V 2WUAC&$m$Zזt* ,|娎|}ZugIUDIDM AHfB,lo]c=WTݳJzmcl`(
[^M#`@!M\kȻ_q/b v !k#H "m8m+ %I;ByHHKda d\ȤcbE9Zn$xUl: `pf<[}T uӃa_]]6R#\^P7m ¹˙)Ҵ'M7GkZωo\
k=H
4w֨u=\rx^LA
UΉ 0U*JAE&*?Gs=s9qFߊܒnk)EO# UaW8 nCz#!qon~/^\K(8y[ReܑpxK BCASAW|r3lsao
Y
˝
/PQlAUB.
_YYWdݤj9p
UC%=ʣх
Hm_{kxnk:۶vPAG6m-#sd'UIqo"ūmWW ڕ6ࠋ{Z Gb#31<2B
@`aYS65*Y{KW9ORs 1 V-BDWxP5Ik )_ ++?S.oя,+O}0'U,@NuݡR)E٠KD'!뢛{CsUz|@E!eYp64EҤ&MՠY]6=}~ʍ6 l*W
.B!$5>\ W!~qE|Ke ާT 6ӌٯ[toM~i늳
DZJRZP3<? O(H?9̞*gμ)oPop?K^n?."mGP
q[6DgU% pcہ4Y:-nY&֨PBJfGwu~; '[!(&Y o ** uPi9(5 z j{bu^ O>~lGTktcLD vnH23i&V:Y`sYc !k,ɬ@C` ȴ}yCwwqި7kU)U7`Տr
aw٨_3eNap?W{pW?wmHv-ym $ Yf" P <&gfCVnW f
VhEF$x"=7q՛--LjwG廽nET *OCvx:&çy|=hՔ*/1Z&ޕ-W4Kh
aCk2Vpfi˭5nxzAYpHkB#;-5Pa IU dR$܉>" xܦwYM^k(^*ZYVgGx2}S}s|.K"]3|χޥWAKyEdj_[M a~%"TJTDxhG2=(X!n SSrm0)(ST-Uk}:H#/:NMFUnS] [LJ9 &rެ}:a64煽/f 7O_I9=D9 lF=r:~1쏰t
9ۀ]k {Xd >Gqg*=A~ $8PTH|D}x
d9Q sPg 6̱DRRhsuf_൙[Gl̩(o2ds3=49#utaT>)Z)mHCr'7xf P [PnP>!7R%1r;է} ce/=d'4]a8h 'ǒ7.>ۖ}4ߵ 0Ƒh<ǕhZn752D_4B4QTΏXRHh=X@.=b/`kx˹[a$Ǒʧ_wOɜ8>@*6t: Xq%1<$2VFrSI\WYs猏C;[Qq8~
L 5Gqߜ;-vh[pK~;STeN.e;4j(iN$9XW<~ IZVxY^
mh$ t/Ǽh<
I9'v;ؿK
>E͐ [ (ަǸ=+ An [ Eyhlۯ,iJq*зz.36ciix=x 7KZZkjV#'Oh+B;p:?0*]d Ou<,4Vvoc> #ψA}t]Vi eQ.5'\v `oC v
/p0ß\hÌr#Ucj9>C 1JqmQ ̋Ys/Q O ʎ;9㝂}ޝBj˕PrCx'!~ QOvc\!yl{l=^oWh8<TÐS1 ǽF5 Z?
:9T k&ρC7W {/]~ BZv~~{ 7A ic!"u%}6ӱmN,nLo>k'w^_
x^.UUW^Mbh AP0DB$ <3H
JUR"-Vj(:-X[ PUNkA,L}Z:XQH'9y|w?gm4(CsrjEc zj^2PKOS G n/Z`o15 ySoX
(gqxs/囱/S Us{6sz{im?>mq lF;]kg 'LŪ)UGϪ j-D6OsjgկP4sx+˸NFflM|"CWmڜளؓGLB@V<^6؝ F9--bl9t;#@N bY(\Y:_83-Gy>"{ QRmJ\ ;ҹ-uG1]?"=Kz5;wEM?!~ϛ-F2! $gcpQp ۲¬22y5{Xa'
WQ4mh?sY3K|-,= "zug ;fL92:8
ҟBX!f_ݴjϜ}R&
wIPc:%
bhۍ\4yOj]檚|_K ʸp0Y s/K#֎>6y #^WN2t; 9w˅\2~!y49V M%cL)NjDTi ƹEfkɫTa febmUqMѯorDpCQԃҏ96ɺ`c= Bb_Ցs#Yyfm SRirj{vDs'6V*(Oo{uHW.q0}F9?IgecVG )PH0ҍ=Pi|9ɾQrZ b
HNdUoDks0gP,[(Dty'k" )T']3lsQ#WGOƊmm6k9kXNM%$$F ?V'Y^گr&* }Vndb[F^&{ynp`g{| zyG' BQn ^AK
)85mg;OM^B `68EŻLrIS <:;:t3Z˾8VBpI<'x325 M>y2Fڠa
8 vP ֆk-l`E2f m?;uMmR+䢜h
`[⠌vgK7i[w FS[iņm e{Ltp{L%E^=$=
sL @
B PD 4FADRyYA-i Z<`@q> ! BG U|*3vآ@+jNksˍmw曵
2L~KnD#m:B e^MJ #M1ۦڒ8_ ,Vܽϝ]o Rٸ. ᖫ۷Q1U:^H_( b_i2+5v-%fzGm,1=m[. 8O1GnurkLѶY=m>%F#W3ԡ8X/Ҍe10a]~ Ɵ'6l
cT s_aTa TׂtnMel^Iw6h+\S 6i+O !O'No6 _o^OFߔruFj6XSU ߾JwĔ̚s|6#Q4( ͆&KuWޠzuCvZl SȗK N r26vV?3p2*Cp}dֽO^kڮZ3:[qƏR+},G'!#_Y
P`w@U" =e, jCI[9-YLu~'_Tw'yY䔬=˛$w:ڥײvZ6ސh_.C=!w
muLp~ /IXj*+^Tm-qQ^3|~yآk:|*O/ҥTtv
pw'W+ Vgt}a
jLm~!Nw67g><{g }w"Z &a}7 b'NǙk07{[Ԟ0dqkV?{?g{,23^jmnʮ Iu~)uN/3?b>g_$At - &`2(t4&
y/' c
?|C6ӲN\.RP 1` $ox؏K}voAV*k 뷟2Fdy3Xr$]Q6 ǪKGOzuD[@ c$x
EJyKI&O&ecJZe=qzo7S7SCwy03MR)|\37 f_h5S w#2m4㑷ڥAy ?E
4 ?GL"oip'd 9o
ok:m\
NڜZi^SoTs#K&a%r l _j품__Z)B}[pIkX'~F=Y!)Ri%xd`ZRvEL
2ߓ2(h@sO!ǃ)^/Z=%|8
{ ȉ䴊n.a[,Cme44A_0#="ViY *w8= :SYUnH
{Ek``IV ŧ
Fn4y;CR,NȽ3fqDZTOE|D^ 7I#pd\L"Fp np6p,4yr]'.-úVNd"/Fb띗3Xa}>iG%~<ێtw*#waFgEL%!j< H?q \k J?s0mDǑ~xX2'jW XefhEbfaK 8[,&TR5γf5 /d\!526|opZ ߩ$M[}X{ʌ{܄T>;9oΉe4ǫCl1mdɡK}HwN_F*# }_{p|d3s'WElV'%HR7O&lǙR}1ɍ!?JUKhmrb%'~8}ZJ{lǿȃ@xc)l<$0Bv݄9/_V*ԮRuk0FAڢZMETDv?Huhʪ
}/ -Eiҵs}{wf﴾xnWڟ_X@}UpU"qWw\w|Iݸ}mٶq&DTlcxpJ]/\y^˽5vlozlP(]1~T
W9gQȻP yqgE:/H>\pܗx* +
;>/X}"G9< -[*[Ơ?؝,K.H_}]s(e<\0 '> ߍnj,j Wk|.s?{2 Eg1+&ϫ|?3 R.'YN_R^>߹KS/U?yC^x#$V{m
W5Qq| Lr \?Ul߹F7 Umkq? u11}w
1=m"5UHf#*vo×xks?I9-mfu26˳ ( kO~<]NT3VnreZx~@Xe`ۍܷ}t&|},(hgS~_د{Ъ|xJ'>ǤSPZ
WzER5i[Pse]m70S4.+\~@p}@x=;#tCy'= b,d~Om.9O7 'n9odYN,隃Xh)gyrqݰ XK 41TZh{ [/^p~z;S Ccm^ f$_}; *!چ e84C߳R`0 `0 `0 `0 `0 `0 `0 `0 `0 (kq *ypu/~7@1~ pNSOa;S LOۺq[PR\`ImV;PYmN{.h ulCsb1Q@,%)D\[2~CD
s_nO!S E71I~ZZuQ;Fm vcl3 8b 2,c8Jg? zUq9)?<· ODӝQVćk'fT^U.Ϻ mc}d=9&坐վ][T꧴G4RVj{
C8k&j]Gb=vhO˯GDPA͢WϷOGv2cɖX4X" KSXFևò=ݓJv+i%[YTdu&~ FX_Jcݡ ;T.UJ,[ xlG@/b=QL:zBIXB6:á?, Y&Ne2֗X]~}Ѡ)51IkLZ"V0he8gA+Hjɚ
͍ d"h斎۵kEj_'ze/sF\fήȝcE6s| zջ9Ox8d{ /Dx}̀WA\aWҞW匘]S_.~K8 qRjkHz'̺uW(kLϝHO8|wKù
s6`+Ks,'NqV\" b7J xqPLjuW9U1MqSVNI28rgPCuNy\%.sC %|z"Ҫ,y<,0qѳGiUO=Xb?) 04CWR~i%oS'mLO|ܖߢ1|No}^ʖE2]-d$DPOm?]_> b^QFrLϜh03y ]:Hs \)3+P ̀E%U,g)DI]ُy09R~Q=(zɺ3+|k^]tuL KHYlUҹV`Zi3rzE C>EKsy_G]wsv6:^>[L,Ī|'UuϹcnlR` \HjG X(kdž%Κ@(v0ǕVM
h44uDcv%l]"Ј:m{L{I$q(1$>Z/#KNJ`vYޠ:嘣En#HbҍU u3Ȣ\1?i> E/Y`Xabj\eׯ4UQ*^n*}qmh%z-N˺⫞5[ٛnio`G>s 0*aD1տɞ{O,-]M>vXʞF :r~kn%+xzyy:=ggg{7x^uy%/nZQsI r8D;(qDN2Ij7dHHf*h|5[9l{JdEkn.Jۦ_kӯr4cH~0 z2D o|@ Tq~
mKگgwݖ v>8>]NIԲ4M.L_Ns?}%{(#41%q蒐 N5*zpBt %kȤIjs6F5Y6HʆIrAGaݨN'G QǠ9QGDXӥ;'Fczǀ_٧G;< c)
G a=Ur>-Oug ua'$ɺy 2VךE$ d^u %_cQh[ xE
zV jM&xBWEwj $I _L=+ENR7sS9Yfr k c Pv/mm++meUJb)JAPN+3E7x/aC V=*GI1]R)o_.Zvg1Ż|+y
ЁN`p_| \;ȭrk:b߃\?ICrR=UPզZ3uu ^) ''[;DR 护XAgS1:IhPw&( (}Z,b`w@$E> 㼓
endstream
endobj
15 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 3/Type/Page>>
endobj
35 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(96-0457.a1)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\
ved%20-%20HTML/96-0457.a1.html)Tj
49.74 0 Td
([7/2/2021 3:57:40 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 687 591.75 78.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 753 Tm
(Jeffrey D. Billett)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 727.5 Tm
(Administrative Judge)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Member, Appeal Board)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
14 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 2/Type/Page>>
endobj
36 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(96-0457.a1)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\
ved%20-%20HTML/96-0457.a1.html)Tj
49.74 0 Td
([7/2/2021 3:57:40 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm
(Violations Mitigating Guidelines: \(1\) "[Applicant's actions] were due \
to improper)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(or inadequate training;" and \(2\) ")Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm
([Applicant's actions] demonstrate a positive attitude towards the discha\
rge of security responsibilities." )Tj
41.439 0 Td
(This contention)Tj
-41.439 -1.125 Td
(is not persuasive.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(It is untenable for Applicant to contend the Administrative Judge acted \
in a perfunctory manner by concluding that none)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(of the Security Violations Mitigating Guidelines was applicable. )Tj
26.022 0 Td
(A reading of)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(the decision shows the Judge gave)Tj
-26.022 -1.125 Td
(reasons why she did not find those Mitigating Guidelines applicable to A\
pplicant's situation. )Tj
37.23 0 Td
(The reasons given by the)Tj
-37.23 -1.125 Td
(Judge reflect a plausible and reasonable)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(interpretation of the record evidence, and they are not arbitrary, capri\
cious, or)Tj
T*
(contrary to law.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(\(c\) )Tj
(Appreciation of mistakes)Tj
ET
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 32.3184 622.5 cm
0 0 m
120.633 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 152.9512 623.25 Tm
(. )Tj
(There is conflicting record evidence on the issue of whether Applicant r\
eally appreciated)Tj
-11.413 -1.125 Td
(the degree to which he failed in his duties as an FSO. )Tj
21.523 0 Td
(The mere presence of)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(conflicting record evidence does not)Tj
-21.523 -1.125 Td
(diminish the Judge's responsibility for making factual findings. )Tj
25.482 0 Td
(Considering the record as a whole, it was not arbitrary,)Tj
-25.482 -1.125 Td
(capricious, or contrary to law for the Judge to)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(conclude that Applicant had failed to truly appreciate the degree to whi\
ch)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(he failed in his FSO duties. )Tj
11.138 0 Td
(The Judge relied, in part, on her assessment of Applicant's credibility \
and demeanor in)Tj
-11.138 -1.125 Td
(reaching)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(that conclusion. )Tj
10.274 0 Td
(As noted above, such a credibility determination is entitled to deferenc\
e on appeal. )Tj
33.35 0 Td
(Applicant's)Tj
-43.624 -1.125 Td
(appeal brief fails to meet its heavy burden of persuading the Board to o\
verturn the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Judge's credibility assessment of)Tj
T*
(Applicant. )Tj
4.443 0 Td
(It was within the scope of the Judge's discretion to conclude that Appli\
cant's expressions of regret, remorse,)Tj
-4.443 -1.125 Td
(and appreciation of his security failings as an)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(FSO were less than persuasive in light of the overall record evidence.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(\(d\) )Tj
(Standard used)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 32.9922 489 cm
0 0 m
67.652 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 100.6445 489.75 Tm
(. )Tj
(Applicant contends the Administrative Judge erred by evaluating his curr\
ent security eligibility as a)Tj
-7.054 -1.125 Td
(computer systems security specialist against the standard of an FSO. )Tj
27.633 0 Td
(Applicant)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(argues that his situation has changed, he)Tj
-27.633 -1.125 Td
(no longer is an FSO, and it is not reasonable for the Judge to assess hi\
s current security eligibility based on his past)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(failures as an FSO. )Tj
(This contention fails to)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(demonstrate error.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Security clearance decisions are not an exact science, but rather are pr\
edictive judgments about a person's security)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(suitability in light of that person's past conduct and present circumsta\
nces. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
29.951 0 Td
(Department)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(of Navy v. Egan)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
11.414 0 Td
(, 484 U.S. 518,)Tj
-41.365 -1.125 Td
(528-29 \(1988\). )Tj
(Evidence that, in the past, an applicant has failed to properly carry ou\
t his or her security responsibilities)Tj
T*
(is highly relevant to making an assessment of)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(that applicant's current security eligibility. )Tj
35.561 0 Td
(Here, Applicant's past failures)Tj
-35.561 -1.125 Td
(as an FSO were serious and, in light of the record as a whole, provided \
a rational basis for the Administrative Judge to)Tj
T*
(have)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(doubts about Applicant's current security eligibility. )Tj
23.175 0 Td
(The Judge properly resolved those doubts in favor of the)Tj
-23.175 -1.125 Td
(national security. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
7.137 0 Td
(Egan, supra)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
(, 484 U.S. at 531.)Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
-7.137 -2.125 Td
(CONCLUSION)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
0 -2.125 TD
(Applicant has failed to meet his burden on appeal of demonstrating error\
below. )Tj
32.268 0 Td
(Accordingly, the Board affirms the)Tj
-32.268 -1.125 Td
(Administrative Judge's April 11, 1997 decision.)Tj
T*
(Signed: Emilio Jaksetic)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 16 252 cm
0 0 m
113.32 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 227.25 Tm
(Emilio Jaksetic)Tj
T*
(Administrative Judge)Tj
T*
(Chairman, Appeal Board)Tj
T*
(Signed: Michael Y. Ra'anan)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 16 150 cm
0 0 m
134.795 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 125.25 Tm
(Michael Y. Ra'anan)Tj
T*
(Administrative Judge)Tj
T*
(Member, Appeal Board)Tj
T*
(Signed: Jeffrey D. Billett)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 16 48 cm
0 0 m
120.645 0 l
h
S
Q
EMC
endstream
endobj
37 0 obj
<>
endobj
38 0 obj
<>
endobj
39 0 obj
<>stream
H\n0 ) ʵC*q
zzWQ,]WYT\ ݤ6(Ŗ
4QKں4Mr">g*Y"co ]17*?SD=Қ&Dy
ĥp|>ۅi S9ΘYj\3:ɤNu@^ $8$Y x- a`Y @/ ` ` 8 ӡZDD8a >Z|4hG Ňn=tԣ}jKӝmWo+ {
endstream
endobj
40 0 obj
<>stream
H|T= ]{/ .64DyD@
#"(v4ػb r*x >}oٳgͷ7@ āez/fИ
W
5k< ȘѝT\t4? @ø wM
|X!Jq 6yO9*W6)Ce :tpL) )}B#e hb-(p cG,EP2Q*ThL>jQ;r:"Ҥ*ʪPM,dAK "Wژ\oO]-%(K M>7*Isy[,TWVx=J,[|*WAjkV:uoпQ&M4oQV۴m|YN}/o} ~ na{;*Oߘ~4p!Ceq# ?:aLؤq)'N4yifĬsϛ`K.[+VZf6nܼe;vfڽg :|'Nf3gϝKm+9W!JM*$!.NY鬬d ALߠ6\7Ǜg̏-]-,ɖ%Vb-e-m-kdխլ5 bP↻iT0FM`DqFh3&:cg 3N;~~-ZE[sDZgX2d(X .Ng30ߧ ̤+P,* x^RAj]USԉj C>|oxy{?+f C o+SHs9՜.9l!9Tzb
/`A8Ʋw H%8D BjVČ5/ב ,r6 Z:8 9ܔW< {s%{]rV]*I7`.? yyGsϝk [7q4r4twsuqv|sﯚ|+pui9r$9 w,:9-sM:jvN\vv-[m-SVZZ|mV}=0'G~3$"tTTKjLinʓ"RvSU`U\2~xqѳ[?-bhZfܶηm۔wԿ^T_Y+BZKe,@HG_C c ~B,b 1 0e x-4BLT8Gi4foR\IC͢4R:#Q1*Ni^%-E2h -eVJZEi
u p(6FDJPIB[5\2Ih;r4vNʢ]PyXC}Ty~:?7pt2ta:BG Cd l:E VR5[Mx
u7FęVy%%Ob{x/|!>G( C} Oi>g |/eml+W_|omw> #~O)?o~q<QRaGsD +N%?y's BE
M(&URCe' t.eih$&h&DsB|$Z֢h+ډcAk5՚i
;]͡kw4omJ01%ƚLɦqxSD|*> E'A ^hbuQx_xHBw'xqww;NR 7/qηFzAnfEnvCnG~y9\ <,ȣ<.Oȓ^ ?ɟ%s9\_owS%yVyQ^u5]]5u-][uu=]_7
u#X7Mu37]OjjjFjLZƩ*L5QEIj9usBԭtkFSL?/K^w SR WSuP RuT Sm u})kLϾOSL\ RoDx+މ@^| 'G.IR&CD0Y 2Qf"JPV&BDIN9('ܔR>ʟi/ JTPBTPQ*FTm?Iwַm}Gү SS
TJS*K(ʫOaNIQ4&R4M4E=4M=S RRުw>O3;,eɊ=l8 [3pFę9 gls?9'ܜr>_t&pd.ȅn]ȅb"w1pq %vKei[2\q]vpyW*\qu5:\q}n
M7&ܔqsn-UZiqknm ܑ;qg]эq{+zpOŽ~ܟ@VA<$$lP yQp02rp`cTd9YH
FJC(7K)Q[C1d^WHsK h38 R gΦ0`~Ive$b8x_;8 e*\ʕ;Ϸ@o_yr iWL5X zߝ=`UIۂ>H8q \hjn5% TdN>=O3\0u:6!p"N@_\۽N7{.+8
p%sj^(r(5[Ya` r5؎ۮm@5yB&Li' Dv "^?{qsM- ^$I(ɈYcǯ$!a`n)F@ pF$~ŕ8oN"~1f% xz\ǑȨ
sr94[ו2zIC\A䍶4]$!ѻAϋT˚HiI ԗU|O6Q{ͣ&νiD&
~"
=t;&NUOV~:A'ަ
poV:'Fi2)äBi9yp.( 6p vo4WkE% !x J~qˠM V#9H#l+b[zP^P
䇤_8]jÆ$'%<(!>N b7*2"O3C{ܽ[ݦ*R0%\f$x
%AKz)Jhr ch09FfwɡXt8ԵfVShƭ\䞐 L\QN`2rV\^'>=Gϩ螒L݃!C2"F "]zB)#ZwҙFaq8<)e^I!Xư2 k7T5&V7R7L}ft!K=ӈ\ϨVgr+썑>W ͪ|+47E'{ ֯ǃo`rjˈQiPRJ*tҌnW?}:m|%na=~}W\o鞔ޝl HI/ [R~q9H(0r
ul$ _y0f39F /4jj|ܮߺtK[|}D+8 e#)HLGBǬ@}TJfq[B7y2`sj}s6b;4QvZ^qOTqOt @n%t
sUf +:Eܚ}dj]}$#?W}lى}>v|wrm'Ɖ dI)4aSaMhY&Ud0A-9*VU Nl& mݪMSJ)RDbs`dgx?~syO,?iHO=P;5w-V@fj9h χSFǖyC]\_ 2Y/BW+ # xg}+3 K|
w [ 梌G|Q#o f;q`D5
L Q ;c a5BÆ2 Ycm/UN6& o/RUv_Zņ%m+H]2CEƁ`lf &gA 5[3$Yf],uU;l?3[̢ (V&+( g4k,
fȡV8 v`kC19>Ͻ* wsIK{- #T{k ._PTtFW^9X5IԮ5-Z=08#
O&i_J(26%}jgsS/@>PЎV:l0rH~Ahxx9^cţ<Ǭ!#3p,əgj;'#` x8ymqueU2CW GFٛмNseT3<д> p-+1%#.t0@< (9hP=M VI:"X
ݘ{o?
[Tn p_Aʁ f{.="j\ba25 i
/_3
&zǽWn ?՝`4>|>{w|qX5TY$;)L5v c499>Ug($7UN'NAU
x*EBVhܮT BC EQBx;N>FxUY
)E\-9)dd3z!uf>C y9:dZg<)6hţ2\aST WN)VY,@/ C:WTu.Ws@_B㥛 / Iiĩ㠏 `guƄeZr:頡'<= iz= a~y2Uf<{1 wgCfujt?de'k$@yÙ'>eYPvm-r0zy&'Z ϑe"a,c2i%pb ،s3Zެ{K|Y5݇E+gv/]F֟m
^ O4?{F B*Fek>n>=rQw _\itjmSn* F{; $LFCp[јX UM !+j`)I,J6*
5Ɓrt"[Sx GF!}*QRZk-n(䢞T;h lP}iF_}?3Xp,W}@'p 2yd&9C투{_b~s 72XÐls_E]EُQ (9{!0@j@}\e[6
!fSlVt6=|1-u+_}{ז%|M-':;F}hzq;iCh`Tzg ΡHu̹ ݧpwJRA{)1!)2d]mgx/ձ^{w%Rl 6r;&&&iB)Mk0Mp;@)m`Jii&5̤S~tSiihL +if9prx%I"~3|ax>POX4O/gg fZZq
rZz]"$ nK.hm5 \*6 =4N3jx!>HH,F\q@6U9!B\&J!!χ^t}*HS Hm*M.f1."AD& zM*@ 5Z@Yn8rN.KwZ{ ?AsD/@$@WZX >D fuG-TIч"n\)>BD
ZFoo9nd[/ ڑ\h
?zzеy[jtMٷ w1st,nhG>tH ɢ
.>N5
i bU5ifu)LzZ=!#0
u + u)Ȇk )z_%Au 蜑oc6>ԓ ?[ 'vo/lg' Rl;~;v$s3W'{,rsHOɷ13ޙ';Fy\,0ZT%9G{~ȩp*勪 &6QDfT#jRTq ߯ tb, Л@fˋW^_8,D(Ű
x Ѫh5q@
l2
إ2Qs.1 Re
=7 :
ޚ\,F+R
]h0,p=:?o?Λcѭ(xm .(_Vj֖:^t*\j)N' mX^nI4qEc,E3z|وvV碛^3/vd/
aw+ 9]T>,c>3i-" ƾT+u7әLgA\.ևi5u%Oϭx+M|?m 9 99lsö\nl
S9+ѕɞ vBc:ŀl œ9RKl$V,"zِ[c2hnDQCRd\\zw 4
r
vvKŷ* ri
eё7#6ͱP
؉H$k%Ԁ۩mN^=94jCTUnۻ[`K7}wc]kߏLuOӯ7 Ukg7yݑ=rdg2 ;bZ:C V%:)p+Qi.Jk#Ef͌UVtWkpwWZJFzKdɲd[쵱B`[m y&bZt `C4aL@&1@COLt:pЉK0M#rʏZ=gw9wVn OWz%# R)*w(r_yJR[
R(HSJHDIAFT/" yeAOI^$)E^zM{l˓R% O{0`Sf w l]+e
GjRjg 4vnͦ"4A6d0cfjBC)}@P&U^;QJ4l*Æm $'H5f" 6Ҕ$س.ﰣ1ʕM|UN<) [-GaPdc6c|LG}$ r^|-pK3F#"CC9tkR~T7тCS4uEGxS ih A/20h ODepS-hN]O=ʲ$ <^TLF1rS,joVqKK>g#,^
rH^0 X2nXU[(6|nA) AZʹ2VPpvܒh_jkRmX1SeƳ1!-~-SW;RG6
чӁ?Uc o>~ 3\i
pZ=!}~N]Ԯ ;oOg)86y!j&Fc@UUWc`䑏"IIbG ;5 K4 ə@q
W'y&2',PhL2)SbK7oL| C.]~˧'z)acϕG n{ [t7BQ,JAxx8ccJ[ `=]7N%'wB p:w/"8H%C!AƱqdVO_ Id /!c%#H!g8{\c,9$ !:b$"$!KL%U E$ 8tۏ)NrRmgE~M1yG#r6<=fYJEm&÷-v*a rQGHK^+2zRF
)G W6ZKïDOAnňKAh$]a@ z(gMRrmR")QF sQ]"P|,.ZčGoE6'H+*n jWՑ) $ }r+i(_n{+,^ߛ=Q֥jCKsiӷE3㲶}-e_ :rQ@kI;{ױ)E_Qgujl7X͙@U1q(G4:c
n۠Fq" %xSJZYo;C2B $]Q#v6usïĎkvb;q|c;ǹȃAxCh(
5(Y:m]J(]"ncLդR!6mUGI\
l}>߃^_`E "u\
K@TtY::@S;%tN_7b1QԖBO.ʥ%фeQ.4A1 qDt5V/2!*,fElrȡ2 mL[gC$P3gQX%oX/$N|1橹u̾ M;mZ]D $cY-y[BE$A ud֑oo1H($3R X6K$S)%-MP l-$f ֙rD=oψ& i5@z4yJ(i
Ҳic3X T ^UL=C٨I͋'ԓgF=p֗`L c J#=k!ysq;Y$&&׃TpLM/"(>qdJ/[*-̪15K'!O[?*}
U@ \6Tz{$N
֢g8&Ogd` ph$LSv ᭊho\z",:o ֬f7 ul΅s텨,$$m~,X{e2?Zk5%E4Zs/dk}nw_ '$ea UOXŦ%Al sYv+E+щIz&^s<=_Ќjjb}q[qۘTSrA<dr5Ɏ' H_? |Y)6ƞl-ZU@c ~<-)|כ9ܑ
Ṙ
z
z
UƔ[
BٯPRTV
UBL#t47:fIĪ|jRJq\< d8RcT
oZjDqwJI'J;~c@°l ^Wڔ[-FP3Xv[+$¥.
5&k
vo)Qg:u
$ "G|)D"Hc{쳦qC
4+ YwWƑ@Ne+`/y8эQ]mb3=KWd E*ط*T~
I``*XS`k=`pw~GZo@`75hZy G*:kÕnr 0-9ga^}h 2S M(Ϡ-j o})0ChU0w
槠{A :"C Ύ30?@amO~7HJa*fte3G{Gtqs~G4(L5#)GHk1Ώ
Qb~DKg_6AªԡYr?{?_:Ͻ||4~{tӣmit r*H^
f%$NSZ̄NA}k,= +c?{u;3
dcU@ ( :8+i9)TlBg/`IXf?ݖ)_fBɃxPT -$.CK4u0<'wYni ߛf{ Zl 甏}! \. `?q C& z?/'W7e9hʺ=Ǽsc2F 8D4D u^gYO=%-_j8d>ٯTg %* wĹcW4|>sFdV>1REJƿ V*&TiL|`2VC*6VaEugs eD]D])UI9G. Ak_;9FI(o\+t n!wUG{C2hx@d NM8X"q83? ć*WP#ôC\dpѕxԏFGA:Zre8O~.UyR.8yՋg7{|>UDM?S+O IiX+S[%g-E@ELIj%fb%WpN)^Ǔ2WjBnDނ\S} |$jg4W }}(G14J2{03T(2e \&-Bet/
#Smr3ɥ|e 3g{Թu,{<[ 丟aSKRVE)ŋr +7vu{"}I~s,Qc>DC錕̡qbxڛPV K٨okLu^rXJg bibIbe4Mn;@
ڇ?$ޅ@s!3OCi8"?4 fz G4u oƓ/x WC
>tds\W1bO1h$uDWJ=K2v]s/?plqcS'OO9rUSԷ8gm0O ոӨys)k ?usr$8oW0OkQ\Xn7WyB4'm0\A\&8J ,uޑbKsY Z*˝Tuw/sTM5Hͥ\.~k"uqW岗__i_{>wB{Aq*GeHws tׂ]u&-ڭ 7F.}{(VA#b/Czا ab+{hTGUJCGwM[SJ HV捓DQO)!ǔ Nmf:= Pk`G=rzфNJ
p̿ ޣ-@=:I>%:#@
e|Uy{Y G}}p[ z0ӔCac!# ϫӊ$ wD2ffcFp uGf 74[!9
weFmuD#ZxQHZӌPZ 29Y-e h}=W u'A{@mm_Fg܇ uٹ] AA=րEPWS!BBVC~,89
.owm$|f{5tQ] ź}nqujAw W \p4<&[O |N?A=%F&y M` 3/`Q6 @w UnN;i,K$tHB\/ޠ^*vʭV(
оvYIjfO7ȍa\8~v~I(%5|TqH"7tP,$e0MSO3iaȔsMjs "ы談'{zܑAt1?OXQ{D.V3yK$Ч6
nX tTXSZ5 Q7ݩRS{},
|ME8㩿+}j$P.[gb zM=Q+H?ÿX e2IjFd4oM͝n ӽMp֨;Yk>;<Ac)Jkڻ&_ eG=s7 "Y[ Áj TFX::B} za G@W״oY}~ǫsmk뚖c![,C1 ϵ(ݞ[UKWA bd
rðuyX״1 |I~}ꄾC #"?.\9E@q`%Wg%4 G -N%Pw$x(8ʰ > iaZ?;JDL] 0~ xp7=X{ .F NIm|,ZZp <ˍ b<^,Aykތ
U!j
ܑ߳F#gYF]T?o.Au&3Yb +aVc Q}MJiZ%j0h5a$_C}i&|6+4GuG UQPg; QY(O+5Y U虀$1iny<=`ه&4deS: ٗ3JsYHy9foZ`f?RƻuL3o83?8xS ڎw9Tj݄-|:l}
* C=sk@ǀ`2 od T.rc#Fs1Z[;|.:l.H<ȕimL!6. :u3t>Z4x j~k/~E>MR^|HΛחg+h碌 |Eβwp nV{ӽ<E;. +Zw|=A.ɾ1[` (K1?P>rK ŃWe팃 f[ }5$c?>އ 5 , sf)
ކ
]ҏ+֘m.kxφ4@
=`M4 |gŘ=SzO^b: 5^Th`E6Ĕ#!ȹ0?eMp,S_J
5 a|(m>OhOm^&<g؟h
!VS"CIZ/}rKhʎWp 7vH@
|;.3Za/lSic7/ _f, wLia Q3u/9AmEL!b:N0Xij%sZQ0^j7ᮤ_ZSMuW:; ͪs\b%&)[jHE
ngch6cv = H}d-d d]z@SSYycMxx. p汞7g*Z;4MO uY'Bk1iECʬut1~Xڲ GawdJC3
N. s1+o5w<_4(
`0H@ηg R>M8; !
PTcPrCK E
u'B)w(uL'֪:K| z
uIϞrsW'ŞC~,ZgEӇ%;E' :+w N mA?KKx' YwY;)^C?Ԩvȷ&1ivxElr=輧>`;G_!]o̧mwɗ0QVsq}
q3Wu,b}9
Tl0Zg,+/sksJ{ӷ 2Dk`vqn>pq_-TPÓÆ1P{g@uiu#ѝ5vζ4q%5rߪЋKsz N R|'_
cm^=ҼX^h i~<_gWdlv\- (c ڦ#nT+Us" v2&y@
~Xe \}Ђ p:g ѻuj'Y_T{VzVou]3~~#2 GX48**QDt1wW>sdXJdM qZ^+Vm(*
YC|lr:%d)"5:UNaWwX:#6H
ϻ C9A_RC j/x=Bƙ9Gd šб@@ b./C]y!ILwA x/ՍyL 7Ǜ |/ Xru yibHenI \bÉM-bSb4;i7 ÚYd8!V"کD"HD7Uk'|Z W^yP.ˡ2ɌVI-F=7),\c,
}{2uIyky[úrghٯEG9AsTP :P]9,}qē
$RS[>cd3a0"&gmO]0'pcu'vӿ]AQQEsUNr8 砚'iUἱ6-#_c W˸./X9 ]U@轖Ko8oR یmڭv&YT <aAR58&_QKԖH 5%V/>gQw ,`[NCNW}Yes]} ĽwT,o\Wsܧ>smzq
j9_ n*0[_ į @^*+:$r+srScj -/;ڎ.):dr >z5b8U+U.;eѓnn1^n:Zlwx0X~
_ W ]:#)XL[i6kCBX!' ^ŃD 1n}_i{:DN3sNB r7q[ s:8]$] `0 `0 `0 `0 `0 `0 `0 X@L#1kF+$"pnv esY:{uX, òK!M4DqNNl! mt+²`²CӰ" >$$SFXl"s0E~KkŔ$O{$Pw6A_csokٚ2Gy#8v) r sPBϊ 6k})uk%#aG(b yS0#)
تRǒovG'߷EO:ɷăgvK,|:^]e|o)e\rAGc$u֙7˷m~#39t kKآO>c}Pf 02D<#% 3LK]X4!-UNJLzL uif:,cǰ ӧ3)>u@(YKSAV#gD O]Ttz`yG6
;?%pHCJt4OEӓRr C~FЏct<^O29>Fb=+X&?߂¿pG+:RV/C!E+ z
X'+ǃ+Etd^k!"EnG ZU0 6 M`_@A8/
^
2_F_OM?av`
GvD H
fGAA,?kƟ5Jʸ EX2\k̵Jx#y jx opsO
^yX'ֻKtkׯ: woBwȝUyz]${,@{c@x7`H?5)S[b{Jv+
{w*i @+{jF2ƘMj5u*Ջiݝ ݤVBB/ZYhQϹ趔7WiWvlh Hxamʟ7r H*B'O>GeU~'FHIۨmƍZ\yo?*Γ-̍*(9)A_^vzT AwZR_ț`E]> B:T " IC*.eeB;SdP: :AnUYmk2/kSנsF24%mb
X3 wYsuoI'| Q* (3 Ax: d9C_A {
]@qF?ġ̛ɽ7ֵaԊ5a1TSI
A .\ȏDtӵ:_|/Nň_ &/3=&m$'$xD?#QI nI x+nN[?P
_yXjSʔ \$9 2Y?djG'|ÔH4gp5>d
m4B>\o}B
h("L K
< 5y52Z6 Rt&Wq=rrt.GwjA&Cc5ɯ/I`-#?%o^"? D~,$7 /
%9#O/˧ɫܧXYm%y Zq%)HsɾRg\lOc!@ʌdx% $=,IKƻjy], L6fz,y*S k>kmafkm5lUB` B V"pVw4*B=9A_ +0 2<Ⴍ8h{Fya
bF a r >_hx4dQm~ΰvZ/G"h͡#Pu= /iQg|)<4b
}(EFwd;=^R, XhqOwl@M}D!'1ھ@4(,"FYJmFy$=OXRhqf-8 =ƹWfgj(FJoh|cs~vJc=ЭJs._1B. PWd}b+1h'bTe.8>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 1/Type/Page>>
endobj
41 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(96-0457.a1)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\
ved%20-%20HTML/96-0457.a1.html)Tj
49.74 0 Td
([7/2/2021 3:57:40 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm
(hearing placed him on notice of his right to retain counsel, those docum\
ents were insufficient to cure the procedural)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm
(errors at the hearing. )Tj
8.524 0 Td
(For the reasons that follow, the Board finds)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Applicant's contention unpersuasive.)Tj
-8.524 -2.125 Td
(Although there is no constitutional right to counsel in DOHA proceedings\
, an applicant's right to retain counsel is an)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(important right recognized by Executive Order 10865 and the Directive. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
29.129 0 Td
(See, e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
3.332 0 Td
(,)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(ISCR Case No. 95-0300 \(February 1,)Tj
-32.46 -1.125 Td
(1996\) at p. 4 n.3. )Tj
(Furthermore, "[n]o federal official or employee should discourage, direc\
tly or indirectly, an applicant)Tj
T*
(from retaining counsel. )Tj
9.553 0 Td
(Federal officials)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(and employees need to be sensitive to the possibility that )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
29.771 0 Td
(pro se)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
( applicants may)Tj
-39.323 -1.125 Td
(not understand or appreciate the nuances of statements made to them." )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
28.454 0 Td
(Id.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
( at p. 4. )Tj
(Even accepting, for purposes of)Tj
-28.454 -1.125 Td
(deciding this appeal, Applicant's characterization of his understanding \
of what he was told by a DoD employee before)Tj
T*
(the hearing, the Board concludes the totality of the record demonstrates\
he was not)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(denied a meaningful opportunity to)Tj
T*
(retain counsel for the proceeding below.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Applicant was informed, in writing, of his right to retain counsel by th\
ree separate documents: the Directive; a January)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(8, 1997 letter from DOHA; and the prehearing guidance. )Tj
22.965 0 Td
(Applicant's receipt of)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(those documents undercuts his appeal)Tj
-22.965 -1.125 Td
(contention. )Tj
4.721 0 Td
(Moreover, a review of hearing transcript shows Applicant indicated he kn\
ew he had the right to retain)Tj
-4.721 -1.125 Td
(counsel, that he understood that he was)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(responsible for presenting his case, and he was ready to proceed with th\
e)Tj
T*
(hearing. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
3.499 0 Td
(See)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
( Transcript at pp. 6-8. )Tj
10.302 0 Td
(Moreover, Applicant did not request a continuance in order to seek assis\
tance of)Tj
-13.8 -1.125 Td
(counsel.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Under the particular facts of this case, the absence of a formal finding\
by the Administrative Judge that Applicant was)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(competent to proceed without an attorney is not disturbing. )Tj
23.884 0 Td
(Nothing in the record)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(indicates that Applicant \(a 40-year old)Tj
-23.884 -1.125 Td
(man holding a technical position with a defense contractor\) was unable \
to understand the proceedings or was)Tj
T*
(incompetent to represent himself during the hearing. )Tj
21.216 0 Td
(oreover, the Board rejects Applicant's claim that the Administrative)Tj
-21.216 -1.125 Td
(Judge made a statement which implied indifference to Applicant's right t\
o retain counsel. )Tj
35.892 0 Td
(Applicant's claim is based on)Tj
-35.892 -1.125 Td
(taking the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Judge's statement out of context. )Tj
17.51 0 Td
(The Judge's remarks, viewed in their entirety, do not demonstrate any)Tj
-17.51 -1.125 Td
(improper indifference to Applicant's rights. )Tj
17.564 0 Td
(At most, those remarks indicate the Judge was trying)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(make Applicant)Tj
-17.564 -1.125 Td
(understand the nature of the proceeding and his responsibilities during \
the hearing, while trying to maintain her position)Tj
T*
(as an impartial presiding official.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(The Administrative Judge was presented with a problem at the hearing. )Tj
28.77 0 Td
(The Department Counsel had provided)Tj
-28.77 -1.125 Td
(Applicant with less than a third of a 235-page documentary exhibit in a \
timely fashion. )Tj
34.991 0 Td
(Three days prior to the hearing)Tj
-34.991 -1.125 Td
(the Department Counsel provided the remaining 170 pages to Applicant. )Tj
29.298 0 Td
(At the hearing, the Judge offered the Applicant)Tj
-29.298 -1.125 Td
(several accommodations \(including the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(possibility of reconvening the hearing at a later date\), each of which \
was)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(declined. )Tj
3.887 0 Td
(The problem was not the Administrative Judge's handling of the issue at \
the hearing but the Department)Tj
-3.887 -1.125 Td
(Counsel's)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(handling of the document before the hearing.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(2. )Tj
(Whether the Administrative Judge's decision is arbitrary, capricious, or\
contrary to law)Tj
ET
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 28 276 cm
0 0 m
417.035 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 445.0352 276.75 Tm
(. )Tj
(Applicant challenges the)Tj
-35.753 -1.125 Td
(Administrative Judge's decision on several grounds: \(a\) various factua\
l findings by)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(the Judge are in error or misleading;)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(\(b\) the Judge failed to apply the Adjudicative Guidelines properly; \(\
c\) the Judge erred by concluding Applicant failed to)Tj
T*
(appreciate the degree to which he failed in)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(his duties as a facility security officer \(FSO\) and failed to demonstr\
ate)Tj
T*
(reform and rehabilitation; and \(d\) the Judge erred by evaluating Appli\
cant's current security eligibility against his past)Tj
T*
(failings as)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(an FSO because his current position does not require him to perform FSO \
duties. )Tj
36.966 0 Td
(For the reasons that follow,)Tj
-36.966 -1.125 Td
(the Board concludes Applicant has failed to demonstrate harmful error.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(\(a\) )Tj
(Factual findings)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 32.3184 169.5 cm
0 0 m
77.654 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 109.9727 170.25 Tm
(. )Tj
(As the trier of fact, the Judge is responsible for weighing the evidence\
and making factual findings.)Tj
-7.831 -1.125 Td
(The Judge is entitled to assess the credibility of witnesses \(including\
the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Applicant\) when weighing the evidence, and)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(such credibility determinations are entitled to deference on appeal. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
26.878 0 Td
(See)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
( Directive, Additional Procedural Guidance, Item)Tj
-26.878 -1.125 Td
(32.a. )Tj
(The Board has considered)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Applicant's claims of factual error in light of the record as a whole an\
d concludes that)Tj
T*
(they fail to demonstrate error. )Tj
12.162 0 Td
(The ability of Applicant to argue for an alternate interpretation of the\
evidence does)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(not)Tj
-12.162 -1.125 Td
(demonstrate the Judge erred. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
11.746 0 Td
(Cf. American Textile Mfrs Institute v. Donovan)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
18.83 0 Td
(, 452 U.S. 490, 523 \(1981\)\(possibility of)Tj
-30.576 -1.125 Td
(drawing two inconsistent conclusions from evidence does not mean agency'\
s)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(findings and conclusions are not supported)Tj
T*
(by substantial evidence\).)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(\(b\) )Tj
(Adjudicative Guidelines)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 32.9922 49.5 cm
0 0 m
116.971 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 149.9629 50.25 Tm
(. )Tj
(Applicant contends the Administrative Judge erred by not applying the fo\
llowing Security)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
11 0 obj
<>
endobj
42 0 obj
<>
endobj
9 0 obj
<>
endobj
10 0 obj
<>
endobj
44 0 obj
(file:///usr.osd.mil/Home/OSD/OGC/JosephLM/_MyComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archived%20-%20HTML/96-0457.a1.html)
endobj
43 0 obj
<>
endobj
45 0 obj
<>
endobj
4 0 obj
<>
endobj
xref
0 46
0000000000 65535 f
0000000016 00000 n
0000000141 00000 n
0000003644 00000 n
0000139980 00000 n
0000003535 00000 n
0000003577 00000 n
0000003717 00000 n
0000003744 00000 n
0000139539 00000 n
0000139580 00000 n
0000139351 00000 n
0000004380 00000 n
0000130797 00000 n
0000096113 00000 n
0000095168 00000 n
0000003847 00000 n
0000003893 00000 n
0000003942 00000 n
0000004133 00000 n
0000004005 00000 n
0000004037 00000 n
0000004069 00000 n
0000004101 00000 n
0000004580 00000 n
0000009416 00000 n
0000009465 00000 n
0000009500 00000 n
0000010008 00000 n
0000042120 00000 n
0000042387 00000 n
0000010439 00000 n
0000010712 00000 n
0000011159 00000 n
0000042999 00000 n
0000095357 00000 n
0000096324 00000 n
0000102434 00000 n
0000102863 00000 n
0000103139 00000 n
0000103579 00000 n
0000130997 00000 n
0000139436 00000 n
0000139787 00000 n
0000139622 00000 n
0000139927 00000 n
trailer
<<94C403149291AD4CA7CF4AC420A5DD8F>]>>
startxref
140152
%%EOF