Mai ت#y(DBe|Tg.raz)3(O[t,ӡ}!lB\(qMR G%xJ
pj 1 7:Rjqdh>@6 "xp >qɱCx$9 vpg/~Avڱ/͏."I`?$"Ѱb4[@8 bC酭i\!W DTz&9"]a#Y5r
u4bF 3W~`B:$[$*oK:
uXd =NrT0-UF36NaE°Nz KQ"ᯚ<l0S_)Ѐ
[Ais:+g{!+ED{kcS6 ^fΚeHd0 GW#O_z}{2 Սʿ! ynOR4DȧB딻#۸m.n''Β4+O9?tqy'taӦH+PiЩzo 0&` <Ȓ@&=G _|,
{ɛw| 7K,I7$^l V"MI7%Q:SެJ#EU,`DTK ʗ!jFQ|
SH%A@h׀:J634.\DV"n渡 8Us\ ձ %ӁJ+PrVZJKf-[s--WT;(W T" 4 ̠F\BIL +VSSzI!u(#Јx
sxtĸn7.. ?wݭ[rk>~OnaS{VCκ_pܺX!fzmJ$VKJKuF:MlEgDPɠyN.Fȓp`Z%/r~nA]^ ?7Y"s jb ,H3JMbY}UNݗNڗ c"w MC!
g8&c1m*-"[c JLX: /ّdB kujQܘ5Q"NKt4nLjW5$ԣ ?30eqJ+n9fLS_٧yETȓ+Vܵ E[? ˃-\6
AT %UR ]]W"`87T ; MtH2AI!h~ ty|FڢնjU
ݺx=Ѱ?=;;pB$oO.9HcsSuW[z?se&Ǿ *5q_=?O(qoP$ny+|.oLs ~fڃƞAկLtsꙚKKOn ,j5xK*[ Q.,{>Ya=V t/F?ϝvdtB]E'|ti 0$
5\`CW!ESþl^ BZĉv^n !)PrĿoN<]͠a8PlGfydWklYԏ:Gxc'czҤ*٦6݆bT
HhH?mm@Br[T56ѤsmVd=s;sgd/ed/N\X쉁PiÍd[B
( Ue!dq"0eB> #³gp^?ZoL~lvso>U02=d~Ws(;/F? M~on&MվXϥjxw o= ΅#'
/쯟tb f. {F1 2?-?J:It,M Od(UVv 0:bjOhl
5-7 V/{Ld&P pDH
s E.c4yw)j2a@;R\xoXڠ OnH(z5_`-1EqIW\d@d@dAKf.d4JTV[envb 6Ot4LRtJIEzb*eQglZ2^.(.T sR
]z(9r5yL'CA1#j2k=)3Pa("v DYWErY$N&^oFCa4ͩZ&K/kiJz5m&7ҷ.TBzyӃj@^*rq y/>dX o @ ɇsun@pƁEa4; fŔC0*S
(( ]0
!Ϥ{NsB?djT˾D&`5^ Tj +Q|Nޙ"MILؕƯA]Dtͧ;l
0Ħq9!GT nJP5N ^J{Av-?|t BN*}8Y۔[qe< JLpKQߚmn8f;;/yI>WR 0
:62l[pxU!N,+kʦ+
QO v TD}4d各"2+ F@&BΫV;l,
v% nD9 x` 9Hb%[JIi]94Kysʉ"m5w0
(nmxN\/r1.)ZQ|oG"vBt
÷OU6¹8hH:Q? >*6AxmW'4t)x&LBK鏌LOd06`sI6~4nɯ@ĸ]dj8|6h6UΨEk6튘mzl[lQ-DR%mmZVVTXi,5^b9Q'-
P`a]"!Xд:FT P`r~',vg.y{ߣ2" to4 %>f-`Wu! 8v8??~3w1ǵa67ט-E& %ه a̘ 7!UX|J/JE.E˯@Y.& 3nȦ/ &
@wBp,pwb>Ή}(5`|v 爁@Vx88&DDcЀ1%:9v;l[4J3LcP"4MU< =٣`/,U.>hcͧ!IUg %5jںuwa ')Dة`6"QK\P`5(-#RrvD,uqCŀz £ &At38Jԭ^\{j>6ĄBV|:|E/3~@f.&oQSKWZb?UW·_QRy?j?
[Q XuuZ#ksV _q pFN2Z7
enGpa8~(+t
Wf&$rC8d:/L ;2`WZ.)֥[-_k5X/cS!na*!<*`\[{~'̽ 3DB^Z& < JkKuƂbij1 r-Wѻ59Ӱ0ͳO_Ѡ \>@nF?6{!eG`3RЃ_ .- 8Ͼ㺮{ ّYnKշ
^^
Ni.flJ`tNO;u}ᛙ*v}735;rmVR]n{g|1cS W_,uMhʊ5Z4Ɇcf8T9kX&2[6yf5Fsn7;MiM :\?C |K ?HGP-e5dcTI"(\fOrB -Q ˌ[ KY`bFa;6]:zKz] ,ty8% W(~ U;1%y3OMYP`so/fCߞY{ҫ0Ro!rdTU;
^P`tsP;RNPJ$c ^'/siuJjX&ge zKIT{}nزȹOy`'2?3>As)9Kj$weTx"mz ~M2k4' lˋ,}͋`!HTGv6qq}v9;>_j'V
!c* Ҩ [^ePJvT4MVM
k.k3uLMXylHtwΗ}~DT %_QXOS Fl_[Y9]N/]nrK=p6-\ w?:b2i( י 2Tݼlmփt {ū
_ˇO66d؝AU*0!~W#ہPaQK")do!˪.bI8B# lNσ}Xh༟hc}p[(zZl' '5t1B[fe1&]^]v ggX: Y'gHOf6*$xpY{Vc{}w<¦ݝǥgd)3ҍȲP/u!&h>!\TRttHa䫓ta`pt*l]yZgsC!w4qиYzɓ?Yg ?i>KIso7ύڝX qs\Ltvtu9.bjԕ#{LJWueĉmN kvT潩9{ܨXKlf 8i!h)3`*B]^9l;=??X9R?};/ ̃v2t>~
?\ρׁ
$&8LIsZc6e
y CڣL\9VH7~܈$FT01sd$/Ej%WGUqV`YEV8¡17](]T%QigAb|1ao
=imF_;*^'3R0Qnw.Eқ^|0\Z*boB -xp&J9Mb9MIg^'^~ Rùtsn=|_0 (~_82:wf yc^}:k*!A F26*T
1$D%q6ܸUE$$P(l) {w|{of9ww3/
XVj߱It>#un֭}'KA4pI>ZL4XѸky}*}*#(`hr/ΥcZ^v A- ԃʈF-ThR2-/ @aÛ(~RL:(xDo* P~Ʒt]k1;hX]!F?Lń´Ȉ-;^a[l83 v y _f kϮ˷V$MeоGR'xtԑ}̃p0(
c kHj;9I; X0U 3Ăɤ>3ܺoH s~S_Tc @^/g~CT)x"vegDEў0"U`"/5^60+$LL0k2vk7k%iY^";0W l`{D4=kkі~O7脁'h^ F4`kww4*x{>lK -tZK8 xUDzA]RoU}aW'6Lۤ*6Tm
&e
V3Et@?VfYY06!Dr)]5eۡHZ&nd\ENW/oONthGkx7ܑ#ѣsG+s҇6/T1خ< k2;JUp
2P,Z w
;~6k*{flA e13+.ʩ0Gd hX+ϸcNjMRGM];S?#t,ۀe,/p e(;
f:Eݾ TԀs&q$NG1ªO&VV|4&Y.7ϼ?ƙRW~N1NLʦ8د sxz`ˁ
-kk R
Sp\$.պT(̮p]1ִ:
mh8;6 \wdqoI#I]IK{(p3ʄ u1(r.C2Z!TyemKP㰨!3(g f(Ys
g+6H .5hU•$#>pl(r9'FnݎBjikjhG dNgsvG8Qf=.82ϙ\v3ݙΎ;7쌳7{, h&nLUJ6H#B
Fy@B@bp%#奐"*n"S;v 99gn;s_9oX~ [r"[{JS$,c.QS+vq]8!Z-}~l{} T
MPXT;3Q /~AqVCZxSs+;:߫n̈́'?5Ϲ*
'SKGG},4n>^hd/n xY,]6X 4OQ0D1jZs ?#|_3'`m0nj"R]h]VC|L=M .9|438˼"nYt?'D!{`J5E/
ؤeE)B-ҦTHZY)ʖ,> 4M3L,INKl%YYTa݅tS"$"XWyXTUăpHgi}pf \6$ .*q*-#:yoLFo- = AiIIOԵ:$;@I 3ex4H9V%L4cnjAa,4c!-
+֪uˢ*({v{RmlMܡ ` vK9q`,`(䰖k`y77:8ExA;b?oM=e)giۘ*:NZR=!k8dL2x02.bIAN9K3"^kj xj:10X:%N " tX~[Z:[o
}?; PT-:[@? M|)(uzWy֍'ȟHC`jMTף.,Uzxr"tyJa'*S0zEyaVߎwj /'ΰg Va;ތXo CzÇGAy icg4?-LgרK%Ჴ+sPt,a g7dž; -y^(gPBwa-&j rYfzz^kh' 8(Lc
R,6o|UnhFCKd
cHj }I5CC.Djb: qaN<OA+[QhU*R` zbe]m%U W?ɛru_^!D巽6a]hQ4? M#Skk8kF >ncY0ILB ␕ tEUIE+<ߒ(tp zd+-J[X@L_mk* 8(*kݰ; 0&@d! BG} ^ E R>s 2~O+NH4d&́oAτV @U\";|US:=G K^$g}@.{#.ie1Ұxzj|ʊ خ|zY1רQ YyK~ȡ}:j/ Z搿=V{W~xRC9 _9\(U}2 #r:)
A˱t!#sUr|@E⼁8POxcNnajج. {þ N{;Q(*$J/{pt O${5!i_?p?W"M" 3O3if=u7Bu K2ctNgʩrNP3?`&Sr'|.y"{Q~xqG
qAW m;,
mSݱ!:ʹ@?
(K;e9tiNJ7IW \]s2*ynsK;b2'3E}S^RIu<后\iS(Fۓ[` z>$Z[vEx"B{tDϔ J4)Uw 8L y!t]]}zެUl
):(mnKr7xfɴH QnT>]7R%K1r9} Ö 䠞+5.ah ?ǒ߶/Ї^z反A˒ߵ
`-~ x(+vuh}΅o2H_44EtΏXJvIhXH 1{^=!(ssIIwn[*
XV~* X8>@*6: Dq51X [ʹh lۯLi*q*ѷn3`Ƚ4M x 7e@=~F up 'FgtZKv#ޝ̍@jN:? UF:A?U0FJ2a3?,C6va:
#ϊAct]VkO e P./\.}`3<_%m; [v_4x;GȲ~r
[G&~5ru!." (ŹRDs0/nd!νF>Qv 컜_+m \%9u
MBހX
> d۞==bǶcnu ̓Q>@u 9 zܛTp C߱'wRQX'pc 0|sshmUǪnK} B.F(ְ]EW߾ ^bM'hDȊr_UTW ?}I
C1$ gJERjRmhT
ba툀QwM^b{q|/j[66Ft.%͵Lc?y^|sń
hԡ2&Ժvv$/pjɫu{xJy~XBMmz<`"ˁ1R u`DNiVпv}Pfqx [(_Us>X6sz{Y Ն6CL]#.ь5`iZOv:h"ՔU&Ϫ ۪h m@Ϊ_=4>865ڹ9]g''zB5x#m;(`9-Mbl+9lۚ#?GNo!S}W-+\VZݟ;gyLa .HեMt@+tn[QrD(MPtnD][ѻL}fˬtJgpQ YrIFO=vb+ n:wSn0mnm?GsY3K9 |- ="zuܝрځr+lGXjM\~Z!ΏSٗj1m3bq.iL|Dœ~\Dm;9\6WU'0r y|\Y\vb vxcF?r%d)+L/C_g\̢/ > ;S(RQ%6: D KW&jN Ym.k+wj~=
% %.^\Ik>~ƾ!6YγuM~_;%2t՚XG} bO iA mB{-盕'tQ JO+ɑLp`IF:?gE}uVGx )RqJ%0ҁ=Pa|9žQrJƻHupF"'0
Eͮ+ן> j/kz%4d9cvSyA*sQ>w*Gh9~OaS>+30Xgv-CwA}o I$J WT);w6mg9OMN}Z
AmqR]ƺ$ϩFib B ș~Ⱦ8VEp=
'yS*e ?2uA+(+K+.;]@À7 ƎkĠ_l9v-fMD|%[%aOOksCC ri 4Rl9r9vXӥߴ]pH -R;j5_?-3|gxkr}%A "@x iy ӂ J(aC5逅Fᕩ[@)3uԁZV[/7ؙޙokַ{[d!ue (5g
%(%\ƹ5 @$Ib(bvnB: I6Ֆ4&,qC,wf˱6VudSG^_2X3!~'pW!Y%\kpy@kvN&
o)sTUDn;)cϻm~Ji!xW^F+2)f'w;J献T5ԕ6ss
E[I_kv ظ{H-Wӷ? WGBV{=)~ĉ}Oص8ꝲo)o8l<8 IC1FgXdl\QLcP"1VocQH-rE1?wI-Qu!.F~ԇ.rR TqhR
7Ҵ-[ yip'u鬣|_[rM~ؤ5D?r$Ά<8aʺ?m>^彆 'P)7g{k6{l\ ߾JcbJzM9RC>kVH-t
>EO@cv"GGAɥwX
Df(oP=º]JlធrSmȗ{}Git+Gʐ/<| yY^#O^
k͵Qg4՛3V-''!}"ߐi
T`K)*J2 CI[(#Xu +Xw$ Y,=)K Bݬ]`=oN
?
/^>dOp {vΧsN /HX:[J !ѩ$1dUҕ{YvM:Mb= SNVX}N.-z"w>)-R] ^kI^&=RņI-ӡMEP; ޡ@Ğ {Vu4$k~ Bxҟ: g}ìFן^mm\W{{rƃ'Zt# 'fyBksVvH蟓3]Ls`~19 J z3Co,0@41 (&~Vyl.fq<
A.XnG~}~ mC*۵ kwJ~ua8X:Hry#oFn6ݤo~Zb^
XhMur h`Gwz;ޥjtTled;z8_Mn*l ~{ce侩I.B
O͔f$ͥ&R>:36ZsJ܊A^$ϕяe UG:$* @#2ѽ%f{k>9-]yzxֺۡOɫee3mf,;ꥷĉ bPc4 RP er|7d %$ tlGi "3D6L'^v?R_$z&x9ɑ\8}\(qF/ F e)`ZPMc$ [ $8/
bl}o'jNo~iTz}jlzHƧ6 t95C`:֎ A>>
E̽ $yh]乳'-c69[4Ki%-dEJ[|@zR#keԲ_OdC_09="dsX+bgd?;l&&5uj0HƀQSSY#cļġ{dVgeˎH)呗5R\Q~S"эRs !sb0G.Y|6*0;OZmx_u@&u Ć ӎNX/
,yR sUZfUɎH>#((\#ęb]׀@ ~Ƶ1%u#H cmF毓aI! :jW Xit
clLWd Y
[g;$ ?iW{kYeRtsY7~hLl 9\.ʿ"q;.;h=)(~m8'MM k
vҚaКލn<^77o=>X؝7(Ӫ~q5Q .'Qį /b?e샩4fޗO0UA/66 ޘ|+ꨝA|5EA;qF ¸6~{*\3ǩO= ;rUlc+e\Oy !w"(r=}] g߲|};ae pkw퇜 6 :=h~"*h˾gc.c'"Vnq
!ΐbyKJ+ S*8ﲏς6!{Օ y1ރ6sobyqp}c\i'kΈ FKk
sG]'vT hv'U] 5] )gy iiI{Gwm.9G7 'nO9o`+Kݏes4+Ok&jIX+G[h ď1l\GDh3
"#|!ڊ>̽ _8cI"'`9Gf}ϳD]':zOh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fs8Z~9呓'CX#rt)_HjF9l
(O|pvLA5_Nu~M*K J$ccbURUT%LOtH==R-X00jZ ZTՑޞKF'P=RcYv;7, ScԎ)Wēx2
cu) %;LLn3CuL-a\g]`G/%#pP I#r6EdG -X0 um'&[B [2rc;]lwF@D=L J+ޗ ]@Ҕ})\1\*-Ӕf ̐2dZd8T}T V7oG
۶A" d dF^ﺵCB?gD;mFȝE;mjջ1ϗ x8(;}į]wi:U?;մ{z+JF̭^T.ަ2 @pm9H@W8Y
dm9 rF.ߏy1a8R9gͶr✒;wPwSg&W+SST CR
(~5w8)sSI>4xRLergJ&ÈuN&8y
FAxV- /s`Ga8,ݨe!$!Jo|i!9mlUث AvzSR<(E@@ m/\w
1$" }ќ3f59w. Axn d
ȕ/Pf ePfEa?cY<=@[;_xS IpS ~Q=.kɺ3K}_]puLHF,e)5U)(b(T"8i
`%0D0=kAb=Ezsmvm:k__ؤ8o.$D,cg! NBF;uJJ4e:1u[.QՀr}Cu 06!-Zy FԪ[;ˤsϹvuh
dU-$S%Y=33(I`paC@I=?-WaC ^,P&Qa#vDm*Wwy GOCOCO)f , * YE
̓JZ+mnlxˊf ,
9* L L=յe'%l=_'HKY< w q`pIK`[ƈ̂Y=s"[<.= W + s\]k-
^31ß uf@ ( ܔ{3`X\0G ]cc##6^
$:|}GO b5k_k!J? | RBLhm
>GD6
V8ӿ ~Vp>kڇav"})mƱФ
}o|L-ӎ0i N
nL?O:fJD 8~;9O ,N?a CGa ] &5`阧m_?'Y1n [q?sbAbꏝ x:0?tb/q >;, '-C3W2268/Pf;u( ],r EDn&/&Bq˼NI9u0}"~ v3Ve{MK vJ"p#V{lC+l)v]Et^G_ԇO
v*vO|+>p>
lQ[&Y
lM ܻoyht"e4*n1Kls\v-[1ϔgssi<[<=&56UUեJ*Q7TV(9ܠQ\] 8\c?%gPM9{g+WsJGϖWP[fBik~{|f1
ö[OɦxK=u>^-IP[yKBGsWD:uE&B_Nr?}%(#i2bre$e$Bl@Ȱ_#T%ާ}\} jA r\-V.ƨ%6:B" 6sQ0 \R1 ="(!4/PHZ`35
My'1] }l,=zz (}r4 ![V {ۑq>Ped 1 S2>Y)gI#toZ ~BiZ . Ym`{v= |1A>ʟAksg*jvhf֬
: \W-w]"yv%RR,3ũQ4(;Shpi>~ -ID` V ؇
endstream
endobj
14 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 2/Type/Page>>
endobj
33 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(98-0349.a1)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\
ved%20-%20HTML/98-0349.a1.html)Tj
49.74 0 Td
([7/2/2021 4:04:28 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 74.25 591.75 691.5 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
/TT1 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm
(Cafeteria & Restaurant Workers Union, Local 473 v. McElroy)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
25.052 0 Td
(, 284 F.2d 173, 183 \(D.C. Cir. 1960\), )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
(aff'd)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
16.909 0 Td
(, 367 U.S. 886)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm
(\(1961\). )Tj
(Furthermore, the federal government need not wait until an applicant act\
ually mishandles or fails to properly)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(safeguard classified information before it can deny or revoke that perso\
n's access to classified information. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
42.943 0 Td
(Adams v.)Tj
-42.943 -1.125 Td
(Laird)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
(, 420 F.2d 230, 238-39 \(D.C. Cir. 1969\), )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
(cert. denied)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
23.416 0 Td
(, 397 U.S. 1039 \(1970\). )Tj
(Security clearance decisions are not)Tj
-23.416 -1.125 Td
(an)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(exact science, but rather are predictive judgments about a person's secu\
rity suitability in light of that person's past)Tj
T*
(conduct)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(and present circumstances. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
14.411 0 Td
(Department of Navy v. Egan)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
11.414 0 Td
(, 484 U.S. 518, 528-29 \(1988\). )Tj
(Direct or objective)Tj
-25.825 -1.125 Td
(evidence of)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(nexus is not required before the government can deny or revoke access to\
classified information. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
43.762 0 Td
(Gayer v.)Tj
-43.762 -1.125 Td
(Schlesinger)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
4.666 0 Td
(,)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(490 F.2d 740, 750 \(D.C. Cir. 1973\). )Tj
(All that is necessary is proof of facts and circumstances that indicate)Tj
-4.666 -1.125 Td
(that an)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(applicant is at risk for mishandling classified information, or that an \
applicant does not demonstrate the high)Tj
T*
(degree of)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(judgment, reliability, or trustworthiness required of persons handling c\
lassified information. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
41.073 0 Td
(See, e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
(, ISCR)Tj
-41.073 -1.125 Td
(Case No. 97-0435 \(July 14, 1998\) at p. 3.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Under Criterion F, the security eligibility of an applicant is placed in\
to question when that applicant has a history of)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(excessive indebtedness or recurring financial difficulties. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
23.075 0 Td
(See, e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
3.332 0 Td
(, ISCR Case No. 98-0156 \(November 12, 1998\) at p.)Tj
-26.406 -1.125 Td
(2;)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(ISCR Case No. 98-0004 \(June 19, 1998\) at p. 3. )Tj
(Applicant's delinquent debts in excess of $40,000 provide a rational)Tj
T*
(basis for the Administrative Judge to have doubts about Applicant's suit\
ability for access to classified information. )Tj
46.032 0 Td
(The)Tj
-46.032 -1.125 Td
(question remains whether Applicant presented evidence of extenuation, mi\
tigation, or changed circumstances sufficient)Tj
T*
(to)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(warrant a favorable security clearance decision. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
20.323 0 Td
(See)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
( Directive, Additional Procedural Guidance, Item 15 \("The)Tj
-20.323 -1.125 Td
(applicant)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(is responsible for presenting witnesses and other evidence to rebut, exp\
lain, extenuate, or mitigate facts)Tj
T*
(admitted by the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(applicant or proven by Department Counsel, and has the ultimate burden o\
f persuasion as to obtaining a)Tj
T*
(favorable)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(clearance decision."\). )Tj
12.873 0 Td
(As discussed above, none of Applicant's appeal arguments demonstrate the\
Judge erred)Tj
-12.873 -1.125 Td
(in his)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(weighing of the evidence, or that his analysis of Applicant's overall hi\
story of financial problems is arbitrary,)Tj
T*
(capricious,)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(or contrary to law.)Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
0 -2.125 TD
(Conclusion)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
T*
(Applicant has failed to demonstrate the Administrative Judge erred. )Tj
27.325 0 Td
(Accordingly, the Board affirms the Judge's)Tj
-27.325 -1.125 Td
(November 5, 1998 decision.)Tj
T*
(Signed: Emilio Jaksetic)Tj
ET
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 16 369 cm
0 0 m
113.32 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 344.25 Tm
(Emilio Jaksetic)Tj
T*
(Administrative Judge)Tj
T*
(Chairman, Appeal Board)Tj
T*
(Signed: Michael Y. Ra'anan)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 16 267 cm
0 0 m
134.795 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 242.25 Tm
(Michael Y. Ra'anan)Tj
T*
(Administrative Judge)Tj
T*
(Member, Appeal Board)Tj
T*
(Signed: Jeffrey D. Billett)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 16 165 cm
0 0 m
120.645 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 140.25 Tm
(Jeffrey D. Billett)Tj
T*
(Administrative Judge)Tj
T*
(Member, Appeal Board)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
34 0 obj
<>
endobj
35 0 obj
<>
endobj
36 0 obj
<>stream
H\j0l/D `ۤ\8$54Q)]XCh5fav4v{q}xMX, .wv*J oYϻx qoۼAg5
l_CgWzFG{VWîa=X_mR tc4ESٵvͫ]Bc߾; 6Ue !o/*-ƞ̶̮ޣޣ̬Y>~KނP/3b5Yg͞5z
}>zAG#
o"&>< O'3L_/+ <|
yX5g5%>stream
H| XWǫ^C*r)^3=3.^#Y jp\ 74v@ : UH } Lёa'-\Cy\c5nWx\o F\y2>$6,!} (-a+[> qRܨ6C'Dmn_q"@@ (,|5ʵ?eA
B Jb x;f@/
ilBzM_u@* -
D~WΏ 7wE
{^|(*ԭ\ݣACF4mRK[ԼEV?iӶ]{ ;u5[O{ջOO}|?~ 0 54z1#Gō 36q&LI65y)3SfN1w -\X*ko0doܴlݶ=g]ݷ?C -8VxSŧϜ=w.\,tU~hi.VUGphSh[ɋh<%R*͢t^z,Hh#|+3TapBx,T
WP SlD*3H更 'i[*J%Tz)h"45|Mvv6MPS tun&:IBJORxxier]EdoAc$9YNgy' 3y@ ԇQQ}<}zm\ms :X=~ kwkkokPf3Y
Ph?(7DJ i-PsfB;a&f sRCPUu:K\j$i~R;!RW*H7+
h4 M m6=WΡNC./8!gɛs( q]s B}Ӡ3r Ur`u8@k/k.?
x}#Q3`⣖\I8:8 vt9 ʍ RltZ[YZX>4-fy P]ȼȼƜ``_)46s05}ަ> Sg¤355yXa,7ZwO\>:n\oncia6Zv=䆑C5yݮ :.qtrQ<
u
HK@/ /b{w{P8&%Ne
ӾkNt]r8/r&=tR B2LS=dG N*=E(o4+4N3(fv6W9TER5I5dc)1 Ȕ̉auyrf sen̝y:@؉1։uf]XWփdXoևe~bgU(> X,STerrr2E9SLSRV+(3gs/Y f_F1@60fٿ (;wg0K A)p q;EJqм9zAnfEnvCnG~yܒ<,ȣ<.OȓIgYsŹ\sn:M.ʿd"šTK1yPQ,|S(S&,D BY)e rQnʓY+JROT
R!*LE(m Aww=}_{QQ*F)JPI*E `
Q4B))"i 4&dTRRVSU>OJV) ;,eɊ=l8
[t3pFę9 g5r698'ܜi4].o9؍|ߍqc87 pA.ą7p rQ.9KpI..qR] `w].WJ\pUչZ\p]Bnȍ17܌sҬ܊[sn=w܉;* w7pTWt܃{r/}/xYdhcbM <0 #x$G^ȋx1Gs r sͦ94|b)b))i -DS6k
qS q+
y"^yŽ W+xe`/+*pa.HqOOk憻n g vd'{J^eWիUjx5Z^mWx
F^ck/Kko[C1=`xN3ܧ N>Lp9Sa Wi-2bȄ r#(kȆȁ @n7yQ QQDQCqJJ "شCʡ<*"*2*:j&j6 ZFkA[C{t@GtBg|. ]h: ^>~:. :o?.,Bt @G]r@]T:|gzg桍I'?` a!aQ1P!\C"i&a<&`"&a2`*a:f800Y9y(,BшA,$b b~rJjZzlFlflVlv֬.v]Wbb x*5qp /8γT rDUg.F"J,"L
fd6-ff fev=撝bi油bfovigvk gUi:Cgڣ;AXYPyπH]D 6EOՠ{UFO/;=(9 Y)8L>LTV[41, ذ 3ěc#ڇ;j]D \5
;+E,J]+9 Ѻ`rg&+n"FCo/ʏ"a%&DÈګ{}m gp)WR~ Vqs.EN~-_-`OdP1puJ~wweV&-o =H``tp@pJ?^sf6PJn_ė2#s
YPk(۰m;Irl] XpLeg%} ̗?3`m[$-&w Q#+I`YsJ:vvA J[mTolh7) Y RGb/nQ)"K$t%
1^Hq8GVs^TᏸAŋqqVh4Rw^(^wɞȞ lPq/$[RAq9H(04HSEYǘê]\@dn7ԤH] #]yɖ҇-{dVpt FjbŅGBǜP}dzڢ&qK^LegNպ\*CŨ-v5*o܌T!VOVO~ (K68twL y5Oж%O:: JF+C?W}pw{wII,XdÑl eccC!51H- 30bҦ$iӖL ;!L:
̴fP:EӴ#wgL= o>2jIw6ݎA6BVfG(Z u=]st /̯[``s P\0cV40 > D30Щ:zO!Y @pp`OGe'6&v@#!mT8 =&c{l}L{O u-.crM
C_6rؒj@,}`xD1k" I,sszQ"q(D¹4뻿mƞAAΌl}n6ٮEhco)-bXx/Mɬ3Ҋu.d vG@%wCta\bp'
sELqx`{1@F'I2 g*[Y{@QzB=u#R +75V qN 82l;2o$.9i@ty]0ڞ$1c=?
캤 8@t1XBF[37sF3|tl{\-iy5iHd<7rX& Yx ǒt ϫJҢKRh Zt_UFf*[bMZW[1x+{ Qyasωg. ^Hrⳮ?kKw~k/ϟ9W?:K ]lc]u?kz߆?ꚽ|ibO D?Y}E)ePק{:B8*r.J2WP@ xn2*^0`pMޱzi]wbvQ!NgqTxt ?g c>% A.pa/aHT}cn9K5IXK
LDx6ImME'\Iţ"{Rph-mGkuscp !^B J HLM2m
j dy)SU4dR|Q_5zہ'c[;l꽱C'ߨ~Gy f6">vaF6>/1Bci x߬>_}z^;NOa 2N]$ʜ$&" 6]6: Q
7? $!O$ZD'*bf
~L7g >>26$I,G~^%&Emӷ!N1hρn]k-_y O|gV]@>ݴoyJyU;>y\{]Ϸkgyq¸Zk:A͟:""q]sIEQGٴm(w
3Iplzφ) K=p0hp6;xxqWy p!y !Qr8mf8, x
`ΎP#DŸHX>9. A
=* gC 8jÉ4AǓtw%.1L&g4-S
:< 48ȆvЬlʰiҪ6Xsm0QCwHC
"|Rjڷx u64P+3oEfKh╙18ŭwfN]3/ ƯI< #laj*YTJӈ95MA/ KE_1;ND "; w>g߇
t@が |6`{]ýgڃkn`j-J+M3Gg/>E_ĭRn_?MC*
U:lYP>3~Hi(0uYggmkݛ][[C=A1@ gaICw:
9fuIBɽu >5A[g%}#:Νx;n'a(pm6=lZ2LU*f(pcHհbĢ2X1+G;eU~ƙ+ >Rv}DGȯW}5s=1S]s z ;ҟб;Yς:B>|
4/i i%vuGW= \|F$x -_,S g4 O'.P݄
Od%\aceH(DG 8y?q]@]ܪ3Be6Øhsi
'ant 0i< X+GIx G3P>Roa}"&jy ~Vd9QB r~] ?|wJBQ|GG ">V*}lǁkO3衁%
Yn*"6ǜ_ٮЬwo
į^z `|!Ajԣ O'-gٳҹkE!(
R-XD}`MDixv,dr,
+w,ZR($q؋,+Lx^_gC)2m1#'@N9@@ژu;8Mz/F2ܼ?'CvN/O5[?QT/ES+U
u O p $;%Rrx1/?
D)3r Xo* Ms$f4H$UrAby
5F z{ҫV> 2lzQ@XQH~H 7/m,S\\l
g UxR)τș koM\ r_h۴]\aK{#F$,
l ͤeP4Go4"
BVaH>[Zf)j)NW5ֽETݺ7oMw.@=~ ^2S^Wz9w=FΟ2{2E!. U{c9b@rL 9kȦG3eHaip$4&5J{!x f,lNߑuԌ1A+V *Z1ަ8t#\##<1XZ`~zppi3ҷ^iX+(E @TVE+
2[cQ>32(--Qdv_4='ęmTaMc)9r+i¾:DJg$B5вF Slq~\ZK܃0( D# BƧS6rƢuՕjiqS
CCFV276Ni'𘋧YY%,c@(C 'cDP/$(!,4k
@ű~\V0rƉ`9<4p2s,SM
8x2Гy ˊ"
4aЗl͂~Jr "_i iE q0dK8tz] 1J>%;[ktFˑ@2%Gj$sNj OkOq)#2 @*rWIM,5tfV/5F_j#v_à=j}B ^s "W` pU.-ҵe{h|w;s=N/w
G=< mbq9
)t stqi98 {=#\'ܼ,_svjަV+50Vq / beom cŷ1n\ j>ɽ''u+YK~n|xKzĝ'`M:Uja4.B0K%Rh.rT|4 -
ʨ&K$:ͱT6*ƈAMG%*K1\<
(D؈P w Q 8u=;D
DSHh
xCr ~7SrɐVecd"" $\
bvFOX 9Y:#@ג\ c^ݱ8|-ݫ7Wr{{|*d߰X݉-ٿh̕ ~-aT 8"Ur`,~;ſ1uK#]qgN+[)
{ A@,- ?1LƌbqIQ$I܇@xi3QɁ-q I/Ѣb63dc8]rct#畢\gBR~ ܤ\ tt"zkTD.2B#"3W U
,ǽ
.n;'=l d8xa!rm_nX8A=f#igΖY|%۰ z?Z *;| ge'i< ʯ[@;A` b\$8p#ƖI7Leف
?HԛuV]NTK}T_\Yin#`EJӕX%QIҕH%Z1h˴rT P"
>OTڬjL)/@NRU$ [bYfs8 s 98w k8>'4ɢT2|^*o[ȟc&'e'Q{= E.6(壱po{PCT'Mi0T7$BaJwkpk&T 'R_f[7.z(b{2>+`ҹU&1`YsW|^7\{`nV^B)l+8tf?ݧ[Di_zLӍRPyz/PJ_rQQ;~`Eht͑jy#Xcb@:aP
sssgKO4& B21y''1GFX yӈa"jRQդ=yabOҖ75ڑN"{ /D E#~?N>(A'JH՜J rbOvy$! U*do(*#Wk::ԐQ_UJjLC
jjy!z8D? Y\>U^]N`'i4u G"6mPۙ-ytW{l ]|uK}>&qLh)B(t]`T˚nL#ͦ
X6J[%2V:&nZUM2tR!ǝ~>x ￏa`w:Te$Bnx )vh%(4eY%/c%hVg tI r@:6Z|7垱]'/gWFԌVo;(7.w5O , K
f.C(&x\'gxt*|Km5`ˊ } Rn-騩
xSK%7a-`- <*19|GS~E@q&AB2 vu1]F7ۡ#
:Nm'e~(;*ɓ)VQ:BLBf]ϔP-!S, c5Zd'jn@-
; %*HiJ/QF&%n_8}2~D.
b4[/zk<_ym˦ 6Dqkn(3P+s SDH@ULH B S)cLۀG#"ӜR(@+_K?3u&OϜ ;zbSNvi(-6K(F=OcN'mwZv k
'w pKy|P<&/|+7@#' +ɒOb*F0
6ѿFzU zj+3#O.o z Q3fT M*J]a*dq\#8NFf,
KmU Z $!Fޱ@e4r(a U0#uQlj؊ ΨBUM P+FRv϶= T ubS<[sc٭?:b6jb(-ؚu!3M 岹?TYxot"?]j8\ufiI4S,SßӭHxl
= 3Sɸѡ[fW}G%Tѳ oŐ% M DDXiUha:soFW[J
;W^fvbOU N!&\Ck}!ZY={?V bvx8 6 LLh^l-r1i9ye+f|ӵIƙ3;{94 t93}dm$gUu!dW0LFs"FMRڭdOgD V5Ab#fY Ҷy'Bk~c!F1L/#DZ[dPY8 -J)^/0 Ton*3jΣf D[UP*EnlYm6,@nUpu ŕأ Ó7EƅxG8w"ԡ'?ung$?39PH_ro LmwsDn0c4@\|nQu~DzCg6lt~WعGd:XeP 6S[BC~~DpJ=LUbPD AdaḢQ1,uGGxI 0Juq
fkvEH$m&HkE#y]R[9da &r6-Y.ub[H/W&ލGEl\nj4| ('dR`5 @3\qUaǗw6qq 緻'w/w~K;7@ĘHBC ecR:V#[5 l%Ka됊:1mڤIgOF[Ҥaܝ`{<~Ka0r+ !uBr8R @$MSt 1-
wQ2,f2S20t[LT_NZ0^[#FbYabdP;B'c [䕥]Kk+]3 % j*):O ^nmhBo<ʲɏ8 DM/)2H9B 4Ŝ4L ;l3IDMHn :)WT &TUJ*
<'3l cqpc[Ցg$v旰3;U-GD袬9YɲqN ,1 `]L,3X16ޒÃ$dL"u #aBo?$S4&{C_ZX h 5!&"N+$ QÒV'oI|4NGq`U7A{ L$ _-I)'aD;ޒ8R"sGt`6:C?EP?@D KH3 i P "KlAb
i
<{sJ ֙4of7Sax
9 5e\=fO}= \7 ev<.]af4_G
^<]IBH pб)4uRe
$#֦}hm L g+X݃DҶb/D eֆUpbouF
pAWJڀ-#Dxk-2zcCCsrX m 5%'6'}4I}uQ@c$BI 9T
$Cr
wֳ`*q ^Ricw97O)OTӟyn*O泯'ywv =_ӚniC \ F샧4=XyrA +rVr#d4QݴWߐHtz~7c1X WM eZYP#68ғ5/L}ǿ%?WBLYZv
}ne 8eEa|فP컝#Hd<tS@ `KCg6ĊcMh8 F
}N\HcF,/`pE ZU{!dt/WrwTU1 =j
iұ܌.6&i.yE+ }&Ȫl-lW
xz
@,ʅ[e E7EƖ5ɴl|l)c2eF{D
E{j Hs|94d]G,ْ21(zMfz:!;
pwmPgj.y8j.L5"j5F ;0k0OH)CX 85oI >aBVKo^D%E6 g0{h".duud辕|c?$SSgNz;WAޥJ_! ǨO|+r?} d]ԡsRf8Hh,n`pڌAZԓ$I;PJA`kTZv'rx+*xCCpQ@I* ,n)3{k?wKOzLyhY<' Kˍl]ScWVkn'"]>8Ll]Sq֖OׄԁNPQј#xpiy}4r*^ IxPwLGdP+'2T=iLۀ
N!O` L d=l3cRM}&hU
+
MDHqE:rHm#^8!ߐIt
Fw2`n[Iĵhn"<$Nv{HYuteMj oIV20l>BBC{Bڥse hhq9|M&:v9 qjNPFߘ`*N9 Y]zR ܴn܇J^G:4i,E D.ϫ$o*`'0pwhh O &Jyv9;IE8J74õ .Zo!5L .4Gٞ
ʷώt/" Î-݃NHou%0` ){Cw>4
[t/Q`B؏b:?ߡ?i`cChԀ} ew a@! 0b &i``-XeVq; PpQǸ} Fum Rlu K9Ib >j|߅?0Cibstlw>L\?ZGeY8e20! ڳ)"$_Sj V/ ]gp-$[O;Z{ ^Snj%D
m]ݾ)Ԇm&@=六TK"}J7> Wd<2k2GcmŒge6:RoJ2e@A(e˖yEb;s*Ni3$@*e*/X՛^v=̞d,N5HEQTwNdov7]\FRI JBIXy5 ʷ$5hGz>!aNGG-k I 0HFl@چw1+קd Gqǘ? L![J
ƛ1ŕf{Ϥ#۴FڠFM1v|pt~%p{ڣPۚk *]A~du6QH#~9fͻݤq'NR.Wj˞ {7K4l 6;3 @鼀Ev7tc
_rД8N k{u/cѡCU8y6t X Lѣsd9Ǧ$b<
doS < +},_H?T9pʧEVڍvpWX(S[j,R5_U]wu (YD:*bUBoļ ]q %BfZ|ߏI3 ף?ߓYt?} clo'HMķ:Fefij G1ξ}=i6p[aӧsT٬d2͒f ܻX
+Q'OZs- Iq?LJ Y'8%s3! w'ֈpΩSF}0? k dxUK 3{f*=|@_$u
>܀NCl` s?.g P \- .A& v?/b|+b7U o϶=ǂqci#P,68-xae; طg\^8~H {'(Qۀo$}_3i+(}ud,GtoTky _r{!Y[ݑ4~b :K84X5BdhZBbxo'γVjU!
˪Pg9cUavkXoߵyتhe5*%iY#JWUʓG7BMV6|_w|]W:rU-gьw\\ rjUffRjKl)90sn:z < o)CF5az5q~F:< - iOO4JQMR7*+ۚOn.yQ-Xu)gj]j;ǧΛȟz#O]4_t r ^L'6Kiv\̓j9D1u~<
.T:[>=ZD-`O] &P|gОFg* {gPj9gZ" |s
v} 8йk
i>SJ_zǫ&5~i:X\2DXCRͭ6rܯ8{i YD:aQCDiuQpvIN">$\op
assNlL_t xZPTVh M>!OKz˪ܜm |p` iDL Af>M05ډ__$O:P| jTS8 ;z¸@b>:O5نYjRU/h4-uuQ+H-CTk֚Hji #4J'm60I8θ^յӵi;WCqfA;9k( DYޙ%` K1*Є" 123=L!B, n6wWq7ND_B> B ͖<-`R _ E{chG:}`90Hk lR[$~+y{qn-[I }_s+?5`ne~c^enc>e> Ip5' T'KϘKϬR'/GQ.6UHW_![A>h\ \y %7]y*
mo(E7s=^c:9^~ڜQvi q yy\Ge}LMcDh6+QU]5 D E7Dd&K^R5F[_:bUg۵{vXM5PU]`S'uy`[9>wBwO%UnV 7x13naeI'Ft ۣ~98Pq> q os t=6?;p? ٲr`Gx.U?P#|Uh6OR"9V b;z
؇3A& 9oD2Ϊy%DQTEV:4li-
Bf%,!XB(6(){(X,}CuT,R*w|@N/{ fC f*y{eF$k.ud.
bA&UWSE:JdEH;y^yYh$̻ky
tRҙ31͑l )m. W͊ts?h1g?X8^ r;8Q~4fY5 +N sZ%n-ev&Կ'BVz:y}ev]3ګ3\학
2\mL(ryޙqP[Ǚm k_L(?L$ʛ2^P+s ĺ0 ^_6Ğց鑎C:a;;X||_,?A s}G %NC }vu!gjp5 @۔EuKeHx}.E7ǰE=al)xެ_EX (h mv0J/y7CfɚwdZIs/ƉcDryFZj^j+vSN|
7ĥR˜5_V!GcdL#wWJ] ë,KB?ہ;h Ӽ3Ă:+d gF &|N
|Kg5-/댷/gⳏBUPt+r%-!z!ZK3 /5Fcg.=vs6c`%b1on9i̩8U|$!g!u~\g_a c] i&NhDnqz#CX4ҥvcO}TM~CĻٞk VMƈ׳#6CwtKd#8&s:η RHw|^3
Dv.U}`M5=cpٞ5@?hJev"eI/ǻo] o FybЙ;h^ ]wջ.]`q̋MpUP״gM]=7ݜ>w 5K ܵyi=Z y\MAKl3,Zt3_Pޑ
lx8Ǚ65wnΤ_'s5g'sz
c=3t{ؚS^G |6U!M $7LX}M;5yi۰ uUz 4˥ޖq.+Fj̬
2U0/Z9-S2UB<u8:|1w6G6ReS&{61& fáݥ$x_%M c?qmW'mn֭9g7]1TOGJF8bw[`ޒϡbZr#BwJ8^0rx/E8v9aPsMY=$}٣lQ5b7sWxNjsw}!;'umUX gh
.̂\~%/tC} mNV-zAT+I|
+d>ݪb1Y,罕}{ΡޅPE |h5(2m@;59r\&cq4i˭ zS@kj GdYd7>rK f 7LG}oy2]'5ei"9!dSgP=bJ(ϓ&p{O9k3 d/CX&Ó>yFJ@02mJ+}'rSR_viMz.;ԖmFN{מ/<(im:}m)2 2C r`;-3*9\\1V :fg_ɧffWܦv\.ͽܭyކHZ mdV 5kLGE cevj0ޕen znr{Yq{w
< ["윸*g c_%C`\֜8%Uιrk{OgLlwH!uiG~k9ۗ^Ϲ]nyw1#{~#gk 5YY돕}ޛ䎱.fO+TgRwŋ 5WT;9o
ґ1 kŧ9w :OHus ?+EhZ;Ԅ'rjn|Lz/% ry e7LNv v SaUQN7#="9 L'yةEmS/4S^܃ K}~{YO. 㹭Azo٫ټzEƛB^1TxGwU q|{b"p+5MGD%D<"Q(`(@x$GP(
!H $K)5-Bon!>{ݙٝjfge`Xd6CD|%' ROC%8%jR/}6 Zk%?q 2 zͧJ 4uސ`u{H%p %9d_2b=ğB#Ch G] Ayat<ˍLۿny=2<_ ;z{'R
if} =btCAُ9ɠw F/##xwD5 7r~F6\*_n@ ]f~=gL{}#jd4 :Tq:oeq}yLH~9T!,+0Vysh!BϯsQHCFg)W:oq̡jwAγZNkɔ @H=a1kq>0W4K*KMеd4ǹyqFk^k&4Q@k9ßkgil]z֥Au}zC w:jL|{qZ82f/ $0==S0>sw 4ں7]F0>f &\Tj& 6tu>=V}݁&âēW]m c-g!r:V?Ee%y!B.繏rӜF\(p;QZK q1>Q}H]1YNƪb& q6P*3csj
hEN<-q&.Lo[kDKKZaJzIfA 5RFRP;qfOR qyn3|DC=/8Rܥ'Q
NQ|⬓LqWC`s;:ww0_K{1ud{n/ l"^5M!%7)έ8_s/ܢ8px͎`/Mv 3<;cwpEt/SF CAPI <܄/T4DNkZQQsy,woq7YMu]@#F8S=TQӊ֚ 44|̔Ij<fɅ՚N\}Jg Mow { Y& `my5'8Vؠ5H
}=j §|jWS>6<*=C}R<3=Cȁܖ*mP"xWK4wH`>R>w"h{fudw"='?@J𥣎߁ 7<;"wEa,
U psyFx85Ӵ n4tw88Z)uT QG5eX)+MZp[ź.~]edF`7 tkūt0גNu'<,/ӯ`*u-}\kϦo#篪"T
-qZr5퇒s}8 : }k
\ýT3
`36û!yW N._v&r閵ۊ5v %?|@̢1o"et bo'Nz^'뷐c6WSFѫB. Qcu=_a7(y1UתmPr?Ot~KGaPy mbh%8u yg59XWWʑR@hv,T ^rۀ>kq^\r1'r>}ϓ9cv+ foEworj"y?=e7{c(MLE,[gNېyo& O`Ė@;" u:ؗ;g7~`_U_H`N?k5b| ߍU %~!QOqTQk
Xf} +|W >&_ ً!KȎRDK"o
9 z5b7u ~%_|A. j]~:s*jl:Z r "x1JkmA`I؇P4sҵ lN0҄n~Q\q68܌}űoC⻤@B8qLįb]|Ͻ;'**h)
.uH"UTш
DUGQi%*RQ3͛7͛ ׇ?+$ZL|^]NRz -dCt=Cɰ̇:#Ξ觪zz6 4\_
SMZNUg AZUձ rmȃAy %Ieق^lӰgG #)4~/QQHkZkW+*FGT7؇0,Sʨ_| ۰&;Y5oB5S #jEuE}a7y
^C,f C A; w\źjLddTyzN8 14 |iz[|!]'b"ˉRQ zEpĄemCb`қsS%ώtA2|+l)z֊tnrLlMOGzk~lBlelQ>g4_rّtNT3'*xC'&2^Ad ۆ7Q6 o|xXE+@#\1s{ueǽN`~<=kϺm4fb.0 Ԉ,$-JtOgQűoNڍ?ۨ#H|=>%U̹ G-9UeROKT=
s1Zsx~^Ƈ g/Ws $Xx-t,CvƔ8'J۹7-0^|, l*5o\UVuk:Vw$WfͷǜwS
0cH`5topN>7<52& k ĞxfG=zHsƜaXd'_19ib┪m&F*^_ݎj~FZ{Us4RlF>d` 13+fcg+,Cq fKR}[xh . zs8C
EDWЅ_iSZL3 >7`>ͷ Ãxɕ=uI4 5Lf\'MW$SW2# ب ծJLX%Xº#a
% kmjOXFz\%[_jwvmria}WXWMF/>
6[ek|paG՞1>ic徝e* < R0 UnP\?)b|;xYEʘƳdYƏ)lD!D ŕaU>GrZIUIv 9?^+)cԦna:-⇟⧌
KiG}~->G[ٜv@O{%o 俳˦q>E8W*0*~~?R}M9}9\GIS|a2kz{ Ww22~K|?ٞ[=~vDTXDM8dMd_2~E!0LB3oWCPoh}h]5fiMY-$(,VZuPT \JZM@L ɂz34^=yfIQc 7y{fD wa6f`EGЃFkɻ]yqyiP^P.?=#4QݗS9'|2ڻ%{ހm3Z1ΉdU,6+ سW33w=yx
ڱZ ]ӊ-.0`0ԭ;& t +Ie uIVaYE u ULNG!)+|P]WH><"r D΅r;J~9 ?s_Ss-w@'>QTsd Yr:gRdzqlF /KQ,J屴3JW }u,GKIw,N&07]\=1
qњͦ7hPQpܨ{A`Y9 *( wd|:ƚzwk9_) pї >eEѷ UDXP [W}}?< <
endstream
endobj
13 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 1/Type/Page>>
endobj
38 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(98-0349.a1)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\
ved%20-%20HTML/98-0349.a1.html)Tj
49.74 0 Td
([7/2/2021 4:04:28 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm
(Applicant contends the Judge's adverse decision should be reversed becau\
se: \(1\) the Department of Defense did not)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm
(advise)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Applicant that he should file bankruptcy to discharge his delinquent deb\
ts; \(2\) Applicant did not satisfy his)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(delinquent)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(debts on the advice of counsel that the debts were uncollectible; \(3\) \
after the hearing, Applicant filed a)Tj
T*
(bankruptcy petition)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(in which the delinquent debts are listed; \(4\) Applicant is current on \
all his debts incurred after 1991;)Tj
T*
(and \(5\) there is no)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(nexus between Applicant's delinquent debts and his suitability for a sec\
urity clearance. )Tj
42.445 0 Td
(Applicant's)Tj
-42.445 -1.125 Td
(arguments raise the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(issue of whether the Judge's adverse decision is arbitrary, capricious, \
or contrary to law. )Tj
43.444 0 Td
(For the)Tj
-43.444 -1.125 Td
(reasons that follow, the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Board concludes Applicant has failed to demonstrate the Judge erred.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(The fact that the Department of Defense did not advise Applicant to file\
for bankruptcy is irrelevant. )Tj
40.43 0 Td
(The Department of)Tj
-40.43 -1.125 Td
(Defense has no legal duty to provide financial counseling or advice to a\
pplicants. )Tj
32.768 0 Td
(The question is whether Applicant)Tj
-32.768 -1.125 Td
(acted in a reasonable manner with respect to dealing with his delinquent\
debts. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
31.712 0 Td
(See, e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
(, ISCR Case No. 98-0257)Tj
-31.712 -1.125 Td
(\(January 22, 1999\) at p. 3 \(noting applicant had obligation to deal w\
ith her financial problems in a responsible and)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(reasonable manner\). )Tj
8.357 0 Td
(Considering the record as a whole, it was not arbitrary or capricious fo\
r the Administrative Judge to)Tj
-8.357 -1.125 Td
(conclude that Applicant did not deal with his delinquent debts in a reas\
onable manner.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Applicant's advice of counsel argument does not demonstrate the Administ\
rative Judge erred. )Tj
37.642 0 Td
(Applicant's debts became)Tj
-37.642 -1.125 Td
(delinquent during the 1991-1992 period. )Tj
16.441 0 Td
(In January 1996, Applicant told a government investigator that he "found\
it)Tj
-16.441 -1.125 Td
(economically prudent to not address, and or contact these creditors" in \
connection with his delinquent debts)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(\(Government)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Exhibit 3\). )Tj
10.109 0 Td
(After the January 1996 interview, Applicant took no steps to address his\
delinquent debts)Tj
-10.109 -1.125 Td
(\(Hearing Transcript)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(at p. 29\). )Tj
11.968 0 Td
(In April 1998, Applicant told a government investigator that he did not \
intend to pay his)Tj
-11.968 -1.125 Td
(delinquent debts)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(because the "creditors have not bothered me about them" \(Government Exh\
ibit 2\). )Tj
39.999 0 Td
(After Applicant)Tj
-39.999 -1.125 Td
(received the SOR, he)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(told the government that he had obtained legal counsel and a lawyer assu\
red him the delinquent)Tj
T*
(debts were not legally)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(collectible \(Answer to SOR; Hearing Transcript at pp. 22-24\). )Tj
34.129 0 Td
(Considering the record as a whole,)Tj
-34.129 -1.125 Td
(Applicant's failure to)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(address his delinquent debts during the period 1992-1998 cannot fairly b\
e characterized as conduct)Tj
T*
(based on advice of)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(counsel. )Tj
11.274 0 Td
(Applicant's receipt of legal advice in mid-1998 about the legal status o\
f his delinquent debts)Tj
-11.274 -1.125 Td
(does not extenuate)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(or mitigate his failure to address those delinquent debts in the precedi\
ng period of approximately six-)Tj
T*
(and-a-half years. )Tj
6.968 0 Td
(In)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(any event, the security significance of Applicant's financial history do\
es not turn on whether his)Tj
-6.968 -1.125 Td
(delinquent debts are now)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(legally uncollectible because of the failure of creditors to take timely\
, affirmative steps to)Tj
T*
(collect the overdue debts. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
10.468 0 Td
(See,)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
3.332 0 Td
(, ISCR Case No. 98-0111 \(November 13, 1998\) at p. 3 \("The security si\
gnificance of)Tj
-13.8 -1.125 Td
(Applicant's financial history does)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(not turn on whether Applicant's debts could or could not be legally list\
ed on a credit)Tj
T*
(report after the passage of seven)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(years."\).)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Applicant's actions after the hearing cannot be considered by the Board.\
)Tj
29.003 0 Td
(The Administrative Judge must base his)Tj
-29.003 -1.125 Td
(decision)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(on the record evidence. )Tj
13.161 0 Td
(Furthermore, the Board cannot consider new evidence on appeal. )Tj
26.296 0 Td
(Directive, Additional)Tj
-39.457 -1.125 Td
(Procedural Guidance, Item 29. )Tj
12.496 0 Td
(Furthermore, even if Applicant had filed a bankruptcy petition by the ti\
me of the hearing)Tj
-12.496 -1.125 Td
(and presented evidence of that filing for the Judge to consider, such ev\
idence would not have required the Judge to)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(make a)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(favorable security clearance decision. )Tj
18.407 0 Td
(First, the mere filing of a bankruptcy petition does not prove that a)Tj
-18.407 -1.125 Td
(discharge in)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(bankruptcy will be granted. )Tj
16.356 0 Td
(Second, the automatic stay provisions under 11 U.S.C. 362 cited by Appli\
cant)Tj
-16.356 -1.125 Td
(do not apply to)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Department of Defense security clearance adjudications by operation of 1\
1 U.S.C. 362\(b\)\(4\). )Tj
43.765 0 Td
(Third,)Tj
-43.765 -1.125 Td
(even if an applicant)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(were granted a discharge in bankruptcy, such a discharge would not precl\
ude a Judge from)Tj
T*
(considering the overall history)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(of the applicant's financial problems in determining its security signif\
icance. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
43.251 0 Td
(See, e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
(,)Tj
-43.251 -1.125 Td
(ISCR Case No. 97-0016)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(\(December 31, 1997\) at p. 4.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(The evidence that Applicant is current with his debts incurred after 199\
1 does not demonstrate the Administrative)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(Judge's)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(decision is arbitrary, capricious, or contrary to law. )Tj
23.84 0 Td
(When evaluating the evidence, the Judge must consider)Tj
-23.84 -1.125 Td
(whether the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(favorable evidence outweighs the unfavorable evidence, or )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
28.765 0 Td
(vice versa)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
4.025 0 Td
(. )Tj
(In doing so, the Judge has discretion)Tj
-32.791 -1.125 Td
(in weighing)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(the record evidence, and the weight the Judge gives to the evidence will\
not be disturbed on appeal unless)Tj
T*
(there is a)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(showing that the Judge acted in a manner that was arbitrary, capricious,\
or contrary to law. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
40.375 0 Td
(See, e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
3.332 0 Td
(, ISCR)Tj
-43.707 -1.125 Td
(Case No. 98-0055 \(December 31, 1998\) at p. 3. )Tj
19.245 0 Td
(The Board need not agree with a Judge's findings to conclude those)Tj
-19.245 -1.125 Td
(findings are not)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(arbitrary, capricious, or contrary to law. )Tj
22.714 0 Td
(Applicant's argument about his debts incurred after 1991 fails)Tj
-22.714 -1.125 Td
(to demonstrate the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Judge erred.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Applicant's nexus argument lacks merit. )Tj
16.287 0 Td
(The federal government must be able to repose a high degree of trust and\
)Tj
-16.287 -1.125 Td
(confidence in persons granted access to classified information. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
25.297 0 Td
(Snepp v. United States)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
8.998 0 Td
(, 444 U.S. 508, 511 n. 6 \(1980\);)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
11 0 obj
<>
endobj
39 0 obj
<>
endobj
9 0 obj
<>
endobj
10 0 obj
<>
endobj
41 0 obj
(file:///usr.osd.mil/Home/OSD/OGC/JosephLM/_MyComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archived%20-%20HTML/98-0349.a1.html)
endobj
40 0 obj
<>
endobj
42 0 obj
<>
endobj
4 0 obj
<>
endobj
xref
0 43
0000000000 65535 f
0000000016 00000 n
0000000141 00000 n
0000003644 00000 n
0000141862 00000 n
0000003535 00000 n
0000003577 00000 n
0000003710 00000 n
0000003737 00000 n
0000141428 00000 n
0000141469 00000 n
0000141240 00000 n
0000004272 00000 n
0000131582 00000 n
0000094745 00000 n
0000003840 00000 n
0000003886 00000 n
0000003935 00000 n
0000004085 00000 n
0000003989 00000 n
0000004021 00000 n
0000004053 00000 n
0000004472 00000 n
0000008868 00000 n
0000008917 00000 n
0000008952 00000 n
0000009460 00000 n
0000041671 00000 n
0000041938 00000 n
0000009891 00000 n
0000010164 00000 n
0000010613 00000 n
0000042549 00000 n
0000094956 00000 n
0000100373 00000 n
0000100820 00000 n
0000101096 00000 n
0000101580 00000 n
0000131782 00000 n
0000141325 00000 n
0000141676 00000 n
0000141511 00000 n
0000141809 00000 n
trailer
<]>>
startxref
142034
%%EOF