Qy :E?93MԼWi@fTQә:Xa )2CIɲ{GKSXsR\
{d O\ٮ +lKOuѷn![5G k[;vr|7z H}c!m
6ȣK8\X晀ۆΓÉ0m>&,Z Ykڍ[PVo.*(
VZ^M?^dd~ ^~蠇: ELJP`sׯ3sQHd L#b
NPv[7V6ȐdcPe9+Euσ69"dj/N(T{LvOz{% Xivvaguw`$ nlwgre\k ͨ]n2p%1bD7 u\$.3dclL `Ft|$328]aL!*ro^e#>x5 F6 XUy|+C[!KS]{ )X o\nh q~GIWCVT!
ԙڴz''~!>j;mx8 z0j< +Ε
ݵ {?\/uݕs][,ɒd[O,ml$@KLL 2b CȀ1n!P٥%mRZ LgәqҩLi zwWg콻C;|ߧݾ'Z8~4ra,ڳ){ug3쵆+mo\庭mx?nkӎoJݕ۶|Z t`Elp@~ =!`@f N֘L5 Ʌ⨁d&e[;\5rhD˳9}DtqB1!*`[3p&3}eEO*+Y%![> N {^NdrzI:mUDފt,ܞ{rsthF[ҘXxpaB~at:_J$_5-궲ҌX"(jR .QԛɀT[ZOwX+t*% 0$nZ M"sG?;"!{,OFR ~kRD [}WZ5I: o 0\/ ymu
;%~tr /6N~5fo[SKwHH-x,Ŀ-:}:7lt2c;Ek vFS O(7ZR♒ؘRBpFHhRz/5G}EFTq z"D'=
X0
s5FOF4 !9b Խd0È"rGrAHɀD
3ٔ Hp 9NX*] >T|HI?q` \2g~8T2
JS#F-!Z[Y)!G VZtHŃEh 0Ʊܡ P?D?Z;I)N
"Ϡ3 mM9M, <p,k|
/5/ %`Ca0(IAZUtS8k\,
Fuξ6Ͻ{Ê[*xcϮNӂFimV՝_
ܚo_\-UU !oC (uud
~"=L0
sq _8聘8
14jH!zxϑAZQ۫ŵs_%P4/&I-7Z **ǼqaNnaGJJI
g?i%/ +tre"s8טBю^hm DI\-Ѿ}6j00JP=D-@*ɮ*
UFr$9ܪZ}mTj/Ú &likk~q.HhOgӶX{^u/zGq$maS gQ6.m2a~nD 3E#|4Y̋8)R"oY?|7 %Q pT
97p% /( {d;P@`,(_..٫ͯN N6!Qw~X=N7Nkshds8=]rVl%w&c`ܳQ7}OD#Y=]rt-(rJM HDpY(/&.#1s?fv:6D /c?8*yWGlvÙFu-sxY+UZCưP@
hHzK6^~,y,\L,fMks@.)tH)vءhf,`MfeOXcsDȭ̠+zYv_
{Io5[)v%7ٟ; ]FHyLg4]0hz4ܱ,)mRQ)kyM(
[kw ?O4Zj0QT ddZkc*:=h!g&Զ Uh0"83C/iv/eG{ GU]}g@6P! ! , L b- ?R-h8m?h7
8Rv63ʢHJi(BR@~{!jg3ߞ{s;;
:t5 S| wtY]!~]u!cFyc*;zvrzB?Lw} 5,U, n[߂hQ-#?-)'W? ⶰ CDgR$Ϗbl7 G Q" 3 o'=.:1GvyNu:Q~ԣ
i 5b 2K(Rl͛@zP@elDB4z""Zqw_P((-jm G[xm
[NH6pN`}\BnaȺ 7,\1U8/i^?xyS/^N wfk[.Q
[LVn o/LIqZ AHђrX8yn^z|Ķ'3 "lˈ 5!D.m>ҥZBpk2@`-w~V֛[ ,j)Z
*+fjok <{^$lڭ\w1 X
$#?P 0kʁoBNj~wM ge5p,f܋vpl T 0V@B1$8}^cDq>1cAk餈Yb$m.e (ү6c$_Ÿqߏr t-x>1 SAdQE-"K1&>+|n>s&eئ{ am_`ӟ!8KH7iA cN
@1z:8N93SQ-uY"h=>C[ aw 3Opo/RC1!?@ɮx-ҾjW%
\uvm+x;P-ts-
C7al8Al=mA6u~ t>@! [R=R;qء}XYaߔ
̶3q5 x"d瘣}uo8}zvYʖ*NSggj;}%/ YVQ1,l
9 9&ڥm'xcBG:w.+xA5F|?H8#4بs]tqе\p5k?:gH z_Y3ZyhZ}e/Џ4Of)fZ9uQ 34m{tP :PfȈS=hB:#J(ҏSC>Ga_+p=dK_;̻T^夻s3hF_;_A9u?S (_v[9`ؿ?#9;maF5q yDK|ܪ{p}K3tD7, lt=F} ?:}_2:P|(rZ.i8,=
;>Ň4YB#Q7=N
b<'z ex
(8}%yU W*
z_ ˍkvWcM Kh*B üP$m>ZbLal>umMAﴭI16J.XyʴǮ`~5pMnCcwu2 Cկ|Ue<9|-9+ɻsLڹe=Ҿ 9ϑ Ƽ||.8R̬JpD%rBl_5\)x&Rv βkA*ﱥP^ ВP< Pjj`; !djQXKłJaOǗ/Sq{w=6Fl뻱A^kQav$cޙ}qڜZC߶i8qROOXFkSXڅ\ъwkCzd~6.%"nOgx("a}vg!ƕ|t2u|_|M"GQ对.kyB/[U@_g]gz^]P~xϺ =юGFbjƳ{ K0ewcwҿ#Zu[̯8u !S%Zj^:k=ItHu`>X3iuj%}l'c(̏(
cc _3G z. ez _ytFkʦw|O) uJo#knuE[께44IZ%n,Q:s1 u-0_4P0 %f"2!9F:t.Pf&OPE`!O7q6 N .a/ 53h-0PaHOS9[im<i5[im CbŃvw㷧ăvCAh_c~4֞ ӿ?C`0<{4 ǁ/,P/.p!`u
sMku1k1)?Gd V穫ԥ
~jOcT7P==#/]9ݡ~ƛ{h.!@/:GG.2q nq6Mä9
tE2"̓?.藩?_|+׆#/sm87a >}2bкB/ k6u
lN*z*N2@r':P^. ;-αPO\s 4ԧf ygKT+2-@6~:;rlz s/H 4yވӥ3\-⭞.彁>Qv*oFU&QQMk`=GEqc U˩UtG=tv&M.yۯ zDA?v:o}fORUhu@G0?o
ߛ m6IjEdoM͝Չ a/cF^+w>={-5Z&_ go{V
nZ3Ŵ ]+@O6hycsZj^T::B[<ֳ.볆s o]]g~7jm뺖fFmקּz&&c=qoU== b(&lPFˣھ]5]OLws5;`G EQ,Z7]Jy`>-偕Z)|/bP c
.;C+WأΨ<j"v*pQ?)<t:Ty*N-{t/} W?MqU)cjۃ,[B |KF0zŜ>-9Pi>ꝃ),wQpa9
s:[czsѰ$69(Uk
<%]ǾlA,(qTbMx 4zxGĤA-Fi\&x$vaQ}ODyuo[uLGn+uhi)^{^՝XFt
JP!J܃OXG»g bh6VO9PJ{9ʅa/gSs
ϩ>/O -wq^P^5X/5VIɇ!_5iYN TXA8EZg==.(k6ƨ3hB5Z~n,s$
u0 DOlzFB3.OC1~aN8 qq9V 3=cGٴȌh\O ws 4w1>a$S]r%[?lW#Fsa-oxgUr/ңu+/|WɻywȔ8A1g<к~'Y0N#(sTz
I%zoAo\Vgܭ`cn=xei}8E[K=s hjx9=A sc P7Z(gŘkoh@y3`۾i2w~/Q͛y;fN WcI[ Lz5Z}eqQޜkH6V@iﱾg ۥ\sRKzIz3sxZM.=p}S`4 mvbzzޞ4z.cr>5ԩV]1$)&4y;7aL
qQ!q1sGts; xZ>amxk;ZӄNo| Os^+`Fcwx}|c ೆl?%7'sۂ_QvJ7wuL~5Xt>`p<0Fl5͜ElG+yryK\Lq3v @L4I%ɑ Od7Mv?MuapS0)<-Y# Zru0zZN3z{u~ӵ뭾f. }:R/\{M{܉irS
ٲQȤonh[ {xM6#%:Wrw|dẺh*HOZ9D%0g {=}K[C;=-ZnE3uPO^ ֳԇC<_026Ƅ8`?]Rt*%_++$ϩ䫇% g0G/?r/ǧҙf= Ct!}e dc.n8_/T)pb3Wi-X!y7<̷>pug8vMꡳv%un=>{
[g8&zm_`>>-w A$YGC9y\Zv%7io'{^:볼Wɹ*7}JSU +tg\v7=
N=Hr#) :G[H|Lb}ڬLfu7]cʉN'=wbdt{4Ot` U{ 6>
FꙚތV `}5Pq`l
㮒*yS?z9=z8
4-^q'PsϼdJE y T3Yk]" ~ U毃1[`VZixm6!&Y ^c-BH2x]< !* iDFGǓ>)'U_>cN9{Hw+_F;G1:3=n,F vKLa i xx_yY?hϸl}qfZsl;
?t4 ֑-.(]z`⎩enn f'yWXvem
TF}[=J_]Xx.<צ5\Mhp=~kYiwp
}B]IZn9LsVv#.iW} 1P gΚ9
V?ڹ9p3/N$t0g\f\pX0~zד>
ɱ+笭\\Zq泷0]`; bX7&!gs䮎;Kig ߏ;0K^={sŽ
V ߉2lʞsQA{
+ +y=Ħkp ӗ/Q37 {Kީ#7! l<ε9^\c_pu9W ~`_b
-g78Y8ypoYyHĚ شsK|^1_ sN2ļ [NP207.o se-IM`m:_ߣZviI|[!6/ c{"=R`/p[$l~"haGypA_Xr,=HݛDx&6,d?ʟ$ QDxh
گu:IThubz S%|hQ+;q2VS
rK6dEi$hdFbȋ4ԨDK#ԁ=蟠,ِ6"
KMO3JQk>l1qZa}an6#ԍ|7Ch͏g_MrR
st9
a aҺ[PEh >8D O&wEԆd$ǔhS.GFkWz`{ d02r wףsщ~2d[j41E2>hO`#
>}]BrbO }ߞf? fk`412dP4JDwD&Î۱vF;fۆNѧ54 NH7D .W[/D* ͡hw jD{yp8.FyDc)? Š< u=}͇v' -5mu|HJ653kkSɕl6E׀Φ)*M,47!ieϰYPMXib'فd7MR K` <$]׀\~wi}ڏaEAF>iLsh%=sf.kqQ{Z+rVp
RIIJC)̗R&Xc]} eed<͞e oз*P:髴(&2 Ft2DcO9Bn},6s0ʆf 5}wHi>ɕVP7a,fpZ[Lo
_SWe?{EYk.+c}0j:|z_x-xIt{x Eޚ 3KB?hc0,Y^!\MYR&9r,F0N=ٺ4l*-rRgqll YUg K,bJ~%-[B"R,CsZ%j,[V0ۏEgg0FC~8Vz<
6O5&,\Qh f˪Xƺ;NB:.FUH@T&4چUPA.\^Koƒ,_s k4ւiI8N?l|@dh2iQ0` Oހ3`t怱*`<}kDݑ/e.UBn\ 7~ȍn<ɍ77
mVKALeTR֬L GEI;/L 2^vqTQ w2ٙ&n6NIɝ 6a@n+;
"-I-Ab!dj;vR'[_|ЊY/;{sgwvK;vBԖ?d*)qF8}b1:1!,=BWQ" دH(_G/ZДO E`\ld|:rΰR7=kUbJ̅bA[h(nUpJ`C|.bN#vό0bX1Ϡ}
fNv`?9 XW:[* ^dKYpLea)w0b{n7,yaSI\ئUa?`K&aWqg)$U`\5ePnvlc7wD#ڢ6yZQۧ=
kڀ֫g];t]O骮D?mTMJ^㴂=tQ=)^,Fm/֚G>?WkPO=q=[ܭvL LE#ѲPދ)9Zi#Df3Z\Ї_dقQȌuC7fmFȫj/ Aġ5eAyӭ)hP#5|-,bPJ0р B]A FJ1ɨ$L&LN2bdS2iܣ1M@ Ơ @ y!ږOD^K"ܙjzk
ݑ u}[}鮶[E/N^&aLu4?0`뻮8rĻPK.
PrFi; nIƹJKJ: B]r4^T2z sulaU=qpxaY9]mטO AP4E
[v=@n %>;x7,63+vްZ<>
pْ |{`0 XjG
endstream
endobj
18 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 5/Type/Page>>
endobj
47 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 5 Tm
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\
ved%20-%20HTML/04-03690.h1.htm)Tj
50.019 0 Td
([7/2/2021 3:27:43 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
0.753 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
q
10 36 592 730 re
W n
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 755.25 Tm
(To conclude, Applicant has failed to meet his ultimate burden of persuas\
ion to obtain a favorable clearance decision.)Tj
ET
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 16 741.75 Tm
(But this decision should not be construed)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
16.749 0 Td
(as an indictment of Applicant's loyalty and patriotism to the U.S., as t\
hose)Tj
-16.749 -1.125 Td
(matters are not at issue. Instead, the clearly-consistent standard requi\
res I resolve any)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
34.349 0 Td
(doubt against Applicant, and his)Tj
-34.349 -1.125 Td
(close family ties to the PRC create doubt about his security suitability\
. In reaching my decision, I have considered the)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(record)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(evidence as a whole, the whole-person concept, the clearly-consistent st\
andard, and the appropriate factors and)Tj
T*
(guidelines in the Directive.)Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
19.364 -7.625 Td
(FORMAL FINDINGS)Tj
ET
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 248.374 595.5 cm
0 0 m
115.002 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
/TT0 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 16 531.75 Tm
(Formal findings For or Against Applicant on the allegations set forth in\
the SOR, as required by E3.1.25 of Enclosure 3)Tj
T*
(of the Directive, are:)Tj
0 -5.375 TD
(Paragraph 1. Guideline B: )Tj
10.692 0 Td
(AGAINST APPLICANT)Tj
-10.692 -5.375 Td
(Subparagraph 1.a. )Tj
(Against Applicant)Tj
0 -2.125 TD
(Subparagraph 1.b. )Tj
(Against Applicant)Tj
T*
(Subparagraph 1.c. )Tj
(Against Applicant)Tj
T*
(Subparagraph 1.d. )Tj
(Against Applicant)Tj
T*
(Subparagraph 1.e. )Tj
(Against Applicant)Tj
T*
(Subparagraph 1.f. Against Applicant)Tj
T*
(Subparagraph 1.g. )Tj
(Against Applicant)Tj
T*
(Subparagraph 1.h. )Tj
(Against Applicant)Tj
/TT1 1 Tf
21.683 -5.375 Td
(DECISION)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
-21.683 -5.375 Td
(In light of all the circumstances presented by the record in this case, \
it is not clearly consistent with the national interest)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(to grant or continue Applicant's security)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
16.287 0 Td
(clearance. )Tj
4.274 0 Td
(Clearance is denied.)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
17 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/StructParents 4/Type/Page>>
endobj
48 0 obj
[50 0 R]
endobj
49 0 obj
<>stream
BT
/Artifact <>BDC
/TT0 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 5 5 Tm
(file:///usr.osd.mil/)Tj
7.166 0 Td
(...)Tj
(yComputer/Desktop/DOHA%20transfer/DOHA-Kane/dodogc/doha/industrial/Archi\
ved%20-%20HTML/04-03690.h1.htm)Tj
50.019 0 Td
([7/2/2021 3:27:43 PM])Tj
EMC
ET
0.753 g
10 36 591.75 729.75 re
f
/Article <>BDC
EMC
/Article <>BDC
BT
0 g
/TT1 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 261.8652 743.25 Tm
(CONCLUSIONS)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
-20.489 -5.375 Td
(Applicant admitted that his wife's parents and sister live in the PRC. W\
e know nothing about them, except they are)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
(retired professors and his sister-in-law works for a university's archit\
ecture department. Applicant has not noted what)Tj
T*
(their jobs were or are in any detail or whether they are members of the \
Communist party. Common sense suggests that)Tj
T*
(the stronger the ties of affection or obligation, the more vulnerable a \
person is to being manipulated if the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
42.432 0 Td
(relative,)Tj
-42.432 -1.125 Td
(cohabitant, or close associate is brought under control or used as a hos\
tage by a foreign intelligence or security service.)Tj
T*
(While in-laws are not)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
8.886 0 Td
(considered part of Applicant's immediate family, there is a rebuttable p\
resumption that he has ties)Tj
-8.886 -1.375 Td
(of affection for or obligation for his spouse's parents and)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
22.896 0 Td
(sister and thus come under the guidelines.)Tj
0 0 1 rg
9.75 0 0 9.75 491.7109 599.25 Tm
( \(19\))Tj
ET
0 0 1 RG
0.75 w
q 1 0 0 1 491.7109 598.5 cm
0 0 m
18.681 0 l
h
S
Q
BT
0 g
12 0 0 12 510.3921 594.75 Tm
( )Tj
(Here, based on)Tj
-41.199 -1.125 Td
(the record as a whole, the government established its case under Guideli\
ne B. )Tj
31.24 0 Td
(Applicant's wife has)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(close family ties to)Tj
-31.24 -1.125 Td
(the PRC, as evidenced by her father, mother, and sister who are citizens\
of and residents in the PRC. His wife remains a)Tj
T*
(citizen of the PRC. )Tj
7.86 0 Td
(The strength of the ties is also demonstrated by Applicant traveling to \
the PRC for family visits and)Tj
-7.86 -1.125 Td
(repeatedly providing financial assistance to his wife's)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
21.59 0 Td
(parents. )Tj
(These contacts buttress the presumption that his)Tj
-21.59 -1.125 Td
(relationship with his wife's immediate family is not casual and infreque\
nt. )Tj
29.84 0 Td
(These circumstances raise)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
10.689 0 Td
(a security concern)Tj
-40.529 -1.125 Td
(under DC 1, E2.A2.1.2.1. )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
(An immediate family member, or a person to whom the individual has close\
ties of affection or)Tj
T*
(obligation, is a)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
6.278 0 Td
(citizen of, or resident or present in, a foreign country)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
21.303 0 Td
(.)Tj
-27.582 -5.375 Td
(I )Tj
(reviewed the mitigating conditions under Guideline B and conclude none a\
pply. The only MC deserving serious)Tj
T*
(consideration is MC 1, )Tj
9.36 0 Td
(E2.A2.1.3.1. )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
(A)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(determination that the immediate family member\(s\), \(spouse, father, m\
other,)Tj
-9.36 -1.125 Td
(sons, daughters, brothers, sisters\), cohabitant, or associate\(s\) in q\
uestion are not)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
32.777 0 Td
(agents of a foreign power or in a)Tj
-32.777 -1.125 Td
(position to be exploited by a foreign power in a way that could force th\
e individual to choose between loyalty to the)Tj
T*
(person\(s\))Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
(involved)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
7.415 0 Td
( )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
(and the United States)Tj
/TT0 1 Tf
8.832 0 Td
( but it does not apply. Applicant has the burden to present evidence to \
establish)Tj
-16.247 -1.125 Td
(the fact that his wife's family members are not)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
18.757 0 Td
(foreign agents and that they are not in positions to be exploited by the\
)Tj
-18.757 -1.125 Td
(PRC. )Tj
(As Applicant failed to respond to the FORM and provide answers to these)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
32.301 0 Td
(questions we do not know if his wife's)Tj
-32.301 -1.125 Td
(parents are living on university pensions, although one might assume tha\
t. )Tj
29.912 0 Td
(We don't know the type of work the power)Tj
-29.912 -1.125 Td
(engineering department at the university is engaged in. )Tj
22.187 0 Td
(If we assume all family members depend upon the PRC)Tj
-22.187 -1.125 Td
(government for support we can assume that)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
17.689 0 Td
(they could easily be exploited by the PRC government. )Tj
22.329 0 Td
(There is no)Tj
-40.019 -1.125 Td
(evidence to base a decision either way. )Tj
15.827 0 Td
(Applicant has not met his burden of mitigating the)Tj
/Span<>> BDC
( )Tj
EMC
20.413 0 Td
(government's case.)Tj
-36.24 -5.375 Td
(In deciding if an applicant has met the second prong of MC 1, it is prop\
er to consider how the foreign country at issue is)Tj
T*
(governed. The focus is not the country or its people, but its rulers and\
the nature of the government they impose. The)Tj
T*
(PRC is hostile to the U.S. and is ruled by a communist government with a\
poor record of human rights. With this history)Tj
T*
(it is not difficult to envision a scenario in which Applicant's in-laws \
could be subjected to some or all of these arbitrary)Tj
T*
(denial of basic human rights in an effort to put pressure on him to divu\
lge classified information. We also know the)Tj
T*
(PRC is actively pursuing industrial and military intelligence in this co\
untry. Given these circumstances--which are)Tj
T*
(clearly beyond Applicant's control--the presence of Applicant's in-laws \
in the PRC places them at risk of being brought)Tj
T*
(under control or used as a hostage by a PRC intelligence or security ser\
vice. Unfortunately, his in-laws are in a position)Tj
T*
(where there is a potential for them to be exploited in a way that could \
force him to choose between loyalty to his family)Tj
T*
(members and the interests of the U.S. Accordingly, since Applicant faile\
d to respond to the FORM we don't know)Tj
T*
(whether he could have mitigated the security concerns. Guideline B is de\
cided against him.)Tj
ET
EMC
endstream
endobj
50 0 obj
<>/BS<