%PDF-1.6 % 1 0 obj <> endobj 2 0 obj <>stream 2021-07-02T15:33:33-04:00 2021-07-02T15:33:32-04:00 2021-07-02T15:33:33-04:00 Adobe Acrobat 17.0 application/pdf 04-07766.a1 uuid:76e06058-31c7-4495-a761-fd9fc534e4ec uuid:00c40062-ee45-44f1-968f-e59078a3420e Acrobat Web Capture 15.0 endstream endobj 5 0 obj <> endobj 6 0 obj <> endobj 3 0 obj <> endobj 7 0 obj <> endobj 8 0 obj <> endobj 17 0 obj <>>> endobj 18 0 obj <> endobj 19 0 obj <> endobj 21 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 22 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 23 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 24 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 20 0 obj <><><><><><>]/P 18 0 R/Pg 13 0 R/S/Article>> endobj 13 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 0/Type/Page>> endobj 25 0 obj [32 0 R] endobj 26 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (04-07766.a1)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\ ved%20-%20HTML/04-07766.a1.html)Tj 50.24 0 Td ([7/2/2021 3:33:33 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 734.2497 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 579.749 0 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 733.5 cm 0 0 m -0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 578.25 0 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 732.7503 cm 0 0 m 0.75 0.75 l 0 1.499 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 733.5 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 0.75 0.75 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 618.75 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 579.749 0 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 618.0003 cm 0 0 m -0.75 -0.751 l 579 -0.751 l 578.25 0 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 617.2497 cm 0 0 m 0.75 0.751 l 0 1.5 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 618.0003 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.751 l 0.75 0.75 l h f Q /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 749.25 Tm (DATE: September 26, 2006)Tj 0 -3.25 TD (In Re:)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (----------)Tj T* (SSN: --------------)Tj T* (Applicant for Security Clearance)Tj 0 -3.25 TD (ISCR Case No. 04-07766)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 17.628 -2.125 Td (APPEAL BOARD DECISION)Tj 2.806 -2.125 Td (APPEARANCES)Tj ET 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 261.2061 543 cm 0 0 m 89.338 0 l h S Q BT 11.25 0 0 11.25 251.0312 519 Tm (FOR GOVERNMENT)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -2.102 -2.2 Td (Candace Le'i, Department Counsel)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 2.879 -2.2 Td (FOR APPLICANT)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 2.722 -2.2 Td (Pro Se)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 16 419.25 Tm (The Defense Office of Hearings and Appeals \(DOHA\) declined to grant Ap\ plicant a security clearance. On June 2,)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (2005, DOHA issued a statement of reasons)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (advising Applicant of the basis for that decision--security concerns rai\ sed)Tj T* (under Guideline C \(Foreign Preference\) and Guideline B \(Foreign Influ\ ence\),)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 31.295 0 Td (pursuant to Department of Defense)Tj -31.295 -1.125 Td (Directive 5220.6 \(Jan. 2, 1992, as amended\) \(Directive\). )Tj 22.798 0 Td (Applicant requested a hearing. On January 27, 2006, after the)Tj -22.798 -1.125 Td (hearing, Administrative Judge Darlene Lokey Anderson granted Applicant's\ request for a security clearance.)Tj T* (Department Counsel timely appealed pursuant to)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 19.828 0 Td (the Directive \266\266 E3.1.28 and E3.1.30.)Tj -19.828 -2.125 Td (Department Counsel raised the following issues on appeal: whether the Ad\ ministrative Judge erred in applying Foreign)Tj T* (Influence Mitigating Condition \(FIMC\))Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 16.109 0 Td (1 and concluding )Tj 7.137 0 Td (that Applicant's family in Taiwan are not agents of a foreign)Tj -23.247 -1.125 Td (power and not in a position to be exploited by the Taiwanese government;\ )Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 29.909 0 Td (whether the Judge erred in applying FIMC 3)Tj -29.909 -1.125 Td (and concluding that Applicant's contact with his family in Taiwan is cas\ ual and infrequent; and whether there is)Tj T* (sufficient evidence to sustain the Judge's favorable security clearance \ decision.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 8.128 -2.125 Td (Whether the Record Supports the Administrative Judge's Factual Findings)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -8.128 -2.375 Td (The Judge made the following pertinent findings of fact:)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 287.2598 222.75 Tm ( \(1\))Tj ET 0 0 0.933 RG q 1 0 0 1 287.2598 222 cm 0 0 m 13.806 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 192.75 Tm (Applicant's eight siblings and mother-in-law and brother-in-law are resi\ dents of Taiwan. )Tj 35.614 0 Td (One of Applicant's brothers)Tj -35.614 -1.125 Td (works in the personnel department at the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 16.523 0 Td (city hall in his hometown. )Tj 10.666 0 Td (Another has a street cleaning job. )Tj 13.634 0 Td (One brother is)Tj -40.823 -1.125 Td (retired from a chemical plastics company, and another works for a compan\ y that)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 32.433 0 Td (makes boat parts. )Tj 7.22 0 Td (Applicant's four)Tj -39.653 -1.125 Td (sisters are housewives. )Tj (One sister is a widow. )Tj (The husbands of the other three sisters work as a street cleaner, for an\ )Tj T* (insurance company, and for a chemical byproduct company. )Tj 24.38 0 Td (None of them work for companies that are affiliated with)Tj -24.38 -1.125 Td (the Taiwanese government, and no one)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 15.911 0 Td (in Applicant's family is a member of the Communist Party. )Tj 23.871 0 Td (Applicant's mother-)Tj -39.782 -1.125 Td (in-law is retired. )Tj 6.831 0 Td (For between fifteen and eighteen years, )Tj 16.021 0 Td (Applicant's brother-in-law has worked for the Taiwanese Army)Tj -22.852 -1.125 Td (in a "desk job.")Tj 0 -2.125 TD (The only contact Applicant has with anyone in Taiwan is with one sister \ whom he calls every month or two. )Tj 43.573 0 Td (Applicant's)Tj -43.573 -1.125 Td (wife calls her mother about once)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 13.328 0 Td (every couple of months and sends her )Tj 15.357 0 Td (a total of $1,000 a year. )Tj 9.719 0 Td (Applicant's wife calls)Tj -38.404 -1.125 Td (her brother once a year. )Tj 9.717 0 Td (Applicant traveled to Taiwan in 1997 to sell a)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 18.578 0 Td (house he inherited from his father and in 1999)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 27 0 obj <> endobj 28 0 obj (.Kg$;) endobj 29 0 obj <> endobj 30 0 obj <> endobj 31 0 obj <> endobj 37 0 obj <> endobj 38 0 obj <>stream H\j0 ~ Cqb>Xpl%3,qC~]:OHvϝ5{p:֠eQ[3N~["Ν%6]p[`uFmAH^3ϲC)ov _gӸx0H;!Y F2_\Tèe`NUEpTD|n2#L.s^c@ǂ@tدfz endstream endobj 39 0 obj <>stream H|XϙsgwAQ0k ņk@^}D@ Kl1b[,XP"Ež+]؟%kwA/wg3{A,~ݼ՛V+ИqcUVjЦF P'@zpHJ~oݲ FzC羮E>_}on?  Aa 6<*zȘQnjq '4)Sc2=nY I̝<E.^trXr5k׭߰ќ6oغmvܻ/k܃;z,N)_x \XU-h` :_B^Hi*%lZCg%b_1X%&|sp#TjSP(ge+B)ׇGWsO  I_ F1V7025*F&c1Kr2 jUEuS=TmQjƫՅuCRsC!ΐ+PǨ{!^A>pHVS 8˜C"L8fn6̯6^io9ۻ{+88n+Q܇C+/Kj̕d&Dmۓeܗ-*6܎羽dS?^5]@%K֖$l)u/Ụ%%>%֞V?k{jֳYRfYXnVe9fɵX2eeb,9%278肮X nxs0!<[axGOQ<o PA=ЈxO`B< QE"<C6mhmvnCQl:@9JoCtPcOI*S#1}9*t.%LWDxJ5*RN7&ݢt=}z@e~GSzF^R,M_h:W4fQ<%vWy^[!1DaZ&19**Pά:sa"^xEj|Y[֎gXG:SօueXwփdA(J$t_z IߥGcy'ϐgʳx9ANy^n&Yn[6];.[{>_p.87A<$#<&<%ٹ\q:7uU&?_oyVyQ^yUWUtU]MW5tM]Kut]]O tCH7vYU/z>SAjajFnUTQjƫh5AMTd7nfn[V~_~趺ڡv]jڣ}j:C:cj:Nڞ:e3cS3\KJo;,R{$>,SP*%IÂ]c͆Ӱei9 3qfY9sɹ875Miw!X7s7Mp$.ȅ0q999r(\].uoKr).eܕ*wø,\+r%U*W\kr-u.3 7FܘpSnSK[pKnŭ vܞ;pG]R]ѕqw=>ܗĚ8oL"A 肺F ""L@:sP`0.g6&~AbcbcFbFc H1QK30 I)i ,g)fcbb0 C,D,$" KcVbVc bc6b6c bfv`'va{pP<Y;{~$8OS%ʉU9!1_tj6flfnvfmvbK油b}f9`vigvO/?yTR!a6`BDnn@F?Or3)f-4 ,0:0-bIQYbšdMeqJ瓁CF ^9kJH` ʋXjd63岾w9T1`uxZ"!SxiF>$L3~kvG# e 1[{DzQ(Wʫ:$Of{¾c'CإFcT6Sz<"~Y5`Nů֫׃ɉЂ'*@CyfX>SV,hH[& fbNKp_$bETF(yj ʿEԽGȡrlh8Y_XGG 0SXltާzYkQ*V\u WLs8+qC!"D`,?yQBիnh^`>Ly_;[o9NΒ^]qVˏ%y+cN8vxlضf?ȏcK*o .0m50J`+Wb1PdYPs K%֒`)eE'}=.c?Q񻬙Fلg;ۡ$xy WĈl/Y:P߁L^qѶ7g\PqziƇHQ֑Srԭ&J;iqTٮ0V~<uOo,btLmo)"I)% D(Yv*#I$$SFv#pȲ&Hl1H86,a8<;f7;ğEˬ6@ [Lv2'# !NV-Q:l oBMYNO5wsBg=+6Oi)4NU7Aq%/dmj;rMgNHA>D;]&I_SRNE,ʹ^yXVim4d{ 2S-lj*3wȥnσ oll)}]54H\wrsƎlÇ jOLrRb>Ȧ |ؘ# +4$*3JuHJ^Pfu/5x MO14O`<|Fuɬt8Եf6čϝzfʓ十r6&h*f02WV\'ksCR)P2M,* <ʕ)8 BeNSC$Fq匳JR 昣W7!lc9 K`m mКRT+܆{c_UeXq犞U%xxb _>n0=⛪t)5Ww-׫| n J#hGO|Qٰۍ3.,82i+e}U?ݘV56LnhΣ T%Fq)oȣfG===: Qn2؀=h^T2ӭ|nM՟]2"aڃ8Iwq~N-ےltpxGpM+055$&:xZԐtejdHd SҐ>e$ɔ68:i&ؾ~{2I7ﱷnKzhQ`ⷾLFq O1ygおcbRS 'tcww=qf#dm᲻bPvCrp:,'WyqXJP>鬂m=!"$޶U랐R4/^꤆L @qk !-j+`;> KE8RD͂/Jٱl""\|itR|YO-dtѽ:| [qd8ұl9Ϡ2v.`IȀeGx+;]/d;(}q@y< hVffdv *e%J_uQq6K& Z[[ OON_2d0pPj̛ ~z?gvlC?,Kf͢،9}o#?ӯ4oYbUyMecJ`=])0JY|暲 ;x\s8?8䬙DobL[3q rb`Z<pr榦抦t*m47 d#uYy34[lwo{ں⾹,k<0dc.Aa,3-pni!^t[8\=8ЇDSf"S7KpW?IUFx^KX1tn,_/ Mwniۻz_ UXVvox?|g7.YrJ[o'/?5ο-HF(Tb O׃:q1\y*KV*Qv%@jd:5*L DBN8E@@tC;yi,gم||2WFJXj-%Nh0BbsaOOg>jkD+ Ȍц/_z^LKuYWmx$Up+òTfL>s^ WՀD;=^FNgmsS:\8ɘ0挌ĕ:U'ݰȒ2rt:Ƅa2doȀ ߠ9} ʱR]wdO6Kz /V4}]CV.;HyTS`n KAo]IKc1:cQ=A7|Z!׿0%)2˽[e_26 o/=r~I-t8ωY[#%grN(QC9;lg;}Uwz6.(>sYi"a){a>rjGsB%=@pG!f|;0Wj.Nˑ0*NSI]eSWYSŸKVSb/[9 Nǜ Nt[E+%G/Z|FbVYxTq}Lꃷ ݚ2hz v4v5HϰC%Tf c/=!SC R={ |>=5\"hc˷PޫP}6S"vHny~*?S$FJAoMAlnp%MzB^8#+:; t+u&feQz'baDuz]Z` {p9-, Yݖ83Oc\ ]Y֞ndq| zo|aϰN׾]W#Ac"\{Nїd/yr'AlȾ<#ms0*M6O|6y\7* Lb3X}~=۾\ `WU<K {SF%o]h́1'R&P{wYS3Rk8h_hy%y{5:HK$,qɨ|$gh1ay;c:\W7KѺv (R6Shce[Yinb.;˥P߄yf8+BB[-wsDjh9h"-y"v_^ R<_y}/E wAzP_#:!@꯳Ddil'}Q{Mý[#'~>WMdK'6K=B?["@ e4&׊}ob83<܇w¥FIF`m`7p];XO@{~ ,p &ɰxR8U՜¢;?PV傏RLf1:[/p΄TsBE[(G)n3dtNr=Bimo9JQ xvV6d %R7[G &Im+{us5..aoA_Ca=]0c/m$g}L2ʕ}T+Z?/χ.Z#A`p .9mhڇ4"GS㚒 ОԺA=6e;)=w n#Lj >"(rx`#^ *gK ֥S!7'Z;x)|3/Է PGB Qjv@?~m nd 'goƠӭƷXDdw; A}{KU;"7O!#OxXપ#sKR:jJAQqӐR$Dd( Ra+F(F$!L" GDoϽ${={<iOG|Ro)ݭ I5+78%U= ^5M!>T*k~uZ ?p Տ oߠCLL|kIjz:ԒeeߠQbFˇQy/sN+\N܄ DnN,tɦAs =uǗqiZNFwQB,VjgΈnkuQ/0Ό;ibhҟ6+u+=5d+Z~]|}}!_gGMR#~Yn WH1 Ϲ㥼3sb`,\5#~}FUg57x?q X8^XjOzE[bdnIm6{'!L~.o`Kf ?y-;%ЗzX䳾\.dXsf qgP g!4x1&%^9,,K@I$0};94(움⒠/ #hspoks7]+ˀ Y =K$1K@=G踽9t.}7k{K '^`_ݗhPDO[|+v?z(; }I9mT!%k1Ξq@ay@kc[W.3󔓁x)bgeŋJF~8߯4Y ]&+{g~x7\sw.&&9`4 [R{MKXk/ƻ|лG<1IOe%Gq7NkBXZsB<4Kg|}}.f⺐/뉀*B=ރryܰUG괏Ӽl;lo >eb' Q7Ĉk/v=Ns Zq@+LTy:g#)YI=~ZD=Wc%БGo[눵tZ'7u!o'Y/b,w/ Ԣɾ|pW w+hpl6rAq>% LB..~1qXCo?m~IAʀZ` d^n %}&/bm/߃C@Rچ¾)|@R.Bd At/w;»*:pYr.<;9W7.78vzfX }nXr P_ҁaz͹xji}\?U7(]m\UC#Lu/j]9_mr4`Q=ë5)8>(WC ޯ⹞Ox!AGvb>(=nȿj;jQ9~B?8нT{;'#SȻ]rd 錹E~!64d쉂-;!vĬbƺa~OVtr,'NcXS UuG="AŜrj%=˘zFkG g bA,:>a'~#o}f{5ϐ{H/ g=mM:pٰ%:<퉨_:ZnI>d:6 l7&cvSqqNy;zD~w yzqYAہs`#PTo;t?/CD=rZvi_c,y ߃Fax7~yG Ki.h}آqƽgv;f;V]$1qʼnǬ8oc.(|m'|kϩ{VϾ>rЇ:mN{$UOJ#ށcޖ}P:YA F{雲ܑFTe Y0;A-i(x_B32C\5R}zl`_8/zB9 %7xDrz{K.y =){GzF \OrL/2Bw] Yz4#0PMe#ttgPrVR k59B()*ՋՑP, Ϫq&Ilykꡁr*UkJj*2ŹjHM51g2Lfa3*Jt>(,i~IQf61QSRkױ]_TWV7QLdDUqΞtxڕ'2Ej,8||7,XMelYN1_),+`˨9g=Sԑ 5*Y'Y̞ ~\_jl.]w 9L^g=H-eh_ dS038ݩ<ȏGhs Vr\5֡N25Aͯl,iONTl6iy(eX3 ga^>y1{$sL>f{ Ud(ѿC$Cw\F#A{] ǝ~mL\I"1Qwo#o QzH9-vb˞"WKRvotޒ3DS[kY.O*5*sl=F&\ܜ, 1WxӾԥL)6bX,bX,bX,bX,bX,bX,bX H*5k;hZ&@1k#p09'Irl51[>}cvgMG%jMv]lolE?1G #fӟ%"Ќֳ`$FqQQI&schljI /]Y6(4'T3ei&S#[̶dz;mF?h1zӪUkla린l?v=댟s_<![bI6CLɵMH uXعJM㥮kjJ>XK!@?gRܩSz:#Ͳ?⻇OhZY`Z'GrBQ=5f>2 ▗1m"԰12գ{@Y72,Sh83@|0Fr)#`tH*gtT1IkHLKYǦ%F2Oh%XLɉVih:b 1-'2͡m P +QCF>zY@+f+EE»H:d;fh*pItۥ@:4Wf\%r-Gzn5V\^+̢@D.E+] ʟS䲹ڭr*aP H@'2䫝*@=rR0Aɷ\ DMoѲ^Y=jkh-E?sڄl_8~9`>IIImүlҨMJ$&٤R׾+?RWjJ9譊 4g,B]x6i7U k+yB*ْf>OsH#x) \Yפ$ېL-Vo jM{L⢩>₩y&@#7߯5kiond\l)$oGشoQeA:ܤ@4t O"be!no7jcKk4OǡgǞ#{o7o}\U.~ΰZX1+u$Gu;6z\t7#2isX9~YBk/z .2ﷷq~>B,@!4j?Jw# P2PmcO11l&VF_vWNTa(]If{ mos:apHJL{<#J֓c5e֥VZ#Vq8Wr"5MESS^Dq _WƁG>&f!@P`:9khs k)0ƥ( ƧKrxG%lTQ0As<՝i|u>jvuTZ`]%9?9a - AcyXx!a&At1=vt p] }I37aapD ; rP{)"pG|,VA]SeTI3ДA}Us{f{[4r{֢q0;G x{S" t>V$Ux`۸^ssyKY Rxw]>(E랬ۂIe>g&a(!ɒU;Ld:҃>qvRtS . m% @bx@k3 C endstream endobj 35 0 obj <> endobj 36 0 obj <>stream H\j@{^htg+A/Cm & MXo99 a'_o7.M]$=wT뱍ٴpM[?>U}[z.+KyHWwjfKj4n>ֻ[.}'5zFOU\cݶvY߉kF}UkQrbҕ,3ͿقeCY,px28|:-3<{ Y9{. k?d Uz:{8{yyyyyyyyyyy ke'߃QQKKKKKKK+0W@\}|}|}|sقK]\M8>stream H|y\TG5o^p rxÛx5.͢o]ݸ1F$*E#^^77x+3:IfG]TwWUWOwHy~)1-' P$;"͐v@r@$!JQ~<:!Jx.v:= r 00I1@DB HIuB?|aⷓ2~򔩙ӦϘ9+kg/]K .[be5ku6lܴymwܵ{}#G?q3gp._rz h3Bb:1\f*uFJR4]*J/>rS 9Z,gʳC7`.]UW N N >|"$'%H V:)ݔJ/2N٪(Dy8 q!<~Sc_$4|*&_)TϤ7u1ŘC5~FFV@@ Sj:APչjNݬR%)zMg4573ǚIMk--E`GmG#q᪌|QզYՋ*g3͙tUwShޚ")LHLiT&FȽy9C)yԁBZ[ٳ>yz+i=ƻȻT|w>{|[mSݟ;c}=#!jҵZ[rkg^eo!I}{31 Lq)~ ,"q/>A>9b5b8@<8$N4~D,Pxٸx;"$c 0CH}X7؎Bc'!a'eҐDZ@%P.-Eth1*B O"oZJh9dUZZG멈6FDi ~%ʤiQ1mC5h'"_䏛(v Z4>O TR=:L%TP0*/p2Ltq:A'3Ja;,9:O"v{ԐQc]ę< ɳ8gx>gΑ8b%/<^ 2^+x%[$^ūy uxoMVm6q1own{y|a.#\G|Oi>gL[:.ѐ%Y+2:Y/{Ȟ|/eWm|+;||C#?t5*'OWS t8ssﲍADz DcfLB)w@8q 1F ץne|g2>|~xytNЉ:I'tЙ\kpM| _k|oMŷ3+J2ܫ{ ʏҵuѹ:O:@fs=UOzg#yz^Ez^FNG Y\+cZZN'zޤ7GEG.D.GD.-zަSSһgzޫ?8kq's rsgrl\΋..vNDŮ c쉽7p08,F8_Q8Dr>>7#w.Fܘ\q.ER\qUטBs\5p-3 \/h$5Hr#yԁsr3>"\[ >4Ch %h}=OL0 >=̀aGoO)>b,R,re a>B֐5e*C d" $E\bd-$eLi!KL2SfQ5 :ՠG@T(R((2(|IٔCGT -էԐQcjBMDͩL-e̥WJ vԞ:PGD?.W'QwA=>ԗQ@i !4|75w]s7Lw;yl)6%ԔAJAFd0N#h$Fh4XGu@ OMz~N+5Cw̅y0BXa ,e X `5s yo6iƚqfyLR[y o?坼K61_D A"b-bX*V"vb#_8d7qsڜ8%ΉK⪸)~Ex1< Je lɻ3\Ϲ_p eP*Tp!RH'Wd+Zˎ*޲i49Jm|OdrVxyr\$e1;[%׈NnvK_+y0F?#'O3,E#y[ޕE,J +*^U*Et2UmTUWW E3X5U-TKZUUGꬺzjj8jGH5FWoIx#y5D/\/+xM+^xCho7ћe&f1 "Ĭ0kl6[v5@mvc/+{~k?x .HF¤0- s^(l _ [m¶a}!v ;]®a{0{ {Ҟ{֞{^mbkao[vP/~sɹ:W5r#F]*Wz׺[ n Sn*sݹ-DKeh4/LXǂ[Ӎs7ѭ&nꦹnfl7u|#|q>'3e8>sﻏ{7w.F* ""RPBg)MJ !@i"ph M8g9ܙsEgQ%QS[ @>ނ "'`>EP$]E#+ԞOPH:GԒDL 6:r-A诔D)ޤuNԙP RunԝzP:^WL}/4Fi !'C#h$4>}LhP!Q1tR R9󺞮O_E?E.ew.VZUkSl*p0' \0aSC7ԍtcD7Ձ:Hf:D7ס:Lw1x):Up#u 5LuS4m궆iVk,Ykk}ֱum=[6 m#_:FtSҽuu_UwuE~{a{أ=nsm=aO|[` m-i{ƞ%Ԗr{VԪ'A.:Sww7C9#Ns9wr<(iqF%TrqNT₸*↸)~▸-~eNc.V}T_D62z_ gbP'baOUxRU&I̓j a2\F0WL 3ee>ef-/+d12VxR&0/'wf}@ fFg21{G15F{{.LdfDL6*DXBś(L5q̤ꆺɜ gڄ2m"U'o7b޴mUYaVUfYcZά7Fm6fj2QegET:̔ uJLc45&f&47j)4Q]_r54poUOu^'B3,!pVH0kdn1vei LS0O; jq~ B ɇ{P"#4w\lh0S 9Vf_ a8g$1G?a{a |ͱ="2O/o7W\`y?rNxc`g1a k_[sf1o rZNu@ ;Gr 13 ә˰@3,O{Og穲ꤿO,tc4!|`cSP3q9/+xq 㓠wh/5kJk/^zQc($02v`w*)+Wb`Ř*>,VLUl~[Y-zӍϮ?ҟ&r/zj.K[~Ʊɐ5 { NA ׾.Õ>;|Q}*2X-p8Kspcۈq׷~O8'Q"Ytx6us!~$N98!CL ,Hp^]† n]FV h+zMΡQ֮Vjbvh64A+1IHcmsw9-t;NCIQ^7?$Ύp_s*qwx/o_“7 `K 6~lJ>-b"*&/OQsl1)<%-}#N.|w= bW\p?>uKsZn5Ugv6w;mOm&g0߅S5C> d*7Mn>Җl &72գHk ]Yrnp0M wJ?{-| Eڿb݇1n%t7U {gȧteTz5=Uz+ XEH Zm{<9q0]=>?0MvAԑna4n ֢`zGB\u8q/zъ' <ML87)#1&!/pʹ Y"zî!3F̞ ̟uE/8wB.º݈6@OUQ̧C]"p qaf\{ VgRza!,A;= VRG~z=uvuz>ʑ6 I鹌;B IbO~)UJ6by +_PڔEnhŨjξkb*q2jȟ5O[D1>ExMeP J2mB+# t# 2 ݞs593GNO0Q84wg "qv_߼5v䈚ms<,ïMCڂPiz8AcVXGb9_?Խ)ьQiPդDSf[JgMQ9TUEjQ5vL:wru0h*}G!I=F+$#[ArxkGlLQBCxy1 hPNՉ:">0Q!  \ xOA3h&e6 '8##͜ gMK#0^5Bm`$Y%P$^YEhILqXD2IL ddani`2I88,V슽 RC x낣d9 ORdH, ra?!'a˪ 5+kW,%@~]=r; hB!%Rv^ÓҐvHzsI<;KI)P˜bf[\ؕE8iw;IJ{M(BFJoK2.Ve(My'SV.sr[ J6tZڜyFl)z'ozozNyeoۂc^+>ypD'~d'ZD:C֥>ց}vn&4;"tN#hr仜.RS[ _ bښrڦRϮ5>!. Vl&Z?\lαώg;'L&ftNhⲮ+ e)MCө Fԕ4b@U)kfڮ4u uِjiSuz=NyG[&o4c?3-3r8@jLWb 2G'oH"z%[ϱײ5` h=wG$ ItwyMBh7ZȲ=(9e% uL~3Ϊ1N5r9HlfX+_r) PU&SStz:at˵8ތ ݳS@/J뀈&2m٤VDI5Ywk1X d :^ =* c(?OaNuM܎zH4ёh } f=N'B+)Zh*gص}ś󝏴|n_{a >Vj_w~?Ԕ%ۉMt]==Ofb.53H] ȵP*.cyZ\jkn^P?F[Aa1*&m},%bzx_Ր{7\u7vSH; Uzp @qf-mq1`}ot2HBe;`q6WY9@_;\>4חPH.7fW(534S>&FU`pxI ,Œ ߏKl@F2@T]*wtD E1qN}:*4 bd#/?=7[_+wJ_Id{C <  +6y6j'S5Fa3Lƅ 1J,'+Uq;i3;bUv) R9A4]~t6ߏ$ɡ븞Ü3$ \ JY,a,TU{BNՄ¡HrHl 0-`mdz.GY\~phAßBBX (/1~M ,4?hJPRJ,hFڃ;<{j܆G+vפζ2YH֧L;ti0KwK%oإ8ٳR+8:w@q57 9İQBIP nYݢ[;le;}i#X+7)(dYF얐 3iJAI3M븵ӆw4qǀ8kXzB/UƜh׀ͦ:9 hX.s,6ဵ+ H(df3e ϔ~_oH ! .BsL?\PNTrC1/[Di|" qk+>xњJnR`[VdyR%4.'l`X֞?ar~wEPjM&nn2i^/ElPx$B#gӓ_kaz>(yze»Y'<9‡[VR/I5lnG&aK &.47iGMe}mnb)M/v&LizaJ ͘;hj@_(*d+'nB*4aZ*q|+<i=hkRvFR+mpnEWaaPLPy b|Fk+Ξ=_A\QG\3ƕ]m]u+qNĎ84*IAׇ:JA3u (*1 RkKqJh%-t2i Q?\gk*&ls}{= ^@CԧiF8P̘+9x ^'9c5NX횵ZT躨*K̯*!C`FdD^BȨ]9w@| U7%I鼡AF:4Kۡ…{aCPNE4gX j˽n%/b[1u*%t)j,K v%Q$]Hau2"!e{W?e[dBehL ^+(KHe: ĶPm?WM(?mZE?t\JiX!aۋ|h_ SO 8Eu-G1IkcVz;ۮZ}c<7T[ְn;ί#&Nu9ݷ*kҪW eM:5w+tFNYNV6ح0 NnT%g ӈBdҋp"(Ķ`F!ư^LZ[ -j$o=Fu[θ0`u`|iGO XK!?Fcsnc\7) kN!xʇKhXԎGg8;k-TZΙꋏ `|ɉ7Og2hwNm昈TGoX^>^ELKꋷH/<޹j'}K'&@ $>cwwY&=I(Y.FZE_F9%.C } ӁϓSS$ \v]Qų qz@)޽򓮑aeJ斖rJ/OmL@%r`XT*QY>| uCԟX}n5opf 7Q;҃d"$ĸHl7$GX nX-&FL$:a{ی6W\9WHy.To\*Xk /}OWPZ8 C45 q1/qH?x+?/owyԾu[wy#8ԸhL7L .bƫ\ić U`2RJٿ_'3T`UŭA*TQAa.iX`ghem'XQ [[bm۾Ƕ 4@L1.$6"ZDhU!YD|ζ5za+-3PT ŽNH+uVAI7^uS 9vdonFcf^<;=NN.\$Ϟx u 4P;~Ҫ>"'ƈ.kG.\Q'H#q'cȜ]?M]E&P'\^cUG &@G C#('kQ}FwXrnd̂TZ;^H5Mu Jۏr\>bifš)Zf3igWlbg> *!5*ҵq+j-"FDl8+xD:&hRfMV(Kg9⦈ρze IjaDs|}lǟ9^/v|@Bid$)P A+Ѯ1 ] k ՄnUc1*tRm ݤ:s7}k|W7w=8lZ /MJChMfeZV:ӫxeE8V̉@b%$rΐAf ƾ٠g3N]chhI}p-.A65kvJ3Am0Ne޼nț娇47dնrwnJa.-q 1(z%.]9F??`@nhCmkU\. nMMBV 6EQ)TҜyol["5cGo/xqYj nvŷߝh&VD9њY5-\bGJu! 76ΏΟ֟uuOUXUݭcgx C5)o▻kqPPO)^5I?+R(eH0"M?!BTVd=n&( Gwv ?L ǻ +,T"^>wsq:,8M;l T8܍ʼ`2~z[$V|.惎9=#k}5>{{ZkG뎟ByH`D?\MI}u;R}X"6v~?[}%t5PCY _仫#c !~Y ~Xzc1*<h03*#2쓋27f'>?wI Dd5' Ûc偻 YVypW02BU*G5c'k3z3PYi Y48.NAo OUǝ?id>˯0W<QeA>şN+~hՂtw޳@ŪlSPa!VyW8oyNE8xs*7I{>9^N&%ytxD$vC̑rmDfT9/̛$L') 1;Fu-V‹$?+v(O3BzR21[ '0rNTh1u9quXQ%?8^P nJgzEgᲸ'޻coI&*CKtInO)KNH yzo V¸pETT#$y;ٗ1Vᄐd 1nqҠ.7t@ m^2Qi0[Ðl۱@J r I$ pÎa҃<|ףpZ3݌%<7a5;NjN &sQ$݁h:M ҈#_'BH\ON!7; rՐ6*(PrbH05='' 7s>vdfS¶B3rsܩMgr>Qu+bgMn"3۟E_pkm'Ql :NBS :@qq;qEX%Uys|3>K3cc HEE 0H Zm4@K'CD+R*tJ D%J1反)PMjy6K~w<# W* 媄X9I `^b]U%'&sm3S (갽kDyLtwOkP{MÍbNn !Cej ې dΉ-NM!@DT A/Vx+QPsXb#~UW\ᵑ55Vq}cgekn a=d.zno69)?5@7>tZ噰oC(UTMsN XĈB4f p&%ȸk;#吵f?f?v뮫[;a,Aѭu>WG`Y]#r'6ACF i {P͠KpGC@k%[Ӧ밿 ChuDo v,rpI S8 9,ݽܠPvTu'BJDS:AbIC\שּҽ7/w-Fgg7v>0jƛ#vӮ5|y)9C?0bH۶mlz NgL[ }u3rpOҫMQ`٩ye@3>6͈YfU׈\IyF&eNDVu0*3OuO[xxOy]{ðry2-zR(Z)E aX4a#D&#(b"SS}\H\O/_w8屾^#dxS?_׮^W#1s( MVӔg/duώ274uذ/ J0]|O?|QYyZOwG"{RGUs(]eׄkCa)l=O~Fv%Rlmq#Ae6j75!c@~%,*0И4q7x?\M%8W?c=68`v00t1̝\JXFP4̪쪌CSFE2/,]$NJ;"ņſ=ӷ/ظ:ٗ/9|/:k}MCv%i]Y[EV҉t+ DMRMMB V*A%V z<4튄tc^8Zc--gN iqRe1Oy"ЪŌ8*Kwks eDHPUb)Fxa,=Sw 6m.0)g)>n0^zRW3>Vf1ozv)[Pм(ETh崯MjMk-\FyX,i74&7w{4 l0F@@H'!.kBA?O/-ܷ5rlНၰeцr6`Y,,NJkZJ#"L g o",nDbT@apgYt=k{[-phC'r4wZI R"HҒtCHa{A8qΪc`=57>p|(:JO$Ic@T袆Q gATK {`F҇MC.dXs%B>kdnQd wcEamxv$ (3<]L"0|T3m ?:[Z$s܄RoeW+B47C?:w}&l+<'8:텑Vl&]U`V?4}+j0EMf@]0fop rq.mUtQx]dB~%H^ \0\0us](A>'a)fHsj NMrzNryrblfw3Å-ӛfKqhGlGaoha.{B&>Ю1c!fqpo%s٤)7MK&m .ђ!=K "j7^wjo|ejB\_!T+TXhFJv cg鬚 1B\r9 uwHbsJB)(1x,cB3AOY7Yu9-=dgB35TMQSØpw!7YY~NyV^EEWW,i{Q["PBKhi;$xNzF;ՄQݰcߓdV1&wk$/CR^c(EɀWŔ3LK0Y: ̅HE_δ4TA=2m !άC!^G:z2q v=F-ڐ۸/eQi:ądhI9ivM!z\\utungGN =`(`BO`CǪǿ׶oqmکǗo+|ر uoMKQV gYfϙi['U;G.7+8u$)Wݑ(EIqI`3>r)ow#]X_8~Pe٩ .oD gz%|r@: :j˓B.Y'nҲ  /De2Q{LL_&~/!sM Y`. 24im~=Z3FN4LxRZ(?Ff6WmdIP)ۉg yH5:F-ޏ*-?2JH ܦ ٬}ۻlUuuѵTS/M7v7M)?2i!"_߻E}3􁑿ݏcf+0{phqx}pt7t4l,^CéN1Cx+\A=NTO4kb4ݯi:gMEIތ SM]У!-k*b8NY1%/pfjCQ&XGP3 L7e=%hd ZI7>g`6D0 \1+vcfq7iso=rM(o/G7KViO֞#-+0XtO߹}_DĿ/+ZCSG@,#>rs+z8TW[w>=˘H]& ~ȋO/lWv~bWwNo?>1[gЭḼg)zmE?fcT1.X+ЏV̞H0OVAr@X 6@<1r4%;e;LXrv̶GDmYI^+D=+bދryx!U |mr"Ȫ(g1N-8N>~~_[P߀>yazu(65CCa5!VA@:{a1ּc{9Anl? ɾ rgmۦٵq,e+!h|7VѾB$Xu^.}4Vϲv/ KcvǬ[ΰ:ot,#_>B6c,N: 괿_}q:6-˿2ߧ59f02??]ianA{J6̃i5aox8< >K:7}s=I Ek|3簎@#Ɉ- PZX $"ߖ߿~K=_$-lZ$g$,oɼMoҊɚYy`bX`U8X!\l|=$^~?ܗ{pU=gs a$G &D2  $ !Rp2@gHEmEC ֪U2v:`Qm6&Z&ډS'PH+E!z!&*9BasՔ/Ԍr3|_I3|vtE%%={"3][R~+ӑ3`zzvNYe}vgkRnlaݟ) wv>Gq#ϱk~m7CVu0 =׏G?\$kŲVvOC.k:+ e#X> {qԪקqo#69qTO{XPPNq"747.'sjiviyMRqs:-6P5_aB,gz h2k\}Ȧ>!AjL+|S;oQgPJ)x#DV$ y3jUgRfg}]è4x>ZN Z 7f "C쿕XY2M<3n^~_N*؈*T>}?BGƈi_KCdQ%*%*?8yߗI^J7lK`Cq- )'_pdUgyNd/\}.e#>~a0M2EDFnVhx gP'ŭEhxG߿1fQ?i*M~(j3d;8yFEhZmúzDy7K4}٥cXW1,cØDe#Xc.=@ur )v}SLYl&x*0ƛ4% ^'Zl׭qY6~'߅͑}qoChyZM[JjVٓN9^7^/q|Y]/&ي8[.lFPG>d3NyD\r'׫v|\oGS.فGp2(z m,{kXTxS.!ٌ 9:W"~T:lSu#ct= Uw2sj6\5_?osRPNԥ6y$nZ ܝ;l*G]\~܋VCD]jB_!w!F$Bdm3TRHH-n^L{ l@@x\̍| kAU`̃(?棌< .b82z\ѳߓQ:tǓҩ)S8\g=m#d__9wRﬓtyb^^V#A.{4c>[>p8 Ass'#n>{LJ뽍7Sg,ګ\lFŽ}ñc@fNЖ.PXvӰ'K%Tf"7&J1w7M3\vQƉ0@sş8JnIp%%63< ӠCfC)9Lb[FvQOr nIFl EVb%V2znSp%WgXJ0ؕez0w:ʈpb5b=c=M y H`/`%r% i2CM.K1yB5z2l_Fe3(gqD #r՜/w_ `a>`ht`ju2ޗۍ'l)MYZvt->(RSJ^ruVaoDN=j梨ro} ~fWCl[{q/o~ !*0WaQGPr(f<5801n9,dv2YFmqٗ).P cR}~Ys$|l ڬ1UsYf렝(=Q,}J=bG4=bkW^G}5(A{~'Q?[B<yd/Unwd0ՁoZ"\iSX;rCVg/ym=V>vjF'cpwd,"g^UWW?y@ BbdKAak@[`(.02JԲ2,T 00S: V[5 XP;0s/ Oνwssd8FSo-'v3Df&gsƒXKX+&M{y68]<~zħ.\qK۔;I3ܝSw_[ݑ&F]"w/ޝcݭ$ [zž1cq`WS}>QHCs#}@WI.Ȫވ;ߓ5Η Vmgl%\k"i "kcfO>"[So<.?nkCFwcC>E`VG}DfH}lgW_P}^%1q5tL]:!ߖ}fi-k hݛ!+=Dc Z/?U2 [QO#V0g4EZߠ:tdStt K?Uۅ6u֫mStuv59K[^޵mm-ހnDA[DkL}?նFWoVZ{}ZڿyN'&wb[}_?lHAp.0 -iN*uQmuVC( њ0g43 9!ĀGyʣn0CFXuʻ }C|WؗC:j,8%q_رW~jA^r%l囘p&p7}=g9bYh_8 [8]g@1r Y[C/d)0eC ش 7~6E׏):rV{QWFcޯ TP8b=^.9Ylb/¾:JlThA?ikjsvZH_}ҕJJ3ÝK\F[(3CbWOIJyߍR-:ZWU&u iSh۟ƷZCm4y:ThL\iIƟ`c4Ď̴UaL28 l(^ 6Q>7,W']-i6#=ڭX8hyvuBܠ5B 7/\oѦK֥?w?))VK/uP?RQ?j]%-\¼Ks}ю]sa6m*ugyOŌ;uH蚘uw63W-S:vԥ% xS]Ul۴5k5{glt_ u>h3cOn$")"V 8R2WO}w8ߟ }/һ υr)fD̆P,%P 6!0ZBiykĻ/dEY+ FC;c%@thzcR֬HcPP'> (`;nL].mwp2{w,w_k$S)aHdMIQft(!p]?\Uqy{@6!HnB!rK ` 0aBx@Ij UTy*N:ڔNiP; E#Ew;dnkә0~g={Ne2B1+@?X^_^LZ^gO7nm{<ŘA;p82xwre2 0\wvv Bg#zW'WL;|퐌٢ƴNcd^E_j㟨BbVɌy2hYu\{V{-Kegbܝ1UMԞE8]ۅR*ۻ0@Aev)dQN'<NKg]PID,#)  jYnVw*4XPD.rN<2^wߵayGru'>;dc}r|mb{=s79$~w9c(uLeECǘ{/=ߊ諩Jx~!s7Es}\O>F)u(+wBfG8c ѶBSc1<T, HpVc?!%'o7\9j%#"N7:1<8@"z*>69]w6 '"I3BS²eU8ut29Jt32cS$(22SEk?qf ~{cK~ؗ#b8`=Ijq>A_[}Z-"o &l_F1 #q-=l>>:{t1x9s1jVo; ԉu ;o' d\]0ى$߃<i} EmNw@%5ŻB7c_Gn76"񈮵wV'V\G bUT}O_TVP'D OO@?3{e;-Q?EiҸ9V$"C?@D[1Ia%pNp?x$:g5]Z\~sFMrsE ܅f^֥gPΜy b}'Ǵ|e(ݟ[Pk$я]k-}9]k"mnB 9hT?6 x+"vZ>/Xn;͸81[/zچtGwNRÒ'A>iDCY&N#! L싣VE IiY5AzSglz'za0Ǽ>uO9TqZ1'ks"T5(HcG}7݆@S/]ls 夘6-2ޑw.l }rL7v%?Tya̋H~3eT#,`Țw; NF=OKe87ϵnD4jhK\{}QP{@Y|*փܳ{sGasLf4 ӘxSq/ݢM=Ѽ A gy2~1h"[x[!Wv (5xvӮG>2c̐f }_\u>ưh3F"΃{c{ڻgymy]yo]JKbO ?(e9L\\I'̿x̭p/ r*GUm#Wʍ3:/)c -D3Gbi>p'׵z I$N_L*~Ἦkq krx;2Ybh6/q{;L;<@@  8 I9Ao|=9$&n03iŒML@g] LT( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( B?+##P a 5dKmh=@MoxM;ctrf9g95ٕ#MgF=g$;gP3sz KٙxP䬫 q$xM'|x*ҟ3fXo|:1(˛ӹ66u)3t&itI%Lx dHtʒF>Keyb1OgEOERF~и4lN3ѳf:9{Aae03a%T.4& f}vE+%H.R>>/z|_Ĕ&yJ>F ܊F}ުswX3@M`p {J<}Eڰ'Ҭx1{)<JFCkAPRԒ!`N!Rgz AȔڇ;ZĀPyo;xfW,p¿= 1H~#%=QJ'r֣u߬&^{LEщD^O-&o>ݏA5A @[ 5@ѭ>E|j[P"X:ax&'aAo%!{^M9Ն0l?I5QFFy`PxTQ`MX<(=J=J6\5ok.adCXaȈ @&PCVh;iw,@^!6)#- x=fkA*5ץ-kВZzI_bBi$Oؘ(i]jH|OⓊԘT_Դ&̞v K4zҮ=L{b#FYC/e3Y:'KYzR9ީ~p^"R^"@n*x|T3[AMlR!jXOIҶJX(X;"TjTF\"wC*Ԫ YPk HefH.le;x ,S}Apxj*{T PV-&ޢ Tf 99j&pDԸ0Dl>`x4i?4_,r5pOSippǰíD )-^枢DU1nds o0.Pk+@AZ_Z :1U9d .CX|5\<%w)]D~6O U/ %H F7 &_hZ-T9B\*1>P`%Ӫ+`trJqY  MhG8G!o'9-Ddm$CZ'=Yk&I_WNR?ѳ':I;DD+# fx.`kmU#V3sxcGksoW \\#KEQ,DAD"6KQ % JXa`uEl})!_괛-ܓv0~-S^]mGbخHTw,b[xŨ;%c"hWӳG&NOdPXkX=W }tO!TW>ulʤ]rOzV',l&2 k2d@L zds ;p E=Q~sQw< @V<4P+9,I:R]˴="]ŋVE *hecai;Nf#ɾH2 >16 ȲspS2cl>INKz:HAdwIG mIF|i|cX1=ka:W3S;ӎbx3BY)ܖ`u&VY~W:p4xiTgՑ-AgTM[MJ3j ,-P+x@H ɡ ǹG$AY7Pœ_-y4tӢO; %Pϰ[䐮{uO85/+y_VRW-7ǫy苼ʟ "TU9cX4|s漹څ\|bsϨe:f@0a' 9Nyby|{I#Go5 G7oCuF endstream endobj 33 0 obj <> endobj 34 0 obj <>stream H\͊@OQEcbݺ$nb~ɝڮ㵿utxnlYϫTCŇu}w곲tt:wnc|cǶ;?ãaMnV+Szѷj^]eO&oSZ!b^SMUǪ;Ǭ\cʷt57~Ƭ,bN)0 r`l//[-yƜKdz<<3{d>stream H|y\TG5o^p "fF% jtͮFvucD%*<#Ⅸ5x'^(^0#1f30=j?y]@| Q=zl4Ta _scRSX%~<()O@gAcw=h]Xn* z C'uaMhlPHSO0P8@7Nm4h}R\lrG%ok3wy)2bB}1JyѰ$kepA'N^; FBmu& r\b|in~@'fHQ{7ᔴ2^>u| ԠaM d UÚѬ-޲U6mz;}ad>/]?ߺuGѳ??Y>2&6.~! C O1rTWnj7'OvRwO2u3gΜ3wY -FeyW\ڲf҆6oٺmvٻoсphɱ'JO:}gUp*+W Puri>RC-IӤRT&=h{-Ody<[>&ߓpv.Caሡ N ^JwG|W+JbU*O188˘c<`|dodnZ`Zc֘k7s3hs\&/ĤBըު6Pj -5BMT u:CԭuZRJvXDXdXǰa1aaCÆH  h1Y&[ , G;GGGCWML͓k>u8SiWT@ qR4KZ!KϴuQrk-OgsruQY>ٯgͷϿ/?[BR}}E=8|<_:%@# =fa:b-VIG 3SD]|\x'X 8lėAD1)ƏY8 ]1 HB"!1Q )HhX|G&j=p)$Ғ j(bZZ8IGz(R.-<'$/OV*ZMZCki hm-\i4I|=K~Tq ?P= >͠TD D !5#TL (R _q7H!#L8R:I4 %UԐ2*t*E|!>Gr |K$|˸\[:.ѐ̲NgWȗ2Wr[W5 ɷ6w.c;H2URYu~:]=].P_ɫ9}{9 la.XzD޻@A411f$D@{8c{]:J[Vw&?g'NtNѩ:M չd˗U[|{=+ʽ W,][gt d6q@OS4gz?9zz^%zitP/ 2F1zzA7Mzs\|BrLޢmzޡ?;.[zޯ9'q2p*q:gp&gqmbl};`G석K]ݰ; {c?8b#5qLt)s.\sn?O|=nč y8B\q .eWJ\q)4WUs :s>FR$yt!3eUS IqO H()R))2)˗M9KyOu2Q}j@ 5&ԔKԜZR\zZѫԚP[jGuNԙcB]}k}]uԓzQoC}4`BC}}[s5}~GyhyjbSbJMYAZdA 4Fk4Fq4^ 4ޠIޤ z~I_;z~K\a,ERXOa9 VX `=q1'7fs;fgƛ.{6;Sɻd9hiA)b.fb/bX+-b)v=b\U]|-߉C{s7yx(S✸$'q_Gx ϠJT/˖?=\+WPPϡ^@G"j+y|Eeؾ(;ˮ-ǚfHX9A)ߖD|_Nȩ1!gŊg'Er\Ur(Yn^y@EM~)cm<"z<#/By]4]Y$Y!PZ]RTJW*SV9*OQuU}P4SUSBTU[^u:ΪꪺzުjjၣF>+XxGTcx_x'=|WKR /k:x]^o7yI[fjf,2K l0fl7^sn fw=v~i;C ₄`t0.L ¬07녍faհu&l ۇŽas%v !{G1{ܞ'){ڞg9{^%{+feo'8NsŹ\*7:.nԕr.ˮqЭ0l;םhI4Z-VJTوu,587MpZn즸nfn[vs\7wa>G|Oi>_"μyLNB+I)HRh!t] AD,E@WB @Hץu^\Ξ#o/;{f3s\r-q[w) b>:쁽p)P (b)vR<%PWBp.B %\꜡$J-Ԟ:PGz^#ԉ^'BPWFݩJ=P*Q:>ԗQʠ LCh( N`9Dr h q>}@iMI4`{ʢ4JCA4fQͦ94>?_οܿ|Bo:H#<7!WWW #L2Q8 z#)}JKh)2̥G+(V*VS}N_ZhimMF[h+m%Oi'`=}Moh7ڋhta:BGTDtNi*R:CgQ9UP%UQ5P-}fOg6]KTG?w.ͭz^jӠIyr+N嘇+pln-unCtktБ:Jig66Mm3ܶxD_g:SI:YҽuWvk=h=j-=eO[jس̞V*[mklm`3'HO("SYi9v8GcqS3(DJTQ+߉GqE\?5q]7 j$e+"[3RowTT#!骷Y*Q+TbLVSTd&H%e seV3)0Y0Y3irdc,2A2I&d[CH=fvS/L bf>;1;NޕwcBteFt7Q*DژXhT7 *ɴ1&tE]U?1g6LXӛMb3y7/{;hm<䛕f̬6sYc֚uf`6Ml/+^2E4 Df˙N8E 6LimBM 7&R-P![ ܫܮqKs^ ?@8bG}V !zA5ײ0C8ߓ:x&uQ1y&@cxѽ͟=w55ײ0uX9- r+Km-WanH`!r`98>aa0 a6ކx{zcW}`T6c?7i.,dDžP$dwZAt0u+n-_+JTK`#yvwjuC|V~v# ^ A_.BL 0,bE%Ϲܛ 10g\i院 kje^G?a]}VCuR#dpSal]= ?WSDߞ_<^ݙbޥB8Ⱥ؊g|sq:,DLw7\iZ0Fn(F< cI`mqϸ'c]o"(;xC43;_&I2ߑr&|yVVy&yvzWGv}uy^ q:pi,0R<;y' ÿ`{~Gn>.e.,,SgYQ\%vEOxAܒ-[2Gfe<Y)yRFիxriaO/owNg t,J. TM0!w TV` b ᬑ8 Grp6ŏpdV<-%gì|| 8?UqcX|99|Iw- {&LR%ZFRsQτ4j%Z"R&mZ*-ه]U䙻y3f7A| ȷV|?  2W [^V^S.+WUkvuzH}G}W}O\[%~d;~_ɥ{D>Ư.*Amu|]٫<\MEgW (+)m?cĔ>!wG?7؏~%}rZ>"W(Ɵb?v]NwIWt V=ďa|>pu[\VOЇnfu1ױq vٷ)^ET#^TN-%,]PBRLURoWj%.La+;|/OK›\b+r{0VZA;y6>D5iZIgGht3~~Ohհx/"go7QòRURF$< ;C;o^.6VNN@KWzI'(`[G}3NOA:y{݃ڂ7MpQwrvS"Aw!۵ >M GaF fgԗ!*9 k*y, uqn9VuS ^krbw|Oh/@w>.2V; M2]t.#ު@D rd&2Al dn"ιQL=-v DzhN]҈z#n@~~2{We| lY:z 8r~(42O _G"CK{h{wvh߶5ukܻz=+hdK‹E!}/_Q^6osU2xFߧ gM)[UPj i ғЁJMS97x3^d}=IC =:[Li0,]{{YB'+tl=)R݀3F:JDOYV^Ǽ/OƲfA(Qi4$|AJ p2#[dC0%.AFX(-#| nhXF9#uّ'Jڒk̉`QAL~gL *Nb@ -djH~- sNN t[`.!]{.fFT:ZVVTԝv AJ7ܕGNS)l`NXw̚-м.{MseR"cA:$1 i%{-P,Q1 f$l'> -0tS72OIv 􉾈DRA (dу9.G8۴Bzsq 2-f֩+8J%-)&(GlJEQU7;P67쿐{6ԓ=~MS<}m6cy\a&iJ~Z8e$FdsVǃ7wGaf %r.5'/{DnPsoQ^s{D,2OQ Zś;x -g8)CO9ι.CΘb*3'?ԈMXuԐɒn7E{{b)EKw11oFaE;-mFm ,L(G>i S +})SBY;aimKa,ńBC7@iBv0pVPҽ4o!/6yߴYP)(8#D 髄jl^(7BB\tl/56 ;ήg/ٱ^{qف&C0e8RhbG ! Q $llІTjR>ԪM"TE+2-=w )UGw=νgw` T} D;JB0F$%] ^5ϺaNh!.xB>H~&mOUϼK4jeH p<&|yl+dw| [VÀ-l55'_x4׍[[\["D# #% ␆zB]VC98*ܧ!!3MsMĻMmsM(8 "sO F~ra 9z)} \Y/}mVfї\V@{uGz(.({-( Sj_KaeH:=k@i+2zI 2@B#NOZlsF }qǾo=Lhj_(?ה'/&ᡂ^9yd5HG>麙wt8Ne բ}#Jبhn,dmPv\:w:\.toOZ98~GϚ4]->#16jMmHmin{s;9k9kyfe0txmDI,6CJ9Q92c({_Ƨ{1W%+xY (xlK|Vp,flw,5x:,zm>2|+, _[qf>0`D,T\f m0(&vrF!*FHLv2_DNT Y +HHⱯ#x"OV).Z5H{zPeUn6 Sa&IRKp.HnrYFZPܙ!L U>|j+W+R^JRB 2B7xIn ʦVP(l856rb3g ju}֚d~llv'փ{6>LkMU# Ԋ'w)uXfIֱJݣ@ Ÿ}Z^ݯwe;&Њ\/d%ȏh)~`QHHS x*xT"7-\/k/Ƅe4E[0@t1UeEYkj*kh*r͑Uu%3 Q,F(UesYZ&mLa:ϓ؈EFtF{%* ^T0 PC6C9m4'=d"[Հ<ˁTYI.,}uE^B!D h>DnP 2&ua#9U(@'ɋ%hmpp&c66d" p5ꂇ]g~;;_nkNی֪?ҧm{;-##c?|l޿-[&il)6u-9u龉KkOoyu:d$y.zU ʾз@[As_h mZAa}qrWozo(F?NuO"4#9([KŨ;̨uه'#=lRT˿cwpt'&s78bwѭM[K#Aզpeny{c'ca26ɂɕ[Vڪ*PN;G?`$op؊Ղ$'jvFl p~Unk&K<ךYַ^_Y[\2 }0uv{)vس1" DqF;p7ޏc+8u 3męg}$1RV\@1(vK:ہxҡU(u˹4/x|?Sئ3~sMl_'vc'q  f YaJ@0JKS @-eyb$:=P`Ҷ?P7tuc'Ε~o ?غ8ѽ8>4x[જZY[;βIO ac0U %yϋl*tr-ZMfTS> hhj'̪&҉xg4N筄/C{Q8[:=+tr:W}~Zʂ8$yMU#YМ%%$qLr"';ef8)WLͶ1r("Jh~,FRKxa3d\\?>2.9z^gzpy$)J,ױAJ7Tר t/.'>Bq__z#ZF534Nar +0f1~0srW[G@O^R|Ps]}Ir1ٵ&,WIGJD ߽從1H/郎X! xuo[ {C'a-Z,,%X/kCk--9ǽ?$p{I}JJxº A7<3haI yh|:lIaPJM" W(kS@ B Kzp/ʉZ6ckF$pbr>[XyUqr&K 2JEdbá\lMnIg" \P.+k^]> g2?Y7s*\F=yџ sĐ^>i7+=O{(+_ӗ;KCQy\xʫ*Qt#["epie:KӣTЃh)JGhXWJC')ow%"F!džʊ r"SA*|MdIC&ql gA IGpXNvbˤ~yuTOT7]%=/qNؼ($ɤe耘;ۋ3G;P2]R*=\7F --Cva!huV6FѬt{KW/F:W۠ =뺡0]7f3n: yo}0oVf$P"GHaZ~_Zּ?g͏vTI Yh]-GKcoiY{B58APWJ*hbѨAyPEyUSN$J,S^}2NhyaQYe|yX|aU=C ' M.}5hGШ&:H+np1m@}jf.4.!q [V4=>^&CK*~s^Dŀ ] 5؉OLíC?u}tmMȦrΆnձ ^WFZRk@_V #oGW2A9Σr.& leG <,GU S5\mGi>)X%qpqGI=Q,GD7(p;يfJęD=.MLɕc̈@vnQ-z%ǻߔjl9*f=E27&x4ePlgůYZ +Jnns5(7TT-[u xaJ=?\ӃoyAD4A0W .v6Ϸ+ QwTh,5Ej YIH&5Ü"ٰB0DoK9)SDO3(GQm8#cHY8>9\B+¢N`qGOv6qﻇ=~}/!ؐ#bP %AgJhV ҅[X1jnd hH};b]|v_n~ysAucsfsvlM,%lP=GWIYפ?vH7n12x0# hHⓘ l{ AlE%6X1@>u-cn%9r"]6h 3c5; B#.$b}NziHͨRHt\4ȗ,;b lD.ZͷׇgGQFn)GUHK9JHCa{R#(s"H%=ҤA1rt׉7v. gs5@]˹"gKbQ^<!E_&vUȡc=U?}/N٢mZ&]Tosc;xo7\fC-_\{%ZMkgw7|p'-DPtwm5jB%ZVz+پmqm.M2tgN?I\ @gJjĈ_Q^HDܸX|AȟNYĝb'q-ِJ%$Թ3~MkŬG<݈iLmz|QTTC 3nTv ʼnma^4$Th1שP/\b/%QL.,'ڗGЗfSM}:a0ĊPYPsmCLk]8]x:kZZ3W}7$c߁_?ɩGvxozϛȆ7^ȡ:TQ+[=͜YFizf=G4\5ǏދC{~ YI]_w_E$oCf0j>x7o51̐O 7z%RưvYGQW> BF} ͦ Ed{JlMS'ޫݿ_sV~qUS/zR\B =mT3 #&c@s CBÊ|4py !!c4HRP>LFF KhmИR.j"<+X%&RxxtE1[(}/_Vi2cKd^<ƢTpU *I~0W. ˤfIX+mD;oڝApqP:͟~<-}_./Iw;=K^TD,tKR" D/Q"qE)9c: &EW'4;-i}`ݜ(` ]+Ҹ:.Z@D :ԭN-ͣ hL^ϕSd@(vu`5 z뗋$>f͞DP|n؟2޵)_^Ќ(e'NN*FaMo_8>?)UƆV|]xJIS_'V~BRh*b񱿢b@ L>2Z:NC=|Cy;2\O[gQu08 XvoVUWjR4 MbrV|?V?)"eB=1薼qo'+e>!]M\wޝ}wv>g>}9D1?ŏDZDXVKh.aCLcX%6y* ?&IS;i0"b]F}s(L)'ş_gmOTzzÅp\8)롼Y͗G\33J2#v)Lq"I_bHisGϓm[lHj&)ƒdY%bs:f ,"VmTߪ.|{jz|pd :2h1@XWW,,ڝ.ʂbeRI˲`v5:p ;oV]N7X0-1\]}i%m~!bvr5s`8tx쀰1jEpRb3WN$lݛ-2$}~relٖsa K^XDD?͞Ūٹ\ tn/γ4W9Ǿcū=޹]{sޛ^ >-vԺ1xV &n'u ͦ!7KkMΣ жXJ7jFIc[a.7VZ]9\]^7g7틄.1:8-jI4VS?,|ڎ좳w.x9M"I&b`O# Slgk֮1U%`~cLd-j 7jow12%EYy̓81Sl=x3﷯My%_t6\7>͝h *$sk fZ_0;(i}Q"AΏ_igNqUr!=Ho5q[Z?{F{ʾbIE1U7k*E "q$Bq ,9d=عEB30ICG²/h GBRkh!lSXUxgN}IS"'Æ< /Ș86(0|Уj%<WޭxoC7QgOwkLy25.\n||ʷ"h=Q Nb&!xOEF~REV8_VBM)vm"E Mʗ].&"O8M+EF*tIevnӗ!pt3ϳ>n)N9u4@5e =ZbJb\H j*$P'a@` Z_p ;j`kzj]EZC 6Ҏ@ #Х;3Xְٌp8j 72BQٲF07訏Gev v_ӉvI8QSiPp3ԏEWXMs_l| orۅɭߝn+xSiUoڞc/6j(F~Y}z呂+q\iGHu$imd9b3`|\6nYn[mkLYi`mm4w8(UrU$1`.$cXi"⪑bDN)JtZר 2L)SX23,pCor\#%(HXKvn xd Zj0xprTxrd2)5b Y!Hi@rAB ТK JhUDn?~DzsӮq: LؿIk =y{)7ئc7@Ҹ 'NnYCN A!DǺK#J6 'Z0\x#˯,׺-@ﻙ <W‹9v|>EֽhV e\z† Ev`eb3no1}x-[/$(J-ށr nII yjcqס%pWlW~'sΉ}8Nb'N$N|iz0F R5 E ) I2ҴV CE4J@UIDM'M~ޝI}?B~\ZsU7FvqVϭyq$,y g0I9슉 hE^TK0zljJ'rpt ˲rIř$,-?^ʪ"1*پffԃL =W>ue+L/]fy̲Bg}>3 ŕ&;:ۨWtI_P%$FTFFturOh7yIZXx}65K zsbɀ<:R8Q+,Tl%޺4]!MφFM NªSªE&hsXТBZp!RyO'8~Bu^$B*,Hzbzsovgd ^VHc P9it R:|JsIz&$@:XܙRL8iN5"SIWy?F/v[dJW!ui90 y(R0^3 .e?5-lU5BRЭc ?:zt6^!p/cڵWcEc6j*t%z5=VuUz~x%H(C߅ŲY`dD5z7iu+Ԓت1)Ց#10Xɚk:>j>/`!t}Yq(F;|;dH,{6f*؈1Rd0L '~/rΙ` W>bb Ō.L7o[/W@By3( cEtZHl}wQH8., sky^Peevr`;1M1̰`do/\mA[u&kºV h}jH&.W)5^zd7rMp-5uP? !Hkx'x-~^KO#йO@&i2iΈ2/.̉Fo)t]"b- ;z)Gq)fp]n&s"!yC'Zt88Aekze@g"d/ɶCm_rƥoSc*Vq]Zɻv&0Cn,C3W,wc])Y9<҃Urv *:^3A3JH|$G#"Fʰ^23P*iz`НaUҢpDk#Pp<aR$x&3JɌg2Hɞ:ќS榤]D +3BE0gaZtI̭þf5r\2C{2dTn|оtlcd$Xo:y_߸vp4xխ`juzavTVƕgwSo*R ()ی-ע qlՐe.ɭJsȧMFxpqQ4&ѳKEDT2,̥kʵ| Jޒu{g>}gsۗ8NqkKF5߈(bh$ Ba t:&. $JBҰvMMKˤҘviԵ{It,϶t:}&X$;rzKy˺\DD=!=cE\%vuX4 "% (TVZygT9"|WG1a ),bDAL Q"^JD\@rW,Ԋ"`5$"v^~JT87Vi8bsDpE*+iT4N{>]bp9FRKMKMS+,Oͭ/)Ăo f"_i(/P2;;KPbpf AbrPNCney $@{ix&7 ލh Ϗ7eL8;24NJV⢲e2X"Μ3\r K>Hd+L/,pŽ4xb/#уUaYLՋs"VTz]LDAwLB?b3@c)5Mhuw9_7۾4[C Ͼ(G*z|LOמlOm8Y#*#\È(gqu)r1qؽ\"v׶m2т,-uPғtֻH% ^T~;ZG\dE~"y )Bj|MՈ  Q䖐NwH7β[J%,paoc~huG7X~wsdZ!haCwd2,5yڻ(GZb>SRo4IUQLI93YJR۔z8՟ս 5WU 5c1?4jJrv">eW2eKi@%d lf0@F.`cj7w~C"Tx- A@9ZAz3p|`/|S'c}>/;j>bEvԄFC@/Z)? Yd xxAKv|8 J|2W(|~WtЩQi$hB"5㕴hh~1Wjh F`9P 2 \@GbU|9+*'72 0rl/a S ,6v:fAֽ^p:=q -\%h7Oߝ e8Q|NɟO9BOg $W&Vt@m  x0{DaρGD8{=.->O ݹAWxC(9z՞~hMmɁk;4o}ᖷ4lܛ.dq ' t !z(3z$3 mhH;BiAeYJ9ʠ`NWg#4^\w[kfВfsАS -a撉+X8w&IF&x[q%\-8-@{慣Q?90^$F"Msa#K %ϒg#] ڨ x_SHAW@#\A Y*B,L_ ͜Is|1̶SrhmGߔ%qGDV`>5B;h/'%_oQW]qK&R="$/kdl}'3иo.O:u|Ǔ'RI}`rQ1//23 -vnRWu}^X}دrl֬1A6ϵ`,m:ɞTՔZR}*߄ FƬn3W^m j^bFb p5cjvVy.+<(0jF$E0uTOݧWb}S16[cbS'͑7Xg Ȣ9Ta< p X?e[ODܐq;+ Ƥ-8rt */l"M1v t#.oarKZ acBh΃uezbS/K;; %l7u96;Z}틿[3u P~`sRD(X/q""$P6@5v>kRy\>L(n> `܍4rq\+ m+ժbe>jsܳ|La?H 8 Z~TN k#խVn+տMؑڦLo~~yKx3Q9*Sok؇c„8!MiYp?:y <<.9Õ7DS7hga#ˬV+_' I>Ӫ]JޕP]#)=/G[Aϻ'yl:N*bokO)ic$Tp ̥W 9B$w{15L.ҍk ^q-8*[\v,+>&Vζ2߲rCnlo;j4OS-bo3_c>w{?nYV2;,sOm{T[r|Uo|!RL@/;SEa8CT#~4L s'23ƔL2"s?)B\P.~} ͟D} sfkӣDveM)lŕ;8rH~"پ8H^uED Xx!ʱqh(djphggpc\c$G.r;L y`0ŝ5 T#a(!,V@rG+mʜg. h#30BFF`S:-$a˱nӕE[42%p~DZiK;k9酎N4 mɌlpSnn%WVoaH:֝YYVXȷ FeL9Mv]tSo%q8 pnv"q]5JBϥkF$W..^cv KEDo|}j\`ng7Euۤm=}6Jgu=S>)HɕF|g[GRɫsWĜ*d=ЗU!NJ2c8Q:doM #3:ӥЉ~?d'֤֢ETȺFH`W.%9C xQC>5%nj;KXoJJzN|inQ)TǗ!s5v4#cT_iLl(yzz{ /\7FY)g w'4OCD h˅P+clFBjG!D 8ׯ3#`揌# X\L fR0:ݕ\\M˴[%)RG= Ӓr=zz1pgu ˙,'*fFa?*.ef4)KeR g4]Y ;LOwwm{ks ~ՅGϞFp5aly{m}']qkꥯiuUn̏Hnۻaw7 6}eoh{_Lɶc3+>|6}Mer/ jƎ7*WFzտ.Ӳ N9)d^eY#j ^[eFDe zDq1o'_%8܂[uzm!: =?ޢSNH1GGkϛ6j_g#b2s=˜c_cp [S> {7~AR7IEh/A1|,ʐ2L*l)AJsMEP ~*%)R9Y\:o:^psVq6$ &l@BM$\paM7IjҡI< ˍf`ENJ$Pj(ƿLtv)1xw_xcս Z_=ù.\x:m%wK-1/n ?lHS? z!><{rIe.?R$˔7Ly;Y P2LBKY9ʌKa+4o5H$$CEZgwdP_Ǒg=“'CA(WFes& 㦱̉=x ޫFb%:^L'+R2!hn}c oq|aX,.2%"R:{B{B? wB60+Zh9inXf1I*;jV1-fsY"Nʄ FV'\K3bsZVW!K>vxȯWք5WmkzrdWV5gkXčp~S:_~mAin APAY!Q(i}bwC6UCGX _Qh":%Ck C1xͩ\ xSfP0 Y.CC P2+@FKxW,+Ә`ʼn;D1xr6Ydy6tPWeB&G]]PG̙L9CpCHp쐶'_'d3Vf5 '2YHr (vzszњ@ir\jp%rz=4Bp3\B`IT*»"u[ƀ9l19frVzs]-bGc Y*@pUƸH}HIAZK %'1 78Rjqd m4 xX".9V"bO$CrT!V|@EkuÎ>ne*=Q3v}(n{v{|'}8jo|tO ȇB#ȯLPZFÊd#lp2'ip\FQ Ge:0ΆP+h+\.F7( ?l o1+cW[F0/D q{U<>U͌']?W ~X݈[g~9^$B>[M\mwsC܈w?=%ry!'4ҽM$"CMAճzqИ0na~/`xs K^ٛ,d3&o%$I\4*ݔxU%X4)ݒDbhOzb+[)b):Rw,y&(_,a* CRJ:au6g h \P;zE96ê\YV!QϒJ\2kK-g嬴dֲ9kҲUp0Rr!.@%ApiLj%Ԡ.>()b55eR :޽GvNG+oο} s[so/rߝ^[f;F*JraXaڦ)!XUD,) ,6}j4QAE'9X!OS)]P&7_V˹yu"zeZ^_oгD瑇A0%:')Ycf.f5ŲC:%z q7<~v:m^ƍ8w7ݎ7IcdBǵɴo I.()acx:LJdGja.Ūqrզq%hKpCU>uxpفfW\Vhhij+2?uyRs iACr9šܢ-F0}c}fJ#@mmj[VB]*V\c ,HoOMٻ9\2gSo ?>;m跼^ݰ$a?Ae=vus>ӛnDLb.aD^f,6mʧh%ۻO%8oqwdWklYgc;uflǞω;;qIfdKtf R\K<4 M"B#! t#oEThP6k{'s̹;}|Ge2'& a%p|sB~ A[bfجd%e-2<ǽ9`.vQOuƎ!8p$(v9&'n% 'u ``I|VY.-85Ϟ_t1I&E4S|nBriafxW!\cMs,aX5*<=ê,;WqO-|Q7$]E:Aخ=ƶ^/w^l\A$k''cJ5Ujj"7ջ R6E=ѻQԐn x #B["Xt 7Xn,v4b'A Œ"9`LyAWȄ4$ Arbg$)LO Ӹ9࠹$ǂǒpxK,xF)#%Li*5-RVN] ~׈`XQ+XIe%CS}L@ow9'S\Zf3?{b1@ZpCKHu7=XUPK YZc{ _Yd9 ?_s}a58W ^"^=gG^V`&o-ٺ;R]+uZl ~ka`HlgùpkÅC NzѬv⑼g8 sj!ӵg2wO niAZ*e ZJN\FGLivq%\#x:zحcGd0.*zi5BGq&U0l00=}f_&x-zK[ [zԷD dރ/â;.Pq PA P H%QD]T&*uԭR ١1 ؗNۚJD) خi){*h BqW[-͗׋Αr.H pT S55X♱|0ACw Yl,P. 70fT-Nϥմy56]Nȋ[iszy'%]EzI {)KGۏ#|4 u+ Ă9HxAʇ5f@Q= "̻ MC U ((|m0 !O-jy:N>%3+_N!ko lx"{ujiro@Krcyӽ_,(RP1qLq?t/x:4P<2P]^Gz 9 =J*!U yz%Y0QqWp!uyCPn*zA ~#UX\^ 6$xg%fA׷8N}zm Ca ΄7eE彸]#3m6-q$Y= 6\mN<j64+%Z#kdYjچYmN3h\i9g##@'T#R'ݻ[)1LzuPld*3vCvh$FȲT֥ iGHQco#c@l$7ؚئKxᬹ<vQJxbFF 2&wПLR/ʹLƇtY^Îr*5>QNqw٥Uӳ{dͲNgrǾ}0~u h^0- n<ݣSx@G:%Sl8%p8ڞ/pCdn7|Zp2{T }B[ηz6tNUsKgD\2n;Rr@Iy_8 0v%QN`15+Ch;DTN: j[Xc \JX ۤyZ<b؆ZaE(;Hr`H^{%{`BT;&q!V hesOfVfX_~ ϟߑ.<1?1۠ \G }(?W|3hk굁7Ts9rQh\'Nߏ=]XVѲ1gK}Y9jJsdN"JTVMoJ9MN˟+R|/nj[}H>OSa_UiBN )O{PVՐ?&'I&l()]^84]HWcf`f0͖̐qbO !RTn] BJ̈'cY@%%FJl:WqGL#l4M3yYRT8E(m c?7iNׯGI4nH Њr9.dw{;YJdY>1Wjo =uW3Plc{T^Wf8p%f?T>"v :D9EyH { 4`}ֹm)-n J9& U1% o\.,JvQKr׹PJĜ 2bzҰnTbt'G'=w7.,M#M!j˙K;_BX6,²aA;q8Փ߭ܿ{bZ;LD]}J 4ڿ4 JE"!}־ӘR7=/]_TSL^ړA"YOA S? A!6 6= Ԁ{l }"!p!X@(@)V^aՎr@!Ø` `LUOuvdQkϕ,es}GGg$U^aWpi~]щ߂b'T8_ %G/ ~#V?NC&%+lMڤoGG T(/ADVnRlf].gA#W\A^[B{~ɝ2pYhlu7]Wg[62|{e ^^/^ UЅ*0jo\ ڍUMS akk(*lظZ9(8s&˫8zz39?<M=d\ZONN/ߨ{kBtt2 ,L<s,K=c^'n"!XdcbOX ’^LM? e] q4:}A?ixʸ5V{WZm醔V;R.3_^=nQ8rp~^<FsЌp/olfIALѴHNp#U;t|Dz|3U`/Ze5Y?"Ś[EN]Z;6ftJ K|T@j Mi"+lƚfqYV;]URwjՔ_?64Z߈#w%0sYx1?[äuU!"pxĢrhj̢C$(G@,L &eքS[b^BtI-Dƅ8%KUSiWLQ kzE԰ޑ^jJ@ӟi~6MVkW_ a]לTy>rx]ΩCr{<GN$&Ο{}y~rkfXͬ dgI$dyuvв';`G9пi9y$d]*a" *"ņiq@LjwXwKN)vMa#=T;FGmasCG )`=Y5$X8FK$ A}@Tzdٜb-^@@3lEFx֤a&&MsfL`C&EYIa3<~k1F.!#N8T#8Φt|E{vsw {'!jvRnydWu|D㩄LT!=Q' G4JrP5KhdW$)^'z;hO' ^7Mۻc7]يی @&P'k J?y{w9;9_; P)$SIFB(Ru[h'nhXCuYU[ ؤŴHoRc-f"5ߝ/9 Q&҈P__)/eyM+N/x*7K L̕Dw BT5^yjO~8XÂk}/`캭tvZr>X-b&!tg+MpqsR4, 7P"DFQ^"~Tx`I< K.c##Tu&/dy|?*l0J!%", 1SMHQ#QAQMѩ6i'8E#};>*;|H>,Bj|B_F 42Wxgdu`%.X,D4s\(jDS׎գO>=ןy_̞_̜^W8}O}(ޝm`Ѥ,lYwF-Τ$zH"\I"L iMhP!rIr"N!2 L"AG5+zX_Aͺ12}k`vI݀^]U8<1":\BQ&$j֢jC_񒅩?4i=يZ }Zti}yjɍvYu8Tl ʌ*[)mz 9Ee!ۥO1{͸ot`=it}8~ N kqG|lͻvkDrv[2<֔/j0B787iYu4&Q]e!z'dz睑 ǗJ'UH c1r!l[[pk%*^usT#4&[4R^7+ztI U6PKmtv0yCb[90P5픅5#۞mrxCe KME;V$I&Ca qWA a ĄH6࿗p L&NT Cң~/T9Ġc(eZ W![ep$2X3Ġ6*9Fm3m?Kmc;x!lŎe6[#2wfX^eo|"sLTuBrG/¯)l|ú~fum^ .)UlFi31YT5&~$<'b JC=f,b?B![I[S[w"\tߵ]̯?_%D: 'tdzU@-j 'jl G'^ŒXlf 8i!h)3bB~9 n ʻ8W|/?\spOff?b$h'^7-w;Яzh[@b }Td0E|&iS֐#}D}ZĵCk8|I-iՈtQ'ɅHbp7L%SaȜ0ML񲗁0\X.|ɣ+uwE. pMh@`$},'91 >|[eOu'MtVi[| ړANf_ZL.(' br%/2 C织C6v-2E4t%_Xo{٩SDnzx1b48at 2|Wj S(eUX,:`",%zu5_&(M' v⫷hi02Ri{᧶\Vq 73xglm^Eiџ0)Wmvۓ?UFc;}cw=uv{1EJHąnJd*򃆈$D%qܸUEI$h(?B DN];q̜sJ£'s٬w:YmT}b,$kk٫?enf\ZdV/ p^j߉it>4" a6N"i8_z; ga%Mfi33YA) ձ곽ϖ ϼ\ͬlZUڨآmd-/I@a(~Vl&(xDo*WS~Ʒt]k3p_,r=~)&f®0)qqRmIa3զאE 7Ё*|kOi=HSz }Y@ .K]ه;Pj e RQBo%>#_/cS76;JX+ݕQ _DS^`PT/eJ(r; 6;v;:V4 HIe8ddltHН,d!a^uJڝK%*K(NRo>tE#a CW :AMIQR M #Zoۿrqb_IB;]"!:EƢX9XށgwT_9gD* R=5rUYR>}+=wb6h?3řĐ/_ϛI6U\U%\\քy1QW%J(RGTŜJl~U`Kb4i#E!pڍJ:;RhUcLpQG6o_$n#ѱ lR@hȱ0Fd9 k &[e1z za)N B#f-XnwF(-IW@]dU*pM'fYJJ:eX?קE4[cM7b"[wli #t|[˕ąx!5TDzA]ToU}x6L;*T2&e3EtbV)ĭLc2o"mCtlZ:vǐnLtP|MԶ/7oV d;U>兡z=o_>[xhu(TӀ?2ƜrM.n%/JpnAJS6tIV/JVqZ'X!͗(м/q0ʭ|ER[ZeIayP6YS :(C~2< 2=CaټE0j nMP`ᄠTQ:JeC'-1dD &]Œ]C6vBz[{{Z^U.̤&svNe F#SPxJ&Q]GԦܜYE9Ψt *iՊ@uT)9܅lZj̸(E#NI)%TI;1d[Y-BF^%l5"C20fjp该A Wv9*=v}_?>r`ڋvsv枸zhv瀉rksC>I?5D2`X<n?cOYƋf3 HbݸgO7v7f2($ǩi4MOz[~W>涳昿-3Oi'ufH٫ѪNi%)pZsK[o0ad92z<,HCUF ]oGs̫gCBTXDj(&$+J o6 A iUhZfڲL%4cf4̀23UVKVV$9-IWdIdSYX%tMAwKp' |)&4z+Z5( Y+QrA&{2zSFȿ?>TNC<,:vx-!Љ N ή0ӆG@cUDIXMFH~B",Rh-[,zb[gw*iS[ ai52 r1,ƶ^{'zH/mp;G)BL.0$Nz6ΧJ-D)fkdޥL2x1<.bIA)'%LF`oCM_4K3J~4 ~MȎ+4}ݴWYoCۼSEB;ܘhZD+g_mu@!57E~LMf30_ Ғ$c SKBɱXKFY~t9ܞni*<4_\)QŢﺣ6=-&r]|Yfffhi' 8(N R,1_|ZUmiVKKd cH7 X}I C#.Dj0T$W@ 85P(E6W/eQծ*#O[|Q.G&qEK仄OvvמZ\]{; +~kcey=*n )O{]~jS~v܅Ecɱ$?6 Ba9.S "^qH1*66` B? B`@LvbA*ޡ$ڸ5eXlW9_S9,.p)ίÑKci(H.zFɓ|Ay8Aq%3)L3~z@oJL8YַJƯwݡ/ ӣ_} +ͨK`ȅR!b,P\# Gʧ(cm'j 3V]oʣr%}]:j^}v9QWV|/K_` Ju~ױc/2EgwGtR++_$VcN %6F΁#El@=i9!l IM7a~};컰wD1-Qt'Wy߃Kl|.>@狻.;D}B~N ̰l,?gx59t/~0-9Ntt{Sc1 c,{V>Vs='A$c{ȶA*rClNpl;L@Ad0DY+Ρ+[q5_䚢V/#v%g_fFs9DiHۜ8J G9tFgfCOCF1ڝZݸ׽q|'o=oΫ8ʫ ]M6$!$$qK(BW-֩DZ; m3vALl)i,jQjEQ!fݟfd=s9 9,@*0S#"~Y?]ڷ=&BM3i33 u,+YtN_Ä)GfYx3Gqg#:9]GP6?"| daj]G)%R`q@g9NҹJiXg3-aՅvx#:!:X"-Ǧjݎ P**BFfT,Xh$)dA^tҚ~;.^tt\l1?l&wmRFTCVjLvjÏf8)*K:]yI=,crzU$u~ՏD:FgF^Pj Fedo\:trBE9Vx=GT01{Zr 0[-bSc(LUַ&>}fWHhM}yW_< #zsXZ~zM$HD*{d9B<ڳ27"'K|a_| x`[4eu!8Lu JKlփS~eշUWFo]ssX1ip"+K8-v*5#:ښ//; ӵ5W^lJEI15顃N N%vZ$Mc(ߨگlȍ2I m`600<BWZ[LX(lͣ z>EUz5š7kPETu"=~hWbC;D|rP>b!yy)ЯAN |1@}Zdҽz61؛lA`"]>hPom1obJuT-:J{5>DYn^&m&}}πm9~j0gdf[aZvڹ4;JX Q6NS#@֫B]zjlT>G}fn1g< :S}dUc6>#+,UʬRvlz=il>IO#j9{ۋr%P7z&tz_}&d3gtZ#%~r#񺱗0m6GaYV|< O+CtX2㺺9OQ $OUjɿ\tR)JQq:j.A/YK;NzpK<><ϹsH7!OJ5~tOLiI-8>@&6g{|Pԇxڇ/ܟe&Lw{~ M& 9wlp U<`? y'+=7rj3lKy4FMЌLջy4)ߺ`b[}p^e ,nK.GfqST1֨mF&^Z=˷$ &T!32'ǂV|㬼go_Pa&9au&LDeZ嫦Ti0}>{cyLNYip#dX/ROZi?Ii;KnN`|mG.5l~hc@nW'@؝-: S!>CܗpUO޽bRB*"B20A-U;JcE vP:-TA)*XˆQR;XGA(ٻr^B7vs9]+`{>dpSr  7)2&{b靺Iz{C@X9ٟ8A{̧W5NO=ONIJpk\k|8"B*x}#(\ӭWD<^/׵r \/deڇ3KUж%UŐy>Y:F[=w%>7.b`밗زg6u.j;ug"=VW':N&ќR'ڲWC5nv PӜ>$xU~]d Qߖps􎖧EjZԿy)-((<q﹏ )-o]0l=ϋcГj?NԺ{]Nȶk̺DkdYOQ6h ՔU&Ϫ3Vm-qXsjgկQhWuFvl-8$'vmrN)&~D\y %6m˱bkIN;ȏSGZW%Jgc<9:;OҲ&.m:)wsZ.cĕ{{NϔIYع*z7jCgΛ-3G!IΪAbF9rʷ6Yd$ej0Oa,#[(Aʹm~[F2g&~_Z%khrkwO~'s+Ӏr\LX L\~Z!_?>ӴiYb _6iLJz$Ra\A " ޖ~ ojrj>_B{%n;G}OGc옦us6D㙱M Xid0e]g뉻r0ʕ&o~>fˀehr E ÇdxZJwIߢ_oE')'4Mruy&(aIEerg3c[xLPAsn{HFx4ك2Ӽ# J`;Yj 'Je0]jx>;o1~'cTxs8G9ź5&)FToQ鉯͸q:*KSNȍX,VoLqu?x:*nO1Le 0X ?Cef\4/UcxwHwMA4Xp%zn4 7> nhߖF;VQD^S[s،g^fLÑ+ҳF:2NvƆZ^X:ͫ_# lYufun;ncr\w`K<ݢjPgXr-ms[]aѱ%㏐:B$nv$:-N鈀s/0 1T9pߓ.;VbƁqumq͋n߽'] g x>J.u61EPK20h컬>AZ.75,D$Ob̥_c7土mW (`$}>4#^oGy]qpz%ghl)s2꽭V=9zQFsQ!w喗-Y7r*~y6^ ?nGޮeH&_d Fd$=@/099ϟA^U?jYIKs1\j4Ew[HY/ج3?Pm vBB҂-%*T>X1d#0q|ȶ00Eu 2cQA H\f\pqf(i~Ϲ/o:/9=uxφMLZ "?C MDi=:=E]܋B֭,dFx`9|(풶md6:3[&ےhL7-n09jK?[z꽊uೊPf{>nl;4~߆72f\8guJF}?*UeEEXG; =AFU=hR-}$Wjߢ}ws5*ރ]in~wZM~GGk*w>W~|A4<^Kէg}Ausa֏Cm?7hYVr%5GWIjS-n1Z/4cX8?kh}<nemZh_t~ƾ1b?4,+*FFؼlKb?Nek*dOucM`Jfsק'C oA+,B槴]̯2 Kdwe=ȃѐcU=+_dx~{<9# !A à/\38oP\OU9뤮gpw֪kwFZdC9ž®4}+~]Խf|^hLW'M:4FwuIdN0oK1u23|xPm<҂_u'ľN,LYB&DOܻHɱg^` 1sEx!,\_E7~WzTUW,CWubrZe:/O t|J/~n4R|`cL2k{X,ir$7RZ;._S7%7ry֋ tԳK>OI֗‰mpL["+-5rÎi]/='^p<{iMJbZe'[QW*m 2q0C/}LYYJU}þЭZ>7 }˥Oj*'"]+5fpEZtJjT;/ex2")m'E˥%g)w9pg5so,IC 1e,0|矖slg'.^  +MBwJ~#< ddDFwnN'8.~G}Uq{ lBB1)ɏHҐ,Z@!aB a0/da_nLj Z[DJRXӑg  -2Y/BMs߹z WXI;s$('rjR`s}\JJH )sSxg5y5By z;Q~,qK$ioWoQ߃"Ey'*]9YwEڛ^"߸oQ\ҕq}?Al8ϱr"N{Jc7qYǛs\.ҿ^dgl}1Y*d[=5%W)Rp[~Y7L_-sL_"{EIK;+ rKX Si/_sw.”R:yx%o4|n'Z@'oڝ7yߑ~ir<r݃"]ϳǢ*贬,?c2zLyռ.G IM\q<(\ZxKҼe:0EUDw(-9 |Un1Θ?Cr.' 3qĶvI]؏~hceuџ}>uM7dll'k7v38V0ʞ`}C;cn'^X؉jv8K2!{#;^]P!KѵrO-/kW ߨ)kڤM}Ǿ3TA"sN5r8r?%r%,Wv;hϋ{J{MTǶN nby?+bG/wIWm"AaFc1ߤ{Y,7ă?}ʇ+O-/Jy|sWqGxp}H]k7;)Qė#)[S\\wc83 ?Nstow&xu Wuu/"G1Fm{|Ʊx1,&c!`=V[@-t> YL-߰Yf:KM=qY޷c D9D9ɲ80LԨ9CuM86u2M,#kvuD:.e MwDj^cRSҐZu^M)MkLs։vqe9jXqLi5 5>M_rdoCg8[ijcb֍)K+f)DXAbZo׿sf2[Dfk2&RD*$fc4jvDwgfRpYPlu^-iͲDOƌ&GBf(ܚmL} sLf֘hlCFj&fsO8-G tGf~))QuL'zR!IW7̞xJ,ik,ӊuZ69ҡT$)[`$]Բ:YVoG"h _RԘJ%43`؊SD_ #>(>b յ`o9q[cԮj% ;_c>˘J¸R\pO<".ʆRqK4qGRIR#{T\ؿZL,(8<)rUrjnqS4Z N_m,!CÁJw oc3TecE~v8$^A1AÃchL~:G &J\Hi|PJ2IxIy>NdqѲ(ŋbc/gP*ϴsW0&2kT_e~]v˙d^͢G'uϹ׾cnl@CC8o I( cg$ vh;PwZ4T]K4P+% (7?QaioҢalL;P$^&&}=fr @Yܝҝ;L㢧EhzXq˯g4^xz]dK:ʍcƉ X$3̿^`lmq<źd1'`e%|X*X@ֺg"mi#˂g?2af 6ivk@7qY0+x|FKeႵ;5DziG.- ^Vx,wG_`'7x0,6?E\.aCݼkjZƼ*3:U/+Ǵޅ׸] _NzD! Fo[o׷HXc+|3V4GV8d dϲjzK;HIWǯݥI+k%xEni!(SIM4hbе$(zU괴Њr)xK'NI=9uy+|,v3\5"=`pщčpQE, D/1vQ9 Y<Qk|f|Lx'ϳ]"EљQkdZls}m̞E5 smW-AF188hu49|:zGuV:W9+N9%'qV,!sXx(66q8\N |JNI85R$?nREǃ}Pt|=H3(OcdY՞B(m| MK$ugL*v-^C־V\mW _У&ū.nM[[.1#ܧݽC+Ii8"pɤW}O3n/nnl`80  OJ_6r;J&pPhO$F\\s W>,OSf9*wYَ(˱bRNgݦ{}m7%喲U>E1_QN)ʬVR{}-{>wpA ס$"d)\˗ CX [<h@+ ɯ>6: .PInJּk 7i)ll-B=%cmyNU?>rD3ɑ\bZQN( 3 ?O㧘\r x<ו J > endstream endobj 32 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[287.0 220.0 301.0 231.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 16 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 3/Type/Page>> endobj 42 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (04-07766.a1)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\ ved%20-%20HTML/04-07766.a1.html)Tj 50.24 0 Td ([7/2/2021 3:33:33 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 688.5 591.75 77.25 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 756 Tm (cohabitant, or associate\(s\) in question are)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 16.8 0 Td (not agents of a foreign power or in a position to be exploited by a fore\ ign)Tj ET Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 742.5 Tm (power in a way that could force the individual to choose between loyalty\ to the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 31.852 0 Td (person\(s\) involved and the United)Tj -31.852 -1.125 Td (States;" Directive \266 E2.A2.1.3.1.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (3. )Tj ("Contact and correspondence with foreign citizens are casual and infrequ\ ent;" Directive \266 E2.A2.1.3.3.)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 15 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 2/Type/Page>> endobj 43 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (04-07766.a1)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\ ved%20-%20HTML/04-07766.a1.html)Tj 50.24 0 Td ([7/2/2021 3:33:33 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm (Applicant testified that he contacted his sister every one to two months\ and that his wife contacted her mother with)Tj ET Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm (about the same)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 6.248 0 Td (frequency and sent her money periodically. )Tj 17.577 0 Td (Applicant has not rebutted the presumption. )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 17.802 0 Td (See, e.g.,)Tj /TT0 1 Tf ( ISCR)Tj -41.626 -1.125 Td (Case No. 02-24267 at 7 \(App. Bd. May 24, 2005\). )Tj (The record in this case does not support the Judge's conclusion that)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (Applicant's contacts with family members are casual and infrequent.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Department Counsel argues that there is insufficient evidence to support\ the Administrative Judge's overall favorable)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (security clearance decision. )Tj 11.272 0 Td (Because the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 5.053 0 Td (Judge erred in her application of FIMC 1 and FIMC 3, and because she err\ ed in)Tj -16.325 -1.125 Td (not including and evaluating evidence of the intelligence gathering post\ ure of)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 31.24 0 Td (Taiwan in her decision, the continued)Tj -31.24 -1.125 Td (viability of the Judge's ultimate favorable conclusion about Applicant's\ security eligibility under Guideline B rests on)Tj T* (whether there is any sustainable basis for her ultimate decision indepen\ dent of those errors and omissions. )Tj 42.684 0 Td (Beyond the)Tj -42.684 -1.125 Td (establishment of the basic facts that give)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 16.467 0 Td (rise to the government's security concerns \(i.e., the establishment of \ the fact)Tj -16.467 -1.125 Td (that Applicant has family ties to citizens and residents of foreign coun\ tries\), there)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 32.823 0 Td (is a paucity of evidence in this case.)Tj -32.823 -1.125 Td (The only favorable facts cited by the Judge are that Applicant has cut a\ ll ties with Taiwan other than his relationship)Tj T* (with)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (his sister, that he understands his responsibility to the United States \ in holding a security clearance, and that he)Tj T* (would report any attempts to blackmail him or)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 18.829 0 Td (his family to his supervisor. )Tj 11.388 0 Td (Those facts either do not readily suggest)Tj -30.217 -1.125 Td (refutation, extenuation, or mitigation of the government's security conc\ erns, or they have)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 35.808 0 Td (low probative value. )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 8.442 0 Td (See, e.g.,)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -44.25 -1.125 Td (ISCR Case No. 04-00109 at 5 \(App. Bd. July 13, 2006\); and ISCR Case No\ . 02-22461 at 12-13 \(App. Bd. Oct. 27,)Tj T* (2005\). )Tj (Given the totality of the record evidence, and given the errors in the J\ udge's application of the two mitigating)Tj T* (factors and the Judge's failure to address)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 16.425 0 Td (significant evidence relating to the government of Taiwan, the Judge's)Tj -16.425 -1.125 Td (recitation of these facts was not sufficient to support her favorable co\ nclusions under)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 34.239 0 Td (Guideline B.)Tj -34.239 -2.125 Td (Department Counsel has demonstrated several errors below that cannot be \ corrected by remanding the case, given the)Tj T* (record evidence. )Tj 6.857 0 Td (Taken cumulatively,)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 8.469 0 Td (these errors warrant reversal.)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 7.497 -2.125 Td (Order)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -22.823 -2.125 Td (The Administrative Judge's favorable security clearance decision is REVE\ RSED.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Signed: Jeffrey D. Billett)Tj ET 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 16 384 cm 0 0 m 120.645 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 359.25 Tm (Jeffrey D. Billett)Tj T* (Administrative Judge)Tj T* (Member, Appeal Board)Tj T* (Signed: Jean E. Smallin)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 16 282 cm 0 0 m 114.656 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 257.25 Tm (Jean E. Smallin)Tj T* (Administrative Judge)Tj T* (Member, Appeal Board)Tj T* (Signed: James E. Moody)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 16 180 cm 0 0 m 119.994 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 155.25 Tm (James E. Moody)Tj T* (Administrative Judge)Tj T* (Member, Appeal Board)Tj T* (1. )Tj (Department Counsel did not appeal the Judge's decision as to Guideline C\ . )Tj 31.091 0 Td (Therefore, only facts regarding Guideline)Tj -31.091 -1.125 Td (B are pertinent.)Tj ET q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 12 0 0 12 16 39.75 Tm (2. )Tj ("A determination that the immediate family member\(s\) \(spouse, father,\ mother, sons, daughters, brothers, sisters\))Tj ET EMC Q endstream endobj 44 0 obj <> endobj 45 0 obj <> endobj 46 0 obj <>stream H\j@}l.lhNE4B]e5}gC t?Ysv]]=ݷs]oodskEloӳl.%|] L!G\gᛯjv O`"٘/R^M8y%0%رdʶ+JrErmLvk//w,֏Ha ;N>'eT&0)keLfSdSͦ 8QN2jZ@@Ȓf Y,!K%diIV2>stream H|TU}8 8^8T4DyK,V(QQ,K,X;DT^U5{dgfٳηf Pq`}]iqr&-4<*,zҍ \71.Eѽ:tT0"2+`?@uoԜ@2_>rl)}>Q1W( @Aa H(Qan;%`Y?GACcgףDD[x %A,TQ'#PAaE(FQb,^fש[~7 hڬy`jݦm>_tePW~]ݺC0 ٻO~D =xИ 1G7q'LL49qiӓf̜5{y,ĢK&/[b)k֮[6nڜe;vڽg8|̬'rN:3gϝp\ڮCYLB30 &CWF cx2Oe|_2"H|(t%SyWWO^}uպk?hfk/BS/`4"S鉹y9<Ǽb8YY*X*ZX4K K-KGK%c֡Һ{t_PqzOg V}O?+]@V~mB" =G6)攉)RRG<'hhh*)zSTTrg 0 ؗy$Kx+QV+J2IPr'^x*ww3S3iwB8mvL]Ӟi/M0EbLIds9=Ce;^%L!=$=Y_CpYrhC_?!xxXRRRS^'9rHm Mn'QQގײ$ WJ Y4au X沯\}n.3]f'EFR-uP c!.&`k,!,G(L'8O)Yr s|/Eė _5<1_|omw>?~ȿ#~O)?/9/_P!uXQG1u=m/[P'mW2&;[D<\/kFQ|Aijq(p$ELi2N%O @)e,el"D씃rR.My(/i(ME*Db@)ӝtg}Kw+Zѩ1Q0*I4TBO=FAEh"E$LSSJ3\P/+ZQzޫ>Â]c͆ӱe9gLpV9sr.y8/%Mn_q7M\ȝ隸 ܅\pQ..rs@`.!\Kqiw] .e+Ujw \+qeUW\kqmu$pcnM7ܒ[f6ܖq{w.5Mw^ܛp_yo;ăMI2fI1 xa= Ov9iHuv9⮳gh3  |ȀȤ;YsYdAVdCvs9D9_CNBnA^!?W((((G AIBiAYC򨀊ʨꨁڨhFh&hfhhVh6"m ]5tǷa:Nb'z7/?B.袺(tq:sP Cuyvh{6צ"0#00c00aGHD,LDDc&c bcf:1 1Y<"H$$c>R K a9V`%Va5`-a=6`#6a3`+aYkavbv+{qP<۸ŝqW9q#j"Vĉx1+u`6Mfbmfav]fc۩vn.k思agYvc;>!_<xxxxxT;|4ߚ9l憹in9f抹j~s܏D?O)_/ _oos|4 ܍&w }?Mj:w."y*"Jh5. x<ڃV]=Qi4>ʀ}cL}X1l5o?:Yq'#8&O 8)&Niu xGQD%W?|%_i]ӆGoOi /# 6?\ME@c`ԫ4|#r95iCK5q<}0I9P6 ql S[Yp dWFíOy<:5^_Ll9StAn@{ƚ*RjVrS=si*R9~V$h%HCIg9a~ĞJCG[R@ӡj`ǁKDRxbX]F4f`X;i(Xp"M.fx(xpFFy.夸L`JZيf>voDdş!&ނ>nQ;.^Ky-9'OEd_r\ER3h(?5#j!Z.ZGl)"}t#ಂ!^y:,E,sZ<ňP8:DpQ,EN}}q@|/!Ί/.'$g"m[$-& Q#+`YJ:v v.A *[mTg/ooȔZ,}Am!%h)c7 Ѥ!ED/+%k8yM6 趞bdazZ mDW\$'cV7[7nΥ}07!8[C"'ȡ m5D:Ȇ"vYN@~H C ' Ȟ3f9iW;u9LQJOH^/{%rEkqT+rpB]@cђ KE*Ew>ZdGvRfvUq7-؉S@.9!B/&qTr1a*+`32j3nӝgg8~\uyb)K@yVU'L-5nF>lhZjJrR-v@~1}"#=;WHݻm"SKjFP)1 Ӟgdv쮑)ɚK׌N]kiEnȯ9uf y]@ U j.#wauss)=b0$#Rn,"ҕ(('2u;- *i]ÓlpN^f>B9e [a,ͱvCZcrous(yzgNwc; :Eo&ǽsEѬϷB3~S~az<\/KE,tnBwY-*O+}U^#gPq)::{F.WS؇|ŵ{fk}IIn iƐ^=*R`%w-IC+נ[F2 g`c1nctB3vkƇ>O>jŇ'K+X6D+.9p$t G$/lP `>*tc'3 6w8,7gS*F]QYLe%y zZOztM߽DFPB_Ј0We?_4ͭ|G/yٟH2x6]{g=~L؞ĞM&'`4%$vيT)W[+m([tmH08D*JUVݶZjjK[5NόëS>sgΝ{w=01"¤!O|`1BI7L[ G0A[,>TTʨ?67͑.OMQ$a”L\],ڞ-S,.K˳G_PDpwCg'NG؊[ }A]W3\5J`g]dƣiJꝨA}}BG )eFC#<0P&jSS$47D{8RÎF'F[@ Q Ѕ*zVz (tجG"Mèb6#2^6f}A\%f@Ѫ<1PA| Rc')\(쮰+H7/I&YxWxwewn|4d[U\LGG{]tz\X$8ܜ$~\ ~$G\{E.Ezvg5uwQ04UAt\tMfRRIzAb^> 붨VOmRw6K8QmOZxh+jx ~,55-X0@/ Q`x$S$ 6,BX+ ^wvS$D5Ϋb/˿o6}O?$QɼWVéHZ}WZ|]i$x 1ڼvbe"-c ga\D`Y!c1^ #?HYyDr )-Nٻl,p2t!%ݚkLWڍSrLjr * 3SPf客T o f \7qWRbn@T(h3GΣbrx7VB hauut,ޖdb@cjbq+,霽Ӿlhfu?~ HRܸgW`4IHY8M T*9;qrٛQ_GSumVR^]I@I5gԷl{GJugZZ}!?[ZBa(SI_Sg>?_>L,|%ԙ5V&1Qa!:s,:O|tbi[/_:4u?4`xAS /-۳>AAu}O~[F}Yj,hv^lsT%|a.ԾAE6g&rkת\|aOuvQJВD8<ܼdΐ䕪%v?|ls{|;w; &PH)?;h!GK dcAfRҰ[W)KB14M[i@U]D1UIv }|>< MW 3Tk=} {=b7G_ Op X,!)$(zMI1J""Y/b0ml^븄(nñL$b'Vu1 B`̆:QBb]v$_/vd? ^d ;IRapz(IdPáxM{hzde 'iw]DLl>o4O5L+o&#bXK*Շ腒Q*ئ'KmWY=nAwO@,N7Dzu4}4s4{9ǜU=,Y!zXyl1RE#>Wob^`aB6Wr}l|oy宎4-&<^0i_'~Ovt{;ubΆԜ[7Dm*RG*n$V*OҊڎtv[zlOZCm k\f(&,Bu$+|U[>mI|Iɜ1}y3_jvV*t$ 798oGwYպ(˓.,p(eS kib-Uz0!aB*vi%t|Xd뤂#D+8b5(&'HKOʺDڶ5-w12@+e`.+N!B fJ41Bɥt=)WIp|AR7.GnLJ Vt$Ųգ^יKy5$b&# ׂ^v$,27|?;nLR(5 ęLq/?qc>"Ԥe#0Z'l,NnUbxW]g?]_7#eQ_m}ΞZȚm [_Gf/x?;\x"xB8Gx; ]Oҭb޷ο1xaS햣jjEw( ^/`9~+:L tvo71Axwn:\t`{jV蟛)ksZ)2%a瑞c?nOwv\-A?߹> hy-q:pյe/|&-˸p"aJh*S(k"5ōq2WsB4-I%IV8jrRwsDrKd+Xi ǫ9]Bc@#u-r(R=N|ZDIjWgz/ 5f+dLq$%O P h*d! ?ܷeMU;j{g}l kayVWWxsڿ}~8QgpY|5/UKF={oJvZ1_<p3^˼6Xi<,^KՌUBxP|!89)E.G_R8.^9eBVKE˩Rr*v3y5TM?W{l.Η8yLȃIx @!ЖQhH'AQ:AY){0Z 3ZZHIT&e]e!ij;;t"|}{J Da;GBUP*?Os(TzYDc{ަhH2x 1 yz՛jY򒿓D(iD oƝp[KV%;xO/(aYj>O 5vR7=^+:ykhYԫT%.`3j>^kw/^H}'M6#c-G"7˙4ZQ?юӎ_ \v;]mg([6EY$Ee(QKE$=Iز&\vۺW4qӮ\EaEam V,kՉ=`tg6`F'+P`vD>Q}G+s埔.7^/_1/YsQ=߲ͧȷ >s/r G^Ggø^qпA{N$ 1Ze\@Ԕ`DPdA#d &>j{a/LH. 5`Qd-/#פkz"a::E-7f?cffXqYsEg-ߑߧ}?&ܡgSygzbf7(V[*?{-g߽J$&bN<;WIV9H4)/lw.tq7V_,o0P߆ʐԔkZ${ZSxK/:*<p$ݳO! ą|0D!$S|N+`A }*@tMM9i3G93U:k&rV5(MidLIpS×!%]84 { l;oxmO݄h_䖇Plp0IuG-3Pua;=ovP.1լC=GFbᘟbC3*( I7]k 뷯V[(OtO&: ~XNQ/+t|CjF?&?Fd5!M?)TҠs38`g$e 9Ҽnt. ⲗ4Džn.!99^A%02.39^WϬF+D3,p l6ܜԜ'f~Um|U#BPm1xSr2W+95[g#`THh,ZxUM6Ts!>nk Y儶zleHA gDŦCNwܜh 3#oN1 ̍7O"? J ̠f+vѺ= : if&oRap5bT+d3KЈh:e*'pƥ8)!!۲}%iK-@t4*'@mq$ 8_No%{#q'eӡp%b`9D/E3W_D$$OeK9ٖk \*0MٜX)N]Wne`q28af ]2@m5{:Z3)367oX}e++n ®f~.PHF8VOBJp|д?hDz F:l L/y㬧D]YHž'V/:b}& . cF2LufXȝunk}VvVS4E{'S `QGcB'ZqCq؉:^me* Ǵ R!jovyAlSm W/T7X#Ֆ~Yo9x70bPM:m҃{Zڠ܎ͺ"7,JLI3&i""#cdw 77)6gcLVz[UߗONC_H0pnE7~y+ˁC¾!tDx}D}"\;5%Y15>yTS8RY-|& ģ@iRr q,YH,i^u"QTK.꺆S8zDD·MgXvl6&mNoC^rk43ķ놠F3wXf `;2@ߙdUx\Ldrå;%G)1_Lݽ[0I֪GPo T׈51byI;QZZH@":k^kNiެ؅GHķ͑F ;všO)2{+kHR|oUȥmԭSƪaYQ]Mw;w8_&~I\%BIx ЉV h +)- F*, Dm FŤL*uIKU1-%*Ǐ;_|m2j?ZtlgaO/LD47"v[ -]V##SO`V3O|x77n̻x2ܣýr>T`m}KN`vdRO!U=yيUIPktXNyUkV~ne-+ٽp5~aΰθ =f;ßzzg~q $INH%QП@$Q\A2o$w!G1GA1,7ІKGDD O) RbYTURQ4[E:|Z^~7<*?- 0뫹 vj ĤRDl~hDPi.կ Wp;Uq_C1zjGy[ɩi,ɢ<5]~ `"Õ$h6aq&(<1=sYsPLʺ-=7xmWL_݊Mh%>ܷ-sRyʜm?{oAJhs}Z:$jܨy "bى'S;ԗVO!]]Yk U"j7VhTVD譨ZA FCԱ&l'8Nई٩v-, -\`lK)|*w8{%4{!$)>gQEYO~_ګ {w}_(($E!I CdG T ) bAB D6Pȃ@(8- OAixwox$hgf9{={wlѹ6&6Hw6t.i>F[% 27Z۬6Wv{jz9ө&>4˶-/=Yp4}>)+"_ȧI.; 끃N^.Uo:|@qjCAVR|'->D\Ua^6v:Sq@M|Z31?J Z}0gףڣ21&2scwް !J%v*S6*蔛@?~#~s[f|a972^{і@SM1? ktxUb3{n+|'=׼$|}c\Ha[<{ab-Ƨ/.F|C^->؞NB`K/0ċ>'%>K7yO+O;AI]|I"<YFgEg >Ȕxh=j#P뙾ϢI67Bt*| 1D%pql!qh:R?hZLGoγVjU,ǩ3˩KlHA_}ĩh40Z.9"p%+1}U1VU o.:2,jM q `H2Y6*Jt+hAb--~9M~ _%OL=''͵%?G " r9r7f?UQA)".OٿGppb~?l Q׀i#aj&4QK  !arSu%j RGxiSK>}ovO7?VGu3RD2q(1e`:8/E _3)Opny#c@oӨLc/u ֜rqL]0@s80Yj t ̜YHLSg&Խu3d8Cp3;r[k$~xYu~V5+N7ބ' KM"$ssuZ,e tMsلZZ4<7Dj/٩4؀5$q{/kڦE@Qhn䛮b ߟ_Dџ&uzӼ.jԯe>YJiSJ[[H}D_s/?5n~^n>>iTkO@ 9 QB|[W *?EO3 KpuWs $c(Ѽ(}}dμ-7ּFy{㍐fsNnNy{Lǜ8Q+>SSGԷ%gڽ''Gj\"C,F>qYkIq "Pxu=o ``)&6Ĝ=8J!q_ nCr۵vTM"5즚sG$OD ]~]y>wBw%=yxS8oƏKcθ-Z8-)&7[iۼ[ML$|T; ȿhzԳGy5N.a#CoSicH:z(T"Ԫ#@f 78f-<t#gQ7E*5R݁Rs'G}#\*b?mMIn>}qIY}hzOŸ F"Sr.,!g#[7&{zܑAtfb}'#7B{X.QSyK4Ч> y]Z}ca]計j0?!ѕR=>Q>ێޢ =}iVSN\b7u1{L$>(L"F((ÙDx-y c<3xv^tq~ gR!W:k|{,j˴{M?d =s7 噢ʏGp'2xƾ-ѳYh}xOuY5 tuϪ:OT(X }}'[z󡶘sɘϵno[UIϟ7J:=򈶏1Nj◴$记`}ވ(F*(,wN4PXkɥ0nM%QQ# #Xi$ʞxyF%0p-Ϲ M5`w<({&ii, 2,Ga"Zvx/T>W Kbs luvK|/~"!<'qTbM<>֟ht|jᬯwxG)I|[l=6pgcL$%XJQvY׃/n+uhi/71/xdy]>$@+(AQsU:r} S;5 _Bˠ=%DzL]pc:&bÛ=,3hޭRQ`PR,~C#S&Sc.7iYBZC̡U6,zDe<(`7Rg,3Ƙ~ ~m\W/:bv*ƙA_6(vxh9̧ {ĜgPvo͠V9td/t/XGԺyw_[yj(4>|<Y &g^샊<%]{|6\֖m2D'ur⾶E^"gH@_7!gQ{|gCZd!W[xssB߯ȧMA. %jf5 ;[{<݃,K 侗;#E(f?]}rxA=ji>CٲWޜA< x ~F 9þҰ^>> 5,3) 4+h 簫7^5b#.G֘νGWwת1zOh}䎾.Zj.{RWPIEm)1Frsa} X#اOK~=H<=OOz4Z[kBq=~b5DuB/ơ={>_\oz u =3}ߙuFQ#셭+lj ,pL@L(+ ?d1>t`,~:H-j%5cD.]IAg&KEFg[du yFus\j%e}+biDR ; ?z7U'W-v͢3)kFSs FGE|=}iޡ,/uy&$+nS0A ֘ȊL H`,JF(.2KFKJSNݥ1it{?|TXvJ~mf)UZ:_>g*ϼg[S3waA%s9k:߶}=uL~5HArQe[a/=8k>gEmVzT0Ao8W{)s͘LdiAzELV>6NFK7MՑc{S3l9;óGeJd*rP$DЫ9 "#` +d<,yS*˱c&|mGsn<t1bwf^1b=n*ȜysֈqK8*?UxR{rleG7?UE2#}'Q/w%+}dϘX${Ӄh=cCKoT)Ñط䐻|wE8ưd5.5w~D}<,/m㝰BQz!Pl*jb'T53oc9Bۗ{Old6x+Q{: /ѬP5Y4F7CNkd`>Bg rNesg4݋j2 =[H{O1^`<>-wTe:g3tIeh̵iF{;2ܘR]|\TD*Hׯq7+uN;0x5/A_p%g9AjÏΗ}ܗFqy;_+^ŴnZ&y@ ~N> .sP83SN-w8s)5 gZOی T@$aRs742|LT3k]R]GسSɭwVzh0V9xt2䓛dYym g)2`RH]2"=Ԍqr".'r1勠]:d 0;ԙ)Qg1B;ߖe& ;U$OJuО^<뫼gƢf7eaY_< %CI{2wnܓ1UӘ[lj!n_TF?#Me;q*I#IoB;i #9 s!ۍ%.Nƛis7Z52ԻLnfs4SVAZH_(&/b`>+(3L6OsbhH>_Jw$ Gk঎᜕9n u?!oY7\qS<?ҭ y6ʻ?$n!;C,JkNZs2H !h0h < BI@^Ӂq@˜;g_),bX,bX,bX,bX,bX,bX,bRtxQ$jmNdi 9GZ'[Tivi6qǾiL8NK4PJh`@ mKYuIVBBB*+M<1wNnC&1!C5m < DXrU22gOyKe eCaI]sY)*YjgП-..nPQg~{[yĭۈθ%-8"LV oyd9^rw5n$R}?q5 Az aGjjq9NܩPYfPJiO743J o>}IN'l+[Yd9夓 rE7m砑CQE 9L!nRr l'$oWU3T5.~0B"6aT&?;mt&ϧ2SAM`D>'휝=a'BcYbg|63̱TB$2ӳY#d6KoJdǡ;31%$s2Sl"dEOj,JӢ6$L6aOƳJY}싉=m {rN&H/kE%i٠ʑT:>KMڹd|}8Oړq_4*߹8aCYD޽B!U2g?8^ҪOQzd >"1vM+F\\{ /2nG xP(]eKw"hKPQg&ڨ79 X\ZKDcK@8/:w4(SfXf7o5_V"y"H6.{-n oF@(y _fWdgf";p:yut-[$5!p0 xFueEjSΫ,=NGoǼ4R\s+9miK-]kuftuѮGӜTkeAڂ"E"ƆeX:eu֓0maMϋFy=(x$p$ ^_ I]f`F^)uf;tĬ!Y~s ǪTfm`2rLK8Zie.!`J tYu;5#l*/YjUuZ~i"pvs]ΎNVXo t\rDjx5q6f?-rr5}ԳF n+ε""xo-9,EP@_XÐ'm4XllCco.b'ikY+#-%┪⾻Òb4Yu Fh3f@"W MHEٜ\@cAݭn7;-hW,[`WuQ8kelN5Myc߶^/jQ~~#)rM50Qys(`x! 5Ts>(a&t/q?zeE s>?f74$Y~rOU!2`)C^{Cc ];Nym W~هP&</џ= h=szRqO'i4yV{k5ޕ*ou{]^KW"-߅I.]$6jx+b}ZPO) :Z  ?GGh_j_EZy蓅Z#}:/) iIzj(zAґS;Ntu}۞]>]-~Zk,|ohLHLq;$_Ծݷ{E IA-Z 4- BbbHnƐ#wG8Kwy{w~Nieg]cVL{8b%A7`iL &0!54M06 foK&-7&`Elw(]TGKxzRȵrO=!?弔GR)U7hmþ@i D&|$lw;eAJ%)gn3nB-/⅄ڏ0wR+vFi{KIp))P&:rMH)&2Y&8:2[4Lr,ev~RuT¦`r/s&sfgtdMU\S;}[|c>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 1/Type/Page>> endobj 48 0 obj [50 0 R 51 0 R] endobj 49 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (04-07766.a1)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\ ved%20-%20HTML/04-07766.a1.html)Tj 50.24 0 Td ([7/2/2021 3:33:33 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm (when his mother died. )Tj 9.137 0 Td (Applicant has)Tj ET Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 729.75 Tm (no plans at this time to travel to Taiwan.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (There is other record evidence not made the basis of a finding of fact b\ y the Administrative Judge that nevertheless is)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (pertinent to the issues raised on appeal. )Tj 15.94 0 Td (That evidence is: Taiwan ranks sixth in )Tj 15.968 0 Td (the ranking of the seven countries most)Tj -31.908 -1.125 Td (actively engaging in foreign economic collection and industrial espionag\ e)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 29.796 0 Td (against the United States.)Tj -29.796 -2.125 Td (Discussion)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (The appeal issues deal primarily with the Administrative Judge's conclus\ ions.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 7.156 -2.125 Td (Whether the Record Supports the Administrative Judge's Ultimate Conclusi\ ons)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -7.156 -2.125 Td (An Administrative Judge is required to "examine the relevant data and ar\ ticulate a satisfactory explanation for" the)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (decision "including a 'rational connection)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 16.833 0 Td (between the facts found and the choice made.'" )Tj /TT2 1 Tf 19.053 0 Td (Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Ass'n of)Tj -35.886 -1.125 Td (the United States v. State Farm Mut. Auto Ins. Co., )Tj /TT0 1 Tf 20.636 0 Td (463 U.S. 29, 43 \(1983\))Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (\(quoting )Tj /TT2 1 Tf (Burlington Truck Lines, Inc. v.)Tj -20.636 -1.125 Td (United States,)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 5.61 0 Td ( 371 U.S. 156, 168 \(1962\)\). )Tj (The Appeal Board may reverse the Administrative Judge's decision to gran\ t,)Tj -5.61 -1.125 Td (deny, or revoke a security clearance if it is arbitrary, capricious, or \ contrary to law. )Tj 33.402 0 Td (Directive \266 E3.1.32.3. )Tj 9.034 0 Td (Our scope of)Tj -42.437 -1.125 Td (review under this standard is narrow,)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 15.079 0 Td (and we may not substitute our judgment for that of the Administrative Ju\ dge. )Tj 31.105 0 Td (We)Tj -46.185 -1.125 Td (may not set aside an Administrative Judge's decision "that is rational, \ based)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 30.499 0 Td (on consideration of the relevant factors, and)Tj -30.499 -1.125 Td (within the scope of the authority delegated to the agency. . ." )Tj /TT2 1 Tf 24.54 0 Td (Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Ass'n,)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 10.74 0 Td ( 463 U.S. at 42. )Tj (We)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (review)Tj -35.28 -1.125 Td (matters of law )Tj /TT2 1 Tf 5.97 0 Td (de novo.)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -5.97 -2.375 Td (Department Counsel argues that the Administrative Judge erred in applyin\ g FIMC 1)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 420.25 443.25 Tm ( \(2\))Tj ET 0 0 0.933 RG 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 420.25 442.5 cm 0 0 m 13.806 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 434.0562 438.75 Tm ( and concluding that Applicant's)Tj -34.838 -1.125 Td (family in Taiwan are not agents of a)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 14.717 0 Td (foreign power and not in a position to be exploited by the Taiwanese gov\ ernment.)Tj -14.717 -1.125 Td (Department Counsel's argument has merit. )Tj 17.287 0 Td (When the government has)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 10.719 0 Td (established a security case, the burden shifts to the)Tj -28.006 -1.125 Td (Applicant to rebut, explain, extenuate, or mitigate the security concern\ s. )Tj 29.101 0 Td (Based on Applicant's testimony,)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 13.151 0 Td (the Judge)Tj -42.252 -1.125 Td (applied FIMC 1. )Tj (The record evidence does not support the Judge's conclusion that none of\ Applicant's family members)Tj T* (are agents of a foreign)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 9.19 0 Td (power. )Tj (Applicant has eight siblings in Taiwan. )Tj 18.913 0 Td (At least one brother is a municipal employee)Tj -28.103 -1.125 Td (there, and Applicant's brother-in-law has worked for the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 22.7 0 Td (Taiwanese military for almost twenty years. )Tj 17.855 0 Td (Moreover, the)Tj -40.556 -1.125 Td (Judge has failed to articulate a rational basis for concluding that Appl\ icant's family members are)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 38.806 0 Td (not in a position to be)Tj -38.806 -1.125 Td (exploited by the Taiwanese government. )Tj 16.495 0 Td (The Judge merely stated in purely conclusory terms, without elaboration,\ that)Tj -16.495 -1.125 Td (the relatives were)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 7.302 0 Td (not in a position to be exploited. )Tj 13.165 0 Td (For these reasons, the Judge's favorable application of FIMC 1 is)Tj -20.467 -1.125 Td (arbitrary, capricious, and contrary to law. )Tj /TT2 1 Tf 16.799 0 Td (See, e.g., )Tj /TT0 1 Tf 3.832 0 Td (ISCR)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Case No. 04-03720 at 3-4 \(App. Bd. Jun. 14, 2006\).)Tj -20.63 -2.125 Td (As part of its argument regarding the Administrative Judge's application\ of FIMC 1, Department Counsel complains on)Tj T* (appeal that the Administrative Judge)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 14.913 0 Td (erred in not discussing the intelligence gathering posture and past reco\ rd of the)Tj -14.913 -1.125 Td (government of Taiwan with reference to the United States. )Tj 23.714 0 Td (Department)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 4.97 0 Td (Counsel's argument on this point is persuasive.)Tj -28.684 -1.125 Td (Although an Administrative Judge is not required to discuss each and eve\ ry piece of record evidence in making)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 44.82 0 Td (a)Tj -44.82 -1.125 Td (decision, the Judge cannot simply ignore, disregard, or fail to discuss \ significant record evidence that a reasonable)Tj T* (person could expect to be taken into)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 14.69 0 Td (account in reaching a fair and reasoned decision. )Tj /TT2 1 Tf 19.741 0 Td (See)Tj /TT0 1 Tf (, )Tj /TT2 1 Tf (e.g.)Tj /TT0 1 Tf (, ISCR Case No. 02-)Tj -34.431 -1.125 Td (19479 at 6 \(App. Bd. Jun. 22, 2004\) \("...the Judge's decision cannot \ simply be)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 31.446 0 Td (silent about what, as a matter of common)Tj -31.446 -1.125 Td (sense, appears to be a relevant factor that could be an important aspect\ of the case"\). )Tj 33.949 0 Td (In Foreign Influence cases, the)Tj -33.949 -1.125 Td (nature of the foreign government involved in the case and the intelligen\ ce gathering history of that government are)Tj T* (important evidence that provides context for)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 17.994 0 Td (all the other evidence of record and must be brought to bear on the Judg\ e's)Tj -17.994 -1.125 Td (ultimate conclusions in the case. )Tj 13.219 0 Td (Here, the Judge's decision is completely silent as)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 19.759 0 Td (to the evidence of record regarding)Tj -32.978 -1.125 Td (Taiwan's history of intelligence gathering and industrial espionage. )Tj 27.089 0 Td (The Judge's omission was arbitrary and capricious)Tj -27.089 -1.125 Td (and)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (affected her ability to properly evaluate the significance of Applicant'\ s relatives' citizenship and residency in)Tj T* (Taiwan and to properly evaluate the applicability)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 19.909 0 Td (of the Guideline B mitigating factors.)Tj -19.909 -2.125 Td (Department Counsel also argues that the Administrative Judge erred in ap\ plying FIMC 3 and concluding that)Tj 0 -1.375 TD (Applicant's contact with his family in Taiwan is)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 19.398 0 Td (casual and infrequent.)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 354.4023 65.25 Tm ( \(3\))Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 354.4023 64.5 cm 0 0 m 13.806 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 368.2085 60.75 Tm ( That argument also has merit. There is a)Tj -29.351 -1.125 Td (rebuttable presumption that an applicant's contacts with immediate famil\ y members, including)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 38.003 0 Td (in-laws, are not casual.)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 50 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[420.0 441.0 434.0 452.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 51 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[354.0 63.0 368.0 74.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 12 0 obj <> endobj 52 0 obj <> endobj 9 0 obj <> endobj 10 0 obj <> endobj 11 0 obj <> endobj 57 0 obj (file:///usr.osd.mil/Home/OSD/OGC/JosephLM/_MyComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archived%20-%20HTML/04-07766.a1.html) endobj 56 0 obj <> endobj 58 0 obj <> endobj 53 0 obj [15 0 R/XYZ 0 89.0 null] endobj 54 0 obj [15 0 R/XYZ 0 50.0 null] endobj 55 0 obj [16 0 R/XYZ 0 713.0 null] endobj 4 0 obj <> endobj xref 0 59 0000000000 65535 f 0000000016 00000 n 0000000141 00000 n 0000003658 00000 n 0000164698 00000 n 0000003536 00000 n 0000003591 00000 n 0000003731 00000 n 0000003758 00000 n 0000164011 00000 n 0000164129 00000 n 0000164171 00000 n 0000163821 00000 n 0000004394 00000 n 0000154071 00000 n 0000119814 00000 n 0000118384 00000 n 0000003861 00000 n 0000003907 00000 n 0000003956 00000 n 0000004147 00000 n 0000004019 00000 n 0000004051 00000 n 0000004083 00000 n 0000004115 00000 n 0000004619 00000 n 0000004644 00000 n 0000010444 00000 n 0000010493 00000 n 0000010528 00000 n 0000011158 00000 n 0000011596 00000 n 0000118058 00000 n 0000064777 00000 n 0000065044 00000 n 0000030720 00000 n 0000030993 00000 n 0000011965 00000 n 0000012246 00000 n 0000012572 00000 n 0000031467 00000 n 0000065659 00000 n 0000118573 00000 n 0000120025 00000 n 0000125361 00000 n 0000125788 00000 n 0000126064 00000 n 0000126512 00000 n 0000154296 00000 n 0000154328 00000 n 0000163171 00000 n 0000163497 00000 n 0000163906 00000 n 0000164574 00000 n 0000164615 00000 n 0000164656 00000 n 0000164379 00000 n 0000164213 00000 n 0000164521 00000 n trailer <<03409F50ACDE5D46A3F2F96569B062DA>]>> startxref 164871 %%EOF