%PDF-1.6 % 1 0 obj <> endobj 2 0 obj <>stream 2021-07-02T15:41:36-04:00 2021-07-02T15:41:34-04:00 2021-07-02T15:41:36-04:00 Adobe Acrobat 17.0 application/pdf 05-00374.a1 uuid:009fdc27-bf64-4351-b669-a393317b0b60 uuid:474e27ac-5bff-4c05-b5c7-1718657200ad Acrobat Web Capture 15.0 endstream endobj 5 0 obj <> endobj 6 0 obj <> endobj 3 0 obj <> endobj 7 0 obj <> endobj 8 0 obj <> endobj 17 0 obj <>>> endobj 18 0 obj <> endobj 19 0 obj <> endobj 21 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 22 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 23 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 24 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 20 0 obj <><><><><><>]/P 18 0 R/Pg 13 0 R/S/Article>> endobj 13 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 0/Type/Page>> endobj 25 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (05-00374.a1)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\ ved%20-%20HTML/05-00374.a1.html)Tj 50.24 0 Td ([7/2/2021 3:41:34 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 734.2497 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 579.749 0 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 733.5 cm 0 0 m -0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 578.25 0 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 732.7503 cm 0 0 m 0.75 0.75 l 0 1.499 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 733.5 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 0.75 0.75 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 618.75 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.75 l 579 -0.75 l 579.749 0 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 16.7499 618.0003 cm 0 0 m -0.75 -0.751 l 579 -0.751 l 578.25 0 l h f Q 0.604 g q 1 0 0 1 16.0002 617.2497 cm 0 0 m 0.75 0.751 l 0 1.5 l h f Q 0.933 g q 1 0 0 1 594.9999 618.0003 cm 0 0 m 0.75 -0.751 l 0.75 0.75 l h f Q /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 749.25 Tm (DATE: September 20, 2006)Tj 0 -3.25 TD (In Re:)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (--------------)Tj T* (SSN: -------------)Tj T* (Applicant for Security Clearance)Tj 0 -3.25 TD (ISCR Case No. 05-00374)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 17.628 -2.125 Td (APPEAL BOARD DECISION)Tj 2.806 -2.125 Td (APPEARANCES)Tj ET 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 261.2061 543 cm 0 0 m 89.338 0 l h S Q BT 11.25 0 0 11.25 251.0312 519 Tm (FOR GOVERNMENT)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -4.166 -2.2 Td (Julie R. Edmunds, Esq., Department Counsel)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 4.944 -2.2 Td (FOR APPLICANT)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -1.457 -2.2 Td (Joseph J. Defrancesco, Esq.)Tj 12 0 0 12 16 419.25 Tm (The Defense Office of Hearings and Appeals \(DOHA\) declined to grant Ap\ plicant a security clearance. )Tj 41.649 0 Td (On August 25,)Tj -41.649 -1.125 Td (2005, DOHA issued a statement of)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (reasons advising Applicant of the basis for that decision-security conce\ rns raised)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (under Guideline E \(Personal Conduct\) of Department of Defense Directiv\ e)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 30.212 0 Td (5220.6 \(Jan. 2, 1992, as amended\))Tj -30.212 -1.125 Td (\(Directive\). )Tj 4.886 0 Td (On January 30, 2006, after a hearing, Administrative Judge Mary E. Henry\ granted Applicant's request for a)Tj -4.886 -1.125 Td (security clearance. )Tj 7.689 0 Td (Department Counsel timely appealed pursuant to the Directive \266\266 E3\ .1.28 and E3.1.30.)Tj -7.689 -2.125 Td (Department Counsel raises the following issues on appeal: \(a\) whether \ the Administrative Judge's application of)Tj T* (Personal Conduct Mitigating Condition)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 16.055 0 Td (\(PCMC\) 5 was erroneous and contrary to the record evidence; \(b\) whet\ her the)Tj -16.055 -1.125 Td (Judge's "whole person" analysis of the case was arbitrary, capricious an\ d)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 29.376 0 Td (contrary to law; \(c\) whether the Judge failed to)Tj -29.376 -1.125 Td (adequately address Applicant's involvement in a 1999 domestic assault in\ cident; and \(d\) whether the Judge)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 43.03 0 Td (engaged in a)Tj -43.03 -1.125 Td (piecemeal analysis of the case.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (The Administrative Judge's findings were not challenged on appeal. )Tj 27.395 0 Td (Those include the following: While serving as a)Tj -27.395 -1.125 Td (noncommissioned officer in the Army in)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 16.552 0 Td (November 1998, Applicant was charged with fraternization when he, as a)Tj -16.552 -1.125 Td (student in a training program, became friends with a female classmate wh\ om he later)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 34.238 0 Td (learned was an initial trainee)Tj -34.238 -1.125 Td (soldier and of a lower rank than he. )Tj 14.412 0 Td (On a cold evening, Applicant offered to let the female student sit in hi\ s vehicle,)Tj -14.412 -1.125 Td (which was)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (not permitted under the local Army rules. )Tj 21.328 0 Td (He and the female student received nonjudicial punishment under)Tj -21.328 -1.125 Td (Article 15 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 20.468 0 Td (\(UCMJ\) and he was required to perform extra duties. )Tj 21.494 0 Td (In April 1999)Tj -41.961 -1.125 Td (Applicant's then girlfriend filed a criminal assault charge against him \ for hitting her. )Tj 33.948 0 Td (After)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (a protracted argument, he hit)Tj -33.948 -1.125 Td (her after her repeated attempts to provoke him to do so. )Tj 22.437 0 Td (Later, when Applicant told the woman he intended to end the)Tj -22.437 -1.125 Td (relationship, she filed the assault complaint. )Tj 17.829 0 Td (The military police took no action on the complaint. )Tj 21.106 0 Td (Applicant did receive a)Tj -38.935 -1.125 Td (letter of counseling as a result of the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 14.773 0 Td (incident. )Tj 3.721 0 Td (In December 2000 Applicant was an Army training instructor. )Tj 25.16 0 Td (He met a)Tj -43.654 -1.125 Td (female enlisted person who was in his battalion, but not his company or)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 28.939 0 Td (platoon. )Tj 3.5 0 Td (She was not his student. )Tj (Applicant had)Tj -32.438 -1.125 Td (one sexual encounter with this woman in a relationship that lasted three\ weeks. )Tj 31.88 0 Td (Just before their sexual)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 9.497 0 Td (encounter,)Tj -41.377 -1.125 Td (Applicant learned that the woman was a student on the post, but not at h\ is duty station. )Tj 34.966 0 Td (In February 2001, the Army)Tj -34.966 -1.125 Td (convened a Special court-martial, charging Applicant with three violatio\ ns of Article 92 \(failure to obey a lawful order\))Tj 0 -1.125 TD (of the UCMJ because of his relationship with the woman and also)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 26.606 0 Td (for giving two other female students a ride to the)Tj -26.606 -1.125 Td (movies in his privately owned vehicle in a non-emergency situation. )Tj 27.576 0 Td (The Army alleged that Applicant)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 13.468 0 Td (unlawfully)Tj -41.044 -1.125 Td (engaged in a nonprofessional relationship with the female students. )Tj 27.16 0 Td (Applicant pled not guilty to the charges. )Tj 16.33 0 Td (The Court)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 26 0 obj <> endobj 27 0 obj (ʢu._) endobj 28 0 obj <> endobj 29 0 obj <> endobj 32 0 obj <> endobj 33 0 obj <>stream H\j0 ~ CI)i 9e{V'='E},!')c 8'h;"-Z ^;6N}TB Mf->}h!ss/Pܻmׄ[ɗs;" `d endstream endobj 34 0 obj <>stream H|y\TG5o^p GԸJ4%ј]ƍQ7 APxFH"^x!^x!^(x+3q?d`&=jߧ~!!g͚;_XlBbcSZN3@Q@,jW& )[퀤1 ,]@c? b,/r0h =l`r6z[ICb51e@0JR?baHlrzЏH:"?ex|_LCG!I-*WdFƟdF/dY#iFxAn JL-tFrDE~jZ7? P='DxeFE8%:O _jթ[~`44l&i,-kdV?[ԇmڶkߡG:哿kOG_=ջ/&_O0pP!CS Qnj iL̚6={FY͝7B-_b.XlU׬֭/ܰq-[m߱s={?p=vSq.^• j5h3BRuri ^R]%I4@*k}fr?y)ϐg܀]4V>+81xp%!?*`MR(_*㕭JrN*g0̐m37<15N2fW4&6MLL]SS)>TjTjToO T 0&j:EV ufuW-VK2z'<*]xC5 jbLZvX\k";(GG{GWU\ճOUW;C4gʽĞ2k1jzk 0)Z+eN2\zߓ{ɱTy옊D `$# C`P C cF*Fba4b a< m=(摆$Ғ h>-ppQ-|ZBf* $/򦥴 ZIZEi u imMg\LʢI>Tvn%?I(iZT>*t! :؀Ta*Ԁ)P ~dt :ItNS(*2*3tyw!5Ƹt39t3y9'$)>e\VkZ YhȒee=dOًY>"_|+6ʕ||o-w.ˏ"]t*th.'3{\.lc.إ RI.3C"(MIIc1HRX-u+;3uNI:YTuYܐq[|/e.+|kWUzU^Wz:WG|Gg&:G< tS](s8zzg=yz^Ez^FNFJz^WƨA^kZN z999997-#UozDw]zޣ81's rsgrgs\b={b ~ 88P|p#ccyp|t)pS."n͹'7&< p!.Ÿ2\+p%p)5%sZSf:|G#iASq:{}ST:UNS:#yŬ)1Q@4|0`!BCh48wZ8-!! C2@*Az̾ļ"i崆l 4ȅ<ȇh *v|9ŷ7P͠9 ZCh h0~? SatfL *e `->luX6q2^&`=E!2EI"MHD.1yL)2Utɐ@fL%ԐQS%R5dJTJtʠLʢl_RRS5B*Md5ԂZR+jMm-'=u'̕yԉ:SԅԍS*Tw޾>ԇR?zHYLCh(=Gh8=ous4mSw{~Os5}<4T %H ҂ # lIh4i,3@i@/K2Uz~N+5A7̅y0BXa ,e X X k`-CJ7FdL0$y&oom1o34_í p T.fb/bX+b.>;nJ|-[s3'#8/.'qKp}x*JvOʎ ;kc7jAox >H 0=‚Y*lv O]naGX K^aO7xa{q=aOS{{ڞg9{^d/2{^?kAc>'yS\t.9ލNKu\K빾k\n7tLK#̹VFњh3MXǂƻ n6v7Ms 7r&nn۔a>G/]u{}͝ *$!R lBg)M EwDeŕ-@iXC3 U8g9ܙs#{>EPS?n1[!Aނ= bȆc0(N+n+(8\jFDL V&r5Em诔DɔBoS[zQ{@)Ҩu.ԕQ:uWB7ԏFi A#~Eh84> }Jch,؂&DʠI4P&eTFiͤlwwwwWJsMs Kh~?u:[:|48 pȱ2_lН]=$P# #AVE h!-ŴRZFiUZZGim%66W5}C;-,6I?nC{>O \:LG(Q>T@TDTB'$TJet,U9]Kצ/~L̠ t~Kt]ccTk!`&bLr̀Tuu=]_7 uѡӍu4tNӝtѺST51>mb@EYcZ[Vikڶk*tncuNuS:A֝uUwD}v=`C6GQg1{B[dm=aOS-e-gmEzA31{{'x3Ds9:#Q'wqBiQ*Q.Ί qNW5q]7/Rů̉6̅-Ȇ2X0>PLn*]ug^ VC{̐NSPbLaS'S5F)+*KMeeagLѲ eMe2A6͙OS;z~cb3ڋ3##}y&D 3P1&R55Q*D8D%TśXgI u9ɴ gD8o<'üi}FEH,3 Ҭ2֬3l2l|";Ȏ2UNaj,95HPSo 6!&42a WrՕ+{W%;4 uYZ~`4;`aSVI&tB,!BƊTڍ{fbt ] H;wa&ᰓwdѽ!gհU0!VR.5j {I0.hk`+OJ=>2Ū9n{>ўo w< աh51Q hg ,%#8Ǝ0s;K9L8 ESל#ۙ!p^c@4fl+w c*{>!GA04$Un4 G*Q6d{7DW<Gn+˿͆o93p- $=j0bO<VE 21o rZNvB0 ;Gg9r !東3 әP3Ud*Nq3eq:W86>)\lp % f\_׸K,G_V} 5+^!YOFwfY \z<#qfw{}r'A[0_+a#|/w^Z%<;M8 pVIac&lb~T3V>Ŋ1M d}1TIr<'癬v[VW__&r/z9=Ʒ!a !k4+;g\8\r W^MHIؐҁQZF`SPW2g@jl V41Jn4ڠ(s1Ͷ_}8>A;񻅦7~zWubab}¨;]6_b/oɛXX̽!O YG[6;7|X>l-=Hr4>Gw2/$SPBYdn1?ب^U k.2.z_tNR,gB=_Pzc R =M$5FpwKv=x|ϓ!F$c}plX6tЀ" t^f_?+lz'ݤiv֢Pns\Xh\(J<Md?+N&1FwٰY{x aImwc=YZ4a2M2g!Bʠk\aAzr`>rls.f<qfhGX%0I=݉iu0|##IO\ꠅd'Q|]Øp^ c '|rt+sر1ڰ O<zX:8vkY w;s{ɮWr eeCP eKU #$JR'T,H6F0^|qMc5t x$n63f,u/;LhCx(fեғt)x0:1,|]\oH)w&u!B'4gˢn̥XP$dݥQzTS@Ȩt<n)1200Aؠ#{b5rwt$;Bu";MTssou%Lp" \yt#nt/ݙ|}w/\Ҽu'۱ܷt`ѿU֜)|#,;Uʧ[9fx*뚿K%.k8?ta|V8a͵yψg;3}A~1ʟ&g\,%bzoH|5]5Y&M..HtwփKL!Fn''x{u;m@ :O׾.Y?ReV gX[ RqqhLZ3F 񪢏Z X3C38խ"aM B Xa d$SHDIQ&NKP|{ǻv|qW@ͱӽuM"v{ , zY&+Pe&¡bv{v2<@n7f?.ZK}F$L&+݆3;b>pi9I4]|mLaI(Ga:z8!)B3RW|R]T0*ؕy|-N5¡Ht9:R55AEb5Csr&Ԧ3hbAjq`iJ!xADZyڡ-j3b{k _c=rg{Zoܺ=|h M 8775]cxybGu־$GC1ȣt䊢d?}8=D5 ;e٣ b2g.:=H,x:'XڎN1^c `t2e@@r˲x7*TSDRXVYh+wB"]%Gqfӝ4}MvSuOmFn0ƌӆx"!zriV. RQ>Uqgv$`!CO1[ͻ_6V s[#f  MJW @1]nJA#5q;9]7<^۴?_m-R=Kc; NJss wKO^YKsdbSPCg!(a\Hb t5Xvl`w#mop2}v4Β,k+ǛwExCnKHf`FɌAu%I3M븥ӊw4qǀnpɎ',b3ڠ bMjE ֠pxZ h$E|3Yzbe\* WOs_Wk#: 23 4Õ(J qnQiOԓW 6=9ƾH)yiCV, D#UBڋ#R*ײ+N6ћjvVo&Uj}XYEG" }jD|ѡ7Bgll7Mi7]ZYԊrYTE*rBQdT"ԮfA*,PB0[Vwɜ[HHrd:2R d[%,FfKZiLzuW,ΈX+16=lSʆnF..9fdp.-6 a*iѐ Ʊc gz/U]^e4$+si6ZW[݌ w|'ZCڤ*TU0e~}soײpzҳ}ߪE#x.]挆kldʸh Q[ 3&90uN0='gU@16* ]D0i##MlrVɸ_H"BD' /%]xd{]GpS䀧T:u>]Ǵ k^Ehc+hXǴ1$`' 2GW/z !#^\}K l8_b%0ME : |cr/:x1x//Ybl}/z)*6+mShdA3G-Wplv k?iVDokd{ yI?gy~%ս~32Ϊ ?~[z[Qo%#1,HR BU f\2sJwj-L~"S)Tx2r{#;uD""HJ MUG#${EwhyRJgouF2-`Tz5|'F {C}n,5,_>-ނ<N2 ~bᨅ# ǃ) I^XlMV+v8ZH}b5KG"\"RCg092-D |1i *Y߹}|wk-SsƷ#8ܸh\o߻#_4ΝJ߃{0Q's~ hHkES< w oQk|k0#Mģ<CӱX`q/q^fqAa.L;$|?)ݺ`l,9(Y&k&$QH o&2J\kBkd,,pലĨ]K%@žONPmrS ?V +5^uK9~doaYfa _:+C$'E3HU_ &j8[atØA`R>oȇ{;Qy8a)ޜ.3S?I%_ ɟ/9vfM5 C0Mk &1QQ1}cpF1mx lE0VIDȟk/šHM]7 H0\9 R~ӥG4ԉAH} `nzܫۮnq}?j10Ew*B!ŠVkEX ;^mb$&դȺZ-C̈́kO&S)5L\ IH)zSK5ġVmli.cCr|AB` !W 6X(eI@i |h Qm4R-6H2M֊4uh$iE մM N ~wws>?aAUѰPI$  cb䴩ڊ誠@gBDNeP0N9C)(HXaDKQIIRIԾ@6-yYgy}mg\_Y/GO*'ض}1g.>#0/o! v>TnLi,Rke\',ˌ$b (Dt]N#2 g2Emӎ+epYd9Bm<8 $}Ʋ|DpءV|d9&pUu'vU n,-{M6;g>1 J7z(,B(N F6X!qꁃXE$ W$"j[9lcGZӛ+c-ui[T28URT׳mqgsYfx\}H鍓cai{D9jjW\?rrIϷ†"BJ-0D~yxvy?8c6, Gb ?B&@VT ǻM܁¡,4l1ڰ ;Fgv*Kge)<**:)VH \:TZLѻ!2#SyuY'K'yN{) u8:}`Zq jYv8MM& SAdB֥ GU^߷nwKͽ vg՚Sx֨+msǠ0U^ώqh^.^.u{KsEU2(b,nz/ݧB']iۂmvN jmy6*!N7<;#N]"uu%3>(|&N mi9ʪMjʨTbT2QeX^w՞+: !@ u,@ĭi@xl~ wd NjdqO_,e"!:1YYB~j@؏BĮH -wתmGw}E͈5/on*]=~bӡj_`+6 DIđp9NAR)NDQrm8Rl4~t|qAA!\SJX)q Nb\?PDѴr%J=fc.Y:K3<D(S?GT:E2P}Um1%SEJ^ )ޣnS UvsH+O4˓KRo06?ʖ{o-rt9i-N4\?[2XCO"R/֫ņ|mwa07? EO"N9^.N1!K@o~Jkd}eJ>rJ}ڰ%#C{mCd3q@٤BvY ɡ}F4ϩ}ˈ Ecw7S>;W84ƅ25laps~bⰿ; 3_y U: >I$7W5xŬ}=$3^&f^e^’An"J~<39tK%0ѹ1v[W$?KFRm yd-erj뛓{^i)_Jgo s]{m%6:.5ɔ'2Nld6{ `ZRl??C{-c(2Ie?F yG15̽?erK} zy|+dlZϬXt==k6ϼy'||89y:?^eQ56#^\:glGA`:#Fi@㩠Y*%=8Ci=[;\F+b2&1vWaE|^6x̋AY*bwtO߰4=_?^,4GS~ֻXX& 56tB<+'hoOKvx)'יa+שΣ(z^;tv">\ƃh=>)Wxjcŭ}C@ON g9ֺN )QX˨o-rt5IT tWa= jizzto'0"o7$rvTlԦma,ikL7?Fp ; .!W hD>W "(_@Fr<xRNl JZ1\ris7|踪+=9n:"if=s)>AIr;#mC?_bee qIrI2#%ڐFDS8~ ONy沚?kJn# &hHsO-yT\!VX=dPUC Lb }9d\,rZ[[֜/#/SXA>?@$@"ŗNZy>Dzsyi4Q{hޑVJ)Kz[^2BDR,!ǝRԽ{e)]282l/3#3dD2:<;VclCf~}MZRu;j~nCtf w񞔀2 <'{;~?ZۓV{z&LbsIĭNq|N̞3cnoS 5\gLt?8!EA ej\|moW.PȨ^!<@vB[sjVepq>}BY-n) C9o&Frv2wLɡo{HQ*bgfa"Wr5[mZb#9CQQr3KnΖc K[Wʶs1*8~]1/qzUF?Kdb#p@<+ <^.& قlIIƖaqā]z6yߡG g2=BZ%)DG@q-#k͜a/z_T4L6>Pjz&e-+Xf9n3G~:/#@mٶ]عASM]uNW`Zٞ39 bI USr9NQw@lAL&' Gqw&$~mwG2.}xwNvQG, {n;wĨxi}޻ڟ3YNS}U1iĕ]3#)Jo#w{|kEG(Ͻ,]#+ {D2jm}3}ш |=;q[==&Gdmwg=ǸKL/ Ooa4XJS@7ʜ|L P[97j۟Ѻ$1WSWs loцӂ3/MV7k=$]Owvhm5z6IW7jү nYFmSw6E7cu;6=РB d'R՛ֵ}&sC7'ݰ|e+/?!6rQr.04((f!& Vŝ S9 \څ5 rpy 煱q'|~urݜɰ^k-Ә܍=No~ʊ%k/kk-EeI7u1!\挶qĞek=Y1uy:':݆!+a!5hؒ~ _ر_z~psU/x7tf-,ˬZVx7' HǪۅ ߎ&wz#8ezt#8K|"Σ?T/ n9 TM:6vv'A c ~.r~H!bƭ<],0 Ǡuv9Ӎ߫Z&~J5VxYVoiUϗY޴Z^uS~c~3eZ.,3Ll z "*2K[[П{/~àh="{e<#*gX!Ɲ1 =A|;+)}Y-I髬wtN;/VE&=3K7eشAI-AzBȰ*t*4LO8sFcޯrД_8a7{|Rg=+\ )RF0C$2'z({?(+o7gқt߬$Ku{rJsx9wR"O񽦑ּ[іZY)PԆ?TIop~njEw7KbxG1N:+N1+D(]R=H@R'߽fŶRwTKAUխIw5ƩNtU[ 4qv%"go4E&t ~ O+)R bG7dҟp5/Q&o|^duO-<ꄱE8ę0Cażv3Ljo`HJgr}[J3Sږ4PRw˝;*bLyvKF%QZ󾘘1_Gzf^ w ys #K-O}{MܕFWvзxJz8`z=9SGq7*ϢwɽeԒ %| 5Kn_ ҵ7 V]MJ;Eۥ*K sV&h ~Ks^2z3R̓~s?g!Z9A cޟIuvJgw3ʔ)c΁M:GGˠ+ITݑ2(;5sۚDZ#딢6I- rzXg*$]ʾœ^wy6CD]sߒ.Ƈ'Oc|JKԏdԏ롾OE2  '/WvאvB304E=3!skb{@DP_Lu࣎Kcw.S2|g>e=ΟU%ML=ͧYC[QƦ{Oՠ_]3:L2!6ػc܃8gw y` %!BnxrI@yHI(D^&<,TF;BUQigD:P v(TF :mA~Ϲ{̭m?N2={s24LlN"@E9qK"Yɹsԍڴyz&s2 7]0 !dG_RBydJH),b9zxw%F.cv"yd*mH-\b "H)&$de rڠl#"uE6F\$垠VF{vz1kVwOc[4aDj4FR/pO2t l}OH¯W33Wwg&iٚro igGkY@>rNw ` ٙ>c(s?W?v$7SU9H֘XNN:?,M%1*+΢=fd2u)QXa7H&<.3AsIΤW Ź÷ aRw~E- lgg+{I{t Q5l:DҀ]ǡ^R(%+mwVY5(O:x jwO[a~O+x΂M:뗰>{f5񄵘׫C\C g/ n;|Bt_s bujM#ܿ؍򾱀'cXE1 uX1B;m1 ND`8~#V#BߊeSOa U<7n Y=dD7ɟ :7os_Sb5p b&㈤Ӣj@b&0ub=X)BMG[\% x| a5^P M%}|Z̺36ls?"=ξQc }٭"ׇB<`Bo 9BYD1L_3tJl%>)JyAF{LlrO:B_TsU:9gr^ j"sx"nͅ-xRNIv鯏F*I}H2㳶we[jeg~S.1d}Tr&`U{0OY|KhIu sg:xw٧뻈Snw qr)d A sB\u<7Qܩ iv&y~Ҭ\}Sz~#^Ʈ7YK_3[̥/ø *sGp]_i=ڨ>>K?IQ0nE-yhambX.Hg~>8Z!U"\wC\4/[x}!kB w% 㪱w#`xpW8"WUheN3c{:s9e1cNGEOf6W75g.kM1IXDd>Eg='G$Ulc~ݍ1]j/,Gr8!Ct> m}Cʫ@eD`=\K@!wctF{VFh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fi{ύ!= ^J>.Dd 6iSapc_lHFnЗiKh j;m}!cHDMSIӦPmڴαvRM&-la [_BQWi\kD_6DcP[P)WEhISK^AiEvA^Ut}OEs#>"+Td]TdYT]SȨ N0uC(L4edA㰧G'V”ƇlR3Mx_MJ:|դK },O#pĵ3E YPҁZ7∐/G8 6XB=9dϭgT΂SXָXcU:2V_"%Irrq 5侌1ߔ&M tRR^/<,b~ه'Ib}U3) M=* wBNA_qYIYb\;(7yl+cMNgM~e\|2ee:y8C cy>dE39̚s6>mMMu! +;{ux:;㙄5SɼKyqFKO4dJ^^``*oCs`2˔e ~\ avjjn7炡[k[k@%AQ虲y򮾲xŹ'9M`pJ&IM+ p_hAoEa'{aRxYIZ5RMu4Ʀ~ A󴬔9:%۞0䂽{15zt{G\!"9ZjF#ZT4ʻNcm yEX?vdc;&#SPi,**oE"vө7|_'F3C_wv rߪx,8]F4ݡV pQ盎g ,~^v׮/k45tɳӓi6n:gowQX`b^Nݻ2NwQ ײ99Q뒆+-GeY_gnQuzc1f>?>r5(|}={AZ1hp4kb X>]eٻTCroIfbb1 TJ{# ` :@("p|IfȎ fY@ˎ# 0a I@"bth lU:"0 ΪucqHZG)PA)V BCu+_n7B )HH;.YrGnunsѮ ]=w"#KRUhX-)>h>h+ll)Y{ﱥՎÊ++]J2hbvi:b ڈ')zXD=z==f]ۮ ׶kĕu]%׌˥WuUV\F.:: T-I'WAoK$ЬCQ)";+'VЀЁV<–-z7g>?W6m}:_uEV*Wd+ع"s .$.Ke-Ke l#Y)@Rj I][5D@{KjPԫ^ ɜva/^P&jc(̜q"s|,:T!&]qC78F؉bl ~DRTP? pDD1J6 KU~(WAmiUA+ -#_}fy}ߙ#ʫ6'R;'z"ηv-*S# ۫F甦ƵFGa_5::v 9٣}4HK jZs.fׅ@Hb8Cה}^*e ?WϾE:0UPv]K;O$ ={kZ;!_H믤i}8I+Snbޖ%71&2)x9eQ6o[Άde>0Fk&m$;U6$[iu4$,4aҏ|$Vk| m%\"N=}-31Y`(^/Dġ0-PIOaI/ ^iHx9)Sy +MpTwnp&s].=HzRFKLE.•GK:i[>+V+?jL>a ql ֌y$R﷮.vMG.dW`'˭X<#T+W}ۯ0cg߈sxo7jZN[kZӘF46KY?MVI[MLZY017Ċ80> endobj 31 0 obj <>stream H\j@ໞb!t' Ia4v$d)U l`o}N.9!Nvm;se5m=}<->ܯSSiuc8=]~ Gnr Z&ҠoD˞MzN?~߇~IL7:Tur+ҵb .;j^,Os133 yc!2"1'X鹯Ǿ~ɼD=GfAYpz:=N_37̛AhAhAhAhAh PСCA ;ta@s9h0́g!oN(++++++++;QtKE'N(;Qt(_W endstream endobj 35 0 obj <>stream H|y\TG5o^p "fF% jtͮF4Q +Q0x!":xx3:IfG]S]U^}?2 ![歂R.,6!bcR7W"iFCsy\d]m@4LCƒKcDkVK!R7i.MBT&7?4|W~إKoԻ A}Wpz_@ŠtT*=h2F٨+@y8q!lcq񡩏iiiiYcfhn`VMo;c! Uz~jZOmԷ5IP3Չj:S-TWm\=P/""ڇ K,=<(d`)lV?&;m98\ձOj>yTLs;]/K|ShL^)TFKST,UJϴQrK9Z'Sr(}T)Pnp#8# RO1**JRS.+FicS_S)ڂS}sKNq9S+N9jÂW~g --k-V08 NN}D@>V1 Q0qpGp3p'P}Li 1 AHF)T 0|4 H(|1QtzR.! I%T\Gij$&*Ԉ Lw\uRH&2:H0tS*j tNl5t'⩜8 ɳx6+.\ |1>'R[:.ѐ̲N'|ȗ6U|O| ɷgw.9:O"]"OW[篫 ~:{y{6ﲍ]:"eYI13$!ҔA4AP `8. uQRl3_>?<qp82F8DZ8Gr7B.fܜ[pK|or+nmp."\Kp).W*WRs\2q 5e ~4$;sιw8NST;5NSPS*"DP3jN-%ԆR;zSz:\G3=E]iJݨ;bI%|Q/+_L}/g? 44s4}\77Ms6~w_4w]s7CSa*MR -H2 +Ȧ4Fz8O? 4& "D/+|^ z~I_z~Ko\a,ERX`9 >հ:? yoMZ 3L2/ nVv!ۘ?>O5 \ Ϳ\Lb-bX*V5,Sb8h51sҜ;8!NⒸ*~D w܇*dȟ𧼓kq?zsjcBDm2_N"e,e_9@5(. E|]!yr"ߖb>6CΊ9O.,fgjQ(r*w]rB~)<,f<%RY&Zk,eJ(XY@5T JR*]eL\"\TkVuPUUuWUOUzުgT5@ TԳj05\P#ըQy7?,ƨjzYŸ{'=|%y^y^k:yO{=^^?o7yW309fYdfYo6Mfjv]fhnw=s@ `\01L0/,vaKt5v{aϰ$}A{GQ{=e{֞[j/K-WU4~w.8Es݈ĺDQW..Ƶn6pCԘZ:UGhczi`ol}Zmd smll6m Nu`tz-{>=d#=f"[lK {Ҟ̞gl=k+llt&AS8Exz3Es9q:ǜNS씈(gEU✨5V|+ŏ⊸*~?k⺸!n2'0`!e+"[3Row@ƼT!Y*Ue+U:L5QM2RFhL5Kf|dYdYʤɒ12RxV&D$_#qOW01lL&FKX8xyWv эD8MjkbTUI&īD$DfuUĜbD0mbT/o7ctTYir*kV53fYo6fl|({d"T=&rp,ȩ (6-MieBLkjژ0n"r[>5B}c+!|G5Q_ }`;t kP ;! A@/BI:\HH 1TX@km:Yb CDU%+6H`!`%X8>am`4YxBMXiY⎃Μc*_R0ڊAXބw@=&h(w&aCLnw7D(~#R`$,ͼIzg/{KLn8ĕG"%AZA_6L p,M%Ϲܛ 0nd\i陪 je^G?f]}VCݝuR`:l]=?WSsDߞ_^pRޥ8Ⱥ؊g |q :,DLw7B頔Z0R(Fq< cYdmqϸٞ'c]o( xC)3;_!I2ߑnr.\yFL{W)GF>պ^ /Xh9~4MdMY0r<"(/;ž[YyKDkV$W]EK+r9+^d ̒sYdqU+o__zO?~:e^nC? .byX8 *^@C9by׺boLa4Vk(`8sq>~ $wm/ui3 ?UqcX|99|Iw- {&LR%ZFRsQτ4j%Z"R&mZ*-ه]U䙻y3f7qKx _&FQ n?oJ8@rYըZWC;{B-#xDt?|.~( o M.5w#<1~ vQ jC'^Yn*:e@y}^Iϔl;[\%%[?-U~+ hRB1;_Gvv ŴvKzϥk!~ |Lu9 ܿ=Grz>T 7v׸6.On4ȾMq*1rm%-g5bbf~w(g}RV3/q` [ݙ(h,[| |Z[It [gӆg'( S !IOJ:U? ^}L2u2&la 8}vr"UuZ[څ7XCN:F!|#j8tqz 2ΛFxޣpooҀ{V;L't/ i߮EUo_=z o7U0? WQwnpG_S)cN }skT=RB]S,{2@{;w`whQ(UiL2]t. V re8#3} bU= s[q}bMlA 9E;PwBFԋ(q} ߣ,\kPdQcǑ|GD9Yh~\^:27EFy.!J#6]Ctu_:G>0C{3пkgG u[իY5wWG#˗-]R^l, |`ys}Ǭ3>MU8hHٺZe46VKHTj*mMg߿q' i}uTO`9bLa׿B?=Yߠ fI:$LY0QDw&z̲:uxy2T4 BJ!) Rb&U,mt 2B oK> wCz6zˎ=PҖ\cN6'> b;djPqgHm1'SCkYCpvRXxGԦc-~2;uz{t1è7=6.xh2>^ʤFHlVj٦X ?;Si1N]QD,mI97A)퐔06?"dsT* ف`eܛ7M-tmjk pB 6PNS")#9`7 0 =T; 3K,sa=90=%vckB㠜{S$bpxx%*8Sh)8+IzʱttzpS1=q9pPF,lŪ8NOp),:kÖ 1BًE1* 8g v%gG:ͱ~'z+4sL'{X.)]`Kʼn2Uܝc&ps< ES*pEy\&Ͻt!% ݌:D$j3etm`,l9ƃcLpJ\mDX/;4OਗEK1<"xJ X9˷FyHCBT!ǒ\yMb~ϛ N@l#vO `J͐{H%-2]%IMy7ʿ (2ii0n@fW0daB8NcZUXILڱ4Ln[ ca-& UZoҜO3|ӆ՗5y y͂LAA1 b8fL_%|Ud`H0OF!z#g jm:{'v/q8vbd%%Ҍ[ A*jhEiJJ`VUuuĦlijCEg i\;˃.BD%8@T3&'-A&C!jR›v&_)F/\AZUh 0^9#R.{G9KsK*kHǃ.jg@!x&ϩ3K'@ze@y†zlnQ,="~Qww*`s)B\)Ej7_Z#*x&"N')Ҩs#w } x!V4rIƙզ/fQ|47TyVCU-UK9`R2A~uPVM(R}}OGuٯǂbVp~vr,C۲ =V:)oMQw[8^*+KCo7ͫ2hLiTSY{*.Vh >8|"JtVvtk?0uscntq~ךs^s+~ήWĂUъX4}Sl=믵ԗYƯg?ߛ-M$?[o}5`CmC y5ޤFh^;Uc.tzFY tPy1|XmZyQqzǐ3*x>Yɤj%@xL<QgqBV:7gA38@#m1?h|-@q BML)B(+=\& <ėGNک'W<^*n( Nme_߸ CgʢBTkV)Q"%+9 !,+X@H~>äA JAY݄ԉd(|DWvj [pDZ}O,m[ QbV|G+1Uv.MOTHRK,h"봪^nS{Gdmqݮ gf@]K LXZgxu\ ;@68?*w@PVnM.=\|wQ^ xMszs,5x#NаN%n?}$r LP w#xyuѠij&Y]˂`]On|~]@ZXRʂNr&A ʛ,b"^8T|@n-FrS4tCj͊%K!tM>*M0 SuV l*m~tw(O⟓Ty=gQ_r4fp t"Z?ghsށ̭! X Ky̏r5z'E&r;<VaڎhxA9La 8C!L1b-R6ڰt>2rӃm:B߃%`,&{rk -a>zގ Nחjw?wwy-n«E1.]+Swq,a @ݬw5\+qc>JՔJ7iJMd "}"Jn(&jghh\S9c<'EH LM0y+#C ~^+?#шZ"T,$ɁE4CIba㧳 ZEU%PVVvW'6!L,<GNr; %ٰ!Xsr{Ӧ7G?/-3}<2?OYel5bzfe*BiR=ќ&T]/_EBBiTL *3tbfe7300c Rihr)|[GH>| T/K2?wa2EO@:AL 鮋.R↵}v_NSe4dǢI#nW]^[ Wb-1 \iH Xr %krlތjnD#.)E^GX2#FXb()KuƧrwX0nl487Nߺ`XÒݩ/M{sneW{1~=GZo_ѹcϟ]Y&K,?unpσIM?(qKt; j<"cJc&!z/ PӥtN8N`+G6VQt0@K:_^Xdftʬvp:b(.?9tQM\"Ou:k&80[@/؎CenIIbet^T$s@^tjUϏ ܉b`c{1dԂ4dWQ6k89k.9H$ڠ`wt0tPApW#b:U j2,VU5]:nR䦦Q T>,Mi) l wgL&i 4GtQLdh-،F&8h\`₽p^6!v`=4X# ;$@)tCQ=꣢zh:2QeF%r.U]w)] ̴-lEX,:J:W&N$#99q>ظWz:VW6r_ۦ,__Ѱ5$տѾgOYLbe] ̽Å"KG%.5Kip\k$+`J% _>4ah՗W7& Dxm,mbcgM(Fftq&Ͱ{S61N涑bdl&w8=3f{B1a2BP99f)G .xv+>^]}R~y]txz*Ly~q~hdK(eMRT~w(?={+4l _\\~,yD|b-y|!)d3ie:XQ#⛩,i?";1}#j`{wgߝcu>ǎ/m%t@aFBRD j+VRcIZ!h;Mb֍2(M!դE۠2{wF7ef1Hc^9x~F JɌ}bs J̙0Qċz1[Y?,Yt#AA+Z0\V $B4(KVĽ")S#ΤNh7&f2dFq+aS4tp%Li_Ƒ&陾dpzK'Vffszp9.,S,HF58 !)_~G6Ͽ:vylڬm\Rh*>!^Zo݁\*ok榍5y%_n^oBOQ g齣n]1>r%FLۘ-&fۀsS3N %Y) Ǽ&RV(@NU cՈ56|GAqx#&č?<& QO LhJ=ĵ;k- aſ& SW3i)hSuu͸Ӥ(#Xy%W C*dT4EXA*[+4B+U4m]Ful7} Baӌ)3G Vx? )?zosmzO^9C];ZPϟ3'/\ჿ۴E6 q`I=ݠLJe u>HP7jMܚa8ښF#imÕ[rؗ4f:~+lUp*dk)Ч?u__ciNqJz͸-޽Tdic]lImaySQ:!:;`H& @z !TuD4h4,uMdLrL `@KAy?]OL|zfmYIlEfCas~/IoFanT)2]k2ф\h,ecYԗGz~;6x37EnwqKNRy-˯7jо]~p@>ɝ?)]/.󷹏?rQ@P"(yܛe@ ".a۫į4]!0\׬ ϑnaX&P4CCkBȎPw4{fN__GGϏ:wS C$2õAxiorдl A~u 2 \Ʉf-B(Ѣd-(.=,6)'Qgg]3´. p88cF#õ=~gO^n~69sc (75$ss+RzS(Tl9t%KD=qw6{8:/.-#N,SZ_K?uQ9PfE]})zEKZXEz=tOvy^~2!%üS)҅轨B!nPR EHbfJ%ӑxzqQ8cȔ ziå265OWͅ/@ N*j@5&)EMIN3e8.e+ɷЛS4pM #A#5o{eH%D͍Q$jcۨ ݤQ%I%cRBYSZJ09GTdBc>cQ)T;ˑIV鿏= ]}=ncetm̦mT0PB?g57X07Hl/Z /Xirٹ+*Y-Pyw{_ΩotnMbC,YR-G5I(M]5-D ʨX%6*TF7i::I61*X49LU|]>_N'e|2羵]ef`ͯyx;6"~&sz 71[,8##)i!1kf4Wsɺ-8]ZM0X'Yʮ:ŚNzc"l^]Ueφ+ BhXyӋoɋ2"OP [pq_spt4̥wFGV^5GEJ_朼N:'۲f=ʒ΅n\01#I+{r(\0굫T7F!6,I΢I[~(]_sۧ|͵jos fIgj>RjÉɣ9{nyc\!wK6B?]B1[}oEvqo\k{1lt(\C*gچaeB-RTE  un&(ԉCũ3hV|3:8=3xm)෠F ciq#DgBf.=qfQyL!5:>d6SMߣ1 vvT;/\JՓ)P[w "+TAϦakjGob;ߓ.JozZzCDO׺Jj# 7#Fw= pE(,I[|:_Ebccb˳̳߳͛{{v۰u{nkƼtVQd>U.d*sn.bTu3 N@ѓLZL4ᐑJ%qc@H ӄBSi4q zy7创M9bQʑ(݌RD>f3ЁGf9 |9y^.#2v9VkRIf!!G Y'G2L%/PZ,-('9^_Pl/GGuJ-]reg -g ɠˮqM_ jKwQxZ IAh_4A9 u~eYR4bw DXXȑow;`{.> Tɾ.GD8i>N@^U~L Ըtu528YLz {^ $d!JNҠ$$$y,$E}rE=ȃM < ?]& I>ŸɋN5S,Q"zyӞe\:,b(cKqY0Y^E^=M%T=loi`eaD6h" ,NeXMp䛋28%MCfp~/=L[-@]k#?ڽn }*:Rm/l>< zۥ7څ}I&E+]?ٗ>l ^XR'OɫgܝIQ/KHX@rn@eF5Un5zٿ1Q82p1NXmp耷d\'E)d$NOߺE'~I6/@#={4o)rDՊSܥjXޠȲCLfUM;UނH]HD 5tUCq kw)Ӫ8^=z.Գ늸xh?(T82J j$׺=--4hd j /&3{qv|{/ľ $^'BX' MGfD@kBMQi16Cl m_sYTӘuD*`Jۭd:YBj}϶}?Y:3Rf-g "W.JAqc` ÝDE Y_ΥW^ Bzޓ(Z )I67 ~kUw wP?MJWzo?+CQQUήG-Z,n>MuPdSȲqT-ۈj ̈ըFh v`8.N¼8 >( ;)(6{X,,]̹<0 wYִ%kz be֒7 ѱNh" C ZN/~Zhswo?,+$DP*vpG B O%*$&PXuJ@ЀovDoq,:잔NgEz?#UPy3πIp  7 4H @!)Np3TUvvw;*9z=\F:? ݔp=fHv < ^< cw-'l7׀d$&a1d&6?DT=7 I~ǒe;13e3xLo'XLZ.`˒F^J]w jd~z. PU0˻2?5|ww*XM"G&{./7Jqf< )Uئv!p>4Li`]>i+S3+4ʲW+TCH嶖' 3 -S4u=Qκ}``'J`\eJg9H; 9+' ]MNOC 54Ld OlM,Ghk|GaN0=ShgVtq`4S]mJ["j^>?~|cﷶe[ưך͙zίEOstJbܔxG>qŸsC#Pٞjiގ6ho=o鞍58CކCoC.pD`fLju5"Av[չtn)L rAn5T\n*Le# i ,+Ѭ`\U|tUPWϞ9VnR p?c(Q )N=įg? wGESocxKAG6w`!J>%.4]zwٔ {~c7Oa"y JdgŠ~ _33H.U}s?Է:E|\WLx̬6N-EQӮʼnF5 G#X'vC^k: "$S"Nu:n1mI73p<\>ˍw+OlA3G-J|m-^"-Rda:*AaaEzN'ZT6V A#hUi!W'GRf3",;&ee5oA>O&fѱ*3 9+c8~~ڹvy׾8Ȁ"Q<]&q-0J2teA0Q+P6:iTM-XRg$Is~sF$abPEA_ע>q}K*~[pF|- 4A##<=~* vaNМ%8V =Nnz+ę㵪Cb n筐xmR!3 :ԉ<2[dFX4ǭfsfd6u;DDXVfB\wb=FJ_Nq]f/g?B>Z6 " ψG㰅=aɖ@;d,rY#NB\rFOuB sȌog^Z)hbEn| <pj$'ٖ/&hrgP,]bmId#) MO 6iU4* !PmNzg)cx LTckƟO>GN]G66dxb=R; 4;tR:JY}gT_-su z"VV❉8>- Iyu8_}~Xm?ać2aC?ѥ(XQxw*&$"a׭+ZUB:T7u|H_9= L⁉90zڙ_C#gr11.sSb-)u6Eg<tYMɞh"l@ ]Pw/P2ԔNC$$D@E.fPMI'$3~ɝ?tX6V3͵MV I]4j[Y*pX,{8 D|z2_UvvӘi#WKs-DRBFLJo:=;+ʕ ׭(=6}ʙE0m ?|,9D csi ϩ70>\\Lgl"j|ޑ۠>mN,;(9MHa5(aQU`pa q|*Oiju<:y$hO2v$0uKtSBaClP-rX4:Hf݌Ekγ@3g8B~6i YgԔ@@ճ5^05a@#TrH(1,&Mi$ؔt!;1(OM"qʎ)UN Lkhpm^T[Qb3+ \wx <E6ʡ:wݴ}2j+~ƟqDYW^48-r(izz<$ZZZZh3Qra2jov ^Ӗ1ۘ}cL7Vm%_C( &"X 9o. KlRU 4X*KRi/KyvbIXb ut&su޲W=Ⱦ^N,vv+ x0 h[^e? ~=JZvj׬)!ff[H"I9%2P D&A Y%'ᄐsNsM !xHK-}RUsdU` xfVFL#^@4lfSNs$i)9i^Vs|K"fI (,|lX bMkqw=děM{462礏HՈ3l}SXjkj@ b9*5RT{y+?MDN9Q[Y?,V94@ѱiri `643}XX.SPhn.vo~>>3}߼xK+-|fb'׿E7<o],}voH}ߕ,ͦx: > LpW'|_7]M\w޻]q.>>9>-d tA "" F Y CT,`mP TZ;inB04ʤfSH]դ!1)ʊ}3?vݻ{bVcq0yBLb\j`VFw%ʹWrF>Q#"#\=fpeAAx}BϪ`'FyE!Q+ilW.孻(4* ꇤ|G"(nQ(2@O$Iz8C ;I9>|w)r[^HߏubKW)>7ѳyg"Ї~tv6 =MX0\LJ+g%ԊĊPb(u&%dR_z?y@Zq,xO@?jDb+"@Kd.- TI],`E["gn[ @4'O&W?]S-6O[6gGMxޤ7v؏jG#䞿3~# F0NP+H; PR7U"E2c[3sږT29${ccҲE=Fg0.s!X8.N4 "MaZ*@.F ݼkC x}qkSG?:IY`to/nk-Խ1ھ/_[^maVL}9ƯH? K Ia68YòU jUm|;vJ|^Izm,h>_V`7"5҆u?R)^ʍKg%>g^9PI|9TƯ?.[xhs^ Th] c6|n(x"Z5#- [o>'C_w o%끹~*ÞrK\1})vS;,DצVfFd/o8 gP9Lh [ sr[sf Md$唆J*ՉXlR8,J7 j  t>c5ޒ$T7yC=nSP8^F:.Qm^ȝR4= ^Q?8n!8@7SsN9&g3Ћ[}Gt>&='C{dB?*G X]ǻcOslޝN6 6>Q+<}c՟:fAGAUDje+G)) UR`K5B fud; i"(K=m~!MI uBu;H2/e|D?J6?Oup'Jl+@vҟw/}'VR/oM* V9!L>đ/z3ۇ:eġƊEy7߳;Ң"Lpni+0ꭻbAc6"1ca( M 7S`XY( ?)> Hݟ/m3{w3' UH\%n}(xEEbmixK!HM*D$ tl,V鵋+KR_F EH:VDrL9)`o^Gyya "' XJrzNe6^eN'K|P*'G<#9pǻDO0:4]'+ XNt{Dn mU<)b/+^*UeyTVrY!C%x TX6NO܌\ޤol^?cPTE]q+`j9+ٯmܷCI)(J"o)\E;n"+3VԪY,ε[f!K%xp;hv#_vW6Q& hT@ೃ/5ˣ|`8űϾ;Ήp84)aYiBsڊNS*FC0*UcTtӊ4Ґ@6]PHl:6 52y4Xs({~wb5 *H;98sjS.Bd{2LU4`B*SA?mldt0Uk2B1'ӑ6\:3:tMܖZ8u :)z*%ӪKjlqlRuҎ/ lTϴNA *mUe:Li4 YYM9S N3NxuBVVEßQgx6JzN9;(-Qz3c>sHcZDϤ;;ԧU+ciq<00CLk7vw>O0D<5u^g[U[}#mȚCkk]kM# #>8/;s5|f.`ʽE |;ގ*WPI?NP!!P.rH>b =(dk.ܰHa!%܂[<2̍|""a8ܝ!ߡdHQqE Dzϛ'#6ts¬xˀʵo{/rob:F_V֐jWjgxDkEumu&]\,r.ݒKt?w~Rq@h,+J=̧Oipט,&L6j3fpk䰎"BDD$th}? DIGGg3c(t_$O_/ :x0Wu|?qA =ymm̝ Ntuo忭]w7S!n @Zig)&$вL%@3ݒ-XJihΊ@^A=HފH Iعe*DEƦ47\3o7  @Ly\@܏GX>a+IdM|9;ŗ5;[mv9[jep%A-5a1R-j}MZ')d]%e|Z\a{קd;ؤlP(),ʣq4P - 0=!fkV%#ALE [{>+sr!Xҳr@Ģw5 C"{"k~a⧳wY!BEg$59_W &6I%-VQ\w%b%mN53&ldΡObhPpbR2miD }u|+d~ٚ\ȱ哇|#6>^ݒH%{'OmGR" KTAR :*rDfDdCg*D&Ff aGb[T (9d ",LW] <%*e=/B̲d>H>D n#kG+n83L57kaAH5SN\ڥy&L (R:ߟNznNSs󇹉ԙT)%fS)ƀ=;GEqT91)ZDĆ ns|33[F9)Q__ Rmԣ>\2@5#I $[IL7&3kh}ҰUoN| q,s<8LR"xC sŸ$E-@6Ixp ~dR|N*<9(ڂh{ۊcmfs3{'.}o `7dmi&fԎGwN|fӆ{.-8F{~+|g~Ꟊ Sȏ"Cʯwhi7HUѦb*ВE0J L:Y=$Ȉg2[̆DnnC::WϓZe↸PQ_.#/=:cM<!5DhS"<"'{X(F"6AdQ'n!1FS97t(to< ųDbb qXd(Q"sOD"~ mp&/Ә0MAEU.W@NtNi xƨ|CUB4=}|5qn-,4A1 \¹d_== |_X.4A!)A+8*K.Unv:!sVS-MX$`Ri RS!c^8t&r/%}sO据Hxv6DQI(XVВ_G"^#识[TH (,yт5_RXj//KuizXHX e's(j4 `ED Ȱ(&vL(& >WW1ak!1}~|΄ړyv[-Eb!tAfT r57B[kA:(G4҇%$Z A`о(Y,V$)G](Ç3btp̼phSⲸ&/2\ύ՝yp\ n>]+mTra 68QܱP0QPA/z"5aezy".ffin-MMv]j5dӠv%\N@.z@۱F<[Z4hW&IBhx}fs"wϾ{/fo:_CO?@/w3e*uk|Gq8cTOOSl殺9T<*ϙ̧=e_qz^]{Sؕ\l_ɩ%?Ud.6٬p8-qmXkqQ{S1Z 4πF,oTFm!5LQa/֒R\i؉5I!2|]E5ðJB f|*;rho"a|I\Rh25ZL1)/ R*[hcfF~&rh_I=ChB1#ٔTl93D<.ݯT N4rl_=7ԀՖ)s?ڍvKxS\j?7dt F}Z rBaH*J*`5 J՛* TdQ XH7d*\O"]lE樶#ݑ`؝ѡh}J `T S5 P0'[S0ܿQ R6gнaz}ovyzA,[ǏDVH@1 J MJJ BT Y*88xTQ;B=";Ngn esǐ9o @`ZFp߻ w UIAAWġb,aCTd[H5l*YCMzUBQ$Ca'DAw @(*5,07Z愉io/1'{-!zK+׷J+zݲH$<~-X/)4^b|'RY%fUx{$A*/ג|gSJhb* o^*Py5+kL~>o_ίE)l2({A ys2l)mA.s=xχ8d idw=iv6l .+A!^^i j$ Mm*@VUY H,T(݈<@˹wm{H:J5Ǜ)Ԧ2t@~, f'$ QX. I}h{fe2WYDVRA]WnV7_\!dˏR}#|Fw,cz7CRŇ%fAt =kq "ʋ}刜 SrPp"|ȵa a-/g"CߛXmvǜޡ޴~|@yp8J+J [Ph6fgCv7 yܽNMʢ)ґ|sϵ01n&-s,QB0&g&v)EݓbIR=dg{4&`jh814܀k1K{qi/[v̲m6 Mwse(K}t<;){S 'Bq XiV|ż 쭑)W0N)[ \_#k讑54-hMmYbJi<7c6CIm-c-31\|.,҆醱I1eMGw:O|G1ڻ']Nl<>88*> w>^|. ثv$ m<$Ӡ-1PBr\{Ң@!=?SLrJb2܀CT˰7˿'1͍*6uݎ|Э]8y4j)wRjNM[=.gnDnĈk)t%nF1z|n 0_/*HYC/P ZsUڎRmǩmlZHМlmY"XkO)r2HO~H"Y?,ԝCA#PЍ*UI /S̸>CD]H=}ݢٍ <3ؠ@˖_n-J^ʯ[+%BN.q-4Vvut˟̎_,j^^KTN'N~Gn 12D1dұȿi5(~t0LGDGX!jɑTO$RFDm >$uMH᳘&Y\UՋ G>cW'yuYܸqhX\$t{XZzHв,~YuQ-#Ҟ榿-]?o kp',--.2K(lEfZkBWfWO+>K*_OIpJmDDɞDf$ D@wg"N]>;|7 O2j#NqM"2o0yGfmLuK[d9$?,YfT{T{15U.ѼAD*U*uvΪo;s+ ܤf>o1?88>^%^*г|[>!8UƟz35djwkWk|mVi4Pg0Kσ{G;In+[A-DI;T˘11Cꐎf@nKJM`RY,]Jx>K 2pbq;+KTs[!nU9 =I$zuU>:fjSf?8 @`wˀ]ŮY]֍H=Y/bD{ɻW6yjdD>(V1cPf10ɴSqH!MORz. ӛe{ư؝-KF+bV=VJT*L[T9V*D;HuaCh'_#IZǭ!_"(x+T!O8=d| nO;dN-Q̛,hbxʬ? jӈ.Jc)+o/:W(~@ kVx-)SS X2lwK˵;sk׷ {N|LLs)_ۘЛNW8gF2舥ZGvs|wvܣ|\q~Vע_{g- Q>1 ^N7z&5-ad_^_yZH$x' L&Ed-˴hNdMj`|D\Nט0-0ta7RhE2Zh #*`DTH\{H*p&q$IP#d >zT`}U`im90Ոٴ\˿'!S6_dYK.M.MF0 SGkI@ a<-}3XH#caDz,BZ3ւdX&{ذ[\bcòfD˟u=1 P^8pcvOhO5ɴ20!.A_ٝ8BQ N4JR DhH)9{_ihf?SN=й_;f{^({gGكr{7]Ą0W`c;#,KŠDӆAy ʳY>lߝ󻓸oWrok.fM֖Iay)hH앗D 4 AGǘC]ւ`QU-lLeB{;]<>_mآ6ѧG^ٱ.a\6fHFk܁{{{*){C_؜U-Fo!@_~e8qݲ>yyǩͮҾ!֛"< , $ $GJ:~,V .pq'ɴ^.H C (yl /{CiىrLFe^әCg%q㜁hi:¿=-H%t^zOb$67g/j.jK{[w Wt TGƠ!إ#I* j ;jt>E :wm~H\ފ6{6ӂR$3gZZc= ?;5ٸޑ?}퉥ӂ\U6Xj~ ~S,zgyN#h6e{uP_!q}uvA,I=ժ膣'ɅH`KLe@>s73>pRm),-G _ _$pw=0섕#:1bmwNs}0>U]\ݢި= 1{x88;H.iO&MӸ#)7 rn3 Ap"ۉe=T0뺁&) xX0.1{a"[YvQkւjQ+ T>D 8"3ٓ]f 0BMd:Wg;]GsM*GRWۗ [;OAs6u[¹21Sd c&ݼD4xh*TI#kX.Ӈ ~x\{ys|!XtEC,bPSA iiCEJZ6j5 Ԡb.^\.-$xG4n5"da1fyni_h--z^ qc՞vnp^7Ѩ т(,iQ,^ZrwfFNp'7XNT| )ssFcԟSW^X+>\z8&IfBP'gJe?xø}ΘFo H\Eiόq,y, lqG:P}4hɓ+/֨3tTA4u\G˚r&Հ'O*g"d(~7Ij7T(P/+\gH?XM!|{ &Qg¶wG?3|SUʺ &4G 1.6 ?ٹj]'oi[`߹'Kp!g ާBq/Sµכ>D4_65TԉX6BD 9sZl  (a. C֏(x2fYf]4NEbӝǓ% |y+JřLcf rg - 1gc8( ds[>A{E-(V @c.d%[j%EB)Dhmx0-a?\$Ux6l?MU5ROsAgUmDR@hd."#!|_OO%2z|ܙ/~z(!u؋y`/cvUcN.q \y=>yTߺڲjg> o:/Epmq]I!ĆH7DJd$'" ;(:G!'ȥ f] 9߮tpyv+eFG0Fd: s{%uʒA+%:"!(}\Y q]P-B=Maw4@ӽrV:+Wn6QQ?Kf$2dEeޅ'#uWt4rEGKl8&季kvр\_UU&{c/ib'u.G2V ڡR"5AeBjJ PIMЦm.M'[%hU@( 42MZ{.sy}/0ؔ[2F _ rH>z2*Fwe0fm`S\2bါp(J p,z]V]F]g|m(~֭a;h[;?o $G}=wt<=Xwgۿ}VlX ^P ZSfp5w&:i'νlT`f#Tbx=ҥA* E;U{vZtCNq{2$q'y%R0pU e؅ֵi($BLŨbn~Tbbd(Y i36M*v [ ?@͎ =y|n_ư;S4Yƻ2E%Os:+t(>p/^i$iJkAsQ3xxo|":*1d6|\颲$7G'9\:Tucq3ey1(TShI4g}ǃ'/HVzvm-8${ ^g>Zy{iβƊp͸fVn\1ޱo(g-9ģ£T'a^9fI̙^~ZxZ @a!!f=)ePF2Ѭd!.ۂ|TN„ ;86@° #e ԈQj AE)yUIPT BeYH@EPW!uc` D/Q [(ؼ~?z t8eLf2*~E}KO  5Β+X@&4i堉f ήp y:qLMWaF!)ѝsi;7shb+NϨZ6mf`J 8i hƴ\cɻ?! IdLQaqZf4p,3=E*i0+u%]Ol 1>XH R#82o"b&D%g(dج7l< yLc1bxfy68wUW&21rUǹ'7X>ȤaB>~?0zoM2FJ"0@sj1R5.W2 YD#JRmFԜvQ|L8gUo\lR/CX9H6l6:gߝc|v8؎%:?)kJ;涣uRh[۱( 2@H 1 &]j&ViSQ"ZMYqsZs{ݻ{}c]ޜ,}]' DŽjtlmVmaqA^kbͽ[W;_"t"ڬl^WV?onU`5_6jVQ~:x]wvss80v{hFdk])H. 4 [ U?fꪲQpU!4*OFRJʕJOYAf:s njOJw{d|~&1ܥ@WWx0;ڲc \/xC@r6'xRYOubc.>@zSVF4$SXIC;4躕Х33=Vc")B7.m*3BRIU*3&@ U~;q;0үH,E&#T̾ e*KE>< 2"m<7Tݺ47LE={tXBK)>xJs|殰1!#S!V@3+{brR,bC/ig0^7q;6x,t?I ^p8D:wh:QJh&utdz^-FvܽJoHKhGxリZqS4wߋe"!10!F':)թCv3?) N 'L)T]@8xw:_ PjeԹNKufrR)Ftx߾wmn>rС п>@D~Wα{;C{Edt?{{ģV:)`:d3 po' /1Ϣ?D- A@%nh{"y*^.]d@Q72HP'p/ͅЮj =Bps/ X x/Șɷ.)fc;_pB~X>7 "`=M@{'ܗ{pW<GM$cԖZH CG#3ej͌CF$C[2m E)!Mr{l7 I7{_g=5OE7r Ś5j (U!7y'֟uY_O? j_խviF+6u3Td"h,(54:>s}TvqїnP=~ޔ21^=Ӕ |oFU8y3asQR3sks|Vuw ƞA>2DSڇM}=sf{ &f fw xy ZM '|+a1^F@*m𙄱9|xm-#?SL{;Ⱦ,E~lJg=[uwHO}G E-܍4mCߝ;4[NA9iw_t^Ov&,n z&n} –emղݞ -iQg{aV%>2Ӯl͜#"FK 0)cGkW" ) ~s<$3N9͐T&o. 4Yn'aғb!5-4]}+~^$߁#*RHE"I,:?Í4Q\ gOYyIa K?${9#8Xs{ɌfznV8FͽSA qq͹N-qר%bZkg=|?\vrhl{@s 1YkLzd;蹫WV$M9b`~n.5/hMsh21΋Tcz**DZuE2%Q[?MFl*G NnfֹZKuEu>}>ƹt;#3M/bWK)]x>˯ON}NS:߰> #t Hl8h@?ӓR:lCՐ+n:PKK 84^,F>X>=/ x| 2>b/@]EoǜK|Tyy2xg>~fbIocBw#5y_e|$]S[S~Gԙ ׉6 xV li߉6ѽ›u z?w> p]:`3h? ڳ:8x`c\zCe_;0ߟ4Hm_75q Z:kJuP?sVevՙ |VjI`/k1 u#$"^y #\+نv:ELlci7=y95gi>3 _\GmaH)3ru ץ=~չmACui=SϤQZн,m!_{o~6 8prV6h!fdNIh#*-5Yh!]R]h$٦Sӟ?s]f:~\P ܜ5{b/;W.Va0؉v"ڈc^S&_\1{zwS q$Jʕj9tfSQ݈hOESqng~,a]RWJ컒;V$bes^202Gd0IyM0^\Y>L>+%OuȑKh6(\yZ 6T<\Uh 1XF|K=ym6e7'M? pUǿw@4 1(KPʀJXX :J;nTneVZe:4m(Rl VE(mGաQ|sm:f~sٗ?];(0.{fJMŞd/1eKdj&??,Q/-u*D+&)!Iዩ|Y(2bR[C"OvGqꀷѠ8-R?+蛼 (a\M? ,sEuIznQ홒 uՎ̆|lW[ 5r]!ِ?sGWeC~Y7;;?:Ά݌6kǁz~O\z:~(/ؖ%O/¥6-wK χ za#eyC@,ַEu~›` {F}>Mx۳asԟ[ǿ[km'l;qghގ6B,]i(Q`(Ѻd^ м}%d|%ުAIr3}- C>{1S~>ig6S+ d0iVwt}H75ˉ @ӿ ALa ʈ0)or7~_w$wSwwxN 2{\6iMP$CrcgƵm 칁@rj4i7c~oK c<h}SJ~-=RS#cTதbG ?!6J^lUok}gL ܌,e:V1]sc)eXG%4s>?a덙r{ ['S?g0./e3XӟҋAU 4W/W_o˗9.Ցd^G_}?ɶqTF~7}FdҤNem||҉m:lr9#u =,uq"=ktjY9h;cÃ־cȶm+ۥ~4g-[_gV}ݹ]At6ۻv%4Z9a0lձ%%u;%;LJBzb{/sj瘸>b -|(9f;!O#KUaqwmCV?\ڞxu%w<޸Ϻu_>yw7$WW:/Gf\aϙy[3psdd!HxW_hNg7 (`4uc#^zF%GRvY|%ϏL5>?܊ Hee~B=u}ViOae6 DcXwpsG@/DQNIF[E܅G0hIumwmJ04s(Bg{Ծ4Nݙ/}G&.rs^k9rs0]7Iq^8w  n(ط(6vH++^BԻηuXrb'C-6\n-߹j.>5k{e.l+V-EsŽ\NDoȞ̞(nBqGQ'/Rv9ki:ҽKZyjn0~E7ZM%ܦpOYV}}F&7=1խ|. C'm4qj|5o>H|ȑ _̶>h6;5_T[o(JPg}PSrQwPz2l7Y *T8]Hm3R[[ޚzYn bv[`lO0Qs=Jtj~\P}XoXOyq)1<޳:턗1B}vF yKmnqظO"ދ8g;e?ry/i{&7s,z2j^X76ƽ_Dߟ`cfAgdIt\k4L/CRߑz:*[ Jd:0Na\ʛ2zK7yU;ƽ^F/`6"-paO^o]o:e3S{)Ŭ5ZN< K,hƞ&yuKƺ7?]pI_D9?@?m`+F~ HFH^ EwW`ʌ/':-ZGE:1$0H<8tl]Ǔݟb" M ^Co^IXcxY]ltmtE=w k{bg@ pTݷM !Y 6 `HH$ !~ )R,PAXI3:X?hqڪԎQ،A;Ա6"hZ/F@Lڦ{9UQ6Ǿsjpq{Ԕh-sXSe\\ݬo>:?מu 6{H{O~{8'FޏsvV~>3WG:*Zs{d/+{dg&+! nVG,EId35|AO3}e<ΞL?N~C]ͮ[c+cu`8QYTffIpZV5 3>9ը4י~25z9Hyc)ߡJTU~V|^f`r D/[qxS5<N,S{]uĤ:Wɹ>{?_N>/-Vs0.U}}%S.br RqM[FNd|unr  :7﹝ahOU*/)~j1$xĭ]c':ߤFf3U7GK#yUxۮ'uԄش(&fgr𷹿R;|iⱇU2}<ԧ1[Vf Q$SAkA}]lϐ'd;)Huc+C?vUD7#ȭ ČD+i)>ɽ[ݧ{NmokS~Ywc㭴C)W˺¯k)D6_\b=j5'~U9P TF[EM_ӞkncYW6^: WK2]o jmQ/fMJi۟|+ϝM{>}l\Wčm0&+\ Rijg"?.`0xy;};~TlP>E6fʞC2<491)CxeX.bK?2w?`b/uTNB{=ۉĴ>uqMnݨieApn-t!Lݭs{d9{*\_ʭגw ȩ^'yCr{u ۮIoǥNӐڦgxkRRK;m00xEjpފ8 osC'v:?ζW"c'>ӍNt3Qph/9B=ݎ5ƪ~ -QQl*()2QL8րATŵI15Jׄ`6 EɉjJ875q1}pobjx2Ep_gۥiAִ0ޥk,cbY$f1l;Hbc\o&EqVk*Қy۔< NE %:E k|b!{_M m4wN ȑwpyȒnv2o>"2%Hj0,۞Oi'jMJ<^EK*L]CVQ:OT~?ݭJdrQW߮BRGjX@R9ˢ$ _D`9.ˑ.r7Vs9e ӰwIF 7̹_Sa[Z@ l s޷ڿt' W޷h}_W\il@pj_[3K*fl,o%\o<]}ݽE{[ _b>'icı8*rkc2*ЈjCb2{nvz/Fxt o|A<<1<6N~Կ+zL'vP)#Vg^> v+e]0N*ݔM6n`߼hw8&%zgl6"ݢأpGIT [,qkٳ?H7k{ÉOrxߙ;G5N~2!u|T8 dmvF}5s&R>u=WxFDπD%HxVIc LzW,'̼T|IβYw=BO10qʕRiR]4 Nt_ϤɌfo?!:~3-; -:/c{C5YVuTckttg``#WPiMЎMڮi1bc{IQsqܼ܇^ztl9oMT<~7- j&jHԁ?"Nt9%?EqpAph=yt^'ѧ~h uo}t8q^P( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( 4f%C:#{aLTH߃deBJ{Hc c3;.;{maD暋9WckTcTwlc`r|ؿslgz8y6Q v% c-d̨D$@1|8׃ Ȃ2"3 |aEXwf fcRvv:|vմ֚Q yB!\uCXG>' ^xEt{LϞI!*t^pø  N}< \2hXW1 jS3y4bO;QY"-aQ?HɝrO#}w!"4_p 3 ]DDAO>=ǽ՛jx{śDf(iD*H2Db1ͤyR{H%7mVW-I+.j@=0'C)Q՛j<-Kmx8)"iR{o4c;uѮX4qgE$(O'Ra ;3JY| R<#΃ѰO[[xڲeE"Vr^T4)(׈XP4?вiC{Jox.ϤB?~'QwG厨|[h}7Fs["q{<ɇOOn{/~󨝽d?7a7${=֛bS$ay٭[I R*ϋlGe%k2rծsOܛ37z汫&Uv媲*}ܚF&6[;v _pdQm,bŸP1w/AȹlB/ LA^4pQ}F~0\4Ahv>z7dH~>!ٳl7F- ;(3ˠO 8B9㧡E:KraC?_s{؀8zUfQ`TCh!Mأ,&W>?ѮT>=KhZ?΍s#Bhx&g8 #g9,]p4.g "0.Fl}:_' ҕwFs/"t"גQ+;wZe+sY}BN Ap]Vem(u湪KKd1H:ovぽKiC$8\8m'K'6~$ס0r#ύ<7nx] Dg#35"ZDZD -)CN 4ad`d`d ~ ;,0 gbN|ȗi3Z߳vB;SWh*46(..޻?8tu =7T{^].9{2o;E:!5Ȅ \ۭ Ԃ PqZBNLdLX"g8)S[͸:.󩂬";gMHK 9Sd;r jA'H<:pv!M§u9biIKj/^XP(ڳR>%>)k,6775kaWIY0Q00=TBX|!פ.ǿxxx8Zb|t[_ C_$|!'lri4:L4vLT'*) }হ3iœI* @=ww =wмɿMXEkt;~Kk=&V{DG0>A DqjucZua{Ӷg!\A۳꫶'.m֛Z"7LIYqfA?+j{DUX`RK7AR\δK!WRbM/r 5ܼA.K,go]jn8߃5'͗˞Ibeڃ9,@?Yж(|dKr5n!MHQ1M,i"bŖ2HY vp:Y}(%0=0Fu' `{Ε v9}>^YNTL]i;yKV Њ( =%}H_ޑ>L@ރMH-iLc MҐt܃u|%U[[[Nqc`G<$_$?)>w6U fIN CCЇm\.Du(GA9\`me0i=!]珦Ƞfag.qiJVIkCw>lՇmrPD|4Mΐұtc*^ 9;wd\̏`nrYg˔,sYu}5EА, PZ ɔd\ hԫlUYnku4 jk1QWLiP`-/kF%Ҍ`(@IRPPUxVv\yTy0>$(c#G?b?qpP+X y12W)'|6Er,dA1B HbVQњvEc)K)nms9k듓\3-`Yk>)Is4MsmA.{* *m#6A[;H#Ý!_f%C^Pj45J!hR w1{0پ9>dOZ̺c|<+{Tg3gD7]L9eNKUB%Jh\WPZIDVDw%$)*%JuΔe}MзpD~&3srI^ y[(0P 2`Ceău#K#=#2 eve%Mר~1 D"0 .z8­s:3yqI\٨{DCۍ(ϙdJ,cJs5_:2*1w@G? 'H}sAjæؔckjIc{k=uw67Ӱ F[U}? a t=i`QX S4 Q T {><Hף_w@h0<4 endstream endobj 16 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 3/Type/Page>> endobj 36 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (05-00374.a1)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\ ved%20-%20HTML/05-00374.a1.html)Tj 50.24 0 Td ([7/2/2021 3:41:34 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 459.75 591.75 306 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 744.75 Tm (Signed: Michael D. Hipple)Tj ET 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 16 744 cm 0 0 m 129.311 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 719.25 Tm (Michael D. Hipple)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Administrative Judge)Tj T* (Member, Appeal Board)Tj T* (Signed: James E. Moody)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 16 642 cm 0 0 m 119.994 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 617.25 Tm (James E. Moody)Tj T* (Administrative Judge)Tj T* (Member, Appeal Board)Tj T* (1. )Tj ("The individual has taken positive steps to significantly reduce or elim\ inate vulnerability to coercion, exploitation, or)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (duress" \(Directive \266 E2.A5.1.3.5\).)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (2. )Tj ("Personal conduct or concealment of information that increases an indivi\ dual's vulnerability to coercion, exploitation,)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (or duress, such as engaging in activities which, if known, may affect th\ e person's personal, professional, or community)Tj T* (standing or render the person susceptible to blackmail" \(Directive \266\ E2.A5.1.2.4\).)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 15 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 2/Type/Page>> endobj 37 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (05-00374.a1)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\ ved%20-%20HTML/05-00374.a1.html)Tj 50.24 0 Td ([7/2/2021 3:41:34 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 754.5 Tm (government's concerns)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 9.399 0 Td (under Guideline E. )Tj 7.831 0 Td (The Judge's ultimate decision is sustainable on grounds independent of h\ er)Tj ET Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 741 Tm (consideration of PCMC 5.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Department Counsel's argument regarding the Administrative Judge's "whol\ e person" analysis \(i.e., that it is not)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (supportable by the record as a whole and that)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 18.355 0 Td (it used an analysis of the evidence that is "piecemeal"\) is not persuas\ ive.)Tj -18.355 -1.125 Td (There is no presumption of error below and the appealing party has the b\ urden of)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 32.74 0 Td (demonstrating factual or legal error)Tj -32.74 -1.125 Td (below. )Tj (The Board does not review the record evidence )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 22.103 0 Td (de novo )Tj /TT0 1 Tf (and make its own findings of fact and reach its own)Tj -22.103 -1.125 Td (conclusions about a case. )Tj 10.358 0 Td (The Board does not have to decide whether it would make the same finding\ s of fact and reach)Tj -10.358 -1.125 Td (the same conclusions as the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 11.303 0 Td (Administrative Judge did in this case. )Tj 15.303 0 Td (All the Board has to do is decide whether Department)Tj -26.606 -1.125 Td (Counsel, as the appealing party, has shown that the Judge's)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 23.842 0 Td (findings of fact are not sustainable in light of the record)Tj -23.842 -1.125 Td (evidence as a whole \(Directive \266 E3.1.32.1\) or that the Judge's con\ clusions are arbitrary, capricious, or)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 41.258 0 Td (contrary to law)Tj -41.258 -1.125 Td (\(Directive \266 E3.1.32.3\).)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (The main thrust of Department Counsel's argument concerning the Administ\ rative Judge's whole person analysis is that)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (the Judge erroneously minimized the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 15.024 0 Td (severity of the disqualifying conduct in this case. )Tj 19.856 0 Td (Department Counsel argues that)Tj -34.88 -1.125 Td (the significance of the Applicant's conduct is best reflected by the fac\ t that)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 30.03 0 Td (Applicant received a Bad Conduct)Tj -30.03 -1.125 Td (Discharge. )Tj (The Judge considered Applicant's discharge for bad conduct and also othe\ r evidence in the record about)Tj T* (Applicant's military offenses such as the circumstances under which they\ took place, the fact that they did not involve)Tj T* (subordinates in his direct line of)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 13.108 0 Td (command, that no abuse of authority took place, and that witnesses who h\ ad direct)Tj -13.108 -1.125 Td (knowledge of Applicant's troubles with the Army indicated that Applicant\ 's)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 30.465 0 Td (punishment was unusually severe. )Tj 13.914 0 Td (As)Tj -44.379 -1.125 Td (pointed out by Applicant in his reply brief, there is no simple formula \ or rule of law on how an Administrative Judge)Tj T* (must weigh the evidence in a case. )Tj 14.106 0 Td (The Board will not disturb the Judge's weighing of the evidence absent a\ showing)Tj -14.106 -1.125 Td (that the weight assigned to particular)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 14.996 0 Td (evidence is not supported by the record or is arbitrary, capricious, or \ contrary to)Tj -14.996 -1.125 Td (law. )Tj (In this case, the Judge's evaluation of Applicant's conduct is supported\ by)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 31.604 0 Td (the record evidence as is her evaluation)Tj -31.604 -1.125 Td (of the evidence in mitigation. )Tj 11.997 0 Td (The Board does not have to agree with the Judge's ultimate decision to c\ onclude)Tj -11.997 -1.125 Td (Department Counsel has not shown the Judge's conclusions are arbitrary, \ capricious, or contrary to law. )Tj 41.725 0 Td (Essentially,)Tj -41.725 -1.125 Td (Department Counsel argues for an)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 13.968 0 Td (alternate interpretation of the record evidence in this case.)Tj -13.968 -2.125 Td (Department Counsel claims that the Administrative Judge engaged in piece\ meal analysis when evaluating Applicant's)Tj T* (misconduct in this case. )Tj 9.804 0 Td (After reviewing)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 6.608 0 Td (the Judge's decision along with the entire record in this case, the Boar\ d is)Tj -16.412 -1.125 Td (satisfied that the Judge properly weighed Applicant's overall pattern of\ rule)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 30.365 0 Td (violations along with such Adjudicative)Tj -30.365 -1.125 Td (Process Factors as the presence or absence of rehabilitation and other p\ ertinent behavioral changes and the recency of)Tj T* (the conduct. )Tj 5.137 0 Td (Directive \266 E2.2.1.)Tj -5.137 -2.125 Td (Department Counsel asserts on appeal that the Administrative Judge faile\ d to adequately address the 1999 criminal)Tj T* (assault complaint made by Applicant's)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 15.649 0 Td (girlfriend. )Tj 4.276 0 Td (Department Counsel asserts that the Judge briefly addressed this)Tj -19.925 -1.125 Td (incident in the Findings of Fact portion of the decision but completely \ failed to)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 31.827 0 Td (address this disqualifying conduct in the)Tj -31.827 -1.125 Td (Conclusions portion of her decision. )Tj 14.776 0 Td (An examination of the Judge's decision indicates that Department Counsel\ 's)Tj -14.776 -1.125 Td (assertion is in error. )Tj 8.192 0 Td (The Judge did mention the 1999 assault incident in her Conclusions secti\ on when listing the)Tj -8.192 -1.125 Td (misconduct that made certain disqualifying)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 17.523 0 Td (conditions under Guideline E applicable to the case. )Tj 21.077 0 Td (While it is true that the)Tj -38.6 -1.125 Td (Judge did not further elaborate on the incident in the rest of her discu\ ssion,)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 30.187 0 Td (Department Counsel has failed to establish)Tj -30.187 -1.125 Td (error. )Tj (There is a presumption that an Administrative Judge has considered all t\ he record evidence when making)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 44.818 0 Td (findings)Tj -44.818 -1.125 Td (and reaching conclusions, unless there is an indication to the contrary.\ )Tj 28.297 0 Td (That presumption has not been overcome here.)Tj /TT2 1 Tf -5.474 -2.125 Td (Order)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -22.823 -2.125 Td (The decision of the Administrative Judge granting Applicant a clearance \ is )Tj 30.185 0 Td (AFFIRMED.)Tj -30.185 -2.125 Td (Signed: Jeffrey D. Billett)Tj ET 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 16 116.25 cm 0 0 m 120.645 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 91.5 Tm (Jeffrey D. Billett)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Administrative Judge)Tj ET q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 12 0 0 12 16 40.5 Tm (Member, Appeal Board)Tj ET EMC Q endstream endobj 38 0 obj <> endobj 39 0 obj <> endobj 40 0 obj <>stream H\j0s{DRBh5/|Ne D~n=w7= (˼: PZ)~Ynǩ1̄AŻ vOjqSaunxȠA@^:M<ہ<7>7PsYb;3#2ѪA\i Wϳd9&p9H//$L"0Q#WOFTed DruFgj?bg 08 endstream endobj 41 0 obj <>stream H|XTs.%`h$K^c" ŊE#*{ŊEDņ]W1&kЧ}K͝s;g e/g$9KK7(p_1$Τpc{tP9piس߰Y۝Sm;P~Ȼ#f|{ɉ<€:&y8 G^_yV[ayxS2ePGWTaax=vPTj;4JUsJU4@mKt'NC<)ŠP,lQ0,cs -^t֕VoH߸i2عkg>sܣǎ8SϜ=w.]ٯ_(7UW`$Lu]x(dȋ$eDW)!ܧO_>>E|>*j>Z{Uжhͦ=ҞkH@d|S鱹y9<ӼbXY[*ZX4K K-KGK%g֡Һ{tP zOԧ&}[֏'K6a}jfXD=#lllRWΤ`03g(9L楜/EYS*e2US@rS 4ߧf:j!o9j 6-G;]ўj/L0EL4Ps9ɡ-0Kd _py!UOW+9\Gr Dj&Yӭ/ԕq6m Mn'QQގWRGyK iՔKKKwyH]08nhhhQQQQ?5;puY+Wz^ {3{c{{]{ ^i'C[amQ˖c˴eHmmfm3cF)ccY9/WK_]unxRR+(H񊬮s_~զ%߆o%;90jc`,ܶ_s],n{z;>in3٩3$ngT+)/kxYq,*,;%1xI$dɾ ϱkq9X@*"(QqE4N$=Sqqp>荾A?G` b1#0C@Tjn9N獼78ɻx7ὼ3 _9p6>ćQ>  y|O><_|/|*_|o-w.;~C~ď ?g/8G/TcI dcqqqq1U|">N\t! ^- oB1# ݙ3̿wi񐄠J)1!NZwܝ"8o^o\+r(7r*r)wr+sι.:!yXG1y\')A(?;Kes޹*K-O3<' $/jkZznFnfn67KT?_ P JU5T S5RR՘ڍSU W*RE jVd5EMus溅n[ֺn~_藺;jڥv=jڧ:#:e{cS&ęx'}+♸"x-ވTV >O"(M-\#M҉`)=}A(#e̔EMrPNE)|?M?Ӿ_@(C0T8~o~_7:U= B%2TQ(W'4("(hMhDizJSizz^7*UU{A}TgvX0˒3{p: 9=g3s8;0rNŹ9|4Mp+.&\ w s.EbA%8Kr)..q]e,Pw]\+r%U*W\kr-u.܀nM)7܂[rҬ܆r;n#w܅)w7p4W܋{s?~ǃxI4I&7)f<ɣx4 /+&ݧ6g;t.gsBuv8;sA u29b>,Ȋlr#(g{ȉ\ȍ<@>Ǘ PPEPDQ!(R(2(r5PPPUPP5PPuP M - F-ڡ=:#:3+F7|=LGt6]LWD/FE?]HEW]Tu.NG]r@u.o6Ҽ]sƁTS10C0T`cFbFc b# ( hLdLTLtLg6fa68K11X! >dG `!a1`);, *:l&ll6l7k:Nnu%`/a?x G_pwp3L;ζs\c<#O/ox[s2s07-s5s\1W5?֏s~'|?_/%R_W5Zo7-Vq$nGYտ]QQ\gEQ AeT>"]D 6DOՀG{P۪Qc'j9GPSpk')8xb(ȼ'չ+ͿKt|i;` eǀr,4zP6oR."cyɼ&/&)jfAq>ΜMaj+= Hxռ`)8Yfыi5m"gbJ5mhXSBjRJnQb" Z%P =ϊ$ DIch<ޠ7,89LOS)~@|bQ h:4] ֲL80tH^U X k "׈f?ެ20;8i2^^[چ_\Nq[X?o3#̻ Nkyc|2<00 ei^(jhJڏ<`v@ƍf6FvQ^]vCf0d%LL}nqFyw̷͇ kS2 E NI O/=h9Y)>8L>\R6[Կѿ푈,ذ3[cG;j]°8\Ëy);'D,K]+XSy zc7 c`s"tOaD5D}vp@ׅG bTx3+y fwo+F!'үj:%_`;{2pٷ}ڑq㢿??? M|jn3w fK S%b?KCDȜ|zf@`GumC6EĝρB{nt\Vp80K:O2ռ(PxTg3QJGpHN1Q Eo/ O/YqYe?x% Xm+[6 |Pt%,k\iSN3.E9Zek]ۀjMv@둥O<} !׊J>‡9B$9A8FrHGWW9iIpx(5aޢx!0Jp7<:g)J2}_IOTyϿD].hz>jEN(Ѱ{,Z2aHe]{(ߧ^NJpr4lގ*;qj8g>C8D9J.9Le%plF4UP-mwl _r=.OV4w2(ʻJu%ƍ9:#}Ç MKMINJ2xPB|>С/&oTdDxgz #{ MU`Jv^HJbR4>544>=мa#1r5C46%Ysq©k< 5ь[ =!;*^e.N|1{S=%C dDՍAD2RFt}u!]3"pxR ) 'C('a1e9n^kLnn2oRnCz5z'a]QW<#}9UVhoO:_\bՖҠMU.[ z D *u4EGg7(ڥJܺ{JvOl=)ɍ;УBEW_@ .s> Q`h4qHSA a2f sn9^_hn7P]']uG-dVptFRhŅ=Y^GnLdl*CŨ+rw5*i$!VOVO㞮^(J48tWtO󋦹5ȶ%O:3IF&;ޝcΎ\%;)Y~ $ ,+?U4e@q(ݘZʤRFGvm".CдMMR&j-*50x١-?xwys()+=B$^' ʨiV@?}X@O,7[ih>ãa+ӜmSLϔ'фu10) {xZ)h#8߽zaFҕٞZ ug_PЦymgGHtw]h@yjJ`+6bŃ0c9^Wȕo (یmlՈmDQnz.Bln1OVbwwq\s.|g)3މ}Q7j:ɞNL#=}Y jujz~a:35ҥҡ k#wav-X<(N鳞h4JDQ%3`% I, N1*7yIom|W n#jPD@+ L4L\8XAB+.ŵ==[IN)Wu,==0 ]4ZQ>*km1ҏ0W*^Ad0}?>4Z˛ZNЎ Ay{)/z왝X5c~}vt,w'g6odl^:XH7\u D>PO\s3Tht1j"q8JQ[cHmU"]w2o1q۷l#1W|K(?ZOF_/(0+@4/PJo@:j$I. i&,isU A5Jb{o%Bm#[ :B a?@`]MF\Q|#<\i͍Lv\{a6bn&!N.)O÷Է,/6}gͬÑҒum?@13^o,ίjڵpI93fUY͊qbM˖Ūs5=.MqK|NS9nS=0g˗|6k'+~2Ʉ3.>`4SL//u-Jk%UDQ ͐gFtPױ-oθcXC·Lw֫ ;EswfVř `LȃX_{\EDl29TáR><^(oIRYf)KXw/A- eTSW^i8:=9h'0ae1ů>:6}v;D575f24I~1矛[.DU>W9Y<U3B_<ʛxGLL[a{F.Dyم4OHmm6%Ƨ5*XlIɞrx~AZS+t-f;bjs%.β9ue;kv{ȜV5ْ%c&fN'p7ƈoZQ;:;)|fVer,Q[OYsg[)!3V [kƚ(oU*o.ٞϓ_)< NtqHd! ͪGc{?~̗*H|SMA_D`߫[N96m8j7۾o^r~\]ŗuGl*  }9A/OIMrSƥT |0S\2S3[h&invlVmNѯn=ESU *Š$礵T&o{{C@t ݫgLjSО[ƧaURB5jҕ]n `!U?5_!qשּׁIϤFK~;: C-K%KO8[MW^М,e>FRZӻ|9NG7- L@5< Cf m>r=# uj>uOچOyM;c.Isv,{ߌrWkh/^ZM~S?AZ7=S)NM1U+X{B;{ (o sQg#݊ih({v@lDžqw KM(D[&&kx#sc@p_9g*sy \RhJq}IZBv9UXex|xXԣW~x7H1u ϘE 0_/3p`vZXvJ.gɩ,&NmE}?VV`- `cO`^-!hHrN\׹#?܌@_v._c,n@  `3ŋ(_ ]3Mkz2>v}7X(nX+MF#a2zpq⚉pX K}\Wac ǀsm 1k_~4T5*x<xx|7OuaWD8CܦB^Fh1MIWϱ?)<]*^NC[F^-G{籞˴W2^f0th;o^ϏHDr?n:h)a4v3B 5H6yQloY<}`rCNw z`T#<0VsKAp/(?0G:?}7zWw T4R#-قh8#y~;; 8e5}>L~u4_,Zݏh >SN-OT?G{Z~{#C,1 $Вg $$J %Gm,PBZ) -H@iФ "M*e:tZ)ݵϽ̬{;}=g#y4/;xs~꼉int2@]$qe!k&=mUb/տ)Gvg&ɉQJ Ui40!oFp}fIhkѱ G|P =ȯZ3ҜLjR~*Ug eQ/tnM9YCƬy9Xױ23K2[-DZnmm(C}h>5^V.3>n{}$7DC{%ss :-FJ$QwB7ͣ*:WG`k)Oj&9o#S%fZzU种!thޣϨ0*I*qpN0.VmL";3^ճӳ WCc,'H\1k4bO1߻5\1x^|79`}iPPR7g]17Eo5]oP |#|`8?^o cY y^~?ۺ'`O|Eٗsʗ_csonnmĮ}Db"[%I\&TISu\|@0/TRg*7#F.ܭ?\V"tc;=Fj!a Cɺ+0PP]k˝no,k41jgxcfwc^6Nз%g{`4~Ѹ y wmt,յY%]C[C][iGp85.P"+=\a ?P>WYivM/9Jz4=7Ev͖<7. ߪGzfw=kݛ8sM -2Dw3Ǡfz`Mg;ޑijn\ h?O3o9%h$|&רâO@"CgӨɺ_YF\DZמ?6> @#٘7ߍ‹@}}J c*_D~!8ޮa\_P&}G n$L"*8 ?HC_y0YGVه]媫 X@QQ$} E]H1mѨk$m \E`Xp @2t>́tj xM, {gp*@|`Z` گ0TB%x;fBbՁ(bc ma+|hNmڅ3@{fv4ׯ9;kO_l~}9?Z?~亭:(5j8n;:g;}t7Emo{ hiC[n6ϸ~(\{_@t=3}`x@8m]ѾŘ[oA>x\〡-9X 0}`QԸZewuG]2w9_id.7OGE4U5hFaȠj 7;gu| J;LVo!6LGuDܳʜ {9B㮆96_J ɯOUot~.fujl;|_tPβ$Jto|h>Hc&'4ࡢMu97v:~RdXC=W{6RH.KVnJCAŃƀhdxyX#f̍ {ku@\pW'Uv)Ĝ8蒮\Fcz:#ē=*Uߏ?ډm }] _l]lş"ƻF=UJrhUm)1Vm,XSyا8xb}ڜOC6P8S?@=0.+XM xOϺCBIvZ o /3@ 3~L];WT]˨Rj#m#F%[j%=ڋP;~b\.npu wnp:ij藅B}"Eg/]j0r _:L:q͢1}zOY^.!;C['-C56Td)![vG8dyT/G"C76myg1jƹo3"Y4D|lB+1/B俘NVf筵Y֣#8;E>fއ3 >63i]O92@ *Xz}~T?}Z% 8hJ>ŔX=< y"XЧ_B=YV۔ I1N,o՘Jx:UG9vqh`#k Zo5˺Bև8 ,Ok[syZ7 ǝ& #OC;nD)`݉"p M'w:@O>fpi&R׼6'LBN,TNɑF -ټWCIj˟F^‘DWtWl}8Ъj|<  踳18pnR3Ce~Yn-̹I $q%q>j v3:;0T쮡6A}\לID}& Sxۑfcutw2i-ZZAOtXY:CC4DnmRG&*u5)Vڪ :&޽H]nh1orn )zAwǩ~bσi2uq5UFMgao5߄-FݡX<0V ߶gQ3.FGqF f|lߢ֤@)nQLX(6ܢ3yC{ԧfŜ|>rFS,TwiYX̿+LJӆj;/ܴ=Vic8BW`<mBY4kV:xwYs9;ު!@*¸B?VÞjBgh4ZE@㠹|LR<Rt:ZiS> 凞"n?6;$%?`k(1H/^v׸6 D#$Z׉9,B(R&44*EfwMچjDoߛ73}2vj,z[`[Z9F3xF|ߵv{nOx[.>#;0 {"E(חI/;/y¾bo N36'1^6ƸS- p4JTyXiy_╞7F?aNJ1Yc1F%lG_{(gyv[s8N>jᗍ2+@lq3o .i$[¾wiH/xF=%,ԿMSC¼D|gamKT)wv>^m)ݝޯe;} BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP|$QMN9H{i4Wd Mt/Ri9RL?Ӻ`Z>4DM>ҺFSi]{-i!{Z7-bucvC^CETɅM ̩D*]5 QRN!;ThL.j/o@RKR3r73,}7FgУ(X?Jh`\}!]wRM13'A9]kPKP"r}r%u~":r&|E}7mL4V@~LMbu]X$ޕ5\jĘbI[8rE{vwB.s*KBA/GDu⑦߅K4b1'!1ƙ;ɉ6.q7RNc#&|PpAE圙: ϛ?jz‡k>YwP1n/D %Qű3ĕ1]#K2(ؗcFm ,\Br^ϳr} G_;GvFG\k4\vbxc@hɻXgi޲vȂB)Æ{;d|/N[Ӊn;Ig^Jܑ#['+*Ҕ:bBykk@gZ+vA!*iyfG3ґ#691OyJ$9`ut\t?YMvAۆ^Hz޹զZ_ŝX2wiyyW;v"۠.}oPVCSr|ȑ2`qA>pQzG:O=Ԗ[6dQvsQzFQE{g;Ǵۥ {;;#th;RlwmJ)]^7"D£hF ѤV:;&&& 5Z1`b >p=nJ޽{wιٙkSJQSzc/F,z}b*6JbGw+]IFu R[uy؎Ofnxeuu`A\34emACMW)+"e9XV}Aے6ޣ@SVq?L;RDdH'O4!R5i&n9/B͒ ni^b0C>Yf^8 Zi#guu-_G @ pi3|9ֽmFj2W {_"$z`~Y o%*$/Vkы ##6DZ38$w9N% ciOz'=|R'E%܁[GA;LQoXU/̔,r5lV$Uj@ItD^Fc1  @rdhh5C*!/VE6=op{Bd,[m;D+vIPP,#sn=N.zRW#'bq|0̾6 ,%߄fסȧjg'erY9x6Ĉ'Ud Jm!KأFz3c#2aw-Pel5rJ#=I!]ˤCBϐ"\M2so`%K +![.Gahf0"<% ZB*-rL,E):DNDbU.!.T9]*Q m8,rkϚ'Dբ%rB~ժ%5Y_L(_ᒾ V܉-w%uzlq0Z<8Rk:摣SGRh'\uNjG{Y$x]E.z}n_<6JNn@|-X j?Рh#KiP#@# 4!hQe3$8!acQg/"e"KW(PBJ@w, mQ0`h18&QgkS细:XTn?T{/?CZ*;RE"u7nvYN 0(}e`9#2PKshcs&dlu%$:nꇺȱc4maCOX}YU[ RZ3/V8E -iipb;Q4nF0i.Ŕw{ ۠N?D+HiDo,O endstream endobj 14 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 1/Type/Page>> endobj 42 0 obj [44 0 R 45 0 R] endobj 43 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (05-00374.a1)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\ ved%20-%20HTML/05-00374.a1.html)Tj 50.24 0 Td ([7/2/2021 3:41:34 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm (found him not guilty on the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 11.222 0 Td (three specifications under Article 92 but found him guilty of disorders \ to the prejudice of)Tj ET Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm (good order and discipline on the three specifications under Article 134)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 28.463 0 Td (of the UCMJ. )Tj (The court sentenced Applicant to)Tj -28.463 -1.125 Td (reduction to the rank of Private First Class and a Bad Conduct Discharge\ . )Tj 29.66 0 Td (The finding of guilty on one of the)Tj -29.66 -1.125 Td (specifications was overturned on appeal, but the military appeals court \ affirmed the sentence. )Tj 37.569 0 Td (In 2002, shortly after)Tj -37.569 -1.125 Td (Applicant began his first civilian)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 13.358 0 Td (employment, he received a verbal counseling about his inappropriate use \ of a)Tj -13.358 -1.125 Td (computer. )Tj 4.276 0 Td (He had opened an e-mail he believed came from a friend. )Tj 23.211 0 Td (The e-mail)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 4.609 0 Td (contained multiple pop-ups for)Tj -32.097 -1.125 Td (inappropriate websites. )Tj 9.525 0 Td (Applicant's employer told him not to do it again and there were no furth\ er incidents.)Tj -9.525 -2.125 Td (The Administrative Judge also found: Applicant became an Eagle Scout pri\ or to his enlistment in the Army. )Tj 43.49 0 Td (He)Tj -43.49 -1.125 Td (performed his Army duties with distinction,)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 17.803 0 Td (and earned numerous citations and awards. )Tj 17.466 0 Td (His Army performance)Tj -35.27 -1.125 Td (evaluations routinely rated him successful and among the best for promot\ ion. )Tj 31.159 0 Td (A witness at)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (the hearing was a 22-year)Tj -31.159 -1.125 Td (Army veteran who is also the chief executive officer at Applicant's curr\ ent place of employment. )Tj 38.999 0 Td (This witness worked)Tj -38.999 -1.125 Td (as an equal)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 4.692 0 Td (employment officer in Applicant's Army brigade and knew about Applicant'\ s court-martial and the basis for)Tj -4.692 -1.125 Td (it. )Tj (In the witness's opinion, the definition of)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 17.678 0 Td (fraternization has broadened over time and infractions are handled)Tj -17.678 -1.125 Td (differently among the various units in the Army. )Tj 19.635 0 Td (The witness felt that Applicant's)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 13.149 0 Td (punishment was more severe than)Tj -32.784 -1.125 Td (others. )Tj (Applicant's current supervisor and former Army platoon sergeant also tes\ tified. )Tj 34.865 0 Td (He concurred with the executive)Tj -34.865 -1.125 Td (officer's comments about fraternization and added that, following proble\ ms with fraternization at a particular Army post)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (where sergeants took advantage of)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 14.078 0 Td (their authority, the Army began to enforce its fraternization policies m\ ore stringently.)Tj -14.078 -1.125 Td (The command at Applicant's post made an example of him when it chose)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 29.533 0 Td (to proceed with a court-martial. )Tj 12.884 0 Td (In the opinion)Tj -42.417 -1.125 Td (of the witness, the discipline should have proceeded under Article 15. )Tj 28.131 0 Td (Applicant had no supervisory)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 12.053 0 Td (relationship with)Tj -40.184 -1.125 Td (the students with whom he fraternized and therefore could not take advan\ tage of his authority. )Tj 37.932 0 Td (Applicant's supervisor)Tj -37.932 -1.125 Td (has recommended him)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 9.303 0 Td (for several jobs, including his current position. )Tj 18.913 0 Td (He describes Applicant as reliable, dependable,)Tj -28.216 -1.125 Td (and not a security risk. )Tj 9.331 0 Td (Other witnesses describe Applicant as)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 15.468 0 Td (trustworthy and loyal. )Tj 9.054 0 Td (Applicant did not abuse his)Tj -33.853 -1.125 Td (authority in the Army because he was not in charge of the soldier with w\ hom he fraternized. )Tj 37.155 0 Td (Applicant's)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (current)Tj -37.155 -1.125 Td (supervisors describe him as trustworthy and loyal. )Tj 20.33 0 Td (He handles classified information appropriately. )Tj 19.549 0 Td (He is a hard worker)Tj -39.879 -1.125 Td (and has a positive attitude. )Tj 10.886 0 Td (Applicant is now married and has matured.)Tj -10.886 -2.125 Td (The Administrative Judge concluded that Department Counsel established i\ ts case under Guideline E, in that Applicant)Tj T* (had engaged in questionable conduct,)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 15.273 0 Td (including a pattern of rule violations while in the Army and when he)Tj -15.273 -1.125 Td (inappropriately accessed pornography on his computer in his first civili\ an job. )Tj 31.492 0 Td (The Judge)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (then concluded that PCMC 5)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 16 354.75 Tm (\(1\))Tj ET 0 0 0.933 RG 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 16 354 cm 0 0 m 11.369 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 27.3687 350.25 Tm ( applied to the case. )Tj 8.164 0 Td (The Judge also concluded that, while his past conduct might raise some c\ oncern about his)Tj -9.111 -1.125 Td (judgment, the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 5.749 0 Td (positive statements of confidence in him, the changes in his life and hi\ s overall work performance)Tj -5.749 -1.125 Td (outweigh his past poor judgment in one type of situation. )Tj 23.081 0 Td (The Judge cited factors such as the fact that Applicant's)Tj -23.081 -1.125 Td (violation of Army fraternization rules did not result in his abuse of au\ thority, and the fact that)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 37.657 0 Td (knowledgeable witnesses)Tj -37.657 -1.125 Td (testified as to Applicant's character. )Tj 14.508 0 Td (The Judge noted that those same witnesses testified that the Army's hand\ ling of)Tj -14.508 -1.125 Td (Applicant's)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (fraternization violations was unusually severe and may have been inappro\ priate. )Tj 37.112 0 Td (She concluded that the)Tj -37.112 -1.125 Td (probability of his past problems recurring was)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 18.69 0 Td (eliminated because of his increased maturity and the fact that he is now\ )Tj -18.69 -1.125 Td (married. )Tj 3.609 0 Td (She noted that the civilian job computer violation was an isolated incid\ ent and)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 31.576 0 Td (was over four years old. )Tj (Under a)Tj -35.185 -1.125 Td ("whole person" analysis, the Judge ultimately concluded that Applicant h\ ad mitigated the government's concerns under)Tj T* (Guideline E.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Department Counsel's initial claim of error involves the Administrative \ Judge's application of PCMC 5 to the case. )Tj 46.185 0 Td (The)Tj -46.185 -1.375 Td (thrust of Department Counsel's)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 12.678 0 Td (argument is that, since Personal Conduct Disqualifying Condition \(PCDC\)\ 4)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 535.4395 191.25 Tm ( \(2\))Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 535.4395 190.5 cm 0 0 m 13.806 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 549.2456 186.75 Tm ( was not)Tj -44.437 -1.125 Td (deemed by the Judge to be applicable to the case, PCMC 5 was wholly)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 28.577 0 Td (inapplicable. )Tj 5.387 0 Td (The Board has held that a)Tj -33.964 -1.125 Td (determination that PCDC 4 applies in a case is not a prerequisite to an \ Administrative Judge's application of PCMC 5)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 47.228 0 Td (in)Tj -47.228 -1.125 Td (appropriate circumstances. )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 10.967 0 Td (See)Tj /TT0 1 Tf (, )Tj /TT1 1 Tf (e.g.)Tj /TT0 1 Tf (, ISCR Case No. 97-0595 at 4 \(App. Bd. May 22, 1998\). )Tj (The Board continues to so)Tj -10.967 -1.125 Td (hold. )Tj (However, the Board has also)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 14.052 0 Td (held that if an Administrative Judge has not made a threshold finding th\ at there exist)Tj -14.052 -1.125 Td (facts or circumstances that increase an individual's vulnerability to)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 26.866 0 Td (coercion, exploitation, or pressure, then it would not)Tj -26.866 -1.125 Td (make sense for the Judge to consider whether an applicant "has taken pos\ itive steps to significantly reduce)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 42.812 0 Td (or eliminate")Tj -42.812 -1.125 Td (such vulnerability. )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 7.693 0 Td (Id.)Tj /TT0 1 Tf ( )Tj (In this case, Department Counsel correctly points out that there was no \ evidence or issue as to)Tj -7.693 -1.125 Td (whether Applicant's conduct)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 11.649 0 Td (made him vulnerable to coercion, exploitation, or duress. )Tj 23.077 0 Td (Thus, the Judge erred when)Tj -34.726 -1.125 Td (applying PCMC 5 to the facts of this case. )Tj 17.165 0 Td (Nevertheless, the Board)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 9.83 0 Td (deems this error harmless in light of the Judge's)Tj -26.995 -1.125 Td (overall decision and the record as a whole. )Tj 17.299 0 Td (After considering the Judge's decision in its entirety, the Board is)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC 26.341 0 Td (persuaded)Tj ET q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 12 0 0 12 16 38.25 Tm (that the application of PCMC 5 was not the substantial basis for the Jud\ ge's conclusion that Applicant had mitigated the)Tj ET EMC Q endstream endobj 44 0 obj <\\_N_1_)/S/GoTo>>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[16.0 352.0 27.0 363.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 45 0 obj <\\_N_2_)/S/GoTo>>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[535.0 189.0 549.0 200.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 12 0 obj <> endobj 46 0 obj <> endobj 9 0 obj <\\_N_1_)47 0 R(ʢu\\_N_2_)48 0 R]>> endobj 10 0 obj <> endobj 11 0 obj <> endobj 50 0 obj (file:///usr.osd.mil/Home/OSD/OGC/JosephLM/_MyComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archived%20-%20HTML/05-00374.a1.html) endobj 49 0 obj <> endobj 51 0 obj <> endobj 47 0 obj [16 0 R/XYZ 0 551.0 null] endobj 48 0 obj [16 0 R/XYZ 0 512.0 null] endobj 4 0 obj <> endobj xref 0 52 0000000000 65535 f 0000000016 00000 n 0000000141 00000 n 0000003658 00000 n 0000134726 00000 n 0000003536 00000 n 0000003591 00000 n 0000003731 00000 n 0000003758 00000 n 0000134103 00000 n 0000134197 00000 n 0000134239 00000 n 0000133913 00000 n 0000004394 00000 n 0000122538 00000 n 0000093792 00000 n 0000092030 00000 n 0000003861 00000 n 0000003907 00000 n 0000003956 00000 n 0000004147 00000 n 0000004019 00000 n 0000004051 00000 n 0000004083 00000 n 0000004115 00000 n 0000004594 00000 n 0000011313 00000 n 0000011362 00000 n 0000011398 00000 n 0000012024 00000 n 0000039792 00000 n 0000040059 00000 n 0000012417 00000 n 0000012690 00000 n 0000013083 00000 n 0000040670 00000 n 0000092219 00000 n 0000094003 00000 n 0000101747 00000 n 0000102128 00000 n 0000102404 00000 n 0000102752 00000 n 0000122752 00000 n 0000122784 00000 n 0000133257 00000 n 0000133584 00000 n 0000133998 00000 n 0000134642 00000 n 0000134684 00000 n 0000134447 00000 n 0000134281 00000 n 0000134589 00000 n trailer <<38E248688910324CB595FC14649B1A21>]>> startxref 134899 %%EOF