TO qF
B9j >We@"b/A{(Y"
nỈ>F HNnid8ѕ_':(
ځB,0,krޛs=D!R>3y*59; B.L?lsǻnnI E۴fM>3%H\ލXk
~qEϕ\k7VMߞKjFܷ!ר{|@ӍQ)ȫk
h![fŵh Il:M*'qI& E?:Ո5&- $ qoX|AȟNYĝ b'q-ِL%$Թ3~McŬG<݈iLmz|QTTC 3nTv ʼnma^4$T h1שP/\b%QL.,'ڛGЗfSM}:a0ĊPYPs;|{ lpd9Luִ<g*nHƾyS{>;l^" ܄nă>^ >-4m nHf1 E}\U,x&k
,'MNyٚG3 K4Qb7SN⪦ d7@{ڨf0F$L
Hh,$< Ad=C Bh֥?~N]-|~͗60 1\DyVJL.j.!b DQ3WXSeڛ4/%Aɼ3.zEdyUlaT]/I|V$6n7&9ۥ]C!t?-.xZz$\ _
w{½=X(:$YE^Dp-/ R(snzt<4&1L 0 OhvZqK *ã8Qj%(Wqu?9;Rn@u?[ZG ƙ+ց #PmB jz87/OI|8'#= D8cEq/ehkS
)iQO4
U5?lcZ8xq@} ~\
/*Z%dF,eUcC n!w%}h|X!]Rz0V-e8r;m*-+]c`pP,v ߔ;*WRբh
HZq p,=x
^~*SD l{,b-yOyY7OV.+?dWl wgߝ 8;wgs QFOc4FhRڮK:ЪD(X+VM6It&NLXѩ,f
S%wIWA=9Sy#pfdQ7_N M~hrR@(=ʌXGn0ǥ'9~^= ͩ o'?OnE"⪙K*JIdgM&ЋE[ be3dzd[S}5^WwD].DȠPg;a][^IS\0|hwz( YK%-˶҃YۍW-Ѓu [tS;Q xb0zpu
Dmۋ=6O9 Sb̓`4
q*ߥAqa)$,JBț)=2Q0*L uLZʘ`͙MMBXvƨ;K%u\9:wo Ȑ
A,ږse[݆
k6,!x b4{ƋfۿZCRs-ӹY8scf_YsNjS&F[LzG ڎ{v
]zoz7$?}vPVǘY-|go9[F:խ+L4 H.69t+ݯǽgx[xC_
9 1qYfc')b%QufQ aP:1N
H3榝?s:/}6F!: x<'\BzcA*A:Hܨ%k mXjupuaxF?ܴ/p%XN9!k;vܹk O0XD"4$=]0>'LeYƈ?VE}^21ܨI0,e7~Nyq|Π߾6|
g~ظrtz7ws#z~CU*@ҫρK%mkZ puEb=^_Tf8?:~YuU$
:ErU1 RtI@#^,ok U +%TTQP+D!+
CXbv
z̸G|$ nR;2~X eIOaW_;u-;: l"O'MDTd " 'g c_xPA9 DtT@_ynٿMD?>-3XV;Ըp+ߊHD!6
k\;
hW*>IZ|Z
U
7Oڦ)nْ'4E2*_?( ws8>4$&څvN_ɷH$jr &}M'~%zXGMAq| ΘS?b9\jۓb5~m/1Uo
FL ',~wov껭M5FTj{ZWبiPee]kā+
p #-^ב\ZYlyq!sٸeeooUv3eb=p!Difk*3ln{,dRIJ#brNTwsDo~iS9'nP9'>ҏcu]9. ٳ<~ ~lS*)ρzsL=JޤУHaYZHre4+t6qtvU bmԫ%/F FF3*## huN pK$h7yIZ\|}65K1zslŀ<6?/-這%ޖi T͚T4UlAS
ZIT tC On $dVI<|oDoKLJ ii *+3*fs4ih1` 9]Y ّxSR-2]IxG9cĊIRZiE1 q>YV_/ H1 '"
q_xR٪V/j i-%[n~numB1^ǴkRȧ~m=*t%z4 TvU~xO(C߅ŲYPhT47ku+Ԓ1)Ց-1p Xɚk:E>j>/ `!t}Yq
(;*vxɰ<*?Y#\Q1#/Y`)'^K[zQ (|İ]-; o^+,YePU+-F
崶% zcWq\\ e̱T:˫ ̩;8xi xgG#7&x{VFUgҺ&kUȀVzr`[ #S9m lװA=3 " g.8 =fsO@&i2eΈRz~/!6ɗA<Q' 9ǽЯoi_fV27}/ ̳ԦK2ǿ#ணFMA|tH)pI%Q_ lo w2Ȳf+E4eҊGZ rSȤO x29K CY`>Lo}
g!`a?]>!vT%H!9,f۟
4 a c_^B
Aꠗ;n UEc=MG"ԝc (_S ]S. &;;;w;>lؾqX)ֈ#mV4P
C -kM6 Xva QhմnRTM]Z&ƴKKFpK f~>~W7æÁ=ו+[[5$$hD
S-=.3ŢQ)AAEr{-%`<ɳB` eL*6|.u#khLo\Qhωff0S%~K 2
U,G"!҈ةDBhMw2@
eXH%EqI.!A)'-9Ƞ& UԃĠ #!- I9|3ELyIt&wJ M6 y~nO:jZ
~_`8ku
qv iL$Zf8q> ÑF0m )Q Q \. 1pֳ̳s cM1&G{)qYv{r+1W\P+Ր z~;*YRE$"d[%DIz̥i\!Sw8[t݊IQ,5I,5M_Բ<4= 20aF9@ H.AK˛-K)A9
eTїh=, U߀1{7 ."KO>z_GTwVP}w;GFU/ F9DzG&-_rk/s!uHٟ{NP^1~a^Uj53D)aZͩR\BZZ[1xU[;۩CFæ q">=ѦưYwq<M߇^QH
YJ?du,Q*sdrn:嚀x` ؈ΰ}dy"mۿ#Oqo*\}-Xf YBȦkF:) 3$ `h
6 hqs @=$B5Qwb
tuA<ǧ&a82#ZdGMX:j4Y14Wk!
ҨJ@dWWi'o>{7̓wql:k8BƲGc{_v[[zHEqvfLԊy3kH o%įdNgYD
N1L܋6NcǢc{G`$z<{$^I7|5у `GƋ~8>g 2C&ᢹ=n=hB
5Oc,MZ,D
gV>џ#;Vx4WWN>վ wb^>kT07Oz f'e!<(?.p:l&J3ЍEwL-k qm55U;Nx6T7rv7GaLjk$3j-HhuÅpkH,ڢ
H:-lV+k k{;6H3DZն 'ԲuKqK滜\]]Su>(zw6q{9?ξϻ/6!çЊTd5TlI!K&Xi+0
Rʘ(hĪAnS5&Mc N+ju^w;b ;_[W?펬j3 \fެt7|b ǟ+PąY9T8
Eq|HI%+&L!W0+s+
ݨt?! 3ٞ V:4%5dr2x,.-Be\+H #8iI"CQM
&Og2,h d_kk# j+H&1ɵ }nBϘP6l`t'%t{'}Ib{@h\ČOm\d_btKm-.[Q,AhD
ug=]|fVk+(ӫ+xﻣAQ( [\w /TP?$ݏ`PW ̐pR`u;Dof])%*1QW|\d!~7 J Ak3ܸ8U;Nnoǿ'KHJϼ̿<` /8!Phr}O ӉSө47ͿI\wգF8 0]ʸYF'ȏ
^O{쵙a+ sa8ʇ7fD MQ
Z\Y%s"=RW'cv$/$RcU)((i+f؏bbԜ.6eZ}际n\/Y}[I$a*I4S{9oƥ19GLռN{=4
[zI 8g7UlkIChX_Lw"َI͋B1wodz 2F ]/q1[$#M 7
C_|=4 ;W&_V#w.?\?r9,V
3R t 6K^
_|T/
0{S۾D[<{o
Pf0\R LXTuu~tDDw뻍/lgi
rfCJ3*
iB U`Q~m7I0Ij8A 7ez G+` hzZ(PVA5ǢQd}"h-98ǩQ or j(MS,m<ޗwNΎc_y쀓8q3f6|HTH(\<5 ڇAh.SMP[Uk%B0N&6UI&n2)E${s(h[7w=_eZF`l*:mg "m];Z~+%:Vb81(%BB~p1E4: $W#'Ll͘BQ:u& bjm\r6MTQvbZJI IёFݹ
WH^MU2e=(P; -Ep\f ROLJ}V%7@(Μ# {N3*c:q{@i,wwÇv I_GP 2LdD1md
.2~ p#2j6V+L]Ugj°PEK /x8]]&hSRBW^ܕ{P;:N p Lo1_`ɷe6>zL>#rBP upy3gP[ÙnRB., QY~ 'םƍ`OI}le hH ^
¢%II e{@24:!:!E[ ; 8T1Y(0*~n8\NU +25|O5BU{6ד}K|T{N
bKϖ_l_qgs+rcnpWmh`oשM<5і3clǦ
Gϭf}oe\5A;v½|{ " 畑ʴR!S){@B]t,~+n%2o#
[ɪ]LW~i˺C# Cp\@*?: 5 vNrpے1OG [W8~/ Dn
=Zqy4&C&Ûp=~A RtɛtEAs 2"ˊk5v%8R\.q9q
کHϮrz+ɪy1N&D4 p!ԤJrWQVp 0 PU42%M ^lDD81"P I+GCLHigxs?|sSo1Zu=W_=ɴ{WY+JJ 6 Po e٬ 2
/S v}F(q |m Rnz֭pDVɴpLnLwϑP>v/'<|"$ s%Tk7E'N::\TdK
iM:9|_7q'ULERRkH#
|'pttEa3~C_ԗt~8z\g{k`yL )鿍xHL䔂:h M4H'ѱ 8PY1^;yX dorbw092Q3aS/WvYOCaP?}}}
2RT3:`rbP]=M\w;9ߝ};7v 0 PY¿) h:2Z)Rlݘ4Ґ--mb_i$J=A{GmJZUܱzTӃ![5FX,r-YĀ RUȒ/Į ?195aU[vcO,~j=,x&n쏄 N y KMqk
42.Fg),-4~a3 [5t<yV(S2Tp۽>ϜJQ.\u e RBIN
$fFGQ-lqȆ!<g B~dҺ= U0Vfa CPp6105M+
4J8Boфq6KFXr1 FW,dl@Aǁxq _D}]GL 0lj@
?h)}HI/a tv)J$U~|fJ5E ] ~+33`.Bgl/dbCuomlD}Yӷ`^, (x}D=)˚Y O<;x>@}Q7#mI^xTh7rrwdM
sQ|Yf)?;N4O0"8lw j6
:UƤq #{Ypޤ ?%!xy 3y7"fi\⚥1ī-J)$JC@W|֛[QxЙȰJ{}3Aҵ8D
P(*a
0P'@iz
h*4T3" 76Ujsn;C:#@d:Pi*ZJYiɬe+rP9`
c
B\JoݚԈK(IA]_RxjjVV/)N2u={<_٭տuAn>;ѿ`-L~{juo*{Y7B WP[+L6M !Ī"bII`3[2*"?4)yL뢄2Z- +}"=KpyCPB_%0ibV i\],Y?@Qҩwssi4^5aLý?v!L@t\ 'Ҥ|L=MeU~oOrAI KG 3aR%;R _sa.V=*V&JĩBb3ci.qƍV=zug,^]|%-g6츂ij+2?uyRs
hkàry+F0}c>3 31!}uAjT зJs[ 5
}g0IC3=(9)D ͯn25o0 P[[ږPry"Xa7['{gջ:^QDMvs7G I5tvnj}pK^gؗ?Ae=vuV >n j-/[B~ewޕ c/Ռ Y{p?~՚p1S=Ss){r|;}eBmF oI| |k@v]S=Je'K#1J6ۛ dtB.aDYf 6l*hz|W+\h3R8юKr/83~ s_sC"$ej[N7ͩ]5 ڌ65Ojm#s=؞N#L<~ڱ۱w=illtInCvTk$͂XZh$Z6^R@
!-*~PZV
EKhRιw+p29s3ww2|F|!2R_'7; ץ^fCE;p>8n/w)Nī1ރ#ң:
00?,f5xEc-\zsLI8i*xS܂xy
{FOpCwB* ?xoUzsUy=w4 Ϟ\%dJN;Z fhDoZlCK@S. u*R
TMM0RzO5@^=jX܋uH S/, >p6h: H`,f (~S%ͥB& 9[ ~ ^N+df:_
<>8p& XRu%>%!`Ԗ0gT`4/Ji U!Xzm=r
=m!G,b!xq~D|^Pf`>fIӧ:?{1@Zpc4
>Ǯ`UA-Ya `5EO6[ &AXBj&Pko7_̛Oh~u27+w9}Fù &77u`&PuZoTFdW_<; CY eCSo|.\>yWOD2s< # P 7E Ã$:EEYsه'2y`Y}+ (:j. Khl
5% v /L`"P \pDr y
s.g4y+w)j2a@R\|oHڤmOnJ(5 g-1EqIgLd@d@dAKf.d8BTV[envb OT8LRt&JIErd̋e GtZ4^)noy*r.H:CwJa56 = `~(v DYWErE$*^oFCa$ũZ:K-)Jj5e"S)cjyge*mLFA5 a/eg<ƗR/`4`3xD DRT}Ec"0 8t1dʡonHZ|cm{F
]9!}u|w}ȇ&3צvG{eGȷwLrO?"4-f䛧sGv!Ms I*eI3k7`814HN~îʈ{UF nBVc&`a45 m,9wy MޗwD=^i0pX,rJe{MsIִn@&"שt{GFc@8aM0M9NQn V3
H;c cx a 3w:jdYjښmN3hćr/T݇#^_ '. Q;I^8nfvU+PO <9kNK2|ܪLd,WUyMޒMzx'<-d ȁV[rI -Djw9C^F wGLW|-dPG/Cnr~XX2Y 7;;1[A_ CzMr29(K w_y{Crgv%%vl=;ݬs+?cgF n P.C6?)!b)!NHն88@%<7jb쀗.|{P]{G/=*#y;]9Jy
P^m,2 '%gMzJf4Hn8f;;.A>m04
62l[PhU!,+kʖ+
QO v ' TD}4d"<+ F@&BΫTl"4uV% nD8 x@ 8B>#݊
Rl#%%{MH,*'B?:hXYwiH.'iyWy=8 7 >U8
"gF}L~xY.Nւ_i[b# ,i? bS]، K%g|8&SWأ 6;UQI[#bv.ض+.)Z$-dK%2-G۴ĭ.XjrN!@,[l
$C 0yH4`^C7#(by(0lŀ
]s[aKsd90A$ď ae+r *T ?
k;ڵwR+7$ϫ%R (o(xsGS i_Ufje^ْ~\5GBeͪBDmSͨgs_Uxvm/T":ƿ %LO{ӾUuY[cJ"L{0%gG:GWd&_8,OѕLt9e,
(35e|2>FHeR
MUa6
T<*eߗl$gr. ex3lZd|1
1oW$UJe3[ʿ $?x,Ey[ gߐwe^.(SVB˫nngVϯV}d`sk
D 5uhJ}̚î\ K?p un`> Pmq`@t/=} *źemBI!B*KA} GS* (A3 טdӣ NÅdY,2QfYZ Z5%=4*~q @ bg#a6ԆX qj#s2B J
9# BaҖpP<&bZ'Վz@
Ô` Q1JU &we.ɲPT!A5 I:?Wp430d0X2֍
e N
'NpJ_Ǭ~yo92ݒْ
%+?} չд6$1Db%aȭ^\M/t|<42 )3_rgdV<FдpwKݳ
^gUf'7e;Y
vrDZFb3S`/gFm9<*[DNYX9/fdBKŨ!5\4نcf9R9kXf2_6qfRnFT #11|/ ~Mrk ֤H|-V=͋d!HT T#c68%/. a!P)$ SI+)Z
Q$
mNENjLԩ аn6CX
X'Ǵ?P+
IUk9{ sy|,^~jQO7Wr;5<j+nCnOM<]n(`mnA8Q!+p +C5Mf=(qJ7J?*\WXE<|$KncC KLP
L_$v>9)TX?aCD YxȲۭER0P/[ E7?
mtn E/8\` .WhKCl$cbB
8{=r--IhzԞ>"~>in.UIm;3n~})yM;Km(Q,gr7e
U_D
RBH҉3% N5 EGAd F:QGvWH6U (O/pz-~z?wyH8$}7__o/Alu 곔8:;J ܨ݅`?dG{gg~ S Ո ˇ /[;=#G9̓_NGn X}89S)IH Dٚ7$1duD0)
i MhPsB x:ErB@/d6dD8QJtϋ![ѵ@~y sbfe>RU8<[":ܕBa&³$tE 8RESمi.y/{,]} ==}ރgێ֮Ph;ku;JK>лF HhRhL1l؉Lh ), 6yI;3NyS}sq+(= ETTGDmUUۭ"nJZPAf,#zK_gO'DQK N uZBwbHMq쾉xs xy
Je --O5j* Q-)
/soLB ^abL!|k}[[LaÃ>sTTp^M$P6 jcU[ -9ʤmW$z >8ī KyĄbBp_$ax 6L ΣJ̥$/T8Ġc(Ueќ'W dp$G2H3x!AMUec~:Ķ*J_+ڟhz!u = w+c2NḌW=/)/E9a27 w` /̌//e&~5څ(rF,"{T)i_+hy"Ji Fh1ȎL L@g=ٞ) /:R ̯Tځ OBPRR>%1 ^a JĉmN kvT=xnTf+&9&NZZ +
j'Wo*|+z+ 'Wu| ?}];/ ' >٥(;-` | \- 1>Za*C2B^!kKH^"^fZ͡5v^ǴjD,F$2r0[ToScx@.BW[,wŚ;" 9 s0S^ Gb-|M2{ ϧZKƠMǢ-,oeЮ p6zjX05IXG9]_+O; {a( :] 85kqMt4 iJ3~EM`\e'OLd``r`&;S9ͽL҂] VP(TZgz'z`m)[{_ټ1p 3=Ys?p3 $}⣧V5Q#w=˘2
F2fɘ (vÍQO-)AX'ci2iTw3AJZ-H%È:߽8ů$ ĝc]H4ݥX4s siy;Pw .X=} ;?kL/|f*Iύ |v/}}guߐ,);|oiבvOUǿ87Z=8Ҡ y2ʗ|.kB@üȫT%#TbN%6 *E1٢8rrsˎw?ZX \M9|{Ht,8 (r4Y y@_xY!ebԸY 7]Y/I:P9BaI4Icyy^mt3Nh`p20iјhD
.lHwL?M#_7 y滔FkEhT_q
!Ǜ PQCE*%Wէ ~ubԬM*@uF`R:h1SD'M!neAmC Od,ךحV
iv("/Wӕ#hCӲn( Ñz=oiگ'?wdhd?
ƜM:53k%;/ǚNpRS1l 4 S6B$@%F 8-ChGK8TNak;].tY 4˰` Z(BWeن_D+.ʩ0Gd hX+T?ǜ^e陷 x(vq`'h'G,`Y,w 6'X^8P|7w24u
bsX LRIb ULhr*Mϳ\x],!S> >3P5k fg# 6\Oʶl6F*?T>jep;qm\c es?3^5_R_pg9M/h7R=4 «f07&zݸk ǍeZMK,/~W>Fa~X-%3OhufD٭ѪNi'(pZ^9C5]0ad82z<,HCUF ]oGg L v+^a`\E&eS WT9o=Nbk@ڵѵ))m( Du8K.
3u\W5gC[5:8j F3qW 4@u0L)YYx; "w2D. L % BW
r r9"i8R|`ab opbDRWè*M%cCi99GF-7rvRè0 N[W{ׯD= s:>:T<ĉB6;Gwqq|3ݝ]8s8{2ځiBTuATj :"$ld (TOP$qH
W2R^
y!*b0U@ 3kYs3g -kyc)ȫއWNdcG^E1I;lJ=BIv$ o܂myGvݠtX
kpvJlu.J:ȡNiH2^qnuKǑ{;~L }RS.ͬbU = ^r?>2k9J_3>s9}֕W9==NbTx@`I,b b4rL<+!YI˲beExT a ݅t+ %$$"XW1.T 8Y^Bߠ4EoT̸@8ʃ |u:jd7{}* ]4aI
m aJ2D{Gt:8M k RW)͚&m53! ZZuZnY\ŶvL)UiS[ ny52 r1"ƶ~Z'H/mp;G̎c!ZPrMtM>B/i֯HFB&]t!C.c "&1 @h&Yz `OEMO4K3r ^4 o CW쭷ӆlm` (Z/9@?MHl|R WzKȟH#`jMУU
.\azרjQÊLT`.8{> -19y-^IO?1pu۱6n#zCAqoqy Ri g3ҫ|A(/dL(8%\K[7Ipkb4A*ώ
R.y[(;oR %\䙾C.K٬h4x"Qa0h6M-5D$6AgiebyL˨h [Q7>DX4t%1TO̾%)OH4 T ¤ЏK0'K&D(߭dob'@,ʺ"J.
R%(?)J u_Y[Tbׯ4]x@Q}~Qz|a Hm_{kxSkź۱vPa:6m-#ɛtt7UI)ړyO #8o߅\M®0X}rdCd5{CV~ uΗb
,@@ ~q[&!1蓒Xi2rk" A \ H |]%E14$WR vID(R1|d.Wݐ"iA/-6Ci߂"Y /@k%rw(tzt A@eui އd}A.#.BameRfY#A@[ía"@9}t]=9>spOJ^?/~s~I]ǎ= r7T*$uVV*]҅ Kl mF32
l@=ѓi91lIM4kamz5.;m nqT!-/P
t'S~CHը"묀
ICK3_y?O)ש ,3<
Mç_辆}zhXqv:sT%#jH Ǖ sΰg7gy55' Kԭ=ePD (t
!Nmˆ謪rC|pl;4 2<@T@-+b$^/
I)Dy>/#t; "4
mAEzA#C;J7fCO_Ln܃u|Ǐjo]
>S&|*
J7 l sWv W1EVr 2mi BSޥ7zMk#=\/*:vޛBzo G6$ -F mFiT XX+Xh dU$$wν'n7 x|{s~Nr=MֲFG =_87%8Y㧇RG32*BZwبarﴞ[s
FJ_o7)m8"}
Cbk-8=Gen֫f C B:t:iz ٪aqGZRf㉿C˦\ٕii- - # |Uu -&M'ɕGgҮ#S]yFw+ +; ȸL_r Ms!Wqv͆˽F= P-͆R/
jc9+(Q |jJ+HsTQ LB6Y
}= 9`><
UIP?1b+-,ϛ'oP*tq5t%DYH.ӓ' Re[CϠa ֳ>m]H [ˡU(T>S1HO = T_AhXxunFC-gDm'@}wVM`&$lmc[?t_r6DuNniV_ υ_}c`01 O9ujBh{ u0
K n?3^aAQ So@1A#>v<>þ! $}q
},g~?N[@<ȱ6EB[_x f <6RԧG#~O)9ro94}Uwh*lxJ*x?P)TQ R5}2ߡYF -K,(U;tQHrwwt;о0F;ڡ i6ۗf0*T7Z[qn6qavضA/rS)Ekֶ{#tUF=hQFӌrPcuXZ=' XGtu }/IU: V*TWAܓA;V±g H1_{.;,A?/-jH5|Is{Mwk_&:7s}
@ oDXo [z{c/{ fYb)ϓNchEγ Sc/bx87m^g[!82oF,Ջ%G9 ?m !Z,s6iYNsчxele?,D ke^{AyIk@i<σqcy));& |9 8 sͥ<9>٧R1_"u%[41P&W0*U7l[D1lόO;{& cda{vN8={(_
jߡh- :wix뷟R㈍%s0WGISQ@>G &p 9З?sp[?eŠg>pkϫWŽ>/8Iӡ\H^sϺ}]ΒڸF{-p, *B9k17D=8 ?"(F0ʶC@qPn#h;1B}{o1z<!ܿͬ rQlC7 f0|7=\ g ߡwUo1TUJ}C I?0UÞOQ
rt) wYg?)UJ1|5 pge;+TpZ'5?Hh t[$ x8Ay
i bڎ|ilwvvc +\ܪ\@ٌ;.;巈8UWDR>)[^6UW ?KbR h4"$ v@7QVd8 )@*#R:)A-j+Xi R:Xķ{aݷ{8I]BtPHm9;κ%q9I{/3%RHܝ-zv6i؇9n|/~vc^G9oU[}Ȝ8C_j
(_xxϋ=7e oVʝ(g!>X/D}>f,r.ޕb@c:UReL\Amoj3K]W^1ŌX'"E ۍqm^>' a() F0.~r??A F㩬ߡ|̟&52U)uyap|e9Sj\r8[sR
1X7/R_CǮ285-AZn2gk~4o`7<'@q5z1XKg3̇WX=o)<3ߙ}>_w.&՜1I諶& j+$ԫ ѭVh$_%{+P_юP?,hk{'w;~LNB ħK?E 83z%dw\M~fmc]Lm" 㘕p
Fc[ܘoD;Ƴcy֍'; {oC7~{0>\X}p d\6N_y> oxQ K5x).ALO5S rs\WKI= K'įLjkKAP$ jHXC!=y_1{`?w'&3-758[Gܭ(WڜJ f͔Ov@ OɀL)N [7%}zO.)WȐ潄!߄%ҏ8=.L9jNkyOIyoLМ[F_.VaN/r?J])" T獖pT${ܘ崛KAt2pVF<:cVHB}k;J5u5LjZg9ޘ Wwꨤu>2=sz6\vL !oiQh@
Ucx?B,
YM [e;K߅ۢg|w-j}?rcGd߉0A\ۨ;I٦ Gsp';AǙFzXG7Se樳G\}'k+IWeԯv%u6NIގ-vd-w T:Vα]ݟVd1:?݃K}ӈۭ} g GHT.j {/_:B %]V'6?aN_zhp9@3 ͉=x^ǏE˗ g
ݕ=v,z8g>We- x}ӧ>
xM8V#3A%~]8> j7ı/eJ zil{k2}N=9 z;ENژK 'FsokW 87q."}Vmee
W쯣FKoӒNWN ;̛#S)?G= i;>t)w7mTیi_Cg4NX|˸^:_G ]eNf_w+X)eG
^vXQi9a7mRVVPW]
wAQDz,cG`2:;9Zwv${}9J a,Eޒ3ec6)xe/-.8eNR q{BS
1Dz+Rr~X1tɤė 5/1vymd-MM3-SYq⅗#v 'Vcm~ '#Sʌ;ga > Tr:p-:WbvyS`IL住wP%Yw)_v9`㹮e hZ#hBOnо:wT륏fV˥[f J[qA,M\ZBs[/Iwpt
ju:^nľKO58whcy9>[McDOyWU]a|s>&%!H !@@!D
孠XJ[v
P 2?jRZflkmQ
Z,2bNksr4zgY{ 묽Z߂m ?ôq־ԇh"c㊢>ASN1cm,*4"'Zt0!Q=`/ b70VBN<8X
[4oJel^Iwh+wK7MZJ!'HDl
ޫIoxr~sB:&k.kƚ7jSi^xL!0I-t)EN@cv"GG@ɥwXBƕ7 a&KqppS2}|-wm]ʐ/܉| |W^%65Ag4o4?Jt]Ǵ'##ߖ
lU`˷S@U" =/
F[9'Yp,KwTy,=$u.k=gB
R y
U᳣9{'v,~S@ )K;):mH=:Uzk%浑 k 4a5[t^Ɵ t꓀ꑊܖ{]I?Oam
쒰M
ԋ
k#U_l2 jTjTN{lwb}@=!yu~ pa`9)z92W~ j 'NǙk07 ߦ׃wmm\V{{rƝ'Zt $fy
ks{Wv0H_3]LsR`~9 o" z3Uڃ\0dx+8{t,J>\m
?<-9Yt'tG@ >t
Q =Y[MƠ6Tohs$IOy9r&'r)*k6R jN[
v xH% \Δ*TL |7:qy X2]ָn7A2!K;ݼiIWLj"S3cC%<+YrZtep ZF)~gɊ~L_ ^Ԙr<^W럥H,u5eH7?hcҞo4ZQ9yԼy&c k56=KS$KA]B6GNH F#TBʠL 1
=&yh]3G,+fi6;d AN&URj eҕ&?\zO#uK :%2[;.CHx`&=7UA <`^ftŧ
a'm%&8!#5]GITķK) \/&i]'Dk)g7&3pm9SwC~6XDsѱzt=pO4vXzVʓmq0W.l,)EAyV k$Ў8S:0_rm 9{PzMf,'ҟ3.֗LG26$:DF*e YUg+s?CΛw?Yɸbign*R 9 b!ټy+gMO͗qΫcɱ`~+zl :_PviHOt\
Dߗ;8>2Լ
%~V_D+b
6&
}1ɍ͑?$+hkDzcs%;~8}NJ4O:;G[o/mc96A؎gEL"FZqѷmxʩ2W1 K Kbf
~R%tJIyKsxk
297Hɷ.Ux0/>pxqXq DV'<Kl6^ngOu2?{RʜDwtQ,l@1Vrc2$wdLl=2&:aK轩
. {% Q<~6u]q9 ,2H}QH$t
!H)rH&~ILl?琢&$
꺡vK:QtP[D*bZ 6e e[YI kIQ&s9y]hSU n.N_C^9sq:|'s))>LUН.% w|E@ u
_-}^ w 1je8uZp,?KX ÕsWAkquN"0F 7/3tjf..`^2: !| ]ȷ..=An'˽/u ۩r y;dYd^^N0v+!2ytx&x}.XЁ8op9oh=1 B>]! k^ G hxmσ~ Ϥ n'Ԁv-cHPK{%|>M [9DߤdYrtQO:@ff?%ig?D
_Ew&Sɦۘ#ZY䧐 a;F>w|'#k@%W".w>V^" kNƪQ j= &z&DeZ-m=ǏNk!jK bJŏ%ѓ|m
=D ǰ*Itb /)
BP(
BP(
BP(
BP(
BP(
BP(
BP(
BP(
B~ϩf:D丮 P2@JQJfu9G,kZz,6khi`L-F
E[-NeE KgXAt^$N>j
-HCA m2{TO1sꂭ dʚ>҉6zai9z `{pk`('KW@5:FH-Ǽ!#Ӡvj
hI!*zd,8 d$c~ ) >=)iB < ƚDt_Bv:1tDZQ-vOcQ4 i.Hg"" v1(aC#HIo3RI#JGD b+?6yn}z;mzoJ I=}Pnjh
j!P,9B u1mCS O -x _HAZF^'vy-cfZo1{zu@0 4rsbW۷AIP82~̮O0LK<)dz |luo 'F^d3N7U}O -n3{|{ʱא=geouP^W `ߧ10N\( t {u. @CdE>7(Jv
vC~}S߃X}lHK[rA`ЎB; ' `19ӫ>x^"\+3~zo! EGQDn4F
mFmֳA"31)rYnCM]Ϡ Gaıۓg j5!ͬ/toVmBq!,muճ JUV.K0=* h gV{`;)^Be1 ZC 0cx.76\qg3K+}.fi(A0f?ҋۭ 4
xgQz-OHЄ~a2o=
&`b38&
מд3QB"6x쌡ɠ&J,]<j./+sw<|:`T]?[d~ :6 ԇg}c,
66
FWxll,ďg ރϻܻi+v-<[VKLk 4Ôj@5m@y~@Nv]S Qer_FlBIpk
fhڭI凤r3|TL*ʃIo l ke(Sį0 `і!QFKOa 70l9u(r Ȅ>R#XN) $
R7Hf
hfh+:_՟AmJTbfq?F`N@)2YWxO1 NdV(Qm ɮFŇ ;sI{9@
&{(/a
r$$#X4663^l
RKv{"8GSK0} _rYyO" UrŬIl8WR샖ɢyQճVy]%֡ #%: ;>{vZ ;mA1l~O _Z R5:.ȱp7j0sd#^6#WlS,>qM;Ą^\'J-RLZ%5KM$ RH$$V}*( !!v (9%vrp-.rf^í+{-KCW1-{<,Q:ƝG_l="r'aIQ?ehxev8wB;G__qwYnv箿s8? r27M/㧹C=ԏv2r C%*[B*!/1.&未E~*u> JA 5D dbR*QOyf,Yd먨 1u* ,p'xHgut:Ѵ5N<&/_;PMj+xx" F X(>Fy|ҿM:ITNjw ix\sۛI'sڸ-uv$hy.ai-riy{rd;J('7(%vG%϶]!
oֲFC
&U6Bg%.್P ܫ,I wnKRDR1 ˕8sa&]ѼoVη a6ͅ)}}j.4
sP֩ww΅FtNBvx}y;vٺjqSuܚprYrc: WgEU5~X Gaí ×6:.ULGGX$ؑHx<;4?ȏax
ĭ=@ak W/\> _ %P 9!<- d[ DVרRic!<琈z>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 3/Type/Page>>
endobj
44 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(02-03186.a1)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(omputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archive\
d%20-%20HTML/02-03186.a1.html)Tj
49.073 0 Td
([6/24/2021 10:48:07 AM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 353.25 591.75 412.5 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm
(Administrative Judge)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 729.75 Tm
(Member, Appeal Board)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Signed: Michael D. Hipple)Tj
ET
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 16 703.5 cm
0 0 m
129.311 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 678.75 Tm
(Michael D. Hipple)Tj
T*
(Administrative Judge)Tj
T*
(Member, Appeal Board)Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
14.115 -2.125 Td
(Separate Opinion of Member William S. Fields)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
-14.115 -2.125 Td
(I agree with the Board's conclusion that the Administrative Judge's find\
ing that Applicant had stopped his alcohol)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(consumption completely after about July )Tj
16.58 0 Td
(2003 is sustainable. )Tj
8.11 0 Td
(I also agree with their conclusion that the Judge erred in)Tj
-24.69 -1.125 Td
(finding that Applicant's supervisor was aware of the government's securi\
ty )Tj
30.075 0 Td
(concerns and that the error is material.)Tj
-30.075 -1.125 Td
(However, I disagree with the Board's conclusion that the other issues ra\
ised by Department Counsel are not ripe for)Tj
T*
(consideration. )Tj
5.887 0 Td
(I would address those issues, rather than remand the case.)Tj
-5.887 -2.125 Td
(Signed: William S. Fields)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 16 496.5 cm
0 0 m
124.002 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 471.75 Tm
(William S. Fields)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Administrative Judge)Tj
T*
(Member, Appeal Board)Tj
T*
(1. )Tj
(Department Counsel argues on appeal that Applicant provided no informati\
on as to when he abstained from drinking)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(or whether he has continued to abstain from drinking, and that there is \
no evidence of any participation in any alcohol)Tj
T*
(support groups or lifestyle changes supportive of alcohol abstinence.)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
15 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 2/Type/Page>>
endobj
45 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(02-03186.a1)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(omputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archive\
d%20-%20HTML/02-03186.a1.html)Tj
49.073 0 Td
([6/24/2021 10:48:07 AM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 745.5 Tm
(1. )Tj
(Whether record evidence supports the Administrative Judge's finding that\
Applicant stopped his alcohol consumption)Tj
ET
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 28 744.75 cm
0 0 m
564.369 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 732 Tm
(completely after about July 2003)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 16 731.25 cm
0 0 m
157.957 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 173.957 732 Tm
(. We )Tj
(need not agree with the Judge to conclude that the Judge's finding here \
is)Tj
-13.163 -1.125 Td
(supported by such relevant evidence as a reasonable mind might accept as\
adequate to )Tj
34.709 0 Td
(support the conclusion that)Tj
-34.709 -1.125 Td
(Applicant stopped consuming alcoholic beverages sometime after July 2003\
. )Tj
30.992 0 Td
(Directive \266 E3.1.32.1. )Tj
9.034 0 Td
(Significantly, in this)Tj
-40.026 -1.125 Td
(case, )Tj
(Applicant's honesty was not placed in issue, and the Judge was not requi\
red to engage in a critical evaluation of)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(Applicant's statements and denials. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
14.26 0 Td
(See)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
( ISCR )Tj
(Case No. 99-0005 at 3 \(App. Bd. Apr. 19, 2000\). )Tj
(While Department)Tj
-14.26 -1.125 Td
(Counsel's interpretation of record evidence might also be plausible, the\
Administrative )Tj
34.893 0 Td
(Judge was not compelled to)Tj
-34.893 -1.125 Td
(follow that interpretation of events.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(2. )Tj
(Whether record evidence supports the Administrative Judge's finding that\
Applicant's supervisor was aware of the)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 28 624.75 cm
0 0 m
547.5 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 612 Tm
(government's security concerns)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 16 611.25 cm
0 0 m
150.779 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 166.7793 612 Tm
(. )Tj
(In )Tj
(explaining his favorable security clearance determination for Applicant,\
the)Tj
-12.565 -1.125 Td
(Administrative Judge stated that the "most compelling is the letter of )Tj
27.764 0 Td
(recommendation from his supervisor, who is aware)Tj
-27.764 -1.125 Td
(of the Government's concerns." Department Counsel argues that the record\
lacks any evidence that the )Tj
41.24 0 Td
(supervisor was)Tj
-41.24 -1.125 Td
(aware of the government's security concerns.)Tj
T*
(We agree with Department Counsel that the letter from Applicant's superv\
isor is insufficient to demonstrate that the)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(supervisor was aware of the reasons for the )Tj
17.549 0 Td
(government's security concerns or of the Applicant's alcohol-related arr\
ests)Tj
-17.549 -1.125 Td
(and counseling. )Tj
6.526 0 Td
(Moreover, such knowledge is not indicated in any other document )Tj
26.743 0 Td
(in the record. The supervisor's letter)Tj
-33.27 -1.125 Td
(merely states that he was aware that "the security clearance process" fo\
r Applicant "is at risk for not going to)Tj
T*
(completion." )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
5.407 0 Td
(See)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
( Item 9 of Applicant's Response to FORM. The Administrative Judge's find\
ing that the supervisor was)Tj
-5.407 -1.125 Td
(aware of the government's security concerns is )Tj
18.923 0 Td
(strained and speculative, and this is not a reasonable basis on which to\
)Tj
-18.923 -1.125 Td
(predicate this finding.)Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
7.156 -2.125 Td
(Whether the Record Supports the Administrative Judge's Ultimate Conclusi\
ons)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
-7.156 -2.125 Td
(The Appeal Board may reverse the Administrative Judge's decision to gran\
t, deny, or revoke a security clearance if it is)Tj
T*
(arbitrary, capricious, or contrary to law. )Tj
16.188 0 Td
(Directive \266 E3.1.32.3. The Board does not review a case )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
22.779 0 Td
(de novo; )Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
(rather, it)Tj
-38.967 -1.125 Td
(addresses the material issues raised by the parties to determine whether\
there is )Tj
31.906 0 Td
(factual or legal error. )Tj
8.689 0 Td
(There is no)Tj
-40.595 -1.125 Td
(presumption of error below, and the appealing party must raise claims of\
error with specificity and identify how the)Tj
T*
(Administrative Judge committed factual or legal error. )Tj
22.048 0 Td
(Directive \266 E3.1.32. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
8.284 0 Td
(See also)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
( ISCR Case No. 00-0050 at 2-3)Tj
-30.333 -1.125 Td
(\(App. Bd. Jul. 23, 2001\) \(discussing )Tj
(reasons why party must raise claims of error with specificity\). Our sco\
pe of review)Tj
T*
(under this standard is narrow, and the Board may not substitute its judg\
ment )Tj
30.773 0 Td
(for that of the Administrative Judge.)Tj
-30.773 -2.125 Td
(In the case before us, the Department Counsel has demonstrated factual e\
rror in the Administrative Judge's finding that)Tj
T*
(the supervisor was aware of the )Tj
12.884 0 Td
(government's security concerns. )Tj
13.065 0 Td
(When an appealing party demonstrates factual error,)Tj
-25.949 -1.125 Td
(the Board must consider whether: \(a\) the error is harmful or harmless;\
\(b\) )Tj
29.685 0 Td
(the non-appealing party made a persuasive)Tj
-29.685 -1.125 Td
(argument for how the Administrative Judge's decision can be affirmed on \
alternate grounds; and \(c\) if the)Tj
T*
(Administrative Judge's decision cannot be affirmed, should the case be r\
eversed or remanded. )Tj
37.751 0 Td
(Here the Judge stated that)Tj
-37.751 -1.125 Td
(the supervisor's knowledge of the )Tj
13.649 0 Td
(government's security concerns was a "compelling" factor in his ultimate\
security)Tj
-13.649 -1.125 Td
(clearance decision. )Tj
7.856 0 Td
(Considering the critical role of such knowledge in the )Tj
21.744 0 Td
(Judge's ultimate security clearance)Tj
-29.601 -1.125 Td
(determination, the Judge's error must be considered material and warrant\
s remand of this case.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(The issues raised by Department Counsel as to Alcohol Consumption Mitiga\
ting Conditions 2 and 3 \(Directive \266\266)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(E2.A7.1.3.2 and E2.A7.1.3.3\), and the )Tj
15.608 0 Td
(Administrative Judge's overall mitigation of security concerns, are not \
ripe for)Tj
-15.608 -1.125 Td
(consideration at this time.)Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
22.823 -2.125 Td
(Order)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
-22.823 -2.125 Td
(The judgment of the Administrative Judge granting Applicant a clearance \
is REMANDED.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Signed: Michael Y. Ra'anan)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 16 83.25 cm
0 0 m
134.795 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 58.5 Tm
(Michael Y. Ra'anan)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
14 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 1/Type/Page>>
endobj
46 0 obj
[48 0 R]
endobj
47 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(02-03186.a1)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(omputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archive\
d%20-%20HTML/02-03186.a1.html)Tj
49.073 0 Td
([6/24/2021 10:48:07 AM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm
(approximately $150.00. )Tj
9.776 0 Td
(His driving privileges were suspended for six months, and he was )Tj
26.551 0 Td
(ordered to have an alcohol)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm
(evaluation. )Tj
4.665 0 Td
(Count 2 was dismissed.)Tj
-4.665 -2.125 Td
(Applicant had an alcohol evaluation, in which it was recommended that he\
receive alcohol counseling. )Tj
41.292 0 Td
(He attended)Tj
-41.292 -1.125 Td
(weekly group alcohol counseling from May )Tj
17.773 0 Td
(1994 to October 1994.)Tj
-17.773 -2.125 Td
(Applicant was arrested on January 19,1997 and charged with Obstructing a\
n Officer. )Tj
34.211 0 Td
(He pleaded guilty and was fined)Tj
-34.211 -1.125 Td
(approximately $271.00. He had )Tj
12.886 0 Td
(consumed alcohol prior to the arrest.)Tj
-12.886 -2.125 Td
(Applicant was arrested on March 1998 and charged with Public Intoxicatio\
n. )Tj
31.047 0 Td
(He pleaded guilty and was fined)Tj
-31.047 -1.125 Td
(approximately $90.00.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Applicant was arrested on March 18, 2000 and charged with \(1\) Driving \
Under the Influence of Alcohol and \(2\) Hit and)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(Run. )Tj
(He pleaded guilty to Count 1 and )Tj
15.692 0 Td
(was sentenced to ten days in jail. )Tj
13.385 0 Td
(He was placed on Probation for one year and)Tj
-29.078 -1.125 Td
(was fined approximately $1,101.99. )Tj
14.636 0 Td
(Count 2 was dismissed.)Tj
-14.636 -2.125 Td
(Applicant received outpatient alcohol group counseling treatment from Ju\
ne 3, 2000 to August 8, 2000. )Tj
41.657 0 Td
(He was advised)Tj
-41.657 -1.125 Td
(to abstain from consuming alcohol )Tj
14.136 0 Td
(during his counseling period.)Tj
-14.136 -2.125 Td
(Applicant has had four alcohol-related arrests, in 1994, 1997, 1998, and\
2000. )Tj
31.464 0 Td
(In a 1999 sworn statement given to an)Tj
-31.464 -1.125 Td
(agent of the Defense Security Service )Tj
15.327 0 Td
(\(DSS\), Applicant stated that he had: "no drinking/driving incidents si\
nce [his)Tj
-15.327 -1.125 Td
(1994 arrest]." )Tj
(Notwithstanding this 1999 claim, he was arrested again the )Tj
29.595 0 Td
(following year, in March 2000, for Driving)Tj
-29.595 -1.125 Td
(Under the Influence of Alcohol. )Tj
13.051 0 Td
(This last arrest occurred after Applicant had submitted an application i\
n November)Tj
-13.051 -1.125 Td
(1998 to obtain a DoD security clearance.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(As of his July 12, 2002, sworn statement, he did not have a drink of cho\
ice, but liked variety. )Tj
37.493 0 Td
("I usually go out one night)Tj
-37.493 -1.125 Td
(a week to a club and have )Tj
10.579 0 Td
(approximately three to six drinks. )Tj
13.719 0 Td
(I also drink at home three nights a week and have two to)Tj
-24.298 -1.125 Td
(five drinks. )Tj
(I consume alcohol in the evenings.")Tj
T*
(Applicant apparently slowed his consumption of alcohol after his 2000 ar\
rest and treatment, and then stopped)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(completely after about July 2003, some two years )Tj
20.134 0 Td
(ago. )Tj
(He has now "shunned drinking." The file does not contain any)Tj
-20.134 -1.375 Td
(indication of arrests or other alcohol-related problems since 2000.)Tj
0 0 0.933 rg
9.75 0 0 9.75 332.2305 350.25 Tm
( \(1\))Tj
ET
0 0 0.933 RG
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 332.2305 349.5 cm
0 0 m
13.806 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 320.25 Tm
(The Director of Programs at Applicant's employing company says: "[He] ha\
s been a reliable and honest employee at all)Tj
T*
(times during his three-year tenure . . . )Tj
15.245 0 Td
(His work ethic is beyond reproach, )Tj
14.246 0 Td
(and his scientific and professional integrity are)Tj
-29.491 -1.125 Td
(at the highest levels. )Tj
8.415 0 Td
(As [Applicant's] supervisor, I unreservedly )Tj
(recommend him for this level of clearance."Applicant)Tj
-8.415 -1.125 Td
(has received a letter of recognition from work in 2002 and an award in 2\
003.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(B. Discussion)Tj
T*
(When an Administrative Judge's factual findings are challenged, the Boar\
d must determine whether "[t]he)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(Administrative Judge's findings of fact are supported )Tj
21.425 0 Td
(by such relevant evidence as a reasonable mind might accept as)Tj
-21.425 -1.125 Td
(adequate to support a conclusion in light of all the contrary evidence i\
n the same record. )Tj
35.516 0 Td
(In )Tj
(making this review, the)Tj
-35.516 -1.125 Td
(Appeal Board shall give deference to the credibility determinations of t\
he Administrative Judge." )Tj
39.174 0 Td
(Directive, Additional)Tj
-39.174 -1.125 Td
(Procedural )Tj
4.582 0 Td
(Guidance, Item E3.1.32.1. )Tj
10.775 0 Td
(The Board must consider not only whether there is record evidence suppor\
ting a)Tj
-15.356 -1.125 Td
(Judge's findings, but also whether there is evidence )Tj
20.758 0 Td
(that fairly detracts from the weight of the evidence supporting those)Tj
-20.758 -1.125 Td
(findings, and whether the Judge's findings reflect a reasonable interpre\
tation of the record )Tj
36.112 0 Td
(evidence as a whole.)Tj
-36.112 -1.125 Td
(Although a Judge's credibility determination is not immune from review, \
the party challenging a Judge's credibility)Tj
T*
(determination has a )Tj
8.081 0 Td
(heavy burden on appeal. )Tj
10.024 0 Td
(In security clearance decisions decided on the written record without a)Tj
-18.104 -1.125 Td
(hearing, the Administrative Judge does not have the same )Tj
23.327 0 Td
(opportunity to observe personally Applicant's demeanor as he)Tj
-23.327 -1.125 Td
(would in a hearing, and accordingly, less deference is accorded to the J\
udge's credibility )Tj
35.557 0 Td
(determination in such)Tj
-35.557 -1.125 Td
(circumstances. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
6.164 0 Td
(See)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
( ISCR Case No. 99-0005 at 2-3 \(App. Bd. Apr. 19, 2000\). )Tj
(In such cases, the Judge must look at the)Tj
-6.164 -1.125 Td
(record for )Tj
(corroboration of Applicant's testimony.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(There are two factual-related issues in dispute. )Tj
18.881 0 Td
(They are:)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
48 0 obj
<>/BS<