%PDF-1.6 % 1 0 obj <> endobj 2 0 obj <>stream 2021-07-02T15:27:45-04:00 2021-07-02T15:27:44-04:00 2021-07-02T15:27:45-04:00 Adobe Acrobat 17.0 application/pdf 04-03720.a1 uuid:96370470-5132-4e82-b1e9-a2262c0da9c6 uuid:46b1f062-4020-4a4e-929d-8fd4993ebe08 Acrobat Web Capture 15.0 endstream endobj 5 0 obj <> endobj 6 0 obj <> endobj 3 0 obj <> endobj 7 0 obj <> endobj 8 0 obj <> endobj 17 0 obj <>>> endobj 18 0 obj <> endobj 19 0 obj <> endobj 21 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 22 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 23 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 24 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 20 0 obj <><><><><><>]/P 18 0 R/Pg 13 0 R/S/Article>> endobj 13 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 0/Type/Page>> endobj 25 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (04-03720.a1)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\ ved%20-%20HTML/04-03720.a1.html)Tj 50.24 0 Td ([7/2/2021 3:27:44 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 734.2497 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 579.749 0 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 733.5 cm 0 0 m -0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 578.25 0 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 732.7503 cm 0 0 m 0.75 0.75 l 0 1.499 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 733.5 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 0.75 0.75 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 618.75 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 579.749 0 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 618.0003 cm 0 0 m -0.75 -0.751 l 579 -0.751 l 578.25 0 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 617.2497 cm 0 0 m 0.75 0.751 l 0 1.5 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 618.0003 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.751 l 0.75 0.75 l h f Q /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 749.25 Tm (DATE: June 14, 2006)Tj 0 -3.25 TD (In Re:)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (---------------)Tj T* (SSN:-------------)Tj T* (Applicant for Security Clearance)Tj 0 -3.25 TD (ISCR Case No. 04-03720)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 17.628 -2.125 Td (APPEAL BOARD DECISION)Tj 2.806 -2.125 Td (APPEARANCES)Tj ET 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 261.2061 543 cm 0 0 m 89.338 0 l h S Q BT 11.25 0 0 11.25 251.0312 519 Tm (FOR GOVERNMENT)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -3.068 -2.2 Td (Melvin A. Howry, Department Counsel)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 3.846 -2.2 Td (FOR APPLICANT)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 2.722 -2.2 Td (Pro Se)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 16 419.25 Tm (The Defense Office of Hearings and Appeals \(DOHA\) declined to grant Ap\ plicant a security clearance. )Tj 41.649 0 Td (On April 1,)Tj -41.649 -1.125 Td (2005, DOHA issued a statement of reasons)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (advising Applicant of the basis for that decision--security concerns rai\ sed)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (under Guideline B \(Foreign Influence\) of Department of Defense Directi\ ve 5220.6)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 33.322 0 Td (\(Jan. 2, 1992\), as amended)Tj -33.322 -1.125 Td (\(Directive\). )Tj 4.886 0 Td (Applicant requested a decision based on the written record. )Tj 23.936 0 Td (On November 30, 2005, Administrative Judge)Tj -28.822 -1.125 Td (Shari Dam)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (granted Applicant's request for a security clearance. )Tj 25.503 0 Td (Department Counsel timely appealed pursuant to the)Tj -25.503 -1.125 Td (Directive \266\266 E3.1.28 and E3.1.30.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Department Counsel raised the following issues on appeal: whether the Ad\ ministrative Judge's application of Foreign)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (Influence Mitigating Condition 1 is)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 14.415 0 Td (arbitrary, capricious or contrary to law; whether the Administrative Jud\ ge's)Tj -14.415 -1.125 Td (application of Foreign Influence Mitigating Condition 5 is arbitrary, ca\ pricious or)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 32.937 0 Td (contrary to law; and whether the)Tj -32.937 -1.125 Td (Administrative Judge's overall favorable security clearance decision is \ arbitrary and capricious in light of the record)Tj T* (evidence.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 8.128 -2.125 Td (Whether the Record Supports the Administrative Judge's Factual Findings)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -8.128 -2.125 Td (A. Facts)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (The Administrative Judge made the following dispositive findings of fact\ :)Tj T* (Applicant was born in Taiwan in 1969. )Tj 15.886 0 Td (At the age of 11, Applicant left Taiwan to come to the United States on \ a student)Tj -15.886 -1.125 Td (visa. )Tj (After arriving here in 1981, he)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 14.579 0 Td (stayed with his uncle until 1983, when his father, mother, sister and br\ other arrived)Tj -14.579 -1.125 Td (as legal alien residents. )Tj 9.524 0 Td (Applicant's mother became a naturalized United)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 19.506 0 Td (States citizen in 1989, he and his sister in 1990,)Tj -29.03 -1.125 Td (and his brother in 1993. )Tj 9.776 0 Td (All of these relatives continue to reside in the United States.)Tj 24.021 0 Td ( )Tj (Applicant's 66-year-old)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 9.927 0 Td (father is a)Tj -43.725 -1.125 Td (legal permanent resident of the United States who maintains his Taiwanes\ e citizenship and residency. )Tj 40.904 0 Td (His father travels)Tj -40.904 -1.125 Td (back and forth to the United)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 11.497 0 Td (States several times a year because he owns a small business in Taiwan w\ hich provides)Tj -11.497 -1.125 Td (income to support his family. )Tj 11.999 0 Td (While in the United States, the father)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 15.106 0 Td (stays with Applicant for at least four months)Tj -27.105 -1.125 Td (annually. )Tj 3.943 0 Td (Eventually, Applicant's father intends to retire, apply for citizenship \ and live permanently in the United)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 41.584 0 Td (States.)Tj -45.528 -2.125 Td (Applicant attended an American university and graduated in June 1995. )Tj 28.963 0 Td (After graduating from college, Applicant)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 26 0 obj <> endobj 27 0 obj (~.J) endobj 28 0 obj <> endobj 29 0 obj <> endobj 30 0 obj <> endobj 35 0 obj <> endobj 36 0 obj <>stream H\j0 ~ Cqb>Xpl%3,qC~]:OHvϝ5{p:֠eQ[3N~["Ν%6]p[`uFmAH^3ϲC)ov _gӸx0H;!Y F2_\Tèe`NUEpTD|n2#L.s^c@ǂ@tدfz endstream endobj 37 0 obj <>stream H|XϙsfwaF`  %O1"*(*łB`-uXžuX%k\Ч}K{{7jA4oc[hxlXܒ̪!|LjZ4YQqc{DKph=8f|!#'@)ёa2Nh4,{FƏ{ՏEm1#`H!<~6.9 |^|x|@ʎ1: }H~ܨȸ64A>jtj(rEMnqx mnZЁNV}4:Xp5%_|p ssP TD$;VZz ]jשZ~nVT 7i3-ZiƷm:uݺE@_*(|?W|058za1Gč5:1cǍI$L9q3SRg͞37m Yxe|U32׬]gYO6nڼe;vڽg:\x'N*:}l1;_rp|rX$j&] AA4P ͢t^j,Hl.Cęb8W<&>_ uv}*gJmMQ)$eR(&R)FhGjhk eD]]^;kkk}}3}>L!x8yTPꤺjCSR[~jNSYuAݪQjzV7 ] pCaa]:Lc1h_m6_-n<3:;!<)&4aeR1fYR/lqX,VV WE(8( NrIr9ӻ 9jG'9+C" C9Pov55I[p`sqn ;J Dʋ񊯚r%0{wNr_`] p7ֶ6Vk+kKk ksgV/k3kkc~j́7n,,dXR,*vnԵc440ۛ}>&fŌ'Rtt-QS)ߔWGLkML=L]M]L&IgrUPcߌaA]˸r^`W2RG'YV0\ǘ7XGs?N\痜Мvs;%rY/ t1,0@*lXN!%(g0C})x%d8Ga# pH8 p N8Ep@P 0<!B2 !0 b!C:`40Ƃ?$yd-#x q.F `w2r~qUQFGU135ס0sp=np3n ELT܎;p'.q75܄[.amp?cx+lXa,Qx m jQz<SX z'hX<؃16pEL[h+mvRݴ>OEtS!t :IN Otb:G穄.ED ]kBLddtnmCwݧdJ1FO)3zN/%^QM)+tA3)yIz;+\zMo-Adg c"s`&19**PY jZ̙%W*^CԎk:̏ub ʺɾ`R{Qj#ݗHVH*KIOrުjjFƨp"UƩ*ZMP$5ͮ覺n[薺n~_6nvjڭjگ::nnNNy&wL</5R[N$^$>T8J8rI"&4J#Bȧ2R&Q2S*QVF)\PTL~>Q\$T S @ u{Aw=FtzJBE)Qq*A%2Sh SERq4iMI9M)z^zީdޫ>/`b%+fX4lsZN9gLpVf윃sr.y8/MSi]p>7֍\wD7 r!.EEb@`Ÿ8pKe[\Ksw]0.cDk: T rbDg&Fy"F#"B fd6-fffev=條lة撹lfoivagYvc<#</o|'9h戹in掹kc枹j?ϏqB?֏?O%R_W5Zo7-V?|t8G'nrЏ>?_7N*ÿ{{ ("kKd (3 jD bD;JlRb8#1M5c%Ǵ>*MI&ښѦ1jL=Mqn7 yo}'GcO ?9~^}b /6SK7etyEDwv]D4zfA!`JbӉj.b{t Q! P6ri4e\B24 u`EDH١6cJ~yL^6))JV+Xo9aQ&d\D14 8$P5nW0N IOTHM91uۄC68=Gѯ=b rCt, f5r]b2exsHH:x7^@I'LpbZp]Qm`2rvEѪ^To/U`^o=AIviG,΅u"WfQ>?8`;0f}alrJ!Wk-:*e>{J߯w,b;OA^T#tP[qX*S~N`58pȶ_45,jd 9'` AނT [@]i/ri6`,[hJnW~@ `- mŝ7~ܜcFg>1rDaCS?i~*>.6&:j@d~}}z R]zG3<u݋c CCSc =92#y]#zF26Ƥj.]3N9u,qs^@yc͆ +ʩ̣U>ljz:tдTj b/(}iare5q PFt1Ӕ.oQ\v9lҴT9p{`9AFojC#f+Ux+J,!}iD|*pxokf{I3(q?k3XsybǗL#F *]J]fgf*3hjؼ+|ݺȍK䛺@LdOZjo5wz=^(=dDz!hĭCL37|s21 RYF%0qx|,[h5=Ox[,_T6v#%Ō 9zFZf~Y_jb7f m6ӫcmQE~j/59'rٳQOt=xBi'[D 6t/tk.۶Eӟugu&3JX˺JKز-ɶ@68АP4I PAL?4g&3`OICzL I)m2q::i&>[$}{~{߾M{(0[_&0ʄUr@EՃQwU砢 -T'' p,+2|7W D`"byg.ZΫ!{;uelFZRƐ)byYҹj& N!@:,8rƅ;ٹza:1E9 4+!hA=9+k ID)`0(P j!Z͙'mXhswU`;`;h;a;;i{Em\;-]%kj0g8k}lٰǙk"b}H4`,Vl5L&s5"ގ|t6c9S,j6 n-<4U)ɍ[r׻eSܬHF69L1}8;x\ s8oK rL7tT~qE&*,8H % _kY! i-Ǵf;XsSSsSseS:4ɇ{Zבmw;*3.rsz ?Z?_B!,-Pn<7. a>sF[r{ʐ S|x"F׆k5UUm=GGLo&ZKp@FJ7Fxϣ|^oϑ;f)R(_SpØEyl1hif &X9~?h,dRTX2OXȗKH8? @B0@|AyLÑ0k0`FZ6XʨH8jJ`73g7v|G6 ['Mξ' s_3m֮y/x tt 9p`*Sr6+~S슾ex#k%Z+0䂺$ԭP5t΢ct|o!LF7`BEr%q/jExN)Gd,Cvl/*|1js~kh&=36kqX҃xCuGv4;Y/v^-`lt^P}3s,| 1ܕOumKuղRLm-u]۟WCxK[b׽#Btgbkxzc+ƌ}m^i!plFzU*{PT`2p##ֹZ-ܘN1j a&Z-LF S>Nй<PU-뱠.>ezj>C|f!7̕bTRRaaĨ_l8~߅?={t}%Z4t#= _#?0s x,UqcIv]ow}>`+R5@;/BGeu:8.?Xѐ0 H:U#4KDKr5Sr o&r p#9xL:X(E+t\B t~JOaa XVNu8RDz>q bet|I(Q )j-vd*2(s:vl\ؑCE?R)*k?Y/Vf@σ= ?e}hGƽ To=3MsDA*'zgU]޽R(%"6րASb2R6UKYRjI:(%-aȄ 2脭0NBb߹{_<]=lŮJϣI3Rw"ts?cBT0r2S7 kd@ oPvXȮ?;w9;t DF/سe r5ՓvgBֳv%Ohr787h .VBW{t.92svQo'J%jUX+z߂u<{*F]07%͠.$ΥfsF1@Kp>-wː_sE{ޭ2w/z5W6|)2Xx܇}1(6A(N1?40,*6#bbb9ml$ :Lf^_fxkm,39T(ءؾȪRGWDF^[=qcΔ`E}]D 9Q Hj8ݣGKo3>g+5 S'HPՂpSNMBp,)O%)?VXwcN M #>M`1p\Wku ,ةgA r$ϭe^=cɜL!:Յذ)dJ*0ZTPk:~O9|MqqxbKUNJ<uS;|^zpH!61RO9=>ɧMh9Fuj2R' c" ﵫibhުċܛ({5ߍ{_D=$u]9<_- țTېh=ɫIw=|Ry0/R]J;OiQ?F.kYU]'TjV̋Aޞb5zr26&C֕yrq\:Gؕ|u(=10 CQR`=.-߽LqQeKwXRnK^hvӁ1.,ukXn28?p7G`0gX'k߈+H]1k='yK]sKҼSwKNR E\_C6d_~9gʁXHl&qUbS'><.qMrjzcmx&TS G,>?m_.*uÏ)7tw@^ ˜xy=A5 /4ڼK I_%Dd{yLm>ag3 Yv> 㟎CWt 0WGh6  CqMT{JhO hj О|@{є;NcDhn<0 @]z_n3%ZRd)ڛY-чZ˝ K u#_Cׁ^(};`o~|? FCZ7RcwG3zcPOJV[jk"Wԝ>t=٥*f_'ӁJm<W}pU{Ϲ%)5 BD J( 8ȇiH W"2|)UD0R# #PEJAX"VMxyf?lf~w=={v ` `k'yypW{# Pj[ 7oօAȕzp *yJD/&C]*qvPS5Ro:]NKiۅG˷pjoС_L&yv&RäW5=jI|Gز2oP(1NC(Լ9'n .'ufqnr"7'rz:dӌ}˸4-t'o;(!~Ms+3|gDǵgsy ݀4qp4OQ wr͕žs2WS^Gnb?q.> g>MQ #&XҬsH+\ ^Y\R`P{1q0DxTo|S`?>}#n+#g pSw' j|3-[%P"ފ ?Þ _2G-j_BFd/W _;jcpl $ <. bZXG/O {Y{E)]侸\\0Q1\i&KՃ[VmR%W=u)?ܗp*=yE:# E|Q}C`R)3+1+.Q6is+(+h}oT_ru8O_"k=ݭu3OT[ Nݣ W| cĘ礧_fjm#5z!_Jt!}ʥL3>>>i}3q]ȗD_O? br+@ 4G86l 8SO&Q! KH!DWĠe@-@|2rjU/ۅ>ϗ!mv)Gqm aw>E)X !WS2}۠gė;DO]p8 | g,aKߋ|M􌛍CcRx;`3b,>S,{/0|G\uV4>|.UZƟ6ST΁hNUso.P9d0RWx^iQ!`[\ϧqO֋;m1 H__B^=ݓV|)ݮK9tOl2DAFĖX;bne{c]0D' E:} coX'f1g,ʩ*~ ag bÏ9{͞eLg5sY3p[ T0vACws|^7k>3=ƚgH=\$񗅳Ǟߊ?ݶ\&CWlؒAuD/~Cd-7 c2gW}X۱f`;)8'<=kuvŻL=9` (* :eEqgfgfW"nR B\p9\`#`X!$ r7"K@Hrɕ +VNaŠӳ߷RWot{P3 H/ReԻhȞ{ep"0qͻ:!YQ;д1CbO#f0=+yOg_az [CzCtIէe1o žV^| QwnMkH 2j yMx_hw{Lx|^6e߯N|z酒<"~=ҽ%OMˏcU[=֣[{h=}OA.'E[9o,=~]b gN9+b[a[!CuEjHSIm[lk^g8CyT5V@ D9*D%5n\5zQ3UzSYGm~;ê8)<{/)KxM_.1bnǘ! uȧtWzw'\@ߒ-dm؁q+"#9d~I(momϥH0~`L(#J7c`7QŅȦs CGu7{6۟ 9߯7xof͖fߕrNhs^7NW\1qK:=r3̾OY',$5>Ěc>2<y[-G۪W?=K xX*_~Dc,3ˡЫ37K~KA ~3S#`r_ƒH28O~ōL~?dx\2P_yl㢼g+M%87K֨!||;CuOɨ YoD?j%O˶/idpo hI҇P2xo)uT yGߣ } wA͹seu+9ykhtcELP'P͚W6' b'`*[^R4Sxw_}^,r0Zq/ͼƽYww9Uf*2_M_!oR!;G ǽh鮄NFg6c&s`t|軷O7AP[$tP;BwceOj%M[xoɃ[PJ5,sw`ǹJNuB{[q.rnN܄[+ih`bX,bX,bX,bX,bX,bX,bX,$Z5p4@w@wʂ5Ud$ cފh>1;@ 峦f5&f;h.cc]OrhFhFY Bg0#8Lƨ$16G5R 񗂮,ala?_4Y)j}ӑOfN 6~G٘~RJoi*5Cȇl0uSo6u+[ccܺ]d,d)Ʈ- KkA d&%&MLi2ɣf^1(UiifRJa:miizd&t2M;ӕ9{s^/CͰ-A;=9$x/gBFXi|G/w*,c`~jb ׌*''5$(kds.+> 6'xfA "p>2zK`S|*ٞXy~j[##zn*I/k$٣[eIڨ erOZ0-q},'']#mnyf/L1=QyX<2EFY98zF$X4)3FrV4ùь&Ƶc}l[1m4䬦ZjHǵ,i帖ei rD2ߺIC>=o \ȗ62r.khf 9_9D0G[秎ҁr8L LA8ԙS`Ub{a}91|%G-()ޚ]9!˨ QFx>zYDgf;E%; H:dU;fh xQx*r)yV.Uf לp\B+y[@|(ݜZ/̡[@DΣU%SZ] O+S䒹֭ɥSpa'PH@U2w;wkwK s)*"5I+zibuA I?$•yrap`) U<ΩUNX&*Hׅ[BQ<'L S#taBL)r\!`),TX#t =eoP|=wqsyEo1. voA1_@ׁ55$l@&xQ.@r ~w Vh&HDK– 9.$8gh?K{K~#8Q+Kq};Gsڄl_8~8d>IIIlүlҘMJ$&٤YRǾ) ?RWjJyͪ`7K/ DT) fKZM#͈vr5KdVդېLMh M{ wM₩⼩9<[ʄϚtDg X"i/4L,xMP~g 3 f0ȴxݴ@jڷCWP;OK|#G /cp2'AuLN},0s} |Taw=ى|tb<Gst,VR B4q&= d@;`EbzL dBo@O<&=WiCЏi(#t'I[mqqV&]*1V90)?XOXZY﷮Yﵮ.:V (VHo(j&*-[}5apDH9AtH0 a^g8o-ΰa}t` q1CI> endobj 34 0 obj <>stream H\j@{^htg+A/Cm & MXo99 a'_o7.M]$=wT뱍ٴpM[?>U}[z.+KyHWwjfKj4n>ֻ[.}'5zFOU\cݶvY߉kF}UkQrbҕ,3ͿقeCY,px28|:-3<{ Y9{. k?d Uz:{8{yyyyyyyyyyy ke'߃QQKKKKKKK+0W@\}|}|}|sقK]\M8>stream H|y\TG5o^p r7QѬ,kv57FݨAPTh$QQ/ED>fDu\5Ə&u1GS]U]^?!!gZԟ'OXlB$E'3@@P^Cʭ_uqɃZqqi#r3<86z/C| CR I)cM(('-Dkόz 8j&F'n{J62# v?yDlFB $kB^^,P_R>4$k4zI'I{W!=w4@<*9مZꌴrh6Z7? P=/DxmFE8%:O-_Au֫ߠaHb0U;7y"5Eܪu>KGm׾CN'{??{}ѻOٯh|306n! IC%12e1cǍI|35M>s9s_0kQvb.[_|U-k֮[/mXhs۶عk8xGJ;~g+p /]kVRu0c4MoF)L!RtiT K/>r3sG"L'a~3%|K\'3\*m֩uɐŏ,ZYYzC,|/eW[׹oMomw?d;?cD ]kdju@]4W=ss.]"HwhbčI4'q2!ƨtԭ,L&g_Пs'r-NdNTNtLڜ9yE>>v ;caw=>aq!88Gk8 GR:\uܐ{܈sp>.\p9 WShu溹}INy\t;ONS:eNST8ϝJS7fM)$\0x TC >Ԅ8!$A2@*kN+2FNcr@mȆȅ<ȇ:P`nrSn_!~ uԇAchM?a2 >)000!gX%XeX` d52ձ_XErdL$AQHKL%dL2|2d)2Cf,F!UT((jQ%S RSeR/)r((PՕe6գԀR#jLM)59̑ W5ԎSH3?ԅ>>S7N='ԇR?Oh 4Ʒ掹k)~'<2<3ŦĔ 9H R =2,Fih13KhZ|#9nNP9qI\7O(<'A1@l!_-y7{+9W 2 ʡC%*!DV )d]l%[˶}{Qv]ew[5p&Gɱr|S-ߑ\,?Sc>6CΊ9O.,fgQ r.wɽR~%yD yF^h$o˻H>%BV)beU5U]ŋ*Q42TrThjZ(PuRUUuSUSRUWS5P R5T SG}Wƨ 5Oz^5x^{^{kux=>o7&zd309fYdf`6fnvh{~~eow/0A `\Yan VaM6l;NaK5v&C=bc=aOS=cs`/K-WU{^7M{j%?Op.9BsչFUnub]"ܨ+]j]r]]]Z7p[ݭaM'$|,wtUg}Q~^H%\dCDJJ,EࡉRC4BWV:H B`Ù ,xvWx7ޝ;3w|׹,qWܣ0 w {#z 1[ASş(bdwCb )R(ZR㔈6Ԇ^@7=%ӛԁޢԉ:SJTJԍSJԋz~ԟh 4Dd9@}hQ4Ї4>i 4[$L44N ͠4fwwwwWBs3GsZ@ iQMMx:lH#<37C|sUwzfBޮUZJh9.VjZCYz@)6rL["Jh;}A;Kw.[;Mi}XECtPctr)NIʧ*"*StY*R*r:Gt^~=3='H?%LW{x_7JzmMN—`&d\+qf!tj膺n:P`L:T.FQ:E4#tnanj1>m5[ְ5-j`%km-[۾b_:gmQ:ZX{^tnaؽvo؃=l{mͳ'Io l-=mسĖ2[nيZ$ȅ<=YgPs NNf"sq:ǜN8-ΈD2Q.Ή q^\W5q]7/Rů̉v̅ު+Ȧ2P1SL*]d^ U;̐4Uu_ UOUʘ"D5yX2Lt>a,`g,b̔e2F8/[cD츯ߘ̨L&Fc(hyOu ̌`T W&BŘHkZxeU1&t]P73LPM1}BCC$t<+w b {>!kA0 G $gМ3l>R?o9A7[dP7<3w&a:rr`iĖPbl̞a*{`&.5~~eշ_9d|Kn%@%yȟ:n]f/n!w|t 86qA)}wU#?T# ` eqfBf,N%>eAlS`և_e"*mگy+T/yU?GDE/w^m%s|802FӸ9a)(ڗe"vo1<? O^7Ӂe}iq.ulq3nVy_ "J$Μ/ئwνq:ď 7'q'$<`@ ΫKؐҁ- S٨j[meRI9X4uuݪRMҮ͆&h%F}: ~Lu'rS.:M: &XލZLH_ >N'V/7Z557^Ǿ&ed9Fӄ0]e|^W1k_D/ނ{5d҃;|ވSh%.B EX=8t{uK$.9.ߌ4C;z} AJ/,%hJ^O'ΎNGX9҆^d5 z3=qZh!Iɯ;e B)vFS8/ab  SutH UmאP cd3Lb-kNcagpPЎz:|9#/aO]~0lX&_f˪VV,^T-+e%"Oat/ȳK6knN%,*",5oB㽬RY|MNb| J>_dpVHrrڵ0S5,.kрp.Š䈻?,k$!GPIqd%B} HZFHs$q%@]$s.*pD+`a]+tj-Hأ( zXQ h&iW$NrzYo׎u=>7v?BqP\S#YGUl*8Ej>Fl*n`")3MZm@N\og@5o,5b0 4GFMb T}uԡ~gi-+Pzׄ2}`̧tMSLe}A=NfC 3iK!"ЧZJAI?4mUh~E|$nDXsUF:g|h93 L6I'ЀeՊ]@xx(sd~o]p5#`IC.;4L{Y5afeغDo_~ 'vVnǓM":xDkxRIϲs.'rGr))eJS,bKqH5g9b')@sI2ER¨RivQEV[jCVb)dJybExNBnKAƹN Y8ϓ -AMM/) z[r̫yv}:nwC@oCPD 9ٱsslDZ㄀IܤЌ  Y\uw!,`"ih:hR&V *umlbRu.R-mjvCqX/}Ix>D?.If]RY%$4?b`.i~oY4Ʃ].'͌ A J1xBP8 2]nU2Qf"((^BU(\v"YTJSiTXZܢpR)" PŖ)؅z\}n=|/ufݞݷ]ӂM!8uc/ZM w>Hg;OɽTHL<@G *`oz1Ͱsr&%,]^tdF2cPz]8>MI?(bivN_Հ}#ٹs͒ @OhʘQPcT''5 Te8z eluLQGJf+g/Y+iy"3Eh{+iU[Cn(e0M{ܓOd^>nzb~}GRBa2ZpRmX lˊ,Oƅ g#RUo]mpdm٭^&1MQK{2 Dx szkm:LO @VM4Š)M/Lsa`GCpMM Ex2d0B-ZH&LkV0o"0cC6 m9\wn[z%/.­*lzݞw0} I4!;^hmS=66+x`o~ո_=s~^_?}}کQvWt]%6)>>PGI"hNTe2&VXA[@tm)TiDS42!G4u4qlMńsUt~7h37zt/63O+$ ]VU]UuIUU%|̈Q>|K>/j$)74<]Hfi;Yp9 bʗr8o"4*=3 h]Â{S,!-/~]~ y_7` ;-1;͡- lN[q#e!j%֛A&gx6E|) Up~ohPP/Mg99V}fOA֓N>5_8W5p} _mڲ"G}BbXn]'-2n'=cu#)c07ӓi= &P}H#Aytu ,q"{}o'~l뙜_LUub {r0,\_vJTj6 @vB臎K)+]4q{7KajPI5a"To(;f imvJBOsp'pRktol'9ۀ|{֭yu{Uĩ΢1ǣVeMZ \Cxι`NH2ɊV0AIэ qWh,`VQzU$AcH "֋Ik ;88:B2 Ǩn77Tl.^Q/m6詡k)ǜ~s{.a1Ea)Zp  Q,gqS9~=\}sLV/91"i,wVfnЉݾ ǫi WQ}ś;"TG6[H4DˠYTزнJA^2:hFjpBo7d|71MѿϿ%'Oww6vDAgUᓾY~6<佞')x@9eHK('!dVإ943V{Oa:yr}y>0$ˮ?*x6$N}1Ż7W~588LY6RBXԡv9 HD6XjU%*˧xƒ/nq~í-4s&jGzp3L$5] &d(+ PAþD' ||QFX^r8g ?υ*` ^+^z-XA6 J yf3!@9B\3F%)'W5~|\#ڷn=/vi\^lxu+-~:!a AߚB*?PQ)+<XXDw ױu#Hܐ <*Ȳ;Ce8 k D13S p2 Q3s_rkKvW6rR:Ȓ)#"ƅ@FD+M*$Q6F/l:}fJ D I`nBWJ҃5H:+nj#ǎ}m?TM(r ̋~ɅٓO/pjOZGadqaq^%Mȅܜs;;iD?n\dS'񻉻  z̰*h7a1~ddM:]>BN֍YCK0r aIi[]`QˑBAX mBSX,:]X3QlF5[9L[,@3Z%D5FE1nwERͶEĨȴm\gE"^(QߤCMʬ) eTL"^<9P^у Q ;hcﲏm<~;;'K0wŎpbH(P $ h"ڵ:ՠ c@a VPխj6&XVN*M4Y{&?|q]o3g ZkaQW_s }g6}&+Z˶@oWvi1B|欆CθzY+zcskUN۩ RolL܊ZGzzP9HQN2 370a]}Ʃk mW- Qݰ#pt QpfunUv1[QmߩܛrV y0憬ږ^έ\)ץ;N4}S6>@d6e^ֶo0L -vm/!}Y٭ɺIҪ(*EJ]5m_fO~2.Km5@=ۍξӲ *2G?Z3+ƢWx].!pSn]ݸp,/bv&Mr8^ x  )`&I'zeB  U4$SʊG-"#n.a } _xaaJg<C'xQ[Ooʙ|1gdg^6/\kHxs#Qh3 GV7UPU  Y1Žԏgv\5W|A5|wUtz$3/+^+Q/7z,T;fFeD}rQFx܌82axs’Mr>{]1˕GQI[?7<?Ǔ/'suc={*Ҟ@4,өyex}ZN{XmRc*48Īp2J~< v[&i'b|7Nj?0[y©A$9/ȑv؀9 |Un]¹87k[}< W$y3u~$`#fܨn Tx{_PGs:csFPHO S&&tk"Ci -.1+V _!0ݍ^_l;^,\{w쭗;@$Vsh.ib)e߉۸ 4OJqTjDZD3t'=*a=Ơm4N%QuKA6w\ jX1# f+3`Rm`;H"AQ.Q$Aq1LzzNkw񲲄gS"&Lfxqivadp7Jd;-Ti!7YtD\ "^Nia0]v6$֋\[Q kZ8 EHhIP%.fXO8z)GXQcD4l濄D~KQhK%`I=zq7%3/30WdVJnh c}#>t5%ummY-`Ι.,n*,(Ll5ќYt}<9ځ̘ nJ[c!otܔ1@ -hF Z B_j  69'˦ Nԫ-?$ز}4B˜6rՖO"T 1g,ᗓo-#fߴ$ӄd{g xu=uHp|v4H,97f-c8ocx8`xq͸eЃ4qGQhQ#I;"9Fr'yd`Cac8w>×;珳}sql#!!@(hc=AKhu(hEJRN0Ba`T ?1Im=]fs{BECB\˲3'pK ֑xmf tEUW|m>(ii Z`|Q̉t -${l`Zmdt=^̕baԯJ/62^5&*ϗV??p쌗l-#;ޟL޳y߅Sڜ>7'E;_ƧN<mx=* iy $QȂ,nWd5wmv[~VǮyu5p=x+p' %(N܇4 Q< {@F?hhӈ`a6/aXt h~買rdkڴrWR7!|Sȑ@ cEU5>_a  !pVڎDYh['H,i(5_rǾF͟xvnUϾ8/pټO[k|){HdO(PcneQsp;2ێ]_Կm#n$[F&#+qnKܼAfE0h7SrC@^iYSC f-FȮG g+'S#`YJN`cvA|{CPp+X-px\3S3S7 ?ν;$(bxiA&Пa^JOX^Kpr9v5(des|3@!fq Fu0b>zL!W1fInD3lcQu抪Qj)Eub2n 'ՖnjjIJ;FM7Ӳ_ljItWhpS[kEmA=i_D*gB2Q%zU $"{/K 2ZAvѵF5.Q逥HN!? 5S퉉/H yKֈ<2c.+y- THaQ*OW٥r"Ke`5E)P5{u` hGޕMkdumWڤ_Q) VD]d}76o\:;;'_gdHn>w7[S茮zkKC>J)7~sf뷋k']cڲ@a6I\#ˏ.7R8ƌ0@#z454=FhHp6F`FEM qtRu'K!VD0ZV·`xmV3gAU5%V_ 7'`"Q0RfUc΢vK2,b0tL!.u)EʩI ~YXJaAJO4P)BhD = 9r3RP84Q4yx(RKDM:a`B к ̊2R),j} ȯEӞA<Dgg^Uw?Y J^7Y]qh h\HqџŢĴZC ;_~G0gvYeYq?;r>ž}vrWriH.$+kJ:nԡ?V Iaj 5R^R#?۪PU!PǗ]N=~> Gke #-S,&}4t)/ZZ@cGenm. J0JbQ,]2ň[z/̔g"&1>,#%bY &?B\RJ vj,M.X{ W Iֵi휶+ڈ6%&@nO &$e~Mw=g]?pe߶EF ?9<,P,Pe)RpX {mZB "CzD),!C!-]m?H [9. 6qmasDN9iA Ui^ZnH _jn,( ?֎baez+IjG55KpCQҝ PJжTܣ^RԐΫz`\xGyvoR€cjik^ak(kli xv=Kz>ڑjND(8Tebe趦74[\dOdOtcԈl0{3aJp@j7 sыbr|_舅_{6{ s?' rQݓV q bGM8U|ag\gK+7rP꭬ r%SFfGnۻom}}2dGg02Ҋͤ љo%]tcHi2 nA.ΥMj.Lwoҡ$S?dhI TY bpELVt! 6;4e,SDBa62̅KI!z2)cː51e@.p"˸6d y]|1E.tŝm qdw$wۄwۄ'>nVt "DZF{^Cvvvt˳ukH'DC:ܚZ-Rb+z>z~z~満.` :Ч342lp^m<dRҩ)TNZN;=ON<1z{fp}z@3w z 0N^?v9<>br9?L m4eOpU#f,0#,nd.4e洉|ɤMA%Z9ĵgIb^S Nmq9LM6j| 4BvTtQ].aL6U!FK2IRlA AZSC]1Eš=tLh4vI>24818Cǚl|Vhٹ0)j~3N2'hNA醱ai֩_}f{kv(\՜lӡ_[o<.*GvCj3tZ;" :R%*0K%tFdU1AoY:s> Sua;^gR5/6C=l~rl5\ڲ$. $/^8L{XxZ|i1'5E尟OQ%VWWz2@1/8RZ,9)K:RJj@nG<_ִ':946Kh|uQ%mO" b Cdy {ZH’`)-mωP?zC7v{m=m~rKtAF??OO ?kE> Ћ? 'bPRАu1{;^#9-Db}G2:=_95QzN^%2[zHU{q6z׆eF'1d^Fń)*&:DѡKϳ 6Qz/FoRdYQhK ٮ(+|ڳ}{}ט5xtwq(NP "ZUU$`hڂRhJDq@1%ί% iGR>~gvjw͹wwνs ѧl '[ASׂbm7W(2\Kٜk֯m74; ]5yG}қX^߳A/6ғ$:*›أaܥ7dzSV~72?Y=W)S/+?LN*WYsS6);n* t󍦇sXoυ%V|3CiR&owRc+Gܸ޾RwR ;Y\ ֭UQb۪ ;r5yW]B+ŋEvhz ;5G!8Ltl Z oNQdrJGۦq31R ˎn_ṶvC8cX!k*u#(L&0%1%1ˋc処 7[z5G83!01Y[ yꖢ*@Е (J$~.\a]zW`ix`.FJU-r!oNT% n Awf Vd)+#ȵ!6hԆ=IJӉ%.&3DKҶ0d4DOsh ЋwĚk1=9q=Mkn'nF۵k'X ׿1{?tչMwmiMKRT g9dϛ)S'U|G.ǔvTlʡTEMrlP"Ӥ$H9wX}[3y!.p@/A{u?p7\ղv>Fk/i+J"䓷ni}*cS'u޹I$^?Ls-WeXUu/Fagι)g#/G&#{wBTqzhD%#+v^J&TԓLh"d>XRD 39W;  /De2Q{LL_&~/!sM1,0Y~} )Tj>U$/9U$ TGSRB!u0%Q4J4X|`V쿯:Tmj0Y߽h{#3b Cy^ LV5G}GSO#l8E|.uH=O_D羶o F.v?̐[`w37ۍPca7o4hHXe]uDb@uW/꟬7k, G"4ݫi:gQMEIC)[.5Kv,G~]3~ͦ p]#(s~lhYN6 A+gmC ~ %lk|u7fGws5XAwEʜۗ%KHB>88P:pAJz2(^٧:[Kの_FMiH?>^xzEYHcs rϜ߭ut0]ӹ[cGqu!}tCE*xJEq]k8.سqC)uw@>v{c@5ILYǒ]uK,9QΊwX\b;܆B ~IG~NcbnHp}l\/Ⱦ-  }67ON\GyyVzo}5 eey]dpgkf?毱 i:ּ?f˦[ I(Ul? l5W$/s8WIa^Ӏ_4߆Iu@_fY/ֆEa|q&uiV= { اo,^Nk:/Wyv܅|}Lii]|pYymnk5퟇Y}㮮avQ{KB6,iUa>[C30<>M:7}s#  ES;kX5fb{F@[54@GB>k b||fA[~['nd5w!?#ib9K欘m"[VLVPL,E{#$ӻճtʂ,SS>]ntc |OWн?c~}7^]h bsL~~X>"Y,bd}r\k]1U/RGQ؋V5ո>x+ɉ*~ړx u8tTeIYv1>VH uO3hix \bYǽP:poWg[ClYHt]?#=̓̇v"x js)|3`i-h&0r@S8:.n/B/wg<1{`bPISWiCGV!y̻6/FL nx#λ_[tE.jɕ8(GFfh/e&Z,qu.PBc O6bb5AS1ޤ,k>Odn<ȒL;i.|lld̵{@h"VP̞tαzzZz16VwXeC'6>?` qꔨs'?^klk|z;WמXw<㨐G1TlcY]Ƣ㜊E%t^fUoE'AWұOgQ`VB\>W\0xo㔂r.wVi%hw#'֚Oty`P9 ^]D"xRʗ 1" m!B/GGD"mqJEfbug `W`pJ]֠#gn;_\ cDy0eKNw.Hw͕1+w'7D䊞"958 NENy4粜?sInC?'rʹ3篐}g{pϷY rߣl,|O|`ȄӠzԃ"~9u.V.K❷{ǣߜiY诡_fgCjT9_4qLcOb۔1mc1VoZ-B54@@vtq w*0G@?}{_|`0 4Q#r>rx@!5߰9@wa!c4F8[іG*5hg̾4XLqj{Bc:%Lgof:2[,G:hg9ESk\,=b=&kT^C2BX wA%抻^ڦO:pgJG41:{n%yX6'Q;Dl >Z]ϙB~T{Lm4oC=,#[SHO|HyEÏ&d7%C4tvKIdd/|w䧟aS2ώVlƪ7nox(k4Z '>>-n%=dJTR8РG;tOJ w7eDVF4y Qvdh;cm,a.0zm]HSxY#4WG4c7}ٚzq1w[6)zvz?"@#26F,g?˸J3*/ ß P8eڭ2oa 03Lo\mfXF'm_!L\z:yU=WXuh}z9)zձ#kX.A筽{M^m뵷ӯInYH_okkw&B "Ќ]Slf5zҺVOf;p:1:p%yMgGR됭w!goICpRAmCb־i)^KdGsh+,d+ѼG cNlMwC^>{շDv}~s7^ʊ%-Ee'˛:uA} [{ҷy7;]n~^ 8P`B7v\ߣR" &2t m-4N:?-:Nʝs~.r~Ʒ9[ y]p }-#ݺ"Ӂ߫Z&^o+>ϴx)Vo UZ^u|S.?~b~ emy-qL|>z \{AeE|;Y;'k!^jLyJT:Zo1 o!=7 i퍓V>IcO_aƹMgYJ%}!N)fM,Ҹ~LKёK3:̵7;~-iRƹrɡb{~{9ՁVbB`I[[W7vzERTR~V\J7Y1/{rJpx9x޿S*Wԓoƻ%ԺNKg%9FJגv7qw4'" gIp\`5%FeHr GzWMжWnjiz?h\׸U5VHcDdw%P_5[ogs6СFXdJKLj0ca vd cIiecԌ0Fjear?ij91U{WlC K&wn=2mN=n1f3HƴV>H"ۘ&uOڿ;gwJbDvKJ1_Gzf^\'~27#C-i?MSC莎{M%FWWo1 6Pދq:Ks=X۠YA}+Q7/kl+avc^q~Nt6iaJ`œT`Roa\D@))ufH@g:լ˿g[8C `ާU] 1vJkl9pJ|.{t/c'deAvI3nd*$)E m,͛GzG$]ǜ'ݝН|z6-X.k$PdIO,\|Q/ka"\'kWv׈v"3anS3>{*fC@mjGԱ\^.et-g+gPbۦO~YC[>cӽJد&E,w~ }r$NѶ8T1uY"M;mFLPc|f~.Ky5k%gM7e6 2`)b(< 0 MK-^#}!k,ȢXe0tS-U/! @;fE?1Q@aucֈ4HriChds_#y􎟊K C"ۘ_hNj4F_cp|/ઊ;ޛB @rB[I( KBH(V T XSv"ЦtNڡPP-jA(BN!s[={ (p2(Yy b"d:{wkK)ƴ&ֆÑN+XrXkub=Ygֻ瑨u'wvؔl?QƷ%{nk[y'&;GX e 8.'x/j'b?{!V4/0^F_M`VB= (VS쟏zŨ5>N9ըFY/ 2hN$ uh %N+;h/rls{*XQ,:p5|e;9<{ϡ뭠ՊFYD+򹖡[f]-7k6,䚯75Fܟa'6qޝ/}p? snȃb{;P\ʟ^|ZD)[Id:'N?a3`nUm{YܦkVY?4Gc3>UV+kv#҇Vpę[|*EOQol^B<c0vg[ڱԬ%C}hW8syogGQnᷤ}AEC@+ * k{p]Y&Ƅ!@Ϲڋkzf-\yr?ʢj)̽RnԜyYOych 29+/O/}oX`YN:1 z1p@0 0\W^wQ̀N#Pfl `:b`bBP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( ]X  ZU? m A`%[lC?RmnRm'=#59Ȯtq=`nR?6s=N v#H6wb>e%4ɞsؿH[~Ŵus1cAHҐb/ u2k$ RW} ׳YV^}!}%aZmODդvѲiNIKVMuu/ds?IB3 x? n| `3{/DF)ak"f$ ' gö0Zi5! _q1d|41Xjo}?Q1 Fz $jsS&La5!(b_ޜL+)&`wPNJˈ>& 'mUtϗ {> ~_D)c 1Hb#[ wBL^_qQ%IQb\;z?Uwؘ͌995q35sɔ`t ΍Mِ7rvgs6521L|ڜdi\*fv:0>f8jcCtv3 31is,y)6ʳ㌚9֛:N%i>&9K`9MeFM>NؙTX01qH&$KW,iT7(r$x*8qRF~0dN3ѧ{t?v`f[\xuWo|l˹;FY:8Pt%`P e`X"ZmiVX޽^JFċּS%RC"iPqQ)un>k>mI y0H֮fB-Ѫ`l*:u@V".CxDE<ĭw'яmOG#d2ODʀLLWRd_D]נyNP(nľz*=Z4MD p\<%ΗmW+"5_,^W?ϑfvjm"uzI7ȣi:ni*[/H߷.^I[q^nճD3,NVQ"m UZ$L'M&H.ƣ UlwV8U~C臘"_G59@GBޅt^kpLk85Xå%|Nzd黤BVro!تݠߦ0 "f'l],7 4E+%{O3kY}zx-$*?ؼiN? n1#{nhE|jKiYM-'c5iO MiPV" *jB\q>ڭ逘ŀf!{uܮJNCVm0J҃ݚ{- `:@(C~$DGy@G PQC2& @= #%@FN^PP6Lۑ!"0TgՆ:ڰ槌|\KJ -HA*ZP ; ނV4<'t8΢3^'s e; w~*9J5r^ P,yyyccr.ߩYC+Toֺ%S*H%E:iPRI 2UTI{pWUtѐKwE]b.sͻʮcձu8s8ԚΚݡlDbsL%!yJKB ] )@wW-܏ׁa˂Yk  LFP\ rP.GQ \U`Ƚ%n?.}m4+$4*hK-+_BaYP BS._n?|uH*_eث GSWJ@`5D>Fɜ vc g4V\ ~CQ2E&QȚ'HF&~r@e6QAÞak?f@_Nz?ѳ'I'DD;# Vx.`k}U#VbsxЏD(sokJB\'KEQ,DAD"6+?ƒ %El, 0D_ zt-zwM9I{qJힰKwﱋQlW&Q7-bԛr 1+c#ӧ ;OӨj=^i_eȏ^h]SF'eN lRNzԂ0&H ҩ<"%:Ae @&!`>v`9'ډ&Kx"I㢘$z5Fx iܡV>$ΡIFȶO7pp؞ C촥VSn JTd8N"m`<=52|LblkaW|3_WWJvGqrWQ4p^(+2MG*!<6%茪`\iF<8ZT,GQ6oZ6; rxxDVOpYey%Y> endobj 32 0 obj <>stream H\j@ཞb"腺}YZwNH[GHL];pi ktu tnbM[wo}̋ۘ.t-PopzLEmhvk{x K0 Uh)їZ]R(eO&?oS^>t?'6Wu,Va?"u]xWC\,_r^0/YYّ__[9#C3ϑiE"lј g3p5yüYhAhAhAhAhAh ;t(PСCA* Ҭ0+ Ҭ0+ Ҭ0+ Ҧ)= +CWƹƹƹƹƹƹƮ ] +CWFcЕf]2veٕ+w~w~w~w~w 6nvͧJ< atL;_W[`<R endstream endobj 39 0 obj <>stream H|y\TG5o^p rfF%5fW#1hAPW`$F@k[BcF4^QU~4?|uA&$DwެepÅ&_\Jl{(Z7}IԸXoݪdKmRbG o ~*Ǧ$蛧Kw!4۟64!mSB|gBޥVQ*@Ɵd%Y+k$uDadoCzt`D*yҙhWrݳ.!HQ}!F1j45߄Sʬ{xzyT'n B7zq%Y-[nڼ_#?lQT>o??t[?սǿ?yL_|٧oX|A)Sӆ #G1c32}7>&L4yisrg̜5;oNyXp%K-_aYhfm6nڼe;vڽd8Xzǎ8yϜ=wE\b]m`8h8K.QY+JݤR4Y*JsLL+O'}7d.CYG2$\!!C~VQTbʗeRU#4 {M}LMSLM+3} s}bnl~kNՄT[SպjC5LmFjNT3BuQݩVKjzY>_x\xbԦ-&Keŵ:)9htus|pUU=Ijg3ݙrU,Mh1izi0)Z-e NRBz[1r\VkZ Yh YfY'eS|y_+le_JG7;{|]Kt_秫u8sslcHY&E@@{bc I4w&M'q2! H]`Aԭ,L&3@`C9qp4q,ѥ\M7ܒ:܊[sp>.\p9 ?զ\4e\kM|Nsǹs9NST9NS::SDA  <@  iᴄH$h ɐ1,6r   )ܖ>r@4ZB+h m-'=d=SO6Li [3!>SKOh gi0  4|75 s2M=s3TJSe 5H ҃ 3 i$44hMIH/ ߧW59^_үޤ[0|X a,%X+`%`5~+CyH3L4 E7GǼw6+| (Wm/(S;b)fbX,bM 6mbDg+/o!s̜4g8*N⼸$-Q.]< *A>);')G\Ǐ\jZxuED8Q['̗E,Ȯ}wY,KdoWcM3J˱r|Q*_oȷD,ȷ崘͐b3GΓ "D.*Zʵr$r+"&_}6: ˣ<.OɳTV!}Y)keJ+VV5P UTJW*Se&*W嫦H5W-E;ZUTGEuUU@S^~_ P 95L W#H5*ph{p 1j^VIv aq3, {>a%{{w=iOi{ƞy{ڋl{`': Nsѹ\z7:.nԕr.ˮq m625/12J"ZVGk<66b n&nMvST7Mw3L7v9nnS>ćc||, tUE_7B$}!l  a !l:"#d 3,t$@I$D%0swx޽w׭˹\r-q[w)Rb~(x>8|(EM1 GV PӜPJ ;)j87uԉ^u +ԍSIR/MɔB}(R?Oh J?M)PFiFӟe"a2]1q4ާhMI4T@4_i}H3iͦ9Esiͧ>E>%<›:;:b8sȱUkno&P z#)}Jh9e ̦C(VR}N_:Z+hmKim-Fh;%O)vW7 h/[ CtQ:FǩNI:ETF YJsTM5TKꦺ}GtKOots+צ>l JU8,n-unCtk0#tN6x)NQ:ZX5~oml=[6Vk,YkmCmd 6ls>_tn@t=X'$~` ^D=h=j{žl-[n [i9[mklm`3 EPNީLtQr;G1S;%8#YQ!*E8'Eߊe"⚸.n̉.̅t5Xe`JL&5P1/F7(fHq?JUgJU1E*y2AMTdQ22SR)0Y1Y2ideq2^ 2Q&d;CH=fvS/L bf>;1;^ޕwcBtcF0*Dxښ`bU3*Ѵ5 &tE]U?1g6L˛Md1y7/{(eVf̬5ysYg֛ fd6- +2Y>2U1A%g (rMKlZڄ6&̄@`n-d.4pr햯DPXl_` l6+&rC` BoZ6f`x zN` P{RdW R2r?Dh /3Zv,fP,e ZA8t0 u+n_w#ʤ `3yYR!>|;?quIVDA9)S8DnS sn#B4 c>!&=ϻ< x9rV,r><~&њUbWC\Ί-B%\Y(ɬ]kynK,dì|| 8~Fq\7wƘp/=3w)gbN>a0] Ȟ TCI{*"Fk'jQDTi3-E %iTIV%j"J7{aWj+yng̼y{\6^a o㭨~A0?:O1eN+\Vr5֨nPKj^w?#?>- [}BK6O}_]T(xWyVή2GPtWR3e?!W)}4B.{ 'j)kbKoJ"%T=}DįP?בrB1^szà&S]}N8k\dG5.bc/- oS:Gb[x nKYl #e,)#⥬Y߯ՌK\'V@w&- _7VRY鱵aI%Jvm|jӴ@ =fXa3-!W^E`߂obӣLeIx&wv:N]mHov=֯NQH3)4guf;o4=Iw6E߃(KCŷku|xgۍt(*Ϩ/C:Ur+TX+=Dstϭ<릔APר=.d=K/5 -^}|]Few+_A.eL2]_)C-GU(&v"Ld|_fb5!~Esz=)D[gmCmC@eԝc;"G0f2d(⡯ " "!Ttq>ߣQid9"7L Dpoyb^K=~G]]G|  Ѿmk|C}kc֮w{V~qEeKTB_+X9l;f1df"OS(4R.lV6@'!l#tcӧroש2;n+;OϏRf=)5[y=]Z ʤD&лuHbZ]KNZX Dc@HN |@Z8`Χ7ne*&=J-)(}˥QXs\ qi+V@dZ҄mVmle^l6=!UH$!Cdb&wS<}t3$^+R`IL@cRcoð7LwZ8b3 YP+|VV"Sv,r;"ӬۖnXX CՅV[o4 _&a,"c{ iB^li6SPq G0NW _&71ҽ2 QHoق"c˱<<Ɖ?b;% ?X 4$kSJ4"HQJem(+VT+BIHtBiCBSfiٹ/1ss~w[u*!w9n U=:.Ѩ !i7M<;p r1So![6 fTS ~є_;fi}npldsBl4h`lz—+C92 ueF: Qc,ثpB4^CInmZ)mjmByЅ{1kQ/Kx3A xk32B^Ml?2@QXuAqpi^D RX +s_ND)ݐ=8 \ XyJWؗ1 wNhhsV)tz`1FPde7ȄMC E~^lS zgQ#f P:I&lUCGQ QXڠȹ2tWp:\ҟpsrnaܰ~# ٰDPu_l0:tQa *LC,cX/|v+O޼y^Ӓ4&%g97~iJg?X̶ܚDP~ 8XQ!8\ٗ }+?3f(KaIg2f@dؑ~}o6u!Һ`J*-=ڴ>>n ;Tm wQ]6Zkv~⤵ǐ2grb8,Ң#|}9Ut=g fFb+r_Wf3O7%듪0aT-}CZF4[̒}k:,UKƛo$VSvNn/{6d^`(4FӈpaΣa0=[ /$FJPJkѡV5{bgÿ_ =Z[ROZ9z->=uw}{ {veXCYPI|Lb4 (Vhľi;\3Npivd,hSNGkm jس˝==>񱴡0'LJ&o \\Y|]+v+`4bY6)i:l *0yMNEi;L3t<|gaUQ M {YD:/l?鼕p/ 'rK\gNN犹o^+[Y!j$ D$N=IN$dr ڌ06F^b"@D)Q͏SHj o2lL"|+#]Їb: _%GL.d9R]C: yYp5Ι- r BR3E`W%Y˚c=;.zu[be }6MCכ3}cG>CGGߨ|~C&?kNnga ;aGlfLde4;~4G(7wK_sZvXhfI1LΖa,&"Fz=]^*]wk$œ׆+\W_5\L2yvm#ea Kmi>?Bw~g~$$:g;)+Vo!>GKao}(\d:bEeRD@e~rhMx%%gNyO/ B_ ] OXw<򦐟gP4,)!oMϘB,)l>STI1baj:Eqr}M} (YZU2a&bs!8Mp6Ƴq Yä#8],ZoeRż|iuUVŒ]l'l^d҃2VWt@LÝţTPFL)E#!_G:+gѬt{KW/F:W۠ =뺡0]7f3n: ~o}0žoVf$P"GHaZ~_ȷZּ30g͏vTI Yh]-GKconY{B58APWJ*hbѨAyPEyUSN$J,S^}2NhcyaQYe|yX|aU =M ' M.}5hGШ&:H+np1m@}jf.4.!q [V4=>^&CK*~s^Dŀ ] 5׏Oí?u}~6Ʀdva9g v~C؆X+FR-_/Xۄ{ۑ ޣ+D\Q9ee X6F ޲#T Xm`G6ǣ4rha,Ȓ888#$c(gtEpn՝lE3[Y%]LsK&x{rK˱?fDQ{XO-ՏjޢW^rM96 Bj6Q++ۣ]j8+sg0l1; -8:K dE MwU*㑒e+ |_/,?9V2VvX_ɼvz?/}"7}J.U_E ;~GpOoKERSV 2ؘdR{`$ ,h* CF"N=IM9~aՆc62de= 퓳̕-",JTOv6qﻇ=~}/!ؐ#bP %AgJhV KB- J72Z^aR`j BNR &- U¾ kNf-qJC2 fqlBf[ b#rh&aYbv4L'0j DR'r4aIOzsp~n]c60d*`%>F i) А'15@cN|Jmc$|kZ88Kjs2 hAD *';mg;nkv@FInD xӐQ+۸ց h0//Yv;-,؈]c= Oar~9X`C,unԽ*wpA5%3J4籦DV+JDg{Oıyj8I>spEbTi,؃ aL3rLprf e0-Ӑ eLY5 !Z||/Py~>Ajz5m標rt@_TZ9푣d14T'52'_#M;ML GW~{x*h |ڟzo9>CX,Hht,2!G_ﮚQϻ%-pmӚ5̔좺~+#1;swz7cݮk6t߲=WroT[6=~{vWˇ.}qB_N7zGݦ\#Ʈ)Zl2[=+.+Cw$4%y> PWV#FԘBr$ƽ>`:! 8gwsZ2ĵdC39$P(5Jt#3 RFQQ u2̸QIbvJ'"ly=hWdPRu)_Br=\}"GQ0ko#B_&uN5iꄙ+BfA JSu\^‘ͯ›0Y,!湏O97[^nNX7y l~pû3zz@Zm t0(;^S141*h^b]uZD6d61YQ棑h>G/xVC ypӨQr!%j kK~xqUM*d[xo6m`(&;Sek:|,XGeL:ezГ :i"N0) p"UvoV棱t01iAZA:w02]6_BkƔrQiY*1û#(!EaWK_JcMkoҼ\0/%ϸ1gmWO򳅹Rmt9TX^&5MZi'ڸ|lvE񇄃Cii}p1|I+?(#ܑ_R'b@XB go'zii-zHP$HP!!W0)<g>}9D1?ŏDZDXVKh.aCLcX%6y* ?&IS;i0"b]F}s(L)'ş_zHOg>\wP[XE|9y4zJ==(3baG;*xy%t@6z<ƻOfb,Yh(I&Y5\B/m.:c@ǒ)m5ަN·֬'{_Av#CYuEo z%MrX,(fAPV/,Jfn7^NX@c}lEo%*NDApx2[5З;[Bo/fΔ'cYP|+#(h r4 fW_Tdo'_kkE~(Ta+$?ibi~fK*R4Ɉ| |Rla(ӴJ\DhB[Fj:}"/k'ߊJ7#(o<[&9c]7J]ZPp-H_(V`e@ZHhIu& c]΢c ֠|@7^\;o-0]s9e rC+#5(-ms}T&`G`5jci5=>a,`8cNXpjmO4 +W޿](11Zi٩ҋ7ܞ>Qƪi1_bBiuקn (vx=_GrifO#9ƇeVVI`ϔuFsqR%'/qQE O2Vuv!+R*Y;,VH픚tAu!-NOz *SȔ2%3ò 9;q(ላE8JQ‘(9Dd ЁׁOLcw G؁.G&ZSMi ?4<ы1 +yB"fi]#-CivӬ `VXg  +WMvuQꖸjq ͨf,Y։jk;IsIP.%iqل.ϱNhD~>Tfx[zP hz:6kzoPtTZ"ZlI N- (kkծβ2'inj TSSWt }T? M/Y%w\(/3M[.+{q46\^1<8 weTgG NbSKFsv'iU+&'Ki$UHd]Z}@ lf7k}uQSKgZ^vJo-W׉ףRǀ{AӮK-#fַ!pDӕtPZTZ?g~ }կ;FI~Vxl}N<[6q/ }f5 LCQmR[8Cvjܜ6Z֭PKf> >clTG:3^\Mc$kAתE<=rgؚfŕw87bG%d\sGFČ*f5ѧ$`bxM/bosGuKg(ftajp>Sz¯dkAcWE@P)Xl뻃, A_qqqp,u3^R,*t2Z@Yバ3^/ _ޘa[qaVI뚰U"Zy~GZ<ʵjn2L`l|0^^#`Cΰ/ϋ'~rH<`L><'{Xzr?$ĢɔyZ8#KVRaN$6bM~NN$_."FhDp:BNn]2[IdH^0ϒS.h_7ŗI#ݏ3䱴e}SKlMJTi@\TUŦ uj#J&GncKf쪍&MOzMvwYŢZ],IjT w. ^h$*7~#54Bk]QH:n'lGG}}ɨ"65J|;0I+bkl4MO >%@#1 ˜.L.W. ejaP35=w]9^SM ҲnJ7`/qXl}Yz. *H2^{Vl7TSwbSSep`0vәQ|B% + g6S08؆ p)$5US4D)QEhq@+N0hѩ`O5S-eDb0^:mC8;ooSs"TqCژ v7Kn, @3U4wc])Y9h_~:1{Pl4'n/XmޏJg 8pRxY WŰ{:qgb@ًw+{ʳ7?)WuEm(#p>#MPuvMiqt@3#ʓzx hHJ^P撗巕|M_H~>?4"wO|`8~]}c)Nbd4 Z#"YI@) -6N[$`]ۅDIHNiTӺIQ5uiV.-v{/ N%ٖN] _WXo)oYהk(Ǣ5rLKҮF^J+ﵔW', B2X4_֩xWOTZ0CrE]n=' O}cY/-4W b`K#B.c" _7IQ^*j^֗a"]R$D ޛ VRJ~s&Zi)fL2%EЙ)4qn7?U묪i7^aï%o^67a5{1hr7TU8wGn|?'TsF#2GpxƐY2qgg>~_?RYCxêߝV0~nr Mp"ʑV|R!f9ByyUcSRLTi6Jsu#iimU>joofJ{ "*lj8 Gf98k4~xAF!)d*=ԙ[\D9^ᓹ˹k6 s`#b.';NMxln ׷m\<Ž]ȿOrUnbR%P{g  逦$d:,K*X/=pu@D-a5D;.F!Bfaz>? _Xˎj5ad_g4KVBV+1^В]7_%NëL4]JxDZ5{ q"C\֎}iyomO7[!#IA1Q+bmPh#1:e 48D2q/;NcÏEI8x%ZvDw/ %\Rv8;u!,\PQc(aHN=঄a0x1,b1"Oi %~=˟1ԳZ|j1a NY.~c.{H?nb+>!AmkkXb~cǾ1}'.@d8R৽ 0a~E1;+{k!iv)À\ )%3"R(x$ @.XS +R!$c ̴\D \ir>-4x dI.2*`aBÒɨcFmؔ&i"?7֧LE%NiجwI eʔ L 50:0l<=в6ھju4HZ"YihGz[_]9TvTw߉yS꾧7;_ۗ8ɝ I--IZS K6bh[EUA&mT[d.CbS%?:ƴ"IC4dtڢ޻w?dח?dvW~W};BҨv}h !tjzD9e6_jr"h @h 2 \@Gb}9+*'7W2 @9O×0ʆOo}qB/ɠ 㧝rYu﹚1lbt^BK)-E9qwg@g6|h6p~8S@Y0'j> 5]#P@{(mH`s=%"0#`Q"5S#j"A@J\ 'Dא)Z9,tYף._F,s`ʾ(½3cyD,;x@5s1L\pExR, </2xy{.->O ۹oAwxC(9zŕޝ~pMm}k;&<'n0_Hh]#Ϗt&'?P .+Gpp*; \pl|^=@KOR1*c/Pi{*ЉN%;چ6!BFo@MW-㶇|._W\[R|ȷ"lv&.p`lZln34dCKd"J& z; ۤ#ۭӒEQA=(L~N#MolOMv&sʹ0%ϒgI͑.mTB5B;h/'%_kQ=W]vK&R="$/Ԫdl}'3иo.O:u|Ǔ'R)}drQ17725 -vnVWu}^X|دrl֬2]A6ϵ`,m:ɞTՔڦT D- Y]g^ [Gռ(" d-f#kFcvVy.+<(0kjF$E0uTOݫWbS16[cb SY[ ,It:`d*scLJn8qhlڌH'"nȋLcΔ B01~K7N'$=:ax]݈xؿ’Vrؘb}oY]hyv6b Gϋ-_|-(f?wJ]W0J9%BktNHZ(w{X5)rM|@p. &7 U0cFL5{8 GEv Xjڬby>禪sܳ|LAa?L : Z~LIhVn+տMؑڦLo~~y[x+fy?X:HNZ?:DŽIqRLӎ'3GYႿ:y <<.9#7EK7`+ˬ^V+_?/ K>Ӫݖn5ʼ+" 5GL3RxngKHbSӃ-Lv1Dџ̨YTTS,U"xKQ/hEܥMg5ɟmngԬZ*E3(a!mgٱc9WNNJhYh^\2W+c&WpNy&;|s88_wvb'>c;$XdPd4M$hX5Q)Ҥml*jJMդ&&m:PԵ=#߽߯=Of!Ìgd&3nAƞoK \MTԉ?1ESnJ Urrʵ{~"ZV-Y;&:ێ7t`?k[^n+E0 * UD,iDX6Pk-- ]z!̹<S  lh -7뎅x\o~,ݝ7ƙDJr޼?RC),%z:~GcC>b yz== ˏ:5M3'VRBHYN7;;*6]2U֍lJޭpz|#`G140)ڿKzd6~ \дT*1L!'/4I%ģ,ߣF鐣Pj2LZc22La+C3l1 ]?T ի`I]tWF)[^:AzK?pU^zc]V\m]cƊgV$1S8/IC,6^HX0i@60é4W  nA$ԅ4)hϾSӌeaXaiq! = w " ^1n;~VkY]md=U Z2)bJ&E'kvQ$5NhHVWEvgt X&K衰Z{~*%Yf{RFN2Q h0$II+֪bPd-S,JJ5e0TPo%Wp&([^L'Z`/WYznHR \u08:=Ή;,*%Vn6ۇِƫ( 9c#6 O s9q׽$R:P",{r7KHZ]*Xhyj'tRbT{Ub"`OfXW((LZ9P(EaOUH_[ylg>7Sr9xl7aCc[i-h=HEÚL7i7$2RTa3H2VP 32x4FfDZ Mb=*20\)f  MHدg - ncph`Nl]Q5JlyPG:EAhȞSq>'rE+ɖy X̢Œ >.'K2luW *d[XPTof{_, &h`ڿ}ga)W_$#,hi γjw.M"[څ)Vl" & ՠ-s7}^K|Cp 8,-ߍ lv*> /'D(O1܇h>&Is9\ph.:䔝Ӏw\+杓o,(RYUW/֬'- ,p%*#ʄUPȯRۥb-0S@ h}=tU)pc{w{ws>}'uvJ1XR¢d ԍ U'21ȘVT~Pid!mkHu)""ZTUB0w~},~!^N OJaY_R`Y-^~]oP}8qbwSS Zкu;+RߟX}ñgQl\C*E7ō8҈F#5`')0ʄT«xD<%"-FzO]./{|[nG{C%^&s}v-`c߈w$ |;;?WՊϥ;"\v8z-ĈĿ{0L8@K((7vr֐!KLˢNZcVњz1|ۃ=WL`y vEQ7tqsrh1TDsH:r%UG+qemmAHTESlm!h~[泃|NA/h3-;+'4 ܌PhAVM 5 e&UK۷|#[/rw_&| e0Bzqb55"L^L.O,w߬Jx]SΩ^ۈgrdKuZt旪6a`JpdDf`hLJt^>Mai_CW6#E(LQeQ^s23D0 ^v=<$g4Lӡ0ù0o\cEC3h 9z47lqb(ON'Jt(N'ne-@IS(x1M\uu!a(}6]L;=Pڨ=ik-B6l:۝ۜo ;&B3MdZ!7\Oo0;k(5ϐ)rU-V7j_^il EmQ:۵h'QE.mRӣ9c8kQc{]"\M}#ڛ}%4M?n)᪌qx+2^-՚(!M\H2%6|l|<8?x|,HGoia4pM&o=sW[:ޚW;v+e؛XF0BaWc;^˗q_`{֩7mt~Q XC~'C~dҺ=U0VaCPp610^/\!W0%#6MgPx /ЬV\nQeY0#ևI 9dǗ&QzDbWQ$cG$$Q=a\,fl5:%҃b.EFn3?d/e'\a4- /ȡQab2D鬜R OAuw7 W\`G%,Yr;oA!@I_O=7E?Oˑ4?"< eO"Sy.wFr[ 78;-vIyy7^t!\Fw#icD$?T}ZFm]_ opdIGìY=~>!7$&ecqEH ҈5HGJ+Ƥ9I()5(ҥHQSЙȰJku3Ae)O S> aj Tb /P'@i  gQs3gqk0巳†~X51<˸T XM`,[n9K-g%]TL2Val\A˫l_]^f&%x.>,)|b95ek˗R @FěxHEoǯ,Ŀrtx]Oa3z"pg9@ ncO1=LTR6%`%K5xGwm&1`"Td[NScjoso8p; 8g#dTUdU~Kp!IHGW)EF#F*^]*Vj5( QϜ;©8KjbUz<\.uRUX8`}ʀRTfQH^1]uMdWx;{LlO2c;c'N RVvK⡤K6Q+]R}X *>R v7Zze{̽s|ߡ =Wn<.(yh>-?춪+F~s+1/E_\b^YDMVTF z/׭O Pos7OwfAz/ 77 1:&%.r )En@**m=쎏VWX|P:(ф!>m]]Iӱ7?83eC-'{vmOb* xER4d:saF̅hl^\_XžN__.Mͷ-5M(ҳR{06Ld)S>:#۩\NG k{<^mIAnⓚxO(hq.++*RG8.AY ] ',/}(Rs ia} axr/֑,yŔT6UjjG xE{G xFQ!BDjFl ":ёv>LK#hg X8`9/}DP?&R_oBėG$ |j"RMp:% I[7 4*  P؆\6m)R큱эӁ@uAh!ٞ ~xy]S "N7Vɮf `A' *4ԒA2 uB®z:Ewp[raOj+Xhگǿb]0i5ڊg3ЫwjHh_aa kaVnz9/iY9xgsAPF©pqӏΞ{onz8$}>3 /e3;/1wGcy4+^JU<0Z1(0vDӐdv8L%2 x?5ch;H"̧!AGXn88pƨ4nab|G + ~Hik o`fi)hjፑvO+4w,O^/&vuyW8׊ܖNsko0DYEh}mx",6{ U, j:M mJrvp8%ǽ$`H~1 L&mw ;,?jMp>/?--HAt.U[x}D^Z]o\@5;qFb$r&'H0aAs1im"i]N IЃW@Axn5'wbû?\/IMN`EFrE^dKDMȘӤ5Z-h@0 p;!7(qGY(a;.Xqc :Mpʂ f+мPV+3"vF ȁ5K!KQFU@mnV%4t!M/l'{{z Fvk(([~ޖ"GraKPvŶm]qHIK%)[$3OYZQcxe[xC X HzC^0h$OC,MT0 cːž0 VdQcHKs)%6A$/sfvt}AW&}fEAGٯ70>bC3.sB&ih˄{pٝYivknCv1"DQOͫRms0  8Y7] 2]1o:eSL_Ic]#^#CplqT;˗$$'#2LM mLI]0l㲱k ǟ~`\1@eG0,WfnF!J7^nn2U5A`YXUOH<Ћ|F:(z7a%#4mdD)^= 9(,W-<_KŢ RZ/.&b+Ti2~n&rB$ͻGkfG rQٞ=Z¸6m:2t7 F!ZN:bal h kR%-6f7@+${TRh{+$j;fb[[[{0چ8 Z`9ܻrA/݂BîI zQ~C~pM Br\=RN|ίw}7ږwnoI-EJQ*kҷdoQ!c8[&ӊأ+ʼTɢ|[D񼬾!Mh]aEYrr< \u1OCWBTxw;d"LDqIIFRBςIB4E)ܺMW|,3`i2`Y\Ű y&4TC^ȄWA%Q P)5 ]q I)58ʖ'S3\AJz "'gAN()qZ|dW#>$шuRr~@3t4i"$ h%YR+֖uYdڰxke$߾7YX][ t{DY'dY}YET*F(⹀1Q;mtsC-g' >kkq"n[]N AUWA-Ρ9P8ڑl@}D1\)nTBIP,Jکh s8㻱c<&'SA 0MaE0iBѻ71Lο_%/>7ܛn=jZ`O(Wߟ4ocgـL6NNn5#$T}Z* ƨdQ={YOa 6E¢ X `h(B06_@X&rAp`ŖP4`tje{O 2b XFa']a 0=f8F~d)w9Άj. I4;G ]ӈi+mC EH&.C)9#đ &OlP2G =C7eK=jxB9G*8ɘi^JbhF'*RɊH,s~B.bA>LB3nݓɣa*j*[t^urH[lW?g^h~k [-Wʬ_I$Tnθj'gU;žU lɆyXZۇ ypb8g5ϳ<ΑW*C509K79d?mb9Y굹^ۨ\M5DmeyHC6CƣC1?J_cIa|\LV!T 'iP h:P-> FÞ S4)6ҵS>%8WQ 5gQCb;)Q24{J=iFv4)J^A/*80,̏3Zo1.P{$8 Lj`݈en:xO<{S_]R)U]oi6%/bz#h,pM9`y3T3A4^KkMܨ;b$ՠ PO ijRICL̡tdE CU;]G+]s/8\=v@`^8RCy76s/z揄(;w{w_.1[x A vV) U *jE {dV(JDG(BVP*mޙ;;wgfgƻϾ[7~l8D./4΢}r1{>kY⅒6%~w 1 ;Ey+*Qr.NaΚ4eJ梹l^3Ys' D3ө]P T (RHͨi|!_?Ѕ0s=չi>{}ّC;sٓ%2C ޻g|O`H[<0y>ڵ?\|pH\ɗ?2Ql=oÔU#XAHAgp7S|>3̢gY4"6_E|)4Bi cڠ FWuiUhb6mۖ2yJєRaҠas,K})H):WOk`DbmBěY n,6cn:^EZYJ+p( mZQ*c 98Q5j^B++JO빿7=77seԮOϡs9ix#qv\%("L4$Isy>{>'(`>lמ)>c?Ebs3(r)jN4"PI-UZp咖җ)#m 0A})% " B* Ej|G׵s Go+)W3ga2-& "Y[h[^Is,4aM[ 1m2_9!o~ߩFǜ*hIgƁ\WypBr茴2Q; :w:ݘ]]N/-KS%`w\"!l"cX순5,@wGL_9%3=+KT& f2>Cnױ,)[?鬦ࢤl-޺DfceѴ1"aDsG,5, %? Kf࿯&w|ڵz}YjK+u.rrC7T7qMsף-[H:8^-Yh \/#&wZfM#o`:z5>Q{oSB vmhRM.&$'TPJꢺ^SzՉ/n5#vK;J:]vSk " f`S[frAnCWZ9%8&E2u#5.tZ!G}S<5+zXふ_)O_D;(Xe֘ T> Q8zVB0 df bh( /1_ Qh-ȃZWt#('Yn@2f7iT@R]vɷ"POrB4$ǥd*#i7:l3@H6BhN59eTFblvx }Ùf&L4m?ַ;m'Fcq`.p0!gOٸw;GƉ]GiF<`Y,w&ϻXS p'C1_ )v:oVzx2pbULxi$i7 Sڗu柛pfÇ"a=ld}|Fum.{3{vڋ4`M|Qcj硡 ЬP%}hh NBbɖ6 /MИP5MU@,Z.|眙93s|j&Z.KRGLOrt O o/zf⯘k&6[IWE?~(@ #j5@AR=O͡K ˣlism-&U@/qHB)dPiNP-y ,\ebPch1t,0` 3ioT ǥia]ָsQn-{1|,gsMTTm<'^[7ڒߨAx` 1 }gSg]|": [I %2.]GLoi⪐ SaYހ[d]J.0 MAƆH ;%}t[dmTogMko#o뚮VbH#v2*UU#{WzERuKL1>F;[: J$QR'A~ P jIg#OJ5sLdƃfb78r?7<_╴M>R7T ڧ3Kڗf,۶r Oek 4:NO3GkGqk^ċ%sZMm7''-LE#t,Y6X3fu'Lu! ꒶/}M$,z,D=!EAjP(K)|YV2o1 'i5YfֲL$4ca Â3s5NrV$9+IWeI䀩& tS2T |UeUBdQ 8,mRŠ{jf\}ȿAxU/]/}a!(0l:!m<6t*Z8紎<}Q`ήüTD=3d7h"! -ZZeݲh`V.nC6H`pX.#r)bNNz`98R5)fʗY4M#IϠNTEDR(#xF !@cqa3JjS1$Ao@lJca tf_yQ5O-BdcJApQ[އ֟(rcᔘ kZXln UW(!MKyz84JE*RT/HkM#M sE6384 509Q-"勓7Lrr9, avxǸby[x-1ǝ:Nz6\7b}&zpD֟6j{S)mw^/a! / M]IEy |Baq8;>םEy<+hz["MAGF\8$ jNe17O$Z`lhZ۝v󎀄|bd^Qh/VrUeͶV 2Z3ԉFiMZGv:Z"ocDJKlBltt 'tDD_?ɗP {dC$vS%G#Ml*{XA}?+<5e)>LT% $yGdշOg#wE3x*55L7`n >  -fTXɹqHYWTtڟ=$^%2 ^FL^:ާ%#2y2۽5TWx&RkI8G<>*) :!YI t1,E.Ƽ+@ix97J>4 9=/sL5DzE`.Ow-OsI;PW?D#vCCXqg R&jzV9"i<=&j}ʋ}Dgy1W錓Q B݉ bRԱQu8ඪ+|}idY, %ٱx7N,l$!q K$4 MBah v贅xڒAmiG'S!.6!Ld+ɸht{wysY+ sHc?]ji@A uj::r 5-20>x]Uq68g9ܢ)v(*ܞj?ְ**Y*5[=Sh?:T LS_#oϊ,d0.+_UΎˮ%Xf\ cuzAnS.t: #;p3K^_Odos ፑ͙\vGvfvvӫoәT%TE2$-!͎P8ܑr!N$Tة9xipS k[㹨 C|W<'\Visҹީ9t Rcf0Ge3=3PW}qh*'nDZoSR,P1a3 \ -VJ^vFqvJpCh?5tPgzM=ݽ]`]W*WܹGk쎦H%;C{}W%X[- YQAyQ8e 2:s5#U*`|@c}^G<#>W;PM33H#_y dQ<8\efa*q:@9zD9D,U[>\n(v]mDch eA[o'T(]ZL-i "䣝̓ x{!m?1~)d>i6.bk~ZA\x lv)ÿL6?si3ɫ?야^IM\ɞޮX@kXr_)}OF\:Z}[,ڰNd':y}#kǾq|ۧ]XG'+.sSogrd{iB[@t$0lKKl9Z*] #D-x#  "p5 }_sT=Dk:k X =A)}Š/g|KR zZQ}zѯI[qndz }<6C.^Zv\cEur_ }~6B>{S Xqx {`&,/끌p_٪." zF{W_u+kb٦"o&J)>9 k])IyjO[gm~ZȰN XI o=j/3R@$ݧMRmic&/;c}$-I^7k{BP7Q&[jJX_y)}Y0ǥ e|bMq}E`8hPqx/;7Jf= [A|*pWBca`>`]&󃹡>)9n0J>Cy=2Rϑmf_๙[̙D{s'y̩2ndԷ2fV>K-*hslX>Q{?@j7Q-{EVbZ>MI-7DNJ- d)僧GiB"i Β}Yr>.ưQz\q٤ 5F]%Tr6X%cf*gP>%I8>@*6T:S ~ ~^qټ-˹SS\Wq'ж rgҵ:$S#8oYkm;Rk-yv?lM$e˱,\ɥOQ`:&ie9%9!hʟoSqFŶ}qy-nYmsv)샫~}I B,m Bh -)Vd@|tڪH 2ciEtha*2qR1ȴ´P> &oIoΞssAcLKn[+^-3Aj:O5Uu+I9("WK_\v,) 1s?)rpӽߜ,3fw%-[*)g"VTUHxw2> evkrrT1)Hr6FzM_byfT0s%-SȻY2<qL}k>6ONƽ-SLQ{pIz|!]~_H^uTꐕ9'zc2~&Jrx|{j7܇od9Y2>I!ϸ̱ʓ9*U;m{7I9etl[-''W+ iĻckH[6?Jm׆T;63v0GǑ,t|dW%}Gc<6BM };d,v䛰e 1nvb<#i[ ]*N[{z ;5;5(R)grkPC]"9Œc=q=ޓ8S]Ȧ,ŏ#o?(j~Y(J {\jl$3Dm>.y{wϚqVD}m}HTsrVpAiopϻu0eZw[su 臈}.KoWv0b>\j߇KtQBC!'lLGXVȷQޜOෟZ1BW05jqQs 9w"M9&jwѶIiJGlZ']d0Gr?"< Xozf*B5cyAn&?P /)#mColq2g35wp;] is;N(9?PKjMuֲqg[j,́Z;kJJRc¼[ce-te:Ğ,b zwkH?E{K !/9-bl9f͑  /St?q.o'GU|Hp$Fz J.mUtwTvV#uIGi>zz&Wr[|wEΫhC;nI80U #bFd*5ɝi[d:y{展^3]ԀԇR ^ݓOZo=י]p!Rv(ð= X}җ| 8?^!fX.3}yWm8%%_qxs5C[,]$>o7r ]mcAIa䁡+eg.yva|-csXG9<?0vdҖ}D)j+L0~Zg1ckd5BŒ}31}&VJ5ETq|GN{gθ+W5'ω/a Zc(zR,P8/J{Ѝ3Pfl¹Q2Zjf"3衺!1M_jb{yJ}g>-sH-ξ?|ftFmLT=o'^1}zva|UrwH{,??y]%/6c7qŚ&\YvˏI~ {5Ě9 >kS79B^5s,50vl3]9`=8etƪ,Bʢ(A{nUB6h_{v/ n[WNўFu Q;OC ?yz%$›'~+?0ͤw^,p&]%DŽxO·Z|_iƆN=߀,5A]{}OOь{φy_d.L|e8mȿ>K(䘓-&7vO)71Wu)j1?~Vz8?#~vL2y".PI(xbJסC|$1sW3_6g o!&щwM"VaE&oӿAҍ댛*7^GDFcf(r qjzKɛvKz}B*LGCqse qzLq}eֲ6K>@S h-R{F!h]w@ {ne"K$FI;Q`M%EC+pdRkϕl;ijBEsQt9k:*:pI ިJ!D<:**+R;B̉B8/_)i_6޾R rBPJaJr+M*B*8EFtbs8u:&(xɀɈcE˔EӨL9otj~y[^.%<9߹_lF{$Ar̆eXR R" .ku]_]bcNem||ށm:l[y\Ԥp';AǙzDG3j;kAguzWtqk=komuۢ; VΥN[S XW=ZOməƴX O;%~lekS16.Ʊ_cd:cOOchq";iM:&;oǯ/ԼO44V: Y͢ћ3!셏{,+gU]Ns,s-ɞpF“gϠϟk}.p}v3Q*z- ~וAľ`w$p!` ԏs}J6H.C)cLmgdSܦ޳DFŋF#ˬv:I-Oͷ!Д<5~ԻKNe>\9]+s_{Q֜KYJcFI+t:a T]>^V8Zk l)unϝ)UAf]B\u:O{[`Zi4s̻t7r71míVӽo4O)"|Vp_ Q~|Kh~^MէnRjBSn:8oT;q~VCh<6)!ze3,}3?685_q>j5e?&yLFcE0i'eOwImz_-oMAdfgZ N3MaG939'e7n95س^묯8oXO}s)mcZ޳Rcgot;2Tv1Hl$qS&ׅrLq0pMolޠ,|@Q\|;b'|w|p[bhn#'/OG2$CPgZDqh rWޒ[)dg">)*9rC{zf:vuomT/˰YȽLEaJe717={ù:o戮g1D;>m{ }Y>Mvlsh#azصdZx*Z. G<}1hAfKXȃqP?j9=srXPr[ ;a%P40΁yk{ >kUvۯ:`mFAږC%󊙏=-']I$Rl\4K-Т7B1ok{<_ ޤ|_ m;δ;oJ޾[0wgpp @޽yD3^ '%/Zśyi.7GGѷ^o *QB)mcgjbd$S1R\jYÛwzЀnk46ֽKFfƛ}M^,]w"l{rMn/"^fT@uGKis6_dDzN~E*ʬji`lD2(\ Mb^BS2(;#2?1![OR5×'Qp%`Dr}' sp3ד&5 GQb[`l×H,"q4,|f0=R}3dgP˻NGgF/ף{w4ϼ.Q%R`(zԫo._2tW-a4J S(Eh>/ب+g޼x!:k1Yb6KS ό% n,I64)HE%&KUR+UV*btJ%įsـZ=w;s;*~n) h'`V`uhsAĦw/{Qyc^E)"YwvnNHNNV5!]s,a{wD)tSl61vځݯbՂ,DeqA} ba=vpbSb/T{܋y-CHVsbzl%7/2E-h&1T;sϱ c?6N4<_"]Ns4X}KNaLW²}Yobe}RL)Ǒdv?vټ$Y?zn{|5:`wne[,w{S}\N#+?8^ DfLqy2#F{ oћxQH8%v! +L{xIJ-zAda[ZS~e?U}E  a\)þ.~bg/ؗc4Cu9K+2cПqn%#_ ~['crOB׍u>qcb*s}3.{d}d"[Nݫyn.(2Qѥ'+d4u37ɹ_*+U>X\-P6yGiix;[i? 亃Om@Pwi_#='G^B(w|Kۜ7)k4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4F? mp n懞dWkgȯ}˜Kv?;#{)sdVɠ".yٍޘ#,?/9G||Y K)a #FR8.Ue 4*1;:N=n걨7N))w.16562TR?[55tqGt]\;KsLIQ~|ڔ-,2) (KܾƴRKڠZڨ{&TI7[,:IQbʶ+TjF'Kԯhʓ,uuH}gVhԩX謥m;%GP3RsUt7i(+_jx,:V]D JhjjO%p2ZuDxHxwʊwEV0u !},Q_Vi͗div[uX0`x{̪%eHҊު-j#H0&Ad; 3iK $?ٯ&3m Hȡ A4W$!B8D؛"ozҩs:zwzGAmen\S\?z]k:g7?L}wo23/QbmEYcѨ5vZSVkg4ٷOLPwvV4-;{ [z{{ny\4XaJsڿ/ m?|>dI_9#I+D(U,WΓb{wpY̓ x;p0 ,j>瀌in"pyЊRrהp~UΑep[/([ϗ.|nMX^bnۤ,*Q5Ua1SJ8c&Utk9?c`ʢ;B?e? y%\R\au7`0^}2 &19Pl6&0η z#+{݂7q;&M"/tTO^}%/^=ـlן1ӗpw V`%P:q,qS}uLq ړR,אng4xbk K: a冈{1J6A "fPY b. VacXwa i(0&jc9Fu86YWbUsR{؎bבyYb#BsjQ&e k48ae@!Rೀ0^Z/Fc"> apa]c.d"ؒyMos17m̶ v+{húaPN5 phjfęg V&K{3{,7r<+J@=j*j*j*n(`hx~{i;)2#*x˦˩VNrqx]P^^ȑɆk  m :97+V8^.rUI < * $tjM@; iJ( )?O=4α6`TTk*MJM1i{ml#Ύi@ :ۆsẃ>`0nc۔S1G]y&עd㡪W$\#ԓSޭWT~^]R;JKy{ ^uW- b#@r`{ɍ|MȦ~`S_{mmb/y`zBr䥞\ Wq^N|H.L?`ɼ+CGOTwB9]woMwUwWTZлz]@D QZ?ud: 킎7u@E$o4vN_K@SKz8e֗uXCon!Kw/\EJ!E! 18;E+H}dUj'M2r.XLrE!5UR"դ ;/+bԬ濽mE7N࿜˥$u\⿰_?.Mҭ:v&Mp\s&zDZbzO:yez]OٷWr p{HO0IҺ_UCY>&.ȸԎ\૟yi7v74Vbbc)d1嘲MY&)d0)&bOx*LL`,[ q+Ԥ>ÂJG `8E[SLM_lSj$%-آ4RնNJF 9 Ѡ6!v3ڼ]˰ Išk7Aix)xSXN[gBKPj϶N){ހJj/*{[#%Jˆ[KFJhB50ג?^R z։ 죷ePWR@_MB,!ReHuf~lBͲ3s6-Aq!NW;wTKݑN8d <>)K`3cb*1i"|3@h^|5yS8[y^h8ݴGZo#pG;lI$x~= a(1>\TCs?aY5|;("WP \q+GMqjMiBעXwd@emi* \Jp%iWuLe9?iX?&h`?P(xymAm[sAe Cq\l:  `!8 v8c%. 5'p@rpxptn][B.-tԧ$ x2o󀎳i~Sz_ed^gAV;qN~#<@ԎٗxtۨUFhmmlK[y!mx9{D[S+(t?] V.DقM[%Y"HHbF]F 3z437;zC7=: 9]36tn8O+4`ȘGIMSRAZ`Ra/WFC.G'>|~:8I}=ȕvjdx՛FO^4:yh4vA/>} .~p\#0, AF +x6v* ]# At@Wό(!Wx endstream endobj 16 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 3/Type/Page>> endobj 40 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (04-03720.a1)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\ ved%20-%20HTML/04-03720.a1.html)Tj 50.24 0 Td ([7/2/2021 3:27:44 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 122.25 591.75 643.5 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm (American accounts.)Tj ET Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 729.75 Tm (The Administrative Judge erred in her application of FIMC 1 and 5 and in\ her whole person analysis, and these harmful)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (errors cannot be corrected by remand.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 22.823 -2.125 Td (Order)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -22.823 -2.125 Td (The Administrative Judge's decision granting Applicant a security cleara\ nce is REVERSED.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Signed: Michael D. Hipple)Tj ET 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 16 639 cm 0 0 m 129.311 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 614.25 Tm (Michael D. Hipple)Tj T* (Administrative Judge)Tj T* (Member, Appeal Board)Tj T* (Signed Jean E. Smallin)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 16 537 cm 0 0 m 111.322 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 512.25 Tm (Jean E. Smallin)Tj T* (Administrative Judge)Tj T* (Member, Appeal Board)Tj T* (Signed: William S. Fields)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 16 435 cm 0 0 m 124.002 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 410.25 Tm (William S. Fields)Tj T* (Administrative Judge)Tj T* (Member, Appeal Board)Tj T* (1. )Tj (Foreign Influence Disqualifying Condition \(FIDC\) 1: "An immediate fami\ ly member, or a person to whom the)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (individual has close ties of affection or)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 15.801 0 Td (obligation, is a citizen of, or resident or present in, a foreign countr\ y" \(Directive)Tj -15.801 -1.125 Td (\266 E2.A2.1.2.1\).)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (2. )Tj (Foreign Influence Disqualifying Condition\(FIDC\) 8: "A substantial fina\ ncial interest in a country, or in any foreign-)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (owned or operated business that could)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 15.552 0 Td (make the individual vulnerable to foreign influence" \(Directive)Tj -15.552 -2.125 Td (\266 E2.A2.1.2.8\).)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (3. )Tj ("A determination that the immediate family member\(s\), \(spouse, father\ , mother, sons, daughters, brothers, sisters\),)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (cohabitant, or associate\(s\) in question are)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 16.8 0 Td (not agents of a foreign power or in a position to be exploited by a fore\ ign)Tj -16.8 -1.125 Td (power in a way that could force the individual to choose between loyalty\ to the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 31.852 0 Td (person\(s\) involved and the United)Tj -31.852 -1.125 Td (States" \(Directive \266 E2.A2.1.3.1\).)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (4. )Tj ("Foreign financial interests are minimal and not sufficient to affect th\ e individual's security responsibilities")Tj 0 -1.125 TD (\(Directive \266 E2.A2.1.3.5\).)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 15 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 2/Type/Page>> endobj 41 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (04-03720.a1)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\ ved%20-%20HTML/04-03720.a1.html)Tj 50.24 0 Td ([7/2/2021 3:27:44 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm (of support for his family in the United States until he can retire and l\ ive here)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 30.825 0 Td (permanently," he spends several months)Tj ET Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm (each year in the United States with Applicant and other family members, \ and all other family members are U.S.)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 44.931 0 Td (citizens.)Tj -44.931 -1.125 Td (Decision at 6. )Tj 5.776 0 Td (In effect, Department Counsel contends that the Judge improperly shifted\ onto the government the burden)Tj -5.776 -1.125 Td (of demonstrating that the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 10.275 0 Td (father is not in a position to be exploited. )Tj 16.664 0 Td (Given the burden of proof on Applicant, and)Tj -26.939 -1.125 Td (considering the nature of the United States/Taiwan economic)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 24.714 0 Td (relationship as the Judge found it, the Board concludes)Tj -24.714 -1.125 Td (that it is not plausible for the Judge to conclude, based on this record\ , that Applicant's father is not)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 39.532 0 Td (vulnerable to)Tj -39.532 -1.125 Td (exploitation or influence. )Tj 10.33 0 Td (The fact that Applicant's father is an ordinary citizen and small busine\ ssman with family)Tj -10.33 -1.125 Td (members in the United States)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 12.025 0 Td (does not eliminate the need for Applicant to offer substantial evidence \ as to why the)Tj -12.025 -1.125 Td (father's situation would not lead to exploitation by a foreign power tha\ t is)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 29.59 0 Td (an active collector of foreign economic)Tj -29.59 -1.125 Td (information and industrial espionage against the United States, especial\ ly when: \(a\) Applicant's father and his family)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 46.973 0 Td (are)Tj -46.973 -1.125 Td (dependent on his business in Taiwan; \(b\) the father lives in Taiwan mo\ st of the year; \(c\) the father purchased and placed)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (property in Applicant's name in)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 12.872 0 Td (Taiwan without Applicant's knowledge; and \(d\) the father deposited mon\ ey in a)Tj -12.872 -1.125 Td (Taiwanese bank account in Applicant's name admittedly as a way of avoidi\ ng)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 31.337 0 Td (inheritance taxes.)Tj -31.337 -2.125 Td (The Administrative Judge's analysis of FIMC 5 is facially inconsistent. \ )Tj 28.648 0 Td (The Judge found that Applicant is the legal)Tj -28.648 -1.125 Td (owner of property in Taiwan valued at)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 15.633 0 Td ($230,000, and concluded that Applicant fell within FIDC 8. )Tj 24.163 0 Td (Yet, when)Tj -39.796 -1.125 Td (considering mitigation, the Judge relied on Applicant's uncorroborated s\ tatement that)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 34.31 0 Td ("he personally has no financial)Tj -34.31 -1.125 Td (interest in the parcel and that it was essentially, a gift . . ." )Tj 23.401 0 Td (The Judge also then concluded that Applicant was only a)Tj -23.401 -1.125 Td ("partial")Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (owner based on his use of the word "share" in his SOR Response. )Tj (Decision at 6.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (The Judge's analysis of Applicant's "partial" interest is incomplete. )Tj 26.948 0 Td (If Applicant owns the property, by gift or otherwise,)Tj -26.948 -1.125 Td (he has a financial interest in it. )Tj 12.496 0 Td (If)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Applicant's interest really is "partial," the record does not indicate w\ hat part Applicant)Tj -12.496 -1.125 Td (owns, who the other owners are, and other details of ownership. )Tj 25.827 0 Td (Applicant stated that the property was being used for)Tj -25.827 -1.125 Td (the father's retail watch business. )Tj 13.454 0 Td (Government Exhibit 5 at 4. )Tj 11.165 0 Td (The Judge seems to assume, without)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 14.859 0 Td (evidence, that a)Tj -39.477 -1.125 Td ("partial" interest in real property valued at $230,000 is minimal. )Tj 25.865 0 Td (Moreover, as explained below under the "whole)Tj -25.865 -1.125 Td (person" analysis, the Judge)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (relied, at face value, on Applicant's promise that he would divest himse\ lf of the property. )Tj 46.937 0 Td (A)Tj -46.937 -1.125 Td (promise to take a specific action at a future date should be given)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 25.963 0 Td (little weight where a person previously made such a)Tj -25.963 -1.125 Td (promise and failed to perform on it. )Tj 14.496 0 Td (The record shows that in his sworn statement to a Defense Security)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 27.16 0 Td (Service agent in)Tj -41.656 -1.125 Td (January 2004, Applicant )Tj 10.053 0 Td (stated he would "sell the property under my name in Taiwan and transfer \ all the proceeds to my)Tj -10.053 -1.125 Td (bank account in the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 8.053 0 Td (U.S. no later than 2004" \(Government Exhibit 5 at 4\)--but when he resp\ onded to the SOR in April)Tj -8.053 -1.125 Td (2005, he admitted that he still owned the property and again)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 24.271 0 Td (promised he would divest himself of "my share" by the end)Tj -24.271 -1.125 Td (of 2005. )Tj (Applicant provided little information about his overall financial intere\ sts compared to his)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 39.518 0 Td (financial interests in)Tj -39.518 -1.125 Td (Taiwan, and as explained above, there are significant gaps as to the nat\ ure of his property interest in Taiwan. )Tj 43.762 0 Td (Given the)Tj -43.762 -1.125 Td (burden of proof on)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Applicant, and considering the available record, the Judge's conclusion \ that Applicant demonstrated)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (that his foreign financial interests are minimal and not)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 21.91 0 Td (sufficient to affect Applicant's security responsibilities, is)Tj -21.91 -1.125 Td (arbitrary and capricious.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Finally the Administrative Judge concluded that, based on the whole pers\ on theory, it was clearly consistent with the)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (national interest to grant Applicant a)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 14.884 0 Td (security clearance. )Tj 7.689 0 Td (Included in the Judge's analysis was a review of Applicant's)Tj -22.574 -1.125 Td (educational achievements, citizenship of family members residing in the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 29.213 0 Td (United States, his partial interest in a gift from)Tj -29.213 -1.125 Td (his father, and his claim that he intends to sell his Taiwanese property\ . )Tj 28.409 0 Td (A Judge's decision is not measured by a)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 16.177 0 Td (standard)Tj -44.586 -1.125 Td (of perfection, and we assume that the Judge did consider record evidence\ unless otherwise stated. )Tj 39.237 0 Td (The problem here is)Tj -39.237 -1.125 Td (Applicant's failure to present)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 11.788 0 Td (substantial evidence that the potential for pressure, coercion, exploita\ tion or duress in his)Tj -11.788 -1.125 Td (particular case is sufficiently low so as to overcome the government's)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 28.033 0 Td (significant security concerns. )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 11.94 0 Td (See)Tj /TT0 1 Tf (, )Tj /TT1 1 Tf (e.g.)Tj /TT0 1 Tf (, ISCR Case)Tj -39.973 -1.125 Td (No. 04-02233 at 5 \(App. Bd. May 9, 2006\). )Tj (Even if Applicant's interest was "partial," the Judge drew)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 40.766 0 Td (speculative)Tj -40.766 -1.125 Td (inferences about the lack of security significance in such an interest i\ nstead of relying on record evidence. )Tj 42.65 0 Td (The Judge's)Tj -42.65 -1.125 Td (decision indicates that she)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 10.719 0 Td (relied on Applicant's promise to dispose of the property interest, but a\ s indicated in the)Tj -10.719 -1.125 Td (discussion of FIMC 5, it was not reasonable for a fact finder to rely on\ )Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 28.438 0 Td (such a promise to take future action, where the)Tj -28.438 -1.125 Td (limited record that was available already demonstrated that Applicant ha\ d failed to perform on such a prior)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 43.012 0 Td (promise to)Tj -43.012 -1.125 Td (do so. )Tj (Significantly, in this case, Applicant did not appear at a hearing befor\ e the Judge where the Judge would have had)Tj T* (the opportunity to evaluate)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 10.997 0 Td (Applicant's demeanor and credibility. )Tj 15.259 0 Td (A "whole person" analysis also considers the potential)Tj -26.256 -1.125 Td (for pressure, coercion, exploitation or duress \(Directive \266)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 23.112 0 Td (E2.2.1.8\) and the likelihood of continuation or recurrence)Tj -23.112 -1.125 Td (\(Directive \266 E2.2.1.9\), and for whatever reason, Applicant continue\ d to hold an interest in a)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 36.886 0 Td (substantial business)Tj -36.886 -1.125 Td (property in Taiwan beyond the point where he promised he would sell what\ he owned and recover the assets into)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 42 0 obj <> endobj 43 0 obj <> endobj 44 0 obj <>stream H\j@}l.lhNENRYe5}gC t?Ysv]]3ݷU97ܷ7_9q"6uS Y].%\ܝ L!G\'ᛯ7bv̄ŭ~n0lLg)RvM8y-0%رd++pErmLvk/NAQ$[x|IJXy ^*2j&Z3ك)f(T5SIp u dI,i%4eH+JoLLp&u&'tK3~ZEӪUO OOHP&<棺y/14: vmg$w+C endstream endobj 45 0 obj <>stream H|XT3""M{w,(64XCDM JMTX](}*v}b\¾Y{g̹g}3!BCiѺqn219\7GIԈosY$ C,@6ż&@ qPltD o Vnol|bR*KOhgAZߥs8kGGs~||OqBˆщ6'JFE'ljO(j5v \cP6(QP($v\lA4govV%dTBG-/Bn ]=Ba ҩsm:nuyyoаJ-i:_YI&M5ԯEV۴ h׾CN|Ե[={}ŗ*$|?~38vaqG$5:1cƍ '%OmJiSgϜ1;sy,\x ,]|EU׬]gXa&ڼe붜;vڽ'wᄐ?|hᱢ'N:}8_Zvpt\\; ~TGphSh[ȇBh,M4I+fYBN ilPx:*Vԓ+ϥJ)I .P*STҌdhj5ϴS:AWG箫ktMtt]G+eWSɾrs(r*ϔ+9O> ʧsU>PGc#Ofr M/`X]]=!>*d+@UWl%_ 9dj*JBVB?!B!%3pqBUl [HR{aRG*.Iץk hb4LM60m67ΡNC./8~)g?p(p?peR 9M-9zXUCWv?v6ݓR0^QS$:p*:Um #e-Tn;XYZ--,---,Z[YX[S(__ммʜ`^g_)24q9o524:L&&ӄ' xxȘo#D|LQNUNSNW*g(ӔʙY le&}z>/P5ml33XAQwܝamqwwwJ) Cݵ wH)A8[' r$7-r&r%w=r's)9ayDqyBi<#?ɟsù\_owS%g9y^^%yY^Wuu]CԵtm]Gt}@7ԍtcD7ts7MT_ P 55T S5RR56vBU W$5YE)j9t RҭuVsBԯkAwԝNKV{^OWAuHVGQuLW'lO}IuiD('}/ⅸ&^Wx+މd^|$RD(G.IR&CD  SH((IY((erQnCy)_~}?(-PQ R!*LE(P1 ugEw=FtzJũ *E rT*PO= BF4&d)44fz^7z{A}TTJUa.KVf2/8=g3s8spNŹ9|ͤYbw h7 pA7֍s.ąu$bŹ .ť].O w%r\+w-sEĕ Wj\kpMŵz\pCndsn͸9܊[f=܎sȝ3w-M[w{'܇r?x CmbL3D8ǝ0Hl |Ȁs<1_GfdAVds;G]@NBnq"/+|(((@18J$P QeQQtD0** jj!1)9Z%Z5ڠvhN.n-z;4Lgt5 }1uA]Hvވt]T]ҁ.+`vd6&A!abcFbFc bcB0Hs0 )iYFl6[Vl7;N6{^sN3Ls\6W>0,;αs<;.  SgxxWx7xwH{|G|B2s4ms5qs\5us_G:'(ďcX?ΏD?_/+*_&oߛOQI1P&w~g'Eӿ?|W{T{gvQ1(2*Ebk]@1MTx56zQh|5EǘcD1V;jj ,Jt.|5OG1q\|*NI7qJ|.Nk+x\!2/jICu 86MZvi.ү~JaZ:Cw_䅢Q3+=!:nk©WSVCۖO[h.uSZ^X߼ 8 # < 0y:L2WksBZ洒c'@x/Be&q2N:JK൵.p}u_d%I=w-(faDJ(` 4Bᩣe=?`8kxWo"0Gɇ*jb+77y]=q#x vlC}GKvb^kΉ\Q)~*$>RJ%(rH6ȊΈۋc9Xc| Q'x0>x_+8zGgxӹ+x fwo+ƈ~!'s2j:%Oa;{2pڷ}ږvbKgpr?^sf6̦PJnėҟ!sy.Qaw> u}pY1C/ge ̕?aj`l{(SѕDYrE;x kζvvnɵ߷7MdJG> @؋hPn"I"MIE`DΒ 9yM6趞"d0azZۈįIOƬh6SwzݜC؁*77!j8C\q]y(#9ph;ND m,K4HլA46ɕzQ3!6UbyTĹ7UOxAni)6/@2 qT..LH1U=eT?-'n0v/ qѷJmr#|E )(.q)I۪DȆ"vșN%_~H 3C 7L%Ȯ34+m:syH)%ʤ}'˟^^p\dL},U N({ߧّ䨣YcUMp |/v̗q|HqG23\r8}pWMTNH}3{?D.~ɵȺ\1Rdܥ˨<+*Ug;f#:dpԔ'%&Z|>b{8{z{d];w TE T׌$$鹹iV]/AC ~CCSc ==2#g#9RCcR5'ܺS _s>͸CӉ '­˻8֬j B3~S}i| KE,o\X-J褏+~#6`PQ!66{B-P՝Ƹ8W]߃E{zekIKnn.];BRh%u-C+ӠWF2L ebc1nmtrvk&FZ>O >JXq F/eYbm(5M$i7Zp4N̍@L@D$BtWѳrՓ`lFF GLzGE3ebC&l4uzt x٘?n`frCyE<8BQrf6JM"@ PF]aW.+*o^2L H ջ*@Diɶ}6]tz\X$8ܜ$~\ ~$G\{E.EzvgLMTahuJD,tmF3D3ļo}ħmQ:eQw6Pems N. 㰧Fvض=%kD(_iU3K^ʂ\Sӂc nG>L 1 o"pJ +Nup+z7j7LITc*r vn#YCOE̫~my98*O˚o~' ^(l6qXkXYF0XVXmȏ1%$|V\$b=<#!E+,f˳ciLv_Z}8a|\TB:n͉5f~ڍSrLjr * 3SPf客T o f ` \7qWRbn@T(h3G#v19rt+JP@40ifv:ioˀd21 `] 1F5n}qTSt^i_6lz`vE$)kn+L0$$,cۈĸi9(:6y)Pפ~}W퇉3[w罣Q%Ub 3--;y-- ? [;Tהę$/w$S+3އ 4c[䑱;&p7GJfMu]1Aqmp\ސɑdA%O¡2} lx7f "@(G!xeēןz}t,4K- kqTejߞ]Ooc&14(RL3qSRoӌBH+GRyVW Q\`IL >(.:5ʳ6>m,3:m6 1J:3>p-j-?Lׯ=o»Us n{.aW_&MqiZl*oz$d&IGv_z@ *~d: %^D0/7c˼ ǔ9ﯼٍ2׬UK{a!:s,:O|tbi[/_:4u?4 BoKK,,jOо~b]ߓߖQ%e..NZ Gq.5ZęYc!ӑDNBnw縆TR"N:©1GFJtU$&?+Mr} 1j8nKqQs:eT+̬ڠy2?'OZQ8-,CSj<7S$=17 *9}1Zr@9ICk`@>m_2Z\4y s;/f9*w j_"e3 UkUo.e(%hI"nQuCWHJ t; w.&3{Jl|svN0&BJA?ZmЖ&!IJJl]5, ǀn`&6mզIiRWuTm$a.vy,<W +Tm;} ɽJ¯7@,tKHȺPEh4 ^IdYc#B+3QPBE<IKcG NFN*uWw]zE$rg-IAPô n:[j?9Fh.~˶Bʪ>gD2h."hAr$JRGG3sY͓ 뢋7D>tpl8@h Xӷ3Di ;:VtnI']]xڶSJXMh)x1ehsP׋SPhH8^F#xH0@91̿ȿS8ο?sLuy*5ef`3,sp#+O"M֡&ʑ:F,X&ț%&$ A${W)SU)/"G^Enc(M'-'8vp(^+KJgc̓;6?smm瞴4'w9֮l`-,^O<o=OBkA1`9sH#XBu&hɐ|P-ZQ61jr#t/cDt1ϒxGkt\_m gVk`y):L tzo70NxRQy&4%ݞ$tRr:­g]??SdbE}elsn_Σ۱ܑ[/j{v.s}t) Z=36׆/Ū,±\EnhZ"kL3U7l^f JJ"I 8$)+dYEF%zDRjHk%Nĭ<@L$Wı֓x;.NDAҲU&qJХta)N)[r+ :Vȣacww}G>_uIĉ5[c̮,p롯?D}-)L,TF|0>d⛚2T~fNԜM儹`mqκ6RU%U-gȹ[t[hpkѼMLcaɲh&9bf'4ţ02*aE9tU2OkV7iEy]܉F"|A$L$5Eb)$bHHZU|@3R) ! Gת;~ߔbk^bR$BI4 T=9},HItOnCMu8^~n  I@g (=D 3c<733&4~ܡk֮do_EG(2o/ţ%kG,[p%rFsn]4gXpq3.GzGxlGj1ֳcvMV@ٹ'Qݸjƃ##eSc]g>{lՖr+/h+?^F/|(Ńy?>?]])>@O XPQKW昇dMci5K)lMl11zni?;yMb.8ymʆs0kb+$db*4.i&*DK9u+fsՒJ1(R/z)k JjUVl,4i6YPΒ`_ $rTaTvs9Sy4)K@^X`o4ġTuxdcϊǮ#;:6j̋Ç;6nt/um߃m>{uK5ŗxDv6hDΠ;2qtkJuɆHpwk.8e>RHaR[]ٚ`sL[lmn[Rۚ^jOh0c\S*:+N\*Uɰ%،l1ϩ:K14_izfu_ȍ2&(M6ԇ9-sy׫uq5Np_lWil'ʖMQIQh٤$JÖmQ2IOf;,I,ש(Ƕ.4Mܴ+z,WtXbXEeubm!];@ @ }$;O%yŨ}ľ1WIr31X1g1-Kh||{oҮXK"f.W=o^D{Vׄ:3%&lP(|"ƃ5F9 b)R밋5 2Xe=Y '05ڨ^H*NQˍ&A$"f\hn`ofzљ|w)t7s}s_il{άjڅɜU JSd@- *`m7e9l +y%v3M`E03DS7aZnW0ar{7퇭[hA\L]E:jK T}gnsly6].Kq̬~q5kt.5 ӃsGWSq#2 搦*ePJ`C0pdVi^B_7q{qs"!7"@@y[Gwzk!ŜrjzgV|^|\{splc$vLd ntjyǪykfbye6QGzMB p!f6YpX D|Uë֕ m?$5]upy~U lZRu9[0FDQzipPGÝ0g$23>`d(*ǛS 1B%H )AJ{ȶwxjj t~ɺ% 1DӴ^2Ad$ 1kIѲͲq'Lx<[ .ǖeh7Ɂ")p}SRPN%Z"׻2LSd6'3V S_AX=@܆ Ndp!6!mW =z D ćbey~ʌ m͛3V_Y @ۢ("z!=!.drplv; @8i%0Qt&r3$RFtՋX_0 fgm;X+(ѮL!Sw'vg݆{JN2pDyOS8O/<[ SnPPj ƵR a'lz(6HYrRD[p7w B{뱯^h$F-rn`Z5ŠG-}q߃'u]A>?p۵zA SuE oDn8&^ӊƎAH|tcxџ3;<[mUoxproo`_z <>9p}! ^_W+/.]^_G{ Idfhr=?;aq㣗f H"j4L J<r$\[fY^Bg1M"Ed2]*EwitT5LQ%"z>b=KdzKfqhSv#xXW4!ޯa1ŋȨV~gÒ "(Vr~Z2ӝ.)9JL'5bDZIV= $zY磊F̘֠Hډ>OzFz`v1X?^+uN f.L=jDn5JرEHa!K$p^A_Cg~kǬgF.h˦.:km0V퍰OϊB0@\0|ήnjW{dY7[Bkn60$:e(r`PPҁ32 4qӆ)tL;pҩK~e,xB뙣3>Q[7Վ'.g RYk,Jh竍˚Z*{+t(mزF9xX9̄lĐ;N)c:%L95aUu 0E1wIؙ6nC|y!6](+kyDpk+,&D"?d)ЫsC^Fo'՘##KhO_jWITKcpB#,Kr}$F\@| ~t;|:C?LKibw)I/jN̼c)QSz$_~IRڵP1w7j=۽/v zF[F4cPZ03ngp}9kZqCu=& T{j垭Z [ h V$~Pqںsāc(Oǀ @Aei(ty$ FpCoC՛~TuŨ/@`~0*)1nhe@С ֯Ci&=i:\(d<0B MG:q@)hbE! 31t*Oѯv)'1A@$D #1/BD"H&yO2y^y-:w|2.b~(sꪕ0pDh_0k7(c1m,h( n11/_W?2Vƛk7Wj,-Y(U^Y5-ǏRd|j/#"C~|#,c[:{yNeZT&/C;2N77ZԜٳyd"פA;<&b0PgI8= qE)$Zə6+N3nJmIF[\SNRyI D?IU4*/ݑIs ޕ%oFe4{5}r]}CP 5>[H苰KǺhMz|ZI:yMrxt#X᡼kY,􋔩T6Zҽû{y 9ͨs3?BO_(BBoPp6WY J;J1crqVۗf75 %u c&Q ѷX:bTNmtGJ^ XU):sX ryVI,ƾZ?+;pY43h5g~YE(  ˠZj-De3j SX> U7`5E//nC+7Io)bڱeuw5{tē[]r59gY:P.| 奷\}?lcu{P=?4]FdGCK`=;j ۏD#Aj_9B 8à" ,Ljqqb\ı9D8)@fB1w`rD3 *950υ^І紪i}Ǩ/FH^EMr:o RfjY"T |Ըij5D +o3|<{eyr ra;4u\7vrĕ0w6f7?ͽExxi,)b̰mw7E³\̖hXb,]1)sL H=UfI@5!r*SN˰9\ByB~J),:/R&5J)$[6"()H#nA''n߉v+\(K 0&dSˮZw%n=]M 3ړ(B<,5/<ٲ?NKjCUՠ Tٰ4k-`:it|k@ ID l1Ѐ߼[]5l,awpsJI<+,t*G)Dcv- >8;>rK{Eu]}owDvN*ֿ:jB iM`lզAѨ4IgV0 1A+ :j#MbZc1tw9w{w,]278_z)i1zfĠĴڕ ={Rx ִn@dt}8`|o ;8]\iNөy=9=.={A]\_1U LUKnݧܦOO}xTjoo-8ˮ0ސmS˽] S0o+5z}I/9K"[N'"qu5WrKK3BSW+URR_`bZgLwWd{eT|DYn}z/=!:3z܉KMj+Iс9~5O?S'rsf}vxjjY)^f}15 13>Cl3L 7krKQA[Lg;*ܑAZ޽Wx~f$/ r %xS <,_I?3.i3Jy&@k?,fvZ[ٷgli1R~eI{)IـoK,78Y.dq,Y|.FDGciy*Y9ը).C<ٹTf=!>9>UD4wi=xVq1x2Vx&/E_\Y򈥘g YY()[]%mW+,}j >Z1(.>B6;ɷ;ToN~?Fu5^-Y8rqK1}HT3x*7sMBڨ΃笠O\d \Hr:X\2F֙c:ŭOr[8bw.RxI;:J%3F &zkOesuZFr ܋ZFTB3%oB y*^ f8 .v4tNHf2;꣥gA"Q4Y5)je8*/](Wϒ;ğiX!4Y< }tLA^kZ>9#*Wt]^mM/~yl D|]plmmا^5c3;Nf0+A( ݽG{Z~(E{ %AR^D%5@yP*bEkQZ0@)yMf旳{8!'Cŷ0qȗ`,ΆΤFP˵v [ϟؿu?cCn 稠jpVX:I jG3 ǚAGSx-Kdde>En~FiwAuDca_p]c!M:Anh%VGN)Zkfwȑ9Zwlow5wӠ1~ ЫnWs HBo<^>4՟?<7 ^F;oA ր ~cЖ< &'\ƣ1’ RᩝHiXm;"DH]$/Uu=Qʭt+ON7_&˸Ǻ#|}GC.2q#nq6goSߩ H"ķ'-f/*+ĦA IkqO1 ٗ9 U]BXWiV6ȚM])N2`z*23_Nwdl_k!ك[L!}^G>q!Y}hz[çrSDž?#Zi>rEרSl;>`/E<Ϣ1V_oLj# c}'#7B6{Wӥ7Ч>JN0hX:*)|瘶?#ElHw j)';k3~oPΓ4ۛ9#} \L_Sy3{5&{~ƌ~s(|LRK"V/Ot ^tq~ gҽ!W: |vz[,jm{M]zWnZ;EY+@OkyC} ZjnD::dEV-zamk[үQzfm-}]r\D_7eo6}8Ḑ&;Vg NN)an2a]΢(r,zaIlrj`Sd-]Ǿ\X0NĚX}8۬?Ӵi^{z '0 o?E^hl=ex+،0^0w[EKN n*բh- 8CU޻_@3ԑwYE㓉6@oJPt:Op9zkGz՛eV) cVhs/|SezImj4M^j-W 0H o'|Lf.bccoPh::;hD\xXu HK41]k^ߐp_?/5XcA`2O0?3*TwmX-7݋Rh"zAK69CҶ F:YsJ {9B1 J߯ȧ.f*ydu ;Y{<݃oYr]7tnr{CywB*Zw砀ɾ1^1{sR 2k{ r<j& aV^U}es,Zd\,0L-Xgsčg1]9áK2OkVOn^OMM_@}D·i}]-1.]!ooQ$O~G-Sa xGwQ\q%-S@RcE$HGAl + B$% AEBJ pRx ~ 1ϙݙ{9N MSCyN6~}<'ڑw?@pnGwrm/'4u" uYI4=n5`{\#3dANG^6vU=Ir ]{B8u"g ox\\KLL@f}y5i3׵'գO֓Q|g-m'<ʶ]B},x$y9Ջ;Uj>ؙZe)٬q\}*Dd3BR\٬NDo޸^*ڱ,c>ה\iw^z5D9 <ɓ *FVgs?VO6i1t7kFΔ7ϼX3߷aAsmҞ׻m#~$< }#c8u-RM8F͜!q^sf>>a7T_Ao~) ) asb/cEP2Gh'7&Ӷ, E\-u!Y Est+<Dz*FIlg }80ʵZ!y7<̷>PugXd;&9tSuND=:zڷ$YX&d>x|[w~$YB  4mSNTN;7$::|wk]fmJSU]KZtc \V7= Nv+^ER0 t92~[p//MvCщ"؝+F&z ޛx xJr ~&H=s/7`UbճZ?` T&+eҪm skL=N= ;X4^3~2I |LV3Yk]BnM~UMo>k`VXx M M(E+|I +lqI4$q=HƔO~wf!pFs3ScX8ŭtTv|#d96ẋ?ޗ?:/|`D?3m8689/TcvC`& itH0~21Ǡd{j+Enc}(C\tx-ME*X)L8No$Ht rYṉu>+M\\6Y72e<l'#,T{4#W,OPr=v\vbUUS76H]߉BMuiC=NQǘjjUC'&#a?87R7q^a0뱎+cYוj w"?ӈW2WuĜ$~?\rM; t.>}ϣT?8@es%Fl~=B_"1{hc,)Ze=cw\ܧ"罉/(+9ƅLl=cb|g 1_1ND[> uD)J#?iShV$P k14B*6P \3w@)jFƫϼ73oޛvw׀{S3*;Uw'~@8l5MU^_ %s?~\tw"/w^~#;x.w:Du˽ c_|,>$ T{~˝Νem -?q}b_ro당d>q/_|8[n<\[iE C,ͻYDP iGP -J~y_ܢa ~{f,x̾W|D|QD @ͳsDq$72D͟! ZhsDm!jߦP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( mш+.MOt&zsNB! ^#Z4'П,LlA@?^н]Ћi9KS >҂ 悮tW :ނۂs :S =O,jjK@$ шY^ h#KF̄)Sƶc}Ҳ@:ށ6&- \mèC;1QzFq|$|) = }sq7 -pJK"0[>4X]F(C\xZpBfhDVsI22(f2_X#q߸k'Q\7,k\wCC)*-/-iܼ"iTڐ\iC!J+"w)܃bPŇF«|_za7p>gb_ à(wMM^mR YDM`|LlJ;Ʉ1s媬UP ֙p,;F &6Z{4JO3褻`uq͊p5Jx xI:.PK WԞק%Z8P2-wJv[ܩIޥ1Zl(wJp[PQIIy9ߟwp)ݺ{q0xKxEd{:Ћfȿe O?At1dUʅpU+=vD4pU_E-ָ*aaUMaٹKY{CV?v9gsC vy{m}k~Of6kNv6_ GqBf)6o~ԧ6)%.2a4l+(^ K6!oBeZG4.Ew}޶|(x_ZѲKpY<ez?cIͱr'dSU%<5ڲT]6($ )|{6D|]hڀ݆Ce/ ̝o=q46.. F6y;l>O랽ld' =uUs}h3QN WUHd$TÍ8opcF}XōQ!fvh *=]Ùi#(,$; ͬ> tB)3%BKoQ 4b:ᶤ m1-fYXVcO]:3a55 p?zg1kӂ^hv;?X-&(,b):52SR尉@!&]E>Do 5fă'o$ƛc ٓf5F/tMξf5~4 ޡ=מ&,W,2A73ABzӇpK}C:㖚&[ bD/p=ߠI#K{t@(whohvr.]w`',=҉="x ."+6#׉Eb%կZFRUիzTEEjC%>1zܧQ^_a)V*λ'1,~dR:S[d]nSzWNJ=Bx\+$2V?Wm5ލjQ@]o2ajf*=Ϋ8F5;OO{kb.jˁ]#x A!A; ʒ l%`Mŵ6̹|dg!# 2G'90لLm.@H"1Hr&˸-ۂ(bA0iuIYD3XPV ƎC5#:H< endstream endobj 14 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 1/Type/Page>> endobj 46 0 obj [48 0 R 49 0 R 50 0 R 51 0 R] endobj 47 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (04-03720.a1)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\ ved%20-%20HTML/04-03720.a1.html)Tj 50.24 0 Td ([7/2/2021 3:27:44 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm (worked in the field of architecture for a)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 15.993 0 Td (period of time. )Tj 6.165 0 Td (He later returned to school and in December 2003, completed a)Tj ET Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm (Master of Science degree in Computer Science. )Tj 19.271 0 Td (Since July 2003, he has been)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 11.803 0 Td (employed as a software engineer for a)Tj -31.074 -1.125 Td (defense contractor. )Tj 7.857 0 Td (In September 2003, he completed a Security Clearance Application \(SCA\)\ .)Tj -7.857 -2.125 Td (Applicant did not know that he owned property in Taiwan until January 20\ 04, when Applicant's father told him that in)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (2002 he had deposited monies into a)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 14.858 0 Td (Taiwanese bank account in Applicant's name as a way to avoid inheritance\ taxes,)Tj -14.858 -1.125 Td (and later used some of the monies to purchase commercial property. )Tj 27.546 0 Td (In his)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Response to the SOR, Applicant)Tj -27.546 -1.125 Td (acknowledged that the property is )Tj 13.801 0 Td (worth $230,000, but pointed out that he has no financial interest in it \ and intends to)Tj -13.801 -1.125 Td (sell his)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (share by the end of 2005. )Tj 13.414 0 Td (Applicant also claimed that he no longer has the bank account previously\ disclosed to)Tj -13.414 -1.125 Td (the government.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Applicant returned to Taiwan at the end of 1996, in 1997, 1998, 2001, an\ d 2002. )Tj 32.493 0 Td (He went for pleasure and stayed with)Tj -32.493 -1.125 Td (his father while he was there. )Tj 11.968 0 Td (He did)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (not go in 2000.)Tj -11.968 -2.125 Td (Administrative notice is taken of the fact that Taiwan is a stable democ\ racy and it has a strong and well-developed)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (economy. )Tj 4.166 0 Td (At the same time, it also has been)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 13.691 0 Td (identified as one of the most active collectors of foreign economic)Tj -17.856 -1.125 Td (information and industrial espionage against the United States.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (B. Discussion)Tj T* (None of these findings of fact are in issue.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 7.156 -2.125 Td (Whether the Record Supports the Administrative Judge's Ultimate Conclusi\ ons)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -7.156 -2.125 Td (Based on these findings of fact, the Administrative Judge concluded that\ the Department Counsel established a )Tj /TT2 1 Tf 44.627 0 Td (prima)Tj -44.627 -1.375 Td (facie)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 1.943 0 Td ( case due to Applicant's family)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 12.565 0 Td (ties.)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 209.7695 429.75 Tm ( \(1\))Tj ET 0 0 0.933 RG 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 209.7695 429 cm 0 0 m 13.806 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 223.5757 425.25 Tm ( )Tj (Also, the Judge found that even though "Applicant did not purchase the)Tj -17.298 -1.125 Td (commercial property [in Taiwan], valued at $230,000, he is the legal own\ er of it,)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 32.601 0 Td (which constitutes a second)Tj -32.601 -1.375 Td (disqualifying condition.)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 130.6562 399.75 Tm ( \(2\))Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 130.6562 399 cm 0 0 m 13.806 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 144.4624 395.25 Tm ( )Tj (As the Judge indicated, in such situations an applicant is responsible f\ or presenting witnesses)Tj -10.705 -1.125 Td (and other)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 3.999 0 Td (evidence to rebut, explain, extenuate, or mitigate facts admitted by the\ applicant or proven by Department)Tj -3.999 -1.125 Td (Counsel, and has the ultimate burden of persuasion as)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 21.773 0 Td (to obtaining a favorable clearance decision. )Tj 17.631 0 Td (Directive \266 E3.1.15.)Tj -39.404 -1.125 Td (Department Counsel challenges the Judge's conclusions, contending that A\ pplicant's)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 34.02 0 Td (evidence did not allow her to apply)Tj -34.02 -1.375 Td (Foreign Influence Mitigation Conditions \(FIMC\)1)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 257.3125 342.75 Tm ( \(3\))Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 257.3125 342 cm 0 0 m 13.806 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 271.1187 338.25 Tm ( and 5)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 300.4448 342.75 Tm ( \(4\))Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 300.4448 342 cm 0 0 m 13.806 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 314.251 338.25 Tm (, or to conclude overall that it was clearly consistent with)Tj -24.854 -1.125 Td (the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (national interest to grant or continue a security clearance for Applican\ t. )Tj 30.238 0 Td (In effect, Department Counsel maintains that)Tj -30.238 -1.125 Td (the Judge erred by improperly shifting the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 17.079 0 Td (burden of proof on mitigation to the government where the Applicant fail\ ed)Tj -17.079 -1.125 Td (to produce sufficient record evidence to mitigate the security concerns.\ )Tj T* (An Administrative Judge is required to "examine the relevant data and ar\ ticulate a satisfactory explanation for" the)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (decision, "including a 'rational connection)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 17.083 0 Td (between the facts found and the choice made.'" )Tj /TT2 1 Tf 19.053 0 Td (Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Ass'n of)Tj -36.136 -1.125 Td (the United States v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co.,)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 20.636 0 Td ( 463 U.S. 29, 43 \(1983\))Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (\(quoting )Tj /TT2 1 Tf (Burlington Truck Lines, Inc. v.)Tj -20.636 -1.125 Td (United States)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 5.36 0 Td (, 371 U.S. 156, 168 \(1962\)\). The Appeal Board may reverse the Adminis\ trative Judge's decision to grant,)Tj -5.36 -1.125 Td (deny, or revoke a security clearance if it is arbitrary, capricious, or \ contrary to law. Directive \266 E3.1.32.3. )Tj 42.437 0 Td (Our scope of)Tj -42.437 -1.125 Td (review under this standard is narrow)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 14.829 0 Td (and we may not substitute our judgment for that of the Administrative Ju\ dge. We)Tj -14.829 -1.125 Td (may not set aside an Administrative Judge's decision "that is rational, \ based)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 30.499 0 Td (on consideration of the relevant factors, and)Tj -30.499 -1.125 Td (within the scope of the authority delegated to the agency . . ." )Tj /TT2 1 Tf 24.79 0 Td (Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Ass'n)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 10.49 0 Td (, 463 U.S. at 42. We)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (review)Tj -35.28 -1.125 Td (matters of law )Tj /TT2 1 Tf 5.97 0 Td (de novo)Tj /TT0 1 Tf (.)Tj -5.97 -2.125 Td (For the following reasons, the Board concludes that Department Counsel's\ position has merit:)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (There is no evidence indicating that Applicant's father is an agent of a\ foreign power. )Tj 34.334 0 Td (However, Department Counsel)Tj -34.334 -1.125 Td (challenges the Administrative Judge's)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 15.343 0 Td (conclusion that the father was not )Tj 13.718 0 Td ("in a position to be exploited by a foreign)Tj -29.062 -1.125 Td (power in a way that could force the individual to choose between loyalty\ to the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 31.852 0 Td (person involved and the United States.")Tj -31.852 -1.125 Td (The Judge concluded that the father did not pose a "discernible vulnerab\ ility to pressure or coercion sufficient to create)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 47.863 0 Td (a)Tj -47.863 -1.125 Td (potential for foreign influence that could result in the compromise of c\ lassified information." Decision at 6. )Tj 43.174 0 Td (The Judge)Tj -43.174 -1.125 Td (reached this conclusion because the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 14.522 0 Td (father is "an ordinary citizen who maintains a small business in Taiwan \ as a means)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 48 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[210.0 427.0 224.0 438.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 49 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[130.0 397.0 144.0 408.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 50 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[257.0 340.0 271.0 351.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 51 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[300.0 340.0 314.0 351.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 12 0 obj <> endobj 52 0 obj <> endobj 9 0 obj <> endobj 10 0 obj <> endobj 11 0 obj <> endobj 58 0 obj (file:///usr.osd.mil/Home/OSD/OGC/JosephLM/_MyComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archived%20-%20HTML/04-03720.a1.html) endobj 57 0 obj <> endobj 59 0 obj <> endobj 53 0 obj [16 0 R/XYZ 0 344.0 null] endobj 54 0 obj [16 0 R/XYZ 0 291.0 null] endobj 55 0 obj [16 0 R/XYZ 0 227.0 null] endobj 56 0 obj [16 0 R/XYZ 0 161.0 null] endobj 4 0 obj <> endobj xref 0 60 0000000000 65535 f 0000000016 00000 n 0000000141 00000 n 0000003658 00000 n 0000172458 00000 n 0000003536 00000 n 0000003591 00000 n 0000003731 00000 n 0000003758 00000 n 0000171697 00000 n 0000171845 00000 n 0000171887 00000 n 0000171507 00000 n 0000004394 00000 n 0000161259 00000 n 0000121596 00000 n 0000118246 00000 n 0000003861 00000 n 0000003907 00000 n 0000003956 00000 n 0000004147 00000 n 0000004019 00000 n 0000004051 00000 n 0000004083 00000 n 0000004115 00000 n 0000004605 00000 n 0000010097 00000 n 0000010146 00000 n 0000010181 00000 n 0000010813 00000 n 0000011251 00000 n 0000064434 00000 n 0000064701 00000 n 0000030376 00000 n 0000030649 00000 n 0000011620 00000 n 0000011901 00000 n 0000012227 00000 n 0000031123 00000 n 0000065319 00000 n 0000118446 00000 n 0000121796 00000 n 0000132105 00000 n 0000132534 00000 n 0000132810 00000 n 0000133262 00000 n 0000161484 00000 n 0000161530 00000 n 0000170203 00000 n 0000170529 00000 n 0000170855 00000 n 0000171181 00000 n 0000171592 00000 n 0000172290 00000 n 0000172332 00000 n 0000172374 00000 n 0000172416 00000 n 0000172095 00000 n 0000171929 00000 n 0000172237 00000 n trailer <]>> startxref 172631 %%EOF