0ȇ1GL`.)Z8ke=lIޛQ rDkOhf }]N Wv瓿oly 4Ilã.i;ڈD74dr[:Ў}gu&ʡ9ws؆v| lkdTcbF_?~ íѕ  ]9H:dop0gW][ެgBaNNZwԽ|faLLP UO&!?L@@3@ac?Bo6.EjMёX*61L=H?@*-:GX4)JI!Ȥ1 b {"HJcg؝Y#kXZɢUĭL,q+M$3E"=a+:ѕ^3瞞 BB"ƭhzH>!/rE8W.ȶGH% O/9-1ԒTu}X'r}½zOZ&xig2>AaЋhN޺!J+V3jan,`ᘘMhLEh]l/0H)XnpCf8Pb}RR_^PKO9m5f+mF*{R&ͣqޞ̅NGg'mMF\;pȨrA{y26"\o7{6Lc2%eQ=YKxY_{Ȩ!_eV 24#O9uX5Z%m+ZX1^Zo;rx%_\l?MsU)9howM~Sk|&$U"o0|] {Dlʄ+FM\޽0f6 QػK)9ݾJfTHSMqJU|t]!)H%pE٠7Fn"rz5lBo&gצ-qMsz1ΚX;ٜHn?ym#MM Q ]iJp0Bl-⅗PLTQŸNÑ㚏nTEҐِ穐g0 yzB!gEʟvVr~W ;sMx&L{M^bz絅ᶽȇju` endstream endobj 35 0 obj <> endobj 36 0 obj <>stream H\j0E -EqXLMZⵥi?<ËlgsuK 5:F3hvd40C%ñf^ڮolOh m]S8ma0umw>stream H|y\TG5o^p rfQѬ,WtͮFvucԍJCE%Q4xވxx_x#*^x3mq?af{IϧkӹK&G>qih $/nh1E@+aBZbjLLPYl֗c>j$h% CXEI;**0&)b˟ E"5vxZ\^bS9sbĴC8$yǧiz'@P$)YS zyTDn|$hIhN5:0%];5BN=5ՙhW+-rGϿ!DxQm!kh5Ϝ/bPʬ{yUR#fuFW~)Q4͚DiV۴]vo1gW{׽z7q}%OI00m!6|Qߍ1v3qIL͞3}Ys̝7 -_t+-VY++(\_a[n۾c{ۏ%J9Zvqs/\+VՊkg@#E:Db 5FMwM.uIdiD:%=i;ˍ/y,?r]v2nCᠡ[vJ']|V6+%YŪjYUYJwend3Ƥ)"i)8eKˤr鹶6F@.ʓt\~0]>_U)Pbp!llX~XRS1*7z+cJrAT*N0sLM Nao81};brQ5o9 NrLD!%bLYm,808ZNmgUѯ8t]iN[3+穵xrr^G̀cq]hv?ml]cckVV,*VzFV -*VD٢m̶ٚٚ:`YY{;֛UR^6;d]a]omgmcmm&ky9D.I%JTH4#ĕZ[z_f|)C{"D.|!lL9[s="S ]dJO{{O⍤B߾#} }K^D+~7#~h{o_ܷY3W qVo)%qU]fP2drq?"YXXLc&gLL$ca ~A%b)JQoEqGqp'pPB$,pvLB2?R@ BcE:ba8FbFa46,Aƈz!vP.! I%8i.ͣUppBZDyi y7/-ex紜VJ*ZMkh-*TDh#m¯8O)6Jh;Q5A;ɟ::nP.*ASh7 X"E PK CTxE Df:LG(1:N'$S 9EtY:գqd)S\uj.[,>4dIʲ̲N^ç |/%W6| ɷ6Ï]Kt'P u8sslcHY&E@@{bc I4w&M'q2! H]`Aԭ,L&3@`C9qp4q,ѥ\M7ܒ:܊[sp>.\p9 ?զ\4e\kM|Nsǹs9NST9NS::SDA  <@  iᴄH$h ɐ1,6r   )ܖ>r@4ZB+h m-'=d=SO6Li [3!>SKOh gi0  4|75 s2M=s3TJSe 5H ҃ 3 i$44hMIH/ ߧW59^_үޤ[0|X a,%X+`%`5~+CyH3L4 E7GǼw6+| (Wm/(S;b)fbX,bM 6mbDg+/o!s̜4g8*N⼸$-Q.]< *A>);')G\Ǐ\jZxuED8Q['̗E,Ȯ}wY,KdoWcM3J˱r|Q*_oȷD,ȷ崘͐b3GΓ "D.*Zʵr$r+"&_}6: ˣ<.OɳTV!}Y)keJ+VV5P UTJW*Se&*W嫦H5W-E;ZUTGEuUU@S^~_ P 95L W#H5*ph{p 1j^VIv aq3, {>a%{{w=iOi{ƞy{ڋl{`': Nsѹ\z7:.nԕr.ˮq m625/12J"ZVGk<66b n&nMvST7Mw3L7v9nnS>ćc||,wtUg}{7w.FH.IDJB <4QjWV QB`̀T ܿ޻sgΛ:⎸+AN)Ԡ#AyNYPo&؄PȄ&\-UW: ^gj$Geulj Y*ApZHhMxX' j NC+Rj7a{a 6@t7 ޅpN޽!:cGttw?V: M W8XI֨-%zhw? ܺ a<}+ (w$0:FlwR清Y V@D{ڻA2; $Tflas D95`;\f.nlZ0$zNj_stlg}{ɏInW@ЎO{qB4-ooxDV g9И3LfFwq 2^(O^DxB,6yV8.&n& 8Y<WX}6fؒ3|*T]j;]+`(&܇Xw$LgB.BQ(Wy=<;==ϔU\~ p%X볧6ƞGKp%~_>,<Y-x(z1d=%ߑe'sG{\ǍvK e[mF ~ \P?r]{ir7B0Y&a_8SXD[+41თoP"'gJ`۩rcoe@Xg_ȽΫ6\0m,L ]rr2\y 7ߧ*lbi2ݾLƹm=n­\ < >@ĈƋ668}w{6뵏;cC ́G:&6zpEurKԨ.BKDUi +=@,JIE!(ITUH:g?ޞ{3ofGpGqg+ߥ#t+OV{8/bWh(G}Ϯc[دwq-\+V^?^soq7sS)oW|+5C>g^Ԏ/Cq$9}?ȉ9hAlY,ɷ27_=l`*v ^K{.4=_t^Ye/aٍv'QFc+l">Sѧ1r~3*Ѻ>_ރ1F$b}ށkٚfd!S#Fht.%[xJ5fq>#Sl)o!Y ^o[l%0A7{c^3y|Na8=F~LXJv8U8ѷ2@/g^ *Ư߱"3g>>SGqPtC9-0-?HmKpB%.xxLM(kBFTc_*i® ~.÷ԾQwk}wsOO:{i9 aRXcnFtc$w*{cCm"-p9Ef\ 6awqϒH郅tI=݅:{8!|#g$I _g5*4`0oPݵQܰC94p z9K U]א' c\1X9vkYw o;دp]rq"afM]J5Ս Ҋ5˪K/WUv-(.r {aj1&e(`TD͟XRr 9&")6_FS8_RA'KRK*DCQY.Gd1K;?"'Dm€ ",I8Az"FRbT Tجa9oBjCІ3ijD3̅hV"GOhLU4ݧutƣRIJT5{45GF35P#nw#b&8 Г }-qI'thozxQ8o.Qm>Q;˕15p.>Nl(67^T);w_)fu{ CSjatD]veIk*HYfv)o>:yfip.?3 C\6zɭ+%qT֣gi}m%RF׸*Aջ O|6z̦g`-Ж.ScLƵ:8?_>@ߦ5~I7CF2 qWVG)`ⳌY)g/MʼNցfCPd㰼VrJ*H EfAdݹO/aQh5٘,)VlB-o< ''iby-Y$WW֭"KD43^hNzV/7LL%|ޫokI͝0P9IDK?\Wlw绳;c'8& 0T%,&:~AXh:RBզF JITZ@vTJ7&]i@jِiSbj~}>!曚KUu\sS1fbAD thsek;>p}QJY8Z. vb^Om-&^GH]:h ۄXyK}['SuI+bpo>;GkuWn}|e =i1,9+Kf:Br!u䕃ukiiadFjlAKk"1_N꼭DւA-Keɣ׃+PsWHО Џ$>B%\37JY`Ha,tMs6kQ`&|cX"FPpJo4d $Q|adLf~EͲ Vx,-T@s@94Bm^QH_zo_N~w_kccLoL]AVN# K}8 c8-jle~Yk" IZcȹÿ+8ĸpR2/Z+!tN'nyW!QNjW/ `tu.Ѳ,bv54\MJ&%RWT@a.ڍL/: bC}].1vi Q4}+Mym4N[&1f|5vqF!Xy7^kssףz9UY؞AT~[]VՄcf;.s)(Æ jjW!UuټVaF܃3<zlc["/%5_ zjHghOٶҦUffZv*{s򫿬t~"'vUx* +o_4r f-Eɐ{E k'NuN] pXfvx6EMjdy(^L썏$X$ z]R^!_uKbW })ַQd_6"yp2,.u<4JXhmWjDʱU4oPzj l ;Mqv"y'"yNNP iݥ:teځ2TzΘ[ǼǫZ ʣVڊ\kLXHvE\Mia"# )I%'K EiA?ྖ"mn!e9' }&,;'ī'#qB ת,Uw`^,H"R(]ڙv}ak템~|/v NՇAedimA.;yDJ ~\ Ρuh79sA;BH+M:ż> nηbW,^)bDuoqZ^"5`r VdiQE5-Ȩ<גRpFX"Fc7ZdU7tazQTv30ΩC-q<.f1ц{c-} /s^g$~r`;d34:)kLf{p@nޕ"SfZfm6uvͨfJ_Hv-8ѯT{e {ޜ_W卦FuXk#q8W<&k{A\}_Z?]#ao(@KGbƺyg~v2Xf= N3w^]vZ^VC!o ʮ##lӑjUy!vuK=ɽf;))GHLZ%QbB"8G_)uvkqi^>fOt9Ht[* GDӡщQȎӁ(IԊ(YVDy.m1Obދ: <V\ޅW<1?`-ւ&k*)@l~ɠ-Д%SWOWCxroû{s;|u};%>;cBR@VG+ ֑m@c4ľѴi:FZ4An6YwWg[==nF_%gF1 ODcKJev~|۞ݠf6%h92"ݻ5-BrVr&^3pqkUP&+zjaX8"i;žFߓ ̄3sSɻݻ]+_FP#U?<*m+?\0jllpFORah .KNYve(Q_л[%z $9G[Ff&^_@ .$dh5YglD" *[M 9l.^v5s3e=n-L2p>m"m8Gޘ@m)Bp](挪V@7*V eY:ԖV[Zmi_ʁD(>ݮ F30v:toivlWGfGz"'ΦUd#3oj{nHi 5ARR, 0vo3XC0 W8n-OfXZDF]=E~{Ns'*!'z"K/`linjz7o[Uki%YN {z=ak[@޶RFpIF+\NJZUõЈn㤙5RHvW>QhuBC{#΂W𗛷fO⸬W=yK?juHxʆޕ㓜m~`Fub ;@DH(~BR29IGdj@nRC!$ TjX.!7$2y8ONG%Me%x |!ˡ |ș,Al)m4"UPiPnVr/lϴƍľwؼ|vt`,u!0n ,\,6tB϶'MM9\4u2~6{1nF?ǙA-\^ZGS'8mv玘DzrOVm ΁W\]Փr\BC3WZO2 M):%RbvF&m֥}UvLMmJi@ r]cIgi3rz'>FE@3VKѤA|yXTwG# y=$Y^AS^%y(RĘkb푅lH m`x*b2Z p'96` pyk{^has¬ˡ 2x{&g^jc` JTa,Zg:s m~OILOr%+|v5e+Yzpl|5:C->#M,2T5W~`@[f?LBSƏg5x,s* `' L @a w n >[JOi ޞ"HQ^i[=|}랣2g'=+cOwo9͑jƎڒDfA./[yljXV<$ḑPÀuI5xMn UF:׈&ql?Vy/;kCv* 7AB4'Jfa+\bHU 6^ƞdx>! }>KPsuNINPoЯHRW W^tMu59lTˢNHcw>\TȨ8f D ZC1U&R\rg:Z2]䪥͝k»WG}7ݾmul^F:hԁ׏|N]>\FU&&8CE5ͨ"{hEZh+}ǽ#vRдC@bA7o!iTt^g%;Qz PEuƶm]a^R^&y%iKHQJ2%'tۊر륱!I IkYvExmCf@:4ـe0$VÖ ͏QdS k\i;:<{0"bT؁cc/$Tͳ.~ +Aurjt*ML.giOb&K90iEY]!>8*Mp:X+# Ν):"TxO,wجoSjGȶJa3+HIp%.]ݾv3c{cRڸ/MHnsgo?Te[guu_87N_92 *`c!*:l`=8 >t F8R-1dnea cÐ'Fn@ fug2L,ʽޖ]Y$ʹf76g$I`27k7yv|٧mmORPTz7o 9vؕQ_{Jq&E1 sSQ߭mij7<wf{#N7#s3}֐֧pzSLK VuR5z'ZaVjef P,W<YaA`tKKD3Vdf{q$!;99=zPϪ褋F dXK/YpVCBG )H2,㴂 K&L٤MKdn | "3Z/Di\,x^C}Fh fT"JW9hɊYرX7DUӰ -N~Eu|݄ H lJna]쀋|2&csW7g3L V2/PLl_Ur7ߟ9xƞчTFۓQՋ m3<ё[ӻfga=Ec[Z̚8^8תf6ī3˟/w޼?无éAr4)/Q;Ӿn`Qcޠ]N'f3Je.Wx Q&M˯f5YMMR&+{TNj[).UQxe䃢h~vIL6F@uHQR|GDB s]2&FT;ɋRl V}ѰCsT sY;v'Jٹ|!;I(f6>9RXP]7<0YC 1!v<=bG60gLLӆk<)^%X> %[eS[ u,J,ۉ2|t`znrfU,(6w9gM|S:]RZsU}{b[dxc; hr|TiHMS*.qو&MQ9MTTDdmXB-q6z!T\>`ٌNf)bVl^DEp~;`Y{mFݴ i Н'; ON/o7r΄՗op܏~½,:ͽ. -0ig)HA\BRBpA`DMZXl\zָZ[$F:Hi5lSNAD\xhp<"uM`аj听ɩT*F*8L%>7bAx8Z'%Xi.˔Ay=,?)N쒀XQMKC˷2*G" ^É݋4?/#dBBNЉÒ$ L1I`hڒ>t+JF-F~TY*R^ػ0^Z6H!R=eg_SFP'Gu%8eۯcw]-"` ^qe뻳/g_8.g>;w{Eo-W+kGvR!_(hUh%lm *t4D%X&~󾾴]D^~<@3ðlgW`O.Blva*=[ؾ?`沥W{jf[~ϑ7kdhZ;OAm]Hq-9Y'R`4 ;v$$D(Ȉ"ÙC|L-B|˛'~d"1* aWr+qw=kG{qhC'r4wXKsR,HҢtEHx}p<:9qq};1WL Vi- ^~ E16F#I::*5uBePbj0^zIwMN|YZS4 F o00a8Kݦ6jYVk}XFp-w>{TݣszoMRZrV|eVkyڅG.yu/!ߝui% h@Ǭ]ksZ ZqCNE{+qp=,7jNJ&#LmU"UİY.">^f֨(ëUGĩ|墪6GY;(t82W4Û\d[d[tmX ۘm0tDx`̫Cϋf?ɒ_#܇H.Z qCv1̉Enm~}c'=!e$:ZvɗJj@o߱kb׏5Aؙ=7GFvQ0:̈́{`!ea?-¡Øzjc4oE`L_ %>E - P]]̋ Y!2ݲ ;Z$0(rSEBa6B _wArDB8) 2-c+eA{Cƀ)c1[ʘ-E(͝s; t[4I"lⶨmQۢKE@nwضu+-T%+djaYʪ8IhR';7E(xdu9@;20en)̔0S )̔L gat(-5!ߩs#[,$(9쾦ݒ񱽛N4 eAy?>1ȾO17]::SyOF6Fۭ8ؤŶE&hطOp/ 0?7{oX2h>3m&ђ!Ҹ`_akOKv\9m]W]He*HPu (/肦T;4Xtbd[fU&TڨojWQg,RݑMj㔜R *&JBF f|CVfY~VQ^k;Yv&>#̦NgYϓ:k FH(Χ~齇. k7&۹jWUH}o_~jrlBSlgnn B(a_QXCcDV`:&8/tg H`` 1lXDE?*A~q^ '*KW&*ӕpEjaI\y/^ fa%|*GI a'i$*YZ VZK+,}d9!E/[0gJJ]X*RPJ6.J4a |hjj ?,7i<.?azZ}Z}~<-Ĕ6$v]kouh>- $޶loNgBw 5Un{'_3~su/U(s+OGa=ܡᣘ6ST3"gqC̋ C|FAyQ#Y5-$:=М,RE-+bAdOh*Ay-KP0"VSֈ| {`Dx7Ȩ٘0I^ASTMy]b!+>Gcx,uy::4~V )ū$ q8X" A-rVm0c0D;ZH"0Dmp}mu8gD|yɮs17ߚML>KCbF  #]~~r>M#a1^l1]y"[ AU))$_Ϋ=i;6Gyر}$6!LCY.P !0҅ю+!bCtenvePZUB]m0`,-SY2MAݪ42i"V;NS?[w{ιIf8ÞVJnMSrL8H; 'siSZ dkef"JbX!bxH3SE-qc3JC.Bznv^E1-elgvSwgz6,g%148JWWW%U,_!#~fX/¯HN%N3ov.'(@g3+w#7L-Q\*I.@`h EtezF3̈dV%/;E9jEQ_stO(ǐ`>q!(^' %WZZRZ(/3K1ZtYXrRl ~BqT5(BBuIŐS9"~V]P?CbLR3:-Ie>0D4xOejA4MT/ KގvE?QrK]'kpdUkIahryFI3פ55ZZw,\g+|$ǸuO>NPNccY< I}PH %]6݊{k-+C,ܗ<%OiBAd[mp8x-#]`_DGA'F{ŒuR?KI IĒzi _ʿdQRϾ‚o?˥vՖm.ܔ8.'|fkTsݽ_5CvyJ#L&F,LjVr)褧 չQ(u.uu.u.uuu%.2~]ֹ/0w:߰|î g>MCafư!Ōs\k2d# Kᴏ(U׮9e"Qjk^Ie?_=x1Q_TA8d P*jHk@@֬>j\-+MzZMqnȈswv&p{MIn> ܲ𾦃h2OI/_řגE'p5sE.^ؒ4NiƳ\6#J r| 00 lma }PAŘ3Y|7;ֱm B~}= ۴nc؄s5a롷Ѷ)¬f}mq|S<?h~{=VRGK ԦCYcB=efpF:yw>vht wY^:"'IX39~Hù9fu|];C68G8ޗiȱD4#88c]bmίc@vAxh5>xMys*4׎e|.y rGvL㼛ryTO . |>k%M )J&d'CKaĺ;ʳ$ ڪ8_yo% "lN&"ۅΛ"yxcx1ߵsT]i664 QFw>ٗ캂q_U0DsZ z3c#br_UUW_s A>@2``Cq_QuꫭE#t(N im j)Z'( $7|^{Jf؜ܔW}qJuޗ95 c{jļ|b˕R  /8d<3{"e(>Iy2޹J8ߑ1^mVA6> O,}l|}H)_˘Is.2ό?i(V6mހi)-v6؆}5M}z 8;Y!k!w$VMlrU Dxւ7X!;_x*(eloٺ(tʣM|rU8C&Edw >vߤpo?Tm~'/[/nG6}<5.Ti|;]8+=2e9C$[enmwA^z\G\ MyqV.=P|vg܅Qs`) -ڃx>RH:ޣ޴ekcyзo2t8GlLˬ/iMn5;/tyB8+0z\Hԝ"'A$'x=1'+PFJx2|.x#H<J겵&'{6a.xK?hi!PF75x9Onis;G変'?@Y0 ڝxRHϗs?N;r qF|}k۷Dl!|7}}Xd@K)V-YenCGFWΪ_aK:yL]6D|3TgdڼY{SG[>q n퉭qxIJiַc?bjm1!e!(LQ̱7=3?qk׼={UD߹8cϥs1%#_@\INQք_ fgũ$j󥁸y7Vz]YRʹIJ5Q6SGWn"˟@c@^L !N(;izV';P;<-u$ѣXƼh@ 2}}Y/Eԍ22Zzij#gw*;e;LV̖J3wލ;[4^ٸjbbF&]7/kkۊM輶_Y)M!V2mk!/c;WBk|3uO\/YGɅ[q\gٹ8Gri!Mo5eup?\b ="d"(CFͿ[H?#eک*CKe{:9כdt^~Q U.f04SO WذQṮ{u1kaHmF.cRͽ5?ΓRW!GKw)|5G5K}J)џ0=HS6V~b`$#"Ük$?۶14`>WYޗee 㠯rY+#,ʓ|Rvjˎ\%qP^9ؑk8(/nǾ8(9;r8(؎3|F6 oc0o x;%xGPvi`J=a[L9cg_ <1P̥}OmkSnoi3WSc6y ڟ{ ?o)0˙:5/q 3>O0f ۼr-5B;h,J>WO$F,u;=N+F} #;i\/,L gn &|xc}]ϝK~iOiS[JAy28Y+Ccd=q#}XbGNJ-!:^:%)2{EY?(?s@S7K5mƲ?[s[d)6FG;?$%6K6ԏٯN20=x>[eh_ew11;tmP=ֿW;{wɨt']"Uo=Hdej.vXk1VR?8k"ys~~?7+m68uE;ԳdR/c,r7mB:>K1lbޗAPpx T{媖rcPK~B60HkKX>!aFzpL /hQʾ+m-H!OPˡg9?S.`! 5zq69~m=ko-M:By=2ByYzWUq9& 4D BWm%Q4t"VԪhARvH (vR5RZu,hj-ݓ^LG3˷wǷ~jm~D2I3K.::}N'&BÕ;}߆$;?O@r J .D3D(6*v!@Ia,H`:ԿB8b2GQ J<<·}?g]O{6=(loF _ga ib uQa-ŠږM}P#,lgk$99g 7?.Qur^{nǾGcQ-*Ď-r{/9$X}SƄ}s!w30\6||x >njF8]Lyo/K?H(oYn %bEG^ga0렟j{|V*dC?j"IƌuqIE6ftWKv%1({A?߭̄a+'t؅:~u au~#/)]yWG N4Z UϱzX]S7H%?CW_uo2CעĻ^'''A{E[A*gJZ~5+`*1no*썇](^9;(E+YXj؍/ 69Ywl݌lLM˿G3}95nɈntV[iH[9sVcޯz-{Fis;Ӂ?WۥN1i=uWK2xgERHnT~\f6qe0mxq,I=NSLmvOA7v[RhKm;㼷Wz)m?\iR%k-}}G31t訟:?{I ]R>GKEiSLJ6Wnjiz?h\׸U5p@cDf9^56.AlCƕ/?ğĝJΫ bGĊLL78 W5#l7z%^C&^ğ3Zycky78ę,0YHþ61m`-Hzgzei%Mx>mGеQv(ߖKĘI68$9-o."}1.-b5:۩ZNo&0<γyzo1O/Y[N~{M%VWvзxz8`=جۨ&ټF})gQKj_o ?ʤ=apK".wx+=. ]V7,V01|T[$,15I.PT3d vEJf/̳Pv@*#htoKttt~6USEl90Kp*|6{&cR`F8FN|68s@ :)+B@ n |^9J;1-%MJ72'?CJ5VЇҖ}dO^]6}iѪP_ol0ރcؿw?_lrsعl sMsgc;uh95c=#fZ@G.ƭ|ն%<5S>]5mԵk{+t/͌|#$ 賄[`fGS'S sŹ1_ip}nH-Qs DzG%P#5IcJtLo=wz F8*`Tt<8am2(ļŝ.ކܓsDJszz ROrΎJ^r -g l~M]$yგޡܩ鬮C%+)Y&ʘ -̈́M>*y}̏aih{rzr]nNKg |[n m~Mrlg9_kE.#vo,!=*,cAҜpQ=^,S›=*¾HdvMB`$|.yli2;E~!hm/OVbK4Km.&k;Fށ>_!Sjtuj>tKZ-n`](&ט؅2ɶVn F_/vwMEQ,4g+mnEO͕d?> dƏyGRE''S9]8?++Gr/ਮ:>v7 B$Bސ1B:tRf쮻dڎvA3U+`)QьU@ub+/l-YܻccǙg{s~Ɖ xjr|&^t脼^K?AO"!"FhpL?4}tudIsȝn`'Eez?scQHJ0eϰ^ Q~D| *絣 [Z= j=6n_1jnj'ӏLy?to'񄹗}v23VyYs#$IS4X_ ({on?'H/=xeh%9GQwh+d1hw|sx~.@{p<#{y׻voդ:۠ȳLg"O,2Ǖ 2,"S&jowP@1b|( "ShG:3Kg~o81]ܚ1~geZd}\;XP`O q :k/}1m"&<۽s}~,GO;v[̭gc =*2c=׹*@x;|Gk)_)0X92 h˴=M(~ Ydl"vTɘ5yS /_eLs-uAnﴌw")m|oGqkSdB|Fr86C;»-r8anO1_eMTr}WA5 )Ҽ7B54Se¿!7ߦg Y̝ͤ7#NR{w(sI3L^u"4๟i~SsCAgi/ؖu:ܺ\LVB=Џ~S- WXV"c.:Y<@N'|S%&MsI9s%=/2O |W//0blԞ~{uHN9*G}jc,X-Υ8[Y)O3ErynZ@X0wk%x@4};n_9z>3\˨\JXX"j+CuXޡ'~76ԷOg96ΦDŽ]~?ƳZ´y_?-4&)rS}}~/}柨Z6ݜ;0b~IGQ>we)Ơc?6z{"2+j_4~2z=;G^hro[;NO;F;$*{.} .^D~kR(Uѯ{ô10ko_Mh_Mέx+ORMkB^Wc~>+ ̝\G{iY˼7⭬mX/>óh"^8]SS9g_ˍ;̋= [tC̢WZGB3ԍ39z`9G c.> |>Bò4aA`[4֜R( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( B>j/a9N yXn[;y hRa9Ó=:=lP+{)teYcdbc+{rseOA׮R_+s>:샅jTaj(u6V%)".KKPeJ~Y-tl3ۧ9 ɚ9o`6FX.{r8-}}gAAq~K\Ǻ2*,4Jrg]8#ns,_85 =:"לOԅ( HM~bJ-9zE}mB VHjbyf?9'l]&۲A)4;L]K'Y"W!80[&.J6w-;(5YW@RXŀ\o͜}Vuբ߶ZcXj4n[uD<±h&:ÛSINډa;Ti4ؽ {j.Ѧ%0JYp W-护 DVC XZ C?"%H8XV26LR#m ECvJu4vY-Mˬm[` !+Z!;Lbr #Ǝ]A;ftEB]7QZ,dXBJ%!{0b}V\dK1O#: c>؀BBi\GD Z~ q/lt3]fjc8v_;@(61G aBvM6U I?t?gn$ne LCi]i &Jԕ$ck9YM<9=y{cc-x-ъ55JeK]1^2*BeDH `$Ljf L@ R~E0L)_͟ mKB8Q!Ï`h (^qAEgʽUkJ[ȥq!rrq!ryc݆:h20$볼{u)(U3Z/b;?!#4 I`p?%;U S^cmD(e t Zb -6mo+\;|Y_%,ines}2F~.Ht/#m/oz領},ux80+feȑa["{bMd\$cc(f1uC-T^?^G$0k5cLh4.-`U2ȯ20 @}ǿjGhVv@}{bD뭔%mjŸe ^,0q:q^J&?<5"NCE`0 {E^9dz9+6l}6(s:o!n_PO h6|2-v/&n6tۙ1]bzlK@^m*q7UI[6~qu PB: ۳"s[&0 8c<*^`J:lw8vU%=!u` X{ Vi-%`@Xp jZhH748>cĮ#Q-KTuAvڊ3J2T;Ψ6Ƿe ceLI0+M0 z11`jUn6D:I̜kO"., l/iK.OY<-ܫ88,vIׇV<"I PyÎx?|vDv;K{]iZj!m)?ooVG~'xSEH& {U&-Wma7h_rqy"n!@5v? x<05Ҙy6f3GcΘ Tr1˜֨Ykc|3j55p?դ?Skv\eP cbFʉ haw 2w!m2UR"`!zi&:`]2dL'*sC>۲H *9OM ad($H; |W]nrL!9L%!'d*U]˔ k Ge0prD&xC$th}F0̫2 Z ~ݴ@R:oB }&IGZy̫<&2tzэTn9_ܗdadLtLE/Ry@*P\NIJH,lHe~2, 4H :b#GΈ;iB&mR|7W71>yFz5 wSŕBL!MZ#~۱OTc˷_=mQxfdWI)nJV,=E q׻hA-Q帲QTkK\)**!fӂ/\#_ޛ5u+rތv㍚KCDY'q'Q}i=k 0~Q5?OQMm'S֚;SoѶ3hes,4Ď>4Am@#sWAR>>^U_b+o\7e~sޖߒ2ĕeZQ)eBiw63`sSq&p븄# XHT#HN+ge\ )ʣ&N-ztM>2)ui@җ=J6=C-'w%p8|yd߰ѶظiT\ӂǗpq9Jr=vu"sOhSڵhMښC4R h1h4FDFC$&H7#ReR;" y6K2B03+h*B]H )P_1c|YM](R8lu?8n]MuU~iA- :$yLn7qޮNn񽔕 s9p.eĵ7׭'|Nm[^tzE Ճs`U*΁[PZ-*KB)Թ 1V4wi-Ģg- )UJ#t̯ um18/LoZ~tj8X}aicŢX (X{3'EЄ]b^3S^g1UPT}ЇP_14b8txga62< _m̨ح7&Iw1@•A ~Kd0>h [2` endstream endobj 33 0 obj <> endobj 34 0 obj <>stream H\jP\>lJ <ƙ 1x^Y## n1߇KOc8]36)ҩ"4m=~|/|~y/rua\( M~mO:n Z&}9rix{b<'4Wu,Va_"uxXbg{^-he+َ~f?_/W+zޠ-~gg2sM[-FvDtF8 Ms9a4G㚽FA`A`A`A`A`d2pC  7l(PrCņJ¬4+J¬4+J¬4+J©t*J©)l  `0 `0 `0w3f>stream H|yTTGƿۯfd051&C jťFftbD%,*DHↈk "n(t-j;jG3iNa0GRܪV{;z ~ {4o:ӑ"b?.%6 ~(Y72d\RRbc$I,V,b'Gzm@P@岣o|*yh\Zr(VmSbG .MCbS$"=EipăF?S'no5{h?6eC^^$Pk\$jIhXFB3a#V3:Rtu:3n1{4Z? X=/QFE$%:_-ځA!uB֫ߠ̖p5/͚h٪[oy5vDN壿kG_=z^}q J2dh#Ҿ9j_}=n|LSN9#kfs˙`",YlyVYk]~F)oS-[m߱sW={?p#8VxS=w.^|*7oB!6!CƓ[ch6IaRwi.M2yO]n."' [ߡ?w ncqG%D1(nJ/%F|Sv(JbS*)4̔eZb:dzfkdng^gXo X[Kc˛.XKB&, ̬BըjUjS-5RMV'5SPm^uZȈ#"#G m,Y:ٚo-7&DNv:8#:8ݕqϫ>z^U s]Jϗ%\ 4fMoM.EKc )KZ%H/rK9F3YrF]>WK)Phpa`5V(uEOR+ Bya)єf6 N03gk8Y՜[_q2Nji^ $34k ZS[/7 rm(gGgggieʊW~q\ N;oG5SkKDP"7^.Jߓ6S8tVAvx9tvɡqǽu7ssWO֓Z>ZG.wwGߵ7[ v=9lll=lEC65ͶNpfzw$%YIP\q^!e'GHq(\-Ack#gY] 8XX;Uxj}olۼ˼>OjKß%c}} :wc~G_߂?ͫ s/V5HdBq{Cc)c50M@9x11H܋O *+(&|8d4ppgP(A> f.LEa0R!P C*cDFb`4b 8|@:Ƌz"1P' I%NTZHh1"&%rʥECV^jZCkJh=mG(6Jh;~eFi]T@ɏjK@)=Q0Bu(A:DPB>Bj@ @F:NE/~m!Ld& tN*t(Tq@.a/5715]ܣ |1.\'$|,\Vi]Z YhȞ YfY'e/[ |K2_|s7o-o>!?b?BW]2tu ݯ4W=ss.leP{/ D$Ƙ)*MzIc1H)Q)Kʲd|~xuN):Ut3uly_+|y^WU{5^W=G^\u.tNo)z =Szyz@/ "8r"RDK2F҃¹q:w{}ҩr)r꜇N)YSb  Ai `B 紀xHpZ:  @ BCF̾fǼ")qZCB.A>@!4"sr;>g,[\(ZB+(B;x > ?- S`*Lw`:~ 3`&wx!lHx "$L$I&$"ԗQ@i !4pA#}}[nn斩K.~Wm枹oJSeMMAFdA=K(MKg "Mez~N+5N7&́0"X K>,eVJXa *hҼ`ƛ E3&[dkiAkT)b.fw1O,r:V-b.v]3WwZߙosĜ08,SL\Wď⦨w܅{p@%TA|B>))Z\Ϗ:xDD8Q[/,Ų|ZvbRUv=eo_5s"C/ȉ|])d|[N 9+V<\9_.䒘D\#ɍr&w=/o k<,ˣ<#%Q"BޓUN6(beU#X%*Y TjTjU JSU[zJuPT*PuSUSRUWS5P R5T S5R= 5w#\?j&$s<{x/K\/+􊼖^qx!o7M^5ofy6,3:l4fi V/va$caJaa<, ۅOτŽasXv ag+dA{GQ{'I=eO3-l=o/؋lثZЄD?)s9ys܈ĺDQW..Ƶn6rCgjMȇ0|2U]K B$"",B¦#:"AA! QvE;IBvqe_Μ#_]h]-q[w)"2b ;A(x8cB(%IQ C'r(WiE(x\+@up:cgxPWF/KpԃD=EW$JJ4`Bi4=giepA#iu̐9Ra4ޣ 4&M)4t](f,+ͦie\G4BsS9T"ZLZJ2ẔM -]-iDkfXdOS{~)BH~SZA+)Va\ZCygs6F\EhXN[h+m7A;i/i|J5}THޢTD0t :ITBtN*r:K稂S%UQ5P-Q=}kw@ l|Hx]g5H2ʸMI|`bO^8Wc.Ypv;y`wvlءvn'i]ZvjGؑvG7Mu3miibfhC?5ײ0:IDc㔀?;%+`g$ 0ٰ`w`0 oC ]\˜НL嫁0[]jz&SKp҅B( z ΁Fl '҇}DA2Wq3nV=.TȄa>;#\y$p]ϫpN)da*,;T¹8 #f5x| ;*۰ꠞ}\uHgU3\g/M A0f6Spq55OԺ }0ߝ}/]*ì渞Ww9?C&U7d8|8 }% ~Gzar\*9Y*p}9~wREn ri"šYJ\myyK7l1N|=EPUpwPoA Ѽk=?&b+5G8?E|YvX:GY4wW}l3{g GRc9qp&'ݵ 0IE>"bvj! ZEJΙF=ҨQPhHUiU"&RlgvVgv}̛޼ǡ\6^a o㭨~A0?:O1eN+\Vr5֨nPKj^w?#?>- [}BK6O}_]T(xWyVή2GPtWR3e?!W)}4B.{ 'j)kbKoJ"%T=}DįP?בrB1^szà&S]}N8k\dG5.bc/- oS:Gb[x nKYl #e,)#⥬Y߯ՌK\'V@w&- _7VRY鱵aI%Jvm|jӴ@ =fXa3-!W^E`߂obӣLeIx&wv:N]mHov=֯NQH3)4guf;o4=Iw6E߃(KCŷku|xgۍt(*Ϩ/C:Ur+TX+=Dstϭ<릔APר=.d=K/5 -^}|]Few+_A.eL2]_)C-GU(&v"Ld|_fb5!~Esz=)D[gmCmC@eԝc;"G0f2d(⡯ " "!Ttq>ߣQid9"7L Dpoyb^K=~G]]G|  Ѿmk|C}kc֮w{V~qEeKTB_+X9l;f1df"OS(4R.lV6@'!l#tcӧroש2;n+;OϏRf=)5[y=]Z ʤD&лuHbZ]KNZX Dc@HN |@Z8`Χ7ne*&=J-)(}˥QXs\ qi+V@dZ҄mVmle^l6=!UH$!Cdb&wS<}t3$^+R`IL@cRcoð7LwZ8b3 YP+|VV"Sv,r;"ӬۖnXX CՅV[o4 _&a,"c{ iB^li6SPq G0NW _&71ҽ2 QHo쪁m~߳؎;γ_NBBPJ 4M(TK6a+ӊtP( Nc?ڴU4Ul%{iO{߽ޫ}ͳAyp6KmXv֜GK^PfFL0UyiУHS~㨽m3plds9Bt9X/#e*bK\G4W'Idd5=\% } ċMLgWQt~D<Cf"0 Xcn$B>B#uX'P?YuQurHND@X=V?:K*nq,c~˶k%KIIHY@QnS0P7H~Ow_yLgrs3](;ל&?y{Ȣɲl};kd(O'%c BI;ho,fphrreOk^UCE&?|$֤(gT|ToO̫oGctS}[[k8wV;'5LgγJ/?M,/Anta$)ʟsQ>TES˸>D…ȂOZ9_1YUUiƗAN\(ť*>8Q2J'qX|*R f~?50"r r:r3vhx@3?](4D(85Sk1_BMlA8L(fPhDJH ]w<=J8Y0bh`"^\c UTFC2qoe]`YQ+ES(rU9pޝʃ N̕~:)f٤o(F=p8L*): !bX1F,uә4|ORQ6x }M?Ž[ai#b'i xw,Ej̾_CCTt㏸m[9{\TM>J RE% #$2Yt%f_j/Ÿ#%$Ah/ŨJKҞŨ)P%nj 8ejX |Db^6T>,e]tC3AP6ņ/4hh~DXD|^%I 6kfNG NJxڋV/Fŋ@ Uѕ^6Vn-Mxq6"SE_Qjy0{>X B@Be?F(Sy#EҔMpM d2mp5vaUA 5ig``H&2P'"]ć탛Fnmb:i~: ppIBe?ϳ(p.x@)_ E +r?kfr}nyA=]#%64eS8d+!UVLgUvm.$Ui{Q&3߽JZaI+Ye ?,L@&e).Fd mF!dNhB& t6a~22ɤ<@SORwCWWssA:rKjm5;o?y8ed\Ԓ\.à|Z&n(Q&aNydbxZjꖖZ]cSчd!*θ w5X( aźboZA,"%9f;mFGSs^a;m~Fhdap|)ߋ‡7yӸRsvFaA(dO΁jy0Jv$$,d.TOAIڙsbzJ%D$@R("T%Մ+҃:MN.])q ;9݉Sa?**vEN&椛= %[)<,`'Hɬ< $o_qGG~˻tXumicMc7[-ϟW/~w7cSxȶZ[(z1 Lg}o:BxBVƽɑl8=w>?_NM\pT&e@1 I=as Wc~)%‰E߽o~$$:g'FO?OOwK!Wc0TT*dᢳERL@-e~fvvQׯ ~9:UpESgq/XXQ^"z@FCt\є/8`H!`XwBu" >^A%˖/u҅ic!=0K뭾v_/}9, se/=ԭo'$C%r\#&'ZhIBT[Gt?? %L f6g6t|mA^Mx7ڐKW9(Z,F4l&7==Hnsf=aƎRa&E̹ c[6 &#VĽٳfi,ī ˡ_oT>~"?2 Q=jr7KK]+J2/R]ĥEwVXztJ,p/s`HYȧPQ*h`p4jU֤9X<)es2ZC6c7PZU_EUeH^m2@|a9dSH wywG|z鴹d 6$}͓m5TĒNK̸Yj&L^ɤmꄘ;ӅSk;X2_* dL}\E@^G{Zs ќtgGS&ۀM9u;Hݘ;tΪA^05^[caŕ?{h|vWǑn~k]9~xfOϊv͢XOѲ;{Z2'jAY@[X*TpC,] ǻ^t+"+9pP^DAG9s Qt/2ԣ6Z.YV) ӔܵBlWtq%|M&&(nM!͍56i؂ʶaKEFݼ(b=SQxv["#u<6+P1A>peR}0KOw?OޝjgjD5LXic7߽#om;vVójVjmwߝ{>IΎ8K@*(TJFHUBwZ duSKnJ7T-/aR`iNe-H5iVses.{1p󘢗ٗkF*'p˻_=!DuԽㄎ]|*tr7 ` qN;_sQ bMz=2bH(#lCnDklH1@jV8}8QK&B2j'ИL3i 6~r;l:~&@\VW8k/ E# Wl%QXU1҈P#*0=pf:aYэsጛy0#"H&i>Ra-La_|@C{;W\t ,~2}պdqj:"k- __fp`?1nU 7kG:u/11+ul{S&\ R? `FʓMS$ iuI 0nah~{τM3}H3Ռ(R:ħ[|kj{:'P=.Iޠ܈R[6mZͻ6[k}f؞1pMB!>AnG@U.@@@7v֘ϋ3*YCVҚ X6FX_l,FŰƝa70ztyS7צ(M:f\G6+b-戤# nDQ ,B&e* Օ7(9柧3 #<"^!f.t++4oX3Nα~rͻ/o}O޹@5m+k+\g?93}ݚi{8۹r]}G~׺"^xЅP =9! *b < U [5> z$fYM|%eIiZM4m_ZpE0Jj?˜W5pߞ9sg!3 +[*/gqȕjPV&0\#JT-l _yX1 yppwn*Mk3ՏJP+2Gį~_KZ"ojN_OrM C1mJJk''<1QDdK%ՀCu,Ֆ{#WeuSl<`ň_ jA#϶/Vv|=O<{Q8T+YtDṈ&ᜍI=aŋbOqdױu-HdD6k#.q4n?]վkYt* ^jicPS֘DzAb Ppӆ 鬁)[X e .c'w'XNj^E.)6S^i JㆍKAP܆ ^(4y^ۿZP`R{=s#|qmxe7gƬ^]VY_ 8 _}l\y_gվ)TqOXU((!Mʨ@@@d 4XrF%{$~V;f zؼO|dH'ڇ"8b^-ᾇIaT߸()&bO7M ĞTl {Rijߐq/s(hGӂQ<ѷޯ_ᯣ}Q{GSg}s7]a-G 1\k'A1 'zu [:T͟(8C7ucܸcd1$tY4Q?CinR(ShZfE.ʋ4R!,ꘙZVF_1c1v4s8[F9xcnzwmV3ܚ?-GqHuEF^Oa\@Dj5r#7N$cՁ遏g@N~R :7ΙN{V5ldY4#<_&L ^M͹DsDĎ5jtG5Wִj2V~p4:#2S77[ n(hƒ"-Ivcf7׍jxnK.AS2_ x(`EVd`m#)ՐTo9]昃Uyv@Ϙ}z9攦Jɢ$Xߤ"L҅$IE53d+Rj2x60Cz*#eU*t>]Jm,+sCoj&4 # )Fa$v$v0 ݠ2pectk,@5x`8Y.fVt൫)NICH"h֟c8d0L_,E7 L`,^۲4n]GeKp|̙d\n5lO=_/t}/mL~y0;Q)Vl˳tW lW?_眓c;b_&qK,.lm6Z(iI',Rk"*ؐtiye $* f] QI߻w_V'Z(a͛C4>zB:>' 2\G]ooO[^,-niB*Kj~ʁ:z [ &\3rJwW?Fr=~rS]A9W^WN&{j"ağX'm6r z20!BӺƍmOۏ+Qur4M5/rD0020ڑf"E=$n򊸴;lj WRB;xrbա!KLÒo])rD EnWAES5N5VȲlScܫXsr9I{[[$":ᨦkٴ2 !.:Z簱 =oJ)89R\^Cǥ. @ '70iZdzs'ie+—J#2I@T{@ tlaʫpQaM@~~oUBbw ?:z|cBpOAo3zReEeS͖ΰ:LTMRd1"ԘKaBy)jXsL"ϭX<_o|y9.,VFF괺r:VJhYA-LNNtg>(c$kAתE^KlM[Pa?CgЏw D yV' |FcP0D22x6XхR"á&Uxe Ȓ5 ø!~ :xtW%RۮX+MBḴT,|̱ ; Hv9eW&O s@L1?qX0bxcR 5a] hi}h.j3 wk]y/ anf { wþ|D$B~΋ vsA3 r<..FwaN 6b~ Π,n[q4yZQgEg-p]:$9s9<my\p|_r7 |y}#sA>ʞ4/٨jƫ5ԣz:R0,K6ߐ=IBŬS6IVL ]6]jEnQB\Z,˒I5ct=!MGL~nF@ =FuPGۃt„pY BnۃYҒw6)B65I|kA3i+bkl2ݦgC=2xY2g2j`(kkC̖Wq(#JubTL5]RJAB `_ О$zeR=uZU495tdrmmRj3/=Eg4Е-.^LQ༳B+laVg /j:pvB,. NJ^.9e[8)v,-DN!P3EF"F,&Nou~k\Z3iE ֬o<=$% ˕wcMZ92Z7Ň[B1=W`n~eسQ۳DEQlj'Ar,z:+Q7+fN?Hi":7ʾ^ͩȢ*Q#qOH"1iIff!ƳT,dDsNF4:ZT5qyKӮ$Ҭ0YAu )ۗg9 ֺfCܺ0pּ唺oGȞQѝܣ^|оr"){hl5>R?݅>_lw>=DZ}q 'Pb2U lъMB dSuk $ !iX;QmjTDaiV4K~O:םـ*WRG X8Up AqjMgYoxy,ʮR{[}:Y eϩ+pMUZX\b-U9PW-ER(IPRPUuQ[o ֫huS~}W'rSURBiŖA$V)dT6UZX˖(hCAo3LKҮFnT}VmU%}>e%L6l& *c_)93t };]tAaL}$* J@$.INbtQвA*Jr jAU .9Hwƪj@rϋ+9LJbIN&W#=H1cr*)D^ .sm\ʦHv,W>gG#m޸-X5@"v뢍]Nݹ1tf.\PC2{p3u^3 e&AADDܔ,=90QKQE_Ed,$qޓ.Ҝq1z̥}I%/%!KIsGx Ù0IQ,5I,5\/U<3׼>DAO1#E9Xdjj P`pF uFbONBN5[h܋?6 ?@s*ԗ>)g̗wdh%@óƦ1_8s,9 X򐯯@"yDeרKDPuXD(0w-bUәiwue" "GHl\Gf6' q(f0IN?; Em6o?jg5K`3?xbDǬՅA.aI\g 1 8Z(!;ŠvkٶwwLuH}tArqYhؼ?^wԸH5 nvkdO)62]v" TKRUyiU)@B%!_iQH5]βKJ||7Ǟ#S",h=>>MϤke?MEckz>ՁNVBp%Rm( JmC2fB㙌17eǬijrW;tr*TO .n]שiL1)/BPx,?P$Yr±>"kؤD gGOAO;&-9Ulܜőlߏ2'nFgpF7}$Y`:nn[pc1\XϷWe ̕EtM59l.|9y t-?U#urK'utkղϻ3/9~7Uz]= j{EVi T8VMaH\ ePyBp(K4=HnX 8ꎧ@&nVMH,.f'zPGc<_-#i tu;T,&xgz=>]9?g>Niz42?5@&0W)qPӧϑȞmXz[q:_ʿL zžJ|ZWl4>dhϚirc.d_'8qRsx+) u W;NڮI;F<þ%L 3;B-p]kǾz[Cr 9^F$_2>`VRqݢ{~n&o.|0C.-p{?>ٱG[c?R*lmP64*}!L0? `7Yj' W_~t|.=3z*eׅ.Lb՞w:0]ݩVӧ'Hv>ȼ~JǸ-O_͟;_|s#+a$H ˥ |rGZ2Ӫ =*c03Lake031 S.Q߿m,|ckTFjItZ>]ZZUY)o46 Sq.( om77޴^tw\xN)J U Ro^Œb U,)1]U*cθ[?3yN#Pb(bV 2[y<0ebJOx/E&2fM\w|>'; !,N J-$Q74j44N %[5GE@: B4wBY#eԱihbJ)h;͒{{VTqx4(؞HU a2oiu2Lt j́ C\ZWqX49y2:Fw6Mv ?ܓo|9U;kV7NԆ?;yp4Qȥ6 ;./X^"YE?ώ+-i`*oCH Bxˈ,]޴ y}$mH'D~H/oCCŸR#<98bE@$9?.CqHQbQ@G{+aIG9q Cسz+n~5ĺ]+y<.BFT~0??m-(`~>}.0i]Fsvf~h碿~f[ʎ-+t>\ rWrM Jp A:)9 c<, D x¡Yljcr`-$HQyYIhڪXut˅l]-]^ͫOhЩu_dj#p]ׯov-?ʦ 52Tkb/ۍQW*;# ^*Du#*#4u,g4jA^x\=y+C"$v^\04{U w72V l---ȞH \yF 8sK ׄ5z;9Kߤ[mVAY0N#;!{16 +ŰHy-z,f00ʚi˜x¦kX.o< }ѿQ^,)gqqr@}>C;?wQݸ&\d?91DVy#-p[7/|:#M˓߸y+1Jⳛ6DuK5.N}{}G}7|@ AZ^{N3~$@w%&rj)mvH^oA҄5JJi v"MJ(t2iw#sġ:t\ ґ̬x&(_6/0,@bCI `(m: ABE4mJ$zc8>|N;αcrĎ}B|$!c!Dij* ic1u[Dl>RCM%J6EH햁a:QZ hy_'y{|wC&S,֜3|=4X<:%K_9k#6a݂/ zh28em:vDf*S"k3WҔUR40^,: #'ѳh!?y߯]q"d6m+yusEX$gF:(MJ5|f`Z ~ vq9pĶ; d3y<Q^r$U_r2^X[ kZq" )YCR)D`'.H#g."4l$ƟnZ(.>WWiFxݾ3:3jN<-Z/ ˚U`&Z&TSWmd4gASP(^HH$"ñQEߛӐV5/>@N(w8P{wuBGR7<93oG85&e;c~@34[s`ZEw7t_/6݅ 1?/S4|7LH!. ۇ:>A8!:i$:K.&餄~FåЫ+$U]ܱV ƚZ/3d1ۨ3}Дe@MSRAX+W) x>LVܖ&Wk UQ))AtRp$SOM^ YJG*ʤhfgt8ڦDWF(=0Ջ ajF_ ~i  6ua;'U 5L}aswm$]޾EKV:T:CQ]p 8Ip¹캡LABNphCs(!4b+U{W|"M,IFau̓`Ot5E 7,df `A% * ԒN m ]L,gG0G}zתf,CNnod`w;Ə̠MىGȞw=uF̅}Ű0Vo#oavO^sE.1̚i~z̑;ZRLgOx|rpcJ2sjw1ꁹltn^ MRFzC@'hw/$3:Uj"uSQi $PD]vh;7Z}Ұ4.j890TȴF%j_[K_{r`Ǔܠ`kR:lKb̓`5NhKcPbAF 62&13MrwJ!# &/R.7VO=4gDJ^xmG%y `>SA nc@ƣ:[Ƈl aK \%'e4  H\~g;v݄ڕ'ϣ\kR]{ڮoDZ.> FnھDk6cV2츎[J";>*7H KGExrB [y`p'} @Vm0j&d\5wMisGn'k9)D}>Ӑcq9\ݱP2'A-LE!^3vtFNt>#͊ Rl'l\q9'J B?h]*s]Rğ v;g惯tz0,CdkI `CgI.2k ka?pmOd4I ,N4u)ftFݕؐDd7&zAX J/7 8majeꔽ^ 0c7DC{ssconA,C0`QZh6A"j`-T^7./E8-OgEyѸ%w \{-V.7#,1jѕ7y>'=fo8JF%]SfKZ%;G3zzoAKFaFU MF ᤯r?'O)J'F"ɏh D3M = < zRxtC]QaKe)>ULVچ$$U[EҍDRw@*e| DId8B,ӈ7 Ц3 dhP` ;߅BAЯZ0OQ~6&i^U/iDKERiY,ҮKs,9>;xiCNcz^bT;^aZ/F"m6EB@6M9GQao V9>\Hk Xfcc#mw2 SlhDDa4#,UKyzaT?U]ZS7]է*O a( u-i괺.5u&/)&}I!e%W G0mLB (d.]O{$WxKODdC612f?K{>?!jnjG0 .Wɉb媯:#Lh=Bbi_Dͳ,9?&I{lZ`-V؏9Q=$SQvƶm]qH(J%Q%zVd{f 6z%}:$WaLлLxYiv]bW˱w&4W=[ d_6簫6Tӏc=~b]ʱNŶq;[*(d w;]PBOJJөnWJEPHEJD"SVQgT<|K. g]\8h̎.]惗~^wSrlm׋[J d"6 uzjƥn_}s9b~O]8s}g*_s7ku5ZPe.-#&tA?"&AJet/WUI\}#!E$zX lPJs|p"\ r X 6oR7P "l82 #zUpxQ_abU82 J;^ ^VBEX,7,b_G! 7R/魌T{}t/W;gndX\d4 0ݺ .R &/2LG{ /!k B>&"^s6)38GT\7->?^u glk_H2aD;`ڑΥ ' Ŏ!*EHл|fZ} PS-r?(i`1vTч-OtiRz, 3BOޜ.Ֆ,e>9 `# <9И򙿟jm׺sMb/0ߨ֛MͿ.xZ,ڏPYڶK4Aoڧ("GH I ?!wdÊ@2\QO2K@b1lnpKdpmk6 EgdVA dhooP.^ٓ͐U{߿|wg9k菵ݪh3%bk&)hFiڏ tZ:-HӤluA]SaPQ$DU5S}v{=?1VR]Å^uo`¸zDO)<~\#/V8ywnFV!oNH'B=/H 49ab2\JYLBv:Xia  Gwf//?sa o*n:B0>T@^: ́%_j9hd%U6g5y vsZiwukfC6y nKo'&aT(y3LSqƘ7vc$#EМhւj1BEW>iq6"+f'뫻_ಭ"  jɶ϶{=޿tjwX ۸\ڥxs~{S\%{`y&Zt}>'6+SWaʬPLUA L0|Lu>rLJ㉘~2M,q;)@ީ<> ˆ:*VZ }Z[lj(FMYim%yeG4dg4x؟L޹Y5Vˈ^ ;D|Ouh63EҘfڍV@WCh4jBC7Es"+*f}Rx6m8=YOn2V8JHt#lR@V|pcqIu26?sg={ov.s$\84b-(V++>x9ur\s@2P,sT˚r> j#t&m) C-Ej(R&}K/'K~u.T0S0~~OٜI#RmӞٕ$Ԇ2zIsQI\Z9{0}ސ}:P* !nl&@hljZ@4W2;Չx6Bԃ88r8ZqfqIc୬6 xSv?RbSZyarndd^">5˝U,z,ƜYx*mM6v6fFh4f%+j|ؼ.YEYj%E\B%Dh;Vy'q?êu89H>l(U,[RHשxh)jX΁vJjKd4ȎڹTB4.u?;~_2]:/&Q2q_YkO'ǝ^~;zgsQ֖v?22_h_E&fW1_&QUBk^Lt.R)R*M1"pz_>G]P j ^>B=t*NcENՎ'*+!HJ?U•vj‚Шtѝ#b?n.5 ,;N+"uIQ}a߲߰!eS"aYQ9 Pp5rkXdӑ{0{Fh,ʉ3 6lth0 +$4h', n+i"l`( MZf5ShZ a >p=;ʷkY@q[ W^L];^dfjrsiOz9?l]zuhc.w_exdm"ؕEn{ɰ{V/bV \(5Ҹ ŪDft*8Lehq52PL%.N8F@v$/zޕ8?lW]lKY"%Y")L]@2Zm s4FK#>dȰ@Zaal0d68(Х{8hېyX6@0`Ⱥu.Ȋ}tRlޏ=|0S]^ˎ>b^X]e;q䰠 rD20?1Et5D{gTLǙQ=Bt݄4A=*x(M$,smס5kmgӌ@t柋V. Z~=rC !Xg]VОN3@ʣa BQJPB B+;$Dbǔ8  Œ#|F,+\tdG,Gp&l4#(nzV#x1]b[?fJnx?u]ޓͣs7$c׎^5Edg,K WX^yFMDR$8t8?_b@76mW!3Ua1,}EJSɫmD$bމNY/u JTEGz)%|.Jz$늮&n%rCiOpcnGޣ'sP_.y{MyM}#&e-u5wC./ˏQso-ˏGIb3 _ @[\f*;ʳJp8_$唖d$[^TxUeEqqVUK<g BXdQA^Aa$^K8,؉TsWӼrZ]EYFgxxxV^\lаm0v+%uWѸO֋T\?AuEݔ?V}u)y/@7 ݽ\@qD&(  b*p Y^Eeá_vvTA9 U+ksNo'[Wy| '*AvY$¦S :YE"c23Q~ڪro p`بkfl&yJHvA]1Nǹ99ȱm/OL*(&UT;*8zPYR/nt?+C _/bCvoˊ(7I$MED)mZJ]ofv -f^w51I+ q&BlkZ VKMW 3g/<= wVz]ٯMYMT|zֿ֭(PH*DĂ3ݼғZ\j=T +(HõFM,P?Ua!Wb`N~MZ5tn},4PZE prDi'! {@jƈbV% ..PĹxjJN8V@r"P$bx*h2YV+" c2(Bf3d6: .kY!3G;i G#խRVP?…yb@EV&F=N šAn>9a-lQmM 9:AaVWLËzVVt5K͙,' 3c_=e͕kZ}h('gt:Ӵ!{got<3).?(ڨپ^GfIX$7X? ,67ZJzIc;.Ń~!ds 0EQa yi(_ln:Y{/go(YKj7ꄲlx[v32jW:Vy{-$ݵ]~J"5=7'/~v4z8.^F^VFSͥ!΄6AtRuI3#qRr7>H[Ә2JEuUb|C;(vV6Dנ*7.* $Bޘ䯾 ?ԇbxaTa t_ݟFEXyWJnaЀ$RJId Qg@\J& gl7y^mԺy6&pAk+M(Ta\/NSpuszj. f/]xU&|$Rr/%OtTFg66 G#@G {m$VʽNxC m1qrcQǿN rQ犮*dOV:!̑G7o_|XgYLlMT>Xrfn$a2`lGY@.og&*]O#Gr=[{>ɪXn7y9qB GظKU#ldxWm Eҋ Fy5D/n`5/#Uѱ=f;T:V ,>fnXEzhsUjGJ:;(UU2G1oHf^,u:oCG] YA~%c:sv+x?8?xЃqBmh,P_Q_Y'^1&{GĎKkX9}ӞK{"I`1w7Y Y;bpߞ=zKLikIֆX9b)Ga? hh\xUl f5}t!~XtE O3*b)alvs7;3C,{܍!+/'K@;0zd&[IHgJsz?A$lkmIuDż: [@:[<d!{$(ђ}mKv_|?F_GK|o.D!7e'lܦu/OnTw5ܝ7`^+!*Qdlj9!Ak%P!#q5-qG0E"92mG`WD>K`|cU8ېQ:ﶽ(h{/xGNޡgTv8]3" YwZso[!?)8~zeC.]9њ&ɟ5lnkp0'y5w599xUfFq#۷& ȇCHu{G* 5!5wUl\<ŴȷvĴ3]i1uXȬ]G|=%{Jw .btv_Q5J)1vK;ݔs{Z=.C{|Hډݻo d-,Gc\D̪)> `){rZ岜eewhmȚQF2;{ۭ.?dϜ/UP"̋Zߞst{lXح!(g)"Y&? )קr}ir/KdY`OTzi?PD߾Ģ!^9/XajHeā+Y J.0H(G%hGЯLJ.26c?\F3F{cIR^"$Q 22C{@VUw&eʑz;FOK ؟ٱko13A9쪉Xgc螺_2tu8K6yMoLgVeQRJmbo3jc2Yitao+ڗW.F*23vnTP/<Χ'>gpi (wntO\ 28\ǀafh3ûoj?Sqa>"7(-{K~kz|7S.yReQωJH*4nhG$Ͱ)Vƀy[Qi?w7u#˂~W9=עY.b0Q17>ϕq**KEqWyEDuGWeq/;zt5oIKN8ԏ]8>šëK?A?Y}]2}a=a'џ6 Yko;$h0&Z> s+NpM76us|6sk%=S .68+ĺY|~11iczWU^q$A0  BeP Pd(chZe@iЊ[[kN;b6+eh;֊RmGuc3>n^BҎߜ{y~myEP/R||ݔ;37PgWhd0Mwkd0LL~ r&͓_*)#Ɍq*rvn3z4#M#}9ߓqodllsGobOnicgdZy\Js'2j4y57c~w~g()2M|FRS+e cTத"E {f %/75>_&n,tlq :Mkb.c,3¶d{'Sp\EճrIhZOUcM{$AU 4 װ`!SeK Oeoˣg/>ѶyTF~w}F3"J:q:l<sFz8ғ]XEzXG3h;cÃ־cг"۞էկ,s߲uv%ٺ[hXr>Ac =T+'l6S=Yb[zsfއeA %;2 wh$ĭDUzXggƶ 4>w wrƫ ;i/x3ymJsRvu.9FSLto:u R>4wЂ5\lws; 1~ oE"tEVbG+v)IxnQ"7u_\}2hcwV^7B{7 Xrb'tȷvzT/u'Qږ[ s7;Ԋ^$\rLF}+vrR5uP&x L{?֗xC#lFox ꖃ~ 2{2['=C2&ޭR&6ٝ#Fƒ '=s_R.ǔ Ԝy&ےMg zDGVtG[TM7N#S42O.QzS'*:Vg W4)oi!> (B0jxi^V[kZ&*ޗ(,@O>u}=hrH++nIf>V9)ywޝe/Fw,F7Q >wV8k/ȤT b?R}eA4mn|mSj1tqh?bɓT[q>5i!GRs4|orAJ)jz4~mh>Gƿg}Խ/~1yfY?4,saޑ"L^ĥ*'݋dz}Ě zYY]i%1-V'ە&L{YNI%:M5"}㜋=x?b|͔L.b5r=&Ssϑ9ijZjb_1B}vdbms< :7$83y]&S/xx col]XQk|쿱=okދ= \=drgѺɕNJ`;dP[2S kV SF\b->򦌡b urR"~_wؓ}r3 90t)Ŭ ZN{U/FlR h.ky XuIW;Mgb d4u_׽5[RjbRSvljaIRFm8҂Y+} ҍX0r q̻XiҟHn9V򃻉c#ca^ϥ0(Qb4mcT^uojh 1~LsI?ZzL~r<%!! D0( XEB@LxD4VIMi;Qc"TJ괖qSmgmAfcNkN?{`ҖMs{v17Bܶ's{5ƙe39 23)yIqMB\ UAmqבhKI(lI :VȫuImPQy rL y J^TyjyMNLI-ۣiSOƽ613xG;ggw} T쬶9l>">^R{-#h\}rTv2yݏ5[HLJ ivzviսʫΐ~ 6 J2_W5^DZ)8[Ch#j2X?ƚ{} f^}3'+ftp7llʖz(褁屿cύc{X滌~`P\Iie1kݥ/xwj:9רxbFN BW3wkFQҬ9f{?Xa8܋ߣLXߠ2E 'n1OGC~3'ʣ8%M4՜KTJihoŜF:w՚mF<κo&h@0ߧY u ЅM66=bQ G:73م܉h[ovoҟyГ|})c cecW68 }7 ՜8'KʼWc͞p-ș+:rI,xPČgMZ18+~̞#|_C!=G*ޔM77{*;T&zCTPFor-*s%xQ9`%a#sV`gcg<^_9g\lqŜwO|)n7|.|,}{mM|.u-T8g& Y3yW,9C-DgHƱ9oO~ p4 ^s9q #pt6i$7kqԫʋ-]+M|L.&fSIf, 4;7˜RC 2/EDƨ}Mb<`5oE-Hy~)i nmof GG?mۻ҃ܭ|c.k7*X,bX,bX,bX,bX,bX,bX,bX,bX,%qzw;@W] ?P@]g@97SZO͉rSp"9D>)]0g?$ ''as"{oLdD%2IjJTKBMEͰNkmr%ېW=dV?Dsh[ujkMM^oc3:jKimi{3ogV¼aj9,^vhTsaAEV۰V!@{]wA8):թ$I6ֻjh+N:jvJZt4$i>f&δy~a$~XG.-T_N`vA Y;D\{Io:Z;c =9eOKB#U;VG{LNwS~օ 7*- i?$yr;d.#t҇3ŤtE󱚴`,<}"3)4c's4/K#b$*;5.ze]YBkѵш G#o ߤyB!13=6iGG,r-58r4*r4}mh{|pOg0'5cZ}Q* }!-}"b8T~k/k= >j5oЯZL5SJYGѠ<#ئڶ>=O?74mvi`ѤIjO~ȒrGԒ6B[I#7Fxx[4&,z7N>m;r㥾+~"2'62y16J2v`'cF V@9 cnصNBnX_cj[%pQU^|n[jذyϓweTVb&G/+qfNubM,4ԥNl3C#(幖^$;oi`L$̾OF$`"V0ʀzaalu|+ '&{^uv" YuvZW!WAȗ 9C E!_Haσ< ]olP 8kͳ~ (Vg:ѝo XHt ٗװQ`h8J8F:crØ01543Ȇ3! Ey1- 0.q4pGڿ> KPqvXu'7XFf]ΓEYENKեWO,Z"zbU~J"דKBrEgjFQ#}#1dʫi-$ W2m$. ;\bt3:ŗ6DS vg̥E=;h63Ь" V+,<  f.xsD͆5]΀g BS| m` hx~y_yȔY3s\Cct z]3z;5ux/HM'rB^3VrVX=;ITppP 2 ʀJ2qY͂y'c'V¯|%-:1Eϧ \ jRiOǏK;0#i@%D rm9&ۏV֪\%s8YW{RcSࡪu/H>.Rr;V}PVj e=TzFr{GQ=jGn*$g OÝ[~P_[T*P?_ VBUr%/LJֽ?j+W+QI5Zd NpBsõ i~~@Qt{?Owi qbW 1]䟃 )I5R:;7Gq9␧>o8zpA4E YJI"bXx'!ݩ]CdUta NTyI<vd>-V,:KMxJi1ǰKqj5.D-PKk )1.v$iuK $m1#i#k GBIG7lQ6b?) }vO')nsgQmIZr1qok(*o([syyyY3Ws-9%۲ĒeX2-&b!܌07&DIIm`jQ Sꚪh<5W+JҺ mW(f;$%mxEi4/mPZ6z"Oȡ.>'uZA:zj<^,?\2牥۟:҇?+JY_?[flx1=9⻛/M))%"D{}V9Q aP a R(H!M0 ZO֫絉 di[MT@MwXCJ?l݂LEHb6)x-T Ro^Z&=޼(x{UEpo^}_ޛL,ӗPCoh'= cMA UEy2ĚGF,gqBA8 C ĿW#ZQD PzI(Md4?鰹вڊP6={(O}$Rиz-(fo[H7'-nomsi4-iAT+\1zc2U\e50A"-Wk()ڥ{F1hĤ]9I_P pR'-i-8]'`م杜+{kg4LšqzޏvIwъRQ+J?Wj>GJVͦHQ7vf$]={c+GrGɫFHܫ5u\Dڅar]pmq`uS aIXXBH ӂ!TX*c˲<:1jc c_Y_-1o=_+|_4%qEd 1%NXc%lu'7%q̔XĔQS5W+ 2iY>C `#a'0? 2,c%M[o$ /宾|ڹZBrIBl c9 aq4 Eঋu/(N4vzFbB8\E%Ly endstream endobj 32 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[180.0 322.0 191.0 333.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 16 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 3/Type/Page>> endobj 42 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (00022210)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/00022210.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:35:49 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 273.75 591.75 491.999 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm (Michael D. Hipple)Tj ET Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 729.75 Tm (Chairman, Claims Appeals Board)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 0 -2.125 TD (Signed: Christine M. Kopocis)Tj /TT0 1 Tf T* (Christine M. Kopocis)Tj T* (Member, Claims Appeals Board)Tj /TT1 1 Tf T* (Signed: Jean E. Smallin)Tj /TT0 1 Tf T* (Jean E. Smallin)Tj T* (Member, Claims Appeals Board)Tj /Span<>> BDC T* ( )Tj EMC T* (1. )Tj (This matter refers to Personal Property Government Bill of Lading YP-106\ ,357; Army Claim No. 96-431-0084; and)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (NCS reference E-0383.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (2. )Tj (This amount is shown in a copy of a page taken by Eagle from the )Tj /TT2 1 Tf 27.743 0 Td (1996 Orion Video & Television Blue Book)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 16.997 0 Td (.)Tj -44.74 -2.125 Td (3. )Tj (The )Tj /TT2 1 Tf (Orion Blue Book)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 9.581 0 Td ( indicates that the VR526 was manufactured in 1992 and 1993 by RCA and h\ ad the following)Tj -9.581 -1.125 Td (specifications: VHS, 8 Event/1 yr., VISS, 4 Head, VCR Plus+ \(TM\) Progr\ amming, with 181 channel, on-screen)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (programing and a remote control. \(VISS indicates the VHF in search syst\ em.\))Tj 0 -2.125 TD (4. )Tj (This information was obtained by DOHA telephonically from AAFES Main Sto\ re Support, Hardline Division, in)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (Dallas, Texas. Although the VR526 was listed in the AAFES inventory data\ base, there is no evidence in the record that)Tj T* (this model was still generally available for sale in the Fall of 1995. H\ owever, it is our understanding that the VR542)Tj T* (would have been available at that time.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (5. )Tj (For example, the rationale could have included a feature-by-feature comp\ arison with a differential for missing or)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (additional features. Or, the rationale could have discussed the relative\ placement of the two VCRs in the quality range of)Tj T* (VCRs at the time of purchase and determined if each held a similar place\ . The Service Merchandise catalog material)Tj T* (provided by NCS for a period of approximately one year after the deliver\ y date suggests that the average price for a high)Tj T* (fidelity VCR was $251.54, versus $161.66 for monaural VCRs.)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 15 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 2/Type/Page>> endobj 43 0 obj [45 0 R] endobj 44 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (00022210)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/00022210.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:35:49 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g /Span<>> BDC 12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm ( )Tj EMC ET Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 729.75 Tm (It appears that the Army's mistake was accepting an estimate based on th\ e M650, without substantiating that the)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (replacement item was reasonably equivalent to the lost item. The member \ apparently was able to purchase a VCR with)Tj T* (more features than the VCR lost by the carrier for less than he paid ten\ months earlier. The Army reimbursed the)Tj T* (member for this new VCR and automatically sought reimbursement from the \ carrier. For determining carrier liability,)Tj T* (however, the Army should have analyzed the quality/features of the lost \ VCR in comparison to the proposed)Tj 0 -1.375 TD (replacement and documented in the record its rationale for determining c\ arrier liability.)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 435.1621 663.75 Tm (\(5\))Tj ET 0 0 0.933 RG 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 435.1621 663 cm 0 0 m 11.369 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 446.5308 659.25 Tm ( No explanation was provided)Tj -35.878 -1.125 Td (in the record for holding the carrier liable for the cost of the Toshiba\ M650.)Tj /Span<>> BDC 0 -2.125 TD ( )Tj EMC T* (Damage estimating is not an exact science, but there are too many flaws \ in the NCS position to support a $115.50)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (estimate. First, we are unaware of any precedent for applying depreciati\ on from the "actual age" i.e., from the date of)Tj T* (manufacture. We recently decided another claim in which we rejected a ca\ rrier's argument that depreciation should be)Tj T* (calculated from the date of manufacture, rather than from the date of pu\ rchase or initial possession of the item as)Tj T* (personal property. )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 7.525 0 Td (See)Tj /TT0 1 Tf ( DOHA Claims Case No. 00031420 \(March 24, 2000\). Here, the DD Form 184\ 4 clearly indicates)Tj -7.525 -1.125 Td (that the member purchased the VR526 in January 1995, and neither NCS nor\ Eagle ever questioned the date of)Tj T* (purchase. In applying three years of depreciation, it also appears that \ NCS simply assumed that the VCR was)Tj T* (manufactured in 1992 without tracing the serial number to determine the \ actual date of manufacture.)Tj /Span<>> BDC 0 -2.125 TD ( )Tj EMC T* (Second, in advocating the $115.50 damage estimate, NCS also violated a p\ rinciple of damage estimating that it had)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (strongly advocated and with which we agree: damages are estimated with r\ espect to replacement costs at the time and)Tj T* (place of delivery. NCS provided two 1999 prices, not two 1995 prices, to\ construct the $115.50 estimate. We take)Tj T* (administrative notice of the fact that, feature for feature, VCR prices \ fell significantly in the mid to late 1990s.)Tj T* (Moreover, after arguing that the Army and the member had inappropriately\ compared a VCR with a high fidelity audio)Tj T* (subsystem \(the Toshiba M650\) with the monaural VR526, ironically NCS p\ roposed a comparison which included a unit)Tj T* (\(the Toshiba M684\) with a stereo subsystem. Although the error was in \ the claimant's favor, the Toshiba M684 is a high)Tj T* (fidelity VCR; therefore, it may not have been a good comparison for the \ lost VR526. As noted above, there appeared to)Tj T* (be a premium for high fidelity as late as 1996/1997.)Tj /Span<>> BDC 0 -2.125 TD ( )Tj EMC T* (The Service Merchandise catalog pages that NCS provided are more relevan\ t because they represent prices within about)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (a year of delivery. While the VR508 at $179.99 did not come with VCR Plu\ s+ Programming, we note that another unit)Tj T* (on the same page, the VR4126 with a Zenith label, came with that feature\ \(but without commercial skip\) for $189.99.)Tj T* (As indicated above, prices for VCRs have been falling in recent years. A\ dding a premium to 1996/1997 pricing and)Tj T* (adjusting for various features, a replacement cost or cost range could b\ e determined from the Service Merchandise)Tj T* (catalog pages. However, NCS would have had to show that these items and \ prices were available in Anchorage in 1995.)Tj T* (Not having such evidence in the record, we note that the AAFES regular p\ rice for a VR542, the unit it suggests as the)Tj T* (replacement for the VR526, in November 1995 was $275. For purposes of se\ ttling this claim, we adopt a replacement)Tj T* (cost of $275 which we will not depreciate because of the limited time be\ tween purchase and carrier receipt.)Tj /Span<>> BDC 0 -2.125 TD ( )Tj EMC 21.878 -2.125 Td (Conclusion)Tj -21.878 -2.125 Td (We allow Eagle an additional $75 on the VCR, plus the $269 previously al\ lowed by the Army for the CDs.)Tj /Span<>> BDC T* ( )Tj EMC /TT2 1 Tf T* (Signed: Michael D. Hipple)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 45 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[435.0 661.0 446.0 672.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 14 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 1/Type/Page>> endobj 46 0 obj [48 0 R 49 0 R 50 0 R] endobj 47 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (00022210)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (r/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Ar\ chived%20-%20HTML/00022210.html)Tj 49.712 0 Td ([6/11/2021 3:35:49 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm (liability is $115.50. It seeks a refund of $234.50. NCS notes that the r\ eplacement cost claimed by the member is based)Tj ET Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm (on a Toshiba M650 stereo High Fidelity VCR, a unit that is not comparabl\ e to the VR526 that was lost. The VR526 was)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (not a stereo high fidelity unit, but a less expensive monaural four vide\ o head unit. NCS denies that the $124 for which)Tj 0 -1.375 TD (Eagle had initially admitted liability was based on an average retail/us\ ed price in the )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 33.988 0 Td (Orion Blue Book)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 6.776 0 Td (,)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 508.1758 716.25 Tm (\(2\))Tj ET 0 0 0.933 RG 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 508.1758 715.5 cm 0 0 m 11.369 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 519.5444 711.75 Tm ( but it contends)Tj -41.962 -1.125 Td (that the amount for which it now admits liability \($115.50\) is calcula\ ted after applying necessary depreciation \("30%)Tj T* (depreciation off )Tj 6.608 0 Td (actual)Tj ET 0 G q 1 0 0 1 95.2949 681 cm 0 0 m 28.646 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 123.9414 681.75 Tm ( age of item"\) because the VCR was manufactured in 1992 or 1993.)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 449.0781 686.25 Tm (\(3\))Tj ET 0 0 0.933 RG q 1 0 0 1 449.0781 685.5 cm 0 0 m 11.369 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 460.4468 681.75 Tm ( NCS contends that it)Tj -37.037 -1.125 Td (introduced the )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 5.998 0 Td (Orion Blue Book)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 6.776 0 Td ( only for the purpose of showing manufacture date and VCR options of the\ VR526, and)Tj -12.774 -1.125 Td (therefore showing that the replacement estimate offered by the member wa\ s based on a VCR which was better than the)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (one that was lost. Eagle contends our settlement inappropriately picked \ up the "New List" price information from the)Tj /TT1 1 Tf T* (Orion Blue Book)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 6.776 0 Td ( \($399\) to prove replacement cost and that, in any event, it was not r\ epresentative of the replacement)Tj -6.776 -1.125 Td (cost at the time of the loss.)Tj /Span<>> BDC 0 -2.125 TD ( )Tj EMC T* (NCS offered other estimates of replacement cost at the time of the loss.\ NCS offered copies of pages from the )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 44.181 0 Td (96/97)Tj -44.181 -1.125 Td (Jewelry, Gift and Home Catalog)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 13.026 0 Td ( \(Vol. 27\) from Service Merchandise and directed our attention to the \ VR508. The)Tj -13.026 -1.125 Td (catalog indicates that the VR508 was a four video head, 181-channel, 8 e\ vent/1 year, monaural VCR offered for)Tj 0 -1.125 TD ($179.99. NCS points out that the average cost of the VCR selections in t\ he catalog was $273.99. In its February 12,)Tj T* (1999, letter to the Army Claims Service, NCS enclosed World Wide Web pag\ es from Prime Focus featuring, among)Tj T* (other things, the RCA VR540 at $145. The VR540 is a four video head unit\ , with VCR Plus+\(TM\) Programming, a)Tj T* (universal remote and memory protection. To arrive at its $115.50 calcula\ tion of damages, NCS proposed averaging the)Tj T* (price of the VR540 \($145\) with the price for a Toshiba unit, the M684,\ listed on the Prime Focus World Wide Web page)Tj T* (for $185, i.e., $165, then depreciating that amount by 30 percent for 3 \ years of depreciation.)Tj /Span<>> BDC 0 -2.125 TD ( )Tj EMC T* (We also researched prices for RCA VCR four video head monaural units off\ ered by the Army Air Force Exchange)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (Service \(AAFES\) in 1995. There is an AAFES main exchange at Fort Richa\ rdson, in Anchorage, Alaska, the destination)Tj T* (of this shipment. AAFES advised us that it continued to list the VR526 i\ n it database until early 1996 with a regular)Tj T* (price listed as $379, but that the VR526 was replaced with the VR542, a \ four video head monaural unit with VCR Plus+)Tj 0 -1.375 TD (\(TM\) Programming. In October/November 1995, the VR542 had a regular pr\ ice listed as $275.)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 472.5508 351.75 Tm (\(4\))Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 472.5508 351 cm 0 0 m 11.369 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 483.9194 347.25 Tm ( Although the World)Tj -38.993 -1.125 Td (Wide Web offers extensive information on current pricing data, our searc\ h for historical pricing data was unsuccessful.)Tj /Span<>> BDC 24.031 -2.125 Td ( )Tj EMC /TT2 1 Tf -2.126 -2.125 Td (Discussion)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -21.906 -2.125 Td (Generally, under federal law, in an action to recover from a carrier for\ damage to a shipment, the shipper establishes his)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 0 -1.125 TD (prima facie)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 4.583 0 Td ( case when he shows delivery in good condition, failure to deliver or ar\ rival in damaged condition, and the)Tj -4.583 -1.125 Td (amount of damages. Thereupon, the burden of proof is upon the carrier to\ show both that it was free from negligence)Tj T* (and that the damage to the cargo was due to one of the excepted causes r\ elieving the carrier of liability. )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 41.511 0 Td (See Missouri)Tj -41.511 -1.125 Td (Pacific Railroad Company v. Elmore & Stahl)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 18.192 0 Td (, 377 U.S. 134, 138 \(1964\).NCS argues that the Army's )Tj /TT1 1 Tf (prima facie)Tj /TT0 1 Tf ( case)Tj -18.192 -1.125 Td (fails with regard to the amount of damages to the extent that the member\ and the Army failed to demonstrate damages)Tj T* (beyond $115.50.)Tj /Span<>> BDC 0 -2.125 TD ( )Tj EMC T* (An agency's determination concerning the amount of damages is a factual \ matter, and we will not disturb an agency's)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (findings in the absence of clear and convincing evidence that the agency\ acted unreasonably. )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 37.401 0 Td (See)Tj /TT0 1 Tf ( DOHA Claims Case)Tj -37.401 -1.125 Td (No. 96081202 \(April 28, 1997\); and DOHA Claims Case No. 96070206 \(Sep\ tember 5, 1996\). For reasons explained)Tj T* (below, NCS did not provide clear and convincing evidence that the amount\ of damages was $115.50, but based on the)Tj T* (evidence in the record and the additional information we developed, we a\ re also convinced that the Army did not have a)Tj T* (reasonable basis for finding that the replacement cost was $350.)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 48 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[508.0 714.0 519.0 725.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 49 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[449.0 684.0 460.0 695.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 50 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[472.0 349.0 483.0 360.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 12 0 obj <> endobj 51 0 obj <> endobj 9 0 obj <> endobj 10 0 obj <> endobj 11 0 obj <> endobj 58 0 obj (file:///usr.osd.mil/Home/OSD/OGC/JosephLM/_MyComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/claims/transportation/Archived%20-%20HTML/00022210.html) endobj 57 0 obj <> endobj 59 0 obj <> endobj 52 0 obj [16 0 R/XYZ 0 536.0 null] endobj 53 0 obj [16 0 R/XYZ 0 497.0 null] endobj 54 0 obj [16 0 R/XYZ 0 471.0 null] endobj 55 0 obj [16 0 R/XYZ 0 419.0 null] endobj 56 0 obj [16 0 R/XYZ 0 353.0 null] endobj 4 0 obj <> endobj xref 0 60 0000000000 65535 f 0000000016 00000 n 0000000141 00000 n 0000003655 00000 n 0000149513 00000 n 0000003533 00000 n 0000003588 00000 n 0000003728 00000 n 0000003755 00000 n 0000148678 00000 n 0000148856 00000 n 0000148898 00000 n 0000148494 00000 n 0000004391 00000 n 0000140460 00000 n 0000134419 00000 n 0000131378 00000 n 0000003858 00000 n 0000003904 00000 n 0000003953 00000 n 0000004144 00000 n 0000004016 00000 n 0000004048 00000 n 0000004080 00000 n 0000004112 00000 n 0000004616 00000 n 0000004641 00000 n 0000009045 00000 n 0000009094 00000 n 0000009129 00000 n 0000009643 00000 n 0000010076 00000 n 0000131044 00000 n 0000076934 00000 n 0000077201 00000 n 0000043385 00000 n 0000043658 00000 n 0000010537 00000 n 0000010813 00000 n 0000011322 00000 n 0000044131 00000 n 0000077816 00000 n 0000131589 00000 n 0000134644 00000 n 0000134669 00000 n 0000140126 00000 n 0000140685 00000 n 0000140724 00000 n 0000147492 00000 n 0000147826 00000 n 0000148160 00000 n 0000148579 00000 n 0000149303 00000 n 0000149345 00000 n 0000149387 00000 n 0000149429 00000 n 0000149471 00000 n 0000149114 00000 n 0000148940 00000 n 0000149250 00000 n trailer <]>> startxref 149683 %%EOF