TO qF
B9j >We@"b/A{(Y"
nỈ>F HNnid8ѕ_':(
ځB,0,krޛs=D!R>3y*59; B.L?lsǻnnI E۴fM>3%H\ލXk
~qEϕ\k7VMߞKjFܷ!ר{|@ӍQ)ȫk
h![fŵh Il:M*'qI& E?:Ո5&- $ qoX|AȟNYĝ b'q-ِL%$Թ3~McŬG<݈iLmz|QTTC 3nTv ʼnma^4$T h1שP/\b%QL.,'ڛGЗfSM}:a0ĊPYPs;|{ lpd9Luִ<g*nHƾyS{>;l^" ܄nă>^ >-4m nHf1 E}\U,x&k
,'MNyٚG3 K4Qb7SN⪦ d7@{ڨf0F$L
Hh,$< Ad=C Bh֥?~N]-|~͗60 1\DyVJL.j.!b DQ3WXSeڛ4/%Aɼ3.zEdyUlaT]/I|V$6n7&9ۥ]C!t?-.xZz$\ _
w{½=X(:$YE^Dp-/ R(snzt<4&1L 0 OhvZqK *ã8Qj%(Wqu?9;Rn@u?[ZG ƙ+ց #PmB jz87/OI|8'#= D8cEq/ehkS
)iQO4
U5?lcZ8xq@} ~\
/*Z%dF,eUcC n!w%}h|X!]Rz0V-e8r;m*-+]c`pP,v ߔ;*WRբh
HZq p,=x
^~*SD l{,b-yOyY7OV.+!c;ٱ}Ͼ}>sl'2b~ 6
@;j'4v]AV%j5DZJlT5L6!Xv`E HźNe1P*ݽSN??GA=9Sy#pfdQ7_N M~hrR@(=ʌXGn0ǥ'9~^= ͩ o'?OnE"⪙K*JIdgM&ЋE[ be3dzd[S}5^WwD].DȠPg;a][^IS\0|hwz( YK%-˶҃YۍW-Ѓu [tS;Q xb0zpu
Dmۋ=6O9 Sb̓`4
q*ߥAqa)$,JBț)=2Q0*L uLZʘ`͙MMBXvƨ;K%u\9:wo Ȑ
A,ږse[݆
k6,!x b4{ƋfۿZCRs-ӹY8scf_YsNjS&F[LzG ڎ{v
]zoz7$?}vPVǘY-|go9[F:խ+L4 H.69t+ݯǽgx[xC_
9 1qYfc')b%QufQ aP:1N
H3榝?s:/}6F!: x<'\BzcA*A:Hܨ%k mXjupuaxF?ܴ/p%XN9!k;vܹk O0XD"4$=]0>'LeYƈ?VE}^21ܨI0,e7~Nyq|Π߾6|
g~ظrtz7ws#z~CU*@ҫρK%mkZ puEb=^_Tf8?:~YuU$
:ErU1 RtI@#^,ok U +%TTQP+D!+
CXbv
z̸G|$ nR;2~X eIOaW_;u-;: l"O'MDTd " 'g c_xPA9 DtT@_ynٿMD?>-3XV;Ըp+ߊHD!6
k\;
hW*>IZ|Z
U
7Oڦ)nْ'4E2*_?( ws8>4$&څvN_ɷH$jr &}M'~%zXGMAq| ΘS?b9\jۓb5~m/1Uo
FL ',~wov껭M5FTj{ZWبiPee]kā+
p #-^ב\ZYlyq!sٸeeooUv3eb=;sb9؉/6_FiiYV"Ե )
I2ҴV CE4J@UIDM'M~ޝI}dq *[5֜|
2]uXCAsk I {وLRX@b#*E9EѠW8Lj: \ 0 ò'2\fqf8"zzˏV0mJE ϰUx bҚNQ߀<痗 Ow?O*ߗ, 8co}f|r<s/ X=VOi[? |dR_Ih6x ԣcAHOW& E+ кF3ŕ[.3ӮK-#fֵAP+ R+!ի遐#z+By)j@w<ϭþ" `qc
,P(nA0x6}_d*L 0^n&Z$ͧ (
,F!ѯ⸰Pe=̱T:*˂ T]e ,dXL\N.D"-v 8d;:bNY٬1b߱LX[dYf
})2 HYt3gr3r`(kW Ӈͽ,A @'α%`0t RHN*-O*$+bŦW7Ы$-:厛hUXvӑL7v'75X
xCMgrΰ-U\?+؆y6ODf_Kt @!"NN.VKCs\apJ()ʥDN 2Lm _on@^L$v C?ٶt=]`i:ԔL~\ߥ6BfݟϐCL6| XWJc-cj9y۟{
l=K
wٙU%$0
cSFDeX/oiq~P54ݿAtΐ*ip( d"5H0B8 0)7̤_f<d3ɈdOh)mp)i"myऽWHdu"WrU"\h_ ,VZ* uaִZk~hE0vOR_{{_ݍڗn }" [' Un0 ,"^B`1Nܙ Pʞ n-OU|];eZV#p~#MQ=uvMi Խqt@3#ʓ$zxdHJ]TfSwԂ|MO}>?2w]>M\w wv.w}{c)N bd4
Z#"YI@) - J$`]ۅDIHNiTӺIQ5uiV.-v{ N%ٖNmM}{+W̷k5NI##YZ%
zTbiWgE7RBjs)9ȑg~ !LUml$ O/G'm&9'ў`ݧGdE1G"!⨐M[DBhMw2D
܍%]8$} 3t Q `Uˍ8Hku'֓OH1cr.-)DN 6s_gV
s}붯 Fmy憨?,w5
{Lo\GopƷ,\[sBe>gT=*| { 0A Iq-sq=0Dd&NADDݔ,;=9QˎYEj@Ed|L,q NҒq=҉T*SNԻ)r-ihT#Ry=JߣGQ0 4J(FyOz 2
H3P ,ݢB9r^dl lq/lOdm|)YE}˼en˖ :?GȖk lK4%n$RD b$y
-;ڌ`P?A֩XK鸗
OJ P:Ƣ 0X/=Eω¶,,N_( j 9\ ssK\HsKb@Y -QɺBIʹ6ECL4&rFZ(3my@iB"0VBh0rIrihdf')9Ȩڄ %Vc-i}bSZZ 6D;5a!1 5)i:5r6j`t`?y{mlµuGB>lk}8 ( 9¥r`vTw߉yӉ꾧66ؓ<"zd=Lesl 88(eMB/Ӱ<ӱ#VVjQNpðmؾ14
GFmCe,/ɶV8c 7CT&VMfW(ikXo OOCj>TP;>_`Sۖ-- s
)W6;RfgEmsω}w_{mCOkI!"-jDْC M V` mb 1QЈUݦjLm7MbVD'eXd Ccgw|'}Ww>
OWwv Yw)fZ9 > 4 Lxzݖ1'6k^NJXv?`ttl4Q"1 OΌ
s%;t%D_tlzΨA{UC%Ȟ)
VQ5
hX[oD܆6Ѣ.6 5 V sJd6tx V4&l49L1˨ :u˔ {0^,6c*'͢# !56Z6XLcP[)b,Xc`VAbWVxܡiGU#N'%8, 'T=?@, &+ѹ,ۊ0UiBgY.*"N = .nyjox+ڻx+C'^YmPwwE u{V{'6=wxu[WmW7dSlMW g&v@% #HjD cXjLL=6s'
G([d9.4Z
+ h "Oj6/
slMT|Jzʨij[1#.nCON?ӈY2s
L*"{ p^ VPR9R[s-b=HqDf"I2*dP`a=lQ
e浠.ڳW9`|bYY钷oewŌ? ?V
s%pfAvΓ lKVLcwB`,-1VV\Q3~CM
Ά{eY2\9*&7HA G VLb!k;2 1}l&`(NJ
N 2R2!ڊ B('% []XaH R{̖ցr W>QWWTwG ^PxD ?ĚB<ڶ;..Mw`* 7 cj'9Gӏ ]@W IڠT1L _prGC}0<şN7S'in7 w/RwӫGpyA`quNf# r :ua(P<',jvޭ: IꝰI{gyBNfO \L4 vE^>C}:3"r5nߌK7cRs`y%3-YSP {h`,$=A4n zh,
wMTF]~NdrYf
9 i)U ;Rm}=!^(`6|}u.yM65߂Q0}k`&@zՅbw/E_0ظ7lZ4^[f2T9ț 7p;nn/n`3' p>K15 )n VAQfIK)j^EDZrdg 8RnL@,G"FȰ\!Gc4)P 1})ј İ%f!g̜GHdgAv/ .|qjѮY;HwK{y WfljRssp6\Y#GtJl9g:7tM ZՉMny%6v{s{yP @;.8
U-#N_iIBDSր*L;zYV%bmWnSeF7DIOUsU[~+> :uF1p ⸨T"~T%u>.k2$c֟@ G[+Q?_> Cp{Wcsi- U;x! T2b 7S//dELjc1`Kpq0ȡ84G 7 r6(?RU VUM'sNo'#+Z4FҰϮP*\Y]M?_C5WAǏC@7ٿblj +Buv\WZ'FP 5!f$NJuM~ys^SpCG^{`*J]_dKn)++ؘOf~wC} xjN"e6߯R˔7Ly[P'txKszJMFa9Z (|Z"5"W3:zP3ac G
{= ~p;ƕPI/џ8och@sA-]/6L;շ|ES|]g2Vyõ5JK͂S-"
0
"*]^ ]GtkZ?
}Q_ qu!
Ywߕ۰DN( &4Aht ~݇},% #^57y \!C&J1hQ/ UE@q}O A ~q?O?B&.5ukHs wwwg;绳&v؎Cq $6K7R7u2AU'QB+%BjTFbV<5RM21+44UB)0h߽w|~r$omB8c
xhlfP&|$%0Bj8XZɥ髐%_]=bٙЄZld^^t F23 3#eF#ݱ]ږ|M[Nם o5 ϐrv,dECn@7Y7 $Nsb+.y՛PGv-©TwE+궨эsi`D 7D#ݻqش)"
>lt^=I!F/8$P{᪽I=~*! KfC 1^9f oDҸ5Kc
W%[HSMIN)F)7+ңHQKo+X3a/pgkq"QT*_RaZ'5NҦ
ѪUh{gD9nh+l &!osv:WDu!G*rt
T-ҒYV䜡s~KU(+4f
å753P"ӃxԔ^RH*d,
4"^{ y( 1.[~獋 wփܚ}vw|[Un $!V m*kiB UEĒmc gN[e0TD*2hS$<% E e e[P*WE
z 1ڡX$%0K`,Ŭ`ӸjX~h_cS%:=Ӧiek |{xC8N&IzLJ˪؟䂒2>g¤Kv6<Z]'{T67&tMS(-g8];%U
{4ǃ( dY\J[mqW)ee^_dj4 `tmh-+e.r+Eock.^O4OO}wu6\ěo+c>ڐJB9ï̓yܛ XR 3!`l 8
'Haߟ č1pQChWs"N
ߜ"SN)^ּ 4~p׆B˞4\=?j.9px| `ԗ0cT3` 7!X-=z
=e!-j!CypD|3>ߴPa`> fKS'?{b1@Zpc4閐
~Ǯ`UYC-Y e `ٵLjO־[_,mt=a5ܷtŗLvO:{#; ʎzBf}IEpr/Vs)f#ok/;,G[OsI7p /+#ǣY ^d gedA]"KӢJU<0묾 H9T$Jȱ]s$'kU\S[QPMs Zڸ^M. 1< 2P&^ﰗ\~~B g 4Yh 4lP<@h`\["")*\qiADhwrp1? TJ$-oW>~3ikvuãŞ Cg:>[ x bVyn>,l婝}> rW 8I;^P䠦c,|PNd&i t~)R,@cv
g?i 3rUq#Vj,q;&`ܼvx% 9øg
"0UU5\@1tpT' ))ك҃8j"v Ibgu#c`lϵ3af nZb5Y8U,k5mU[65i
pNvHz<Ӄd
$ƕ:i<2
j%2vZ?g}vMiYF8_ɜL嚼*ɛI^ 9HnP5K %1H .'Xrtx(骿eM ?ڻ7/731 X!0 }B%ڻn+ w(y{{SqwEEvl>;v%<+?j`gF{ 頸 pC6?)ab)aNHն8@%7n
aꂗ |{P]}O =;]9Jv=FNV(/6D\>ܒp㷦|%i3{ġ%K iT >C m- ^US!ʚCǺ ()Ag 1
Y9$J>5G/ @]I[v1e!^)r8Ag8HB 3ҫ @hxRRhZrWu$Ri\?#r,dka %hBJ+[[ZL&9;0&{t|Ā UCbTءLӁ PG&\zǸ^!x%q^>7.ʗK5vAn(|wGޓ )_UWyZYK|1sP'2[䔼b3rF\ xU9n -Ehl$
)Rd0!&TmyEYR22NDRө'd أ+"/C xVJt9 X 43\E
yHi4TnK E"rHy@lZ`RR63-ԜQ@,ӈ5
`"adL#BYVdY uC x< -ErWn"+4NQ!@+*y|K1 ln ݾ&oBɲY U]#c#/, {9E~D]6}qm؟5fmxelBI!#CD*3&#MH3_Rˀw+P"t־˶ Ȍ"¾?Н Kݸb.|7]7G-gv<ƂAj Y1^ 䝼wBGS߭=xtъDo|_BRL&">(Fi#h!,XEFn{^'o^^ V2Q/IQ1PA6
jCD,PpOk#s"B J
9b# ƅ"Q-4xLc DN z'Ҍ#
3BS)DO(j %Kc:ڮXiHRY+Gfeڲmh ]ȉv;&v*DH*zb
{ˈ# ,d];c1 @(.<5IP')31u4^O
=1%p$!{N!f`K挟?ɣ[ҕV!E|bŕstTT^ZwG-5:F]F]ֈ5/ n 6\stz
aCYipy\-5
]Ck(&UYɷ춷9k5ٽ' ǎ c
-ruVZ
KT[
p<
% ⧟$s/ ;, ZR]~rA m˕kFj
x4,L,W4h-6я-0F^H)g9=̟T(;K+g,>9G/n%dvdRmws&&o)>.۩n(ݰSiNi]_f&g]LN-ᾜieT(onŞnz_ؔ(?KE]@bMa%+|Κ/Fy̖MmY\nNermB:6϶һ)1TK`/-T؇ \Zj ed#:Cҹ<4B;m%79U^#-rS ߌP EJ%zA!]&i<2OUW-&CQ Ծ20pIIP.u\¦oQ`4ڨΰ*R
)z4=H2 i8ưǒi.1R* >|(cTGFj;+5V%٘SUTڤؤ,#!I;A#lۙ} <2r22 w T;N pwuhu|I^SR'JڶS։4o'2I;YqRvVL0V&#IaAS-Ó H=G=&
{^7lݱwl c6k# L T@z> T*@HO! H bm5I"p*˥A5r$X]Mw |g|Nα痼IBH!J4j5ȖF-:MS;0mtS.@ b)lb @(x1b{ !R#| BeeWeT#~þQ=(:ז}VN`l>SK[{}>\>M fݏ<5tla}FL
uL7@7/[ )]D(+t^aj,
vdP
L_$v>9)TX?aCJD YxȲ˥ER0P/[D 898'X 8^t5+j= I
] |ЖzxYIz~EW~ fco,hNB{֣ə-瓙ͥ"ʾ3ɭ}g ~֥ޯo ;Oiwq-0YLt##T v]k ڨO:Հ 0y$ E!
`Wi~Sڹwɧ 9
̉fr2ҫSws90P> jũcU[ -rx]yK
T-c_IM"<q/# l% 0v \82:y C*(yBxHGr$1[Q LZ]6iygSl-Wf%K鍙A2DweƤX4LѩQ/+/G>Euof.߅|"֛/^oP]LوR*g"[BbFP&bL[)
G0F3Avf]
.`>i"ɞ\)bATv ǓP<ЩvF0#ӟ+ `]&qFf{+E96ߚ yoj <7f+&Y&NZZ +
jWm*g}+{'Vu>cOt_Nf!9] ]iEcxsuoI2iDMYC B|h5j`$5?U#
g$7" 2 L~s̜23.pbI3.ܹ1|w1 ?0tokN_x>ZX\,.Yo6՝nOFH)Ic1$Ts %8 .!Vv G^r!P_k56Ν~(jnoI{ b3"ud @9>3A!
CBt}B,ګNN.l.8L&OX [} 9i!_/k1OX?Y`G kqü6f)8pSo`«Ȝ1gY }4 t9̙6u..
] wKpH2q2i$nFSuӝEM̥tXB%h+7 VE.#a êu0&F?x7U4]2hi[-S[JM9u@]EcN#r.-ay.!KB 璹o|ag aL%#`2iϮ7%%_ԗ=-:r|7ЮW~)wsĐ/_6[I7Ul@WqY@DE^*H Rs*9
oT-Ѱ&|k7]v>Ѫࢤl+HFceٴDa'rU 0-Kl%
~@;%
/ƭ'ZZmIZ׀ * p'$MyZZ8:ad?קE4GcM7b"24|
tF}RB ݯmR9~!N)< o&|@EuQ^Pԛ_UzՉ
Sk6
e5IYjãL86YlVL
yC>m\sJbu
iv("/Wӕ#hCӲ( Ñz=oiگ'?wdhd?
ƜM:U3k%;/ǚNpRU1l 4 S6tIV/JVqZ'!/м.q02|Ar;Z fY[Bl fL)tu6*#1oWJ br*1qB }}3Ekd7>1V3k,9=vcAel,ˀ6`٦ G/&NfCNAQl +3Cu15r\* Q M@ŰIby Ow;sʧCu{MllFKIV2(UQc/k (SvH:;5Ιo~Aa\5R^7I, tbwDtejUK,/~W>Fa~Xs':3hU 'Tʴ 8-/Wۚs|x02 y= ||.h-7#
~3q&T_cS~_0")+* '9XrBqK`ZڂBTm( Du8K.
35\W5gC[58j펍"g Yw[HR }F 8
̆2!GfAg]hp ܽ v0-xU^uY48,j J-s֜ي
%KMF:FUA8h*Ɉ J\92:o9[cFpZڻ~%ٜ_!NY?-6sfw=]̬wwfv3; h SՁR
8(R눐²v %h%}j&q*\Hy)䅈Fʃ[TE"vά:@guwΙΜ~W>[$x& ǖ ֞!I:˘KtԊ]\NVDߺAr $zC N-L0Ë_pCՐ?k"3Tʎj[mvx3!I_Msm5ʫf y_o& =buY.Ke>.^/Ku:
ēh:L?Q>h 59k *>X[oh7߸7ڻ-HĢTW&*2e0f bOSǤy~N(_,is+2zy Q RMcË«>E%,G!86pEYQ~i<VVife-˄OB3h&M (#9Sf4jry@Ӓ$[zID2yXAw!tw8x" U/U " 8YZA 4Fo-;ɂ JJˈ2A2zK>e@raqumNdN(gtRqL k
RU ͘&ib5oP!1 XxK늵jݲ('mݞs[`&w( C9zd .
9Z#Xލ:퍎3Ntx^л![S<=BhDm`lz6Χ-l!`|qOH㰹 w5Ӂ :dRPbELZi gvɳGHFn=
iݧ O i5I,J29E( DoǙͱ)0|C%6JP]w h ک3}G\Y^oDdިZj> Hh0&
SO{4]"K%T5k-˨jF,Fi2EZY%ҵZf_bbKl$Q|aEE"AVT7ZA_EYW[FEUF2DoO xݗW&Q#(k Oo>1L.mqo߲xN݅ oX#mЖMlr?Iw6~Om
#|}Z͏$Gfkg!ϴXL78d%.]g|QUR-hebb
Ϸ$<
1يxj0=-WۼaqΧ0
8
Z7G.*. < YHuБ'n @/@qJRx19=Ig|s [P:3ŲP2~~UNn#;0ף.ɃY ވixZqY4, Z(81+lV5x00~s98eV +ų?rhǧ֟9oU TPW/}0+JU~L ';sy{HNb{mdr,]8AȺ=\ 9Pv8o 9Ƙ¦d$q6˻ް¯w&
i|; \:]#z^{
|nH\<p2CLگYdO;n{]$RL;әr!L5O& <} }3^_'^g~BܪUEdN?BG!cTwlNr.7Ϧ ǶCb)9&Dt]ڱ"MWŜJ~Eﳛ, w6N &L@`TĩTR? i9#?{s88ֽ=XǷzֺa= c3e§ Mbtf
0w]ǰ`,Ch }yCWWiި7kU1[7pO^-Q^UnHv/ym $IjDTC3dQ $w`030$.~pR@ré(tF^u$!>C]s~x` \8trUk\X_*nWjr,tե}I2B⌼ʦ[yc9v7WS"5ˡo^yַ=ZQ <pB
C7:\F}88.6z肨͒vP#@H[ }| 7 Jb`Њ kۨݹ7h\ z<Μan2?,z؆9 @
P A1*{dxmsƖ%>'s*Jjo̭(Yg) Ez?McΆmmKC#-m}?@JfҶŨM~1ަr2-v[ >~,@ͤ;wɾBpj_zD9@/(9A0zFxv9ZBdD ! @Ccв =9w`K J q Zs!ya` M4]*}!֮ AZ?=# G/}N >DO1x}u<\R $ۖʧ֟_'V(,i**?cm4Q\g OYyX^Hnq~9ik*>)Rq}rt~=ֻ*Rۯɀ a7mVa]4Y8aV+A?STev.e;4n4i^$9ʽXW<~IFY81z<X?942߽c@qjpfѣWq|
+XYBIR5=lu>YSͩF(0^W{5Rm\&meH8UFrV"FG@B'\WZIO|2izOpr ETƐy[IKXg-x5˖7gE'NЕ ^Ic7O&Ɠc<,5V6A /p}(w;PC+ďp'" CnEoNbq\6I4i8q[yXc[0 4M x 7e@=~F up 'FgtZK ޝ̍@jN:? UF:A?U0FJ2a3?,C6v`:
#ϊAct]Vke P./\.]`3<_m v_4x;GȲ~
r
[G&~5ru!." '(ŹRDs0/nd!νBO>K|*3-w9?ֻ[۬qJso!d6@}ɶ={BU{+6mg"6F 1tbqS q }n˟|: CLFo"o/(tb}L&^fASM44U
97\:ukj2))&k֜n8K8{H Zhڻn9߬?{V~ZItes\#M2=+֖۬>PtH1v\V*ٖ
)U2ޝg9ڀA-;i
( CvftMg g+6\ k ? vΰgyE*};w'E>7W5tJ\,+dw^ Կ]%=p?HH(뤇35Kr_a <'X-}]^ZzXd g˳;lHvΗ^2 '
Gu -11
~އ.q-%ug [~[ހ?6y#]Ŀ? ߰Zag7B0in;3|fn3 mn
N ;鷵߁K;\
I8nIx Ky`. {|9nrcda`A&
.'-W'z:?.O_?% w= GXIi!1/=;ÔwM$VE(J:]+=>ҏ6>/5 ~RO,.ٿ&/A%)Ce m6&}c7IWZ+~h
ԖbW5
P2юB)ğR9R]NxXrZ)-d)&9U8wnw?\uH3%'759,1O,E[
(@״jy'kB )T'MXgiި-=QCMAJ3߄h4<99Wh& .jv}v_9T{~u%}Y+A,襱%Kp [ 缟% TK G~FVY^K&?U
N>gtԵ#}`}e;U(Z %HZ?KpCn?%FrRgI)$N+L~bƮEA8T 5}Ky`6ȍNR r18kMԇh"cbr>'z:Ej,F~05QOtƗmacq1>Uwr]*CCnWm غK8Ng mݒkJ&Uq%ِ$q6 V S}i*5deT|AZ"? nhjXÍo
<ޜam?>LSf[^JUT!` Jb.EdYFƺ='dr&diHY꜐hg f;yku:Om~ip~!{J[ދ]pw>öt"yD
7teϽzުT
\
NE&y$ï˲sFo2։5o[t!Ɵ
t꓀t
'ui#Y-]I?Oam
쒰M
x\K J5쑪/6LBmm*Z/=I&ݳmsὸ|8'_e] X5շod=Ód8sf7r7|zokӜ@sw3 d-<{ Po<1̋Z۷kưGBTݭgRwC=寗 ̏YWIf3|d- w gOE7d-fsQ6;}+}qPrB0t=B co RٮƠXsV* 뷟ҹFσ y+3r&ż]~3kR ǪHEkzD[@3;k$x\.Wsؼ-b-#3Blr Vgk\{}-#MLrj|Noo6'yo.5)יђeVrVt}p ZF&Y~~L_,^ԘfrHܫ!oY˵l|_'?J{Ծחuu%w`:j'8b"iK5aM?Fۍ87~1 ,M\GJBm're%XǙlWT/c{|;)Vw"~cOVcs- /LLȦ+ȩ v%d i(b00$Eg%ϝ
'8o"VǮe2{Ajedd[GkE2}\NsDF֏WG&1,gdS$7Y[٢HHc ELق 524 0o?8gh~,KAd$ bAS$K6tZͤSiEB@Qv u"?(TΨ#}Ih):sϽsTV[*+B([i~7^9}a kaiuܮ ކIS=4 ,e>ʿ"q;.;h ~m8M߈e &ޗOUA/6#|+jA|5MA);5m8#aܛqm
,qF3x,xg531
klA]IR8D^DE/vx'l`,} S!_Gz['Q OD%q,w݃}-3df]%*./X2}{~C^qJ^ G]YP?gR~>_5F{>qA /ݍ>M=9F4'VDث&w>DKGs4'p5r^f36}Dh
"#|!ڂ}8wǒ1D6zMDO0g*Nth4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh4Fh46q9s#'y. D%=< g%?G[r49Oغ[7 u7m=(0
Цא:wCn@?fnc:%кL6S h;%e%RI V%jH%u)Tʄ4Qz+!Ua5ivz ӊַ#n m)==D?rbu܉Z@ 7~ e"+`Ĝa5-ӣ|! n5<9ډ3|9ՃQ7,(RVbʷU}S0)>!Je`a%&Vpr (¨i ]Тu\:Q6<9>%Ϣ_ͷOG~3e[<OmOre<'p~Xbe dqO]}aKFnl'MH8HGSiA'5Hr 22X%[A3f˥eҌvUL+ 'x
#Vmut Gm]kW T& s@
$e/
}FʹgC+mTsÉ;/&O!Wntɉއ K.$'3}/+1߷\Ee:,0
q>jeȚZ%?t] ct`8R9gMMrҜPwSg:W+S]X CR|tP^ Nj̙?cSDکt?<)^2Lr93%Sh:'|׀Aq R<}`hgx^[~*ȧf*T-
+yȗh{N!vEH?d4'j3w Kaxn&YCere!B!xQXXO@<PG| aT_>l̲WE\ z23fG'S!KlYeMkf
jf*g$J7 N p/h,"Q4J|.c?Yئ3~νu̍M
[cBR;JHB_;6,qBP$dS9jj@S#S+aU
(7?QaioҢalLeslHLu~;3En]$l&*
&9G68 L -
/Ly n
F :?~x0d"0Y*#p] #o#V
[@?zzzTO1 8dYV|z("~Wh ,>VԊm_iv=Fgۨe]V4sf`iWa`b`z@,;.a#9BW?GZ
9πLKZ3<:80 7F\g11q鱸5\pvw&X> 8յ֒U ??#11\gā0 MGx~0&%%sD>"]tAYڎlڄG{z5Hj ?|Zp\pد~կ}_ێԊw*Hp%K m0%4d M(XL&Y1kCX8 k ډ0 B6q 1L;´ %4z:I
*3?'k#ju6V0t10q0vs08Yv~Lůa CGa ] &5`阧m_?'Y1n [q?sbAbꏝ x:0?tb/q >;, '-C3W2268/Pf;u( ],r EDn&/&Bq˼NI9u0}"~ v3Ve{MK vJ"p#V{lC+l)v]Et^G_ԇO
v*vO|+>p>
lQ[&Y
lM ܻoyht"e4*n1Kls\v-[1ϔgssi<[<=&56UUեJ*Q7TV(9ܠQ\] 8\c?%gPM9{g+WsJGϖWP[fBik~{|f1
ö[OɦxK=u>^-IP[yKBGsWD:uE&B_Nr?}%(#i2bre$e$Bl@Ȱ_#T%ާ}\} jA r\-V.ƨ%6:B" 6sQ0 \R1 ="(!4/PHZ`35
My'1] }l,=zz (}r4 ![V {ۑq>Ped 1 S2>Y)gI#toZ ~BiZaLN̻AcupF5>;֎yәZټ,|o
0o҄9m1%]s7݈܌HDd:r&2Y(˗{T.7[b)o_>Z2cwv& wget(Ν]#_١M?[f+Ļ~Sr;O_O %w̗H)J,RtFѠ|LQ+Q)&T&HxK|X>/BS<
>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[86.0 168.0 97.0 179.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>>
endobj
35 0 obj
<>/BS<>/Border[0 0 0]/PA<>/Rect[66.0 46.0 77.0 57.0]/Subtype/Link/Type/Annot>>
endobj
17 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 4/Type/Page>>
endobj
45 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(98-0614.a1)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\
ved%20-%20HTML/98-0614.a1.html)Tj
49.74 0 Td
([7/7/2021 3:17:15 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 753 591.75 12.749 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
EMC
endstream
endobj
16 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 3/Type/Page>>
endobj
46 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(98-0614.a1)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\
ved%20-%20HTML/98-0614.a1.html)Tj
49.74 0 Td
([7/7/2021 3:17:15 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm
(event,)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(the possibility that Applicant might obtain a discharge of his credit ca\
rd debts by a bankruptcy court at some)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm
(future date)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(does not constitute evidence of rehabilitation or reform in the present.\
)Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
32.711 0 Td
(Cf)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
(. ISCR Case No. 98-0188 \(April 29,)Tj
-32.711 -1.125 Td
(1999\) at p.)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(3 \("A stated intention to perform acts in the future does not constitut\
e proof of a demonstrated track record of)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(reform and)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(rehabilitation."\).)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Applicant's ability to handle his financial matters prior to his most re\
cent problems constitutes evidence that is relevant)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(under the whole person concept of security clearance decisions. )Tj
25.712 0 Td
(However, that favorable evidence does not preclude the)Tj
-25.712 -1.125 Td
(Judge from considering the security significance of Applicant's recent h\
istory of financial problems. )Tj
40.279 0 Td
(Considering the)Tj
-40.279 -1.125 Td
(record as a whole, Applicant's prior favorable financial history did not\
preclude the Judge from concluding Applicant's)Tj
T*
(recent history of financial problems has negative security significance.\
)Tj
28.49 0 Td
(Under Criterion F, the security eligibility of an)Tj
-28.49 -1.125 Td
(applicant is placed into question when that applicant has a history of e\
xcessive indebtedness or recurring financial)Tj
T*
(difficulties. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
4.832 0 Td
(See, e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
3.332 0 Td
(, ISCR Case No. 98-0349 \(February 3, 1999\) at p. 4. )Tj
(The overall facts and circumstances of)Tj
-8.164 -1.125 Td
(Applicant's delinquent consumer debts provide a rational basis for the J\
udge's adverse formal findings under Criterion F)Tj
T*
(and her overall adverse security clearance decision.)Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
0 -2.125 TD
(Conclusion)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
T*
(Applicant has failed to demonstrate the Administrative Judge committed e\
rror that warrants remand or reversal.)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(Accordingly, the Board affirms the Judge's January 14, 1999 decision.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Signed: Emilio Jaksetic)Tj
ET
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 16 490.5 cm
0 0 m
113.32 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 465.75 Tm
(Emilio Jaksetic)Tj
T*
(Administrative Judge)Tj
T*
(Chairman, Appeal Board)Tj
T*
(Signed: Michael Y. Ra'anan)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 16 388.5 cm
0 0 m
134.795 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 363.75 Tm
(Michael Y. Ra'anan)Tj
T*
(Administrative Judge)Tj
T*
(Member, Appeal Board)Tj
T*
(Signed: Jeffrey D. Billett)Tj
ET
q 1 0 0 1 16 286.5 cm
0 0 m
120.645 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 16 261.75 Tm
(Jeffrey D. Billett)Tj
T*
(Administrative Judge)Tj
T*
(Member, Appeal Board)Tj
T*
(1. )Tj
(The Administrative Judge entered formal findings in favor of Applicant w\
ith respect to SOR 1.a. \(tax debt\) and SOR)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(1.b. \(department store account\). )Tj
12.967 0 Td
(Those formal findings are not at issue on appeal.)Tj
-12.967 -2.125 Td
(2. )Tj
(Paragraph 5 of the Prehearing Guidance reads as follows: "Neither party \
should attempt to furnish any information)Tj
T*
(relating to the case without giving the other party the opportunity to b\
e present. )Tj
31.964 0 Td
(Such actions constitute what are known)Tj
-31.964 -1.125 Td
(as prohibited )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
5.443 0 Td
(ex parte)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
3.249 0 Td
( communications. Also, copies of any proposed exhibits must not be submi\
tted to the)Tj
-8.692 -1.125 Td
(Administrative Judge prior to the hearing. Any documents to be offered a\
s evidence should be presented at the hearing)Tj
T*
(itself during the presentation of that party's case. In some instances, \
when an Applicant has appended documents to the)Tj
T*
(response to the Statement of Reasons, the documents have been returned w\
ith an explanation that such materials are)Tj
T*
(inappropriate to a pleading and that they should be resubmitted as propo\
sed exhibits during the hearing. If such action)Tj
T*
(has occurred, an Applicant should inform the Administrative Judge during\
the hearing, and be prepared to again offer)Tj
ET
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
12 0 0 12 16 38.25 Tm
(the material previously rejected.")Tj
ET
EMC
Q
endstream
endobj
47 0 obj
<>
endobj
48 0 obj
<>
endobj
49 0 obj
<>stream
H\n0 \/*+Z 4tH#D^㪓 %飯k;,kp~<]}p`U nlY*
>(9/~'3q7o_U:#b(K0Ӈ^ZڎQ(ֆònҰOn28C "UBqU*_>9Hٹ[/1Jb>
w)"Θ$0b9y&19欛BKo{өp,ZNx,Z^x L-AS{96wG
0 %j
endstream
endobj
50 0 obj
<>stream
H|TT=\(X;3p-;{L%)V( FT V]Q,("*6eF:];O[o%g}: %FPok~U95NإEFYZ>@ڰA1fƅ@):?2{TN=K}DV+v {
;|U֫C.*"N2;gI2 4pJ݁2~9CxkdohTbOG~c
< <, N
Z(V
(
TeRI/9Ҥ
+B1"w Z\VߖZhWsPW W~
|K3 }bCaBqqUnŊp/QWWX䣙-V_?UVi@jש[~7 l-Zjݦ ?Щ]~kpH(GDvѳW>Q}E 00Ac u#F6:~q '$N4yJig̜5{y`K.["ekx6nڼe;vڽgo2f :|$'N3gϝKm+W!JN+$!.Aa rG #yO|_RC^ V))!tm*VF3imZg6\۪ejg4X{͓'іDLJb-i-m-c`լUլ_EnЋ Wz]=Pz>Q/4} O;[GW}d@)q)SRS
D<'31߷mAAљI6`1hX~ C9^rK9_ wR:+xe2UQ 91e}LZ;-=`-Nۮei+3Hs9ɜ,9l$}PJr(oy!^ >pHғ 8dK% 8D BR.Ś1՚N6\ȡ়ex-}ػ+߳bRItu xhy3lc9p+AFz:ڎZO U Usܑov:+wVD wErseT3yn\?{[{{jh-ݶ(|˖eKAr[[K[ j|oFQDFiOr^*TK]uaxZB>@ JY%\+}"Uy!| ڰYEo:b d\m ێ{n m(+p6 `'͢d &A
xKsh.ͣ'O h!-dZLFrbTR+ZFiJZEi
u6FDi ^ MDJh;*AҨ$yP)*kNEh74^J}2 yc6Ry@(*R%2 ,7,dCtP6 ctN/Ntr3ti U*TpFěy omSy4Ży啜.O
|3 g!>G81>nxdx'd S|Y>_K|ml+W_|omw>~ȏ1? 8 ſhcx, /NIRq+~AB.U(D1Q\v(wQRxR^t.EDɦ6EP4E(f3BDkFvj#DQz_S Gchcqqq188hhdlbL_/W EWjSo1c }fa.-ݝRkB5$Hqww-NR HZzAnfEnvCnG~y@ ayĹܖG+<.Oȓ<-ȳA(?_5s˹ܔ?K- $/+&ZznFnfn[VnV7Hijj%jFjƩjBvdBT5Mjf9tkFt{AwԝKJo[Yw] WSuP RuT S uRRm u9i'M/KJV DH E IT&JPp$EL i2N"K /)=e2Ҕ2,e씃rR.My(/ gAE9Q
T
Qa*BEv{~NRϩ$TR9*O"US/h2SMP
4i:͠%͢zިz>$>O*E4 Ld k6-}sș83gᬜ?9\p^_ FKk.sc tc87MB\pQ7]Ÿ8\Ks.帼]
o+pEĕݵ:w
Wj\kpMŵz\pCnč 75ܜ[pKnŭ
vl܁;r']+w܃{ыu7[w}/< CxN y7K2cbMH Ȩo;I,EdFdE6s E%;X`ňD Z@eu
ęQ b3cQ4S5 `艚6ѸKv ǘP1mqx
J]~˽_D8,8.>'gIMS*ޞr6^:Pw N mOmU <40s5Y;|ƑQ ,VwzXfn2O[SZ^u
u M "Gk3_57[̝fTPQ2m-i
{ߦ9W(WvӍ
x)\ӹ˒0jc`#a<)[/Q.*D5p&?x qF\!|#9o &i1f0 9]I˚,U.ai` rvێۮm@5"]vROkO<<@-%,8!v)Dx$!
0n<~ F[Ct[O xT=t-DW\ S1 %ԕ^7g^v *
ȅE\ȡb<шK,
r( )"6ޥX^DM
r9< {rm
<*nܛcR.O>|~ݎSbUl_=e0%Be\[ΊbL{ )~ZJ>u7eC߂+բaCZ1 L% f6"*3m Row< _r ._ W4w+ȻJuޘIysG 3<;k!
HOKMп_rRשݫgB|8Gln1tչSdvH5#o(z~~Uh<744}zôGa62}$Gk#idz5[b/ܺO3n°&,wtb扫tk51v^ews
]cz5t p
A=Fmi`$O`QTN_zr }%5<\e ˰fZ:!1r_4S;Mӧx
YktMźnñqϸ˞MAOLͪ47'{֯χo`H+-#eBK}k+m=VJ3:c` TR H -X՝plF= O5DwmfCTGBO
}a)<ܒ
JɖFxDkīc#OE6˳1 1˘74: ݚoIѺOp~-G-dVp FjbŅGBp}Xzڼ}^ GE^LdNպ}yTVר,ae z td,z>ݯ#| "u7"Dx*s ?m^?mASG&+|j^d$[.Z[mIF66&qӀKÔ&Cc^Fд Ct `Bcc!)fB:C &f< D%?\ld_WҞ{9ݻEMݤ/v2 &]\֍R>y&e*bރͣ½GrerO hrKӥI0'ں֤Ӛb ;tٜ^ސ
m8YOz]/ 8n m>uV5^UW$<ܹ{pW=Wt"$彄앝r)WP|}RBh( |}SOhS(BC|Cl2T!"-dSS|Cla>[V܀ rpR|/J,T!(yie"!D% bxN|\C>K&V3JB}2K)INpuRS羞aNftl~d
QuԠ-& 3E@[Vjch$VS
{B^
zaQG3Ta"64V\]{m{D$1Z 3.-4E٪pmO=nߋ@~^{=RG?^IľNoѼ} V~_0DLdpVy?PNE}650!ƈac0䦮hɐT~[T2GJqfa|'SdVdSd"
;]F¤ 7 YilД텱5ּKqvRx[v4 R s37/Б⑿nټŏZw$.7_s/6d6`zZ:|@X_ˬ5ldvv̠a ;T9H#+>RUWj ;xLu$piTo'e%|wIݧ-vr%]C.UDdQ= >
'd^D$Y]) &,+g B=5bX 0+(MָnBxZT3y~VɣKz 4$V&.%˭Ӄ{J/,.f@M9n'ۛ͗Ի[.ŝZޟJeUs
ow4=:ۻ6hQs18Fɦv\Q|
O> ^&jÙܗUgN"bNB.aX
IJ:+$uTuRqtObbNoC~*j y
ԉH) xf2ed(C%}I bcig D "y 'A 'x|ı\#./Xg8*Ȅ @`$s~>ꌎ8:Gur1M6QdT
p2P ..X|a ۢB5._=OfԀ(dgYv*O ( іD212ዠٻG*qaܩ
LD6lc /DYUd5 WiɗL[k ;DD۟[HJ﹗} nu[_H-[FVl H ]ӫW:5oUu]\ZwްKZ4znҕgh+
'{o a1IAQЀpoN]9D-G%D U( ͧ .ҢyycDtD,BؘUWklC]5*@>__ r=/ 3P^Iw} ?
xZA@WsfQ2+lqn
d\ZP2 Y0wydAt⻍u|E !M#qj{r诰0Pʊf-ǘӃOoy}3 0 JI1XB*VE:UԄZVuWv$1uhcyyjw1rIZVؑJ9Q.4
z v5)V3p 𨕐2CB.(;?%{K{orInw' #!"Z*(FJjTU3`:-C @2ԙˌ)uD{ _ʴ9{v/@>s<}. ^_~iUlt ,xp#
i4mORm}
K7Miq1ǁYj. y+LKn XKLܩwl;|8wG[NNVoZe?º}n/*!>g1S}D"IBDx MtE"gezJX8J`hGX w-!~.
ޠ/zh$p$ WY0`,*SqMt6u0W <ʌLu^pixrPA[Mc%*>
b~
|y1>K\/z&MmPaah
%ң1MiS$NbXA g
\4nx]f^tdH3 Qؿm;6lI]-/YkSeKGVoXSYЃC@uP{DDg;st@ ~-gKtU]aIAh5 qeHʟ
T^SlV~~s#'Fnw;n }٧lvovŖpŘ-4zvKCk79Pl'jBiX5G.:.Q
L6kt[^jX;Wzg5RZw wW(kTR4;#?ଜ]h|v$4]{7Ӵ&*HZKQeJU5FZ[ICj[-ol=Uz!ӵʞol* ߍV =pGA4o8<;rOw[CKFO5|VĕTbۻw* l-Jk 0K$h8F.}= )")<;(dJ$ZɁח K8ͭ*av%+TƅWWγw86#($+Vr'3FOXF!jȼE)V)O*=LHbWg+
Lr}&K.ls|
5ZIjx8-T p:AY9"fYwV&l-!oR 8xh.Mtv2״|nٛ fs
ZuR.Z2W}`{1zGKIj)
52lEX@*VI@_6}^-=m'Q\N%%°UGn$yL#E@(+0BM
Zm-3`h*Ǹ;"b a`%>hjai>}֗tXk1\ _
L?M%Ɯ5V6: i4]~ -l ]!&=ڄ[oDb4TpE'6)0/W7BoN<;*pbοR\_0!9sl] =BnXUq8\t8n)"" A FD
4"0CMV
4AJWz @ r1 S2[` ^ɗp_>~w93N{pĩӛݸ 5:Ex= κwp%v=88pA;|+*DFфML ;c .rZBL{`H\H:ZB1ފQvc{H6sUsK
=@5f[ t%~y( :GQ\3oH爪ar۹E;!GRr {SЍ &B3 p]2;=q *hĿ,s r2|qW0,o=V _W
0
si=aM@_|?;KU)Ym? ̶{33[}6K5+5UeImlimvfT8ۛFuO U 0q 5qhD`.p
QTbÄF%xBp;x`T5BjKC|JVz!Her^-M]g5IH:v|m'cE \G!P )JAZ:lCƫbtd2 P蘴.Y+6l뒥iTE1ºڐ\;-9Nՠj5M5VPb P57 UWMj1UmįbҜ|N :hfkP怞 p$X~ X3Q8t?=cR0,c{.<?]~ٹ6wbhQԤ > zQ7m.,/f) 6rϬ˱O!a*kRW %9[ư<5
OeʢJLT(<>R%ťC_j
dW87 }TC2R:`mY}d*͍O6zMB֪ +s&S* Ȭ3z)98mĎ|0Ɇ\5j- wpgM.^}T"vX+w469 ߳^u[ƼыڧV{;r*C[";O%Vp%cBsQ9""`k~x/* RH 6իr@*XmT%x=Eɢ"P3◢ GvM$TఊQvnG_zR"^sj
5Niܻ ]#ձ9=dE(㊻ f{0 wX7%~-jddmC6(RS ds =S=[)ίo(WL1zީܼc.T]bhf2ܖ n|M>KiD'"Z`M,g?R$LP,cJ$Q,OU5Lev+2J0YJܑuSeM.wʗdQvG| *b9Dshnhy͐% d'*251JI) SqZj*pFa! ˠ}%>[
I%$m%NV#" A2暭[%- jvޗ oȳF85kΆZF:}HQ{jTW~u8CV?DJ sqHQDSD!
[n}d}Z P~'s\4Ki8 ) +h"R!\QJq,p),t:h)vx6ᚔMRUfg9i,
?h=aa[>@e6X6~P1rd'IܩoọƐ*236? Op2X jp(Я.
X)./SݖO]8ؼ.T/rdYSC/jۚ_C%%fpkjzԞUY vOW\R o:Ke ur-WMk,%?1+fNz.0n~ˈx.s2U0HiѬs#g̴<|fj č/!@tȓ yK
VyӸlT`*3 _`;&'-%+J:~7x
A'{6ϋIԥ_s?1$q&ׅ` Df`%\z DuѵW{X Cj\K {),q;<l Ę"rBv-~X7Z})8 #پٞd?/znm<{kx kzr#0{.ׄJN gM]8.zVEg?' 3, #U~h苙^ >%)dTB ~=v4ʰY$E DҬ0H{H9[ a C&|
k;|߯͟Г }m2esuʸ7 1"@ )~l +юub _ineױ{ ~C۹ i" _g:3gdG>2$l{gܺ/wf 8tޗFq_fq!o דcr \{a?F z 6|b~, $/r&6Y΅_k)=0!QQo CW液//bl, ܻb7Y翉t]F;BM uL ci#-"vfX/hQE{ gQ]{w oi%ZRG !j)RDyKmXT@ FeZ U$tlPEZ+*Cɞ~ϟM:c3>ν{w;HokNA{Cr|Zγt Z更L őkmK
5d
V=o'6|J
ϒ ^"v5rȻaoI32l%KnS&̵M ' )<;?& e~Ë)?׀m#azA $5h>ISctA~NveOA.yh2h9~꼉io6:$+e}^LbUY^S-ck%'{)EǷxLxuy{;r?kCLB 8S|j|H!¯8ө Lj}\A&rE^jEjȘBާg:7 ZC,OIKXkY%\agsV9 r[+ʒcV]&êRf'q)ήߞ&/Dh{~.cC%,U)ڥ"\kSY\@xD4B/sxKss/q\.yLG3>2b. ;ԃh/:P'C|,jW5|ܼQ*_R$3T!u+t\RG:-i97?QZ>fc5tD=gj.R?f
VK>U?T⌦vaڈ4!N0. }a_53 WC k$x o/9k'
L{'s x.FZ~ǽ>
F/0M@:>A x7CT)<`0^gb o 7y ^[n<ퟁR֯!]M棯jCyo8|-;+نW~n)hdss^`?n~^n>>Yp5' ¥g¥g2?#VQR?=&C Xp(ɒ>krbOT-l}Vr+j6E%9F+ͩmGəf7̓S< <7 D~D'
|]{;ONbg1jrE{m>w66s0m1\J onHS|8LiQ
9-O*RUN]oy IDc\"fI_7YoUC}u;Z&bzQ]а~x:=ѕoi?F=08Kewswҿ#SJѾׯpΈu\ r7|<1vB͠?Ru 8\_9V! |tG\זOk <̛YҀbJ&Ϙ9f
q ]kLzAk] V4PN P( uJȑ=Z>܍_uw1=㴢4 H>~Nj jd>X:4\0 **#hb3^!F*t.Itz
j4 xU`O73q"' ,~bf7qJ1ls鏔gfCb Վև<(|c5ևpK+0.6% Sh ڳ~\{jhOhna 9_ÏιGhq?n @ ^`&ö < dz>8 .2X4xWzB |ps iЂ\+ Ы
| $2[O|~,s=3*;?
Ж\,10XQ>Zwu S;8tV]H9" \YR=FcFoV:0G^`mC4zi"ח"#R+Yj ,ARͳ=HST + EvALG$Yy>2+yݑxFή&3|ڋϣX+[@^#92?АrϝdVFH yZ<]/46GiTuMbת~jE!ݑE
jkOEw4Om q~4B43a?
;Փ@?}v*o}f$T ɧ~
' +ц;I퉌6x-u nsgyu;wxeNp(r)c@ki;Z7]Xs<,֡wt5S\{
ZILzI˿WCK-@G,h~XϺc
q nhK]5_5
uC-bjrmSn~&&b?CoU#=A8^=]Y s/ڥ20cVR`Ltz1J#d!h(eL(*$x7TQjԈ窩GY?5g{=}9gA t&nXRD_N /]i'ۖtU qK"1 ,J4ÝM`nh;M9e` "KPI&i"ȉ( =0Ap+Ͻ{oS r(7dPQ([) %/d|y awyGm_C6`cCQ!{P( <{q
ѶO7rWYU3`M 2s[(R
kM}Q#Q5Q;p]4|*/=^ImrE{a@ |~ooĽZ=uԳ
s6k#muhiսpt{U#3xye'@+ATA(Ve1҇@Ep c} vf*?@sQ+uB
q$AlxG5B>| m lS(iZι+k7P㠭a64+. ;2uCT썙h։ Q)FUjgY]T#虀zjץ!v
ziyz)Ao
Wi )Ŏ$Sv;>evO32Si7/i #i]h{;='Y_Y|m~Tcz
b/Khu>ۜo[5SGLgC_K,5o\`oMQwî!%_K ~ 2čd$bN"tI{Y1=[E keiCCۏa } wG_$:kD=)zG1rOҺ
1% cT \=1bj8GCRm3ҷs :{4фrOęL~q_!j 1Ggsyg.
C!|{
9p
\{A1?o_
w{g݁T{![%Xk -? HE}xվ;TY x#&=N s3ݒ:rn46j'K4Ym%J
7jdx;?ڝMKܙ s.15xcss텸KGLuq^Pش먣-Lߧn㜦YEXw): y=/1 O &cOƞ[ vD"v>2={J`_=MY$ހ {6ÏƟɤcFWzH}d-.f=}Yysh
*c.y'&LYȡ/}{'h+>WJts=\[3s6z:nnJa·}d#_z
Oo!mm7{M9ͷ 4cgZaw 4ـq6W%v NA*`Aj=
w_JB ` Szh t }AJ|Ip Gk
! Eg9 VQQ; K8 ^7rn 6?[$2 :׀`,
8 99
{BpoB;C)m݆: 3n+q^ᕡ|ę?M 'wjQ3g,r~+ʙbrzrC#7wC)Yws=h"+9 |RZ/gab^:A?J{L bv>Ur[9/r~C#Pf8 {}t z#qS_g+}L5 xߊ6W!vF}
yۚ:i;^YJtX4:Eh$@nkSk2U)A'T1tnU|%uPwżŵտ=a %RK[_T1Շo~{[ :\ u%8gQW
=u,J
oM4L/nUJ ]M %D[o|OP=(O}m =8ĆR)%H($16P#l30C_Ȓ!*myVNkXa(By4!2ЈC+J-0m$Rt\oCm( gn2}9lUg'p.}\ٽ2}(:P| >?䳠YR&?ST_X
m2k[}`JV:էifMQkiRM?Bm+oOl"- WkHu` !~7EOrvV*FX @ B֗)dI!o>ʢ25e͚ޥ'aC
q3x
x//}?h _LZa\SV[Qs>U#_~,A y}Zd\>HX}gR6$>tz V mB чb/_IIy&PB(4 Obt=
1 b
fM,b;L H2 p+~!# a/*d%JB_^ƚ֔Κx4.5ؔr7(BLvrW[S:Zy\6 :hRr,VS|-U=$t>ja O'{Xvs 6R(ث7O6 c MHE^O+A^7(ӸY Yo-:)3gz^9`=(os
ti lI3h; e8gЮZҎȢv1 ߷wtsi>uH&揧J}e ד.`_@Za6K_C\O#YU>C8"m
ء /ja ʍgl ۖjcZ ߒ%W{Q3~WO}Ȩm )!q_zr<A{'s9wtFӰ78̗9nd6xzBo4Fa_og;~y^cgv̘Ⱥc/G:v%tX;ivG[]K2zsvvq4vI_.iو-XS%t>*6EmoN!-PP)~&8 ;n\bsV|7_B 'QQ3b<'?IKg2&]s>W:Q I/I4pP/KH"H$D"H$D"H$D"H$D"H$D"H$D"H$eܢ46I*QTM_U璎P$/Ց" j()C.P -PSB!T蟠9H ^߀h
jPPJfØ75tތ1q#3H~~Qz{ϧѐ(GQ11Tﶝ\ Jym#tCP#ԊR؉19N]-fiD_j1vDI#Z(OTw'(N ¡w: ~mWT[[Q/sw"qRc w-Uh v2.В߉Ё^ܧmva~AsH8h:vY$|`$gBvUpa]"nW9q' NMigFk4&Pdao#cGyRcWB:G( 8[ۡS٥P hv<;HjMc7NNuLӃ~' w&qDZ'pv(Yj?9N gϫ>;lp3H/HHb8i6ӑfȌ$ 2P.K9+њ߁XKH<{.;ځ }_=:]4E'Nk jx `
hi{ "A .駵Ӌppk1l;Z
=HCѸmπ,ѫuOi++N
{GS5jZH;"7
i/֫7 5i:>Asm\>v̓6MlZn2ܠ!Z2*JݦMꎜmYRiҤ}@|4AL`{"д}ٝwy TF~71d.a^@!NY+ A]7&H Sl 9 *R2} 7/^5/5[w }WwI'ԼDܔe{ O} |\ >r,6 >hd1s>O9fk{{/mhV7 Y`Nےf& 4 a)&6 Unm%ArMǸCVSGEH8 m̊h1C6ڐvBdudvAhn9je6dF34B³hZ` 'ddX'gcm`U7XQ~" 62--Hd:$3o=ΰW]|IUw% 7Fc헢eFa3xUmi\[]ZE[`a FvrLf04l!tȯ[>W a# Z cM3[PCMzybJaZ'aall" dL]/CzRF4KwiҙːwN>:EIYhz !#+HΊ,b S0uKށӁF0ڌmL0F $%۹vQQ)xLuiٴdZ?崲1ܒVr!r+~'B^BoŔbrLy><SSScJ>17 =5~NԺ3Su XlG]= ы,G(*c@Q?H_|ՇCy(QMR?w g rHE%<~M=r] QB
, a=ɖ >DgGu\eLx沿 [{eWS0ٛSU#<{E.k^ /E]$9#O 's~ A>lf^˞%ͩW,W}SݣuM`> ;,aSײo ƶ.>a`?϶$UVEP3٠ͩkd IaKUҌt@*J4*&mҠ-吼FdYHWlw; p !5(!X&kYK85EOjrFӺsO3e\t.} s1zmnE N#@vi ks%$
J"TSꉸpOp>"p[>
nt7q\Yhm7f>:7v^OڍӦ;8f#FK8yO M#_ rN ڔ۔.hgZUW+.(}<<}y Pe)
~U*TTӷ?_6
APIR!R1Da_~8,=5 aEtZlG'q!"V=0 0
endstream
endobj
15 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 2/Type/Page>>
endobj
51 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(98-0614.a1)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\
ved%20-%20HTML/98-0614.a1.html)Tj
49.74 0 Td
([7/7/2021 3:17:15 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm
(interpretation of the record evidence and is not otherwise arbitrary, ca\
pricious, or contrary to law. )Tj
39.263 0 Td
(Implicit in Applicant's)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm
(appeal argument is the assumption that his consumer debts can easily be \
eliminated through discharge in a bankruptcy)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(proceeding. )Tj
4.942 0 Td
(As will be discussed later in this decision, the possibility of a future\
discharge in bankruptcy is not proof of)Tj
-4.942 -1.125 Td
(current reform and rehabilitation under Criterion F. )Tj
20.771 0 Td
(Furthermore, a discharge of Applicant's consumer debts in)Tj
-20.771 -1.125 Td
(bankruptcy would not have precluded the Judge from considering the secur\
ity significance of Applicant's overall history)Tj
T*
(of financial difficulties. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
9.663 0 Td
(See, e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
3.332 0 Td
(, ISCR Case No. 98-0445 \(April 2, 1999\) at p. 3.)Tj
-12.995 -2.125 Td
(The Administrative Judge specifically took into account the fact that Ap\
plicant's decline in income led to problems with)Tj
T*
(paying his consumer debts. )Tj
11.137 0 Td
(Reading the Judge's decision as a whole, the Judge had a rational basis \
for not giving that)Tj
-11.137 -1.125 Td
(mitigating evidence decisive or controlling weight in this case.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Considering the record as a whole, the Administrative Judge had a ration\
al basis for finding that Applicant was)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(financially)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(overextended. )Tj
10.412 0 Td
(Even if the Board were to accept Applicant's argument and concluded the \
Judge erred by)Tj
-10.412 -1.125 Td
(finding that)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(January1995 marked the turning point when Applicant became financially o\
verextended, such an error)Tj
T*
(would be harmless)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(in this case. )Tj
12.692 0 Td
(The Judge's overall analysis of Applicant's security eligibility does no\
t stand or fall on)Tj
-12.692 -1.125 Td
(her finding as to when)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Applicant first became financially overextended. )Tj
28.962 0 Td
(Considering the record in this case, the Judge's)Tj
-28.962 -1.125 Td
(overall analysis of)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Applicant's financial problems is sustainable whether Applicant became f\
inancially overextended in)Tj
T*
(1995 or in 1996. )Tj
(Furthermore, the fact that Applicant closed various accounts without del\
inquency, and is current with)Tj
T*
(some of his)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(accounts, did not preclude the Judge from considering the security signi\
ficance of Applicant's failure to)Tj
T*
(satisfy his)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(delinquent debts.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(The Board does not find persuasive Applicant's contention that the Admin\
istrative Judge erred by holding against)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(Applicant the fact he borrowed money from his 401K plan to pay debts. )Tj
29.048 0 Td
(Applicant's contention focuses on two)Tj
-29.048 -1.125 Td
(sentences)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(that appear in a lengthy discussion by the Judge of Applicant's efforts \
to deal with his consumer debts. )Tj
45.281 0 Td
(The)Tj
-45.281 -1.125 Td
(Board reviews)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(a Judge's decision in its entirety, not just isolated sentences in the J\
udge's decision, to discern what the)Tj
T*
(Judge found and)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(concluded. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
11.469 0 Td
(See, e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
3.332 0 Td
(, ISCR Case No. 96-0522 \(May 1, 1997\) at p. 3. )Tj
(Considering the two sentences in)Tj
-14.801 -1.125 Td
(context of the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Judge's overall analysis of Applicant's efforts to deal with his consume\
r debts, the Board concludes the)Tj
T*
(Judge did not)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(commit legal error or act in an arbitrary and capricious manner.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Applicant challenges the Administrative Judge's finding that "Applicant \
has made no payments toward any of his)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(consumer credit delinquencies in the last year, despite a 40% increase i\
n income over 1997." )Tj
37.312 0 Td
(In support of that)Tj
-37.312 -1.125 Td
(challenge,)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Applicant makes two arguments: his 1997 income was lower than his 1996 i\
ncome, and income for both of)Tj
T*
(those years)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(was lower than his 1995 income; and the Judge failed to recognize Applic\
ant had to spend a good portion of)Tj
T*
(his money to)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(pay )Tj
7.11 0 Td
(an accountant and a lawyer. )Tj
11.383 0 Td
(Applicant's challenge is not persuasive. )Tj
16.009 0 Td
(The Judge's challenged finding)Tj
-34.503 -1.125 Td
(pertains to)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Applicant's income for the year ending in December 1998 \(when the heari\
ng was held\), not for year 1997.)Tj
T*
(Furthermore, a)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(reading of the decision shows the Judge was aware that Applicant was usi\
ng the services of an)Tj
T*
(accountant and a lawyer. )Tj
10.189 0 Td
(The Board will not assume the Judge was oblivious to the common sense fa\
ct that accountants)Tj
-10.189 -1.125 Td
(and lawyers generally)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(expect to be paid for their services.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(There is mixed merit to Applicant's contention that the Administrative J\
udge erred by finding that Applicant had a)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(monthly net remainder of between $400 and $500. )Tj
20.467 0 Td
(The Judge's finding lacks some clarity because it appears in two)Tj
-20.467 -1.125 Td
(different portions of her decision, with the Judge using slightly differ\
ent language each time to discuss the finding.)Tj
T*
(Applicant's appeal argument cites to the second time the finding is disc\
ussed \(Decision at p. 10\), but does not cite to the)Tj
T*
(first time \(Decision at p. 6\), where the Judge notes some of Applicant\
's monthly net remainder was used to pay legal)Tj
T*
(fees. )Tj
(Applicant refers the Board to page 132 of the hearing transcript in supp\
ort of his appeal argument. )Tj
41.653 0 Td
(At the hearing,)Tj
-41.653 -1.125 Td
(Applicant was asked how much money he had left over each month. )Tj
27.575 0 Td
(A review of transcript page 132 shows there is)Tj
-27.575 -1.125 Td
(some)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(ambiguity as to whether Applicant's answer referred to November 1998 onl\
y or a broader period of time. )Tj
44.528 0 Td
(Given)Tj
-44.528 -1.125 Td
(the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(ambiguity of the testimony on this point, the Judge's finding is questio\
nable. )Tj
32.26 0 Td
(However, considering the Judge's)Tj
-32.26 -1.125 Td
(decision)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(as a whole, this error is harmless and does not warrant remand or revers\
al. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
33.517 0 Td
(See, e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
3.332 0 Td
(, ISCR Case No. 98-0380)Tj
-36.849 -1.125 Td
(\(March 8,)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(1999\) at p. 4 \(discussing harmless error doctrine\).)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(The Administrative Judge did not err by stating that it is not clear wha\
t debts might be discharged if Applicant received)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(a)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(discharge in bankruptcy. )Tj
10.802 0 Td
(The Judge is not required to speculate about which of Applicant's debts \
might be discharged)Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
-10.802 -1.125 Td
(if)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(he were to file for bankruptcy and )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
14.661 0 Td
(if)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
( he were granted a discharge of his debts by a bankruptcy court. )Tj
26.324 0 Td
(And, in any)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
14 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 1/Type/Page>>
endobj
52 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 779 Tm
(98-0614.a1)Tj
EMC
/Artifact <>BDC
0 -86 TD
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\
ved%20-%20HTML/98-0614.a1.html)Tj
49.74 0 Td
([7/7/2021 3:17:15 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
1 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm
(answer to the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(SOR \(with the documents attached to it by Applicant\); and \(b\) the do\
cuments were returned to Applicant)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm
(at the hearing,)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(not before the hearing.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Applicant's appeal arguments fail to demonstrate the Administrative Judg\
e acted contrary to Paragraph 5 of the)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(Prehearing)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Guidance. )Tj
8.913 0 Td
(A careful reading of Paragraph 5 shows that it specifically addresses th\
e issue of what should be)Tj
-8.913 -1.125 Td
(done if)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(documents attached to an applicant's answer to the SOR were returned to \
the applicant before the hearing, but it)Tj
T*
(does not)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(specifically address the issue of what should be done if documents attac\
hed to an applicant's answer to the SOR)Tj
T*
(were not)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(returned to the applicant before the hearing. )Tj
21.491 0 Td
(In this case, the Judge was faced with the second situation. )Tj
23.744 0 Td
(Since)Tj
-45.234 -1.125 Td
(that second)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(situation is not addressed by Paragraph 5, the Judge's handling, at the \
hearing, of the documents attached to)Tj
T*
(Applicant's)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(answer to the SOR was not in violation of Paragraph 5. )Tj
27.092 0 Td
(Even if the Board were to assume solely for the sake)Tj
-27.092 -1.125 Td
(of argument)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(that Paragraph 5 was not followed when the Administrative Judge received\
Applicant's answer to the SOR)Tj
T*
(\(with the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(documents Applicant submitted with it\) without Applicant being present,\
Applicant has failed to show how he)Tj
T*
(suffered)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(any prejudice or harm to his right to a hearing or his right to present \
evidence on his behalf. )Tj
40.404 0 Td
(Absent any)Tj
-40.404 -1.125 Td
(showing of such)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(prejudice or harm to Applicant, any putative noncompliance with Paragrap\
h 5 does not warrant remand)Tj
T*
(or reversal.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(2. )Tj
(Whether the Administrative Judge's decision is arbitrary, capricious, or\
contrary to law)Tj
ET
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 28 541.5 cm
0 0 m
417.035 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
12 0 0 12 445.0352 542.25 Tm
(. )Tj
(Applicant argues: \(a\) the)Tj
-35.753 -1.125 Td
(Administrative Judge ignored many facts that favor Applicant; \(b\) the \
Judge erred by finding Applicant's federal tax)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(debt)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(was mitigated, but finding Applicant's consumer debts were not mitigated\
; \(c\) the Judge failed to give sufficient)Tj
T*
(weight to)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(the evidence that Applicant's failure to make payments to his creditors \
in 1996-1997 was caused by a decline)Tj
T*
(in his wages;)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(\(d\) the Judge erred by finding Applicant was financially overextended \
in 1995; \(e\) the Judge ignored the)Tj
T*
(evidence that)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Applicant closed various accounts without delinquency; \(f\) the Judge e\
rred by finding Applicant has no)Tj
T*
(cash reserves; \(g\))Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(the Judge erred by holding against Applicant the fact he borrowed money \
from his 401K plan to pay)Tj
T*
(his debts; \(h\) the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(Judge ignored evidence Applicant was taking corrective action to deal wi\
th his federal tax debt and his)Tj
T*
(consumer debts; \(i\))Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(the Judge erred by finding Applicant made no payments toward his consume\
r delinquencies in the)Tj
T*
(last year despite a 40%)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(increase in income over the previous year; \(j\) the Judge erred by find\
ing Applicant had a)Tj
T*
(monthly net positive remainder)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(of $400-$500; \(k\) the Judge erred by saying that it is unclear which d\
ebts of Applicant's)Tj
T*
(might be discharged in)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(bankruptcy; and \(l\) the Judge ignored the fact Applicant had 20 years \
of no financial difficulties)Tj
T*
(before his recent)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(difficulties arose due to a decrease in Applicant's income. )Tj
30.196 0 Td
(The Board's construes Applicant's arguments)Tj
-30.196 -1.125 Td
(as raising the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(issue of whether the Judge's decision is arbitrary, capricious, or contr\
ary to law.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(There is a rebuttable presumption that an Administrative Judge considere\
d all the record evidence unless the Judge)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(specifically states otherwise. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
11.718 0 Td
(See, e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
3.332 0 Td
(, ISCR Case No. 98-0350 \(March 31, 1999\) at p. 3. )Tj
(Apart from that rebuttable)Tj
-15.05 -1.125 Td
(presumption, the Judge's detailed findings and conclusions in this show \
the Judge made a conscientious effort to)Tj
T*
(consider)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(the record evidence in this case. )Tj
16.66 0 Td
(Nothing in the record persuades the Board that the Judge simply ignored)Tj
-16.66 -1.125 Td
(record evidence)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(as claimed by Applicant.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Furthermore, the fact that the Administrative Judge did not make finding\
s more favorable to Applicant does not)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(demonstrate the Judge ignored evidence favorable to Applicant. )Tj
25.796 0 Td
(The fact that the Judge did not find Applicant's)Tj
-25.796 -1.125 Td
(evidence)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(demonstrated extenuation or mitigation of his financial problems suffici\
ent to warrant a favorable security)Tj
T*
(clearance)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(decision is not proof that the Judge ignored the evidence presented by A\
pplicant. )Tj
36.626 0 Td
(The Judge must weigh the)Tj
-36.626 -1.125 Td
(evidence as a)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(whole \(Directive, Section F.3.\) and decide whether the favorable evide\
nce outweighs the unfavorable)Tj
T*
(evidence or )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
4.886 0 Td
(vice)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(versa)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
4.025 0 Td
(. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
(See, e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
3.832 0 Td
(, ISCR Case No. 98-0394 \(June 10, 1999\) at p. 6. )Tj
(Applicant's disagreement with the)Tj
-12.743 -1.125 Td
(Judge's weighing of)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(the record evidence does not constitute proof that the Judge weighed the\
evidence in a manner that)Tj
T*
(is arbitrary, capricious,)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(or contrary to law. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
17.105 0 Td
(See, e.g.)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
3.332 0 Td
(, ISCR Case No. 98-0448 \(April 19, 1999\) at p. 3. )Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
(See also)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
( ISCR)Tj
-20.437 -1.125 Td
(Case No. 98-0445 \(April 2,)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(1999\) at p. 2 \("Error is not demonstrated by [the appealing party's] a\
bility to argue for an)Tj
T*
(alternate interpretation of the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(record evidence."\). )Tj
19.731 0 Td
(Accordingly, the fact that the Judge found Applicant's efforts to)Tj
-19.731 -1.125 Td
(resolve his financial problems were)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(not sufficient to warrant a favorable security clearance decisions does \
not prove that)Tj
T*
(the Judge simply ignored Applicant's)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(efforts.)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(The Board need not agree with the Administrative Judge to conclude it wa\
s not arbitrary or capricious for the Judge to)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(find that Applicant's actions mitigated the significance of his federal \
tax debt, but that Applicant's consumer debts were)Tj
T*
(not mitigated. )Tj
5.805 0 Td
(The decision sets forth an explanation for the Administrative Judge's di\
fferent conclusions about)Tj
-5.805 -1.125 Td
(Applicant's federal tax debt on one hand and his consumer debts on the o\
ther hand. )Tj
33.449 0 Td
(That explanation reflects a plausible)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
12 0 obj
<>
endobj
53 0 obj
<>
endobj
9 0 obj
<>
endobj
10 0 obj
<>
endobj
11 0 obj
<>
endobj
57 0 obj
(file:///usr.osd.mil/Home/OSD/OGC/JosephLM/_MyComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archived%20-%20HTML/98-0614.a1.html)
endobj
56 0 obj
<>
endobj
58 0 obj
<
>
endobj
54 0 obj
[16 0 R/XYZ 0 195.0 null]
endobj
55 0 obj
[16 0 R/XYZ 0 156.0 null]
endobj
4 0 obj
<>
endobj
xref
0 59
0000000000 65535 f
0000000016 00000 n
0000000141 00000 n
0000003657 00000 n
0000163596 00000 n
0000003535 00000 n
0000003590 00000 n
0000003737 00000 n
0000003764 00000 n
0000162979 00000 n
0000163063 00000 n
0000163105 00000 n
0000162791 00000 n
0000004501 00000 n
0000153365 00000 n
0000144571 00000 n
0000116083 00000 n
0000115309 00000 n
0000003867 00000 n
0000003913 00000 n
0000003962 00000 n
0000004194 00000 n
0000004034 00000 n
0000004066 00000 n
0000004098 00000 n
0000004130 00000 n
0000004162 00000 n
0000004726 00000 n
0000004758 00000 n
0000009663 00000 n
0000009712 00000 n
0000009747 00000 n
0000010255 00000 n
0000010686 00000 n
0000114669 00000 n
0000114990 00000 n
0000061592 00000 n
0000061859 00000 n
0000029811 00000 n
0000030084 00000 n
0000011055 00000 n
0000011336 00000 n
0000011662 00000 n
0000030533 00000 n
0000062470 00000 n
0000115498 00000 n
0000116294 00000 n
0000121234 00000 n
0000121637 00000 n
0000121913 00000 n
0000122299 00000 n
0000144771 00000 n
0000153565 00000 n
0000162876 00000 n
0000163512 00000 n
0000163554 00000 n
0000163312 00000 n
0000163147 00000 n
0000163459 00000 n
trailer
<]>>
startxref
163768
%%EOF