yj3#`r`,rkQM 7Vf+k 2IJ_\Z|@j!=dsQV*zд>
twK/= ^/{^; h ^ \zTa
E;Ř,Lղ @̌Xj av(̋⃢C/aoOŜ[P|5nM[-aʺ`!V{h-y [@TȎ -A1$
Ů}A^*<=qs|ͲGBUbw
wTаK*T«bHnՊ1빌Q\D
\
hP+ FJ
ו?)[ӭ芇ğK}rvC}
!H&@Hab Mf;oCDs`N9o97},9X3S1^y̤؝2! ,ituFH@)'7
U~K>/#QwwRɞ.%|$ {dB ϸBo qC4 q hCq[0Ϝaޙ¼_m`k C7a!h feα2u0cBSHA,yerA*:T+yPnkyBy0;c2ES;q1H UX}ni_[)[
vTƵ\4?}Fɹsr_MPTi:4 \CSDN !BMpw3vv`Eg F:E٦$%ҹfa8{ګ;Z~k+[ƿumNk k{`zٜwZ41>0H$MYǹwcWZ;<7T=haݳi:/8YS
8tm[14? -F<.wދ h@ ]mFz`Tx,p QQP]#DiGP :QLҹt 7ZF NZCťY6НvȐȲ
iU%GW u%k%,
.,i! #J(^NĚn'Tfwcc5Z Pa&Ց 02uِRtCjqp'~ُ_?u~?ױ$a}d:q'
$^B HӫnХpA
Mq7v 4~ /Hx=]ZXlP j-q4u`:뵆(@H2%4N [GӖϚt30
I ʞU<`xR:s 0GHe)B/INF)1 h Ƒ V qN/_8t(Z@9ic5Ď0F]e1/Azur$`68h),lpYYv
ʳfb̥QMpٶ"ZpSd[cgOĚl|L{>w=p5/+3ʍ*TAM TLkU]B_m۪&b-0G4jtSmMUmJn8y ZQ
!us$W*B{*B˪,'8ö2 vB4s,Q9BbsZ"1*N s )fp}R)} ;wy>t'vt ThG'Ȋ$>#._ 6 ~ &[qDٳ e98 q9n?U
~w.!3vfl]{rj0 ]b $GZbv3$dœSf[,ɝAmw]d`H'Ӄkr7=1dUҨS@a+j:E)0Sn硤f%(d#R\ H#$c:3-Q$+M.'\M6.& xP "0İh4
MbSi &RDĠ>B6{vP C`(;fP,kT5Z;50a`?y{}lµqc{R!d rlEά4|r71{f+XbcutXcӫerǡwNd0e_e{W paHQ lvvL k=kk}k&hG Q˨mԾ1 gs{MO[lcݎ1m0^D[V_"vg @(Lf
`2伹@. /,.,--KZVپ&JAb,I^O_/9%b%љuz^ jn<{9; KhK'= .InyV:%PP
.铢+Eh]V]솘mM
#$甄ˌC5)c*dBN94! .i2֫KKU=CzHϑao/T%iZM!R\3u {uь.Mm:YHhvϑ;9H#̦yY-%m.99c- 52 d**o6(gˌ>"]T#ϼMaf4X"ZPł>859Ȁ @:х#`݄+Fo9JHMgκ:#:%
98 R_=P+N$F4Җ4P* LT: [ ]aaMjRK[!
VyLƟ4tm4NE@X-x%j
2
kA^ Fk,@1aR((7#3
;[RN6Soupzo@/g;8WR},m
eH:uY(Kcuʅ) )$16 R!˼-t
暶ܻ~mChbG}#dO&'*~8plS6[ l~V;Yc| *o3CWTjhR# W!h)\>_-
\C1*~ŧ> Jr>,a3h)j7t݅JW YUҮ~7Z6)JnEi<7ayXdžP)i(-$ "$_d^ upXEVWL:S]
lM
S~sagaWa ,>((ԭq9-.>4?g{W㽳}σrp~;WU<ԽlTwa<6Q's9 z^z6
SjޠU)S\lҝE`r݁q%hj[݃@Md5tLH (k C|єQqF|UV_Chjaӎ["[@f{!kwO|KT3a;͒3O
;XP$8u J}"=M XH0'r(P\ A"G' )*F%̑&ɵ Eu,]'f; 4,o7ArP:( tI4)Ommi4EFUt50e)*f]eU-83;)Gv+yZQPH_,&}B~tjZ邃[cZנcu07R+ى *)cM\ZJK"Kwɵ)NJEPUG;b3KeE Q@J7_b[[+רfD?df~d __bJ(/R^x `qi_6ޞQ @o茷G&U]d
(#8Y.K6Ԩx
M^!O9&?O$,1x@NA;Rw~7 f")YY_͋ 3Tc4 4dFpZx`JOEDoJ{Gӳ *7Q:H*V3BͨMpȆ*rE,8xKԛ)ۖuM -I28@brE/Ϡgϡ4!9Wq mklo3ϝ֝xw3{`xhփY))rRabC9NT;uһ'#ue(-Cdh-J,qc'e!o;>qQ
+ ,{tU؇~Nv>IJ
;'#h2?6d3U)ؔ *3 *cp G#vO7d0&V, ?0uzKݚF.+ )ﮭLVZ#Юo0Я{UA-Z+80? F+ie!ȯ56|nmhhН"8V8
Yb}lm8.'@Y >d B|ٴhz4,V(՜'-Mj⏜h&( %ūjY%
W1 YhH#]
c8!Qdr2r)nbO"՝Bmt|]z Y,Kj:Ec"8TT8@xm g~CqǏprɪҪ.YBa)WV2! {zit4eӀzI]g}B. 5w ^ &w;mjZ !Blg>r;E"9pExKҶ@48ەmZT 4KKD"Ɗ1$'.*eƔYQ> Y/uh{y4 Z ~nkC\$ޖŹ S`J8ui<@4mw?r;1vljCCW5d $+MT*u2X*Md Rim]u4Nk*dZ5&F(Lb6mMR}ϡг{wx4(
9lFE
\ɂPAdmUx&/^.Q+/o6 ZvF l_W~3ԏǗDz} MBxBi< >ېa}{NļMmi &gu?~S|/VG2VuSkx')nvBܠM'}3m/+d6g;wy!"FȍSKn6mNY<(ktn5kGYf4 -2Вk75]j~#YG)oy<4Rd\%LL+!sȫfAԯ&SMI/HߔDgb]k җq*Ƌ`V G)}K%J@ 4O8A M'.͛xw
9n KlH9N3P gŪX2{k5{flfJ&A2+Dѡh"maT
hQEtX*$4?NjwS
ॢlw!UʐF`D }ɐvǿ7^zU j 8m'=+Ɵ_n6@!?m} %C#0iRZK ,K&R&UF4Uؒ $PIzr5*?
VҊR%E +O ߠe
"`Y DI \26KE1keHR.]xU4=fb|7; wZ_ȴ0-ΒY)2pp $'rP g\P^藱jlPv>
w{ 7&*X6k
Xu)I G>2fjs2kHzZ441iQZ/bUܻ.ON0r@vܪ-F0~S
=fh1CO4XR 7Z?7mPAmP+ %vsmpMMi 8j{FϴA]R\MïmW}C u|(k6{V_Xƻ |Hwrs0~2-At_k@iQR.pO6>9FY\ؒW8Hl0e >S;yv۱ Sڙ嬵-מO߽XX.\+,ׅ69i$ |{$G.U]RanLX5*w>-{ gZӡ:rk97*PbJjоlȹ Y, @_v:&Mh7ѐ{>LQ C2Lӗpo^ ۋ65zSAfQ/2Cr
NMfS|yIC)6x
ʲ>-.Pik P Ǚzץ/>_/-q[*/S@?.
f4칵@ tAztPOkX.}Lȥr?BN*Dt6G½mgr8ךyLjy[K3 O|7OM$npX)Jt]NfDMb\X$[#(%pLCg`ǑxtkbW
h)рU@tRS O߱# yk5fllmkMX{ ` v \ '{h_b0k{C:ݿi͇|,4а7vx1ܙӻ{a(A\*Rr gTjڛeьf!Ψ, 8!x4FUa #8Gp !]<|*ՅQ//t mrشUm:yi'B
"h~- CLrMl^ fbXOv6qq}/g{vpw9 S_ P%
!-njq"I*ުnt#ҴaiF[ EȟǐX7U%Z:0{vA[_~I] όd9wR Q3_9].|z MϜW݀1 *?-?UceK<-Ӽlr|UC[9@ H-WDJ/95Lky4!E<=\2(<@j"H&!\x;"^1qIAJ%Q *Ĵ |~(PJ}ѱRwқN EC~i=]+{[w&dQlPƣN9Yg_haSxMx|kลF/ qѾNhK*0x] ;_WS?2ѽ. !僪F M ImKh_V!>Xvל7IrӀ9qIWr\B@74g6XjP
/Cm
}~*tW١ ;*;vﶢ>o<2 >dGehhGK A4z"5}|mgS7m_H%o*I4vWtBm ixܢ@p)*9GNQ.&20
Gc&̓
pivk^n)$:V+R sʬލ-_L+ғIkxfB!KCߐղ7@ǏF !j/8g.
vSmPmZא9mY\F;~r2dA'0'Q "+x& LWxkFW*7aHD!0h UMx cQ @@vlPze85zF.9 zq\yr2_\hmY . J/~tYii?_w%~Lr{?4u6H @"fZd6
)i(X?0) L0Tw$3F1J)N%J+1& K>O<o0;\[[#@Ƙk !0d@Vm6aouxN: <^y[#' *.^ \s]?d?7{RUej/=yvkI-˨[4z |Jڧ^]{}aTuKz%111 PCi!1|X: 1XwK2?.>]g
_ uJW@ZZ V˲Ob&4T4+C!b*y )t~/M0yr}b5t}Hc45iV11os^+ K)m k+/H6#g,l]֬gBKVb@_{OK4
,,B ċHxZO0BvU+
Y2i@8R9d3M~0pܩ)xx[zY\\XefQ-bhɮ0l]>1mT^lW]l; {&?=c;㘉Cb;zL l/Y!F
MH"UC%` ,#ê/luҢURWRE i]UUL9CPke9ޓ9'߄}jd8]$dlX.lixo ԝӑ
+zo9F.%}/#ݖ966(R76mCS] P.=|DVܚ <4\k
$.[ }k'{{d 5 SYW e'[wL}.U۞+>_1%P{ v! Ld6І0 0 Po$w䜌Oo ~`ECzŹz- 8<Nn{{[%6.FeƈLn m&˪BRjk[ꗪME%Uó{brgUfꢺBQ6b3btҟ.{DczF& eNlVf&#)6 n_OinWYD>1#k m̤6,$_QGիdSEЪL0Y5Y W͔%ZW*Q
~oξj `
ڪT3=C3 /nO,+D00\?⸴<1
>>
ybhY"1A\T7@B M GGCߨsr.rSCv5dɅvOoC[s`J62%ţ91+|@Ԕq`dȗ)DW*<* M
l0_E݀jffIF/9 ="=zw︙g_p#`( j f#c*dycn5&iF,l$
F,JTX`gԦͽlֽ,0tt4V+5a81U; &5$;]C\6:~>?m]&3-O軲RX/)c%Zfkjms5oAſWj& x`-ExSCڧWPCH5"EQrMTPr؟eOw*9$ܩw*B&GBYr.XvSM *_ %BD1Q jbF;ԔScϖ[t]eK=;9:w1pr~9Rkw_u
}9TgZ?th<3&0 3%^T/iJ\Uo7~2l]V08/gE
>]? j s?l $˒2G=G6@ ߣKDX#)<r) 㢴2J(MFAkt@@a=m}#X'H#cc۴MDȚ梹b^uӱn5u-iJ4m ˗0~0!1dԈ%Vd.=Xr{#\2?JO' ۩*&uytG&3F`ܘ5CX5u^7PtLc }001 T=!B65쎠=)~-0P7ɇ :n|X8uEvOoQRcU~ʲ]=^k)jκX'ީ V.w, zzs{,/Se@ ~
m!JR&AG.a
'Ѱz)2AMI.ok30eǔ:݅.0 Âr/{ICzI@
7,cDyyO g5~}.GNkr,q<ĸ74$8 ([qv@Mi$8+,
+.8G|ڳt%yfjPUVw Ͼz ;p-. 8||&'? pğB
9] 56 nE{R>p >_,1 VoWc}6.UBv艡XDIm/K. &q 2p$sl|\M8 f-ݽt7?\y뗾U]}W/> ߝϱswv%~9w;MwX -cmkREbl`6^HC+Ltd)s:d+ ??BYͤ)qU9?v?}>|7');EX̍VqN< 8 F#
e0I#qF,Dڒg!p)
*HS$)BfAI5(u{eE|D|1e3+)Ǎn#$u#FgWE'h>ޢbx5x1:qfc F1ͮ]#> uШ36 t8O^
NTjSÞ(*lN)G" yVqKђeE%N;űˤ+Ql[[pku%Qv"4lӆlH|j~{gyiH\7V$*&59v {6>'.OE+Z:bڠϭ42qg0{,Ao[ᡀ~ʦfHf1AiٗIApAchoʚB@H1gOt+:͚sg{AQkwu;og#"zW
9PNYɸ,h:Tsd_fY ScLK=b nfHҿ}/DE|6:Gݞmaױ {g{Wr7@Ne#}Ae#pHǒzsFU\ _;l5Od<%R-MIيz2a'--E:f*$.: +;ˑ;{=Oouw2ec3'xt/sD:-]_AiHnO^噕
zU 1ldO [D-YGaBb;L:wM\:.{1:n8 } S~T0ǭikb,+0kjmyFם~ķNt n `$ 02O^t=HTilm~ziB. U*|Vh_ 8E9hҲg4k^CD @WA=5Xh|CGy*u@Mc)C4^6V ט̽Vm\mv]w:KuF
e{Z+l](VPؾ6aG63J~6*E 'Z P8o(̩7X#=^ 3#= K`Dԁ?SC1eUS*6Hɘ$c&WV>oB7ua[l/:ES^MByV Ґ6T4Ψ
jV:lc#pӵkn~)X~O>IE/ b;Q^te/Mm:}QDxWUL Tʪ'̒`YƮWuWWcX+pb5:٠+z Ȝr,rJ*-dT> :ϯVJss9y9u JcNy3ymx3La@sLǗ 6O0^)Wrqx8wx6l*(١<{9ʿuFf?\=űl,fxvh3k~vv'~);q&ih }6SG|7{ߤtYW̔+AKAb0&#L2H Rs*9 od)EQo3G+owq|JUMM1I[ׇx2v:*VQ;#>(Ed; {:[c0wY9bTm-4E.rr >O [Q4Jz-v-P度hp4oWbx1E<7Q,z:4;H
r%u!E(^_>GF2dA 7%o_>S5b0rT*TTu
_F@щ{2ʬ!/} a ;3`VӄE۾XN$n>*檛[㢝ZNoy[ /8 =H#?:<)q8c:V7 <4 j2#+cII+@51`$ᵻ~~hRr`;ڲ^gk_nݜ NoM|f̖^ W'lz|n6"`ylxY4 }p'eE{~R 3UEu0QXaٮ,1_$V4 X|']Y^g/p .̆ĪQ5..+R^1TCdkܠTS꠶n冔!uvs>k59sf9wڂ캩|}WfR~1]hvvQIt]5 zG}?_b~_7hInJ9z
-+ѴLF81
[b5PT,隖g1e@7ʯ@@x <7r| V`\,3 N H,>"q\JMv
tmVB]pY\UX<:~oBn(U Ǖն"9ɶ;++S}8
ʄHκP ܝ9l t;PK kr .8,ja5Jk!F=lf %JKFAؠh٘ !˲-[D'Bwb4\[(ǝ9mZFgO Ko^1퓻 ߦ2Umeȫ.lZ ӥk)13 'D^$jBk >u5OY[q%U nRY;%T9۫Jl^ )`~|l~J]3rM)U9嬔Uj֗Û{7$ ٻ]0!Мt& Wx ̛εuTP>o &X3`PM ^ܤr
ĸ1WQY]UoA}|9_Bm=w }w}cǎ/g]䂩em3`Z4`&ZY;RFx$4xx4M6 i B/FUU"#hD
A{y~9ߟCL:~[C`:rK:8[fe "
Ra@K ?c0Bd k
1N>Vlf{Jmv6 Mڡ tŠNG7b pXPa-jby9zf/3Nx^` 1 Bf$6=L60e'=mSEB RK`1Q c:9l"^J1v U r2#^, \qe Q5}=1Xz%Ne xעy&썷y`t`(m`˹r9J2HCF?Ir3F \Cv )N@Q}H
: tەa ˥~ g(% eLk^'ʃ;:|p^j776'Z:gi*30f'<
N2vT:*?Qe8(
ʃE7/ N4&
8F@YFeKEyV"X֘ r-&^ (Za0^z.4e$A+BbFHd9w63!3rإ
#oO4sz='(|¶-G9A9?Z֣<%Ԙ j>wL @0'e OYƑ*YJd2 z}VA[E4| Ae/ږF 5A_[ya#{|p1R:lm^{s{Smsjrm ԯWIͶE̹LobECL9zWh㯾}.GҷǰR3 J͙ulu aOXLS}CaW ҥ ,upR+{ۯ[>7o1QòQݶVD'(: FTDqŐpOׁ<bg< > EuC$ F W `qbr#N8J1Ȭppe( h 'e i4x4, 'U ەOLt{y :i`Go_7~pHG==f6>t'JZ /~S
Ѫ4tsH ~zq͆^_ ͓٬/xuB1j8W%=9P0E\ȣ|2PO0Ɯ2vI%[ncnwhwÝ$gLTEUНD_% 1 f,^<#
T.KO?;"`AQI4_6{8_gc:
ec9zi4Fz"Q{1BB55' kčڻ}PDY 摗Qh8
)VwMiXe % 0\2 h-@簙T$q͗3NBjLZ%>ϣ;O)~ Nr7܄ySL!1"S'\lɢfHb8t2v{xȁh l=>b,}LD).0]u7cX!_eS ^S/{ Zî]5t/ Hs]f!
QNSyrv
|U1I
> VѿB xö"=@.
ZApd7 OxŻKGz!|^= Yq"Bi5/~x!2;+(UD2}[>4;#}o^IH'Z W8q#IҾH憲[bES~T)*O:)"H^\#A&E
Y 04k"*7p.@be U)UuD?#S7H{h :M}GP /Y"iG; 5Ĵ gn Dy ŭ∫8t![+a>WB `^ 4x/D"[e.O
}uq{kXrJQzH:ULTKSwӅ> 93J~uRZD7wL1<|p_YUW ?۾PM }!K!P)2TMiS',cԲؚNSD2Ij:Qpmiv( I^~ϗ`f~sۻs9O$.r ǖeL>#}v#_ :˼)m.j?raչedjS^iZ-Y!M]) |kjTf6 RŹG_>*7y0nE01|Kei&{H2Z5;'d C)W&y20
y=信f2A
Ȋ7 ddS<{tY3۔װ/ JlP錙lܟ?+qt Yc 9Aڗ9 죱A }sKCQnt0]חJr}]ںaE=ќ[ Ze?Ey#UJ ބRNƙR :烲>-z۰:)&P쟷*y^Bfj{3dRP=JRBNcJ_1Ma3=sv6$mkMcM=7; AmB "j&w<
7Baޫ?uSQTP0=sl`oƒw֭r`'1`}}s5]йնfBITJm}vE&:f
Uz N2\OsGvd鹇2܋.Kv_Yh R4r-2Ի@DnWm/1_ {9il9m1mOֺ$a9UF$T*m} #nJ n;mUcD0$?wèSݜۜ
[!\e]=ѩĎȽ5vȻ#r#WvQے ܩRO^6wLJAb|s^{2>b;M2eF2*ؒ S\FZsTvo&U[eIxa$h6#a[cG[/k|OMS~+SR0>rmW MȜ%4:{8md{"^zgN%^j=62Wۜ4~
[#-Uٝ.3=Zr[)#f>:]` 9/{% ݷoNM[Əofj
s %˱00c/EuN3f3̘,)U܇'̻,TF[&ȒC2ޮ(D* ^V >ffR7Hwx~;N|B<XN2~ynîS~M~G~zh`[='cL^4&w tߛ1BzYje| WQگ2!Qj/!~ $6kث"0a5~$ɐ:8h[ɸVM1ǐyB~p\sF~*eZGRoz\̯vcZCzZ v=5u gf } G2اcHιV4.~J#TNqN˓hѤ.;U-
IIN/m{zO xbJ^Jx_3?'!%95cS?q {BFۚ)Xq)xawX~+g<ά N(6v_
cг ωa+{ sM˲TB;貇R8SQ=9)W ;?%(;tM`~wݛ#5 t/WAKлX)ZjHK|X܀ F٨MGB_S9<Ww[L09jTy䜵BLH{2k'v-PHI#7#q5% ѹ29,MȅV%ǷoY JƄlA ,\;^M0 Oo G5 ?CTg?D_d%kߛ %zf {)yPb?R! 9њ˺Ϛ?vIo62;'5w՝HΜ+L
Fo YOs dS})אH9X lEC cZ[^bڇ5F^FL-
Xb! Dcq_-v_v,HN T|Hr)R%vz{sG>둼$ԣtk^Jn{Wy?\C wݷ@gR|U ?<ȂRN\?v*i$ֈs;w
=i5}fQ8(,óO}:K3a䀽b g .#)=]}>Ƚ8! K8
rH;чѷ?h 6k VUoeā+96
;GX-06H S&._M5븒^.UUW^n&EH"Bj$!&AI2u ёvJG:EVc
j
>(+ K8m}c+HmQjA'9ywu{~/7k1po,Tw˗Zy9[ Me$cM2"JQxuR7܇6L|L\?bmεL9 t~+s&gK?D,].>cyOi
xףQ3]4EVbnlu6|Y[d;ZLLX15;wɹcq&6gƇQ{gɜUHOw/0$SݻdYf=sami+:G/Bʱg©Px뤆=̵ T Nf{K8 u f0D~|z|~;vftMvlfڹɰȞEnr'T
{-"Z 6Zƚ| 'ȠinoԿ]-%0*5%SE)_qH"^7rs Za%u>,DUT eyxLDy`]ۏM39 5!znQj'^my[?4 jkP_ yޅ_~}?~TjnKt"\lovwtX iC rpNmOs }E]_Of Soj5~[#j \nb*67_Jҿ
jGə q1R.Cr7 %nzG*gebls^BoRIf̝5JVk9OH `=7pl h-Fs_^z#<P_*g 9wHip.cǤ*VʃF&1U+hB6Q/` ҬaVF:cVK2Bnw Gg䭤uTPt~>ƶzlRhÜ,= >,}q#=ktj;Ym{zW$m_#
lY}Kmۖ.%nu2$ՠBYv`)iuO&a,1bo\z
Vw?ΐ3|7"srZ|(=f!'Px7\+;7O-t&^x u;o<~ϻw_mp'߄Z[t7o=@ 6Es3s^,{ -g
]V. # pFOg̻Bu>x@&?RaוAD-9bxM[jT/a\s'>*$'|UV[^<`_e0,
}VeOb _Ds\F ts8>w,'zs(߃G mG `Sܛ;AܧЀ&Χ} Z -P?c-3)tg4F1ÛD ms.N໕kC2MJR[gv@:OOy}6hcRpD>pm2 vCQ upmP|g\ }jl/jsYGMrNb4JxpK=-iA?dvGyKʚc6zgYa.ֆ[
ٻM{~,{?z@c[)|MwI:8s"/s_Ƈ.ǴyQy&ے;7('2کG[TM7uGxUXwjwa'%>3빲:)ŹVpӨ{I7Gmx },%E-g@
5]iN)w6픅ɵ7AT(HMy J/#Ծ%}M}0gkow_~{~ 7~U7ZM5ܪpJ/ZVι,ӂ2~|+h~oԧgVs> C' #6hnpʨ[m|
9
GU-?g]/Y u/mWJ0 Xe) a&.U[?ｐ~<{Kw5ۗV"ﲚ f =g}sRN SaqŞUj 1=Zs)ɜsd _"EX ZmP t?d2Tmsq<
:7<Gd= 7s$?QeZ l!]{x= s͂Ȭ_~ұS^UUW9g{sHHD#Ԑ@ D"H aB)R(PAq-PLQGNy HuԎRfl:ZkNK)|g?]{wiXz6f[5( 4f$1ҩ[ES?j+MoU@U4o #!=;+}E>3y6k
Uv U EQ
|vgoî|)=qO Qkvg6|ciw5A`GNuJ}LsƺϚ-vӾCe: ֧? K/ ()>=3ĶvM[;ЕՋS앋X,na\}af˞0잋g=6;ݻ_%9?'d>\ ekb윛kwix377{߱M̞n `
cl'8;Hb/ 㵱㻊\ n{fu9S_~|B[H2-@ P Ƃ0 TxO*y=-$ Æ0|]\6yÈ+t'
p (2|9oŠbiܯ=St 'r)/$FK!7rswU'i~+1/p8^8+p=
މ&zrR+Ѹ>8_M .Lt\oq7SԐU䝡5D'U3o'7D QdT VA3Jt㑷vi:_Sxh,9~WUuIFvE'Z. s:mly&oNO>OY)Ay McM @^kȚ̎Gzn 6k[=G 0JRjv=Ϫ2Ymj[ĉV_"bNe%{EXOJ?اP7߫×O g ] EZK}q%z8uyitj سUUP`>y{= _noPV6y
Ra@ ú|ĺm$z~4xȯp
^\XB #5e)`8}Oү&F`MUs lES
fրokpz=gCP }j0__ Vüigl.dG=ճ>;mlzgƧ55q,%#Dn s 2gpO1r qU/ǘ{kn@Nk%>5ڦ4qFO+
BE{Gbh!&{Co
Յټ~/[
➉VWE+tf
8.!5Up741o qXmcC]Oj7=
-xx?_s@SJ\>{HJnT{f U-v+z'[[u lL9:KnvbÝɢ/ۉnNX?ngrU܅zT*d?0 d09{@gp(_qm
9s,mު[j` ܭ1z!\EѩyIGic3+''.yDK'-UEp]ZN@v &tf ;tYrŬ[@?d5݇tpHnp Rݯq^u7-okRM~ f'jOS}Ms5<9!hD;r{B#q#
葏/[]dDgCj5ElH
ꖠԂ~xbfpcմ;TZ_Ugkr;ӝAK< y}ڶ@K_:vER!O>믑o`28^t+xb[9semR 32wܹ9e 7 /4yI$a4{rG\Wg_1Z'R'.+PQT84]{ɟ ?=]J55]ix: >|EpOy?_H{?(S-uK;'٦r}XGr Fj~UCmz]Ffb6^M6 - W9;}sY4,9ܠYv6FG[of|oxk뵈o{YϷev~}b<6+\ {WnvnI }Hoˋ69.Ybe߰S "ߤc]\~bhI cV=!pYOܮl7G~{ߧ|ܑ^R{
x 6Ψ[:
f7J7N lOn0GI%XͼIKqabs_D F2ėF" 9x֠9K!nJtnUtmJq@h;D`;X. ;vb{."NJ4F4[i"?&jk!jmv܅' $J x{ CXQctb!#Yə}E*;kwާgyz[
XNٹi3i;%T%%5ݓV+keXJnΌ5V*"G O݉ч
Bldbv'dzbHO"˓ Dg2&3#rlLʳv&fAuV>Gx8RYk'Z:x܊dV6I q+M$o?м9賲M@MStpxt5Gy.[}L/n_PΈ3 vv?< :1iBa}ԻɝOON=hڏ>/"]<%{ɗ5/ n.T~Oٛ4;5"/<^Xu
{'ٍ%͕R7U'Uk?`7sL8嗭zǸgG(ܽ5p-]wήkث202ȣid8-] :o
7.!{[^Kea{/T\,. P(N3 y\SE6
0\4Ah <{ 6{
F }^!3Z_fT%UB>9ziZğr_G{O-Nr g|
#A5`FatM13 +jk(|FC+(J?
rCBhp&g
"g9E|YqE݅$"CP
Q@~po0P
Brm`d`xK Z*Z[
=tZ
|
.˯2Ϛo>Ka}
ݮ=2 P|+c[v>dvj5CYiCzA.~ԥ:?AZ^puh7Z y^phldȟRxKS
hhhȺz!9hL_ vup\,7W^w+Wj<V9F&d6p&N*PApy4ɘD\%ΰslo5 cSYDvњ ץ ~r}HԁnzmC
&ϱ-Ac[I˖h-
yxOJuR67?l0N4ap2Q)E!Ő 2*BF[N~22)KޒI-~o~/~~iyY_ C_*"!R6H!4~bmQc!C٩^r)W gG{00/`bvb;u01pV]8e(TqԤ+LL)K44Ѣ ihbiclD58J ^06O{Ӑ\Gˤ]s\Kvh 9Yr
ݷ~s7+AG g $_ A3$ )JpkdyNxso@֏PֳN4{N_u$CY0_G wU'0 e w- *a%tđI6"
n
Hqq5s_$G> Q+=vN 5_?t=,~.Cn+X#W7
wb"zH .Rv2xVOi-<@>Tk ̸ Vx'٭͒nkL!60o,R 7PҹӉx\| =o|#_' ~aP+ tGWu^A9N5/zbvjVVմ˩Zг+KS
v}<50n=u⛧X6,2>I͞+hH RsͶnc^PnƘٗr:/]jYv{צ/x 5 er c`qhb/$fhH@ie$Qp٥vi_Q*$G7\H5VR@$1Qȍb6Rlj"\En
TRJ)u)@()]{[VXHq(r`\fX0p
3fr"-'A;`t6umvSz({bfؾ-A2YF eR>l8=3U:8W|l`c4X1Wp=Cs4Is3n.so TI@1+~eFcnhb;3)pa%]+U mR RZ
eWĎŲ5r ǿ|>_SU, ŀk,m3=)[
Ĕ < 6N{rrN5=r;% ʭJks봇D!dStOMicڄ6]ּUsu J9iLG Rs6%"E؉ -aG"H }q }m>ݗys;me#l/;z3w Ih-ks-w6N\ƹI&y&-"bIKx`nyFb95aԢOE%c -h- E_.z Y eja[ؖDAR4:۷V 3ToEN&Z-GA xv
^A+*i!ʫ{WUD WO@U|v \k+RFQ` e
endstream
endobj
16 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 3/Type/Page>>
endobj
36 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(98-0395.a1)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\
ved%20-%20HTML/98-0395.a1.html)Tj
49.74 0 Td
([7/2/2021 4:04:31 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 404.25 591.75 361.499 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm
(Chairman, Appeal Board)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 729.75 Tm
(Signed: Michael Y. Ra'anan)Tj
ET
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 16 729 cm
0 0 m
134.795 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 704.25 Tm
(Michael Y. Ra'anan)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Administrative Judge)Tj
T*
(Member, Appeal Board)Tj
T*
(Signed: Jeffrey D. Billett)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 16 627 cm
0 0 m
120.645 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 602.25 Tm
(Jeffrey D. Billett)Tj
T*
(Administrative Judge)Tj
T*
(Member, Appeal Board)Tj
T*
(1. )Tj
(The Administrative Judge entered a formal finding under Criterion D in f\
avor of Applicant. )Tj
37.851 0 Td
(That favorable formal)Tj
-37.851 -1.125 Td
(finding is not at issue on appeal.)Tj
T*
(2. )Tj
(The Directive should be construed broadly in order to effectuate the pur\
poses of the industrial security program,)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(including the protection of classified information. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
20.134 0 Td
(See, e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
3.332 0 Td
(, ISCR Case No. 97-0783 \(August 7, 1998\) at p. 4.)Tj
-23.465 -1.125 Td
(Accordingly, the words "rules, procedures, guidelines, or regulations" i\
n Criterion M should be read broadly to include)Tj
T*
(statutes, Executive Orders, regulations, directives, regulations, rules,\
procedures, guidelines, manuals, position)Tj
T*
(descriptions, official memoranda, or any other appropriate source that s\
ets forth, directly or indirectly, the scope of)Tj
T*
(authority of persons with respect to information technology systems.)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
37 0 obj
<>
endobj
38 0 obj
<>
endobj
39 0 obj
<>stream
H\n0 y Ce%n%4V hb:P~6:i_;'*cIGNi 8`Q_zMkt-Ճ 72 }8Y]ނ^}ZGm~C?XvF/ZwlS:ZoyC5:Y[q-_Qe1\ggB']]% $|"N2]q"0KYrv;T8e6y/g> ǰ9
Ͱ9 a3 ć_Z3{ ڵ>stream
H| TnC*) =3Dh@^L,E#*"h\p W7ܗwG1xwЧw{Nuݺw A~ݪmeb 8l fp4خ 30(F 6GO0; 8*"4%3YkE6! M 3>P1@A~츈حMse :` +D_hJ @)8("LT5?WoJLZ< _V @c֯ğ»|p sy_ZL9;&1VRթ[ϾKn7iv5ZI3-Z~Ӫuuةs> ޣg}>~?柃nC~qhpH( 5bcbǎ ӄ&˔:#qIsSK`K.K_VZ&c6ngnmڑs={;p#G /:Q|3gϕ /]r0oʀ_h%l`*a<(&4JkVAb8[L'+H(1u}rY-ʃ!y\(_
3\ դjVj5ڡmNt
tu[BW< <
(RWqP\7⩴T)J$*I\eV٦RJrZ9\W x{x
54 W z~>K-6WXQSUSS{f2ByRMD!S)U2{$ q@,+9D Bv5r_9=`9A'W 48M&s m6Q#HC./8}d([>p( q?p9U'[[s`q- 9 KOKjC]~%wWzDxg j@Uiթr %qknkncnmnemnf2+ s(@YfRR:S
iu4̣֦ od3[:c
O
-C!pؐg
;
=
Akpo1oFaDn\9[7m Z `> bC1\ }U| Ա)]ڢZqv?"gjm}#gN7n}/`=$L ,0 R!Vf !̀EPa ,$(}-^+X۠`; 0Hp(8',p B$sP
Y0 "D#(90F(h
0B,f0 ~) ZSy R\2UqB5W?[W*\k0ע
u ^C%n q nm pfN܅
\dL=azh nmtF<6Ĺxc> X; ac<8 ]QZ ,ƓX4聞R<"^<76{p /S6]^G9r)A:D) DGQ! ":AtJ3S}H2]t
BxN2M2Qݢt=O!=rzBSzF^KzEה@Wv&ٔ͢DsxIz;+|7Yja c"aLb*f갺Cٳ́92'\
^kx oAX֑ubYϺn3֝`=Y/֛aR'Ej/= JfX*HKOgDL,lUj*YJUW~ ֟
`ٗ,h/uee`
0~{y9;ݝح(
lnng
8&Y&-r& r%w=r'<$;sE qyBiyF?sGٹ\s;MU&?_oy^^%yY^W5y]Եtm]Gt}@7ԍtcD7tsBt JU 5X
QC)Q
S5RR5VSj7QMRA*X*TMQS45]P3,7n[6n~_~;κڭjگ::Nmؾ:v:kpk R7kF(GQ\|"Eijq(p$EL i2N$K /)=e2R@QQvA9)T 0.iãIÁ fB 1tR0UH@\B9ryM\!-nLRn<(H}9fz `%ٕpy R.p~3ɲF͢j dŔ "ÛDd}ԅTL^
cM
HՅT#EJ4z)K4F8%AoY ce?9 `~ţ4heq`b. ֪3txE^(8c I{ xoiN&j>p8me:miTŌ6R7:U;Ȁ<#;$sQ:=k-`N+i?f|?<"]^z)n(_.s1l~줣$Q^[ G`\KVԃ|'zPmVo) NT2 @+:
^v{s^7K}z9).S| nq|R֪-B{IpcpE7Ya9bg`0w
Da ]M,ǯD!a` n)BC H+pޜDaJ:@f3u9 Ȩrsr 94Kו2zIC\A獶4M һM#ϋT͚DSi\ O;%+/8l bX%GM{S LJ d{vLxbt- )AMr>+*tNSe*SHIr6]Q<`'m2i } &
>9Zx9B:8Ld l+b[zP^P凤_8CùC\#/M]ɳR=~JqcF1bCJKMI 8Rbϩ;.W#ggGv%s0MU`J9~HJf4<744<=a#1rn 1#14&-Uqk< 5ӌ[!9?$ ]!;yb*ܚ~c,xn|>KwwNK! Y 3^PXW(enKw[2S2((zqN/-`W^j>B2eChPVXI.3%Ӽ,YktOnñ1ϸ+썓Olͪ+47'{֯χo`Hrjˈ1PRJuԌNx"P?bU;bc-^i}%=(PTW鞴֬HI/$[R^Q9H(02
xul$)Ϥ@Y&1f3F'?9jjbܮߺtKɣ[b}D+8: e#%HN#cV>"-uAWEjQ|asjmc6bz5Pvz~qO)VO㞎~ -2:S1]ޟ7Y+<#?Uk{$Q.UqwNw;N_%t$ے<|ClRG@% SILJdhRJkL[` 2b3MgΤäa FC~ e:'=cw<ﻫrjGӺ7D鲌2:{[pU머~q6|k2JyyzssgZֹfxpkuxPE!/^:T>z^R\:ᡎ5]" :(L-X}. *4J+1(hQF=|BCh@2A71mg66橒M,M$io3%,d(E+3Fs v8Dg"bAgAO@N} ~H',6iyB#Ω蹂< _"ck(P?wͪg%NG: j|PO%$ \Q0p w+bޟ[a +*+ sb_O:ڵLߎ)^8xs;[_lEѾLdױWsk[u%uxF S]
˪ޏW S^L՜?\GT-^ZEYE*Iuֹ l@hԄ3LcaȲdx q2ҜJ9O A)HCxx{gtL^,Ya FADB$D)!?0:R(CEvT %$%G Te]ZrIiSnU3t3 }J%KyJ=KAt9s53Wwj_U ĩ28SG b[p.5lEA7f0 ("e FAR[( R{sF90
.TXԳ7j Kl%I}MF /E\v:}/_;4D[idᜭ[Skz2R&VkW.;vזNm鎊'~gr G A{ʱфU軆L$R<ޤ̀q(v#"Křpy b! 1e87l6EE_ޫY9- 0ȅÈI% Ydz"53L?| 7.>bSs3)U[-%|%|]G>ŏ Lf7A@ >@1`5
A&^* Vv8?#8]5:wyוC=1pdwۻON_g\$/o7Y]Z'g L4
~_5m)zP$%JMJ^ÒmQ$[bd+-+/Q{vi$n'inI=`m tn]ѹky0A`{Ht]
||OO:îrץEͺA >р?56+~8xޡAnLtO`;(|_&i'8=K29.?/K Rn@81X .(3Lixs) 4<й
tX8ùsBO 0DxHQ]QPկ@tp7`};i4
3-NO*,_&Iayj33HGіc3 7K,״|uR#:c%agGvF꾘C;??%xMmcGjWٷYZ\'wN>v gacM:<~jz
0#c v
S*'Qj9 fWᇆgeÕ B>(_`tH63RvJԍE"!gɶM{6 !lGRW
V n]
\,rPJLb&D #Z7 Yx
T06#"eΣe"6õ,̮L|Q ~~ l;71~aWW}v&-!+3/]B.lR nzQ(Aʗt' .8LE{ >k0}*83~?4c̒lXEf=:./GPH&Ad|(TKpeFpHfYhr]JVڲc$9 °,æ,6 ]ɻQՖ@\OXWN1+ցɛtk:16x NN |OQҹ0 8Yg.e~NoL-5Y
W]ãc"r_@ 8wy/h(r#~9AY܅!M !拵rs w= YIL /1lQ8y 6J|_&C4
bg =Ѕ/^/P~Bn1> c̜2VvVocdﲱv~Od:5+`0:$tGTsVS7f;m`LT`8Ũ*P_3Bj;vA #f ZYi}4B k!ӂ uLeY!306A6)Zꤚm"Y&z8hoa
]sG:7I-|ޑtoW<L̟sHw8\nrDtӞcx0v]
kt(qЍa, ^=X Kx7 w+=2 3h? xlpb98,dS A=FRYj ~S7o 8U9LzӔ ,m s[$c}x=u!%R/tni^6T)Set_p|5$` wVe5F$+ᓵ\yw&w~I{f[ $cN7t=Q%*GhT/Y7ZYKl }' .Gy3rT~{':D;nnsb4 g5Y-ԤԒw* N3vJOk iK`fio hhD) MS;t^kv}=b w ow{㻒:v$T^JxV \1[5‷?$3mZ2 A6ڠӵ5D׀0Z,/ld2ɥS
ri.5f2Ywe&No T6CۏRM] Ob|a= /'aRB舥DkMt{
zQZ> 4Q<9bU(˺P4=s/e,>&dz
J<~!?Gk}TQ,B_HK .-yěN*|3It9.U*
e͜21%C
Kc]\> }`ƥ,x*q[۲~$`VyoM}JͩV%,GoJMU]+k:OԘhen /MbTx1ҰuH(0c#}ض]c[(ʿ' Vyv5 0M9 D(s
)%-YeE5TGm} /8a;9ܕcp{ #/%V7ʛ'/SIPD N9 B2@,?@E4 &c1k `ԏ x@)OIy-P.F" VV= O3hNX
] f?"uAt:Y\8~3i[M5X+%]7M}z8EN\ VpJ@'+b/G34e
%F\l
EA&>"ʉ9<(豟Fbhӷ2נ6zV2a<9D/; SM1q:i?5gCwr yǃHO.TYU5-`G:<
k
uL5O+ >V-!'Păd0' MҕaR
+j :.Q
h .gm$? -iZzQS]I):hD5O%}-QZ)u$,cfh6#l565L3t܀_"UK/#l/K=\Z(T_Eqŵ",buS i xYۑ;^4
+n?-=N>B]2\3OU[rvX/eWwlס$hA6 yF שבibմ >ND0A) yàBmNvK8Re7uҢ
y*o ΐk+ųDSYh n v[ƙQ?7xrxMLIL0VW`^1B#r*bQ0UDBGt\ Ȁ E %'Ad\UQ%AfAsgB/~ pdZe:8V^tʑ1-pteC^jr(֜i m&(ъmo:|$UB}{|S9fHHԝKvXЖ R*dLW0'q2^/z-]/I:^J&*1r c4lf0?B|xo ZNuhfgp0X"8"2 E)h#bWK s$7FBRnT)7T"`H QodCe5j*Q
WV@ %Q51*9( '}ɞ+gLq{_1jLAg ,XũܝH 7Mg
UڣwZAWs,gxW_5dL gy:7N>18>+|Z ggpV9ggG4@>0Yu~ V(A-mv ouړE
az;i1.y4UmVVh
^B
ݣ,.QoBD4B/.M5 fK-z&Txm NWy+돈B X(cE xwi%UtP
nEUUٜiQ2VO({z TbzS+jP+*6Ij- qqоh437Oy8pه@BȺcOr5g
A(
_^s!g<:Oט@G?d
V~,kھD
IӵTsyڜB߶iv<)<1qP5BF:mGypy:26\ r?w0fs m6\oIC|(OIA}+?@W9)v/Ws&53=7E~͐<?.kw nX/4 Y'aa85'G⯅sԝ$Rk b|{\>M8jS;hnZϦPs / +4]P.sǟ HV6#P
ԙ QP SN nҰיUt;bXeS9;
`N ;pVjOѺSn@߽%9@ sQEU1[l.kb0Zÿ7`h|O14Qe@aH75m 钀-YbB٘{18 `gc3+ G (ҰͱTb§?PmuTkZ
i1YciM Ɗ
M>h
g5GS@{
w@{-9wڻď@[^s'a6
B:g~{ ]owuhW|a{=t=~v >z4hAw7gU ) wa>|zQB3t{6c}&8^w!!0% ~Lzg1Gy K`wu S;v;VW % ܤRݼL#or+zz0#/]Y[۽5jziBְZ7 )
|Ul
faRw꜊\Ь tE,@ԟ/rkI/\|sv| p8MtʺJ/ k6um4N d=bm{d=gN_xmOkyg9 ؉1tC=Q7B|ֹMӐf y? p/
"*1XGb" #PR"
@E@J IB 2UA `Tj鰧sw˗8fݻs ְVd;[_z
uK%)"_^)gd~!'(]}{*R. i \dVq2Z:*)|sJ[a6Jw; Gcj0S1~hhg2
.Ձ>.ԛ #^ddh$I~P^0; PƋQ=I-x-FNnMר;d^|zfR1ΕZwkM eE=nZ3E^Á*ZjvX::B}ږ za G@WoY}~(-7 쭻
/ xF#QoU =_e9uvb=
am_ۦ#K|AjYw ?Hh}_v eYZ
+wņpVPX:D AA=-{ǀaT*e
֫DQY95>픣i4~*T~us]B0%/7ܿ<7?
ؼnH
=c߫
b6\~
*%?~vxϒ:CW@%It,{Qpa9
}ZxfXeZdEU:(]羘\\0Bb|-tKy (9o[J@7 ?k@ Ž{,ʮx؊_7ζN--zW WuV6ݠ@9ohg5Q! ` MQGq94z 3\=)N
-b/g1RcTOҬs$>ᛂ6Uj 4ZM(ZF3!
hƌfjZ ȤX5P'Qg Qi(j#+L@0hn%y"=f `ٟfvɔfQ*"9?0:s8YNȋf?ZfÓYΤf@{
`r -3g9݄ߵQU[//ZTh}x{E0_Xej44&>1+ӿqDmݣz dqA+8Z1&Kf&ʇSy*H~Yg}w cDXiF+mM16wEX[UJOr5 g'9% kܖ2G'l\Oߍ_@D·Iֻ;c}PrCt^\F'Th`E6>#>sa| X#X<jNwa
|$mOhOm~KkkM(D쩷ϰ>C.+\M ~iݾyci(;ww^ ߀ˠԀK=2.^v] =ӳDj[~o^p4 gl\gf5 S U v!'9h =ij'cW/Q:@8+T3uwͳevUƙZ <9x.BBs RP nدs(YXK=7[%uhe˘wevoCYaOnC=Oڟ?~D"~D]\ϟx;BE
n =c c}$:v = :P),1K=/$ 8/XOk|?kߤثk+,.KI9ʳOR' 1iq;H㊭4:źrk4?"mٻq^[PWoF
]5YeЌC(j>ie<
s¿Jf
0 I60įY5TG
g _K/aSVh5#ѼڡN3Thrυ 눵 4TJis7{ ~@}cZ 0Bh-$H$k@otW@ hsA⌤ޘ?bN'4wx X(
c;O }Dt' _qNhW+P:gټX}gm-Ήosq&rh*{>#p6tu2 gTv|J rh-Ze iyj˗ǠMX ߐJ {%r;tԾFv: -t:4/\Uu9pywqc0pǎb\os$
KrxV1b"uՙb
%y|bit!Ij7#ng驳EC $17Q7UŪqr}G;.č]n0;U5WEJk
מNE]oɥgK_ǝkO < o?6iC6bL,8$J~oL.u`[d o3xF|yz.٥$ߖǕa EV ui{^Ÿ}ʽmߨ;{7p\V{Ԓ@ 4q8q tUoڵ,[2'a=%Hg6s1:r_RwE3[MgVeoN=|Ԛ+.y[qyWd- ;1|ATUz) k 3A!g"1?gcӍa jL{סH /"͙9FVv궗0!$.k@ebNo_ܥ˻x-' zz%^Gi>@ߕC;h4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4M;ׂ[p`X7̩:b ]9~ F<" /^w"CEhaMÊaa@3%"謈Ȃ?#L7!"S 1)HRNDu%9URV,/k$K60e%l_*?dd9/k Q˒I~ 7:Σ콎}װ g
)R[e8^0R\*}
Cu=[qT ;R5Ա}Ne<>ž-SzlDw` >'W v}v(4H
R?R#m!Zh UTU
J)*%Ъz}3g U{͎G 326!dzGF兊rnlj@`d١ TXl)GAf@n8X3i@Q +xTɎ 6tV -X
) )9U\ !ra""H\7HW@>G.vId^q[ N] Rq y^!A:dzMf-;UB^ap z{^*_+fV@ 3E^Ck 2@C扣MJW mx2̓rK9OLҴ
QEvSScJ0=@xed/&{ 9:bfk[eOofu1j juQ8
c F= ?˕.ë<[w+jXw*-F-/fV6f_W( )*exN}ed]3BJ=$ mPfYڬ7]lHy{MJɐ}`2J_xtXM=Ga`j!Cd1ڣEt4xV)ϯ0CHMm4v]oVNYBjI?yJag7Ra`AAmΨf
q̐qUB(i#Q XDx^ 7Aj XC
ῂ6QeՁ ~~)ޅۂ:0j&0FX@"ijD4c?
# wqu*,^
KOtXKKڰs O4+?ທ*Y'KWd˲,}VdiPe)&]\s4n{ Þ)Y0%aFD7Oc+'U ?df(Ǐi-_[ʢ+E
q~B7Ī7/=j&hl >5i,х0;E/&XS!^韍m@I(7j CW{ݦC2_nwB/ӟ%_?QJċ!N|SIS)Z% '}&`./8OнTOy [ 7PYtk)ڣuٿF(/Ѝ۴k<P>qI ϹWe:]\fWkbVE):DADR!-,s8 L;[`Xg-%I! :dUeujIwwj/qҺv % %\Uc˓DɁȖF.
gK
>gc7DzhTEѷkWՌ=r|c0rX Urx b:w k(
endstream
endobj
15 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 2/Type/Page>>
endobj
41 0 obj
[43 0 R]
endobj
42 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(98-0395.a1)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\
ved%20-%20HTML/98-0395.a1.html)Tj
49.74 0 Td
([7/2/2021 4:04:31 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm
(M is)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(explanatory, not mandatory in nature; \(iv\) the Judge erred by focusing\
narrowly on language under Criterion M)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm
(pertaining)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(to rules, procedures, guidelines, or regulations; \(v\) the Judge's inte\
rpretation of Criterion M would render)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(useless Misuse)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(of Information Technology Disqualifying Conditions 1 and 2; and \(vi\) t\
he Judge's interpretation of)Tj
T*
(Criterion M would)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(improperly require Department Counsel to prove Applicant violated some s\
pecific rule, procedure,)Tj
T*
(guideline, or)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(regulation without any direct proof that Applicant was authorized to do \
what he did.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(The Board rejects Department Counsel's arguments about Criterion M for s\
everal reasons. )Tj
36.309 0 Td
(First, Department Counsel)Tj
-36.309 -1.125 Td
(seeks to have the Board construe the language of Criterion M in a )Tj
26.52 0 Td
(piecemeal manner. )Tj
7.801 0 Td
(The entire language of a Criterion,)Tj
-34.321 -1.125 Td
(not merely the wording of Disqualifying Conditions or Mitigating Conditi\
ons, is relevant to interpreting and construing)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(a)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Criterion. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
4.804 0 Td
(See, e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
3.332 0 Td
(, ISCR Case No. 98-0507 \(May 17, 1999\) at p. 4 \(Board construing Crit\
erion B in light of its)Tj
-8.136 -1.125 Td
(language,)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(including language in Basis section of Criterion B\); ISCR Case No. 97-0\
783 \(August 7, 1998\) at p. 2)Tj
T*
(\(referring to)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(preambulatory language of Criterion F in construing a Criterion F Disqua\
lifying Condition\). )Tj
42.241 0 Td
(Second,)Tj
-42.241 -1.125 Td
(Department)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Counsel's argument does not reflect a plausible reading of Misuse of Inf\
ormation Technology Systems)Tj
T*
(Disqualifying)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Condition 1 \("Illegal or unauthorized entry into any information techno\
logy system"\) and Disqualifying)Tj
T*
(Condition 2)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(\("Illegal or unauthorized modification destruction, manipulation, or de\
nial of access to information residing)Tj
T*
(on an)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(information technology system"\). )Tj
16.127 0 Td
(The phrase "[i]llegal or unauthorized" has no discernable meaning indepe\
ndent)Tj
-16.127 -1.375 Td
(of some)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(showing that the conduct in question violated some applicable rule, proc\
edure, guideline, or regulation.)Tj
0 0 0.933 rg
9.75 0 0 9.75 552.8535 542.25 Tm
(\(2\))Tj
ET
0 0 0.933 RG
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 552.8535 541.5 cm
0 0 m
11.369 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 524.25 Tm
(Third, under the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Directive, Department Counsel has the burden of proving controverted all\
egations. )Tj
40.099 0 Td
(Directive,)Tj
-40.099 -1.125 Td
(Additional Procedural)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Guidance, Item 14. )Tj
17.023 0 Td
(In this case, Department Counsel had the burden of proving that Applican\
t's)Tj
-17.023 -1.125 Td
(conduct was)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(unauthorized. )Tj
10.941 0 Td
(In DOHA cases, only after Department Counsel makes a preliminary showing\
that)Tj
-10.941 -1.125 Td
(Applicant's conduct was)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(unauthorized, does the burden shift to Applicant to present evidence to \
rebut that preliminary)Tj
T*
(showing. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
(See)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
( Directive,)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Additional Procedural Guidance, Item 15. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
26.77 0 Td
(See, e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
3.332 0 Td
(, ISCR Case No. 97-0184 \(June 16, 1998\) at)Tj
-30.102 -1.125 Td
(p. 5. )Tj
(Department)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Counsel's proposed construction of Criterion M would impermissibly shift\
the burden to Applicant to)Tj
T*
(disprove a)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(controverted allegation. )Tj
14.134 0 Td
(Fourth, )Tj
(nothing in Department Counsel's arguments demonstrate the Judge's)Tj
-14.134 -1.125 Td
(interpretation of)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Criterion M would result in detrimental consequences to the industrial s\
ecurity program or undermine)Tj
T*
(the protection of)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(classified information.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(In this case, Applicant's conduct did not constitute an obvious, self-ev\
ident misuse or unauthorized use of a computer.)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(The Board need not agree with the Administrative Judge's findings to con\
clude it was not arbitrary, capricious, or)Tj
T*
(contrary)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(to law for the Judge to conclude Department Counsel "failed to prove [Ap\
plicant's] actions were either illegal)Tj
T*
(or beyond)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(the authority of his position." )Tj
16.24 0 Td
(However, Department Counsel's argument has merit to the extent the Judge\
)Tj
-16.24 -1.125 Td
(went on to state)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(further that the government had "to prove Applicant did not have authori\
ty to move any e-mail at)Tj
T*
(anytime for any reason." )Tj
10.099 0 Td
(Unauthorized actions under Criterion M can cover a range of situations f\
rom acting without)Tj
-10.099 -1.125 Td
(any authority at all to acting)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(in excess of authority. )Tj
20.578 0 Td
(Accordingly, if Department Counsel had proven Applicant was not)Tj
-20.578 -1.125 Td
(authorized to delete the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(particular e-mail messages involved in this case, it would have been irr\
elevant if Applicant had)Tj
T*
(authority to delete other e-mail messages.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Although the Board has decided that the Administrative Judge did not err\
by concluding Department Counsel "failed to)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(prove [Applicant's] actions were either illegal or beyond the authority \
of his position," the Board does not address the)Tj
T*
(Judge's findings and conclusions about Applicant's "implied authority." \
)Tj
28.812 0 Td
(The Board's ruling concerning the construction)Tj
-28.812 -1.125 Td
(of)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Criterion M makes it unnecessary for the Board to address the merits of \
Department Counsel's arguments in relation)Tj
T*
(to the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Judge's findings and conclusions about Applicant's "implied authority.")Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
0 -2.125 TD
(Conclusion)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
T*
(Department Counsel has failed to meet its burden of demonstrating error \
below. )Tj
32.241 0 Td
(Accordingly, the Board affirms the)Tj
-32.241 -1.125 Td
(Administrative Judge's January 11, 1999 decision.)Tj
T*
(Signed: Emilio Jaksetic)Tj
ET
0 G
q 1 0 0 1 16 112.5 cm
0 0 m
113.32 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 87.75 Tm
(Emilio Jaksetic)Tj
T*
(Administrative Judge)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
43 0 obj
<>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[552.0 540.0 563.0 551.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>>
endobj
14 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 1/Type/Page>>
endobj
44 0 obj
[46 0 R]
endobj
45 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(98-0395.a1)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\
ved%20-%20HTML/98-0395.a1.html)Tj
49.74 0 Td
([7/2/2021 4:04:31 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 751.5 Tm
(mail message that accused Applicant of sexual harassment.)Tj
ET
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 0 0.933 rg
9.75 0 0 9.75 299.9043 756 Tm
(\(1\))Tj
ET
Q
0 0 0.933 RG
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 299.9043 755.25 cm
0 0 m
11.369 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 311.2729 751.5 Tm
( )Tj
(There is no dispute that Applicant, acting in his capacity)Tj
-24.606 -1.125 Td
(as)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(the local area network \(LAN\) administrator, obtained access to the fem\
ale employee's computer in order to perform a)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(software upgrade. )Tj
(However, there is a dispute as to what Applicant did after he gained acc\
ess to the female employee's)Tj
T*
(computer. )Tj
4.276 0 Td
(The Administrative Judge found: \(a\) Applicant moved the accusatory e-m\
ail message \(which the female)Tj
-4.276 -1.125 Td
(employee had sent to Applicant\) and a nearly identical version of it fr\
om one folder to a folder Applicant created for that)Tj
T*
(purpose; \(b\) Applicant moved the e-mail messages because he was embarr\
assed by them and he was concerned they)Tj
T*
(might)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(be seen by other colleagues who were helping him with the software upgra\
de; \(c\) Applicant intended to move the)Tj
T*
(messages back to their original location after the software upgrade was \
completed; \(d\) due to subsequent events,)Tj
T*
(Applicant was not able to access the female employee's computer to retur\
n the e-mail messages to their original location)Tj
T*
(and the messages were lost and could not be restored; and \(e\) Applican\
t did not deliberately delete the e-mail messages.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Department Counsel contends the Administrative Judge erred by finding Ap\
plicant did not deliberately delete the e-mail)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(messages. )Tj
(In support of this contention, Department Counsel argues: \(a\) the Admi\
nistrative Judge improperly relied on)Tj
T*
(his favorable assessment of Applicant's credibility; \(b\) the record ev\
idence contradicts Applicant's denial that he)Tj
T*
(intended)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(to delete the e-mail messages; and \(c\) the weight of the record eviden\
ce supports a finding that Applicant)Tj
T*
(deliberately)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(deleted the e-mail messages. )Tj
16.66 0 Td
(For the reasons that follow, the Board concludes Department Counsel has)Tj
-16.66 -1.125 Td
(failed to)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(demonstrate the Judge erred.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(There is no merit to Department Counsel's argument that the Administrati\
ve Judge improperly relied on his favorable)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(assessment of Applicant's credibility. )Tj
15.149 0 Td
(Department Counsel is conflating an insufficiency of the evidence argume\
nt with)Tj
-15.149 -1.125 Td
(an argument that the Judge impermissibly used a credibility determinatio\
n in lieu of record evidence. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
40.654 0 Td
(See, e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
3.332 0 Td
(, ISCR)Tj
-43.986 -1.125 Td
(Case No. 98-0331 \(May 26, 1999\) at p. 4; ISCR Case No. 98-0592 \(May 4\
, 1999\) at p. 4; ISCR Case No. 98-0419)Tj
T*
(\(April)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(30, 1999\) at p. 3. )Tj
9.749 0 Td
(A review of the decision in this case persuades the Board that the Judge\
did not commit the)Tj
-9.749 -1.125 Td
(error)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Department Counsel contends he did.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(The Administrative Judge has the primary responsibility for weighing the\
record evidence and making findings of fact.)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(The presence of conflicting record evidence does not diminish the Judge'\
s fact-finding responsibility. )Tj
40.724 0 Td
(Indeed, the Judge)Tj
-40.724 -1.125 Td
(often must weigh conflicting evidence and decide which evidence is more \
credible or persuasive in light of the record as)Tj
T*
(a)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(whole. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
(See, e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
6.969 0 Td
(, ISCR Case No. 98-0507 \(May 17, 1999\) at p. 6. )Tj
(Of course, the presence of conflicting evidence does)Tj
-6.969 -1.125 Td
(not relieve the Judge of the obligation to carefully consider the record\
evidence as a whole and weigh it in a reasonable)Tj
T*
(manner. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
3.499 0 Td
(See)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
( Directive, Additional Procedural Guidance, Item 32.a. \("The Appeal Boa\
rd shall . . . determine whether or)Tj
-3.499 -1.125 Td
(not: a. The Administrative Judge's findings of fact are supported by suc\
h relevant evidence )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
36.586 0 Td
(as a reasonable mind might)Tj
-36.586 -1.125 Td
(accept as adequate to support a conclusion in light of all the contrary \
evidence in the same record.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
39.659 0 Td
("\)\(emphasis added\).)Tj
-39.659 -2.125 Td
(There is conflicting record evidence on the issue of whether Applicant d\
eliberately deleted the e-mail messages. )Tj
45.066 0 Td
(The)Tj
-45.066 -1.125 Td
(Administrative Judge made findings that reflect a reasonable, plausible \
interpretation of the record evidence.)Tj
T*
(Department)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Counsel's appeal brief sets forth arguments in favor of an alternate int\
erpretation of the record evidence that)Tj
T*
(is reasonable)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(and plausible. )Tj
11.247 0 Td
(Department Counsel's ability to argue for such an alternate interpretati\
on of the record)Tj
-11.247 -1.125 Td
(evidence does not)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(demonstrate the Judge's challenged findings are arbitrary, capricious, o\
r contrary to law. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
42.943 0 Td
(See, e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
3.332 0 Td
(,)Tj
-46.274 -1.125 Td
(ISCR Case No. 98-0685 \(May 20, 1999\) at p. 3. )Tj
(The Board need not agree with the Judge's findings on this point to)Tj
T*
(conclude they are)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(sustainable.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(2. )Tj
(Whether the Administrative Judge's decision is arbitrary, capricious, or\
contrary to law)Tj
ET
0 G
q 1 0 0 1 28 191.25 cm
0 0 m
417.035 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 445.0352 192 Tm
(. )Tj
(Department Counsel contends)Tj
-35.753 -1.125 Td
(the Administrative Judge's decision is arbitrary, capricious, and contra\
ry to law. )Tj
32.171 0 Td
(In support of this contention,)Tj
-32.171 -1.125 Td
(Department)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Counsel argues: \(a\) the Administrative Judge erred by finding Applican\
t did not deliberately delete the)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(accusatory e-mail)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(messages sent to him by a female federal employee; and \(b\) the Judge m\
isinterpreted Criterion M.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(The Board has already addressed the first argument. )Tj
21.076 0 Td
(Since the Board has concluded that argument fails to demonstrate)Tj
-21.076 -1.125 Td
(the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Administrative Judge erred, it does not support Department Counsel's con\
tention that the Judge's decision is)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(arbitrary,)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(capricious, and contrary to law.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Department Counsel's second contention consists of several, interrelated\
arguments: \(i\) the Administrative Judge's)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(interpretation of Criterion M is detrimental to the industrial security \
program; \(ii\) the Judge's interpretation of Criterion)Tj
T*
(M)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(is inconsistent with the purpose of the Directive to protect classified \
information; \(iii\) the Basis section of Criterion)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
46 0 obj
<>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[300.0 753.0 311.0 764.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>>
endobj
12 0 obj
<>
endobj
47 0 obj
<>
endobj
9 0 obj
<>
endobj
10 0 obj
<>
endobj
11 0 obj
<>
endobj
51 0 obj
(file:///usr.osd.mil/Home/OSD/OGC/JosephLM/_MyComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archived%20-%20HTML/98-0395.a1.html)
endobj
50 0 obj
<>
endobj
52 0 obj
<>
endobj
48 0 obj
[16 0 R/XYZ 0 536.0 null]
endobj
49 0 obj
[16 0 R/XYZ 0 497.0 null]
endobj
4 0 obj
<>
endobj
xref
0 53
0000000000 65535 f
0000000016 00000 n
0000000141 00000 n
0000003657 00000 n
0000140810 00000 n
0000003535 00000 n
0000003590 00000 n
0000003730 00000 n
0000003757 00000 n
0000140194 00000 n
0000140284 00000 n
0000140326 00000 n
0000140006 00000 n
0000004393 00000 n
0000131223 00000 n
0000122606 00000 n
0000094332 00000 n
0000003860 00000 n
0000003906 00000 n
0000003955 00000 n
0000004146 00000 n
0000004018 00000 n
0000004050 00000 n
0000004082 00000 n
0000004114 00000 n
0000004593 00000 n
0000008970 00000 n
0000009019 00000 n
0000009055 00000 n
0000009561 00000 n
0000041825 00000 n
0000042092 00000 n
0000009994 00000 n
0000010267 00000 n
0000010720 00000 n
0000042700 00000 n
0000094532 00000 n
0000096616 00000 n
0000097033 00000 n
0000097309 00000 n
0000097721 00000 n
0000122831 00000 n
0000122856 00000 n
0000130897 00000 n
0000131437 00000 n
0000131462 00000 n
0000139680 00000 n
0000140091 00000 n
0000140726 00000 n
0000140768 00000 n
0000140533 00000 n
0000140368 00000 n
0000140673 00000 n
trailer
<]>>
startxref
140982
%%EOF