%PDF-1.6 % 1 0 obj <> endobj 2 0 obj <>stream 2021-07-02T15:58:08-04:00 2021-07-02T15:58:08-04:00 2021-07-02T15:58:08-04:00 Adobe Acrobat 17.0 application/pdf 96-0575.a1 uuid:f4a67224-59c5-4f9b-b166-123f662d918b uuid:b0db0eb4-4f27-4a92-a326-cd9ad3fe11f9 Acrobat Web Capture 15.0 endstream endobj 5 0 obj <> endobj 6 0 obj <> endobj 3 0 obj <> endobj 7 0 obj <> endobj 8 0 obj <> endobj 17 0 obj <>>> endobj 18 0 obj <> endobj 19 0 obj <> endobj 21 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 22 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 23 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 24 0 obj [20 0 R 20 0 R] endobj 20 0 obj <><><><><><>]/P 18 0 R/Pg 13 0 R/S/Article>> endobj 13 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 0/Type/Page>> endobj 25 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (96-0575.a1)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\ ved%20-%20HTML/96-0575.a1.html)Tj 49.74 0 Td ([7/2/2021 3:58:08 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 749.25 Tm (DATE: )Tj (July 22, 1997)Tj ET 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 54.3262 748.5 cm 0 0 m 65.004 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 723.75 Tm (__________________________________________)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (In Re:)Tj T* (----------------------)Tj T* (SSN: -----------)Tj T* (Applicant for Security Clearance)Tj T* (__________________________________________)Tj T* (ISCR Case No. 96-0575)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 17.628 -2.125 Td (APPEAL BOARD DECISION)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 3.947 -2.125 Td (Appearances)Tj -2.016 -2.125 Td (FOR GOVERNMENT)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 250.7061 493.5 cm 0 0 m 110.338 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 243.8945 468.75 Tm (Michael H. Leonard, Esq.)Tj 1.041 -2.125 Td (Department Counsel)Tj 0.276 -2.125 Td (FOR APPLICANT)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 259.7002 417 cm 0 0 m 92.35 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 250.8789 392.25 Tm (Charles M. Shaw, Esq.)Tj -19.573 -2.125 Td (Administrative Judge Paul J. Mason issued a decision, dated March 18, 19\ 97, in which he)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (concluded it is not clearly)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (consistent with the national interest to grant or continue a security)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (clearance for Applicant. Applicant appealed. For the)Tj T* (reasons set forth below, the Board affirms)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (the Administrative Judge's decision.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (This Board has jurisdiction on appeal under Executive Order 10865 and De\ partment of Defense)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Directive 5220.6)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (\(Directive\), dated January 2, 1992, as amended.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Applicant's appeal presents the following issues: \(1\) whether the Admi\ nistrative Judge erred by)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (admitting various)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (documents into evidence over Applicant's objections; and \(2\) whether t\ he)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Administrative Judge's adverse security)Tj T* (clearance decision is arbitrary, capricious, or contrary to)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (law.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 20.032 -2.125 Td (Procedural History)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -20.032 -2.125 Td (The Defense Office of Hearings and Appeals issued a Statement of Reasons\ \(SOR\) dated August)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (13, 1996 to Applicant.)Tj T* (The SOR was based on Criterion G \(Alcohol Consumption\).)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (A hearing was held on December 16, 1996. The Administrative Judge later \ issued a written)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (decision in which he)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (concluded it is not clearly consistent with the national interest to gra\ nt or)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (continue a security clearance for Applicant.)Tj T* (The case is before the Board on Applicant's appeal)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (from that adverse decision.)Tj /TT1 1 Tf 21.225 -2.125 Td (Appeal Issues)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -21.225 -2.125 Td (1. )Tj (Whether the Administrative Judge erred by admitting various documents in\ to evidence over)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Applicant's objections)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 28 79.5 cm 0 0 m 551.016 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 579.0156 80.25 Tm (.)Tj -46.918 -1.125 Td (At the hearing, Applicant objected to the admission of Government)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Exhibits 4 through 11 on various grounds. On)Tj T* (appeal, Applicant contends the Administrative)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Judge erred by admitting Government Exhibits 4, 6, 7, 8, 10, and 11 into\ )Tj ET q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 12 0 0 12 16 39.75 Tm (evidence over his)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (objections. The Board will discuss the challenged exhibits by category.)Tj ET EMC Q endstream endobj 26 0 obj <> endobj 27 0 obj (JAʁ|S.) endobj 28 0 obj <> endobj 29 0 obj <> endobj 32 0 obj <> endobj 33 0 obj <>stream H\]k0+e{QIZas69vŒ! r< '!IRVϕ&H`j 8`.xf`;3{I,q¾r 89NaՓ.[:wWY!o`n,G/mzd)T6wӼ5+>g--˘qWys| \viwD4ۅc9cΈw;=X2K|$.K%s$Jʕ+)W"7jgE>}(vPAbE9hvA,MY4eiҔ9+67jn!#]rtMXE`9ʮ endstream endobj 34 0 obj <>stream H|y\TG5o^p "xÛxDF4Y]#F%"(ITT ooDOfu\G l#~ɐ󋖭N%,V!##NY @aVdC_Wu}!m ~H¸Yc **6:"Q|PGPzplbs>Yy.1blRL'aES>[HQ`>wFF'i n<B4 C//ۈU[)1_5e#;@&zt6@<*9ѕ茴th6Z?O=j(DxmFE8%:W-oھu֫ߠah VCiҴٻҢeZyж>aҾCN?o>?g?E}~ٯ5p|3$vh\|BI#FJfOv⤔SӦH9kv/XhX"kevΪk֮3߰q97oKmwܵ{}P9UNb";'oWtyܷ<\6vo$Z<{Fy,"ׁ>#.:F;3xez-/1߽l: ^N.Ϻ47N 論=t l M@xgEN$'FJ<*l)"_#Bqqgpbp(A1.xf CD$`1#o o9H$q[OC<^ʤE!$Î*ZLKh)-C5Ĥ#=VPl!7r'U/ZZGfZOh#m͔Kyi+m)fIh7!/E{iy&_ďTh? K t1GԀq*FԘ(NP!~oۤdtNStS*b* tJ;ԄR3]iG(\'O)>E|9>\VkZ YhȒeedwك/E.|5ela+r#|=~6~t5Nedj|u̟8ss!p0;T\ZZkglk7}DuZXj-RA@IQYߙN/y8ZtNѩ:M t6qkge\/r%_=_xw֫ѻ5y^\u.tNԯzг~Kzz^zYD\/+J*F51zQ7zKtLl,r2r^oz@wzH{^gOs'sNTNtLlᶜy%X}{ao}_ep  Cp(8G(cp,pN'qN)e\s1w܉'׸3wq.ER\qUZSn. szSi.|G#AStn9Nsǩqj:ipF4;cB(HPu X NG$B$CHTHtȈܘWd;.@[ȅ<ȇ(vPd.sWg,|&~ :@G @Wo<Gx  _xkĻ# ŔA=4@#܃&h!D6 ) d{|Dv=cR[@9X5x!'ɩ|Q$_U|]ΌVxr\,1;[-׊"^n[vS_3y FyT<+e,ȫJVZ([PZSJVi*Ce,ڪ'Iy)w.8Ejq#F]*Wz׺ 8i0~_sϩt.EkѺh}!hLiXp7Mr6nꦹnfnu|-ta>Q>\UWIw_ wsJ/Ii. "% %t"XDZDC UTV\Y$RRa)f@p΂gw|s_ݹ3s~}ٺkݳ[(Bb Z9p 6Pd@&F vSER)z>P{q).K)b518NwPjKm R{z:_)#K=L]+u$JN='TM}Q@iJD1@ D_яFhCci}J3&DD MFh:͠tʠ4fK猧ї4Wb_c<_m-lk efQnM{*<*~jD_- \N+i5h 6Q6mZim5o[v{XBli~]ʡta:Btqʣ|:ATHETL%TJ'3TFTATEtV5P lHgLW*F2¸4nda<Va,ǎ8W*\ip3ڪjfW*PPA V!ڥJR*E0ZiѵtmmZ5\Tц1uL]yӼeihƦZEHUQzk!&0!s19f=_ tIr`0K*A 88! ,XyWa"`] .h'/q* v wuq~DBg UA5 2`BlG0n4̷%ęu88tdO NO@ЙOG\[j$|ySww<~`YV)c_ur%g>` %&ޛmT&‸ q=v9(m&|yU9V9x%N:8y<X=6ؖ3K|Ɋ*$>{gWH9/ T-x! ʄ\EV%skr%\]oWh6 >\Clp6¦& f \_xKgc/%ϵ_!DVQw]v&'#qr&@!㯆fd8q6tlT1T:*c+LP礅EFźU]7 mJ9 f[Ͽ>UQGNNNA z` 2g@C98낷Uڿ&\d1:ڱߎGS +zc ~kVGFV=oeRVfx^g`9N5V f ֧r?a+C}4~ WPOID E$+d /z9ъQMN#*a>>1za#V,'Q^>rw:SFK!Tcw cy) 3T@PӭYbnhƨjξSFS8S2d(/$'dQ,hM Q^uaI bUcj|O\#&2B Rr8VXCRhL-*u-X%IIO%ܭV-^]"6!6V4_FYSY=rOt%=^7:|ő\Ĝ[E Uz51+ic2k\ꎧ8n}ؼQdB%{pKQ;vzFIm9,)R2E See (J[BF슖gfaҐX:ekްeU4.A,K4Qg׆zP($YjzdZI)BF櫜[E`ȣ̤tMP nh'SIXz#Sq/Gr Zж]ɆZ4$iޟ A7"`k":ZoR)32ɱkI|06Y{IA%7ͭ 1&l6xZI0.:Qs1(7O kHbʺgЃ'1*u 㪐jʏI$;, 5L| |zf=CQL3xq@ŸRnYde45J,5lnxKH!HF+pF&Z3!ocGbH%NQB#p2SĐҩTjD 5W觨Qw u.t<%ӌ4,ӄF}vtsB,Ҍy`^z9ƇiKL=ɒ~, B9xe!|>C%0yFw2oUP}|8§:npXhdnH9 DfAAdGP#|r}ڃ,  {ʯB.ZP%˒\XarH Ga)ƊVa'&-($HT VAD-f 0I+vY)Kz. % M-vb&A& Bh*] zzznxxDOӂ?]ylh'8~eX'Z;D:^S[Ԁη@NF0;# A)tN%ov6ii]2|#-]R㩩am\ /pm_K1a [_rߵ^hW`t G؆_yi %k~/̭KJ5,"gw^XSIp&;~}g_b|8__Ҳdl*a1aƏR,-@a5e4Vie*U-H]5ڴg; w;?A_i,+WoQ{p?ܗ9Ndߔ;K*w3JјK%f%dHəVB[E 4^lMlv!2? -\ `,vY`YoCx?b HL .+sDN?OWآGa#4ͺz0fHFTo}4JOh A b>5imM0s´hOgn'02ye4?g¯F𞌦"lgg׮jG$+Nʊ{PqG5"rCgUoί^/+op`c+מ7~vtYږW5gO͝}̟f;;fXR1rqVK2!ܟ`gCjNԚqbg`px0dm' uyP &B,o.anjsnQX%fDn>)'v0,@mAU!iw3a2&Bݫ;BPAt 2W!߷ef⵬ BӁi;D)0Ai4jNf+D\p*HyJT% ;h.uY%~w cNMkg߯\FN4Ӵukuڑ]._{t  ƮF9\+ErMh2ǂxM͛&n qDž3w\,b%RnT:Dɐ[ KPeh0LzobҹbKg:C}𰞌t"HԢhCRèU`|3 X<#R{^  V@+6jXsWS+jaC VO)<fcQ9䲂.pGxs[?msٸRdr7R1A3'ёzD)$N#>Y,;s\)w8w='} fwO yc='3/zϑJ xpn2$qZNX^:A8m-˒_Q[ ɠFn,Pv^ H.)[KmWӰ=Cߠ?)7t67ceQ0VvYcxɰϳBI8,B́vMeT3ipAeѯXEVX $O v,$km,iF. 8LhSSPE ZH׵јKL5`J|n'nn_{O%E&+#}Iv]ڲaIKu/|ΣJY#ץ7{Ƽ*t/N.h<~P0~+#oM++T Obf,*J7~݌67pL7'K蛋 GfiDTN|_!^!I1׫9Y+i'D(Zk<`w>o6c`_o֝G<%6 @s`x`ze@v0#Xa{W,F(,¦[>ǪfpkIJ[PguzUƕmv~YԚ}wHXOkE؟1$\ogg0qLF0,AE (,UI8E9-"{̚QpdJ2 drEf"W"01#yP5F {cBF?{<6!rFhUqL5b|Ϩz8r\LzRO7*F Bc6MkVm\6Y9m`Θ",=3c1oφ177*M=sŞ<|-je-ܽUdej`C[j!OoλL#$9<83s#φBn6$Ing7nVLUӆ$K6nI%M!IT@EiI ƝwX*˵ #* XqX}w 7Sā]>M\wvl8IZQBW Im(t@kRʦ1YXЈV`!ҎZ֡UB6D:e*4Y~.O9~5Xt $]=c1H.sQEf+8z#A##`$b7M*SMvUI>79W OXR&n3 [`wVk8{f|8f@An܎s7s[?gsBsCH܊#[<E V`mOGhdp#h2Hah}>^pd-DX 2]K]N7*whۚ)+B[ m~J7c9CN,F:q7a2{sdO0la4,`eTs'pvɯBWl G*@2ASısw3B[97;e؜::(7sƓ:wg:o%Z8x++q;"9Sw8b̽}Y"=Xhn8jQ}J]4o<cb4$I*"iicufd`QD uK@pu1aes19=’ 1:]?ZW< Shp'ɽ[CiMS+.֮PRpVR+r4>HaQ_u!WvK00}A`N7v1loqbUI\F+jP1 .y2-k'h$N'j I Z}M}O>Tf7oɧOq%QyjǦMT!pݫj;V=tOL#ᅤA ԁ4Zgx,<¼^o7H S:u8fBxz/q&e]b]Z&yfO}w_eAhf[ת ׾pf ;-bW z|kQComfDN=_zĢm^]v ov~gߗe~]4'R(PI݆jۈv!M:c_HW,yk]4!/4UDGhMIx#q!wOjI:{6jzB Yxj&H";c$ԅ~<8N,R98d 6cd(l܌u/blm}kW XE:3֦ub?Gv#+_uAفƧw\@E"^7 ~uIRKJ+Z獝:0L{9V+^x Hx:/{`+ TLѱ!0 h#'B,}0P[baek,ѣ]@!_P` BSp cg9O~԰xSP)TҀ\{"/eO.1x ފO$2v8bmfv33?ad^eN ާQL)/㭹SQ N-=FEu9nԎg^ G66= YXL5#s?ʤ8B[<`"^wj H"S ;8M; S$ >ja>;_T[sOJJ%䨊TEEJ9ɏ/N4:9Py`0'O}#BOfxs'yOEt+݇]=[gMvEy5iᶳ:XP>QQ"%QIM$!*YMa f5OXVK~Ad Zd]`kC'd%%aթ6 Zb +=14RE0KNkRAD)B+muX5u:NZUOdZC =W?VLlUgUpX"u?/;^rY1S8ȓyTOy/5*-.5kCN=2!AҮΉ.+B|~gqHz؇fTΒ!)USCrCt )!< -Bǎ}LPA\ o8߰eY0eEFy苋R5/}@ٓzr]hGóX`SX aJMv dQk]eA컐+;K,vִiJ:VKu^$ZjAe( \<{h{1sxc6C9!ua%J45Ҭiͷ$xad)[UI*H 2!J%݊Ag:EWE:aTl=w|w?w$ $҄aY`(V# M-HiiZMZP;ZIDm%MЖkKV$ Hsk>/`|]P0tDy,XOLGGɄ,d]P 9PYtG^gVo V-O>_EmVET`ni)*G%\ R!X)D& uDNl=gCa:L&s +HTpjo8:PÕ ^q*Õno0wa~}>;'b]7 WV$ԊZiVJNG;?rlɮJhJMesUBe5jk3w- SM<u>*ו7̉\-)qz^>g.ɿQDuwk% FoX|t-/nXkM+.=Nd2t:ϸgR~NP;[lx{)8s\d^rK ?]j6G.k4/NNR NhN Ja()I qAZr"-ٴ>M)3!:Z7(^8 U`T@Q(EdgkGĸR4 69g 4a ʐ Sqh'9[nOP\j5(`g*F.pvŲaw1vo$=S}mk@0-˝KlOȶ{^x}[L̨>]RRX 5>L;;wa:TJ, ^FW2WnJJlA;)u9ͽdr> w/8:Kᾃ.\)nhΆ]]J٤XX!夊iє/[bZ65 Gm@8=|&ى/@LRNK;3<_ HPEUn_;o)up^j!((O((^Y%+>x9 D^@8wt5ae` 謸E|r͕[- Gi5I` aa!/Y42W('Gn %a0cnAUmzSF"D* CODY>y%EI t ?#@ZvDYpNr'gZAN# w&ȴd?98 VfZPఈ t,1j1=q Ev 5XEhoa܂&4.KKFO{i?3 c 'J:=\:c{;?2hb.ߦO{)z&I&S4eO(s8wiLh4īIROѾb$}L#|a#3و'X]\K @xpHS8Wv/vW \~j? t$²&dC'fڎK#B݋QN1NO͑7Z]VpLX(Àbk |g03 F{>|A"Zk M1C3 p|VqXt߆(3ҭ_YtٚhK֣(ZLB bD" ,GPmW-62O U'..wlvzY:}sH!i}凇<ijkZDݎ#*4//A=Hn"m7#U&}'9|+)#yT83Ύϔ_^T+A8Sr/ LTQɇ|ȫDt孒P.  &@RHP*BhLYj,DA|JqUnT>x-]U1ZiqB%gstB-*xo*}y'ڶЦd4_]p1uV* 7 m rAov%(iI3X{n7liVj>%F<!F,1,n0x6Q%G6T6Klsу/&q_UTwݽ{oIy $$!Fb@;DJ*fglKAlqRRPk['mm'O: :w ӝα֜.j鴩,ɉsalU<|Xn˖] 6@Jx&!.l?ooqnfH| m@{@{-Cέ=2#1Nʓ9-t֔Sv;G'L=;*uN@gғCɗ3(Í0:;`3c8FEVɈNBt2t"nLBiێtorc%v]O]_UN̥tD[C&yA3:<1\ƞIB{L@')Jx#S`Nk$&g,lƫ]{۠Іv<yU~~ɗVic{߄2sj/U}QncJENF)CWAo͕Y)S]໎A;g?<'G~lœN ݍқ X~#Ifv8S[#Uy_:Rruе!>af2LQ25G2x6 ئw, n~6-PʟUP/lϋ$r:rJ9CϱyrOz?-Oe_O\d4&з%j}}S  5>I{ 2Oб}Է }6ːE}wSLGSkN7ip}+B~[moil-uK5InoܛA,5qtq4:Oj|qoؔ&~&ivdZYS5_fY3z;11vADI+t"V`kh?WM?FkҜ'ǜ{$gpKۅ5lc|9hsAʝM;߬ltHIz!zt = `7y&"I'2ȺSX?Ng(`wع>_Ngفߓa 2 #9~0|A~Zֹό,:@{Os hrοÿ45_39&gfޅ6L.fMZYeGwVF$p~)k^j?\eJG8ԥi<ooj>Z"UU*}cx{{8SG{&g\oWܜ.Ou,o\r{ubۤZ1}r{Y{J"/zn%.5_3=v+r9D{㫤\qƊUҗuT1#bZD~3pFdQOVX뽊u(ؕU():Mծվ?}3?s9&Y;5uφm:\ڄF{p#B3Ϊ/dȅDν"ry6bDGy(l#: moP9q#{CQ6J&!x)1NC;ҽ$R>TC7v>K7ѷ^t 2xJڬ $$M?lxhwE=4qz"hqEy 5ߜw&Ԭo:r'P'-ٜ)gY=?1PsomW=;5 :H+#)*~Oڧ gˇ P^'}%;֑B,K bZ[1_i:AyO'K +}ձ"1:5N "%Jy7>;^i>|HQ.QosIӨ%3o}wO: ![$w0"ɇu>#%y?@KSRB8=V}tCFv ki>ӛܜY33 ɻXDk0֙/}|:t|sB$ZA}}Y/પ;] -b%,)cDdFHD"\ fl8tE`@JNE´-u, Cmc]DQ$*mgJn?s}ylӑ|ι~ߣ'>IʝR9ԝB.s?~r,\9 VfLJP']5qFjemc|D"D*ѹCs>Rm?Jyҩm8Cٮ%?Y-ժ[FuOrWQ^59>N<_{39gj1}ܨ]Cɕmref\V ?hWDrk+3s=Mٺf}'˜30W|[oa8SgEc';B6+MMj\{#=,NyuD_xP+cOE sfP=hqtﲯ2ݫ ֘6%1F54F}\*yk'/fQ}6{ȬYYF;>sS$|y3eeY9L3sDS1 i83job#U{{$Vr.vHQ8s~.>2LN$1w(GQPF xqBnSX}gSzٔf wn|;8%1f\f٘Lhvd&-<ՖeByY;~tT#?:*/ʄGG΄W sa&vL(D}!췰/k$wڠ号rny'-G5FP ±m ַc^롌~87c5:&Xk, n#D8Gn_+}^R0יrN089%|v01e@9,ٜT\h;.5$nG;h.hY\i9bD\D;Bt3:KEͽsgba/=Ĩ9}]]BT <[/G}Ed*o#ui=}&;O^#Iw4X Ro ޔMY?!.)H~(4?7;Z5 W0]}VFKoB_OǐGK>> _^ݥ0|>Oʳ04n FF?OH!\ηzD$75O1Cr%uWImgleL54oƈcNO1"{޸Gn%cl;ڱOggV_DbaqwăkP}ohu Ac=(kP{Ѝr{k̢T>}[ҖO/ hy+1mWSYWsmlwiӅ3/KVwj=4}e"v >ͺTe4]ݮH=g֪۵^;;'YYI4~ʴFWK_mk=/7wo%&b˭oC$> ԃWڐ{!x-!8E!W1߾1UC+Y5NH/dYUu1ZvNَu.kޝ{8h%r(ixgb uŒkYf8qKPYޯSM6`iI9 2H~Km!>]>6H^oJ{HcQ-YgU/]Vyy%Of(+01 n"7c=dyղjBO;qGπ z{}o*7[mE77@/Pw\} fx1hpĸ&7g7'ķr?[z7%=oW#bk|weuv6vSXf7ogاH>h+=i#`2^*(cי=>UhΞu~q}euogTNk0^ضZD] ꏒ13,8%[I\)Ṥ;߲rwMjUdKd,㽮[Жv^I)P9?AIͻw`%kkS&K/bx_rKOG݉4{IdK*G3Hm]Y\l+~7Ch5nUMhSh_mګƷZChS t4C OJS bGv0&78 56F- c?zw6%h=1U{C8gbeYC&^e8XA;bM 3HQ]i%nx ^Ng"ە&mw n1f%s2:=a1R HycCdbqh(BUatс) hvPԖڑZ"*J:UV!{ɘ;sپJ㵿5i>uܩ\ J#Wk)EOksX]QAs1 m:(-ߋ8g}=بmP cٸC}wneҦo ΅|OROyr!WﯧrC袧* sQ 5L.U-eP C˝ +ݙ2;}QF̳ yH}b@=$m2fwHVk?_SأwJ}K,5f<6ri|gB;%_d |^8yQ?&Ef9/sRLPFy;67cy*?i|G:GƳ/A}?;0/`x9kp";0|Btӱ:|skb]ww'w}R>w1uv,}t-ZxW>e=aU3di;}b6{Ru> 8&_Ybo=}ỴՔ]T $4,mw泮i&wܱؕ֎%')60wİ#;c&O暗GJY[&d?>1ȍ a9y| QV+$Zp~/YW0SU:;0s(}8;i& 27s8Q=3܆K?iuD3]9Bu66`GthpЌrwlP !k3c{CY)J_SmOҷY#{ab_a,W;$?Xz\X<&޼Tne99+ I꧒x;@J阐؈.W'e2/|I΁Smd\wղy?{7U3t.gCQQEؑ%;/ Yo9X;ӥ(6A ֡=2h4^c7ۤ-yW[漋ski{̽wP шewg>"= Ssg#Α jUl^)"Qʳ 4'+9.A3?J=vNzrwsR$_OzqKZl.dLGm4s*RIh6hϰJݹKgҞo)%j%QV'E-tKos<i.島-Ӏfs18mYۡ%eb3^%Wdo˶1odu#9{24QF4uLJrSf3U #gT LyW_h𬎈ld97U,㠐s?:0gsx Tl)FbSaRB/frg{_0>cþ *L$S#*nt|.B*rB؜\'k{sD6Q/i=m/uݬܨKT}trrA,]M{k ϞC<Ƽr_Gn4:x>K陣&>Uj2/5v }{;%Rb\8c9܋%|J*fɮqŹK:3~4gkEs*q;|Û _:wIڽ??6vg6g঄{Pg1ƿ0'*Emqwg\4TUU)VJmRNFjK*%UA%R4I+.8DEi͛7̎gw177ԬAknVibo"6)b==Sȧ_)`GQ6I>f<,npZ'Av78Z|z1s^'UgqZ<{m{ܑr]? ԁJyݐ ¼suݠYԁB[MCa| U1̛溃7DA#7?/rXSCD˗Mh`uCi>q7BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP( BP(CTߣ]5FAjDUi? ԉC< mxJujh{ޕu?ve/\6w`}\osemF~]A W!we/m2SN'"6@({(GYPqK6 3}ZZ%F8 @wKT5 xe-~֤1h,ƽ=N7(pgh+ߙ}Vݩmf9~ص 9KaqGFt~>A\/ҿP\oԞe7lk!Ja1ϳ<z L>=Ԯ[O(8E)px'0h^o/\d]]cL'ucOíI!GxGvWob+Q)px1:j tYvQp\[U4[)\}uZ>zRE}^I^mQ&tN]ΔMk `-yљ-ZM!(<ւWX-ƥXNt h: ;pq=<e7|nځ=d~i#: 4ʱaղN N~#k`tOanX ~C`ϫ=H!'QC~~#\Ei _bO ﱧh4hq.ZF}&Eize [FOb?l<1`1†i>ހP`e Hl_1aSs i a:&G$h;ώP#ﳧi4{Wxx/`Lj®gc>!mdm9;VPhHHW4ebif1YlZbWr6m쏔gIp 2xF +9vN#wh}~1CV}4;$^3&x#s2I{RwX68"3peTe]SgQy\:!N~01y叆fX'BW9? zZxYԂO C^-{cV*Wt7n2"ӬW =設Ra}ͮ3yD6YU~nr_I֞anF]D4b1 ;XݟbȠ}88 t1.\[pS0zp԰uˠBj F؇$ `YpTyւqZ`sj6v7xq)6R5PEIR51i4RBf#XVZ!dpvU*UR4uϽDWt}s\^E0:ppPQF!8s!ߘOj|Pf@Fc;)մ=d* W9``09.Ms]S;+M55m 3ޏ~(n]xvKǤRς+KOW{=qC1M=͞.v݋wwaS` / "ei1=S[@w@78u|1o8!ok-#BPӑ#);Ȍr]Q{@n -qas9!=S[Gn1* ρ́I Q /# aQ ;AY990 ⣅2`I`ulooQFsk%z07x~qx S0'T5ޚy@1ND_)o *ïT(k$_B'#"O#{: CX ˿ WatX ;a*o"^kU!_!!!g! !w#EmW6t\IF`oV| {,U2U%'42s-fƁZ'V04H.弌'!wԽ@LBKLU>dV=}f5}M@s,i_u;(ߣ(\bf8[Hkaɏ~Th_`j 5FЫL@0kYf.na#< dG* Gˊ(d\RlmK~ %mQ Q" &J2T<$N%YDL1c &YљR%OnTg|!Ndy v^k浶Eto{2E/Jd$Jx[rl60Wgkc݉5_˔-PS)CJrZ ՝/,0]$H]`~p{;{]F`q|ny1AK9Z׺3ELL ?Z64)ij]~8ݵegoJeqʟ2 i}^9Y44$/vKe1t3G݊@x"0"6.g^, `X旞a#_,$״0h* endstream endobj 30 0 obj <> endobj 31 0 obj <>stream H\j@ཞb"腺}[ZwNH[GHq`wC}Cùi!ݺJ.M[njǾ(~uߞb |6𰮻Sz,oC_c(}']S;YXBE_5r{~3ޟ̿'~ӭ?Vi8T,gX[>VEjrt~bóY>`^ +";#?3?#0 o;++s-#8g#a9" altF8#Hg3MB 4 B 4 B 4 B 4 B 4 BLv(PءCa :TvPiVfYiVfYiVfYT86MQx؛7`0 `0 `0 coތ؛7`3f48z3 fgoޜ~w~w~w~w~w7',ҏՈwTÐi?V~Ӧݩ+ 0}| endstream endobj 35 0 obj <>stream H|y|gyL6H6yg&y֦ڛjPK[E4 D,-Z;eb}'"Co'3>y<}yA|0vk2hb/6%&~(\f4i.+̄))=w<{OP{h( 9 \y.΋ ԋ*z耔_XrHLuk(d[ČLJ#Ť'E7O<,8p/?uh|ꖖ3g ; .@^^ Q/G) 5d:)BнK{#`tUΎJg=Q %vϖ;@k~bF0^ŨѸNI+NSׯAu֫MP5[7ivx-Zz݈Z"?lQTv?>?;wkgߟg_~էo|ĤAS 6<}Qv،q㿛'M=u3g͞;wXxҼeW\o)Xfn}ᆍ6oٺmvٻh8\|'N:]3gϝpTXmW+A) 5=54BʐH2L*7?)t|_~ إoӻ $aC4g%P1(.J[JlUsUyx)>,Qp: 2ɲ|ms Zh8WէIu N9Tgs&}$, J9{m5H ӣ *:0x$=7؞ъc{=v]kzAs,pZnen,2T9КWFU uuE޷EZ̶ٚYZֻ]~kUdJ*kk;k[kl5Yow)rI(^iE}Oϼ?F;!_kɾŢ5S/WN +>ibJa8?c*bk )c5b#*Q)qq 'P 8(G!!f<옌D DRA` A*b# o0b!cEx]KsICiIU4Zj8IGzh-%hy'y7-x紒VQ>YVZKh=Hh3m@S(6N;h'P Eɗ&:~Z@{h/Rmʦ}TDCDu.գTL(P p7I!#LGR:AetNQ*ji*3ty즆5ƸtpgT9gLųy\'|^|^ȋx1/ᥜx9٢M&q5z. 7f[y]^EA>ćp c|KI>ŧ\[:.ѐ̲Ng, |/ele_JG7;{|"]t*j~8ss<>6]^,MJ`OLb1 .)*UAшq'beeed_y[xuN):Ut3uVܚ򹘮ȗ2_WjZΫFky-~wty:_B]b _s<=_U^_oz^z.+*:r"RDk:>ZokެUozީww{zޣCXӟp'sNTNtLl\|.hit%q}0#!p48>p"N-43r1܁;r'k|opg]q .eW`)UZ\qM9o. 7K2n~48m9qjƩuz)v&ٹ紋)1B(HPu>@ Z; N'H$H6+NqB.A>@!A[(6Ww|M|v:@G tno^0/\XBx<0x xOx OԗQ@i ;4>>0N#!Ih44=Jho|k憹in ?6McLkjL3AjAfd94&J4N3g4flz')zz~N+5=O", ( Vx6& [w|kwx+o3WifYfy4@۝vk?v~m 8ABLf)aFEas=> p`8(C¡px=`C=bc;{ܞ'=mس̞`/KbW6\'INs)w;F\'%Uv%u\5u7 Vnk`\r.GkѺh}!h=b#ֱƻ n&m7Ms 7r7s-rA>ćceL*0\tu&! IdSdEH[aAP KA@Ha#N $:,qe_Μ#;~n}]ES'n⎸K(KC!) C ,hXȧ8 q\RJe9MD/P;8ǩ=7uN"G3L]Oԕ^nԝzPOzzQoJCԗQ@)QiL40N#5z,39Tr0h,>}@h"M4bʤi4J3CIh6͡,Kh>}ƿ%-1- - | \tёG{QnC?__p+~C4IԆHMSZF)V`6ZEgsz\AhXJh3m7Fi/i|J5=T@{iޢTH t1:NETL%tN)*2:MgRURjZV7; ,\Hx][aXe6<'``Wn8 Wbpg9u nu+[PFp#ucN}t:F3L}8hgEXcZhl#&mfyZu[4=H:Q' W[`"}v-A{GQ{Eؖ=eKm=mr{VJ[ej[ckL(b=MOpNfz2s9u9ǝ")Q.Ί Q)9Q-jDV|'.qU$~uqCdNta.*CV2Df:V01*y1RF1CRU_Տ)U8W*u)2EMU̓ j$#d̕jLɲɲI%cd,eL2I 1/G1㞺~ab3#٘LޱLq3Tq&JśhĨLWI0̤+9Ŵ`Ĩ^o"'Ǽ}EE(U&׬6kgf3/:l0&le_P2Ez 2M,9;X@SPlZ`ʄ&Դ1a&D/sk!s9{5n|}'jƺWdCk`#_1v!zC5ײ0+vB^ߓ:x&u 1y&Bcxѽ͟=w55ײ1u9- tKm=Wm=W7BdJp}Nh؁6γ9T3ԥa5[+t3A<;].8vq$BT߽>@# r4uޘi Pq + |IfZsۆ_b!f fA>6㊿ݽ3Ƅ#|)챜sL 8s Z@M"JS1Z;Q[?-"RJL mi(J(ID*HMڴ*U)UZٳR[3w;>f{o 9̗;M|oEA)~(s0TKY;[~W'.!#"~b)vi'5t:K`C0*s_{ ]Ǐe}o&; qmV]|{ l`h}UD9bEKp[bk%.+dIY/e&P~f ^"=3Qn>X$%*'J CN*QjlCTt:xVI7z䈌P oYپ//|~~e:,-U%eDM3è=qmcD~ o~%|tRBjFHqԧ<d7G=ި-xߤ%pw!wpO;h7/tG^,]cd{>nGaVAF}i^R"P^!֨{nmY7 ⅺF-)w!+~w/gw_oΎm[[_ͽWݳ+jF/[*X.]e9'0Y%3g}pFѤuQe hl"= a T>3ξ9Nꨞ4tqsD ן~(zA֓"uI .;8a$z-LD1eud,˩hFCR7B '=L6C!:*Xdԋ2—~o}@l3 P)1z;L-ƜmO|Pqw&̡Ԡ$+t :ΐ.bNײ0MZe v rrOIbQo;{l\L#hee|̽NIi74t]y>~z~\?R5{NɬɝyZ8W&%26AޭCOZrׂ b%zpbFv1rCw>%ܿq/S1q/dWjIA@HD,_.ğB:^]= hp|ԌM[~($w8."baXےrnR!) Jam@DTU~es1 7Ooj3Z:M=g>h='Im2zD৅SFrnAF17a*An{O{r"(azJ*A95I"S)JUqRpV2c;霛2)b:I{sHXD?UG Iq,)vSăYu$--b+b dcTjqHK6Ύuc"H9OVv1hN\b%RFye(0PSYNA{Djǣx!URR!Ԩod.GUr HM>E*OSQ3"FDB$iLS3M_64 i051oߍ!6ׇZb5]s,*4קe} h? HQե_:X$Qe8nO{:9uDSЛԣ<SSQEy5*8q5Ȍ? |E$Meg fKzΠLcMLYI9NEdJW&ie8Q:65 G.t=v=IġL:]gxC?@y&EfTjP~DJHFwtN<\2?l,N,ӽ^B Jن cI%IoҬ U 'Pw K':$'K . J1MeA>!])=^2ݬkcaQ Ebh NvP^'xM҇BK|8%x!xV݇*rh+KTp& *C-c3Z|σq>TVI>Yo.XWe/xӨ((T\$8-By3|L7%8YqXU`E86ײda\jÃ܎P|5搽 Ig]Ub vKx!*;uoϚ+f9.ql-FxPc~4 ![2R1lP*V {2L&Toy/#dϛSOxVT.>Q<ij"˾(qE*QR -TEJVr1CXV|Iu?,`& ɤP ;>pញ>zY㭷>:Ĵ.>n#'Wb"]Λ*8ݟZ2XЄEiUi>h0s\V:K=@02\ob:Os$~k}=oo.O $wEc:rr?tVʼncŽdƝqjbO C<1m5R!"ϣW14Y;aX◀|x r-H9DG(Ab0es"fkw^k[݄WNjb\WxNW3u6as[__sc}~7ax(l~V<~//z^?,WyTޫ)6hc #eUE=׶(%Mf}} (*DXC@l %YjrmquWxݥ|)nV*Q p@sEEr !Q ,Lи H'1 rƠyOUPkca"WFv+|WfwhGDX9I"hl#I% .6OgM.*JOxm^uCYx ԣ=3)W[ʓwBKaC^=SMoN>_[f4Pyej̽Z[b2k]sUz9q5M|i,始_.Knl+ .) c%Tf(npg``ԯ* ,Ғ JR"D>~S1} le2_.#exd?tt]]ĥ k쾜-hrɎEF7ݮ"8H jZHc86d-hcLY Ҭ\e J~ټ݈݃F"]R&teFp$ PROjP[)6u=n3`؀;hpnu`ϱ%S[_+4'ˠ0cj{2+\sǞ?#9M,X~S$< B~PA="Zw@y<6Ef(&1MBj ^yA TxK+  (p26sV lԭa~&tԽYtx-FkMMkP\~*s袚Du8M q aKÁ^ځ8#ݒ-輨H<4U3Ԫ /@;1p_} ycɠiɮ4Xmnqr t]\ sW*IIAk+,%} o`6蠂9%R=$AΘLhƏ袪iJ8[fu'ɍF%Mp&q{xByRƛӥ j7tnC3L=o5ْL`+65F1Zh5ɛ [CIy@}+bTDtZmޏwvn)"u=aW}!6<ļ%28ܯA{E;,?wCBGnt0B ADhI}lL C8{hKF$vHR膢zGE(ѣt4eʌJ]ҥ]iRJ'fi[؊(XtxP+es Bb P@8gH Biv\[-PPE6P$3fƠFM H:0}2tHLIFNs&rs}}qѯuluSM]Y,a lkH}OgϞ>xz05S>%_=j0}Rٙ{Y= EK(]j2HVB K4a}4ɥi/bo/M@2X VƎ(SQLaȧmV'c0[m#+Lp qa{8f X1b0d¡$5ss֏SF]>tV8<}q?*̥f+.<*Tq ȖxgQʚ|P*?~{Vh6;ddXr8Ĉ[BR^g^)jQu G67SY)9vEvcGv6qξ;l}_lcc;>KJFuš`% ͥ]VRYh5@1ѵBvĀePBIAeҍn=;ݽT+vac5yǼ sjz:n@33aB1x[۵puл+6,TMk2o=ԁ-Kܼq"A {Gb}JZC 1[MͶgJSyMP6jbH#jlFFMxL͋; @,%zÉk *1w4[Mfh)R'Ѧꤛq}gIQF6J1d AT( hʃTTW.iV?i .6hnb1ЧSf@~Sby0^ܟνrPm vv.O?߅џ?g9O%Nn_i1l8p/ywmUmŽaamEinRc{n}*H~ ZzAR7$V8} *nԜћ5p5F*چ+yT?El3uX%Gu6=chRXy[-FMry׊U%j!Y!ɆX-J| •0>/k `v ]}﷾/)ijufV٪{! ETHRO꾾tp5-#q[ڽ{Pƺؒ4wt<u BW!twLAC yhhX䘀'Ba2 ~&/~ٳ<MYI;x̆:f7_ޠ9ܨRe,4dZ cXƲ/wm\fn7𝮥Z_#o+Ԡ}7:v˻B~|;R~^]oswww=*!!,XEb=Q0-1n%7_ˁ@D]z 0HƸQI rJaJƤ `Dr,/-ɖ$}V, Rw#֓-{z,MUhMWۨ` !~ "?27 jnF `o(RuŃ0_0^nsWT|VQ;1[^]j[=Sx jm}gߝ?|+ ݚN X.dZ4nk&P^ikZԉh:QJlrU n$ֱuuړlbTұ6igs2|=]Od}kә5F>}]_|wmE>;+L4+j@n$cXq+=cGkWnCm)XvEF-%H#/FQ6O/v)k<*ݽ͒ ;Z}ڕڇ#G}Gs;ICl~b!;/ߊv߸x|1zE^_)2c"T=¡tc##D:z%T/,Y_Nw/Љ't:hX?O鬮++(L4N\\lrO+tQ? H8/DPKԫ !43D#]jULJ\JNN*OfTLd 'D<$OH~ƀցDc(/ ۵m~ubu+;4{j/~"h Z5CZūTn{:#¹T01a̶l EȦ eBVl(Të+GD#:Xy1Y1U|"/c'_7"`W)c-5r]89Fdr65%֤ CB@NdJb_ HiX1ZPN%rX׽wk^`|]2 ZZfA]tᥛ xՖZ[J6*;TirHAv˲i,׵áб౐#w\}ev}q].4p@/|>Aֽx+@0q Nk6d*1'1F!qIH&1&IB (AQ.;}II*I vY$I䊶{?țx@~4M0|> q#jJ5X ϣzEqE=˸tXĸQƖaLʑ)zěKzrҒX4m(2E6AXʰv=7se> q2cK:[^({."4[,7y'~/}6[? O)Wչ;WX_eH.6 ݀4jX(SkF--cpdÑc(o$N1S4yIu.(O%l^h)G{3ci9)%:TMS䈪9jKKհ"UAeU̪z"w:=:;;e,H .k誆ZAkjSUq{\a=gqв řQ0qdlI.u{Z%Z hDk^Mg^.}IȽ8N/N%RF6*BQH[ncLmZ( G[Z1iVTV2![uJ=mY~6OMufZΜE4B]p- )j3le-A;ZK H-'Q"R~ln2֪XE~Z߇Y!~~ W幇eokދ]Z>c JxǸZNn75I5LbLv'Ym~zn)M7%vbfʲ=f0O]f7%л(e{f=]D`we$7=~4jT*Eܱ$uϛD^1cL]^-5nȕ$4.x?n3;SM sB|h\&Ӏ= ,|9VfLWh )(e9,W.BEjE>m-O(ofg [h`;.i{* 8+{u+vz^vߺھ5QS}sd[\ eK =X-럑]~8ou3o")`YkmZ4%V§]:j3\%FN@v0tEIDfiqub9bYnf b_!)x8B3 Z}VقvCgZ`&HZ !"E[4I(%Ft-T8Ê" NA <!mFѨ9%B HNf-E"Xw"M6.8nCaCyL ٺ"7qOx;VDNylk?칽Xs" {O'ᗷ'wc3_%ue~]qB!j=IzM꟠Khm[Ud`[l2F9QU#{Mip '` Y+W2nD Q\EP(xOEhYg6W&ӔîRp0GiWXM(>5)|j*p|2RCG QM(c-eR4ʂ`WluTӺ4Z&7֥P 9I%_Y;.P I,z$t؃,E}U>. [h]F4!0GxzT@;"#9Kpz$V3kUX[ [!ڄBՙg\\uΩ'Cyd4`Ɍh[&#lIv(!9s|' 3FT>)z΅N㊻U}>[Wto~Yszs`=3'SGvqmbc\Ķ5,[ Slm-xr鲚l=D,+*%M *)4{v^d)H In1i]֡N\NI/g~;5:1vVsSmffk5;iϵhԊU$*[Yq.8 /\e~_-<56 1?8 Gڗ67`["$*╬&T-t{,wbW+[Q{m39.Ea`~,Xhs30:9Ǣb3Ӫ)Swoa|D=D >,&#A}8ۜ2aYwPr#()(JkPJ8T F?./xuH:.'a_ўeI3aWV'¸ >#Z._-s墉hbu01MV7cJgfp2ZNmD(ڏ)Xg5k>aj.ÀXyfC6&"PR3flt)j.^ uBc(J&J&r}F QbX4MPӆI&)C)"wbPn?!D=;(!03(S5Y00l<=> 6ڸF9gV>x=3twalCOu[1@c1:idV2?P ;?2ǯ2ν+ip[80$PҨ@6;;&aIjy~I޵Rfèe6j ù-c1nǘ6n/`+J/;3P L&3Ewr\ ٖ̅z-l_V%Wi Tr[_/}ŒlHIL:bez?}57YrWL%4`$j+˒((I{Е"Z.ծYSvC̶&DsJeǡ1MRKN| ! 'c@f}C[4եy!=Ȱ7a 4N)ߙG:hF̦6,?4;HS$S rfӼD̒6PAz YyٜŚ{2Ɉ7ehhleFI.g^o`^3Ԁ A,X-GŐsT 93\kjKzW~>7盈s. &]~Ysic%&=lSig!g$ScR\hޡ<;k7o],y|4[}fpyVǃ[Nhc}ǃ ˷ox0Ykߐ=\+yYMg&u`}<pOq4n<"c68nl~8;_.>;{ܵ5Z: =H$` m6~mnM+6*TIؤIhL 1UbZVB{Ҧ~}g~Эl͋ (P6#'w TEDDDҠ~I YA$+{n, ʒ1.2/=#ċut)gQcK5|RBT!%B>.$0ׇ !5O3% 1fϏL\n!'?en@P+apF1TٷEI:>ܯ1)_Ṱ@[wgP1K_Bq(Mm(W!n62zJ~O _ZXv3 Sڛ<%Pieܼm7a[Pmp @؁z;&7IF&xq%B[#,lIp$?ƫӤf?}&Cz+<kC;$N^QVIUjkj< HW&(H["b՞'dE7݂IN%c]ue $=Ml;R> y5&\GLCqv4ww) iJQ|JQ߯?׺%m'z:KfW2+?rOϣ:m/u[Cb}/x^m䋗/y*p:fI5<3\4$<=0xN-9 Pܯ+W>DEvi]tAxiV%cgᷝB]~x/{ƽS_qNvB~ $(G#.Yۘ}un7n-F%4.t@d5Es*ۣ=K=<B:ۅMp;B zXtaf8ڤl&L{faoJ ?uRKПNZ8Z6f2j;#Thf:[E|gW|a`Ʒ]\Ts67a:W*Eq00,WE+NBXi@37ng PPZ8=m1K9t[tWу`54~ 1 8u_t3o[z :q0DhtccTȤ@kV4i)@pF1] Ζim pZY4%@'ak>D/Z@]P5LJ~>{_>99;}睝 ؘڄ œh4]TCPW3f2MPժUN"iƾ"?:iL Skg ږ}}{MĊ+^JP&7C~{zg]>fa׭].v׹yM:3L|4)LzqkfRҝ 3'Sߡe+Q߱,'0&gQ:c_4Bt=Xz}H;Ml`bx3a{6 |R6?Bo >x8f)pO rj "rQ(dB1c"})ј ȰEf!̜YGHlKgAN~" K8AE+V }E27NZSoqzǜa`޲ 54UX):NCA %8he1p8"f r(E x;rYHrM(J~lTI-Zڬ1՘vՏUI(n|~}u)ar T :.5!lq"P P(G3N'%f:o/F^T:Б|2W^9J{W3۽JdZ~:_#VN()l,R˔7Ly[NûzQ(:e9=2HFa[nL"]+[dZFYP~zCG7q爿aq m6<E j\?za9_#"uz_mwhXN~thZ+FV"S-#  *]^ ]GtkF? }Y_qu! ケ4~W@JB2-9.d@3h-e$iI/W[²Z1^xdojrw9?5Yߙc{wswg%ƿMı 1 P,)!u h:2Z)Slݘ4Ґ--"mb&4T à{{~>b -}9 }]o?U,Rk~`3CU.o]B810nY>6X32![5J,2D 4VȒG?1=5!M]U{q+c阱/<~^gӋy-F)fKqBPBYAR)[4>E`iѻsت!#y(Ha%(d.paz)S(y@[t,e CA&od zI8~rŲMqz]M'L B@ "p%P&d9_>ݝIZh _^vFӧ`G JFbc5 l^v~&N㱴PNI0y yCc=k}9ldM)pN(DOktzs]  0KtILY9"G7QɆ 1o{y醦 g[Φ4RO>n ᪔qxWXq %8int$) I>@6He)ZE,-8@CjGṁ7n~ދ=@+UXK#?%qؕ08=<'}˟Pwxw@-^Wf{?? ,N#/ A4Ai]n*RhP( +F (nJؚQM@*0LF >+ݿBG$kL醸@A_P#/?Acc-yle'!v*X´"aL1p?f8󬹣z{ /Ha<ɏ1\Ճ1}MCV7&V}G^aXo62ROx+UɌ0c1ߤtYi?N `$,LDwi/|f SY}ߘ2naax Kڛ,gclg&c7MּYfq\!hqZ)IfVz)b)+d&\LPl^*T,@XE%5B !u(m:@@@pbw3Lq6CsHɵYV!k @d_i+ז[JYiIe+RP}Yeࠔ cp ȚJ Cݞ+a.>()<|51eR' :݇LoϼuqCj;w};?ߝ\_n;A}J0aha& !XUx,*q,6}j$RA''9źh!w]Q:XV˹Eu"zeR^$_oгL琛A0:'1icd.U[YL}VJ>??O6I㵯Zdb\|ك.[NG& aJG锤o;w$̆#ِPbE;\ ]1!.Z*VƋS(-S8Ub;%U q5ۍO eh\sJ[Im" ءUʂ+yg+Ty O /ˁ-t䖴l6 T eU#R[]W>PHw3qwaI xļi^hij-Prz"h1ہھ7WgB-p8d>c^z{d]]CNf߼ЕjF|M O|TkГh]"?M(21oⷼjqU={V;8΍;TR3zx Ok&{J9ll̥ͥʃ 7 WXFm :m9?2ٶHޏ|*$+QGK9a#ch!׮ yIr^/h{x'OvvδGvƶU{ƞ1SglOxر;4iJ6iM!mvX*ŵCAdA,-4O7^DQA !-AiA EKhSιw+p2wΜ3wwV&5H9ÔKx1r5K6 5maFX̒ZRJϳvRPʰdۺE?q;G h0'81TwÃ&Ye1h,n;,Ty=\{cL8i2W݄xy>; }F_t~B*,;ǚX°"kbU{ x{h\=>sF%ߐt}czߥz ~^r)"n W8CVT&K uDFSCºAtCƒ)S/L/ rOD,@n0ϱXh,MNDe"df00HEaX*23yLH29_ɉ 22=U2L 䀃LfǒpЌ%u|NCć &4BFDO)xC@'֮kDTg䨕TJVk匡>&ow9Oqejq>V>' 6Ϝ^jh쉁Pi i2.!9`UYC-94Lg^@k!+.̟jn|e׺,K|qլ\q`i7Ns3yDO2{Ã{ώrLf~[u wz+Vr+Ο$EΆsi>w j.:K'Y#y 2q@ԲCkdAMӂ JU<0H)%3+_N!ko lx"{ujiro@Krcyӽ_,(i8K&8ݟ?'΄5+O~p$ F %ehx`>״e4HN=~áJ{UB^AV{&`ܦ4msH,_mr; /^iл_GU9V%Wq󂲽 $Yj kj@-Dd72F-Sncc-s 0g›2^ޮ!LM8({&$wba MI%RK?ʡ8M`S5Uu5ɉD2uvIn6Oq`.SB/AIXR.]Q+X133_cffKsϸ 'tDAȄWB!%'cY@̈%%FJl&WqG2T 6>LO H7˒D"-FoE@P%w(I(Os~=JT83Jv7dNsyC^}E73 %>f-G{eV( W٨kp!)CuWس볽έoNYmq[P})6aRP_‘p2_`$w.} ;DY{. 3n('F%@w4y2pwB,r4T23!k",+wSqx\=ɛo-H@ȄJ[4 Kùd$ҧk;(1M5A54=4*B~qt@d0TjC(+qk#9ʠI PG +" ¨-40b%:6vL-ƌ8N ]Ì`b`#{htR]{d)Ctu냦?=:# K3DN\}E7t+ϤÙJ(>IK1iw4)Ydn&}>>v:Gy4-tf "e%t4b3Kr9q%<%|Lix 3 %vQWqz5!ylcY+.{{X;z-V*د.TATתq^Ϊ&k7V%6M6n56 ?ul\qM Z9(8s˫8zz31?<M=dXZONN/ߨ{kBtt2 ,L<s,K=c^'n"meXaVkBb,Sg`c]]*Ux{q+ 4X/0O3U ڋ-0§jL7xr =npO‘#X4|@ff;/5xycp'1DJF[#E+Y TJ-Ofڶfb%p_L3j~D5d0vm$ .5~d5xEW.ZYۜfqYV;]1TmԚ5)5~XmiW!m?F$1TK`C-q 8EŠ),DxVHQb#,n7H!' S1({bQr9ȱ(XCQӚ}9X쳥 h(tM"ֈϚ4lD֤i lH(kz"c1 b=,˙y>9x-%ddVXv Gtjgthݮu8C6a$DJ-#4V2x kc0Ic&Ҿ`Dcw4Gv6qq|NqgN&>B IT%Q0ʠD]a֩h/Ii:um]fhՖ&6}1RETXylHws}>FdR/~$REN)ˋnZwzSiYj`Z e$[H(ʃU#<]+};fm=G|K[~w*GvhƖ3)L>[i*67۬ʤaa\&mEm6[ՆOYr1ɠ+0!~W'ۅPaѠW")do!˪^bɒq5?B?:GkC؍66wN]/xZ?zFCWB+g}6~cbA2c{^N3ОMlZ.b<>x~ΑQ{  /^jG~K)Lb )݌x h^7$m4&AjB.< b lBNE6O?-l$?Xѣ@HJ]7?n{Oc算<*7ͩžqfh,LW^HMn*[X o,ڱ}%I7 ]CHk@LH &GEK@p`@7qO2{x C&(K! B,#92YETG$VA6niYl۩t ֐d+v|(Qu83ǚ*{cҤ2NƧWŗW՗?ʜ~~Me;0VFo;hLx%Jp@N!f3Jɢ1 %c%&9!4MvP:14f)Эdѿ] 'Ą$|4?MݚZk -b~-@%ԩT6F8#3֫`]mQS8QcsM=:oϕdޟw/l|]f3KI AKaSe@e˹-l`uSP{䚞gzo73#FÐ汻Ǽv=uv{1EJHąnJd*򃆈$D%qܸUEI$h(?B DN];q̜sIg2^dQ6Pffsqų^((z}Nj)ӈ4ٰN*E$<|_|;4k1ѰbEzYf9ttFP |q`elC++':zPѨ -jF+o0z $69P_)EɤGtH&oRyK?Ej|K׵6 G()ד'dm& "'h;^a[l:hܙtc;[y _y|L˷Vđփ$ʠ}[O:e+pʙ `P8*Bǥ%YԧYtsvAtdsA0JxؒI zY y¢y6;JX+ݕ=Q4Mqz5&^ DfsƚM( /)L/0L(˙2sEo} {9o5.אhh&؜_3Z nIj) l܁m5ZFK!a^5;ҝKT` PjE[E&)J hLU݌idR_x[JM9 )2źŎȹ\].C p=D$s=c?g'X0~'oTdI 0}>-9zl7О~gO8&4|wxޤL:e/&4̋*IUB*(8B*Tbs ߨ[aO- #n,;WG `>)x"vegDEѾ0"˹`X[0/ K LwJ^&&H[pc ݵ$]uW l`g6hz8>+W"WmoI  ƂѼ>-9h ܅͗ٺ[f+M#_7y;Fwܢ \*/8̈́"J zCSǭ_05kFꫠJ:P]vPk˘ix1$}x,Oowmǝ.b $,*lr.;N 2ڝRXR|Rf붱ەVշ}.~D؟Of9Yq|e5us1v3«z`|B7&zqϞntnLQIt]SQh>g]TZo1R;3C^VpBL;A)[ t}+LJ97 #ñ~aA 7gF@xc< ?^8gbK2*{89udR6~Ee$8\T)n]]R 㼨&q֥Bajz늱p6U(r&p>ѕu'%$w$-n=Lm(rD ht%ގݾ ˀnjjA.AC]âHΠ!r8g Q2pdaT4圜#U9ˮwάwwfv3;h SՁR $(R눐²v%h%}j! W2R^ yiD#U-T`";|gn.3:;̙˙woKl|W9ts޼b-nhw䄸GEuFb*X j Wƀ*&i:a92bCݮV%o܂mywݠ {I0 kn-\ϺȥNHȽڝv o&yRRͬaMM;^>?9r_3+Ƭ'qHsF{Ƨ(x,b4j'UjoLA eeX)Vڶ-%ts,ˁ2R2e^O^*d%-ˊmYSyX%tMEwHISIEW1.5 \8Y^BߠtEoÖV\{ ! te:j#6ꄂP[?(Wk# N6hKS$z@1k+ܴYe @`AeYkݢ-&R $?aYQ65;/-|9)% i`(pX^́#`@!G\{Ȼ^f./ v!kcX)$IO!T1p:&">B/0ib/KNL&]t!C.c"Ձ冱(P=Ex]l$`rf<[}TtӋf!!1tefo6}4e{w7F@Qn|nLJFt="R: WKSi]=/kz)OQ?F՚0xaD+LWR4RU삩Z%TZ+P!JyTP=o`JBЖp[w,efD (F٨7B*" 8(L+*R]Z({_|bf}t5c1FWͦȚP=2ꦮGG Or&~_5zdA@$"^E#GTjOՋY()H!S$p3P.*T֕( q_Y[Tb/7=xHQ}~Qz|qpm矝{kx8Sku}lvPa:maZF79s鮫StUW;䫯>wa.%xlzev';" )pT.]|ISSmhyll 2AlǂTPHk%֯ D\3_s# DrP\Nuؕ'^HAXE(n\vMӌ^З[lƷҾ Ed>N@k%rw(Kgtzt9@@eh ?!\(GspOn9o^9\$cǞe 9y $uVV*&].҅Kl F3&2 ـz'sbI4ifv9waoWlp;*PH\C5НTOer!STzynH/<󕷨pAl,?0I5kxZߍ}XUsWNs3Zf1\Z1 {?}3=ǟS^^~Dj|SE8 ŒB!i[JC VSrA> '& \2Z '}z%vu@]s~ċ^}ہ)39Nyui`3&\9)(jSi|Dl EIH|*O  gh3;< z#Q s) =_"*bOu>z*zc ii(qv͐^sc ې`&π>O9B}4ft0nrԧ[p[X4mJn^&mLb"a*mg ˲FɵnݴRtBϷi"sr@LP'6N1P-SL s;(Rk3xBcD*j[iʱ4~Sl_ nB =(F4)\c >wcno~*p$ vzcqG}fn1g\$/:S}dY>#,e\Xthlb]m>JO#r݋{r'EQdGU͓o 7CcvhO:.*Yn'0<=W1^PuV-{D1L&}e]:ukqǠb8q|jT\}s@IJ%eCB3Nƪ(` gC袗euHكs\!WQ}KZ|dRTsVdMHjYұy{}ُ}9 y_&sS\q'Pm_N9p7=5PDQdAys,: Tg!yy/rjlKynr/FiF2E9<燔i^ձZ~>XW<~ù\9\R($;VΟ&&^Z K=4 1'4!=2R'ǂF|ܸgo"?Pd^:9jFuB)Tl}>{cxL!Y[qn)0_:s5Ҩs^(UF }bFG@z@[j-:KsYA},ʵQF0 7GBxnOJO ~O#o؞m;4sgp s^OH9&ޣl\fe|#ȇBn>{ucPxwd+Z9FJPX>g ߠ(@.&x㧴LܤeVr]w}жOnw{}dc~hا3@4!{gy<~Z\!ye$ipX [x*0gHou}ɻݗ 4 `@CJAhPCEQV UʌÀZvjǂVjEG(RKNkA-v@򶟳w潄(o3ݻs[>`SyJ>4[d:xfE &@Td(/QN&m=q|gWzZaƍևR!syWKʕ~>:QO{EtΓrr]{*}+E '?I=γǻßh5{pTr4CF)Z}8s+?E\mk#_]%\ 7t^5s>~]dž;DHllW6&tǒBmg;?**Q'h@ -oKQo۱o9/ mxٱޓP. ?}z;[ӂ'I~#5]/mm 2 } ΐ2jEtJ#KZ_K~'C Γ!"< KSafثobVRJ|7\W(X;`m3b0,?>? sCu 7ĨΜjP6JBړPR?+GIy(ޚ$t$OyDGtǙI?3c_%ے],pW]|.kvwsV٭pSǏc_qZaG7P<ύiz_&aS<[߂5̓nmohm< gChؿó0x^/+qA^ +`͍ 'ؘ+>yj114,M?$~ DCm~|QOӈ+h?23~5`l@b2c2qS󮍳f9FsZSe_F>ȐeTzEJOƇdL^*dP/נSRFޔ[ԧ(Mr|L1&eeZgsc;OPvAsn-x DٗGP?iU!CSwHhMJOh4|=nLRͣN8? s8Wxzρ ERdfQrֿ]_+I]uTPtOyޘ&KepzDuT:R9=-ѰP*UdVD4m(}Ucxӷ󟖾 4"X KX2ӝ[\o%}f[/h 7VYLs ש̭lNd GfXO`郎3թ^GwSgmgr4V$m.fXs;oI}9}]뢿;Yt 7Or[(Wg+;ݟVd19^ŸrnwSY8}߅t12't;a1ң cKqTص/M1;;GwDK2vϻG?/~|Ot]ww{>ɗg*=Ukj=ϣ33i-`ľed<_΢HD8ƼYk,ʂE~8+>>^cp-bxSU8~rǨ^yy\@FbNuc~g:߯?'h@535p5 9ߞė6%tCY;c| {BjEU?YIssc5EKpmJC (< lVǟqR:jPJPiVT> X:K6V@)G\LX-@PAeCD_dػs}[dos}9|?O= OXK d(ޣc ]}ƽ(dRqI SOwÃu)cOcm쎢r zE8Gwc{[ 'Ӣ~C'޸]w=P{%)92yRZns/};R7IδW?t#5Pm n0)>bkﯓ~!W[%׌'L-2D2~ܟs ^$%`8]ҶX1zfd[YZ F#GZtGժO&Z+C5SG^侤SgޫXRq\}; ޤ{Kߋp >fuaQɨSu5X\յYV\tALPSГotՃ)U1 HAb9y-k]묩V\ww^%Z}Op@}jz XU^JuP,(+w݉D5/>=c[\~ h}ڏh$ָ^g+9XL}P>N3ve#G`-?6_6>6E7a[.'&afFc%p ocC۸4*: QV-RAdfwZ4i:4aF=w}{2@K9g6Bb}ͤ\$|8{O |Wg5曒q}:ʰ#gG1:L,ձ*lJu#zg{<!6u׃xEjwݶ^rzJ۸O;8*)жTT[RLy8s/U|)?$:/9d`}stAI^ױ/|ߧؽȄ}&|^y5 Ȝ/{F2L/F=4C'쁞}w|ܽo׬mtUXz0}2y{VϾ(M'O֞a^;kӻ7^m4yj o/\/TR-uZѯM_ \/jeJNLP.^U)"4}OQ ύ^~Bra+V=M*uVοK◆(zNFVJLPЭ.7 pAr% \}MkNͭ,Ge)%]V$F \gNb;1DWdY)y[e)LeZk_-]ɂ~slzYi5Npgho8Ve.lHF)0<ڽh~ TCPe_oRsݶHT,'h1JCZr4[2+aW\ͳ_Q_UnR$ H WBP Ѐ I-0D7}akɨ5CmV,HZU#3ptZdcd޻$X8uGgn2{߹zRW9%l}20F+ʘ(;qۤX>V|ѽ1oiDK^aL8ݸηޓX✭Myo/*DE ?_ #Jt:c#CCX.>{;cr쿁gdsɍF)re-_~wZ6%%)*(KP-DQnJWsV"כ^%߸oQVR:cGm9^nAĸ78c2-x! eLwl -5)KFwJ*}V~i<}E$5x}Z.8ɦxڋU g{.Y }(AڲS^22.1)d]")Pur>Bs&jGqTEdZ:|#YB<#\~T*qt~> rڹ 3W4ߨwcU5q3Pl1I|!V= _z^&ܓ6w*TpNlef`܅g\M7ig 8*!&=bYgw6+_ؿ>NF3F6R^唧Sԑ, U?MbL_u768Mc"Oފ8Z{4^KN3.h<ǁ1L" 6 NX>u`rTˠ?w2œ= T3_s:DwqKX8r hYkm,ez}$HXs1||M`'x)nxQ[ <~ >~ʡ =Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh/pmcX' р~= ||9E*ك9T1i7Na))'X}-(-BCk6j]\/cLICX#r0|7K6V瘵gj^XTIcZ9X1 v1KU{KհerC״G4ZT5rc;8>Y(l*)EUktnTjL,;]Zf[<OJXx2OxlDtRVr1ZlOX1lKp )֙d DfK R&3[B)ٓ72#7'ͦpw$ DLG։S3K-&=eBVLyKYK͔eV j͐ & 9AGJ‘Tͪ~?Rkh z01J9` $ۯ?*xUhFֳ_?nY1-:Xr7s5?]qN{ט x"R)2W*_#Cb^e}c->.csąBj )Փ 12+} 0Qɂ)S}0T,+W%glYah|߹\qo8+aNМߵ<*!8AkDh,߁uqSN hpXbN %dž|hL:3F\g)|PJKx^]@dqqeRU`/(exBNaz _g^W}+̗1}NL?X&3{+$g tؑ<6r-AA.621$)Meijbĝ2OM65 0>#>xiGf4jN2i+a?INӨ Q~dъNCJtNS:; 3AcЃerGG.McI```\cc1l 1cC̘x_dyˋwY Ǻ nJI`ZطMqȱךUKm}%b'X Xxz~`UywX o 5m]Q!9FImZߕ1}h|nFW7QN7&jD jkk'Ntv]u ww҃iI ~`/y.KWf1x 3q`p(`[ D ̂y'S'J¯jCA+An),LOK"yok\Kh Ev!yzxO)6xI!RH@c 3l$F?ׂ޷"!*1LABCc"] _[vStSi3;Y߶FַHTfI;zC;zrb4("v1JƯM);*Z%EUbרNzd:nrˈ.XJt9zZC}r Iu1^ 2R}t ۉ_fe\6-%{*MC|zBB/~~A^)Q51 r3 w6wpmHfVu7Zה9$Ҋ>]# CWBe5qтuvֻ\ͮkkkw׸Un[u;܊6#p:;dٯB N K+jզIzGI\[k"i?Ȣf)+Q#-*LVmg2ezcof4mu3g9:p.^aڍɧP#eto^:VL<@9mm \V)éeeDH6sJmvj2(C+#!Za]2 5J΅Bf} _)W)IAY.°1ʝY5>ٙΖp!Ѱk#`..py8Yy4+P8PQ܈?!nL ~=5[?RutO 0p,KB[Pګ'sOq #As(i)} -L?\Ol\t)rM?ŝ"WZJ\gͳ2Wz{Mdܤ#۹E[c_v,lgd}+/o$kUWs9!\8U{m} }ü@G|>?T(D:i 2a)Of̘_p17ևÍ3n;=p1>h[--30o3ݸa(Ƹq˜2f g\{=t#BáЉTh6 %Ә = ؉tW*)[+1:$.P̚Su/'d#IZbձ5%5F"VmU ^)'gXLv^(l#" GFi*h>!b?!4B<ń $']*hJL0 endstream endobj 16 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 3/Type/Page>> endobj 36 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (96-0575.a1)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\ ved%20-%20HTML/96-0575.a1.html)Tj 49.74 0 Td ([7/2/2021 3:58:08 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 541.5 591.75 224.249 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 748.5 Tm (Michael Y. Ra'anan)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Administrative Judge)Tj T* (Member, Appeal Board)Tj T* (Signed: Jeffrey D. Billett)Tj ET 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 16 671.25 cm 0 0 m 120.645 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 646.5 Tm (Jeffrey D. Billett)Tj T* (Administrative Judge)Tj T* (Member, Appeal Board)Tj T* (1. )Tj (The Board reads Applicant's appeal brief as dropping the claim \(raised \ at hearing\) that these)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (documents were)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (privileged.)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 15 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 2/Type/Page>> endobj 37 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (96-0575.a1)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\ ved%20-%20HTML/96-0575.a1.html)Tj 49.74 0 Td ([7/2/2021 3:58:08 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC q 10 36 592 730 re W n BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm (by the fact that the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Judge excluded three pages of Government Exhibit 10 in response to Appli\ cant's objection.)Tj ET Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm (Department Counsel, not Applicant, was prejudiced by the Judge's action.\ )Tj 0 -2.125 TD (\(c\) )Tj (Government Exhibit 11)Tj ET 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 32.3184 715.5 cm 0 0 m 113.314 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 145.6328 716.25 Tm (. Applicant's appeal argument concerning Government Exhibit 11 is)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (not well-founded. The)Tj -10.803 -1.125 Td (Administrative Judge excluded Government Exhibit 11 in response to)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Applicant's objection to it. There is a rebuttable)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (presumption that the Judge is capable of)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (disregarding evidence that the Judge rules is not admissible. )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 40.629 0 Td (See, e.g.)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 3.332 0 Td (, ISCR)Tj -43.96 -1.125 Td (Case No. 94-0845)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (\(October 18, 1995\) at p. 6 \(citing federal case and Board decision\).\ Apart from that presumption,)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (our)Tj T* (reading of the decision persuades us that the Judge did not rely on Gove\ rnment Exhibit 11 in)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (making his findings and)Tj T* (conclusions in this case.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (2. )Tj (Whether the Administrative Judge's adverse security clearance decision i\ s arbitrary,)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (capricious, or contrary to law)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 28 622.5 cm 0 0 m 545.953 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 573.9531 623.25 Tm (.)Tj -46.496 -1.125 Td (Applicant also contends: \(a\) the record evidence does not support)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (the Administrative Judge's finding that Applicant)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (abused alcohol in excess and to the point of)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (intoxication and blackouts from about 1966 to at least January 1996; \(b\ \))Tj T* (there is no credible)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (evidence to support the Judge's finding that Applicant did not attend an\ aftercare program; \(c\))Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (there)Tj T* (is no nexus or rational basis between Applicant's alcohol consumption an\ d the Judge's)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (adverse security clearance)Tj T* (decision. The Board construes these contentions as raising the issue of)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (whether the Judge's adverse decision is arbitrary,)Tj T* (capricious, or contrary to law.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (\(a\) As Department Counsel correctly notes in its reply brief, the Admi\ nistrative Judge found)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Applicant's excessive)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (alcohol consumption began in 1990, not in 1966 as alleged by the SOR.)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Considering the record as a whole, there is)Tj T* (sufficient record evidence to support the Judge's)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (challenged findings that Applicant engaged in alcohol abuse during the)Tj T* (period 1990-January)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (1996 and that such alcohol abuse included drinking to the point of intox\ ication and blackouts.)Tj T* (Despite Applicant's denials of alcohol abuse, there is sufficient record\ evidence to support the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Judge's findings to the)Tj T* (contrary.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (\(b\) There is conflicting evidence whether Applicant failed to complete\ an aftercare program or)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (was permitted to attend)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (three Alcoholics Anonymous meetings in lieu of completing the aftercare)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (program. As the trier of fact, the)Tj T* (Administrative Judge has the responsibility to weigh the record)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (evidence, assess the credibility of Applicant's testimony,)Tj T* (and make findings of fact. The Judge's)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (credibility determinations are entitled to deference on appeal. )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 40.471 0 Td (See)Tj /TT0 1 Tf ( Directive,)Tj -40.471 -1.125 Td (Additional)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Procedural Guidance, Item 32.a. Considering the record as a whole, the B\ oard cannot conclude)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (the Judge)Tj T* (acted in an arbitrary or capricious manner or contrary to law by rejecti\ ng Applicant's)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (testimony on this point.)Tj T* (Accordingly, the Board finds sustainable the Judge's challenged finding)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (concerning Applicant's failure to complete the)Tj T* (aftercare program.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (\(c\) Applicant also contends that he has not abused alcohol on the job \ and his drinking has never)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (impaired his job)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (performance. The Board construes this contention as raising the issue of\ )Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (whether there is a nexus or rational basis)Tj T* (between Applicant's alcohol consumption and the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Judge's adverse security clearance decision. Alcohol abuse, even if it)Tj T* (occurs during off-duty)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (hours, poses a security risk. )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 20.551 0 Td (See Cole v. Young)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 7.276 0 Td (, 351 U.S. 536, 550 n.13 \(1956\); )Tj /TT1 1 Tf (Croft v.)Tj -27.828 -1.125 Td (Department of Air Force)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 9.97 0 Td (, 40 M.S.P.R. 320, 321 n.1 \(1989\). Given the overall record evidence o\ f)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Applicant's history of)Tj -9.97 -1.125 Td (alcohol abuse, the Judge had a rational basis for his negative conclusio\ ns)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (about Applicant's security eligibility.)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 21.767 -2.125 Td (Conclusion)Tj /TT0 1 Tf -21.767 -2.125 Td (Applicant has failed to meet his burden on appeal of demonstrating error\ below. Accordingly, the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Board affirms the)Tj T* (Administrative Judge's March 18, 1997 decision.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Signed: Emilio Jaksetic)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 16 145.5 cm 0 0 m 113.32 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 16 120.75 Tm (Emilio Jaksetic)Tj T* (Administrative Judge)Tj T* (Chairman, Appeal Board)Tj T* (Signed: Michael Y. Ra'anan)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 16 43.5 cm 0 0 m 134.795 0 l h S Q EMC endstream endobj 38 0 obj <> endobj 39 0 obj <> endobj 40 0 obj <>stream H\j0 ~ CI62i 9t1nzOJ3$K%'U}}?=Iww-Zg^m2z;wmP 7u¡ݨB'tx⬟xƕJޢ~N[?8tR;H :Yֵ~T9ٲ߈;:blU*uqU*yRvwUqrR +xYVx˼10璓sN@.3&&a,hg`p>0`pFk&Θŏa?Fcďa?FP;-itsYf=>^T*ԯUM endstream endobj 41 0 obj <>stream H|TT}p wfNlw(X$j" Ŋb-Q1"XX+v`/3bQx{䬵>}][ JSZDT\dEk ߬nPxΉ&@DfcG<[-DF:mJCrZ˚̅e;*Ri AE ?`Geos@mmh|~s:?7&~eme\RBSg5P|ߚ(*B5QVは45˙9:!ЎƠ4TO3*-}bCnP=<5W -WxJ)- I*VrժרYv7nMB6k_|٪uaw#"9*:&Kn{;O~0p!?r'Oę_x W:ײCGB'<0r^Ýy8'8^($B*7j:FMV'ՇK= 0?^LכmozG}I?c61O01gZ:YFZR,,ˬZk-f-mխ-֘@%'bPg4AF%l4D#gL1 vcq8a6lƶ[-ka]ixC{=we r{KkݍMܡ9ossLŢtPpN&"[j:VNR3էz @@B@Zsn[a9 ~Q?_a57$X-H9DX9CFceɡ1CDeT.i/aړWV.wו[8ޖW<ozw%r_WrVA*IgpNo3ϖ>{jp-$I_UUUUUUU2>^5=f'ӳg-J\/'+\FUg rp6w;9k;k8:;2N?'9;.]ǭݎt9;XXhq4q9#fF^NfIG_Ïa' H 0-G!aM n4fӯ9RT|q7(IŨ8]2h}TJb-Q)*MOtw[M:BV:LG(tN) 2F)Y:G籝>rT*^yoMp:omwNŻyg> |1>'Xy§d3|y_+|UyE]KtUrhuEmQGD}@L4!h&sRh{}ͥ=j#74ҔhemcJ25%RLLMLM h%Z6a/ׂb3XAQwܝamqwwwJ) Cݵ wH)A8[' r$7-r&r%w=r's)9ayDqyBi<#?ɟsù\_owS%g9y^^%yY^Wuu]CԵtm]Gt}@7ԍtcD7ts7MT_ P 55T S5RR56vBU W$5YE)j9t RҭuVsBԯkAwԝNKV{^OWAuHVGQuLW'lO}IuiD('}/ⅸ&^Wx+މd^|$RD(G.IR&CD  SH((IY((erQnCy)_~}?(-PQ R!*LE(P1 ugEw=FtzJũ *E rT*PO= BF4&d)44fz^7z{A}TTJUa.KVf2/8=g3s8spNŹ9|ͤYbw h7 pA7֍s.ąu$bŹ .ť].O w%r\+w-sEĕ Wj\kpMŵz\pCndsn͸9܊[f=܎sȝ3w-M[w{'܇r?x CmbL3D8ǝ0Hl |Ȁs<1_GfdAVds;G]@NBnq"/+|(((@18J$P QeQQtD0** jj!1)9Z%Z5ڠvhN.n-z;4Lgt5 }1uA]Hvވt]T]ҁ.+`vd6&A!abcFbFc bcB0Hs0 )iYFl6[Vl7;N6{^sN3Ls\6W>0,;αs<;.  SgxxWx7xwH{|G|B2s4ms5qs\5us_G:'(ďcX?ΏD?_/+*_&oߛOQI1P&w~g'Eӿ?|W{T{gvQ1(2*Ebk]@1MTx56zQh|5EǘcD1V;jj ,Jt.|5OG1q\|*NI7qJ|.Nk+x\!2/jICu 86MZvi.ү~JaZ:Cw_䅢Q3+=!:nk©WSVCۖO[h.uSZ^X߼ 8 # < 0y:L2WksBZ洒c'@x/Be&q2N:JK൵.p}u_d%I=w-(faDJ(` 4Bᩣe=?`8kxWo"0Gɇ*jb+77y]=q#x vlC}GKvb^kΉ\Q)~*$>RJ%(rH6ȊΈۋc9Xc| Q'x0>x_+8zGgxӹ+x fwo+ƈ~!'s2j:%Oa;{2pڷ}ږvbKgpr?^sf6̦PJnėҟ!sy.Qaw> u}pY1C/ge ̕?aj`l{(SѕDYrE;x kζvvnɵ߷7MdJG> @؋hPn"I"MIE`DΒ 9yM6趞"d0azZۈįIOƬh6SwzݜC؁*77!j8C\q]y(#9ph;ND m,K4HլA46ɕzQ3!6UbyTĹ7UOxAni)6/@2 qT..LH1U=eT?-'n0v/ qѷJmr#|E )(.q)I۪DȆ"vșN%_~H 3C 7L%Ȯ34+m:syH)%ʤ}'˟^^p\dL},U N({ߧّ䨣YcUMp |/v̗q|HqG23\r8}pWMTNH}3{?D.~ɵȺ\1Rdܥ˨<+*Ug;f#:dpԔ'%&Z|>b{8{z{d];w TE T׌$$鹹iV]/AC ~CCSc ==2#g#9RCcR5'ܺS _s>͸CӉ '­˻8֬j B3~S}i| KE,o\X-J褏+~#6`PQ!66{B-P՝Ƹ8W]߃E{zekIKnn.];BRh%u-C+ӠWF2L ebc1nmtrvk&FZ>O^: @fFkS$],f]QS; v:5AY3'D@ gtԵ!2"fZ䐦;20ރ(b"Zlw|SaᮛSHMOMEɨDEɦ]f_T[b /&%c˒+ŭ (#Gvx=c*FS(;[H%c-?kXB|\?BE0퐱&gr|H|R$Dl 'F)nڥGz*tW\֯4UIE6'Åe%)d y¯wJbP"X_S|ܼ76CLװr9C}fhTcC JJRp"`]e^dmlKf^{g.>ִVVx! vMBq"!s/Q+ ׁ]k׀Q==fmm=}cط;p00]>aiH>Ox/{|Vd؟  ;0|Ki&O=˒K փ%T:5=5 Ffn 9L8)Kp1lДj4S~{ %0e /6zgW}{NYf˖M>_ƴ'n8r?qoo!nZQ`>6: #81q/ǝqL8-\B+pFcR}iNwUӍ&g'W9iucZ6;N4}@SbCPXZS IMD8m81 :0b7{qǼBv w!WN\})9TG?cjͩh2c}M%zwwp) V1^rqoB01< j}Q1 ̸\u:tP)TDִ1!j^JMwqy: r 'A-!N#DoO#Z?=+]IGW\d& %s˕]&]&̹Lw.;}] &睖BDr.>ury'ߥLɷ*&K )*"}7+rJ,ˣL7e\{ ;f?vy[BurQcC&jg L¶H|'R88 0kԣ[ZZ#ѹuîl]+.6jɺ5uĞ3o[{q9~msY F6x;MǃUGhf3WL'UStLb=|KyPtӍ$v&H$Rh@6@*"Psě6QH%FhRbHg A"!$NQO&x'Ō*?fy/O#OB~G9=uk$B &D8zbOZ|:P-XõX* Ϻe%8Г.@2# Qj2fjȵɤZ=3s1R밐JuTU!_hcK_K_P҈i<"*sIȵg G++ܼIp@F0*|S#L? >$Tm%պ-J[2m#!wQ*.c-,:_4x+?xz5b-}g҇6lM$6zi-]ܲg1N_6R-_]}귟r=Pfk^%jƚS;PnP:q!,urhA!3xk|JH5$g1Lv&t*0.TJEH"6\ 4pLP;P?ѥ`6ft۹˫8MƇx5=h[ycq)Q[_ÐW eRK(_Ҵ| + mt- ]AE!VtX .: 2fA'2w}p_)5mqH?qmgVXqaGsf{رmWnL j8dL;%-orpL.őٓJzt;sy[$Ԟʤ]zcq1 dںaG9|z4=_4.M},;vr3rj,_qf=q,Q9d!63,Qc5;rP's3Au&OcIX)Ht?rTEK ` a~=АiRt;(C?{s#%Zj4)pKW TjgG~.YPED<2+2c ?LJL&U^AuM|ZZ:KAW ýOfVOM eƶ=c`s=Ł}}X?ox`os+zԥDN=*o~y7PM0G='j@R=sMK.˴>&F' ?6qp%*(g/MR=JuQn+z@] Vl Ϭ ;(,% ZiKNh]mI? b"cLeH5Y:"Ԫ+@|vQV/6,}Xݫkbp~k{[IKx;2gol{)u|\_"aN&Wu,2vjc*BHpw.8/-m i&uK$ۢlLR-Y_rjҭkN.mw+uͥ[ :M [%˥II!i/{ȀyCUȋ1Vv)%ްY$C}Q>>Ƿ+ߏc`Wі%WYx? >4u<>1piy==χC<w "^vYqB!e{)ϳ| WWk#մWD.7 0@%zliɺ[%kvn@ L YWL{Сͺ?zU6^ UNEM"LjNϖFOMe#|Oh':kcxu|7&G7Mm{Htz~[ΰ;iТO:OJܗ;:`"OP l# sХ'm!g|_[l6>7r#܈.q3'-=b ~jcxB.L r)kAUJ _ ΰ&({-~k3d cTiCj5fQhpI5pfӝAk{uCsR=_D]0~xe8!kp3:Od7xgLxX;^.F9z Wm/얩.T=v3;~ohc&L~%J9I %F+5iNBS öb.o)flnmDT;3±\+5A*&lNzݢƆ,.zǎ{MU#Y/?FIgX/A7lVe^RXSsҶ^H R]3/? )Kne/إ BD?:4l%2>mlBny3hޝ@PF 0zqxnSҤtB{5ܑ`PX'S ELn_<`nG30 ܡ>pjȊ3P,ߤ-5RpOT`KD)aF]صYg=pzJ!]u'iwYY8kѾ}ÑNƵ/4ѯ2̩,01h4d 4 ~I[!2ܮ-q'fT'&l_)q6@$|?oYq/(/;`ye;37-M;[3yhHj쉡ě7g-zw%sE"_^ȟ/),1l2?6FH@<9>,-+ϴA Nl=8ˋC%+E҃Ҁ(jkbz$#I$rVƋ|̔J堩T,ʲd&srDzOz;@r[/"yPW$ .+>QV\2@]o;X'>(_WBNͨ'Wux:tjHL*l":XzPK +L9 & D+˵4 3mz)}6~h4ѡ|+GT2tpCޤ6=L,s& wkΌF-cSDFLf&k, ~ѨVVz׺_3ʹBA0>zi]UQdϟݼAfVљ8_} I'Lf[$q;'80o ĉwV6ABP/htAwҗ8h)}oo|O?qwb{OόMTNR [Fނ+Yc.ܕЍ cܨ{,Op~ T@T U&3pyn!غ-2*BݠV]ͤ jXL+N|]:כͼ͸\n,|,bX0znW2fMl3{qdK8TǴjԀayS;ivO=XWcrvmyye-U6g11!y }cK벪-_/_MVw9CUVDǬ<[Nutm' 6v6us}~\>ۉ$NrëEIRBK;:BE)5юT+% Qi*Oil2n]s^b{r~~ߗքęu²=3a:%u.sTvbg᫝^I\[O |``oRœœq ̔6Y鷹rshZ'JQS5Iq浞~F!byI0:̮}b$%L{@[Z8-P,0J2]AzV!Xz)ýD[@J:R҉Bel;VbC/<Q7dH9YsiڻT|?ČkvC :{[r wK{㋬v\F,c8ݳrq~bb˟:>8ugy!m)'Cm9AEU3?iM[{k{GT.rKUw4jh|*&>u4m=ށ/!^(AVzeuM=<&-<hC*,3̂nHyR0q@4@yG|t=(`"Y[`1֚I 'nn󷊌T,X ƜJK:[M)LU帒;粎[6$(&JyNTqG8#fE- QtУT٦UkR8*2ЊbQN?jCyVžV~nf'qkH^ْ? DH,@ը mDh+A3^Yxɵ!+ߏ;Aeb TC}das'=} xyoP;h&>.OG&w=nuD ;,_D|(vw`LC*0',?"LLLs&4W!b  IClBeD(TO=xsE⯈. 7yB&FQN} ޏb0ibyTy>p6s BSE4埊Y$Sb7kvy7D=nJ No!.+]+'0JWT9mfwcޠ6 Wk.{?]R;wt)(jT T*SJizu[WtgE#b5\8އ| H^zzS[N p^a)%`0g `"u97 i))Te?E  Sِ̹cޅ|'l%iX 8E㰭 ({~?$+7\ ={?ľD q񈭧ud^4q؇9 u%ؒ`;0>U~q.߀ wfoHXTZ \u~1&^gNOi-_zۮΘ}_yQJ26`[q'oIĴ2.>+:eAģDoyr=_Ͳ79FIYΤǺV S]- AzO[۝J{[˖NJDMJgN#n#@_ kXՁ~s(YdPN@KFꗩnŪ+ѭ*14_ !g5Q2|ʗ3mfo4yYkutR7+Eg_PQosx6R p/3j6i^&9QͤqL܅@~g@:eI$a O||,w(w 9cޜA5יsrE`/Q8159՜(,Ln:B*3!sӧ|\L_Wr!õ=\jE{֖eVyU-%9Ӎ7xIRH!5\m@CY,j,w6Vh)jH}"5BB~թ2؀5$q;!um& `(x}4;M1OeڎbIF4Kyzj>>`N W{u<ڡnE!|nC#L^Hj>׫hzn[>^Ū >zQB=6u_j_ڽnyT1' c6O܍;:{VNg^3c03HXIlpO42WMhb%8OM¿ P3{uWzB]mw<ڸӫ@O!%&Cs0e,Ɨ^yi#ڱ| XE]7G_WC)-s7_K^{rK~+靃({k%6­o«m§'jxM "#R3R3g#Jobk QgVsFRv} NjRúd %7]5'ݭr=ވn7Yn6=%T̙s39uD}Yr zybE.zbz ѝ~AOU\с7Q*ZguVbb2xg8 QR}k5% 9䦛k7~q7Dj5Vu]K^ןX Yy>wBwy=yxs8oƏKcϸ-Z8_^LRϙڭ4 n\>mR|"~^ǽ=1l:1hށC hf|35΅80 @%1u ǯ#k 4zdxY )_%mFGʡrvVKsxw,FQ&cl7qR`OQ*[%9ëu>e]8ƻd {) >CAk3!V"*4R7[G ]x% .]a"u5qHog]W# a%*,"")eD`@p] #(pADʔ!x㉘R1 GLzf>XJŭ=ݯo!{Zw:R'aI`^ZVJm8Đʊ6ʣW>U{v>a>Iy|(W3{6ǡʏCɇ6߁U>j¿KCs|(o݄WC~ṕQ5&lK~l38;<]xXe߰a C4-]@uZ0ꟴ;^ΆA hx<^>x/Ò}+ƾ[tc;6'[VIf;Ƣ-,\d|ゝYa%iX"f'C]=5/&#+,KͳtP ڣ/_*3~e;8vsu ϕJwGN^%GAsf\H<]lw;LNwr4;]Q"soSZe(CvzPng_wlExl}ۖs_{^5{ $-g}NKdO::^RΨsvDkZV Pqw^>i){"YՊV*.^'gnׅAƺ ~==CȴTCf&>׋Zyp]mű.u>Qkׄ-ZIuTVS$Z5#rf#ίp֤};Y0"8Jrֹid:ϳG=s7 Yr_TO6j}5-Uճγhѵ?W6nmZJMrg6x>҉\-a>t{ĚVOXb<6S+M47Dg}C;9nSm豠#c5;}Q.*yKjR3 ^:nV\^+w3F(oe<αqqvevN}aWl~f?"S8ղ` 㬡.f%]Z&/7;~4w5|%mGbcl賮~7G 5znD1^Y޹0!~ָM{rBA-;ʑ;VtB\wQ\Fe v"zLjdLߑb+uG8"o`wCscG h:? 7&؇F^ .c'<^E} nAi>|!_ &qM!bե]{&bt+tڲFfXw/u``z!tZn|eϐB_CFP\'Կ5]Ά=G8 WcvŹW)ַYgk9%]/ VߛXI=Zl[~z)U=S0KK9u--lj{jg)*xIٙ:>S̾e짻هcYs髆}p&&xۥ-#?9;qߟH.m7#1c{~#ɗ a'ķ7]Z?15U]n9jjt6bJW(Is.g-< [x,15c^qh{;͝9xU.4ӄ'rb.fR._!VK)13Eo™2WywgS`]Tw?vb]0i^Xi*Y_Qec*X;(rX~sYAL:. yAmZeIlw"`J:M5:z$pDff,dFO ve[JnṒWl\jSm]ؑy~iWoPĻ2ܥ2*+KRniAh廫K(}-qt>4CAG.G~ X?^[W'ytWǿf%Ke@" Җ"zl (%l/-zp'T69@d/ 9XJiSvlbr "R{?ϙ7ܹ͛dM%7`2ӎ1{*dl;ual_@(f/b;} #z R$͸Jձ3ˡ@OO-ͬ3WCJ~03z{5@>}FT2:߲-ߗ5z7mT+U%/{/2su*XYa/=8k9gDe9cO,~mٯb^ufW{)͚ d NGJV1k:fV]xUFa]䘽|x&ȝ\IS^8^I]#_!&xg8O{1q͋wڅ+E9`-˗ ([Lѭ,Fkwlӏhѳ,wbD|KofM3aɖ5J8E&A !7?&G=堞/ɲP/iA+B +Y){B79 3064fv˜=YZ}S[JwhF0Ԣ&#g0? l8Kx'^;(v'q躬 !YUC_[֩J'1[/_Gryo/?ASo:>c1ݤgboa i:5裛Y=&HYpxbi:]tX›xIgف5Q%"-E}:hAu:ܪܛ般_I{e<.B[&;6>:GJg-t^ʻQiDy۹e\RkhOu{:4iT@_ףuV,t5xUÿT8'>Aj/`nWG|}oV:-4wJѱ\LFuݙ~: `:`?΅spsp8Z܍Mlw}X&ɖ0JYt*?8o#y@DWK)vALs>#cU: 'tZXak?@^)V^Nb;L#9Y}^Ytgd"(W*EE'j1nU:1\`L,wN::C0qd3Nk` an~KKM~b<摺? CDk _z /^~cwBpb<4D_mB#; uC4䞌x?_bb+V, r{C[=X>4līl4MF rn,(XmaXT7KFYK HK)dj?]̳O$,vvwA/2d-ce9Lfd0wcK@?~zMHC#5e\j+.5uǤP\Adhs4{G9WD8kWq*?bmn)6QB[ľ2 9fn- iW]]"T h|-C7:)/NFd!I6>5H.^*a{0 ],7vت|ו{?rѐ/-|\u8s73eh8D$ }cJn #;_W=Ox1~d,)tˌ1;CQD{}=y07y2U]lVԸʶ|'s6/<+TWJmӘ{Psޠsz~{ԝANDy(]a\u;+kT߂Hևf%e\k~nm)"(bҚr=7[䚩BW.+[Nrmb3Z,69\l&ǚ.^)6w;tBOXz Lf}Ȕ]O0ggS[6D"!ᶍ\2| r /K@mʜ3"ԫc?G0аbX,bX,bX,bX,bX,bX,bX,fXc߹DZKB&$I_ 'אCy&!!qQc/N,ڏ@WN֭6mqo(%I16:$JWMSƼh'gVMܛGPYx@)4Aml(,s)(KP"R*_}9ې_vEKb+Ę.ۦhF.#`"#a &fJI>&-8.;iHIDj1QiڃjM8n}Ӊѧ0$71cA>%o9 d a01Ѽ>FP+v'ԃb3,g!ڰG{\weI܍~4oRj&**'QyŚtbo\v7 cSL:*1WtߖK} 5b~>~g BnLp؟m$U35.FeyzMf1yWb<0Dr" cq/7vt$fL3^{̡ywO!JLy1#(j%FhJd R<8É$o cp3MTb21 &I} XO[y496dFfǗٶsrG4d8j<1|iIrq!Wb'ΩC% >؈e"gZ3p{˾>YOS>ŇF[\ {/X !zM@5~\\s6~06~}4!^A ҅;@iWRkzܨtf#f.B9X /YUIޞg6,1"; Knk~W/X  P'` >atŪ/ JtJa&wr6(Z<.2J^¨߂$P̦mʴ2M]%֚a=:oVc'HJ(ޢOrQP2g@Wy%ZYZ%5+8 MeM516}>%:MVQ&Le pV{MRzgs y6ŭm{~x6ޢi]J+<:OǶHO'JY ų/1ek2?3 j8HIj $jVkZh4L^U/c*B ffo2\Q+:GԖ@)en:H Jm|gn PhD܆!݈1"WЈMrmC bH)ZRnxfM$@B(rNV8eʗ7A%$n*PWO:WC~u_W`Iڕ*?$=oTr=^7:/p5A>ՠJ(&q{KJ wJ!fW[eUֆiXpbn,-O2 sVϲGKdV &&E$^l]A;I0!4/n-_WQ)#P'va-\g""D8M{]#$[]V,AwnP ,cbeԲ ~]cw8)pLYt+8<%ϒ8U)я38\ǎUm_e@ㆇ*3ϼ^=keϓ@]D1zXrPAc(@[,hTΨ &dJibHbcI?]B'wͼn~Qڡ;C-L^OK6?:-CS4@w?(JctƄXX h1rAn`Y 7HW1pC3i 1*f8mVbۀ؈6/9嶖JZ~3C'`8хF@ L hrD'RR(أۗ319nA#XsE(-@yq,Ig,P& l R.<$0|c@GR rzuBS".Ifg4uMI\S;}%f`)Ga!\A!>ҕ endstream endobj 14 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 1/Type/Page>> endobj 42 0 obj [44 0 R] endobj 43 0 obj <>stream BT /Artifact <>BDC /TT0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm (96-0575.a1)Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 0 -86 TD (file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj 7.166 0 Td (...)Tj (yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\ ved%20-%20HTML/96-0575.a1.html)Tj 49.74 0 Td ([7/2/2021 3:58:08 PM])Tj EMC ET 1 g 10 36 591.75 729.75 re f /Article <>BDC EMC /Article <>BDC BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 16 744 Tm (\(a\) )Tj (Government Exhibits 4, 6, 7, and 8)Tj ET 0.75 w q 1 0 0 1 32.3184 743.25 cm 0 0 m 168.311 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 200.6289 744 Tm (. Government Exhibits 4, 6 and 8 are medical records)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (pertaining to treatment)Tj -15.386 -1.125 Td (Applicant received for alcohol abuse. Government Exhibit 7 is a medical)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (questionnaire that a physician \(who had)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (treated Applicant\) filled out in response to a request)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (from the Defense Investigative Service. At the hearing, Applicant)Tj T* (objected to these exhibits on)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (the grounds that they were hearsay and they were privileged. The Judge a\ dmitted these)Tj T* (exhibits)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (over Applicant's objections. On appeal, Applicant contends the Judge err\ ed because admission of)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (these exhibits)Tj T* (deprived Applicant of his right to confrontation and cross-examination w\ ith)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (respect to the opinions of two doctors)Tj 0 -1.375 TD (concerning their diagnosis of Applicant.)Tj 0 0 0.933 rg 9.75 0 0 9.75 208.9492 664.5 Tm (\(1\))Tj ET 0 0 0.933 RG q 1 0 0 1 208.9492 663.75 cm 0 0 m 11.369 0 l h S Q BT 0 g 12 0 0 12 220.3179 660 Tm ( For the reasons)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (that follow, the Board concludes Applicant's contention lacks)Tj -17.026 -1.125 Td (merit.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (The right to confrontation and cross-examination pertains solely to cont\ roverted issues. )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 35.158 0 Td (See)Tj /TT0 1 Tf /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Executive Order 10865,)Tj -35.158 -1.125 Td (Section 4.\(a\) \("An applicant shall be afforded an opportunity to)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (cross-examine persons who have made oral or written)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (statements adverse to the applicant relating)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (to a )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 19.215 0 Td (controverted issue)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 7.359 0 Td ( . . . . "\) \(emphasis added\). Accordingly, an applicant)Tj -26.575 -1.125 Td (is not entitled to)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (claim that right with respect to SOR allegations that have not been cont\ roverted. In this case,)Tj T* (Applicant's answer to the SOR did not controvert SOR \2661.c. \(which al\ leged that he received)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (treatment in January 1995)Tj T* (for a condition diagnosed, in part, as Alcohol Dependence\) or that)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (portion of SOR \2661.d. that alleged he received)Tj T* (treatment in January-February 1996 for a condition)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (diagnosed, in part, as Alcohol Dependence, Alcohol Withdrawal)Tj T* (Syndrome, and Alcohol Liver)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Disease. By not controverting those allegations, Applicant effectively w\ aived his right to)Tj T* (confrontation and cross-examination with respect to the diagnoses made b\ y the health care)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (professionals involved in his)Tj T* (treatments. Accordingly, the Administrative Judge did not err by)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (admitting these exhibits into evidence over Applicant's)Tj T* (objections.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Apart from the issue of waiver, Government Exhibits 4, 6 and 8 contain i\ nformation that would)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (be admissible under the)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (well-established hearsay exception for medical records. )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 22.463 0 Td (See, e.g.)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 3.332 0 Td (, ISCR)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Case No. 94-1185 \(September 13, 1995\) at p. 4;)Tj -25.794 -1.125 Td (DISCR Case No. 93-1050 \(December 20, 1994\))Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (at p. 5. )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 22.44 0 Td (See also)Tj /TT0 1 Tf ( Fed. R. Evid. 803\(4\) and 803\(6\). Although)Tj -22.44 -1.125 Td (Government Exhibit 7 is not a)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (traditional medical record, it contains information about Applicant's me\ dical treatment)Tj T* (and)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (diagnosis that is largely duplicative of information contained in Govern\ ment Exhibits 4, 5 and 8.)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (\(The Board need)Tj T* (not decide at this time whether a medical questionnaire such as Governme\ nt)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Exhibit 7 would be admissible, over an)Tj T* (applicant's objection, if it pertained to a controverted)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (issue and was not duplicative of other admissible exhibits.\))Tj 0 -2.125 TD (\(b\) )Tj (Government Exhibit 10)Tj ET 0 G q 1 0 0 1 32.9922 353.25 cm 0 0 m 113.314 0 l h S Q BT 12 0 0 12 146.3066 354 Tm (. In response to Applicant's objections, the Administrative Judge)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (severed Government)Tj -10.859 -1.125 Td (Exhibit 10 and did not admit into evidence three pages from that exhibit\ )Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (which contained written remarks of the police)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (officer who arrested Applicant in November 1994.)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (On appeal, Applicant contends the Judge erred because Government)Tj T* (Exhibit 10 is hearsay and)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (contains the opinions and conclusions of the arresting officer and is no\ t limited to the arresting)Tj T* (officer's identification of Applicant. For the reasons that follow, Appl\ icant's contention fails to)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (demonstrate the Judge)Tj T* (committed error that prejudiced Applicant.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Department Counsel must present witnesses and other evidence to prove co\ ntroverted facts. )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 36.961 0 Td (See)Tj /TT0 1 Tf /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Directive, Additional)Tj -36.961 -1.125 Td (Procedural Guidance, Item 14. When Department Counsel relies on third)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (party statements adverse to an applicant to)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (prove controverted facts, an applicant has the right to)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (cross-examine the authors of those third party statements.)Tj T* (However, documents that fall within)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (recognized exceptions to the hearsay rule are an exception to an applica\ nt's right to)Tj T* (cross)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (examination. )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 7.748 0 Td (See, e.g.)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 3.332 0 Td (, DISCR Case No. 90-2069 \(March 25, 1992\) at pp. 7-8 \(applicant's rig\ ht to)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (confront adverse)Tj -11.08 -1.125 Td (witnesses is not more expansive than the right to confrontation protecte\ d by the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (Sixth Amendment to the U.S.)Tj T* (Constitution; therefore applicant's right to confrontation not)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (violated by admission of documents that fall within well-)Tj T* (established exceptions to hearsay rule\);)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (DISCR Case No. 88-2173 \(September 14, 1990\) at pp. 4-5 \(same\). )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 42.879 0 Td (Accord)Tj /TT0 1 Tf ( ISCR)Tj -42.879 -1.125 Td (Case No.)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (96-0277 \(July 11, 1997\) at p. 3.)Tj 0 -2.125 TD (Government Exhibit 10 pertained to the November 1994 driving while intox\ icated incident)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (covered by SOR \2661.b. The)Tj 0 -1.125 TD (material contained in Government Exhibit 10 to which Applicant)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (objected contained the observations and impressions)Tj T* (of the reporting police officer. Police)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (reports are admissible in civil proceedings as evidence of matters perso\ nally)Tj T* (observed by the)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (reporting police officer, as well as factual findings resulting from an \ investigation made pursuant)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (to)Tj T* (lawful authority. )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 6.915 0 Td (See )Tj /TT0 1 Tf (Fed. R. Evid. 803\(8\)\(B\) and 803\(8\)\(C\). Such material was admissi\ ble in)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (these proceedings as an)Tj -6.915 -1.125 Td (exception to the hearsay rule. )Tj /TT1 1 Tf 11.995 0 Td (See, e.g.)Tj /TT0 1 Tf 3.332 0 Td (, DISCR Case No. 92-0113)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (\(January 22, 1993\) at p. 3. Accordingly, Applicant)Tj -15.327 -1.125 Td (was not entitled to have the Judge exclude)Tj /Span<>> BDC ( )Tj EMC (that material. Furthermore, Applicant's appeal argument is further under\ cut)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 44 0 obj <>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[209.0 662.0 220.0 673.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>> endobj 12 0 obj <> endobj 45 0 obj <> endobj 9 0 obj <> endobj 10 0 obj <> endobj 11 0 obj <> endobj 48 0 obj (file:///usr.osd.mil/Home/OSD/OGC/JosephLM/_MyComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archived%20-%20HTML/96-0575.a1.html) endobj 47 0 obj <> endobj 49 0 obj <> endobj 46 0 obj [16 0 R/XYZ 0 580.0 null] endobj 4 0 obj <> endobj xref 0 50 0000000000 65535 f 0000000016 00000 n 0000000141 00000 n 0000003657 00000 n 0000140049 00000 n 0000003535 00000 n 0000003590 00000 n 0000003730 00000 n 0000003757 00000 n 0000139507 00000 n 0000139565 00000 n 0000139607 00000 n 0000139319 00000 n 0000004393 00000 n 0000128907 00000 n 0000094875 00000 n 0000093574 00000 n 0000003860 00000 n 0000003906 00000 n 0000003955 00000 n 0000004146 00000 n 0000004018 00000 n 0000004050 00000 n 0000004082 00000 n 0000004114 00000 n 0000004593 00000 n 0000008975 00000 n 0000009024 00000 n 0000009059 00000 n 0000009691 00000 n 0000040293 00000 n 0000040560 00000 n 0000010112 00000 n 0000010385 00000 n 0000010813 00000 n 0000041174 00000 n 0000093763 00000 n 0000095086 00000 n 0000102532 00000 n 0000102945 00000 n 0000103221 00000 n 0000103640 00000 n 0000129121 00000 n 0000129146 00000 n 0000138994 00000 n 0000139404 00000 n 0000140007 00000 n 0000139814 00000 n 0000139649 00000 n 0000139954 00000 n trailer <<23CCD978AAF2E74793F523D4EF0231F9>]>> startxref 140221 %%EOF