>I*.af#LR7=0<5yOlC~@fhy!Qek yeH THln7Bq% 5=3@}u RdN>[5F
1VYZwq?gh##۟5ҁHuoM}_"~ |:ûf; S]cZ 7ṬnupSY;G%}xŢ}e>h F9 a JR3B4` b š&<"q8#hjz81vRqC ʕA b53$a\9Ľ݂'AqDO㢜j=%Z-
s嬐N?|f#g)}5
h[kZ;j^nH7nzcG; 8
g!P;pҬFKu1I|^n6L;><Nk7sy-Pүݺ-R٠#!ppj\ oC,&.3iiE16Qԙ;g"
\So ,̳eSE#im19VShLƼ>)bA-vb^NK K48D YƉF>6{ DԆSҁƲV ?{@
Q91W`3.wcšPLdKTҽ(-lYjH,& Aۙъt=ے?/fc!R/Er%*tr4N#DW ?Rh)vG/
'ؓK
|3FpR蔋|u'pŇ\q q aQƕ 6XB۶Se 5
3 0b;s13bm̏!yZ8tjo Ky4I@--Rej Y;Ązg[IO,:d(:}Q'(rL%:vQkiD%Um\ 'ɮV3d/l8,ሆy =e&Z}q)#[fG7y> ^`V?dtsH:U7 H'7% mTɨi/#>EZ4bW
Kh'1$JKN&d2Qm"J&"0DZTqE K5j7:% CaqĠpOjLtԵ+Sv+',MJ ][hx
7fX.1 ,:1r1YFqvv@[V|U7>ķGęͫc-Sw[A`Y@m3w'Llďv0ם6AR})R;U/NPTt{SFKU n}mmm tS `VU'+v Ӯ6wF=aQ.J!&ꊪǧa*VZ6tUw CHӿL%zREMbh|r&P3(
QBR)jυ0 FWǢT2q
lMˌ*4H]Ck 6m]OoLnk>R ksX/IHI\z
Kpn/Dxq ؈.@@vC'+Ov/_wȜy m\BKlģ]hG"\pЏ.}&w]IٚcӍ~|YGݚ0Ǿ=dіԷ\tla'[D7 tCl+k_6x|aC[omYe-;2=odd Iw={CV
rh]ȵ w;sOS/eOg8P& '?r80Iɀ]1AT̙hweɠU [X%tQ yEO3a|Ds¥sعyw<|GWXm1@x賥4DPG8P $
Jp ZkI$eg3̂OٖrǎS۶M|E 5xgƆG{aϰ)#O(UM 4aV9"dVRa_U-XOBd fI#f~W/ԑNRݥ(guSrX}kiӻ
a MWy}>+kY 43c^(N5mšYiӵrZ,Qu;3 W6dR!!B^k~ }Z?32hIϓ,V/8ZqqS !"AD `͔4B4$Œ@Y.kX ^㕆@h Sׯ Q$ : !6Ud" +W/U~o/ Fvs"|ޤIG-Y5&ȩeV9+xww.OMMmqe@{ blc=#m͕muϾ&-#͝l^ɕZ:a z~eѴUB6$ bEW9[k׳kđA/̫Y1G {nr&ʦ`:`9shگY,ѢZQ5MHgd#'nW)5C(A/@ 7U1/М s VCur8ZϢ$
HFQ9
GFluʹzj9 mr kﺁ' S gɝ}wgv_M
iS 5uk(
`J TmP UlRGs}) 1@CB4!I
,鐐=m7Mw'dzgwϢ7}.5J,WϛȷUYHI : /[|t0U d+Z;AL"I}::30ѝ9!$I(Rx0$"i0%&qQ`coՇwŻ,2"^Ŵ=]75W!{DLڭm/N8i x&Wwb:VW Uh&i
DŽC ШP6\9J.x~,&B͵m24e| U h>{x;Gcb&2f;k:|>?5s0,}<<ȥfo @* fK9w`OsZm6)>&0[mOJ&*,Md N^ps~?KVv?,WV}r:űinllƂhtO̬$sz;N+auqSMƂRSCaHCb!ݢE頺[L1M*YFE H:sg:) 1Z
.Ci!tNf
*@ڦ<1l7 i,6ܼpC qR_,_[R6ӏwO!]?:ޗM-=wv 57:gޭ ,r' ѬVҷ + 3;]u?N~sG 힕7yhHb*+ 9t~fWϫ}Ayٲ,{QӜ憁)O$7 .(Z:7$$3M KA. (s2ay% L2i7% Qx&LJ$Ѿ,^WkUH/($[OHpk 9 ]TWxqX 0vxt!`׆! @)@ 0 I튛B- !ĶNrf̭6EnYByԬjOϻlvWaD -ERQLּOhHoיk}cu>ͧ.a#TepQ|qϟ'!V VgiHw|A
U(9AmBL
!:ڼB#AVr/KY
^u )buv{i$b/ĬNWG֒a&`t;Lx3XVmvm}:FE|`:8pc:v; m%!Mݷ X7ПbŒ9[(J;'ԬT<ŘZ*bf19P$2<ɸG’ 33貞C\AάjhV|ď]/3<_6<}Im"!!+"4((Q
=ݭXC6B FI}_IE!7yA² !JVdBHiʖ3x 뽊%(G
K\.ô9UnU
g-2>M8-+p[LA>M(&k+ 2jKSH,j c5Uy#CE`mW ;PDyghGZ\2`{!2f s33z
Ϗ`VWkF]PވѨ$n lB %$S<ڃFXZJH6tZ=rn7%C,>4a uXQJVf svKcwހUu'7T Ri XBDާm#)~Sր-mm[mmһd Ec^^uAo52d%X&kb먤[ ˳L[WxG5`Wfu3.EmBsr.u^KIpFxw^ e
_ 4s& _tN)hXPF-~\E?^re^*tzp@')xOIa|6Pt \(nCWòЃ~#V`ļ@R(ST_J d@В{ ,9J9VvO+eZǑT ~x#)#HP^!CcK_qd0#նzV=]wYa4L\6 C~4[ou:qq܆`ߚ7Kknښ%XUjYڳf3QᎽ_
~[,{~D e?i#Eq,<1XrSVR u=T#{Obs\< c_@r8T ikX[ٓAYMxSd"j&@6.QLЛ_ x?3,qJNǜv*pQP-Z1XFz${"1] I Ļ .K
F = 'iξ<v;L'U/]}ij}BkE HN9YkF~miʵ\4IG;+] 㙁۷yPWF4c VZJ#i0y
kbsi.pJ:idV)RT̮YrKSePAq^ x } Pje @
(`
->qE;@ۡTl1M3 ZS@U#%I^\?8>9PDZo7>X_. >c.iifxOJ4Q_J NM 8@n0n0/^q9;#|~?S .0PmY8]aR1 K Q119B#XUӂ"f Z(
JYy]H0rZBԪ s1t[5ߕ6V)j2 &#f4} R\̑@$&= AKL+Jp`w
dOÒ&vGír
%%6S}=Z8{}UZ=A\bY.E1s~$!jm Ͱ :Tu(}EfQ.Ho syE 47ޱIw ^MA'LH 6ZF:*){%طk`;|
}EdC$fy~A{/&TY& !
ca6-D1HUJLu |]O|oj*
gn ozyjc4Q nO?T Z` 4łF3 ԓj~M}
7 64;Qr;GF$+%0d#B@E"|f:=E2 e>V` ` ӑ
\ 18#[0C'ls
(\&s!{F3ܫX;9IQ|f1 t:=*&UfȨU8D˩2tѨ":*B
g뻧KO]*s8mȉ
g'Lo [ᕑRgȵ;X OdLjo1k_"D$Y]/2ܻK߁UQ#n2 d7sE#Ecݱ}~re6"цxunDƪId` $eMˬӍhʴ4aHb`i9,\V?MGIZO#T,ua^Uaḓf).Wju*ժpX:+O\ GM;o{ 0+!g 猖0G.O"|2r1AYY
$x'caPD7IYm*-bٰn֜s/b ^5@U WܻG!
D+
*
T::фҚ!UE#Ɵj Z$4-ZIЉ6v:&ASk1w/fә7ߜs9M |sǙ̽g|Ff) 'liiI -M X]8ݛP 1 7
ﾶ6_XAc@/v߾{g۷C>@*ҩҟdZfNs8Zm+d,P6N0Q:lalm&y6"mB=>N/#~|& ZBo:d<29j>mqVH\`GQU?mF'c_ Fa]~K6ԍC(ֳla߀
lZ} 7J}ʀ5-
}Tϲ-[Zq\Ӯu_YREW6`[]qǾ4>:d\G.i hR
XkK{/d
a4P }=|
8zI_KΫ,]{c?V
hׇi+Fvجӟ7,۾oYGPlhM#WmKĀږZB772K9>1@w ШIa-Xk G -ňQ̥ x }-ǖ%m%O03R xՒ3{~f
Ϝ ~~ 9=rK7|Aϡ~[rna~܂K1zׯ ҬO.OGf K[Rc!5SOUAlVcɑZܒ>Y* u N2QcV3e~y09dIwuQ9{Z yF=.1)yF B qL,:5UtDLĽqj'eqT^P+w7hX-[T$ j:.~+?Q k,:dԬmI)h;*`\w([mob=]{˶v6~}Uǘ@سq~d6|pO 8h.}0>7-2O(nMICc0=eL@2 ;
eV c@ _4-}1$ϕj]Gy_܋r%6 )^_앇R{%{6i9Ik uts-?yKSq>s)s)Uiۅj_ )xBV-i֝#ﰎ܇ ze \NeL8~g|_hIe1$@XZ
u-
[Y @X5C\%Y PDSP@T,||pz*y77E>nV ?Nb[[j;rEkakh Zo&? =J vn %7rk\~GiX?h.
t_9'
oUC}u;柵FuA}VQAȇջR!A!X:E jG3 ǚN#@S|3d dea>E9j~Li9f:
R
s[pGa.P&X]GU@l&VONv)~
H-C݁R31e n V.8-)XG WVIv[le.K)\܇jj$i0B3Fl#:x;(tqRN ``!O7p6 .b/&F/_ E(uacHOoR9[hU,?Gmfs1*a]cA;bۓbAء}h#~4կ)?jO_ M1wlƿQ}GS)wjƏcA~ ˠ3ī\dkqq ] gp
Yt}ؾ`3
_@+xDA cZx^u@)x;M%~?Kwnt/fۯA ~cЖ< &' 8V.] " S;rn)bN:涳sD:bezI]*AZҡkKMF ??
=5z"<#: vWPKjYDO78gzaRw꜊\"v)?_B+WӠ_~ϱp~B}(1"g!_ۥufF_A,IdhɡUBe>gNodn_kى[L!c]Y>h4O=mSTqƈVdms y
u w},zs䯐WJ 4yވѥӹRM.]>QUv2oFbuM"ת zk/bct jP+{UtGtv:m.yۯtzLC? ϕv*o}fĚOӡx'AN`6d|8 mԚȸϢn467ǫ{_tq wҽ!W:
|vx-jkogMq?ݴ&gj?V Álj)Ԝ
ttݍVCuY5X?k^h[O_ 7kBo=t36멋}SaCiX6Yg0b}] B%~Rfk^9{8p}.Jr* kh ԊRx)({DuǰT.-_Peh: s. w 39 GhѩP;uN#B%X_od~;^4Ǎ|ƫmhoön1Ԋj-/ZO uvx:JgA-np>Y(r, ƴFaIlr`PdU9zGƏ}Y\X0NĚ0n i^ !&
mu?k@o`WAhuxSwf|4
_'=~AU=xU+E7a k[~ZA@8 =G}.]}V#fQ _ds/%xW|h {>=2k$M%Ri
MVh!Bh 3:OTO菥\]lGT r~
z&3-6(Xߠ%iz4G=P4CefW0ʅ]1qc, qVPbs-7Sf&)Cz hƗ1^q?5Aܙk|ȟ 0g y̎?[ʺ1uvYx1:uQ?|/r
= 5=d|kӿQ}PKǷ~ܮAZ[NIr/D:ȕim>;rv2;}P븧͙'g*}7i j5̱\75:vV^{T/Mꂻw-vzo,o
'qkRӽW|b㳆l?'7g A*Z/^d
%cz8B;?c w
/9d"19f,:ȏ ZA9~}{5cRt` *qWcl;[^ .s%!Iz%4y'Zڅ:C+2\6 Wd?2)0ԋ?[6'?RA k1}+=>x# r\yk6kMhY gll3ߙ³>`#;͜=gs{0ؠ۾?J
%u\jjxs漏دH/3.d N5w^
۽f{b3G;o~ z
O6о:Ne@N&$5r#FAr7KYGWY7aU5 ☽M={y![8*Ug4-x^r*u Y
y͑<'Ӽw |didT:ˑ307rfV= Yj~ 7{Z F14Fw="Zx`em ;pDtCRߓeRG_[
Um)tG) ict(DvHEq_1G z%5YtF3C|Z阃x*\S VZ'X{vbnUHChb_@Uv"Թ)oI%ZKb:}8:ط$d MϡGԴ+ЄiN{;2~n{IWH֧ysEnf .I5&:W5|-nzHsˑ^GRSH<ɶa}lL|o,*4-*Qve@?s: P؏ r 1ZJk,\[}_cV,2\2dAzt+_x]<"* iD2#H}vcr̪/Sz*ͬC>L0233XD
Sm{ѲMyLb i xsx_y
ОqK'
w~ {g=j} RY#7Ot9yH 4F;ysx40>^ab3, {z=:{0/x)jRYRВvIDg-~maX
ģSprw{%#TOWb1uV -[l3ܱj =}>$c>y8q ZF i:DejI袌=&-8.NhۇiJɚ ʨ4pmBm/Z :m{ މ pMgwAG_r*}-SzZ.~rč EsU`5<: ;n NͨEhL~re ]r
16)[`hs?6cN";19Ov H zSd:*K [.Sh럺i")dZ ikn-학x&rbz8jyG}~oH$H:xSI9N&go9ȷ;} b̖ȡ@b]+()p!Hou%57
DS"RGO, ӝHx+繈I (O%]Dw`$i |KK9kxqӻF(g[yIu%cb2FIGbTukK[:bNjs=۾ct#:>YlG,$H$D߄1C6Zpm݈Zm$Lo!ir"f3ku}2_Oe
Qw .vQ?MqM2&{cԷD7N iu/і+4YU-ebuVv8
p xpqٸ>B 㳙ϔQc朲!V.g1t6REvhEu#\ ؋Op?Y;i4(f`; f7Juad|Ӝ`C~C~*4=^}P dz8R֘{a)Ƽk)2;r/#:;4Q-($e\E\Lyz=|y:
Gg!d?Xgc_5fȿ. :Dapm_mEUܘ; =*Yƚ- z*rCVY PAAk.il1&Si9plfhak?|JR
ƶ~u_^Zظ-χ*
~9vD\ϧl7l3Zۨ)}X\dhYߙ7wF|zIAC3NeVYyUX`f-EH`۟_,R$C6Kg$`u1հ&u2oQQۉr\jP6hJxWA
&5P@6f#eXF4. kT4]Ө@)v2PxdhdY/˒Pq84;htMAcyШJR-_r,q7qK܈pFk
8e,R"*8}=`gyXL hs3&L^4_C GkT' T< Tc/=C1J9j~ȧ鄬?EuR,'̔1B P dB88>lT/[b33$ 4Z5wƇ5
ٜPh}Z!!'2wV |- }H $PofJffv;j+U UgZ)_Ka.zYM-#ER_?PU
r^!ٟݮºl3 j<`'!Jr'N䗜q^[Q떂am R\iLsޜ(vpjC
4yԖev` OZT)|9 ;e85>!^LJg&cY}X7bzROI 5ay-cqB=vѨ i^!' {gJoe iihHz;3!%'!Ɉ .uF7:o>q%cdFM{ z3:ŏ^(V:}Oj'v-jn~U/m=!t$obXPsaQEII {AaX4[&02\ n4)+ liL
l4&r;bY8D*[ɣ[>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 3/Type/Page>>
endobj
51 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(05-01820.a1)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\
ved%20-%20HTML/05-01820.a1.html)Tj
50.24 0 Td
([7/2/2021 3:43:57 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm
(whether granting Applicant a clearance is clearly in the interest of nat\
ional security. )Tj
33.764 0 Td
(The Judge's decision articulated no)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm
(rational basis for denying Applicant a clearance, and neither does the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
27.878 0 Td
(majority opinion. )Tj
7.194 0 Td
(This leaves Applicant, and the)Tj
-35.072 -1.125 Td
(Government for that matter, with a final clearance decision that is not \
the "overall common sense determination based)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(upon careful consideration)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
10.913 0 Td
(of [applicable Guidelines], each of which is to be evaluated in the cont\
ext of the whole)Tj
-10.913 -1.125 Td
(person," as required by Directive \266 E2.2.3. )Tj
17.273 0 Td
(Rather, Applicant is denied a clearance without any explanation)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
25.824 0 Td
(other than)Tj
-43.097 -1.125 Td
(that the Judge wrote an insufficient explanation for finding in his favo\
r. )Tj
28.854 0 Td
(This not only is not mandated to correct the)Tj
-28.854 -1.125 Td
(identified error, it does not correct the error at all.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Accordingly, I would set aside this decision and remand the case for a n\
ew decision by the Judge that sufficiently)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(analyzes and articulates the relevant and material information, )Tj
25.128 0 Td
(the pertinent criteria)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
8.357 0 Td
(and adjudication policy, to reach)Tj
-33.485 -1.125 Td
(supportable conclusions with respect to both Guideline B and the ultimat\
e determination of whether granting a security)Tj
T*
(clearance in this case is clearly consistent)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
16.854 0 Td
(with the interests of national security.)Tj
-16.854 -2.125 Td
(Signed: David M. White)Tj
ET
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 16 582 cm
0 0 m
117.984 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 557.25 Tm
(David M. White)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Administrative Judge)Tj
T*
(Member, Appeal Board)Tj
T*
(1. )Tj
(Directive \266 E2.A2.1.3.1 \("A determination that the immediate family \
member\(s\), spouse, father, mother, sons,)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(daughters, brothers, sisters\), cohabitant, or associate\(s\) in questio\
n are not agents of)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
33.713 0 Td
(a foreign power or in a position to)Tj
-33.713 -1.125 Td
(be exploited by a foreign power in a way that could force the individual\
to choose between loyalty to the person\(s\))Tj
T*
(involved and the United States"\).)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(2. )Tj
(Directive \266 E2.A2.1.3.3 \("Contact and correspondence with foreign ci\
tizens are casual and infrequent"\).)Tj
T*
(3. )Tj
(The Administrative Judge made statements in the conclusion section of hi\
s decision which the Board construes as)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(additional findings of fact.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(4. )Tj
(In the conclusion section of his decision, the Administrative Judge enga\
ges in an extensive discussion of the)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(circumstances relating to Applicant's wife's family members in the PRC \(\
parents, sisters, and brothers-in-law\). Based)Tj
T*
(upon his findings with respect to those individuals, the Judge concludes\
that Applicant's wife's family members in the)Tj
T*
(PRC are not in a position to be exploited by a foreign power in a way th\
at could force the individual to choose between)Tj
T*
(loyalty to those individuals and the United States. The Judge also concl\
udes that Applicant's contact and ties with his)Tj
T*
(wife's family in the PRC are casual and infrequent. In his brief, Depart\
ment Counsel disagrees with the Judge's)Tj
T*
(favorable application of Mitigating Conditions 1 and 3 with respect to A\
pplicant's wife's family members in the PRC,)Tj
T*
(and offers an extensive argument as to why the Judge's conclusions in th\
at regard are not supported by the record)Tj
T*
(evidence. )Tj
4.053 0 Td
(The Board notes that the SOR did)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
13.804 0 Td
(not allege any security concerns relating to Applicant's wife's family)Tj
-17.857 -1.125 Td
(members in the PRC. )Tj
8.805 0 Td
(It only alleged security concerns relating to Applicant's wife. )Tj
24.617 0 Td
(However, the circumstances relating)Tj
-33.422 -1.125 Td
(to)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Applicant's wife's family members in the PRC are relevant in evaluating \
the extent to which Applicant's wife's)Tj
T*
(circumstances present security concerns. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
16.521 0 Td
(See, e.g., )Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
3.832 0 Td
(ISCR Case No. 01-18860 at 8)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(\(App. Bd. Mar. 17, 2003\); ISCR Case)Tj
-20.353 -1.125 Td
(No. 02-00305 at 4 \(App. Bd. Feb. 12, 2003\).)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(5. )Tj
(At the hearing, Applicant stated that his wife "calls her mother and her\
sisters at least twice a month--well, since she's)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(been here, yes, twice a month." Transcript at 33.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(6. )Tj
(The Administrative Judge only concluded that Applicant's ties to his wif\
e's family members in the PRC were casual)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(and infrequent. )Tj
6.303 0 Td
(The record establishes that Applicant's ties to his wife--the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
23.701 0 Td
(only PRC citizen of security concern)Tj
-30.004 -1.125 Td
(referenced in the SOR--are not casual or infrequent, and that his wife's\
ties to her family members in the PRC are not)Tj
T*
(casual or infrequent. )Tj
8.441 0 Td
(Therefore,)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
4.441 0 Td
(itigating Condition 3, standing alone, could not serve as a basis for mi\
tigating the)Tj
-12.882 -1.125 Td
(security concerns as set forth in the SOR.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(7. )Tj
(The nonappealing party can argue in favor of affirming a ruling or decis\
ion based on any ground having support in)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
15 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 2/Type/Page>>
endobj
52 0 obj
[54 0 R 55 0 R 56 0 R 57 0 R]
endobj
53 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(05-01820.a1)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\
ved%20-%20HTML/05-01820.a1.html)Tj
50.24 0 Td
([7/2/2021 3:43:57 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm
(The Administrative Judge's favorable security clearance is REVERSED.)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 729.75 Tm
(Signed: William S. Fields)Tj
ET
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 16 729 cm
0 0 m
124.002 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 704.25 Tm
(William S. Fields)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Administrative Judge)Tj
T*
(Member, Appeal Board)Tj
T*
(Signed: James E. Moody)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 16 627 cm
0 0 m
119.994 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 602.25 Tm
(James E. Moody)Tj
T*
(Administrative Judge)Tj
T*
(Member, Appeal Board)Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
14.338 -2.125 Td
(Separate Opinion of Member David M. White)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
-14.338 -2.125 Td
(I agree with the opinion of my colleagues insofar as they hold that the \
Administrative Judge's conclusions favorably)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(applying Guideline B \(Foreign Influence\) Mitigating Conditions \(FIMC\)\
1 and 3)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
32.579 0 Td
(are arbitrary and capricious, and that)Tj
-32.579 -1.375 Td
(this is harmful error.)Tj
0 0 0.933 rg
9.75 0 0 9.75 114.6426 474.75 Tm
( \(8\))Tj
ET
0 0 0.933 RG
q 1 0 0 1 114.6426 474 cm
0 0 m
13.806 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 128.4487 470.25 Tm
( )Tj
(I respectfully disagree with the decision to reverse the Judge's decisio\
n because correction of)Tj
-9.371 -1.125 Td
(these properly identified errors neither)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
15.633 0 Td
(mandates nor supports reversal, with the resultant final denial of a cle\
arance to)Tj
-15.633 -1.125 Td
(this Applicant. )Tj
6.138 0 Td
(I would remand the case for a properly reasoned and articulated decision\
, based on consideration of)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
40.068 0 Td
(all)Tj
-46.207 -1.125 Td
(the relevant and material information.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(The Directive gives the Appeal Board authority to take one of three acti\
ons in its written clearance decision addressing)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(the material issues raised on appeal: )Tj
14.662 0 Td
(to affirm the decision below; to remand)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
16.079 0 Td
(the case specifying action to be taken to)Tj
-30.74 -1.125 Td
(correct identified error; or to reverse the decision of the Administrati\
ve Judge if correction of identified error mandates)Tj
0 -1.375 TD
(such action)Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
4.526 0 Td
(.)Tj
0 0 0.933 rg
9.75 0 0 9.75 73.3164 365.25 Tm
( \(9\))Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 73.3164 364.5 cm
0 0 m
13.806 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
0 g
/TT0 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 87.1226 360.75 Tm
( )Tj
(The identified harmful)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
9.552 0 Td
(errors that require correction in this case are the arbitrary and capric\
ious)Tj
-15.479 -1.125 Td
(conclusions applying FIMC1 and FIMC 3 to sufficiently mitigate the secur\
ity concerns raised by the Government's)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(evidence)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
3.803 0 Td
(and warrant granting the clearance in question.)Tj
-3.803 -2.125 Td
(Even though this case does not turn on credibility determinations concer\
ning disputed testimony in the fact-finding)Tj
T*
(process, I am in no position after merely reading a cold record to reach\
my own)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
32.072 0 Td
("fair and impartial common sense)Tj
-32.072 -1.125 Td
(determination based upon consideration of all the relevant and material \
information and the pertinent criteria and)Tj
0 -1.375 TD
(adjudication policy in [the Adjudicative)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
16.19 0 Td
(Guidelines].")Tj
0 0 0.933 rg
9.75 0 0 9.75 274.1641 269.25 Tm
( \(10\))Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 274.1641 268.5 cm
0 0 m
18.681 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 292.8452 264.75 Tm
( Applicant is entitled to a hearing and to personally appear)Tj
-23.07 -1.125 Td
(before the hearing Judge so that the decision maker will be able to asse\
ss him as a "whole person" in reaching a proper)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(clearance decision. Both parties to this appeal are entitled to a reason\
ed articulation, by the Judge who heard the)Tj
T*
(evidence, supporting a sustainable judgment.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Under appropriate circumstances, the Judge can "render a favorable decis\
ion in the absence of an[y] Adjudicative)Tj
0 -1.375 TD
(Guidelines mitigating condition.")Tj
0 0 0.933 rg
9.75 0 0 9.75 176.5469 186.75 Tm
( \(11\))Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 176.5469 186 cm
0 0 m
18.681 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 195.228 182.25 Tm
( Thus even a finding by the Board that FIMC 1)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
19.081 0 Td
(and 3 are not applicable as a matter)Tj
-34.016 -1.125 Td
(of law, as opposed to the more narrow legal holding that the decision in\
adequately explains why and how they do apply,)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(would not compel denial of Applicant's)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
16.01 0 Td
(clearance. )Tj
4.274 0 Td
(Only a remand, not a reversal, can cure the arbitrary and capricious)Tj
-20.284 -1.125 Td
(nature of the decision in this case because, as the majority correctly s\
tate, the Board is not permitted to substitute our)Tj
T*
(judgment for that of the Administrative Judge.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Having found that the Judge's decision to grant Applicant a clearance is\
arbitrary and capricious, "in that it fails to)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(articulate a satisfactory explanation for its conclusions, including a r\
ational)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
30.296 0 Td
(connection between the facts found and the)Tj
-30.296 -1.125 Td
(choice made, and offers an explanation for the decision that runs contra\
ry to the record evidence," the majority)Tj
T*
(articulates no explanation whatsoever for)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
16.744 0 Td
(deciding that Applicant must be denied a clearance in order to correct t\
he)Tj
-16.744 -1.125 Td
(Judge's deficient explanation. )Tj
12.065 0 Td
(The Judge's issuance of an unsustainable decision in itself has no logic\
al relevance to)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
54 0 obj
<>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[114.0 472.0 128.0 483.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>>
endobj
55 0 obj
<>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[73.0 363.0 87.0 374.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>>
endobj
56 0 obj
<>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[274.0 267.0 292.0 278.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>>
endobj
57 0 obj
<>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[177.0 184.0 195.0 195.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>>
endobj
14 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 1/Type/Page>>
endobj
58 0 obj
[60 0 R 61 0 R 62 0 R 63 0 R]
endobj
59 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(05-01820.a1)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\
ved%20-%20HTML/05-01820.a1.html)Tj
50.24 0 Td
([7/2/2021 3:43:57 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 754.5 Tm
(B. )Tj
(Discussion)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 729 Tm
(The Judge's findings of fact are not challenged on appeal.)Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
7.156 -2.125 Td
(Whether the Record Supports the Administrative Judge's Ultimate Conclusi\
ons)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
-7.156 -2.125 Td
(An Administrative Judge is required to "examine the relevant data and ar\
ticulate a satisfactory explanation for" the)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(decision "including a 'rational connection between the facts found and t\
he choice)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
32.632 0 Td
(made.'" )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
(Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Ass'n of)Tj
-32.632 -1.125 Td
(the United States v. State Farm Mut. Auto Ins. Co., )Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
20.636 0 Td
(463 U.S. 29, 43 \(1983\) \(quoting )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
(Burlington Truck Lines, Inc. v.)Tj
-20.636 -1.125 Td
(United States,)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
5.61 0 Td
( 371 U.S. 156, 168 \(1962\)\). )Tj
(The Appeal Board may reverse the Administrative Judge's decision to gran\
t,)Tj
-5.61 -1.125 Td
(deny, or revoke a security clearance if it is arbitrary, capricious, or \
contrary to law. )Tj
33.402 0 Td
(Directive \266 E3.1.32.3. )Tj
9.034 0 Td
(Our scope of)Tj
-42.437 -1.125 Td
(review under this standard is narrow, and we may not substitute our judg\
ment for that of the Administrative Judge. )Tj
46.185 0 Td
(We)Tj
-46.185 -1.125 Td
(may not set aside an Administrative Judge's decision "that is rational, \
based)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
30.499 0 Td
(on consideration of the relevant factors, and)Tj
-30.499 -1.125 Td
(within the scope of the authority delegated to the agency. . ." )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
24.54 0 Td
(Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Ass'n,)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
10.74 0 Td
( 463 U.S. at 42. )Tj
(We review)Tj
-35.28 -1.125 Td
(matters of law )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
5.97 0 Td
(de novo.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
-5.97 -2.125 Td
(Department Counsel argues that the Administrative Judge erred in favorab\
ly applying Guideline B Mitigating)Tj
0 -1.375 TD
(Conditions 1 and 3.)Tj
0 0 0.933 rg
9.75 0 0 9.75 110.002 532.5 Tm
( \(4\))Tj
ET
0 0 0.933 RG
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 110.002 531.75 cm
0 0 m
13.806 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 123.8081 528 Tm
( )Tj
(The Board finds Department Counsel's argument to be)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
22.314 0 Td
(persuasive.)Tj
-31.298 -2.125 Td
(In the conclusion section of his decision, the Administrative Judge foun\
d that: \(1\) Applicant's wife is a citizen of the)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(PRC, residing in the U.S. with Applicant; \(2\) Applicant met his wife o\
n an)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
30.135 0 Td
(Internet chat room; \(3\) Applicant's wife stays)Tj
-30.135 -1.125 Td
(mostly at home, caring for Applicant's child, does not yet know much abo\
ut the U.S. and American life, and Applicant)Tj
T*
(is her only real tie to this)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
10.192 0 Td
(country; \(4\) Applicant's wife's parents, sisters, and brother-in-laws \
are citizens and residents of)Tj
-10.192 -1.375 Td
(the PRC; \(5\) Applicant's wife speaks to her parents about every other \
month;)Tj
0 0 0.933 rg
9.75 0 0 9.75 385.4102 450 Tm
( \(5\))Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 385.4102 449.25 cm
0 0 m
13.806 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 399.2163 445.5 Tm
( \(6\) "[t]he PRC is)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(officially recognized)Tj
-31.935 -1.125 Td
(as one of the most active gatherers of defense and industrial informatio\
n in the U.S., which means Applicant's burden of)Tj
T*
(proof is even heavier than for someone with relatives)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
21.521 0 Td
(in a friendly country"; \(7\) "Applicant's evidence about his wife)Tj
-21.521 -1.125 Td
(and in-laws is somewhat limited by the relative short period of time the\
y have known each other"; and \(8\) "[t]here is)Tj
T*
(some evidence)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
6.164 0 Td
(that [Applicant's] wife's parents are not agents of a foreign power, but\
there is no evidence one way or)Tj
-6.164 -1.125 Td
(the other as to whether they are susceptible to pressure from the PRC go\
vernment or)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
34.019 0 Td
(intelligence agencies and might ask)Tj
-34.019 -1.125 Td
(Applicant to act against U.S. security interests." )Tj
19.404 0 Td
(Based on the forgoing, the Judge found security concerns were raised)Tj
-19.404 -1.125 Td
(under Guideline B Disqualifying)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
13.387 0 Td
(Conditions 1 and 2, but then concluded without explanation or analysis t\
hat those)Tj
-13.387 -1.125 Td
(concerns could be mitigated under Guideline B Mitigating Conditions 1 an\
d 3, because Applicant's immediate)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
44.337 0 Td
(family)Tj
-44.337 -1.125 Td
(members are not agents of a foreign power or in a position to be exploit\
ed by a foreign power in a way that count force)Tj
T*
(Applicant to choose between loyalty to the persons involved and the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
27.577 0 Td
(U.S., and Applicant's contacts and ties with his)Tj
-27.577 -1.125 Td
(wife's family in the PRC are casual and infrequent.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Given the record in this case, the Administrative Judge's favorable appl\
ication of Guideline B Mitigating Conditions 1)Tj
0 -1.375 TD
(and 3)Tj
0 0 0.933 rg
9.75 0 0 9.75 42.3262 259.5 Tm
( \(6\))Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 42.3262 258.75 cm
0 0 m
13.806 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 56.1323 255 Tm
( is not sustainable. )Tj
7.638 0 Td
(The Judge's favorable clearance decision is)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
17.506 0 Td
(arbitrary, capricious, and contrary to law, in that)Tj
-28.488 -1.125 Td
(it fails to articulate a satisfactory explanation for its conclusions, i\
ncluding a rational connection between the facts found)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(and the choice made, and)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
10.384 0 Td
(offers an explanation for the decision that runs contrary to the record \
evidence. )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
31.821 0 Td
(See, e.g., )Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
3.832 0 Td
(ISCR)Tj
-46.037 -1.125 Td
(Case No. 97-0435 at 3 \(App. Bd. July 14, 1998\). )Tj
(The favorable facts recited by the Judge--such as)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
39.518 0 Td
(Applicant's solid)Tj
-39.518 -1.125 Td
(record of service and his circumspection in identifying himself on the i\
nternet--either do not readily suggest refutation,)Tj
T*
(extenuation, or mitigation or have low probative value. )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
22.271 0 Td
(See, e.g., )Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
(ISCR Case No. 04-00109 at 5 \(App. Bd. July 13,)Tj
-22.271 -1.125 Td
(2006\); ISCR Case No. 02-22461 at 12-13 \(App. Bd. Oct. 27, 2005\). )Tj
(None of the circumstances cited by the Judge would)Tj
T*
(present a serious)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(obstacle to the PRC from exercising control over Applicant's wife, eithe\
r directly or through her family)Tj
T*
(members in the PRC, in order to coerce, exploit, or pressure Applicant. \
)Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
28.715 0 Td
(See, e.g., )Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
(ISCR)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Case No. 04-03720 at 4 \(App.)Tj
-28.715 -1.125 Td
(Bd. June 14, 2006\); ISCR Case No. 04-02181 at 5 \(App. Bd. June 7, 2006\
\); ISCR Case No. 03-10955 at 3 \(App. Bd.)Tj
T*
(May 30, 2006\).)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(The error which has been identified by Department Counsel is harmful and\
no argument has been presented to affirm)Tj
0 -1.375 TD
(the case on other grounds.)Tj
0 0 0.933 rg
9.75 0 0 9.75 141.6309 82.5 Tm
( \(7\))Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 141.6309 81.75 cm
0 0 m
13.806 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
0 g
/TT1 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 16 52.5 Tm
(Order)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
60 0 obj
<>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[110.0 530.0 124.0 541.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>>
endobj
61 0 obj
<>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[385.0 447.0 399.0 458.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>>
endobj
62 0 obj
<>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[42.0 257.0 56.0 268.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>>
endobj
63 0 obj
<>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[141.0 80.0 155.0 91.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>>
endobj
12 0 obj
<>
endobj
64 0 obj
<>
endobj
9 0 obj
<>
endobj
10 0 obj
<>
endobj
11 0 obj
<>
endobj
77 0 obj
(file:///usr.osd.mil/Home/OSD/OGC/JosephLM/_MyComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archived%20-%20HTML/05-01820.a1.html)
endobj
76 0 obj
<>
endobj
78 0 obj
<>
endobj
65 0 obj
[17 0 R/XYZ 0 527.0 null]
endobj
66 0 obj
[17 0 R/XYZ 0 501.0 null]
endobj
67 0 obj
[16 0 R/XYZ 0 491.0 null]
endobj
68 0 obj
[16 0 R/XYZ 0 425.0 null]
endobj
69 0 obj
[16 0 R/XYZ 0 399.0 null]
endobj
70 0 obj
[16 0 R/XYZ 0 360.0 null]
endobj
71 0 obj
[16 0 R/XYZ 0 173.0 null]
endobj
72 0 obj
[16 0 R/XYZ 0 134.0 null]
endobj
73 0 obj
[16 0 R/XYZ 0 54.0 null]
endobj
74 0 obj
[17 0 R/XYZ 0 686.0 null]
endobj
75 0 obj
[17 0 R/XYZ 0 633.0 null]
endobj
4 0 obj
<>
endobj
xref
0 79
0000000000 65535 f
0000000016 00000 n
0000000141 00000 n
0000003658 00000 n
0000177987 00000 n
0000003536 00000 n
0000003591 00000 n
0000003738 00000 n
0000003765 00000 n
0000176736 00000 n
0000177074 00000 n
0000177116 00000 n
0000176546 00000 n
0000004502 00000 n
0000166744 00000 n
0000158663 00000 n
0000151932 00000 n
0000118724 00000 n
0000003868 00000 n
0000003914 00000 n
0000003963 00000 n
0000004195 00000 n
0000004035 00000 n
0000004067 00000 n
0000004099 00000 n
0000004131 00000 n
0000004163 00000 n
0000004727 00000 n
0000004766 00000 n
0000009634 00000 n
0000009683 00000 n
0000009718 00000 n
0000010346 00000 n
0000010794 00000 n
0000117756 00000 n
0000118080 00000 n
0000118404 00000 n
0000065016 00000 n
0000065283 00000 n
0000029922 00000 n
0000030195 00000 n
0000011163 00000 n
0000011444 00000 n
0000011770 00000 n
0000030694 00000 n
0000065895 00000 n
0000118924 00000 n
0000122647 00000 n
0000123080 00000 n
0000123356 00000 n
0000123817 00000 n
0000152132 00000 n
0000158888 00000 n
0000158934 00000 n
0000165446 00000 n
0000165770 00000 n
0000166092 00000 n
0000166418 00000 n
0000166969 00000 n
0000167015 00000 n
0000175254 00000 n
0000175578 00000 n
0000175902 00000 n
0000176224 00000 n
0000176631 00000 n
0000177526 00000 n
0000177568 00000 n
0000177610 00000 n
0000177652 00000 n
0000177694 00000 n
0000177736 00000 n
0000177778 00000 n
0000177820 00000 n
0000177862 00000 n
0000177903 00000 n
0000177945 00000 n
0000177324 00000 n
0000177158 00000 n
0000177473 00000 n
trailer
<<26462356B852DE45B702A3DBD00A7027>]>>
startxref
178160
%%EOF